Тёмный

We are all made of stardust | George Coyne | TEDxYYC 

TEDx Talks
Подписаться 41 млн
Просмотров 59 тыс.
50% 1

This talk was given at a local TEDx event, produced independently of the TED Conferences. Did God create the universe? After working through the science of stars and the origin of the universe this is the question that astrophysicist Father George Coyne poses. Merging the hard science of element creation with the religious question, did a divine creator start it all; Father George examines the relation between the two.
Mathematician, philosopher, astronomist, Catholic priest and former director of the Vatican Observatory, Father George V. Coyne is a fascinating real-life representation of the paradoxical battle between science and religion.
About TEDx, x = independently organized event In the spirit of ideas worth spreading, TEDx is a program of local, self-organized events that bring people together to share a TED-like experience. At a TEDx event, TEDTalks video and live speakers combine to spark deep discussion and connection in a small group. These local, self-organized events are branded TEDx, where x = independently organized TED event. The TED Conference provides general guidance for the TEDx program, but individual TEDx events are self-organized.* (*Subject to certain rules and regulations)

Опубликовано:

 

20 авг 2014

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 156   
@oshibo
@oshibo 7 лет назад
"We are the universe thinking about the universe." I'm tripping out yoooooooooooo
@ioanlightoller4934
@ioanlightoller4934 4 года назад
That is trippy, isn't it?
@cameronbajt4
@cameronbajt4 9 лет назад
I was privileged enough to attend this TEDx event and George Coyne was by far the best presenter of the group. To answer George's question... I think that it is extremely rare to find a religious individual whom are willing to questioning their holy books... and in all honesty is so refreshing to hear him say "I don't know". The problem with religion and science is that science does not claim to have infinite knowledge or power, it must be learned and proven on its own. The contrary is religious believers are taught to never question the word of god, and to just accept it as absolute power or knowledge, which takes away from the learning process of finding scientific truth. In my humble opinion, not knowing is a beautiful thing and we should strive for as much scientific understanding as possible. This is why I choose to reject organized religion based on ancient texts of an unquestionable deity, and focus on having a stronger physical understanding of our universe.
@joedellaselva1251
@joedellaselva1251 5 лет назад
Is it not extremely rare to find a scientist who is willing to question his science books replete with experiments and analyses which could be wrong?
@tonedumbharry
@tonedumbharry 4 года назад
@@joedellaselva1251 I think it happens more than we know. It seems the Catholic Church is not peopled, totally, with fools and the delusioned. There are many who would agree with George. He is their spokesperson. I suspect it is the realisation of this that persuades many prominent atheists to return to the church eventually.
@johnnotrealname8168
@johnnotrealname8168 4 года назад
@@tonedumbharry The Catholic Church is firstly not incompatible with Science. In any case questioning itself is not a sin so yeah.
@LASLAY13
@LASLAY13 4 года назад
John Not Real Name How is it incompatible/compatible? Would you please expound on that?
@johnnotrealname8168
@johnnotrealname8168 4 года назад
@@LASLAY13 There is no claim at least Philosophically that would challenge the Catholic Faith. Evolution for example.
@javiersds8081
@javiersds8081 7 лет назад
I came across Father Coyne through a Bill Maher interview and then I watched an interview he had with Richard Dawkins. I highly recommend everybody here to watch both of them (the latter is about 1 hour long, but so entertaining that you won't notice). This man is certainly an intelligent person and is worth listening to him.
@SisypheanSeas13
@SisypheanSeas13 5 лет назад
Indeed
@alexliu9600
@alexliu9600 2 года назад
Hi Javier, could you share us with the link to that interview?
@genghisthegreat2034
@genghisthegreat2034 9 месяцев назад
I agree the Dawkins/Coyne exchange was remarkable, for its mutual respect, for the way they listened to one another, and for the fact both were intelligent, well-informed people. Enjoy it.
@MinecraftPlaniac24
@MinecraftPlaniac24 3 года назад
I always learn so much whenever I listen to Dr. Coyne. He will truly be missed.
@markfrost2579
@markfrost2579 7 лет назад
The first preacher to make any sense. Always though religious scientists were out to disprove science, or contradict it. Very refreshing.
@annamichelle1416
@annamichelle1416 9 лет назад
This is absolutely beautiful and informative, it makes me feel so good to know we are made from star dust. ❤️🌏
@musicisbrilliant
@musicisbrilliant 4 года назад
This guy is actually very *VERY* deep!!! This is gold!
@randyg.7940
@randyg.7940 2 года назад
Thats what she said.
@FUCKINMETALROCKS
@FUCKINMETALROCKS 9 лет назад
We were made in the image of God, god meaning nature which includes everything organic, the stars and the galaxies. Everything is a copy of a copy, an imperfection reflection of the pure alpha perfection.
@vonteflon
@vonteflon 9 лет назад
Just discovered this guy via a Bill Maher interview - need to see more of him. Very refreshing to hear a religious person utter the phrase "I don't know".
@redman958
@redman958 9 лет назад
vonteflon I would recommend his interview with Richard Dawkins as well.
@javierlgarcia
@javierlgarcia 7 лет назад
Hey vonteflon, Try Bishop Robert Barron. Peace!
@joedellaselva1251
@joedellaselva1251 5 лет назад
He did not know as a physicist but said that he was sure God created the Universe from his faith background.
@arnowisp6244
@arnowisp6244 3 года назад
And now so-called atheist are having trouble saying "I don't know" as they've become too prideful to admit current limitations of science.
@arnowisp6244
@arnowisp6244 3 года назад
@@joedellaselva1251 And I don't see anything wrong from that. As a Physicist he said he didn't know. He knows God made the universe as a man of faith but as a Physicist there is a lot he doesn't know. And that is what makes him admirable.
@KJC63
@KJC63 8 лет назад
As +Chris Canning said below, there's a wonderful talk between Father Coyne and Richard Dawkins (for the best quality - watch the series that's in "parts" - parts 1-7 - there's no "ads"). Its about the belief in evolution with regard to the Catholic Church. The series is very, very interesting, how as a scientitist and priest he states "his" understanding of evolution and "his" belief in god. Wonderful conversation, should be required viewing (at least) by all Catholics.
@Jacob_is_Live
@Jacob_is_Live 7 лет назад
im an athiest but love the way this guy was explaining his thoughts and image of the whole god and the universe
@georgeroberts442
@georgeroberts442 4 года назад
There are getting to be more and more good scientific reasons to believe in a Creator, reasons arising out of cosmology, biology, and physics. So, it's not as if science is silent on the subject, or that religious belief and science never cross paths. Like Fr. Coyne, I'm a believer in both science and religion, and I find the ongoing contest (if I may use that word) between them fascinating. Fortunately, there are open minded people on both sides of the controversy. I'm expecting that science will someday prove all or part of the religious view to be correct, and then we'll see a general shift in attitudes. But, of course, as always there will remain skeptics on both sides holding extremist views. That's life!
@annn2780
@annn2780 3 года назад
do you think the genesis creation story literally happened?
@cloroxbleach3809
@cloroxbleach3809 2 года назад
@@annn2780 no but I don't believe in evolution either.
@nookymonster1
@nookymonster1 Год назад
He could have kept on going on the science route, but he is conditioned to still bring up a God. No reason to go there at all. Nature is all there is. Why isn't that enough?
@genghisthegreat2034
@genghisthegreat2034 9 месяцев назад
​@@nookymonster1the reason it's not enough is that the very fact that it's a priest, and former Vatican Astronomer that's giving the TED talk, places the question so squarely central, he couldn't be expected to ignore it, just as we can't in an open discussion.
@ryansmith-vy2ec
@ryansmith-vy2ec 4 года назад
Father coyn. Will be missed, he helped bridge the gap between science and religion.
@stage1
@stage1 4 года назад
Rip George Coyne
@darkmoon2503
@darkmoon2503 4 года назад
Found out about him a week before his death. Since then, I've looked more into his approach to science and religion, and I've greatly appreciated his thoughts. Wish I could have known about him sooner.
@Roy__Batty
@Roy__Batty Год назад
@@darkmoon2503I corresponded with him after seeing his interview with Dawkins and then had the pleasure of having lunch with him in an upstate New York. He was a remarkable, erudite man
@turhanoniz3523
@turhanoniz3523 5 месяцев назад
Excellent Loveded ❤ Thank you.
@randalldickson8841
@randalldickson8841 4 года назад
Fascinating and informative. Thank you
@monaoconnell5650
@monaoconnell5650 Год назад
I remember when Carl Sagan first told us about the stardust. It made me think it was a miracle. However, I agree scientists should not exclude God or insert God when talking about science. If they do, they aren't doing science. No, I don't understand whey there is a conflict between science and spiritual exploration. I would like to see scientists and theologians work together.
@sabeshbala1933
@sabeshbala1933 2 года назад
He gives a better explanation of how this dot(earth) was formed and developed by chance , necessity or God.
@clover8051
@clover8051 5 лет назад
You are wonderful!! Spot on!! Seriously inspirational.. Thanks to you, I proved to my friend that we are all made of stardust :) (he already knew, but still)
@ahubamicprinciples8641
@ahubamicprinciples8641 5 лет назад
Clover Is Tennessee made of stardust?
@clover8051
@clover8051 5 лет назад
yup ^.^
@slick-nik1
@slick-nik1 4 года назад
AWESOME JOB !! VERY VERY INTERESTING
@ridor9th
@ridor9th 4 года назад
I like this father dude.
@davidlee3703
@davidlee3703 6 лет назад
Deep! Great vid
@tommuench4860
@tommuench4860 9 лет назад
Brilliant !
@thelastgeneration5751
@thelastgeneration5751 3 года назад
What are the implications of the universe being within us? Probably this will be where the next paradigm we are pioneering will develop. We will also discover how many of our desires, thoughts and intentions influence the phenomena of nature that surround us. By changing the same elements of will that are in us, namely the molecules that make up our essence, we change not only our perception of reality, but also what is dangling to this world. And the method for changing our inner self (which also came from that moment of creation) is the wisdom of kabbalah.
@paullrdubois
@paullrdubois 4 года назад
Great man
@amrhazem2096
@amrhazem2096 2 года назад
Amazing 👏🏻
@marcobephage1396
@marcobephage1396 3 года назад
Awesome 👍👍
@thehunt098
@thehunt098 9 лет назад
Biblical literalism. That's your answer. Non-Literalist Christians in America have no problems accepting science and their religion. I would like to add, because the universe is imperfect and in my faith god is perfect, I can only surmise imperfection is perfection.
@bluegtturbo
@bluegtturbo 3 года назад
As a sort of half believer, I have to say I don't see what would be so bad about no afterlife...Do we really want to be stuck with acquaintances and family members forever that didn't even want to be near in this life?
@roselotusmystic
@roselotusmystic Год назад
“Science without religion is lame, religion without science is blind.” - Uncle Albert
@scottdellrobinson
@scottdellrobinson 2 года назад
Chance. But the Creator is EVERYTHING
@roselotusmystic
@roselotusmystic Год назад
ChanceNecessity ~ BOTH the chance of Necessity AND the necessity of Chance TransDual . . . ParaDox 🙏
@MonikaBoriovaVegan
@MonikaBoriovaVegan 7 лет назад
whatever u say we are temporary and will fade away. free to share . free to listen. for the hater comments.
@dragonbale1387
@dragonbale1387 7 лет назад
Everything came from the same thing. Even if it's from billions of years ago.
@a.j.abdulmomen5868
@a.j.abdulmomen5868 2 года назад
Oh my dear scientist I am in needed stardust and our body & soul in written but I cant able to find out this artistic in the Google.But why? Let me help to get it in written for my easy knowledge.
@Hephaistos51413
@Hephaistos51413 9 лет назад
woodstock-joni mitchell
@RS-io6vm
@RS-io6vm 5 лет назад
yup true story
@LucyFre
@LucyFre 2 года назад
We know that we know nothing and that is why is no point to ask because we will never know ultimate objective truth as it probably dont exist...Anything else is only opinion theory and hipothesis.Hopeing in reason and ability of our minds to read and discover " objective truth and real nature of things " is pathetic" .We can find a little bite how things are made ( in frame of science )but never find " why " and either religion science philosophy want be able to answear it. We think automatically that behind everything must be certain " cause". May be there is no cause
@michal88gno
@michal88gno Год назад
You have to see a talk between George Coyne and Richard Dawkins.
@drcrow5767
@drcrow5767 6 лет назад
I’m a star
@thegreath.sapiensapien6907
@thegreath.sapiensapien6907 4 года назад
yes you are. we all
@HardKore5250
@HardKore5250 7 лет назад
It happened in other universes
@leewainwright3526
@leewainwright3526 Год назад
Nobody had to necessitate it there doesn't have to be a reason all the time
@richardwilliamson1639
@richardwilliamson1639 3 года назад
The religious-scientific conflict is a conflict between authority and curiosity.
@robbiehernandez8019
@robbiehernandez8019 5 лет назад
So when I die I’m just gonna be dust? Cool!
@arnowisp6244
@arnowisp6244 3 года назад
Your body at least.
@nctodd41
@nctodd41 4 года назад
does anyone see an outline of a face with eyes and other facial features at the 5:20 mark?
@oingpla
@oingpla 4 года назад
persian cat
@maymahdi9052
@maymahdi9052 3 года назад
Can you explain for me why Muslims said we are made from clay?
@thatguy-tm3go
@thatguy-tm3go 6 лет назад
We call certain people "stars" the rest of us are dust
@misssueis55
@misssueis55 9 лет назад
What is actually happening at this point is science has made so many discoveries that religion can no longer deny..There was a time when religion and science were at total odds with each other..Seems to me science is winning the battle and it's about time..
@Yankees94
@Yankees94 9 лет назад
You are correct that science is winning the battle of how natural events happen through natural causes. God is not an answer to those questions because he isn't an item within the natural universe, but rather The Creator God in which all contingent things have their being.
@matotuncotutata
@matotuncotutata 9 лет назад
what if I told you religious people who are intelligent enough understand science and religion are not competing simply because they understand they have the intelligence to understand how things actually work?
@styot
@styot 8 лет назад
David Viscuso If we can't use science what mechanism do we have to discover anything about god? Or even come to the conclusion that there is such a thing?
@Yankees94
@Yankees94 8 лет назад
+styot Philosophy (natural theology) and revelation. Knowledge is not reduced to only scientific knowledge. You yourself who advocates 'scientism", are actually advocating a philosophical argument.
@styot
@styot 8 лет назад
David Viscuso It's true that science has it's roots in philosophy but it's kinda doing it's own thing also, for example advocating a philosophical argument isn't going to get you very far in science where empirical evidence is required. Science has a proven track record for improving our knowledge which is why it's valued so highly, philosophy seems a lot more speculative and doesn't have the mechanisms for testing it's conclusions and falsification, which is why science is generally very good at building consensus and in philosophy pretty much anything goes and there is widespread disagreement on pretty much everything between philosophers. Revelation as a mechanism for acquiring knowledge seems completely hopeless as there are so many contradictory revelations out there, how do you distinguish the good from the bad? It's even worse then philosophy for having a way to test conclusions and falsify the bad ones. Maybe ironically for your argument it often is science that dose falsify religious "revelations".
@HardKore5250
@HardKore5250 7 лет назад
Chance
@mikeharvey2629
@mikeharvey2629 5 лет назад
No to be rude, but I 've seen Coyne say these almost exact words on three separate videos.
@Howtomake12261
@Howtomake12261 9 лет назад
hi
@nickvlachos2698
@nickvlachos2698 7 месяцев назад
The more scientists try to disprove the existence of god, the more they prove the existence of one...
@joecheffo5942
@joecheffo5942 2 дня назад
Prove it to who?
@leakyTF2
@leakyTF2 6 лет назад
uncle george
@stuartyaxley6689
@stuartyaxley6689 4 года назад
Beautifully explained science followed by pure blind faith
@johnnotrealname8168
@johnnotrealname8168 4 года назад
Ha Ha Ha!
@zohryakanowah3324
@zohryakanowah3324 5 лет назад
I dont know abt stardust....i just know we are spiritual being into human.thats it.
@ShaReVVcanalopeTuv
@ShaReVVcanalopeTuv 9 лет назад
We maybe made from stardust but that star dust has been pretty damn busy for billions of years to actually bring about the lifeforms that we see today. i disagree that were born of stardust as he puts it. I think the things that shaped that stardust into us is much more important what about the weather systems, THE CYCLE OF THE SEASONS the struggle of surviving 4.5 billion winters that pushed life to survive it or die or the fact that we and every species plant and animal are common descendants of an ancient single celled organism (the seed of life) theres great beauty in imagining the course of life and the events and cycles that shape us into what we have become. I THINK RATHER THAN USING ''WE ARE BORN OF STARDUST'' AS SOME KIND OF SLOGAN WE SHOULD SAY WE ARE BORN OF THE CYCLES AND PATTERNS OF OUR PLANET WITHIN OUR SOLAR SYSTEM AND prehaps the complex dynamics of diverse species existing and coexisting with each other. But scientists seem to leave all the beauty and the fundumental views of our reality to one side
@roselotusmystic
@roselotusmystic Год назад
Creator OR Creation is one of the most important 'Dualities' to TransClude (BOTH Transcend AND Include) for a 'PanEnTheist' . . . 'G*D' . . . is CoArising TransDual . . . Creatoration 🙏 TheDeepMysteryOf TheAllThatIs(Not) 🙏
@rainnedevlin6516
@rainnedevlin6516 4 года назад
Did God create us or did man create God. Man did.
@randomkiliinterviews9453
@randomkiliinterviews9453 2 года назад
Did he belive in an afterlife?
@mohamedalghazali965
@mohamedalghazali965 6 лет назад
Is it in the Quran
@Rockysbeats
@Rockysbeats 9 лет назад
not god, but gods created our universe and the world we inhabit. a highly advanced race of beings that are still watching and analising the progression of their work.
@dragonbale1387
@dragonbale1387 7 лет назад
CJ Rocky no
@krejdloc
@krejdloc 5 лет назад
The Universe did not need a god to be here. Some of our brains do need a god to cope with mortality and the unknown. The personal god that those brains create will die when those brains cease to function. That in itself is a good thing IMO.
@johnnotrealname8168
@johnnotrealname8168 4 года назад
Well no God is necessary to sustain it.
@Hummus_1
@Hummus_1 6 лет назад
We made out of mud
@vernonhardapple6983
@vernonhardapple6983 6 лет назад
THE Mincrafter Chthonic....
@pieragal
@pieragal 6 лет назад
God tells us in the book of Genesis 2:7 "And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul. The Bible (KJV) has never been disproved. Study the Bible for yourself and you will see that all the answers to life are in it.
@robbiehernandez8019
@robbiehernandez8019 5 лет назад
Piera Galvin No they aren’t.
@TheAxhol
@TheAxhol 9 лет назад
Lol k
@ibtiheltounsi1400
@ibtiheltounsi1400 3 месяца назад
The holy Quran says that we are created from stardust
@vrijmens
@vrijmens 2 года назад
@GeorgeCoyne Speak for yourself please. Do not include me in your story by using the word 'we'. I create stars. For my amusement really. To have something mysterious to look at.
@gregorybouyer9867
@gregorybouyer9867 Год назад
How do you know what from the Bible if you haven’t read it 🤷🏿‍♂️
@johnadams-wp2yb
@johnadams-wp2yb 6 лет назад
There is no 'god'. Grasp the nettle.
@Flora0966
@Flora0966 6 лет назад
I wouldn't say that if I were you.. Kardashev scale Type VI CIVILIZATION is capable of existing outside of spacetime itself. and creating multiverses,universes at will I wouldn't exactly say God. more like Gods if such a civilization exists they created all this
@ahubamicprinciples8641
@ahubamicprinciples8641 5 лет назад
john adams Alabamians are gods the gods created the universe.
@downtoearthproductions
@downtoearthproductions 4 года назад
Using critical thinking, this video isn't true as to who humans are.
@PaulSmith-wz2xv
@PaulSmith-wz2xv Год назад
a man trying desperately to hang on to the clerical professional livelihood and the relevance of his church.
@jasper826
@jasper826 7 лет назад
But Coyne what has to do with the Catholic Church? His thesis and theories are trillion light years afar from his Church. They have nothing in common. NOTHING!
@mmmail1969
@mmmail1969 7 лет назад
what do you mean?
Далее
Coca-Cola 😂🫲
00:20
Просмотров 3,6 млн
Best tutorial💞🤗🕺🏻 #tiktok
00:11
Просмотров 624 тыс.
We Are Dead Stars | Michelle Thaller | TEDxBaltimore
13:10
We Are All Stardust | Haley Gomez | TEDxCardiff
18:44
Coca-Cola 😂🫲
00:20
Просмотров 3,6 млн