@@WarriorcatsX0i think Redstar should be the worst thunderclan and darkstar the worst riverclan: Redstar was the one who drove away Skyclan while pinestar only became a kittypet Darkstar refused to let Mapleshade join riverclan and Leopardstar didnt even do anything
@@Starburst_Studio ikr they could've just said "nobody" if they didn't know whom to put in the worst leader part but what did onestar do wrong as a leader though? I'm curious he always chose peace over fighting and was good friends with Firestar, I don't see anyrhing wrong with that. Onestar just reminds me of Rowanstar but better Rowanstar failed his leadership sooo...
@@GLBlob onestar isnt really a terrible *leader* instead just a horrible *cat* He stopped being nice after becoming leader; being super mean to Firestar, he had abandoned Darkkit and Smoke causing Darktail to come back to get revenge, he was basically cheating on Whitetail (i think thats her name anyway)
In fact Tigerstar (Tigerclaw) wasn't so bad, after all he helped ShadowClan recover when they had no leader, and it was thanks to his leadership skills that StarClan gave him the nine lives. That he was a cruel and greedy villain? Yes, he was, he is a murderer and a traitor, but objectively, he was not such a bad leader. Brokenstar would be the worst, he was literally the reason ShadowClan was almost destroyed, he didn't take care of his clan and only cared about himself, Tigerstar at least looked after his new clan and had his warriors well fed. And sorry for spelling or grammatical errors, I speak Spanish and I am using translator, jsjs.
My worst Shadow-clan leader is tied with Broken star and Tiger claw/star. Broken star literally ate children , killed multiple cats and made elders live off the territory along with stealing prey. Tigerstar killed multiple cats , made River clan and Shadow clan join , and he manipulated other cats (even kits) to do things for him. Though , Tigerstar was through a lot when he was little , and even meant to be killed at birth and given the mentor thistleclaw.
(this is my opinnion) I dont agree with Tigerstar the 2nd. I have just finished AVOS and he already sucks! he might be much, less stuborn and generous in TBC or ASC but so far i think he isnt the “best” SC leader after all he has done so far. And for Tigerstar he has done so many horrible things to other clans and shadowclan but he didnt live long enough to prove he was worse than brokenstar i cant imagine what horrible thing he might have planned to do to shadowclan but he didnt… although he caused so many trouble for shadowclan i think that hadnt been enough to beat the suffering brokenstar has caused to the cats under his rain…
I think the worst leader of the shadow clan is Brockenstar. And about Pinestar... no, seriously, he was a good cat and leader! The last act was only out of fear for the tribe and because of fatigue.
I don't understand the Leopardstar one, she was a pretty good leader after Tigerstar died. She had a temper but in the end she was respectful. It just doesn't seem right she's crowned the worst.
She teamed with Tigerstar and let him take over her clan, she also let all of her clan mates become “prisoners” and she did nothing about it. Then when Tigerstar was trying to kill all of the half clan kits, she also did nothing and just watched stonefur die.
@@WarriorcatsX0mean like she was manipulated and didn’t really own her clan anymore so probably felt powerless like remember when she said ‘just listen to tigerstar’ she was pretty much fed up with life
Best TC Leader: Squirrelstar (The complete opposite of Bramblestar lol.) Worst TC Leader: Bramblestar (He did absolutely nothing for his clan and didn't even make sure his clan was doing okay.) Best RC Leader: Leopardstar (Probably just because I like her name :Y) Worst RC Leader: Hailstar (All he wanted was ThunderClan's Sunningrocks, which clearly belonged to TC!) Best WC Leader: Harestar (He is watching over his clan and being responsible, like a real leader.) Worst WC Leader: Tallstar (I like him, just not as much as a leader.) Best SC Leader: Tigerstar l (He made sure his clan was doing well, not crushing them.) Worst SC Leader: Raggedstar (He only cared for Brokentail and did absolutely nothing about his clan.)
In my opinion: Best Thunderclan leader: Squirrelstar (i know she just became leader but I have faith) Worst Thunderclan leader: Bluestar. I'm sorry, I love her, but I don't like her as leader. Best Windclan leader: Tallstar? Worst Windclan leader: Onestar. No debate. Best Riverclan leader: Crookedstar Worst Riverclan leader: Leopardstar? Best Shadowclan leader: Tiger(heart)star Worst Shadowclan leader: Brokenstar
@@Starburst_Studioshe took the Sunningrocks by force until ThunderClan reinforcement arrived/She joined TigerClan and did nothing about Tigerstar doing the horrible things he did
@@AyanoAishisdaughter sunningrocks rightfully belongs to Riverclan so why wouldn’t she fight when Thunderclan steals it? And besides this id WARRIOR CATS starting a border scuffle doesn’t make you an irredeemable monster. And she only joined tigerclan because she was scared. Also Crookedstar was a massive pushover he let brokenstar hunt in their territory whenever they wanted to he definitely would have done the same thing. And he was mean to leopardfur after making her deputy because the young, aggressive, immature cat he made deputy didn’t like him letting the other clans shove Riverclan around without even taking to her first so he would definitely have not saved her. And if featherpaw and stormpaw weren’t his grandkids he wouldn’t try to save them either
It's because she just let her deputy (stonefur) die in front of his sister and apprentice and did nothing about it, additionally she just straight up joined tigerclaw when he was killing everybody. Bright guardian akira should have a few videos on it, I advise checking her out.
the worst shadowClan leader has to be nightStar, It's like, right after he becomes leader he lives for a moon and then dies, all he does is led a rebellion against Brokenstar's tyrannical leadership, only with the help of Thunderclan, Tigerstar is not the best leader ever but at least he makes ShadowClan strong again and he does at least hold shadowClan together unlike NightStar, NightStar in my opinion is the worst shadowClan leader,
I don’t blame him for dying so soon though, he was an old cat. I’m not sure why anyone thought he was fit to be a leader, especially considering even starclan themselves thought he was too old and frail. He could have been honest with his clan mates about not having a ceremony though, surely there was someone more willing and able to be a good leader in the clan even if it wasn’t him.
