Waste 💩 Management / Toilet 🚽 Options for the Off Grid Cabin - EP#19

Подписаться 107 тыс.

Просмотров 144 тыс.

50% 1

#offgridcabin
#offgridtoilet
#offgridseptic
Get Exclusive Access & Live Updates -
Join the LPO6 Community
/ loftispartyofsix
⭐️ About this Episode:
Off grid septic & off grid toilet options are wildly debatable as to what is the best option. What it boils down to is what best suits your needs and budget. We considered an outhouse, a composting toilet and then the traditional flushing toilet with septic system. For us and our large family and the fact that we plan to have it on Airbnb, we wanted a zero maintenance system so we went the modern route and put in a septic system.
Mavic Mini Fly More Combo:
amzn.to/2QVwPz...
NEW WEBSITE:
www.loftispart...
⭐️ If your new Here, HELLO!! We are Loftis Party of Six!! LPO6 for short!!
Dad- Michael
Mom- Laine
Kids from oldest to youngest-
Grady, Layla, Chason & Gabriel
We are a Full-time RV Living family with 4 kids who in 2018 Sold Everything to be a Family who is together all the time!! Homeschooling our kids and going on amazing adventures and seeing incredible places!! We just sold our 1st RV set up which was a truck and 5th wheel (see video of why we switched here: • Why are We SELLING the... ) to get our new RV set up with a Class A and Jeep Wrangler! Now are building an OFF GRID CABIN on 50 acres in the Ozarks of Missouri as a home base between travels.
.................................................................................
Thanks to our “All the Things” Patrons!
⭐️ Peter H.
⭐️ MK Lonestar Handcrafted
⭐️ Mary Kay aka GrammyG
..................................................
🛒 Amazon Shopper?? Like 👍 our Videos??
Use this link 👇
amzn.to/2CUE7LQ
👆 This is our Amazon Affiliate link!
What is an Affiliate link 🤔? It’s a way you can help us continue to create more videos and it’s completely FREE to you! Yep, it does not cost you a dime to use our links and we get a small % of the sale. It’s a win win! We give our time, info, honest opinions, and resources and you buy what you was going to anyway and show us some love ❤️ by using our link! Thank you 😊!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
⭐️ Get caught up on our videos here:
Season 1:
• Season 1 - LPO6 / weROAM
Season 2:
• Season 2
Season 3:
• Season 3 - New RV
.......................................................................
➕ Helpful LPO6 Partners for RVers 👇
Roadmaster Nighthawk Towbar -
www.roadmasterinc.com/products/towbars/nighthawk.html
amzn.to/2ZCz3Kt
Harvest Hosts 15% off - harvesthosts.re...
Beddys Bedding: Get 20% OFF
www.beddys.com/...
🤝 Connect with us👇:
www.loftispart...
/ loftispartyofsix
/ loftispartyofsix
Music credit 🎶
Soundstripe
Need Vlog Music? Join here 👇
soundstripe.com?fpr=michael24
*Loftis Party of Six is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Опубликовано:

24 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 180

@BenNstyle 4 года назад

When it comes to number 2, I think you made the number 1 best choice for your future guest needs. You could still build an outhouse (for aesthetic looks only) just to scare the number 2 out of your guest when they arrive! 😂

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

😆 best comment of the day!!

@pearlsofwisdom7894 4 года назад

I was gonna say the same thing 🤣 that would be hilarious

@JillRH 4 года назад

Yes build an outhouse also. Gotta have an outhouse.

@voidisyinyangvoidisyinyang885 3 года назад

@@LoftisPartyofSix Wow - I'm surprised you're not required to have an inspection. Here if you want a "permanent structure" building permit then there first has to be a waste treatment inspection permit required. And so yeah even if someone wants a composting toilet then they still need septic for the gray water system. We have over ten thousands lakes though.

@seraphx26 2 года назад

You made the right choice in my opinion, if you are putting the place up for rent very few guests are going to want their week in the country interrupted by having to dump composting toilets.

@KILO-uv2wi 4 года назад

I completely agree with your choice of a conventional toilet for the purpose that you need. I live in my RV full time and have a composting toilet. While it’s great for two people I think any more than that the maintenance would be too much, as with emptying also comes cleaning. It’s quite the chore. Loving the cabin thus far!

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thank you 😊

@reedconniebarfield 4 года назад

I like the “regular” toilet with the septic. I think it will offer y’all peace of mind as well when you’re away.

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@riwoof 4 года назад

I think I would consider adding an outhouse as well. Besides the "charm" factor, it also would alleviate any long lines for the john.

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thank you

@henry64100 4 года назад

Jerry did a wonderful job building this cabin. He’s a genius! Keep him safe.

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Will do 👍

@MustardSeedAdventures 4 года назад

Its been awesome watching this process you guys. Me and Sarah have really enjoyed it! The cabin looks amazing so far. Cant wait to see more!

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks guys!! 😊

@rustibarnett4765 4 года назад

You made the perfect choice!!! We are on septic and have never had a problem.

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Awesome 😎 thanks

@braveheartrv2946 2 года назад

Saw the band-aid and though. Awe. Someone got a boo boo. Jere seems like such a sweetheart.

@wessebaggers 4 года назад

For me i think you did the right thing when I remodeled my two bathrooms i choose just like you !

@rmom33 4 года назад

I totally agree about you having an outhouse! Great idea for looks after all Little House on The Prairie had one.

@ccrews0612 4 года назад

the difference between a 100 and 200 dollar toilet is the amount of clogs. The more expensive toilet will have a polished or glazed trap. The other difference is they also come in seat heights coming in at 18.8"

@sherbournesubwaymess Год назад

Option#4 - Place a large metal tub underneath an outhouse, when it's full: Fill it with gas, set it on fire and with a pole...slowly stir. It'll keep the kids busy.

@fabiansandoval6132 Год назад

What???? Can you please explain more??? I have a cabin with an incinorater toilet and it sucks. I have an outhouse but its completely full, have never used it so your idea sounds interesting. Please elaborate if you have time.

@rmom33 4 года назад

I think you guys made a great choice! I dont think you will have to worry about it at all. I am so happy for you guys. My husband Danny and I are interested in renting your cabin one day. We have a grandson in Fredericktown, MO and we want to visit with him at your cabin when it is available. Can you give us an idea of what you are thinking about as far as price? We are also retiring next July and cant wait to hit the road RVing full time. Maybe we will meet you guys on the road. I'm sure you are ready to continue your adventures. God Bless you guys! You are the sweetest family.

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thank you guys!! The price will be about $125-150 per night. Would love to have y’all visit!!

@Bobm-kz5gp 4 года назад

You can get a good bidet that fits under your toilet seat, no electric required, better job at cleaning your bottom and only a few sheets of tp to dry a bit. Much less tp used so your septic lasts longer. Check them out at Amazon. Less than $100.

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@CCRider5312 4 года назад

I don’t know the difference between a $100 Toilet and a $300 Toilet.....Without missing a beat Jerry says $200 ! Lol 😂 Love your sense of humor Jerry. 🤣 Man you gonna have a beautiful cabin when your done with it. I just subbed to this channel and I already love the projects! 😁👍

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@trombo4697 4 года назад

I think you made the right choice

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@jenniferknight1511 4 года назад

We have a well, a septic system, and regular old power!

@rush4war380 2 года назад

living out in the bush and potentially covered in mud and dirt or other in hunting season, its nice to have an entrance from outside or at least be close to an outside door. just think about all them days ahead with kids playing in the animal pens and falling into the slop. lol..

@robertmoder1593 4 года назад

Good choice 4 years off grid with a sun mar toilet a pain in a butt I would use sawdust and a bucket before I would go back to that nice that Missouri has lighter restrictions than Wisconsin but place is sold and hopefully September full time RVing God bless hope to see you on the road

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

An expensive pain too!! I looked at those and they are just as expensive as what it cost for our septic system.

@milonetzler67 4 года назад

You made the right decision.

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@darlenefelts1131 3 года назад

An old fashioned outhouse would still be a great idea to have because if it's built right there is no smell or bacteria to worry about. Plus you would be surprised at how many people would appreciate it just for an added bonus.

@Marc-uw4lw 3 года назад

I think the difference between the toilets regarding price is simply quality. If the lid breaks or comes loose or the flush get stuck, that's false economy. I'd want hard-wearing durable goods in a S-T rental property. Just food for thought. Good video

@Bart-dg6qv Год назад

Thanks for this. I was looking for video with different options consideration.

@teekay1785 4 года назад

The only GOOD choice you made. Can you imagine guests going to the outhouse in subfreezing temps at night !!! Good way to fall an het injured too! The smell etc!! Put in an OUTHOUSE too and see if anyone actually uses it more than once.

@patmason7276 2 года назад

Tank doesn't matter your drain field is where your problem will be especially around Lake and oceans with high water table.

@deniselockhart2882 Год назад

Absolutely the right choice. I'm a retired nurse, there is nothing sanitary about an outhouse. I don't have a high opinion of composting toilets, sanitary?? I've watched many videos about off grid living/cabins and I'll never understand those that choose unsanitary conditions.

@laurawgarts 4 года назад

Good call - very good choice for your family and guests! The place is looking great, ya'll!

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@braveheartrv2946 2 года назад

I saw this video that I'm looking for where you turn your poop into heat.

@Miguel195211 4 года назад

Great choice on a septic. The others are too nasty. I would of gone with 1000 instead of 500.

@ruthaspen2076 4 года назад

I had friends in NH that had a compost toilet that emptied into a special basement area which could be shoveled out periodically.

@hartleyemerald674 4 года назад

Great ideas! I would add a larger septic tank with a really good macerating toilet that way you are sure that the waist is truly getting liquefied before it goes back into the earth, you guys are great, keep up the good work and thank you for all these wonderful videos they are helping me with my projects

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@vanderumd11 2 года назад

It's the water that goes into the ground. Solids sit and break down in the tank.

@freedompanda9438 2 года назад

I’m curious how many of the people saying “good choice” have owned a good composting toilet. I keep reading clues that tell me most haven’t lol.

@markcrothers3707 4 года назад

So there is absolutely no chance your septic system will contaminate your spring? Do you plan on using a regular septic service company to come pump out your tank and how often do you think you will have to do that?

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

We will have it tested but we believe the soil is perfect for proper drainage that won’t affect the spring

@victoriakeith2145 4 года назад

I think you made a amazing choice.. everything is looking so good 😊. I can’t wait to see it when it’s complete! God bless you guys 🤗

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thank you 😊

@hayleytuluauau3526 4 года назад

This is the best choice - it’s hygienic for the kids and the family - easy to clean and the kids are safe using the toilet within the cabin when weather is not good - won’t leave odours. Love the option you chose the cabin is looking amazing can’t wait to see how your lovely wife will decorate and a cabin tour well done loftis family 🙏🏽

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thank you

@timandnatd 3 года назад

Incinerator toilet. If water is limited and you have plenty of power. It all depends on your specific scenario!

@bellisimo1 2 года назад

You did good. Septic is the way to go for worry free waste disposal. Like, you, I can't see paying a fortune for a toilet. That money can be utilized better somewhere else.

@sheilabundren2037 4 года назад

My mom has a septic. I think you made a wise decision.

@mikekenney8362 Год назад

Well done. Lots of ideas

@cynthiasnedeker2981 4 года назад

I agree. Best choice made

@allenduncan8046 3 года назад

Must tell you I think you made a wonderful choice

@alexandracuesta8952 4 года назад

Perfect choice!! Excellent....congrats....I also have a septic tank system...and with your video, I learned more...thanks!!!😊

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thank you 😊

@randymcphink3924 10 месяцев назад

Top flush vs handle. Handle is full flush every time. Top flush is half or full flush.

@rush4war380 2 года назад

sry... #1 is water, #2 is heat, #3 is refrigeration, #4 is power, #5 is waist... ongoing is Food and Community... im off grid for 4 years. on my own. little girls need more care lol butt... even if i could manage an outhouse, it would have a full functioning toilet. only prob 4 mee is i live in canada and it gets cold. so heating would be for certain. and if that is needed then just build it into the house ;) although.. i may consider 1 for summer, then flush it for winter. is that top flush a prob for ur children?

@jadecraig9830 4 года назад

Fully right choice !

@angelncarroll1241 3 года назад

I have to have a regular toilet, I’ve had a outhouse and hated it and composting ones gross me out too much

@jamiehoward3151 4 года назад

I "bleed like a stuck hog" too😀 I have hemophilia, so I get it! Love how the cabin looks😎 I think you made the right choice with the toilet😁

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@calebparker8236 2 года назад

Every grown man needs a roll of toilet paper in their truck lol

@Most_Amazin 2 года назад

Are you planning to build more homes on the property? Maybe a clubhouse, or rec center. Fun, and clubbing don't have to be in home. Guest don't have to be quiet while there enjoying there time.. Almost like a small village. I would build that, this is my goal for my own 80 acres. (Wished In to existence) you did everything right.

@samanthahanson18 4 года назад

you made a great choice! that's a Beautiful cabin!!!

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thank you 😊

@conroysmith4187 4 года назад

Good choice

@RVBadlands2015 3 года назад

Septic with a regular toilet we put in a 1000 gallon tank and there are only two of us. Where building a two bedroom small house.

@henry64100 4 года назад

Good choice on septic and toilet

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@chris5459 5 месяцев назад

How often do you have to empty the septic? and what is that process like? there are companies that pump it out or you do it yourself somehow? Thank you

@lindabevier-vian7101 4 года назад

I think you made the right choice 😃 I would have chose the same,..An ADA aproved toilet has an 18 inches seat hight....

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@Joseph_Gibson 4 года назад

So does the septic tank have to be emptied out periodically, or is there some type of grinder/aeration system?

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

If it’s over used and the solids don’t have time to break down then yes it would need to be pumped out periodically. But if it works properly then as solids turn into liquids it will work it’s way into the lateral lines into the ground.

@osombrand8774 3 месяца назад

How often you are having a pump out septic service coming to take the waste out of the tank?

@bradh6185 Год назад

The video starts at 5:58.

@lauriec3354 Год назад

So, what was the cost after all? I conquer, sounds like a great choice.

@lenalove8138 8 месяцев назад

(8:36) The difference between a $100 and a $300 toilet is that you saved $200, that's all

@susancampbell515 4 года назад

I think it was a smart choice!

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@desertdetector4476 Год назад

We are trying to make this decision right now…was looking at composting toilets which are $1,000 plus. Was going this route more expensive?

@erikdowney461 Год назад

Where did the southern accent come from all of a sudden. “The south will rise again!!”

@devonjansenvanniewenhuizen5856 2 года назад

I don't understand why more people dont make use of the waste. So heres my idea, install a system that will capture and sperate the waste IE septic and soak away system, but instead of just wasting all that viable natural gas why not capture it into either an inflatable bladder or weighted /spring tensioned capture tank of sorts. That way in time you will have an unending supply og natural methane gas, obviously the system will require some design and tuning but i think i have after about 4 years of enquiry got a solid concept.

@mushroomking8304 Год назад

What are the logistics of emptying the sceptic tank on an off-grid cabin? Do you do that yourself or have to have someone come it?

@jackman6256 4 года назад

Bulid outhouse over a tank that u have bulided put lines going out it an let nature handel it AFTER you put one in house

@ThomasLeonard454 2 года назад

Indoor bathroom and flush toilet, with shower.

@andyteohockguan7243 4 года назад

Awesome video and stay safe, God bless

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@xoawolf 3 года назад

This might be a dum question to ask, but I don't know enough in this field. So my question is, could you have a traditional style toilet (aka the one installed here), and have it connect/work with a rainwater collection system?

@haleytownsley80 3 года назад

My husband and I are also about to go off grid and are wondering the same thing. Does anyone have any info on this specifically? We are needing as much info as possible, so if anyone can guide us in the right direction we’d be enormously thankful! ❤️

@f1s2hg3 2 года назад

Thanks 🙏 Great 👍

@donwat91 4 года назад

I know its been awhile since you posted this but I agree with your decision. It's one thing if it's just for you and your family. But you're not asking your children for a vote who would have to help in emptying a bucket . But you're asking your guest to empty a bucket. I feel it would turn guest away. You did the right thing. It will pay for itself in the amount if guest you have staying there. I've not had a chance to see your videos in some time due to my health , no COVID-19 here. I have neck , back and leg issues that requires me to have an implanted pain pump. Its to long to talk about and bore you. I have some catching up to do. Your cabin looks great.

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thank you and hope you get to feeling better soon!!

@terrydonaldson1841 4 года назад

Can’t wait to rent it

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Awesome thanks

@TandZAptLife 4 года назад

Hi guys! No more RVing? That's a beautiful Loft home you have.

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Yes we still live in the RV and will travel as soon as the cabin is finished which will be soon. Thanks 😊

@TandZAptLife 4 года назад

@@LoftisPartyofSix Awesome.

@ThomasLeonard454 2 года назад

Dual flush don't flush that well but I bet you now know this. More money means it will flush bigger jobs easier.

@michelledouglas6538 4 года назад

Good choice!!!!!

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@thomaslevey5824 3 года назад

You don’t explain anything about the septic lines, depth of trenching, size of line, distance from house, is there a tank, angle /level of line, how much line, etc, etc

@patriciacharrier3620 4 года назад

You could put up a building that looks like an out house for show but it would realy be a shed or stowage.

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Good idea thanks

@michaelward2869 9 месяцев назад

Yeah bro thats sounds good cause exatlaly as you say good choice ❤hope its all going well guys Do you still speak to Joe he's cool to few of you guys you know what your talking bout ❤❤

@drako1888 4 месяца назад

how do you empty the tank? how often? what the hell man

@cabinlifeatedensprings1710 4 года назад

We use solar. Love your cabin! We have springs on our property. We are pretty close to the river. It’s about half a mile from our driveway to the boat dock. Everyone said why not buy right on the water. But we were looking for a deal. We needed cheap and someone to work with us. Because we were still living in the city in the big suburban home. Right now we compost. We have been really happy with that. Not sure if we will ever have a septic tank on our property. Currently we live in a small country town in a small country house. And here we have a septic. We do plan on keeping both homes. We would prefer to be full time out by the river and we see ourselves spending much more time there. But the country house is in a little town about an hour outside a large city with hospitals and doctors. Our parents and extended family are closer to the city. We really don’t see it as being much of an expense. It’s better than having to stay at a hotel or move in with family if something happened and we need to be near the hospitals. After 2019 we decision was confirmed. Because we lost 5 family members. It was the worst year we thought. And I’m disabled. For comfort and peace of mind the country house makes sense. But we love our cabin. I think you made the right decision for you. Because you have a big family. It’s just the two of us now. And family will survive, lol. If you could have seen the look on our daughter s face when we told her to use the composting toilet. Priceless😳. Leslye

@fedup2533 3 года назад

Myself and 2 other people I know have bought those cheap dual flush toilets and all 3 of us replaced them within a few years. They are complete garbage.

@saadshahzad7668 3 года назад

What is your water source for this cabin?

@DannyCreech 4 года назад

If you have a water source and plenty of good soil for a septic system, why would anyone want a disgusting composting tolet or outhouse? Both of those require more work, stink, and are just a pain to use. You always have to explain to friends how to use them before they go to the bathroom.

@greasydave4754 3 года назад

nice intro

@kevineastburn4131 2 года назад

What county and state?

@LJFullHouse 4 года назад

Sawdust toilet, for sure.

@roydavis2242 4 года назад

Where we live in Ohio we had some of the most ridiculous County EPA guidelines in the state. It got so bad that the realtor association filed a lawsuit. The State EPA stepped in and got rid of the idiots and settled out of court. In Ohio no matter what the size of your property is the requirements are basically the same. The exceptions are for the Amish and for commercial use. A bathtub needs to be part of that system.

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Yeah I’ve had lots of people asking because seems like a lot of areas around the country are super strict. Glad our area is not.

@featheredcoyote5477 4 года назад

Yep, Amish here in Indiana have preferential treatment as well and it pisses me off. Using the restroom has nothing to do with God nor religion. I was told by my local building dept that I would need to pull permits and have a septic system on my hunting cabin because it exceeds 200 sq ft. But my Amish neighbors have a 4000sq ft home and don't have to have a septic system because of religion. Such bullshit. A basic system is over 20k here in Indiana and must be approved by health dept. Needless to say, I use 5 gallon bucket bathroom since it's just me

@SatoshiZulu 3 года назад

@@featheredcoyote5477 lol don't blame you Coyote, do you use your waste to water and fertilize your garden beds and plants...or just dig a hole and dump? Any issues with smell or critters, etc?

@featheredcoyote5477 3 года назад

@@SatoshiZulu absolutely zero smell and zero issues with critters. Use sawdust to cover after every use until bucket gets full. Put a lid on it and set out in the sun for at least 6 months. After 6 month's, use a composting bin layered with grass clippings and straw. Doug and Stacey have great video's on RU-vid explaining this method. You should check them out. They've been using this format for years in Missouri while living off grid.

@SatoshiZulu 3 года назад

@@featheredcoyote5477 Awesome and thanks for the info. I'll definitely follow up with Doug and Stacey. Thanks for sharing. Stay Safe! 🤜🤛🇺🇸

@mattvollmar7713 4 года назад

Please put me on the list for air bnb your cabin. Great job so far!

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Awesome!! Would love to host y’all

@REB65 4 года назад

👍 God bless y’all ✌️

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Thanks 😊

@jenniferknight1511 4 года назад

Head wounds always bleed a lot!

@User-yv3un 4 года назад

Hi guys! I’m early!

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Hi 👋!! Thanks

@User-yv3un 4 года назад

Oh my gosh! You replied! 😱 I love you guys. Have fun building your cabin 💗

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

We always reply!! ❤️

@User-yv3un 4 года назад

Thank you guys so much this made my day!❤️

@GeorgiaWoodsHomesteading 2 года назад

If you don't mind me asking, what county and state do you live in? We are in Crawford County, Georgia....I am wanting to do an off grid cabin for my mom on our 70 acres.

@LoftisPartyofSix 2 года назад

Missouri

@401threed7 2 года назад

What county/ state is this?

@DJ_Bohn 4 года назад

What camera do you use? Do you talk about your camera gear somewhere? Thank you!

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Canon M50

@DJ_Bohn 4 года назад

@@LoftisPartyofSix thanks!! And what lens? and microphone?

@LoftisPartyofSix 4 года назад

Normal lens that it came with and Rode mic

@tat255987 3 года назад

If its brown flush it down if its yellow let it mellow

@jordanknoll2864 2 года назад

$$$ it comes down to money.

@khandam7709 2 года назад

split level composting toilet would of worked fine. they only need emptied few times a year. you deffinetely want to have a grey water diversion system so your shower and washing water does not go into a tiny 500 gallon septic tank. If that clogs while guests are there, it will only last a day or two before it backs up and makes a mess. with a grey water diversion system a 500 gallon tank can last 2x longer and works better because the bacteria work better when more concentrated. but in the end people cant' deal wtih thier own shit so a water based toilet will get you more rentals.