Voice Teacher & Opera Stage Director reacts to and analyzes BTS performing Fake Love 

Thanks to the commenters who brought the following needed corrections to my attention! 1. It is NOT Big Heat but IS Big Hit (Though I think Bit Heat would make for a fantastically funny entertainment company name) 2. "Rap Monster" was associated with RM previously but is now outdated and he has now restyled it asking that it be thought of as standing for "Real Me". For those that hate the Fun Facts and if there are other errors - I do apologize. The fun facts only show up when the not chopped up video gets blocked or claimed. My videos should be protected by fair use as educational commentary. Unfortunately, the software that scans for copyright infringement does not take that into account and rather than go through the whole appeal process I opt for putting something in to break up the performance as a less complicated solution that some viewers seem to enjoy. For the fun facts I am usually just copy and pasting them directly from another site that I don't have enough background or time to vet before posting and frankly since the Fun Facts are just a way to give you something to think about while I break up the film I don't ever intend on spending copious amounts of time researching them. So, in short, if they bother you scan forward a few seconds or better yet.... watch the original film and then scan to my comments after the film is over to hear what I have to say about it. If there are errors in the fun facts in the future I will, as I am here, correct them in a pinned comment at the top as they are brought to my attention. My goal in these videos is not to delve into the trivia and background of the performers. Though it is interesting and valuable it is beyond the scope of what I am trying to do here. So if you are looking for an expert on the specific performers then I'm not that person. My expertise and my goal is 1. To appreciate the great artists out there and hopefully help you appreciate them in new ways as well from the perspective of a voice teacher, stage director, and performance coach that has taught students ranging from grade school to professional all over the world for over a decade. 2. To use the top performers as a way to teach the tools and techniques that top artists use to get themselves to where they are to the next generation of performers (whether they want to be professional pop stars or shower singers) so they can learn from what good things are being done and explore ways that they might even improve the art form of vocal performance. I am using them as an example because they are the top performers. So whether you like them or not - whether I like them or not - I see that is irrelevant. What is relevant is that A LOT of people do like them so might as well see what they are doing that makes people gravitate towards them and learn from it. So if you feel the need to fill in what you see as a gap or error in the information please do so in the comments here. But please realize - My doctorate, other formal training, and experience is in voice, opera stage directing, and mostly as a teacher of up and coming performers and not in english or pop music history. Thank you for watching and a HUGE THANK YOU to the majority of the commenters out there that are so supportive and especially to those that have taken the time to post really fantastic insights, thoughts, and comments that give us a new way to look at these amazing artists. Long comment - Thank you for reading. I do read as many of the comments as I can and take them seriously.

I highly recommend the BTS “Dionysus” live performance (comeback stage). Another beautiful performance is “I’m fine” performed live on Jimmy Fallon.

I think you'd like their mv for Blood Sweat and Tears. So much symbolism.

I'd like to apologize on behalf of all ARMY'S that were discourteous to you. Some are easily offended because of the history of disrespect and current worldwide disrespect BTS and ARMY has had to endure. That being said that is no excuse to abuse you when your purpose was to praise the unity that is BTS. As long as individual effort is recognised and valued I see nothing wrong with calling them a "well oiled machine." All groups that do what they do have to mesh like that to be good performers and BTS is no exception. I loved your factoids about BTS but one correction if I may. RM used to be known as Rap Monster. He doesn't want to be associated with that name any longer. People still do associate the two and thats inevitable but it is to be avoided if at all possible. Thank you for treating BTS and its members with respect. 💜💜💜

I think the reason why individuality is so important to fans is because of how outsiders see kpop. Kpop is seen as a machine were everything is manufactured and to be honest, it's true to an extend. However it has been changing for the past 7 or 8 years with groups like BTS, or many others who have been given artistic freedom from the start and stand for things bigger (peer pressure, mental health, expectations of society, generationnal conflicts) than the materialistics subjects of the past. For exemple, the person that is responsible for kpop on musical stand point (a blend of pop, rock, hip-hop, jazz, etc...) Seo Taeji the leader of "Seo taeji and boys" stood for individualism, the end of a collectivist mindset and constantly confronted the governement. This man who is an absolut legend in Korea recognized BTS as the group that carry his lagacy ,since they tacle the same topics in their work. I completly understand the "robot or machine" part, I don't find it offensive, but some can take it as the stigma attached to the Kpop industry. Thank you for reading and pardon my English.

Can you please react to BTS - Melon Music Awards 2018 Who Are You performance?? Please 💜

I'm an army, and i know that bts never lipsync in their performances. but most of comeback stages from korean music tv show are recorded many times to get perfect shot. I'd rather watch bts's performances from their own concert. if there's one thing that bts failed is lipsync at their own song, especially RM(you can even watch it on their music videos 😅)

react to MMA 2018 bts who are you performance you will appreciate everything from their vocals/rap to choreos and production hands down one of the best bts performance

Some corrections: 1. RM doesn't stand for Rap Monster. Rap Monster was Namjoon's old stage name which he outgrew. RM called out his past self in an interview to change his name because he is a human not a monster. RM might stand for "Real Me". 2. It's "Big Hit Ent." & not Big Heat. 🙂

I really like your reaction because you are an expert in this kind of field. Please watch their performances during MAMA 2018. I've never been a fan of an artist to the point I'm now to BTS. They are authentic. They know what they are doing, to every song they sing, they are telling us something..and they love what they are doing. I'm not an expert so this is mainly my thoughts. .. But watch their performance, I can feel what they want to say/show. Can't imagine if I'm literally see them with my two eyes. Thank you.

Hello, about your question: With BTS hapens that many people stereotype them as part of a "machine factory from Korea", in a racist and actually dumb way. Usually the term "machine" is used in a demeaning way, to call them "robots" and to refer that they don't think or do things for themselfs, and not as a compliment. Thus why ARMY can be a little defensive when that word is used in regards of BTS. But your input about your meaning for that word in this video, is amazing and I as a member of ARMY take it as a compliment. Thank you very much for this reaction, and I'll love to see more reactions from you to BTS.

You should check out bts make it right live on the Stephen Colbert show or spring day by bts

I can't say for all armys out there but personally, I take it as a compliment when someone describes Bangtan as a "well-oiled machine". Depending on the context of the sentence, of course. What I think he meant is that they have such a great teamwork, and that they knew each other so well that they can communicate and anticipate each other's movements in stride, basically what a well oiled machine is, working so well together. Anyways, I also underste some ARMYS taking it as a negative thing, and I hope you know Dr. Marc, that most of us are very over protective and that comes from somewhere as well (you don't want to know half of the sh*t the boys and the fandom went thru) but I know that some are just hateful trolls and I'm thankful that you don't let them get to you. All in all, the reaction, inputs, and tips you made were great! Looking forward to more BTS reactions 💜

And also I’ve been really enjoying your breakdowns and analyzing within these reaction videos. I love how you focus on what they do RIGHT rather than pick them apart. Because reality is they are amazing. And what good does it do to only point out flaws. Very encouraging, keep up the great work.

I saw someone say that you'd really enjoy Blood Sweat and Tears and I 100% agree with that. Thank you for giving us a very interesting perspective on the performance!

Did you know bts has 3 number 1 charting albums within a year and he last band to do this was the Beatles.Did you know bts is the first Kpop group to be on the billboard 200 and 100.Bts spoke at the United Nations, Bts meet the South Korean president and are the youngest recipients to receive the honer.They sold out full stadiums in minutes, and they are the first Kpop group to perform on the billboard and at the amas.BTS biggest boy band in the world.I recommend make it right live, they sing very high pitched in those songs.

I think individuality is important for any artist. I knew you said that out of wow so I didn't mind it. But some people might have taken it negatively cuz those comments such as looking like robots or products from a factory have been used to describe Kpop artists negatively in western world. So that's why I guess some people got mad...😊 It's OK...

Thank you for the analyses, especially regarding pronunciation and expression. The boys could be angry, tired, or sad, but you would never know that from the performance. I am glad you are appreciative of the hard work behind the performances. Your practical advice for performances was also ver good. I hope someone will benefit from your words.

Wow I love that you did a lot of research

*Big Heat* I'm crying lmaohgkd Big Heat selling us thirst since 2013

You seem to really like the production aspect of the concert. ARMYs - I think he REALLY, REALLY should check out 2018 MAMA in Hong Kong performance. With JHope, Jimin and Jungkook performing traditional Korean dances using traditional Korean music, followed by one of the best performances of Idol I've seen - well, it's just breath-taking.

In korean they would say fakeu because of their accent “ㅡ” that makes a “uu” kind of sound

I love your reactions on BTS and KPOP in general. As an American, you always hear about Western performers and how they are good singers/rappers. It's really awesome to see a professional like yourself, reacting to KPOP which can be similar, but artistically totally different from Western entertainment. A lot of KPOP in general is influenced by Western music, but has evolved it into something totally new and refreshing in my opinion. I get so tired of POP here in the states, I love what KPOP brings to music. I'm happy that you are giving your thoughts and opinions about BTS. I greatly appreciate you taking your time to check them out. Enjoy your day! PS when they say FAKE in the chorus it's mostly their accent. Koreans or Japanese pronounce it "FAKEU" I do, however, understand your comment about accentuating words to give more dramatic effect so to speak.

Their full performance at MAMA 2018 is amazing as well especially fake love intro n the dance break. Watch the full one. The official video keep on cutting the videos, its hard to watch in order.

You should watch who is BTS: the seven members of BTS It tell you a lot about how they came together and how they work together

BTS is top notch performers honestly because they love what they do and it shows! They always have behind the scenes to their performances so you can see how it's done and how dedicated they're to their craft! Pls react to mma 2018 performance and maybe the behind the scenes with eng subs.

That was nice reaction, n for next please react to BTS comeback stage "DIONYSUS" Live performance 🙏🙏🙏💜💜💜

Pls react to BTS Dionysus Comeback Stage Performance!!

Please react to make it right live at the late show with Stephen Colbert pls

So nice of you to review them. The points you referenced were much appreciated💜 thank you

Love that you taught a lesson on this performance!!

I recommend MMA2018 performance. It's legend.

i never regret stanning bts. i learned from them a lot. i love their music, and there are a lot of things from them that amazes me all the time

Actually rm doesn’t stand for rap monster. Rap monster was a stage name taht he used before. But now he has grown out of it. In an interview once, he had said that it stands for “Real Me”

thank you- great reaction!

Love your analysis as always.... and those clever BTS factoids used as performance breaks were great! Re their pronunciation of 'fake'... according to korean reviewers-- that is the way Koreans pronounce it...because fake requires 2 hangul letters (or sound bites) the 'fa' sound + the "ke' sound. I appreciate your confession about being new to Kpop and I do remember the 'machine' comment, but I understood totally what you meant. Perhaps your remark was taken out of context or heard by a non-native English speaker and so, was misconstrued. We, all ARMYs, have heard other Americans be dismissive of kpop. I remember one TV anchor/spokesperson say something along the lines of "Oh, kpop. Yeh, I've heard of it. That's where they do those super choreographed dances..." As if choreography was a negative thing! So, maybe some people are a little touchy about that. Please don't take it to heart. I see other commenters recommending their last Melon Music Awards performance... and you should listen to them. As someone in the theater/opera world, you will really appreciate it. These end of year awards shows in Korea are really something anyway, but BTS went over the top. From what I heard Big Hit spent close to $200K on the production. The performance consists of an intro, Fake Love, Airplane Pt 2 and IDOL. And, just so you know, BTS always changes up their performance, so you will never see the same thing twice. 'Melon Music Awards 2018 BTS WHO ARE YOU멜론뮤직어워드

Love the fact that you watch the entire video first and comment later. Your insight as a professional musician is amazing. Keep up the good work! Thank you! Greetings from Mexico.

Individuality is critical to a kpop fan. When we "stan" a group, we learn the details of each member's life, we watch hours of interviews, pre-debut footage, variety shows they attend, etc. We bond with all of them, or some more than others, and many times a "bias" emerges from this effort...that's when the real fun begins. I have to stop here, because no words can really describe the feeling when, as one famous kpop youtuber stated, "You don't choose your bias, your bias chooses you." Your life, your heart, will never be the same, in a really awesome way.

Love hearing you nerd out about production! We rarely get to hear admiration from people with experience in the area

I've watched countless reaction videos and you're the first one to point out engagement via the facial expressions. Helps to explain why it's so hard to tear your eyes away from their performances. Thanks Dr. Marc.

Love it when you put fun facts for the viewers who doesn’t know them.

Yes some people can be sensitive to their idols and they misconstrue what is said. They dont take time to try and understand where the commenter is coming from, or how much knowledge the commenter has on the genre of kpop. As to BTS, I love how yes they can seem like a well oiled machine. They have such great understanding of each other. I think that is why they look flawless in their choreography. What astounds me the most though, is that you can clearly see their individual personalities come through without breaking the great visuals they are creating with their performances. In kpop it is very cliche to give the group members titles to make it easier for the public to differentiate between them. Usually given names like, the leader, visual, vocal, rapper, funny one, so on so forth. In BTS usually people present them with their titles to other people to facilitate introducing them. Once you get to know them though, those titles go away and you can clearly see their individual strengths and personalities come through. 💜

I too love the set💜

Your face after the song finished was priceless! I think you would enjoy reacting to Lie by Jimin (bts). Or focus one me by Jus2

Actually, RM stands for Real Me, according to Kim Namjoon. :)

Kpop in general takes stage production to another level. BTS and Bighit are one of the best but most Kpop artists, companies and shows put numerous efforts into their stages. The lights, costumes, props, sets, camera angles, make up, hair, dance, singing, facial expressions, even a short glance at the camera. They pay so much attention to the details. Practice and rehearse so many times to perfect them. That's one thing I love about Kpop and BTS.

I loved your video... it’s actually help me to notice things

Please react to 2018 mma "who are you" performance!

Oh and keep going with your fun facts, I love it 👍👍

sir, please watch blood, sweat and tears by bts, music video and any live performance. 💜 i love your feedback on "fake" love. and yes, bts has emotions... they're in the moment when they're performing... it always matches the song and the message they're sending. individuality is important and something bts members work on because they're trying to veer away from the stigma of kpop idols which is "manufactured" or mere products of agencies. true that bts auditioned too and bighit formed the group but they are given musical freedom and individuality. they co-write, co-produce, and co-choreograph their music. their feedback matters. there are members who even released their own mixtapes (albums) and singles. 💜😊

I think you'll really enjoy the staging for BTS Idol MMA 2018

Thanks.... I really like professionals in this fields reaction .... it’s deep and realistic evaluation is of course important, this is relevant to bts ‘a works and professional ism

I came to you for my first listen to this group. I understand what you are saying about the super clean professional performance and the strong production values. I assume the fans here are like the fans in any group, they identify with a particular member. Respectfuly, my tastes lie in other directions but this was interesting to see.

Thank you ❤️❤️

BigHit who ? I only know Big Heat 😂

Thanks for your review and analysis... I hope you will also review their performance at MAMA 2018 Who are you... They've performed 3 songs and their stage is lit esp. Idol.

Amazingly professional and well spoken reaction. Very entertaining

Thank you so much for take your time to react on this BTS video. I really appreciate it.

I love u dad ty for feeding us with good content 💜

fakelove in mama 2018 japan full performance really blow your mind

We salute you. thanks!

👍 😊 thats so true, the emotions in their face show that they love what they do and that they feel the lyrics and the song. That's really what stands out to me.

I really hope you will reacting to other BTS' performance.. loving this. Thank you sir 😊

I love your reaction!!

You might want to check BTS Melon Music Award 2018 (MMA 2018) It’s the best stage performance of all time.

Thank you sooo much for reacting to our boys

I think regarding the fak-e sound, I could be wrong, but if Korean is anything like Japanese there aren't a lot of silent sounds. With the exception of the letter N there is usually a vowel so "fake" would sound like fa-ke (actually more like fe-ke) if that makes sense. I'm not sure if I wrote this clear enough or if that's the reason but 🤷‍♀️...

Can you please react to Stigma live by BTS V (Kim Taehyung)

great reaction!!! :) keep going coz you are good at it! :)

BTS, please let Dr Marc Reynolds to colaborate with you. I would love to see that 😁

Great review 👍

Lmao am I the only one that laughed at that "big heat" part 😂 i'm not even mad or anything I was just shook 😂

Yes i agree with you on the set design, costumes! Have you seen their performance on 2018 MMA? You need to check that oooouuutt

I am new to your channel and i love the way you analyse performances

wow great tips !

And now Fake love at MAMA 2018! This is another georgeous and absolutely different performance! Please check it!) And thank for that reaction!)

You know, your comments made me think that westerners often have different feelings towards individualism. I think its interesting that BTS's core message is about self acceptance, and all in the backdrop of 'we are a group that is successful because of how each individual fits in to the big picture.' Kpop is intended to be inclusive of music in other countries, and I think curiosity and innovation are highly valued, so any individuality is also highly valued, but within the frame of how it will benefit 'us'. Also, ironically, it leads to a sort of humbleness that in its extremity is a humble brag, which is refreshingly popular here in the US?

RM now stands for "real me"

Please react to hold me tight live😍

The korean language actually has a schwa-like vowel ㅓ so it comes way more naturally for them to use especially when it comes to their accent when pronouncing english words. Its pretty cool.

thank you for reacting to BTS love it . kpop idols start in very young age. the companies train talent kids for 3yrs. some of them are so talented so they finish their training in 1yrs. the company control everything in idol life, so no drugs, women... etc ...which makes all of them hard worker and getting better and better. (some bad companies don't care, so they let the fame destroy the idol)

Check out make it right live or airplane pt 2 live

You should react to their performance at Melon Music Awards 2018 BTS WHO ARE YOU I think that that performance itself was such an amazing and inspirational one! DEFINITELY worth seeing, you will not regret it

Their company is called Big Hit Entertainment 💜

I would LOVE to see you do more BTS! You have a very interesting perspective!! Their MV Blood Sweat and Tears is AMAZINGLY well-done with so much symbolism and depth, its breathtaking! Thank you for your reaction!

the fun facts is cute 💜, i love it 💜💜

Please react to bts Airplane live

I think BTS and BigHit have great synergy and is a well oiled machine in the best possible sense. I think many fans are jaded on the term "machine" as in the past it has been used in a negative and derogatory way. how they are like robots with no thought of their own and they are just pretty dolls. BTS and their fans work hard to try and dispel those pre-conceived ideas that kpop is known for. I think they took the training aspect of kpop with the creative control and freedom of an indie artist and combined it. Hard to describe, I'm Korean and have been around korean music and kpop all my life but BTS is that one group that really stands out to me.

BTS are awesome storytellers. they believe in their music's message. it helps a lot that they write, compose and produce their own music that's why they know how to express the feelings of their songs and how to show it in their amazing choreography as well. BTS show the same intensity, energy aand facial expressions even when in their dance practice. they very passionate about what they do that's why they are so pleasant and entertaining to watch. BTS is the best! there's nothing like BTS!

U should check make it right live on the late show with stephen colbert thanks so muchhh

Thank you for listening to us first🙇

If only interviewers put as much effort into looking up BTS as he did.

Love BTS 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜 That's the first thing notice I from watching the 7 members their interpertation of the music

BTS are awesome storytellers. they believe in their music's message. it helps a lot that they write, compose and produce their own music that's why they know how to express the feelings of their songs and how to show it in their amazing choreography as well. BTS show the same intensity, energy aand facial expressions even when in their dance practice. they very passionate about what they do that's why they are so pleasant and entertaining to watch. BTS is the best! there's nothing like BTS! i love everything BTS! like your reaction. kudos!

Hope you could react to Blood Sweat and Tears... and BTS "WHO ARE YOU?" MMA PERFORMANCE 2018

GORGIOUS

BTS my life 😍 Thank you

You looked so happy the whole time and damn, you have some pretty eye lashes xD

Big heat ...

RM means Real Me now not Rap Monster. He changed it at the end of 2017.