Voigtlander 28mm f/1.5 vs Thypoch 28mm f/1.4 

After trying both, I went with the Voigt. Didn't like the mechanics and weird design choices of the Thypoch. Like the sharpness in the Voigt as well.

Great comparison. I’ve been using the Voigtlander for a couple of months and it has replaced my Summicron for travel. I have the aluminum version and it is so light and performs so good for night street and events.

I’ve been waiting for this video too!

The comparison we needed so bad!

So, I owned the Voigtlander already, and I just bought the Thypoch last week to compare them, and here's what I'll add from my own experiences: - I'm going to return the Thypoch, even though I truly like the image quality more. - The Thypoch is heavier by just enough that with my m10 and thin leather strap, it feels too heavy compared to the aluminum Voigtlander. - I like the Voigtlander build and design choices more. - I like that the Voigtlander is lighter and smaller - I like the classic depth of field indicator on the Voigtlander (much easier to use) - I like the traditional focus tab more - I prefer the 1/2 increments on the Voigtlander instead of the 1/3 stops on the Thypoch - The focus throw on the Thypoch feels uneven -- it seems like it slowly goes from infinity to 2m, then quickly from 2m to 0.4m - I actually didn't love the detent at 0.7m. It's not smooth and basically felt like you can focus at 0.7 or 0.4, and anything in between felt difficult to dial in. - The Thypoch has better character in the images and MUCH better control of field curvature - The Thypoch is probably the better deal if you don't mind the negatives I listed. If the size difference didn't bother me, I probably would have put up with the downsides and sold my Voigtlander. But as it stands, the Voigtlander gets out of my way better, and for me that's worth way more than the slight improvement in image quality.

As far as 6-bit coding goes, you can get a blank 6 bit code mount and paint in the code (in this case the 28mm Summilux) yourself, as well as I've even seen some eBay stores offer to paint in whichever code you specify upon purchase. Obviously you also need to get the correct type of mount, in this case the 28/90 to make sure the framelines are correct. As always, nice little video! I hope you get to cover Typoch's next lens, the 50mm f2 Eureka which is a remake of a Reid Taylor-Hobson from the 1940s. It looks awesome besides the odd divot on the top of the lens mount, which feels it could compromise the mount or at least could collect dust & dirt over time.

This video was very insightful. I like how you utilized the lenses in different scenarios, different light sources and subjects. I also like how you kept expectations grounded, these are budget options. Perfect mix of vlog and information, thanks!

You’re the best with disclosures! Appreciate your honest reviews Benj!

Man, Thypoch is killing it lately. I wish I was better at manual focusing 😂

Very cool!..that Thypoch depth of filed scale..adds character and is really cool...thats something you dont see anymore..

From 45 years of experience I have learned that 28mm for full frame sensor Cameras (24x36mm) is more or less useless, it always seems either too long or too short, clumsy ! Now I use 21mm (sometimes 24mm) and 35mm.

I Love using the adapter Pholsy or Fotasy ( I can't Remember) , using the M Mount Voigtlander 75mm f/1.8 Helios lens. I have used the F Mount Nikon Zeiss 50mm f/2 Makro-Planar on the SL2-S and the Voigtlander and it is great. I hate to say it I still like the autofocusing lenses better. It does give me experience on what the Mr. Leica's People go through. Cheers!

Would love to see you test out the VM 35/1.5 too!

Hello Benj, thanks for this video, the Voigtlander lens hood are to be purchased separately, on one hand it adds another 100 to the bill on the other hand the hood is premium metal, you get to choose the one you like (rectangular or round) you can buy it again if you would loose it (who does that) or not buying it at all if you're on a budget. This 28 renders superb fully open.

Been waiting for this video from you! I’ve been on the fence and this was a solid video to help me choose! 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 thank you

I'm really curious to how these compare to the Laowa 28mm F1.2 for L Mount.

Apparently Thypoch are also releasing these lenses in Nikon Z mount

Are they better than 2,0 ultron 2?

Besides having the Leica 24-70mm f/2.8 and the 90-280 f/2.8-4 I love the Sigma L Mount I Series Lenses 35mm, 45mm, 65mm, 90mm and the 150-600mm OSS Sports Telephoto Zoom lens. I do also own the Sigma 24mm f/1.4 DG DN Art and the Panasonic 50mm & 85mm f/1.8 plus the 14-24mm wide zoom. Also I have the Panasonic 50mm f/1.4 Pro. I love the Leica SL2-S and the Panasonic's S5II & S5IIX cameras. I have all three cameras and lenses plus dummy batterires, chargers and one open spot for the new Leica SL3 to fit in two rucksacks. My everyday camera besides the Nikon Zf is the Leica Q3. Cheers!

3 years have past since you tested the 28mm 1.4 7artisan. Time flies

I'd assume you took your test shots on a tripod, but I'd love a video on tips for shooting with Leica/non-stabilized cameras. I continually struggle to get even semi-sharp photos on my M11, which just makes the 60MP feel like a waste.

Please to see the ZF has arrived. Keen to hear your thoughts with M lenses in due course

Great video. Very informative. Waiting for your review of the auto focus adapter you have on the ZF. Those can be a game changer if they work well.

Oh my god, can someone competent like you finally do a real review of that Techart adapter that actual runs it through real world scenarios. Nothing online goes in depth on that thing. Also, I know it tops out at 500g but I'm curious if you can get away with 530 or 590g lenses. I have a 90 summicron that would be amazing with autofocus.

where/how did you get the screw to replace the red dot?

Now, how do they compare to the 28 mm / 1:2.0 Ultron aspherical mkII? thanks

Out of the 28mm you've tested, which one (or ones) do you feel have more character in their rendering? I love squirly bokeh and a vintage feel in the rendering, so I'm trying to figure out what's the best lens for the purpose (ideally without sacrificing sharpness, or at least not too much :) )

Fun comparison! You were saying something about T stops. If both lenses were at, say, f2, does one let in more light than the other at the same exposure settings? And compared to the Ultron?

As an owner of the Voigtlander 28mm 1.5, I'm actually finding the Thypoch images to be a little more pleasant for one big reason: the lack of field curvature. I love the Voigtlander 28, but the edges start to come back into focus at 1.5, and it can make a sort of unnatural look, at times. I prefer the look and weight of the Voigtlander lens, but in terms of image character and look, I'm frustratingly drawn to the Thypoch.

Okay, thanks Ben. I was obsessing over the Zeiss Distagon f2 / 28mm classic lens for more than 2 months now. This is because I have a new Nikon Zf and want a wide angle lens to go with it. Now, I am not even sure, if I should try this Voigtlander and see if I should buy this instead. Does anyone here, have a comparison between this 28mm Voigtlander and the classic Zeiss 28mm Distagon? Or any thoughts? I would welcome some suggestions. Thanks

Hi! I'm curious if you ended up selling your 28mm summicron for any of these lenses? I've recently been debating the same thing

Did you ever try the color skopar 28mm f/2.8?

Anyone find a hood that works with the voigt 28 1.5?

Nice video. How are they compered to the 7Artisans 28mm/1.4?

Would like to see it compared to the summilux, since apparently the optical design of the Simera is identical to the FLE.

What’s with the silver front ring on the Typoch? Didn’t ever see that before

Those unreleased presets look great!

Benj sorry i have question how u change srew on leica logo on m11?

how does the Voigtlander compare to your Cron? I'm in the middle of a decision between the two (used Cron for $2100).

Sell the summicron and get a Q :)

Kind of non-committal and unhelpful video. Even if both lenses are kind of similar, I would have liked to see more side-by-side shots so that I could at least judge for myself which lens would be better for me. I usually enjoy your videos more. Looking forward to your experience with the Zf.

间接推荐Thypoch的恰饭视频，给Benj差评。

Nokton is clearer, contrastier, sharper WO, a better image quality, strongest flare resistance, optical vignetting and curved field are always the obvious flaws, and probably fringing too.

Thypoch c'est de la merde !