WELCOME TO SHEA'S SHRINES Scarab God, Osgir, Yarok, Go-shintai | Worst Possible Commander Show #44 

I was wondering if they were gonna do this. I had my comment trigger finger ready to go, but I figure someone had already beat me to it lol. The "if it was cast" is just tucked away and hard to miss

He probably shoulda read it right the first time. He kinda skimmed over the cast effect lol

thanks i wanted to write that down but u did it first^^

Oh yeah. Agreed on both counts!

That was perfect.. it didn't even look like Shae blinked at all

He was trying to play the game so hard, he wanted to play for his opponents too 😂

perfectly stated

Yeah focus went bad a few times.

I think what they meant was playing a Yarok deck against Elesh would be impossible

gain life base on # of shrines, not the life opponents lost

🤔 hrm. The only ruling in the gatherer is that if quicksilver gargantuan enters at the same time as another creature it can't enter as a copy of that creature. It must copy a creature already on the battlefield. However in this case they have to be cast, so you can choose the order of the cast. Emergent ultimatum says you ignore timing permissions based on the cards. So, they both go on the stack. However quicksilver gargantuan doesn't specify to choose a target on cast and gatherer doesn't specify either. you can simply choose to let it enter the battlefield as a copy of another creature. So, I guess so long as massacre wurm resolves first, I think you are okay to choose this as a target. I guess it depends on whether that choice needs to be made on cast, or if it can be done on ETB.

Now that i think about it since gatherer specifies only situations where they enter the battlefield at the same time, I think the timing works.

You're only half wrong. You do need to cast both spells when resolving Emergent Ultimatum. But that's just _casting_ the spells - they resolve as usual. Quicksilver Gargantuan's copy effect is a replacement effect on entering the battlefield, so as long as it enters the battlefield _after_ Massacre Wurm, it will work. So the trick here is casting the Gargantuan _first_ and then the Wurm; since they both go on the stack together, the Wurm will resolve first.

No, both spells are _cast_ as part of Emergent Ultimatum's resolution. They go on the stack as usual.

ps... scropion says "its in my nature"

She played an older text version of the card which says "play" but the gatherer text specifically says : Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card. So Eidolon of Blossoms and Setassan Champion are enchantment ETB draws (i think the only), where as the other Enchatress's are cast triggers. Sythis, Satyr, Verduran, Mesa etc

@@gn0s1s it counts in mtg arena yes I know its not the same but it triggers all of the same effects

@@indron1887 that would be weird if they changed all the enchantresses to etb triggers instead of cast triggers... Go shintai creates 1/1 shrines, so I dont see how verduran enchantress would trigger of their creation... In arena settassan champ will trigger because she sees the enchantment etb...not sure if verduran is in arena.

I typed that out right before the sea gate restoration. FYI