Voice Teachers React to Wheein from Mamamoo and MeloMance Back Again Open Mic 

You need to see Wheein's song "Anymore" live.

this song isn’t really a duet, it’s wheein’s song. she definitely adjusted her voice for him and to be honest, i don’t mind it. i do see and hear her hold back as well in this performance though. but since wheein barely does solo activities, i’m just excited to have this performance. i think she’s definitely adjusting more to being a solo artist but i’m glad she’s being included more in events since her signing with a new agency.

if you want a song where she doesn't use breathy vocals and sings with fuller voice i recommend the song Short Hair in Duet Music Festival from 2015. Wheein and her partner won, and this is 1 year after Mamamoo debut. another song i'll recommend is MAMAMOO WHEEIN (Half Moon) - Who's Your Mama (King Of Masked Singer). she also use fuller voice + raps a verse, She Was Pretty(also from Duet Music Festival), and her solo Butterfly. Wheein is known for her breathy and r&b vocals. no one can touch her in r&b vocals in Kpop(her solo 25 and Candy cover are her best). from all the Kpop idols, Wheein is the only kpop idol in Korea's top 5 singers. Solar(leader of Mamamoo) said about Wheein's voice: "her voice gives you the feeling of being healed". she is one of the top singers that other singers want to feat/colab with. from the members of Mamamoo she has the most feats/colabs. Park Bom from the biggest female Kpop group : 2ne1(pronounced as 21) made a song as her solo and she changed the song just to have Wheein as feat in the song. even though Solar has the power vocals with clarity and power, can growl, etc she chose Wheein instead.

I like Melia faces so much 😂 She looks so shocked and it's adorable. I'm eager to see you two reacting to Mamamoo immortal songs medley 😍

mamamoo medley immortal song is a must ♥️

Wheein is known as queen of Collab because she can blend in to anyone style of singing

And about the breathy quality here some points: 1. In korea they appreciate this kind of quality in slow and atmospheric songs like the song - with my tears- 2. Wheein in mamamoo has almost the rule of being the breathy one and the layed back voice also she does alot of the backing harmonious in their songs 3.the songs that wheein sang it with this style has more acceptance and success from the audience there That's why we don't hear alot of the "full sound singing" from her

This song is by Seo Ji Won. He was a ballad singer and genious composer and decided to leave this world when he was 19, in 1996. Wheein covered the song for "hospital playlist", a popular kdrama and this song topped the charts again. This was the ost for quite of a sad episode.

It would be great if you analyse her lives of her solo album. You did a great job analysing her in this video, lovely. But if you wanna se her as her full you can look at those videos ✨💙

This is an old tune that Wheein covered as a solo song for a kdrama OST last year. Surprised that Melia didn't seem to have heard Wheein's breathiness previously. That airy breathiness is her signature style of singing. I think there were two additional things that influenced Wheein's vocal choices - the arc of the song and the song as a conversation. She starts off very soft and tentative and he responds with more confidence, establishing different personalities in both the singing and the relationship. In the final chorus she is singing with more of her full voice as the song story climaxes so the change in her singing mirrors the arc of the love story they're telling. Mamamoo is one of the best pop groups I've heard at using dynamics in both individual phrases and as part of the overall song story.

Ah “With My Tears” is actually a Wheein ost solo. It’s been said but you guys should check out her other ballads, (they have live versions) “Goodbye” and “Anymore.” Also her last album, she did a video for all the tracks! Glad to see Mamamoo on this channel. Love learning new things from your analysis’ on these videos :)

You can't go wrong with Mamamoo and their OSTs, I literally start watching kdramas when I find out they are on the soundtrack 💛 Hope you do more videos of the members!

Actually mamamoo fans really love when voice teacher or vocal coach react to them.. because they really talented in singing... thank you for the reaction chase and Melia ... hoping to see you two react to immortal song by mamamoo

MeloMance never fails to amaze me, very underrated.

Thank you for reacting to Wheein. We appreciate it so much. We're looking forward for more reactions to her. I recommend reacting to Wheein's Anymore and Goodbye (her ballad songs)

I love how you said you'd wish to see if Melomance was singing a Wheein's song. Well, they just did "Starry Night" from Mamamoo on Begin Again. The video is out since yesterday!

I personally love love love her lower breathy low notes. It really gives me goosebumps. Also for the style of singing you prefer I would highly recommend her song anymore ( color live)

Mamamoo immortal songs melody next please! It would be interesting to hear your comments on a concert setting.

oh and yeah.. immortal songs medley of mamamoo too ❤️❤️❤️

adding this channel with my fave reactors. my first professional reactors 🥰

Thank you for reacting to Wheein, I really loved all your coments an opinions, I love hearing people that know what they're talking about. I wanted to say that Wheein sings this song in a more breathy way as an stylistic choice, it's a testament to the feeling she wants to convey of the public, I like to call this song a 'mourning song' because of it's history (the original singer died at the age of 19, weeks before releasing his 2nd cd which contained this song, indeed if you see the original MV of this song it shows images of his funeral) that's why this became an instant classic song, and is not only sad, like is really a SAD song, like heartbreaking, and Wheein did a wonderful job recreating that feeling on her cover OST; also she is trying to harmonize with him a lot and I think she shouldn't have, bcs he's such a good singer that her using her full voice wouldn't made a difference (but Wheein is called the queen of collaborations bcs she does exactly that, harmonize with any type of voice and singer) I felt that that truly takes a lot of that feeling she puts on the song, like she is opening up your heart at putting it back together, that made her version loved by the public, an absolute succes. I loved the duet, but while I also think Minseok is a fascinating and fantastic singer (I fell in love with his voice) I think it really gave another feel the song, that it really doesn't get trough us like the Wheein version did, so that said I obviously prefer Wheein's version, breathy tone and all. Please do a reaction to her song Anymore live! It's a version called 'Anymore color live' (it has eng subs and it's just Wheein voice + Piano 😍😍)

If you want to listen to each mamamoo member individually they all have solos that you can listen to I personally love this song from wheein it's just an amazing and beautiful song

You need to hear Wheein-Butterfly live record performance. It's so good and we can hear her versatility 🥰🦋

Listen to her solo version of this, she sang this for the ost of Hospital Playlist. She originally sang this song powerfully, so we can sense her holding back here to match the duet 😊 Both versions are masterpiece 👌

Please react to Wheein duet performance forget me now or her live butterfly performance, it’s incredible

Wheein’s “anymore” live is great and will give you more of an idea of her voice. She also did this song no more tears by herself live which I prefer cause she didn’t have to worry about blending or holding back a bit to match.

Oh gosh Melomance his voice is so sooting.Every time i isten to it my heart tightens

How wonderful of you reacting to Mamamoo's Wheein and especially MeloMance's Kim Min-seok 😍. I'm in love with Kim's voice. Since I met Melomance through the OST of the series "Because This is My First Life" (Netflix), I just can't get enough of listening to him (it's really a lovely voice). I always follow his lives on instagram that never disappoint. ❤

This is the second song of the performance. First Wheein does a solo cover of EXO's loveshot. Both in that and this she's using her lower range a lot more than we usually see. Pure speculation, I think she chose to do it because she does spend most of her time in Mamamoo on the high end. In this song I think she liked being the low to his high. I hope you will do other solo performance of the other Mamamoo members. Solar has a couple of recent OSTs on her solarsido channel. Adrenaline and Bluebird that would be good.

The reaction video you guys did for mamamoo was my first reactor video too and I absolutely loved it! So excited that you guys did another reaction video for wheein. I was already blown away when I first heard mamamoo and your analysis and breakdown really helps me to appreciate their vocals even more, the techniques that they use, where and how their voices shine, and how well they blend with each other. It makes me so in awe when you put all these into words to help me appreciate and understand that it’s not easy at all to sing so well like so many talented singers out there hahaha. Thank you for the videos!! Would love to see more reacting to mamamoo esp their live performances which many has recommended! 🤩

thank you for this reaction!!! if you wanted more content to react to... 1. Wheein Solos: Anymore (Live) and Goodbye (Live) 2. Mamamoo Immortal Songs (particularly Backwoods and The Way to Sampo)

Melomance is a terrific duo Minds on has an amazing range and singer, pls react to their song: Gift and 2018 You.

Some people don't know that Mamamoo have had a RU-vid channel from the beginning and on that is some amazing music.

This song it's really beautiful 🥰 it's actually a song Wheein sing alone i was very curious how a duet would go i found really lovely the guy voice i hope you'll still react to Mamamoo in the future 🥰 i raccomend for Wheein to the love version of anymore or goodbye these are two beautiful ballads that makes me love Wheein voice so much 😍

His voice is really special. He's a duo with his friend, the piano player, who is also very gifted on the keys-he's wonderfully emotive with his playing while keeping it clean, if that makes sense. The duo is called Melomance (멜로망스)and their breakthrough song was Gift (선물) and it swept through the country when it was released here. Everyone knows that song and his voice is recognized by everyone in the country.

Harmonies were heavenly! You guys already know breathiness is def not my preference. 😆I like resonance, whether piano or forte. When I hear too much breathiness I get a weird feeling in my “throat”. Maybe *I’m* just weird! 😂 as usual, thoroughly enjoyed the commentary. 👍

Not related to Wheein, but I would honestly love if you guys reacted to the “battle” rounds on the Voice and chose your personal winners for those performances based on technique/personal preferences! Love the fact that you mention that personal preference doesn’t necessarily equal better and love that you’re encouraging people to consider the way they want to sing! I feel like my core philosophy is identical to yours, but because I’m influenced by so many different styles of music, I want to explore shaping my ‘natural’ voice in different contexts that make the most sense for the style of whatever song I’m singing. That way I sound and feel like me while also achieving a specific vision I had for the song! It’s really circumstantial - feels like the best of both worlds for myself!

You can't go wrong with MAMAMOO ❤️

When I saw the duration, I think you're going to react both songs of first segment, in my tears and love shot. But it's ok, you can react to love shot and mamamoo immortal songs medley another time 😁 Anw, thank you for this reaction 🧡

Wow! You are the most meticulous and detailed voice reactors I have ever watched. I am learning so much from both of you! I came for Wheein but I also got to love Melomance because of this performance. Keep up the good work! I also love your covers! ❤️❤️❤️

Strongly recommend. Be sure to watch the [ I Missing You ] video that Mamamoo live performance on the Queendom TV show. Mamamoo You can recognize their vocals. This is a very famous video. Also, the song that MeloMance became famous for is the song [Gift]. For reference, Rosé and Onew performed a number of famous songs live at the beach. It was filmed on a TV show, and you will feel lovely and happy when you watch the video. This video is about 3 months old as of now. You must search by the names of Rosé and Onew.

Omg i have been waiting for this! Thank you~

Muchas gracias por este video. Wheein tiene una voz de miel que nos cura el alma 💚

Love how genuine your reactions are ❤

Loved this reaction, thank you both!

Wheein is famous for her breathy voice and falsetto, but she could go full voice too...she did it a lot a lot in shows and concerts. Anyway, She also did a cover of EXO’s Love shot on this show, which I actually prefer more. I kinda wish you could react to Hwasa too, her Flying to the moon cover is great. P.S. I do agree Melomance has great voice and skills, they are famous in Korea...I think.

Her soft vocal just beyond then everything 😇💗💞

ha, that 'just found another amazing singer' thing is actually pretty common with wheein... every single person she's ever worked with for collabs/features, every single artist she's suggested songs from... they're all incredible in their own fields (and she suggests a lot of western music, too) as for 'with my tears"... the song itself is a cover... she's done it on her own before for an ost to a drama, and now performing it together with the melomance singer (the pianist is the other member of melomance). hearing her sing that live on her own is incredible... and there are a few lives for it out there they've got several other songs either already out or coming out in the future with this show... i think they recorded it all at once but it's being shared out over several weeks. first we had wheein singing exo's "love shot" on her own (just with piano accompaniment), then this song... the most recent release so far is the two performing mamamoo's "starry night". really curious what we'll get in the future from them

Thank you Melomance is finally be part of your react. Please react "Gift" by Melomance too. Kim Min Seok by Melomance has an amazing and beautiful voice. I really love to hear his voice.

It's been one week since I'm watching and repeating your videos I've never loved professionals reactions but you guys are special I can see how real your reaction is so I'm waiting for more

I love this break down ❤️ Indeed they're great singer 👏🏻👏🏻

nice analysis! it was fun to listen to both wheein of mamamoo and the guy from melomance!

i always look forward to your reactions !

Thank you for another Mamamoo (Wheein) video. I really love the girls and their voices but I can't articulate why as it's very much an emotional connection and I don't know much about the technicalities of being a vocalists. I really appreciate the details you go into, breaking down the techniques, the decisions they make...it helps me to further appreciate their voices from a different perspective.

onew captured ur heart with his ballad-ish voice but his full voice is also so good whenever he sings their grp songs. its so unique

Well well well, I just discovered you thanks to your Mamamoo's Killer voice video.... and I was like ''oww I wished they reviewed more from Mamamoo'' and 6 hours later, here we are!

I hope u'd react more to melomance's performances because he has a great voice as u can see, and sometimes he sounds powerful yet melodic but his expression is so calm that he makes singing looks so easy and effortless lol

u can really see wheein's control on the last chorus as she sang with melomance, it's like she balances the volume of hers and his voice so she switches from breathy and full clear voice....she's amazing

Thank you for the analysis and the reaction! You guys make me missed the time when i was in choir :'). For my opinion, Wheein is a builder and breather singer for slow song/ballad.. Sometimes i confused because she sings beautifully for any type of songs :' lmao I want my voice to be forward and clear hahaha i wish man

OMG my Queen 👑 ❤️ She’s so talented 🤍

🙋 new fan 🙂 im loving the way you guys describe techniques used and explain how the vocal is placed in a song 👍

It's funny how voices and tastes work, I actually didn't like Melonmance voice at all, because I'm so used to Wheein's version of the song, his voice irritated me so much 😅 I can't deny it's unique, but I actually didn't like him at all, but I kept my thoughts on that on the original video, because I didn't want to be toxic. Nothing against him, his voice just wasn't of my taste, and you guys loved him so much, on the other hand, because I think art is subjective, like you guys said. But I agree, because Wheein it's so good at blending, she definitely held herself back to not outshine Melomance. Also, please react to Wheein on Begin Again signing Love Shot! She signs alone there and I feel she shines way more there!

thank you please more mamamoo react

I love the points you made around the 13-minute mark and onwards! A good number of the vocal teachers and coaches that I follow on social media (especially Instagram) are very big on how one should sing or "approach" specific segments of songs using different placements and it has made me quite insecure, thinking that if I can't approach the song the exact same way, then I'm not singing well at all. No shade or disrespect for those coaches and teachers of course (and I'm sure that some of them are advising with vocal health in mind, especially for songs that require a lot more effort and technique) but I just really appreciate your sentiments/views on it :) and you explained everything so well too. Thanks for another great reaction video!

please check out wheein's solo ballad "goodbye", it's one of my favorite songs and i think y'all would enjoy reacting to it too! i had to listen to it close to ten times before i stopped crying every time i heard it, wheein really brings across emotion so well in that song.

Wheein goodbye and anymore please watch it live😍🥰

There is a whole Wheein x (another singer) duet to watch and listen to, 1. She Was Pretty (2016) - ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-4f2r92O7a8Q.html (I like how she sings in this perf, It was kinda full voice(idk but it sounds full) and we are not getting that often from her. A lot of people might get irritate with the rapper voices tho) 2. Short Hair (2015) - ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-3VXYwJ1MNVo.html (Probably like the first one. Fun song, full voice with rapper) 3. Forget Me Now (2017) -ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-wPEM8mwuhws.html (This is my all-time favourite of all time even though it is a slow sad song but their voices blended so well) 4. Day Day (2017) - ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-wdRuoi7aiDg.html (Not full song in this one. It is hip-hop style and with the same singer with no.3) Also, I'm looking for the Immortal Song Medley Reaction from you guys!

i thought they both sound amazing and they blend together nicely. loved it!

oh my god i would love for you to react to goodbye wheein live version

I really love your analysis and your channel has became one of my favorites. For this reaction, I like you two to talk about the breathness, closure of vocal cords, efficiency, resonance, subjective in music, and blending voices. As a physicist, I really appreciate that you pointed out that every person has different instrument to make voice and judging is based on preference/bias. Speaking of contrast to Wheein, inside Mamamoo, people first think about Solar as she uses aspiration less and does powerful belting often with more closure of vocal cords. Then, Hwasa does a lot of different things in between. It is always interesting to compare their voices and see how they switch techniques in different situactions. So, I would love to see more comparisons about their voices and detailed reactions for their solo projects. About preference, I like all of their voices but my preference of singing is when they sing more cleary, less airy, and good resonance as that is when I feel more emotionally connected. Besides my favorite Mamamoo, I also love the voice of MeloMance. I would love to see more reactions about them.

Glad to hear you say "how you speak is how you sing". That's exactly how I want to sing. Kind of like speaking the melody but holding notes where it fits. Trying to get a feeling that I'm speaking the lyrics and it just happens to be to a melody. I haven't sung much in a while, though, and I've lost a lot of my technique but very resently I've started trying to get back into it. You guys just added to my inspiration to keep at it. Thanks!

If you wanna listen more to Melomance, you can try this clip (The gift) performed in the same TV program. Melomance is a two-men boy group with him (KIM, Min-seok) as the vocalist and another (JEONG, dong-hwan) as the pianist. They debuted in 2015 and this song The Gift was released in 2017 and was a big hit in Korea. Here is the clip fir you and the aong starts at 0:37 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Gx_Rv7226AE.html

I wished you reacted to wheein love shot too, you can hear her versatile & how good she is

Mamamoo inmortal song medley...please

You should check out mamamoo Delilah! They were rookies here, it is amazing

We absolutely need mamamoo immortal songs reaction!!!

You reacted to Wheein 😭😭😭 thank you so muchh

So glad you enjoyed Melomance, please react to more from them as well :)

I wonder if you can also do Day6. I have a feeling you will love them cos they have different singing styles but all together works so great. They're a korean band, like they play the guitars keyboard and drums and they all sing amazingly. hope you can check them out.

Originally Wheein recorded a cover of this song for a Korean drama so I guess you could tell that she is not used to singing this song with someone else but this is another live performance of the song she does by herself if you guys wanna check it out :) ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-2XMjXZtU8tA.html

Melomance is one of my favorite groups in Korean music. The vocalist is Kim Minseok, and the other half is the pianist Donghwan. Minseok is probably one of the best vocalists I've ever heard. You should definitely check out more from Melomance, Minseok is a power vocal and he was definitely holding back to fit Wheein's song and vibe. Thank you for reacting to this, not many people, outside of Korea, know the greatness of Melomance. Thank you again, loved your reaction.

beautiful 💜

That was beautifull Loveee Wheeinn

i cant agree more to you guys!!! theyre both wonderful! they are doing their part on this duet, and yes i agree that it was unfair to her voice but still she killed it! she still made this song best and i dont know anyone who can do it better. i love hiiiiiissss voice tooo im kinda obsessed too hahaha its so different but in an amazing way!! Wheein's voice is a dream... i hope i will have kids who can sing like her cause im definitely Solar type of singing hahhaha

More mamamoo pleaseeeee!!!!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

you guys are the best when it comes to reacting to singing videos 👍

Guys, MAMAMOO will be touring the USA between May and June 2023! ❤‍🔥 Their tour starts on May 16th. ❤‍🔥 They're going to several cities

One thing I realize about wheein is that she doesn’t like to oversing anyone I’m mean it’s good that she letting the other person shine but it’s doesn’t give her time shine

Please also react to wheein "Love shot" cover it's also on Begin Again Open Mic

please react to MAMAMO's immortal songs medley videooo 😭😭🙏🙏

if you like melomance voice, you guys can check out one of his songs called 'gift'. its really a best song for me. thankyou ^^

woow! This video is such a surprise! Thank you for liking mamamoo. This song is a drama OST, and old song and she sang a cover version for a drama, and yes this is a SAD song, that’s why she choice to sing soft like that. You can find the ost in any platform.

You should react to BIGMAMA on Dingo music/Killing voice! They are a South Korean vocal girl group who debuted in 2003, unfortunately, they disbanded in 2012 but they've reunited & comeback in 2021.

She sang exo's loveshot also in that program, you should include it too

I feel Chase when he talks about trying to not be too breathy for health issues. Im working on that right now. I love singing but a lot of the time my throat ends up feeling kind of sore, which makes me sound a bit off and it puts me off singing. Currently working on it with my voice teacher and speech therapist tho!

FACT : SEO JI WON, THE ORIGINAL SINGER PASSED AWAY IN 1996 BEFORE THIS SONG DEBUT 😭😭😭😭

I was watching ur videos n encounter with mamamoo where are we now live performance... U should totally check that out... That was stunning... Cause that song literally focuses on their vocals

The show is actually called "Begin Again"!

I think sometimes the language barrier makes it hard for those that don't speak Korean as to why some songs sound "breathy", "whispery" during parts or soft. It is like this to make the lyrics shine. If you understand the lyrics, it really gives you goosebumps the way they sing it.

You need to see more Melomance songs, Melomance is a duo( the pianist and the singer), they have beautiful songs, I recommend the song ''Gift'', is a famous song in korea.