Was Chicho Arango Offside in Game-Winning Goal vs. Sporting Kansas City? 

Sorry, no way that's not a straight red on the Fosberg foul - just because the players didn't react, does not make it acceptable.

“Player reaction” can go with “got the ball.” Straight in the bin.

That's a red every day. Left his feet, no attempt on the ball, endangered the safety of the player. Player safety should never be sacrificed for "game management".

No var in Miami is atrocious. Like Wiebe said, if Forsberg is planted just a bit differently that's a fucking season- and maybe career-ender. The definition of endangering the safety of a player, worse than a lot of the other reds this year

What's the point of having a VAR if he's sleeping on the job? That has to be a red card for Miami. Disgraceful

Look it doesn't matter if players aren't protesting a yellow. That miami player left the ground with two feet, got nowhere NEAR the ball, and almost tore that guys ACL. That is the DEFINITION of a red card and that player should be suspended for more games as well. Why would Miami protest the call. I have never seen players rush to the referee to protest a card until AFTER it was shown. It also looks like Tori Penso was hesitant to pull out the card in the first place. MLS wants their big ticket games like Miami in the East and LAFC in the west to win. It is becoming more and more blatant. The favoritism the refs are showing has to stop. The dicsiplinary committee has to take action against these egregious fouls.

There is no "mostly agree" for that Forsberg foul. Tori Penso got that wrong (which is unfortunate as she was standing directly in front of the foul) and VAR should have called down for a clear error on a missed red card.

I had to watch the offside segment a few times. Well done to the crew.

Everything for messi to win

That has to be a red card for the Miami player. Forsberg is very lucky he didn’t get a season ending injury from that horrendous tackle.

According to IFAB the handball goal should have counted because the player who scored was not the same one who handled the ball. The officials must have decided that he made his body unnaturally bigger, or intentionally handled the ball and disallowed the goal for one of those reasons.

Can we stop picking and choosing. We know MLS wants Messi to win but that’s a RED if you agree that it is endangering our player that’s a red period stop with this. I’m not mad we lost Messi had an amazing game and we got slapped but come on that’s a red

I wish we saw paintsil riding Nouhou’s ankle like a scooter 😐 crazy that got no mention

Should be sent off. Both feet left ground in the tackle. That could be a career ender.

Horrendous tackle, that's a leg breaker

3:36 That’s a penalty! Wiebe is over complicating things! The contact at the legs is what takes him down. Ring hooks his leg into Picault.

So let me get this straight, we see the exact same thing for simulation and it was appropriately carded this time but it was not called against LAFC. Just like how the red wasnt called against Miami. MLS clearly has their favorites and it shows week in and week out.

3:02 You're misreading this. The clause only apples to the player whose hand/arm the ball has touched. That said, this decision is fine, since the arm is making the teammate's body unnaturally bigger anyway.

No mention of Enzo Copetti getting kicked in the head?

Nothing for the offside goal for Orlando I would love to see the trig guy work his magic for that

Not a red? Only if we use MLS's version of law 18: No send offs for LAFC or Miami players.

Crazy you didn’t mention Enzo Copetti getting kicked in the head with no call or review on the field

AustinFc had no chance of 3 points or even one point, this makes this decision for Caps fans even harder. this angle shows contact in the back of the leg before shoulder contact. Penalty

So almost the same exact penalty denied for vancouver but the ref called a penalty for the red bulls?

There was a clear Red card for Ruznak in the seattle vs LA Galaxy game. He didnt even get a yellow card nor it was reviewed. I couldn't believe it. And then, it wasn't even mentioned here. Weibe, you are dropping the ball.

What about the Rapids offside goal

Seriously nothing on Seattle- Galaxy?

You just lost all of the little credibility this instant replay videos had. Messi fan here, but come on dawg 💀

I swear the new labor agreement with PRO has a clause that MLS creators are forbidden to say anything disagreeing with the decisions made during the match.

What Weibe says RSL was offsides against his beloved SKC? Shocker

Wiebe triggering vancouver fans in 3,2,1.....

Hey @mls, you need a compilation of best goalkeeper saves, comp of best defensive plays, and comp of VAR reviews after each matchday!

Incredible that you say the call against Tavares for simulating made sense when you obviously see the defender extend his right arm and push him in his back (5:22) causing him to lose his balance, launching him forward. It’s amazing that you think Tavares has that much body control to react without any delay between the push and the fall. The simulation was a joke call and the yellow was the icing on top. Also no mention of Copetti getting rocked in the head without even a stoppage or review from the ref.

Did you know the initial call on the field in Vancouver was not a handball? Please explain how you know for certain it hit the hand and not the body of the defender. Because the defender whose chest the ball bounced off didn't react like it hit Fafa's hand before. You're saying there is no way there was space between the ball and Fafa's hand in that freeze frame? You can see Fafa's hand behind the defender's back in the next frame like he got it out of the way. The arm doesn't bounce like it was hit. The ball took a deflection a few yards away, even if it grazed Fafa's fingertips as it hit the defender, the play was not impacted. I just don't see how he could take that goal off the board over a maybe. Regarding the other call in VC, a player's shoulders are never parallel with the body when reaching back to shoot. A defender can't tackle from behind just because a player turns their shoulders to shoot the ball. The way everyone is brushing it off, are they even going to use it as a training moment to better the rules? This was demoralizing for players and fans.

It was definitely a red card on aviles but it is what it is we move on. The people saying mls wants Messi to win is hilarious like the bum mls is some hard league to play in or win foh 😂

TIM FORD THE REFEREE!?!?!?!?!?!?!? YOU'RE KIDDING ME

The thing about the No-call in Vancouver is that Fafa sucks. A good player might’ve been able to get that ball and turn for a shot, but he couldn’t.

👍

Remember, Wiebe has to keep some controversy in these videos so that people comment on it and he stays relevant. If everybody agrees with him then there is WAY less clicks and comments and he loses his job doing this. I have no doubt in my mind he knows he deserves a red card for that, but his explanation causes more comments.

Well "buddy", luckily the MLS won't ever have you as a referee... It would be a disaster for football. I can see you never played the game seriously.

This isn’t Azteca, that’s an obvious red. We’re supposed to be a league of rules.

Red card all day.

Chicho shot the ball, but it was an own goal. Just saying he shouldn’t get all credit

Why ref give penalty to red bulls there is no pen the players clear diving shame on ref always against messi and miami

cry harder, Messi also had his leg broken no card keep crying. Also Messi and many more were fouled in the box no call to many criers

I don’t know when MLS started having their referees speaking on a microphone to explain decisions, but it’s dumb and needs to stop. Not everything can be turned into an American football kind of thing. It works in the NFL/NCAA, but is not meant for football. It sounds forced, there’s no single way of saying things, so they often mumble. It’s so bad yet so American!

when I see bad officiating, 9/10 times it’s tori penso she’s SO BAD