Welfare | The Complete Moderate's Guide

Подписаться 915 тыс.

Просмотров 722 тыс.

50% 1

Welfare reform is part of every politician's speech, but what programs do we already have and how could they be improved?
Try Skillshare for two months for free by going to skl.sh/knowingbetter4
Website ► knowingbetter.tv
Store ► standard.tv/knowingbetter
Patreon ► / knowingbetter
Paypal ► paypal.me/knowingbetter
Twitter ► / knowingbetteryt
Twitch ► / knowingbetteryt
Facebook ► / knowingbetteryt
Instagram ► / knowingbetteryt
Reddit ► / knowingbetter
---
Thanks to donoteat01 for explaining housing assistance:
/ donoteat01
/ donoteat1
Check out his video on Public Housing: • Cities: Skylines | Pow...
---
General Sources
www.cbo.gov/publication/53624
aspe.hhs.gov/poverty-guidelines
Tax Credits
fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R43805.pdf
www.eitc.irs.gov/eitc-central...
www.cbpp.org/research/federal...
www.taxpolicycenter.org/publi...
Education
trends.collegeboard.org/stude...
Lifeline
arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2...
TANF
dfcs.georgia.gov/tanf-eligibi...
www.georgialegalaid.org/resou...
www.cbpp.org/research/family-...
SNAP/WIC
www.cbpp.org/research/food-as...
Medicaid/CHIP/ACA
www.kff.org/medicaid/state-in...
www.medicaid.gov/medicaid/pro...
www.cbsnews.com/news/obamacar...
Unemployment
www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/B...
oui.doleta.gov/unemploy/conte...
tcf.org/content/report/unempl...
newrepublic.com/article/97971...
www.aboutunemployment.org/faq...
www.businessinsider.com/heres...
www.savingtoinvest.com/maximum...
Social Security
www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/chart...
www.ssa.gov/budget/FY18Files/...
Universal Basic Income
interestingengineering.com/th...
www.economist.com/finance-and...
www.marketplace.org/2016/12/2...
---
Photo Credits -
www.taxpolicycenter.org/sites...
commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...
www.census.gov/content/dam/Ce...
Thumbnail - commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...
Video Credits -
Original Obamaphone Lady: Obama Voter Says Vote for Obama because he gives a free Phone - RealFreedom1776 - • Original Obamaphone La...
Universal Basic Income Explained - Free Money for Everybody? UBI - Kurzgesagt - In a Nutshell - • Universal Basic Income...
Music Credits -
"Furious Freak" and "Inspired" by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
---
Intro Art and Channel Avatar by PoetheWonderCat
/ thatcatnamedpoe
---
Hashtags: #government #state #welfare #tax #taxes #care #money #reform #welfarestate #system #socialsecurity #medicaid #medicare #foodstamps #unemployment
---
This video was sponsored by Skillshare.

Опубликовано:

5 янв 2019

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 4 тыс.

@KnowingBetter 5 лет назад

Be sure to check out donoteat01's video(s) on Public Housing - ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-xqJbE1bvdgo.html Slight correction: The $591B Medicare cost is what taxpayers pay, not what those on Medicare paying premiums pay.

@munendersingh5631 5 лет назад

Hft

@silversandxo 5 лет назад

Cores - ga - zaught btw

@agrandcanyonoffucksgiven2776 5 лет назад

Love the UHF reference

@ilovethismightyfineplace 5 лет назад

You forgot to mention “corporate welfare”! 😏 How about a “Moderate’s Guide to Corporate Welfare?”

@macpalin4099 5 лет назад

Tell that jerk to finish his next video we have all been waiting!

@PaperMario64 4 года назад

Thank you for this video. People have so many misconceptions about welfare. I grew up on welfare because my mom had a lot of health issues. We were not balling out or rolling in dough. In fact, we had to borrow from friends to make rent and also afford items that were not covered with food stamps. We had to constantly be re-evaluated to ensure that we deserved the benefits and when my addict father came home from prison, they tried to put us off the program. Not because he had a job or actually did anything to help us, just because he had no where else to go. During a few years when her health was better, the government program helped her get a job assisting the elderly, and we were worse off. We really went through harder times than usual. It was a mess. This was during the Clinton back-to-work era. If you’ve never been at that level of poverty, you will never understand.

@basedchad534 2 года назад

Was she rolling grass?

@suzbone 2 года назад

Paper Mario that's such a deeply stressful environment to grow up in 😞 I hope you're doing great today

@mateohodge6998 2 года назад

@@suzbone sadly thousands if not millions of children are living as rough as this I've personally fell in and out of poverty quite a few times very easy to too get into but it's almost hell trying to claw your way out with no assistance

@agoo7581 2 года назад

@@basedchad534 Are you 13?

@blee-bleep3906 2 года назад

@@agoo7581 look at his username and pfp used, he's either 13 or a 40 yo living in his mother's basement

@vlogo4371 5 лет назад

It's really important to remember that the subsidized phone is also a flip phone that's often got very limited talk and text. It's a utility; a digital mailbox.

@jbskaggs7200 4 года назад

The flip phones can play video, games, and browse internet my son has one.

@XenKat 4 года назад

Not true. It's a smart phone these days with 500mg of high speed data.

@princessbloomofdomino950 4 года назад

@@XenKat 500 mg? that's a high dose

@XenKat 4 года назад

@@princessbloomofdomino950 i got super high on two Obama phones ;)

@allideni836 3 года назад

It depends on which Lifeline-supported service you sign up for. The exact benefits you get vary, too. My program gave me an LG441G (a flip phone).

@godalseif 5 лет назад

To be fair with the mixed income housing thing. The idea isn't really that poor people will become less poor by being around richer people. The idea is that poverty density generally contributes to unhealthy environments for the residents both physically and mentally. Psychology often doesn't really make logical sense, it just happens to be true.

@kaiceecrane3884 4 года назад

Lack of logical sense is lack of information, and when it comes to psychology we have practically no information on the subject, what information we have is can be summarized as we know certin things happen sometimes

@darkside3052 4 года назад

Grouping the “have nots” with the “haves” only results in increased violence. That is not a moral judgment on either party, just how we creatures behave.

@rogerwilco2 4 года назад

Mixing income allows for a much higher level of services in the area, in shops, restaurants, transportation and such. This gives the poor people more options both in jobs, travel and healthy living choices.

@rogerwilco2 4 года назад

@@darkside3052 No. It gives everyone more options and thus leads to people having better lives and less violence.

@synthsol5522 4 года назад

RogerWilco I disagree, we have seen time and time again that gentrification in California drives prices so high to accommodate that urban west coast life style that it drives out the poors from the gentrified neighborhood they grew up in

@rogermwilcox 4 года назад

4:29 : "No one uses a landline any more. Not even your grandma." Businesses do!

@henryirvine7964 4 года назад

ok boomer

@kaaz1010 4 года назад

ok boomer

@sebastiangeorge7714 4 года назад

"Cries in German"

@ly-yx1rk 4 года назад

Most are running VoIP

@aaronwalterryse4281 4 года назад

yep, still mostly do. And i still do!

@Paranoidifyable 5 лет назад

Read the title as: The Complete Moderate's Guide to Warfare. Very different video ensued.

@TorreFernand 5 лет назад

Knowing better, there's your next video!

@diabeticalien3584 5 лет назад

LOL, nice!

@MrAlias-oc8uk 5 лет назад

Probably means your political ideology is shifted far to one direction. I found this quite moderate.

@johnkeefer8760 5 лет назад

Mr. Alias The OP wrote WARfare. Not Welfare.

@MrAlias-oc8uk 5 лет назад

@@johnkeefer8760 Ah.

@SpecialEDy 5 лет назад

I applied for Medicare in Texas when I was going to school full time, living alone, working 3 part time jobs, and made $14,000 for the year. I have type 1 Diabetes, if I don't take my insulin I die. They said I make too much money for Medicare, but I didn't make enough money for Insurance help through Obamacare. Did I put gas in my vehicle to get to school and work, or did I buy food? Did I buy my school books, or another months worth of medicine?

@KnowingBetter 5 лет назад

I'm going to assume you mean Medicaid here. Healthcare in the US is an entire video to itself, I might get to it some day.

@minabotieso6944 5 лет назад

I feel for you. Random donations is not going to help working Americans, its biasing the government against the rich who just passed a tax bill that raises taxes on people making $75k or less

@minabotieso6944 5 лет назад

Knowing Better please focus on the best healthcare systems in the world. Disagreeing with universal healthcare only makes sense in the American bubble

@alexanderchristopher6237 5 лет назад

@Klaa2 how?

@ThatsJustLikeYourOpinionMan 5 лет назад

The more Republican the state, the more screwed you are I'd you run into trouble and need assistance.

@JKIII-lj8us 4 года назад

Damn I had Medicaid my whole life in Missouri he just said I was in super poverty 😂😂

@Kitten_in_a_scaryplace 3 года назад

My mom fed 3 full grown adults on one S.N.A.P card, for YEARS while my brother and I were in college, She is an amazing woman :D

@jospinner1183 2 года назад

That's absolutely amazing and your mom is a superhero. It's worth noting, however, that SNAP benefits have been dropping (proportionally) and prices for healthy food (especially fresh produce) have been rising. It gets increasingly challenging to scrape a healthy diet out of SNAP benefits without additional supplemental help, such as from a food pantry. I used to work with food-insecure college students at my university and we spend much of our funding on finding ways to get affordable fruits and veggies.

@shrubsteppers 2 года назад

That's how SNAP works. The amount you receive is based on the number of people eating the food you purchase. So if she was feeding three people she would receive the allotment for three people.

@alterego8496 2 года назад

@@shrubsteppers The thing is we dont appropriate the money properly and often just give them pennies

@4sername 2 года назад

also known as the top rahmen diet

@lolaby2 2 года назад

@@4sername don’t knock it. I lost 30lbs in 2 weeks eating ramen 2 times a day

@jankielbobrowsky5692 5 лет назад

The Complete Moderate’s Guide to The Galaxy

@aturchomicz821 5 лет назад

"And this is the fabric of the universe. You can't eat it because its everything"

@Liam-qr7zn 5 лет назад

@@aturchomicz821 *DO NOT EAT*

@theyellowentity9668 5 лет назад

Political unrest? Don’t panic

@geomidia8998 4 года назад

Grab your towel

@rai_l 4 года назад

@@aturchomicz821 congrats now you have 42 likes

@StevePlaysBanjo 5 лет назад

Totally worth the extra time to put this video together. I grew up in a poverty culture where we were shamed for taking advantage of these programs meant to help us get out of pit we were in. As a result, there was very little welfare education. I was lucky enough to eventually get out of that pit, but it probably took 10 years longer than necessary. Also, the wrassling ferrets at the end are so dang cute!

@renee3461 5 лет назад

I know a mom (she's technically still married but he's a drug addict and is jobless) who prefers to be a prostitute to avoid having to get welfare. Her daughter has suffered because of it, but people have shamed her so much that she refuses to be on welfare. (Personally I think that when you have a kid, you need to set your pride aside, but I'm just trying to say that I agree with you and have seen people not use welfare purely because they've been shamed.) I know somebody who is completely blind who is the same way with refusing welfare. I'm all for working hard, but I think that in some cases it's perfectly acceptable to use welfare to get by!

@calichef1962 5 лет назад

Klaa2-- They may have given up after being denied Social Security. SS ALWAYS denies the first claim-- even when the claimant is blind, handicapped or even bed-ridden. Some people apply over and over again, some for more than a decade! They used to have to pay claimants for the years they waited between their first claim and when they finally approved their claim. I know a man that had seriously debilitating epilepsy with grand mal seizures that came every couple of days. He fought the SSA for over a decade and eventually got a settlement well in excess of $100,000. He bought a house with it. Unfortunately, he died less than two years after finally winning his claim. But that is why they have cut back-payments to one year's equivalent income. In some cases it can be a little bit more, but the claimant has to show loan agreements with repayment schedules.

@teethgrinder83 5 лет назад

@Klaa2 i agree with you but to be fair it isnt just America (although from what i can gather especially through vids like this), it can be quite bad here in the uk too-ive heard about old people not wanting to claim for various things and i myself had to be persuaded to eventually apply for disability help-i take a lot of seizures and because that's not obvious like a missing leg would be i was adament i wouldn't claim because i was convinced the benefits wasnt for me, it wasnt until id spent a lot of hard days and nights that my epilepsy nurse persuaded me to apply. And thankfully i did has easing the pressure helped reduce my stress which reduced my seizures and helped me slowly back into work. I've no doubt id still be going in and out of thw hospital if i hadnt eventually claimed. So yeah, while America seems to be especially difficult your certainly not alone, which is such a sad affair

@DAAraiz 5 лет назад

Renee she did set her pride aside, followed by her dignity... followed by her legs, sorry, had to, that is tragic...

@DAAraiz 5 лет назад

I’m actually glad to hear some people hesitate to take money from the state and would rather work harder, Thad better than the people I know of that just abuse the system and my tax dollars, I would love if my tax money went to the wife and child of a deadbeat that won’t provide for his family so she doesn’t prostitute herself, if only everyone that used it actually needed it. It’s supposed to be temporary assistance not a lifelong crutch, unless you’re genuinely disabled.

@themercer4972 5 лет назад

Iv done a lot of research into aid programs in Canada, what hits me the most is the fact that nearly 50% of each program's budget is spent on the bureaucracy of the program.

@DrewPicklesTheDark 4 года назад

It's like that in most nations, not just Canada. That's one of the main flaws of government-heavy democracies/republics. The thinking of those involved is "Things get lost in bureaucracy, why not profit off it?" If you want a good example look at the results of the grain dole in Republican Rome vs. Imperial Rome (Imperial was far more quick and efficient due to lack of bureaucracy.)

@loganbradford2343 4 года назад

Source?

@briddenattech 4 года назад

That is why I'm a huge fan of welfare... but not STATE welfare. Looking at good private welfare programs (eg, Shriner's hospital for children) the efficiency is much better... but it also requires society at large to be more interested in personally assisting, instead of the government siphoning it out of everyone's pockets.

@ykl1277 4 года назад

@@briddenattech me too, until I realise I'd rather spend my income on personal luxury instead of donate to private charity. I'm a terrible person. :(

@GY-bd9bo 4 года назад

@@briddenattech private charity might be ideal but I don't think it's reliable, since most people don't donate.

@foreversocal1 3 года назад

Having been on or dealt with on the receiving end of many of the welfare systems in America, the financial "cliff" is the killer & what kept me on assistance almost double the time I should've. As soon as you hit like $1500 a month, you lose ALL of your benefits including food & maybe health. Meaning that you lose more in benefits than you gain from working, making it incredibly difficult to make that transition

@Xsuprio 5 лет назад

Lived in the States (Ohio) for 8 years. I heard and dealt with more of the welfare programs mentioned in this video than I'd like to admit. I personally experienced a major flaw... the more I made working, the more they cut (my wife's) benefits. At one point, I had to hand over so much of my paycheck to medicare, we would have been better off if I quit my job and got the full benefits back. I would have NEVER been able to get ahead, as my wife's medical bills were VERY high and would never end. Luckily, she cheated on me and I'm back in Europe. Yay.

@ThatsJustLikeYourOpinionMan 5 лет назад

Europe seems like a progressive wonderland compared to the regressive USA

@Xsuprio 5 лет назад

@@ThatsJustLikeYourOpinionMan Don't get me wrong. I love the US and do miss it. And Europe's got plenty of problems of its own which are getting worse. Medical and housing related. I used to believe governments were there to prevent and solve problems. Y'know... govern! They just seem to be getting more and more incompetent.

@tomasxfranco 5 лет назад

It makes some sense to pay more when you can afford to pay more, but it was probably implemented horribly like most legislation.

@Xsuprio 5 лет назад

@@tomasxfranco (Read this as info, not like I'm arguing with you.) This was 8 years ago and I don't remember exact numbers. I think I made $1200- $1300 a month and payed $400- $450 "spend down" for Medicaid. Then I had to pay rent and electricity at about $450+ and, of course, other bills. My (ex)wife got a food stamp card, but I wasn't eligible as I as foreign (green card) and I don't remember how much was on there. Way not enough to buy food all month. Occasionally, we had to go to the food pantry, where more often than not, the food was spoiled... and I mean MOLD. If I quit my job, there would have been full Medicaid coverage (for her, not me. I had my own health insurance to pay for) with no spend down, she would have gotten her Social Security (disability) Check back (which was also cancelled after I started earning "enough"), food stamps would have gone back up and we would have been better off. Not to mention all the hoops we didn't have to jump through anymore, like going down to Job and Family Services and Social Security office, which are *fucking Hell holes*, pardon my French, where you get nothing but bad news. You know you're gonna walk outta there more depressed then you were going in. I could have sat on my ass playing second hand video games all day, but I did the "right" thing and kept working, paying taxes, getting nothing in return. I actually told my boss I did not want any more raises, because the "cost" of "benefits" went up disproportionately every time.

@Xsuprio 5 лет назад

@Noise Pollution Not sure if sarcasm orrrr.... Either way... this is about all I wanted to share. It was the best of times, it was the worst of times. I lived it and I wish they would fix it. But again... governments seem too busy smelling their own farts these days.

@brucecanzoli3423 5 лет назад

-You:"taxes in Us are extremely complex" -Italy:"hold my beer"

@pauljackson3491 5 лет назад

I once heard that only the German tax system is more complicated than the US's. Maybe it's just in amount of laws and not what those say.

@brucecanzoli3423 5 лет назад

@@pauljackson3491 maybe. Maybe here it's the bureaucracy that goes with taxes.

@chris-pollux 5 лет назад

Well, we got to feed all the tax advisors here in Germany, don't we?

@SocialistFinn1 5 лет назад

Do they pay taxes to the Mafia in Sicily?

@brucecanzoli3423 5 лет назад

@@SocialistFinn1 sometimes people are forced to pay mafia there, but not much anymore, mafia boys tend to get imprisoned or shot at quite often. Mafia lost its power to the Camorra (from Naples) and 'Ndrangheta (from Calabria) wich are worse, but criminal organizations as a whole don't get an easy life anymore, they are dying out slowly here. Especially in the north.

@MisterTutor2010 2 года назад

I remember learning about the rules concerning food stamps when I was a grocery store cashier (1997-1998) while I was in college.

@MisterTutor2010 2 года назад

WIC as well.

@Randomeaninglessword 4 года назад

Hey man, I use a landline AND I don't have a cellphone! There are dozens of us!

@makasuevu 4 года назад

@theguyof360 4 года назад

"dozens" lol i use a landline too

@makasuevu 4 года назад

guys he made a joke

@theguyof360 4 года назад

@@makasuevu no, he was 100% non satirical, and totally serious

@in6587 4 года назад

I believe you. There must be some seversl dozens of you throughout the us

@Nothrice 5 лет назад

A 30 minute video from Knowing Better? Its like Christmas again.

@Gabriel-cr1qe 5 лет назад

Well it's three kings day here where I live which is like a second Christmas so yes

@ErikHare 5 лет назад

No it is not! This is way better. :-)

@josecarlosmoreno9731 5 лет назад

@@Gabriel-cr1qe It's called the Day of the Epiphany.

@Gabriel-cr1qe 5 лет назад

@@josecarlosmoreno9731 the more you know. I'm just directly translating it cause I don't know how it's called

@peebay3515 5 лет назад

Would you say it is a.....welfare Christmas?

@zac8603 5 лет назад

Never realized that full time at minimum wage qualifies you for SNAP, gotta love that hidden corporate welfare.

@primarchlion 5 лет назад

Not everyone that works for minimum wage works for a large business or corporation, but it would be nice, if difficult to legislate for one reason (hard to word) or another (corporate lobbying), if businesses that made above a certain income or profit had a raised legal minimum wage for their employees.

@gwanael34 5 лет назад

The saddest thing about all this is that some people will do everything so defend this idea.

@Big1nz 5 лет назад

@@primarchlion What the hell are you on about? Why are you justifying small buisness existing kn the basis of paying their employees poverty wages? Why 8n the world should their income level determine if their employees need social programs because they refuse to pay a decent wage?

@primarchlion 5 лет назад

I don't understand the question, or you misunderstand my comment. It would be nice, in my opinion, if businesses with larger profits/income would be forced to pay a higher minimum wage. That's what I said, I'm not willing to call my Congressman over it or do a ton of research to write exactly how it would work, but I think it would be pleasant.

@primarchlion 5 лет назад

@@blakejohnson3864 If that's the case then I misunderstood the question =P. My initial comment was replying to someone stating that this was corporate welfare, which I felt implied that it was a program to reduce the financial burden on big businesses. I gave my opinion on 1 method that that point in particular might be tackled. Other methods might be UBI or raising the minimum wage.

@Ammo08 4 года назад

Good video. I worked for close to 30 years managing various welfare, welfare-to-work, and education programs. It is very complicated. I have seen abuse in the programs, and I've also seen the programs work unbelievably well. Our state had a 5 year limit on cash welfare benefits, however, there were so many ways for the family to get out of this, well, it basically didn't exist. We did see problems where people would go in a store, use their SNAP benefits to buy food and trade it for drugs...yes it does happen. We saw moms who had a string of men, or other people living in their household and using the benefits meant for the children, so the children got shortchanged. I also saw people use the money and opportunity to climb out of poverty with education or job training...

@Gingersnaps_the_pumpkin_kitty 2 года назад

Honestly this is why Healthcare (specifically sexual/reproductive) and Child-abuse/care need more attention. We having politicians forcing people to give birth to children they can't take care while decreasing children's protections from abusers and taking assistance away from families. People should have a choice and then should be held to higher standards as parents while being given the assistance they need to get the best outcome for that choice. That's how we fix this mess.

@chrisashtonlightell-west1189 3 года назад

I've watched a ton of videos from this channel, and this is the first time I didn't learn anything new. I guess there's a good reason for that. I've met a ton of houseless/ex-houseless people who know so much about the inner workings of the court and welfare systems, they could've been hugely successful lawyers in another life. Yes, even that guy mumbling and pacing back and forth in front of the gas station. Poor people are more savvy than you think, especially when it comes to survival. In contrast, I know a lot of middle-class people who... I don't even know how they manage to take care of themselves every day. Can't judge a book by its cover, or class. Anyway, sorry about the rant, just had to point that out.

@catherinecrawford2289 Год назад

If people knew how much work it is being poor, how much shifting/accommodating and plain juggling it takes, they'd think better of the poor. Just the acquiring of food can be a real chore.

@Jarekthegamingdragon 5 лет назад

"If an item doesn't have sales tax, you can probably by it with snap" Well, shit I can buy every thing with that here in Oregon. lol

@TheOriginalEdFry 5 лет назад

I seen a gas station with an ad saying SNAP now covers Energy Drinks, felt kinda wrong to me. Not that people on SNAP don't deserve a Rockstar but because those drinks have to be terrible for you.

@Jarekthegamingdragon 5 лет назад

@@TheOriginalEdFry I'm not on snap. My joke was that Oregon doesn't have sales tax.

@raney150 5 лет назад

@@TheOriginalEdFry saw*

@mjaynes288 5 лет назад

@@TheOriginalEdFry Energy drinks might be legal to purchase with SNAP depending on the type of label it has. If it has a supplement label then it cannot be purchased with SNAP money. Recently Monster took all reference to being a supplement off its packaging and changed to a nutrition label making it eligible for SNAP money.

@KesGaming 3 года назад

@@TheOriginalEdFry You think that's weird? Fountain drinks are purchasable at some gas stations with food stamps. And at food city, you can buy day 1 Maple Bacon Donuts with it too.

@Johanna040713 5 лет назад

I live in a nordic welfare society and I often hear complaints about how complex and bureaucratic our system is, but it's nothing compared to the US system. If I was a US citizen in need of welfare, I would probably be in burn-out.

@Johanna040713 5 лет назад

@Road Rants All the more reason to keep the system as simple and purposeful as possible.

@trinova9581 5 лет назад

Road Rants And? Economies of scale are a thing, with administration and logistics costs not linearly scaling up.

@trinova9581 5 лет назад

Road Rants And in countries such as Germany, where the public option represents 3/4 of the population, you very much do get economies of scale going on. Diversity of population has sweet fuck all to do with it, and hiding behind it as an excuse is just being intellectually lazy. What, pray tell, does diversity have to do with laying for healthcare? Healthcare doesn’t become magically more expensive just because your population is more ethnically diverse. Germany manages to have universal healthcare with 25% of the population of the US. Japan manages it with roughly 35% the population of the US. There is precisely nothing that would lead one to believe that the US cannot do it, especially when in terms of GDP per capita, the US is comparable to Scandinavian countries and so should easily be able to afford it.

@trinova9581 5 лет назад

Road Rants Or perhaps put another way. Universal healthcare works in Denmark with its roughly 5 million people. Why the hell wouldn’t it work in Indiana with its 6 million, or Connecticut with its 3 million. Germany and Japan manage it with populations of 83 million and 127 million respectively, and see better results than the US. There is precisely no reason to think it would not scale up to the US.

@trinova9581 5 лет назад

Road Rants Or, to really blow your mind, the US already has a form of universal healthcare for roughly 60 million people: Medicare. It’s already been demonstrated to work better than for-profit healthcare in the US and to be quite functional and on a scale quite comparable to that of other developed countries, even with the US’s more diverse population. Diversity means sweet fuck all and has nothing to do with the cost of healthcare. It’s a red herring used, alongside allusions to population size that ignore GDP per capita, as an excuse to be lazy.

@charleshax 4 года назад

“Money travels through walls by osmosis or somethin’ I don’t know”

@richardalderman2752 4 года назад

Not to defend Alabama's low unemployment insurance payments, but we do have to remember that cost of living varies from state to state, Obviously California, that has a high cost of living, is going to pay more than Alabama that has a high cost of living.

@edwardcardona717 3 года назад

Just because the average cost of living in California may be higher, doesn’t mean everyone in California is living in a place that’s expensive to live in. The people on these programs are not living in the rich parts of San Francisco or working in Silicon Valley, they’re living in low rent places where they’re just as poor as Alabama poor. High costs of living come from housing, clothes, and food. Expensive neighborhoods harbor expensive restaurants and grocers (ie. Whole Foods vs Walmart). California has San Francisco and parts of LA and other big cities that have expensive neighborhoods, whereas Alabama has...Huntsville? I guess? Obviously there’s rich areas in Alabama, but not nearly as many as California. That’s why the cost of living difference exists, and that’s why Alabama, and in general any other state that holds back on their welfare funding, really doesn’t have a defense. They’re just dicks

@vaszi101 3 года назад

i thought that was common sense and everyone accounted for that🤷🏽‍♂️😂

@drumraider 2 года назад

@@edwardcardona717 That is not solely why the cost of living difference exists. Go to Oklahoma or rural Texas, the gasoline will assuredly be lower than anywhere across California. Why? Shipping costs, as well as state and local taxes. California has more of that than Alabama, hence the same products (milk, soda, shoes) can be sold for cheaper.

@Jennifer_Elliott 5 лет назад

Love the asterisk voice! LOL

@avlsage 4 года назад

That voice kinda reminds me of Joe Pera lmao

@iammrbeat 5 лет назад

So TANF is highest in the Live Free or Die state? That is surprising.

@LisaBowers 5 лет назад

Merry New Year, Mr. Beat!!

@iammrbeat 5 лет назад

@@LisaBowers Same to you, Lisa!

@peebay3515 5 лет назад

@@alexandrine1558 Yes, we are a nation of Highlanders. There can only be one...nation...under god...with liberty and justice for all (except if you're black or poor or gay...)

@javierpowell4705 5 лет назад

@@peebay3515 black people are pretty damn successful in their own right, Take Samuel L. Jackson, gay people are successful as well think of Sam Smith

@CertifiedSkank 5 лет назад

Javier Powell Naming one black person who is doing well does not equal “black people are doing well”.

@wyttwntz 2 года назад

I worked as a cashier at a grocery store and WIC checks were pretty annoying and scary to do because if you messed it up you could get fired.

@nicolaspinto2927 5 лет назад

UBI really seems like the only way to deal with the march of automation, but that being said it'd be a fine way to encourage artisan and artistic endeavors once people don't have to fear for their income and I support both. I feel that a UBI would inspire more creative ventures and risk taking (as in new ideas) that could only benefit us overall and bring us back to parity with other developed nations.

@johndaly2816 5 лет назад

I think the opposite. Watch joe rogan podcast or ben saphiro vs andrew yang. How many unfunny people u know who wants to he a comedian? There are some for me. How many weakass people u know who wants to be athlete? I know some. What people aspire to be arent necessarily what they are meant to be. If that's the case the world will run out of accountant and plumbers coz everyone would just "do whatever they think they're good at instead of what they're actually good at". Anyway geniuses would still generate stuffs regardless wheather there is UBI or not.

@nicolaspinto2927 5 лет назад

@@johndaly2816 The problem isn't about geniuses who altogether account for very little overall, and also still require money to do their thing. Did you think Einstein just did his thing? He worked a deadend office job for years before he was able to publish his theories. Imagine if he had gotten a stipend and could dedicate all his day's energies to working on his theories instead. Moving on, the majority of being good is practice and experience. Something you can get a lot more of if you have more free time and less risk of going broke. And the idea we'd run out of labor is astoundingly misled; if anything the reduction of risk would increase the number of small businesses dramatically. The number one reason that people decide to not pursue opening shop is because they fear losing their income or cannot allocate funds to starting a business. Both can be alleviated via a UBI. Imagine all the painters, carpenters, etc that are stuck doing dumb work just to pay bills instead of dedicating themselves to their craft. And finally, a UBI is not an infinite check to buy everything your heart desires. It's just enough to cover the costs of living and no more. To have a more luxurious life, you will still need to work, and most people will still want to buy cool things and go find a job. Which may be easier to get because a UBI means you can actually reduce or remove the minimum wage since it would be obsolete in the face of a UBI. It's all nuanced and balances out in the end. Ben "if the oceans rise just sell the house" Shapiro is a brainless hack, and last I knew Rogan supported UBI. I need not address either here.

@johndaly2816 5 лет назад

@@nicolaspinto2927 dont get me wrong, im supporter of andrew yang. There are reasons to support UBI but the "so people can follow their dreams" is one of the silliest reasons. Im aspiring bodybuilder and train in the gym a lot. Yet i have my genetic limitation. No matter how much i train i wont even make it to national level, there is limit to each human potential. No u dont simply be a pro just by working hard. You should do what u are really good at with UBI, instead of what you want to be good at.

@russellm2555 2 года назад

Wishful thinking often leads to big disappointment

@jmurray1110 2 года назад

Where as I think means tested based benefits is a needlessly complicated badly managed system that is rife for kicking people of at a persons whim and having a universal payout for everyone saves beurocratic costs and time

@Himesua 5 лет назад

This is a great video. I grew up in dire need of many of these programs. We lived in section 8 housing, got TANF/Foodstamps/LEAP(which was the low income heating where I lived at the time we could apply for in the winter ONLY). So there were always ins and outs. I remember super cheap government glasses that I had to be careful not to break and my mom scraping by. I got a job as early as I could and now I help homeless youth find how to make these benefits help them get back on their feet.

@isaacnorwood4463 5 лет назад

I wonder if welfare has anything to do with why Oklahoma has a pan handle?

@KnightofAntiquity 5 лет назад

It could be that Oklahoma had some of the most undesireable land in the U.S.

@pickles3128 5 лет назад

Oklahoma's population is so unhealthy that over one third is obese (not just overweight). It should be called the love handle state.

@Floedekage 5 лет назад

Yeah... Why DO Oklahoma have a panhandle?

@KnightofAntiquity 5 лет назад

@@Floedekage The handle was created during the trail of tears. Oklahoma became a state and seized the land surrounding the indians in the handle.

@isaacnorwood4463 5 лет назад

@@Floedekage and now, you know better.

@LatheWerks 3 года назад

My grandma is 92 and uses a landline. My grandpa though, used the internet at age 94 and traded stocks

@Scriptorsilentum Год назад

my landline has an "adapter - analog (rotary dial impulses) to digital - that lets me use my 1932 "candlestick" phone and a 80's touch-tone. my neighbours watch stunned and awed when i made a call on it. 😁😁😲😲

@richardalderman2752 4 года назад

I think people sometimes forget who also benefits from the SNAP program...The agricultural industry.

@brian2090 2 года назад

@@gomahklawm4446 yeah, as someone who works in federal crop insurance, you’ve got it backwards. Take away the “subsidies” and prices necessarily increase, as does literally all of the food you purchase. The system keeps the price of agricultural products artificially low so that manufactured food products are also cheap.

@0urmunchk1n 5 лет назад

I feel I should share this. A few years ago I was working as a teaching assistant in special education full time. Despite that, my income was low enough that my family qualified for Medicaid, SNAP, and WIC. I went back to school and finished my degree at which time I did some math. In order to cover the health insurance and loss of food stamps I needed to basically double my income, which I did. But yeah, there is a definite welfare trap. This is a reason I like the idea of single payer health care and UBI rather than means testing. Means testing often becomes a trap that keeps people from escaping poverty since earning more can leave you with less. Making benefits universal regardless of income solves that problem and makes administration less expensive since you don't need anyone to go over all the redundant paperwork.

@SoniaSephia 5 лет назад

Complete moderates guide to... Public school reform. Private Prison industrial complex. Public School Sex Education. Planned Parenthood.

@sonoftanavast8916 5 лет назад

I second this motion.

@theluckiestmagala3126 5 лет назад

I third this motion

@Riskofdisconnect 5 лет назад

I veto this motion, next on the agenda please.

@jrayhayes 5 лет назад

Connor Barber LOL

@sonoftanavast8916 5 лет назад

You can't veto my motion! I veto your veto!

@MyTony8669 3 года назад

I worked for SSA for 40 years; your explanation was spot on!

@michaelwalker4977 4 года назад

The concern I've had about Universal Basic Income is a suspicion that prices would simply inflate to make sure you still couldn't be livably housed and fed on it, no matter where we set the dial.

@stephj9378 4 года назад

its socialism, just more classy. Young able bodied people do not need that type of help. We need asocial safety net for any citizen, with a time limit.

@brian2090 2 года назад

Yeah, it’s not a suspicion, it’s basic economics that UBIers either ignore or cannot comprehend.

@brian2090 2 года назад

@Brayan Velez quit being lazy

@foca7550 2 года назад

@@brian2090 Enjoy worrying about medical bills on your death bed LOL

@Jamesangstman 5 лет назад

Bruh that map needs a legend. “If you live in any of these states” and a two-color map is super unclear.

@dylantorres2406 5 лет назад

I second this

@tomc5136 5 лет назад

Yeah the only way I sorted it out was because I know what my state does lol

@tskmaster3837 5 лет назад

I thought it was obvious. "Which states are most likely to vote against their own interests?" Piece of cake... which they're not allowing to eat either.

@auto_ego 5 лет назад

Not to mention that the two colors are red and green, which would make the map _especially_ hard to digest for people with almost any kind of colorblindness.

@joegagliardi1938 5 лет назад

James Angstman I thought that at first as well, but he used a green background map earlier, so that's where I took my cue. Nevertheless, I didn't even need to look at the map. Based on what he was saying, I just knew most of the states that would be highlighted were southern states. No offense to them.

@UwgAllDay 5 лет назад

Donoteat1!?!? And knowing better?! Yes please

@UberMenschNowFilms 5 лет назад

What will be the next crossover with left tube? ContraPoints? PhilosophyTube? I need more!!

@theluckiestmagala3126 5 лет назад

@@UberMenschNowFilms contra might be fun.

@danintheoutback1 5 лет назад

The US has some seriously problems, with understanding what help people in real poverty need. We all do, all over the world, but the US has some seriously deficent ”welfare” programs.

@rogerwilco2 4 года назад

I think it's on purpose.

@chris532008 4 года назад

Welfare breeds more welfare

@Snarge22 4 года назад

@first last Right! That's one welfare program I'd support. That is mandatory birth control for those on welfare.

@kaydenl6836 3 года назад

chris532008 that’s factually incorrect. People on welfare aren’t jobless anymore than non-welfare people. Unless you mean “having welfare means more people will be on welfare because they don’t just die off instead”. Which is nazi shit

@Draconic_Aura 3 года назад

@@MrFixIt-le7tl that is since Japan has a shitty workplace life and a shitty alcohol addiction problem. Tax alcohol and tobacco, heavily crack down on ijime, force compensated overwork hours, legalize taima, encourage childcare and increased children, give college test assistance to the poor, and create more social opportunities for people that don't have to do with alcohol. Why is this so hard?

@joexer1 4 года назад

20:17 That man just walked straight into traffic!

@lifestories1446 5 лет назад

What about corporate welfare or agricultural welfare?

@Overton_Windows 5 лет назад

Mitch Grout exactly

@ZacharyandMeghanEntz 5 лет назад

Both are horrid frauds.....this is coming from someone who lives on a farm.....I don't personally accept this money, (because I'm not in charge), but it basically puts those who don't accept the money at disadvantage.

@kylehankins5988 5 лет назад

Exactly what corporate welfare are you talking about. All I can think of is TARP (the bailouts) however TARP was a loan

@thetrashman69 5 лет назад

"Agricultural welfare" is a very missleading term shrowded in layers of miss information. Basically, it is a way to encourage farmers to purchase crop insurance so in a bad year farmers would be less likely to go under and cause some sort of massive food shortage

@ltraina3353 4 года назад

Kyle Hankins the books “free lunch” and “perfectly legal” by David Cay Johnston do a great job of explaining what corporate welfare is, it’s well-researched and fascinating reading!

@benjaminbrady2385 5 лет назад

Not American, also not important but I actually *do* use landline

@ghostdukevladamir5101 5 лет назад

I still use landline along with a smartphone

@agentpearce479 5 лет назад

Where would such a device be useful?

@aprilkurtz1589 5 лет назад

@@ghostdukevladamir5101 Same here. I hate the echo, the lag, and general inferior sound quality of cel phones. They're nice to have if you're not at home and need to call someone, or your car breaks down and you need to call a tow truck, or need to call the police. As far as I'm concerned, land lines are still very useful.

@ghostdukevladamir5101 5 лет назад

@@agentpearce479 Doesn't require data, credit or WiFi and a monthly contract is cheaper than a cellphone contract. If your home WiFi isn't very strong and you just want to call someone it's pretty convenient

@Green0-3 5 лет назад

@@agentpearce479 Landline is actually extremely useful when you live in an area that sees frequent power outages, or where cellphone service isn't all that good. In my case, for instance, my neighbourhood has an average of 6-7 power cuts a year, and they can last anywhere from a few hours, to around 3-4 days. Longest I've faced was a week, and it spanned the whole county. Meanwhile, my cellphone's battery lasts, at best, a day or two without much use, assuming I have it at 100% charge when the power goes out. Landline, on the other hand, always works.

@Feroste 4 года назад

"Is there something for the middle class? Yes, it's called a 30-year mortgage."

@andrewhall7930 5 лет назад

The reason your channel DOMINATES my RU-vid viewing, is because you start by DEFINING the subject you are discussing. So many channels involving people just start talking about a subject, these subjects often have vague interpretations for different people, which invariable leads to persons essentially arguing over different parts of the same elephant (I hope you know the parable of the 7 blind indian men and the Elephant) I don't always agree with you, but you are exceptionally rare talent. Thanks for existing. Please don't ever stop Defining exactly what you are talking about.

@adamsfusion 5 лет назад

Lots of people in the comments are claiming that they see people using EBT for buying fast food, alcohol, and tobacco. I want to clear that up because I think I know where the confusion lies. To reiterate what was said in the video, EBT is just a method of receiving benefits. SNAP is the program that doesn't allow buying what I mentioned above. While they use the same card, services like SSDI, SSI, etc. can be spent on anything. However, only certain stores can charge to the SNAP (food stamp) portion of the card. Nowhere that sells fast food can charge to the SNAP benefits. Period.

@Didleeios88 5 лет назад

I have seen people trading food stamps for things you cannot buy with food stamps. Yes it is illegal. Doesn't mean it doesn't happen. It's easy enough to do. Basically just barter with everyday products that are needed universally. 3 boxes of cereal for one pack of cigarettes. It's sort of silly to quote the law as if that dictates reality.

@mochaqt2466 5 лет назад

Actually your wrong, growing up in California(specifically Los Angeles), there are multiple face food restaurants that accept ebt. It depends on if you registered as homeless at the welfare office. They allow people classified as “homeless”, to purchase hot foods.

@Wargod1395 5 лет назад

When i was struggeling cleaning carpets for a living trying to support a family of 5 and the only one woking i was on food stamps the gas station down the road took food stamps and would let you buy tobacco using food stamps they had a sheet showing the after tax price of all tobacco they sold and would ring it up as food. So it does happen (not legally though) (no longer need it as i have gained a skill and now have a good job)

@RmcBlueSky 5 лет назад

And I know some ppl use it like a debit card. They have cash set in for hot food. Also, some stores does work around it, bc some ppl are so poor that they don't own a stove or anything to cook the food with.

@victorchan8859 5 лет назад

@@zloungeact subway is considered deli food if you don't toast the sandwich and thus they don't collect sales tax like other hot food and is technically SNAP eligible.

@heronimousbrapson863 5 лет назад

Welfare programs in Canada and the US were designed for an earlier economic reality, and are totally unequipped to handle the modern reality: the disappearance of work due to outsourcing and technology. Especially technology.

@Verpal 5 лет назад

I don't think this video have addressed this issue very well..... on the issue of outsourcing, perhaps that's why some people say Trump's trade war with China is a necessary evil?

@Verpal 5 лет назад

@Chadwicked B Indeed, that's why it is a necessary evil instead of a trade policy that we should pursuits. If China Plays balls, start adhering to WTO rule and actually protect IP, yeah, sure, trade should continue. If China continue on its way, an iphone made by Vietnam won't be worse than an iphone made by China.

@killergoose7643 Год назад

Lowering inflation by bringing some actual material value back into the monetary system would do more to raise the quality of life across the board than expanding welfare.

@heronimousbrapson863 Год назад

@@killergoose7643 And how, pray tell, does one do that in a modern economy where wealth is increasingly based on speculation?

@kcain64 3 года назад

Thank you. You explained a lot of thing I always had questions about. Keep the video's coming.

@garybill7507 5 лет назад

Hence in monopoly, you get $200 every time you go around the board. Interesting. That $200 has helped me come back after disaster roll of the diceand win the game (monopoly).

@TheKrouton 4 года назад

$200 is nothing by the mid/late game when a single title can lose you hundreds of dollars.

@GY-bd9bo 4 года назад

@@TheKrouton just goes to show how you have to update welfare with inflation

@user-pw5wz9rd2u 4 года назад

@@GY-bd9bo might be the dumbest shit ive heard all week

@informationyes 4 года назад

@betatalk357 Its more likely they will land moire on your hotels and owe you even more but I guess you aint gonna lose anything at this point

@countchocula7985 4 года назад

Unfortunately life isn’t like monopoly. And even if it was, for you to win everyone else had to lose.

@Starcrash6984 5 лет назад

You don't necessarily get "$192 a month" from SNAP for being single. I personally get... drumroll please... $15 a month. $15. Which doesn't even pay for a week's groceries. It obviously scales, and not because I make so darn much.

@thatcrazykid1393 5 лет назад

It's hard to be in that grey area of being a "rich" poor man. You make enough to be out of abject poverty but also enough to get no help from anyone. Not from charity or the government.

@Starcrash6984 5 лет назад

@@thatcrazykid1393 I've had a home for about 3 months now, but before that I was homeless for years... all while employed. It's so weird that the government saw me as too wealthy to need financial help, but I didn't really have any bills to show them so they must have thought I was pocketing all my income. In reality, though, it's really really expensive to be homeless (especially with food, because you have to eat out when you can't cook anything). I certainly didn't feel like a "rich" poor man, but in the government's eyes I was.

@scottleft3672 5 лет назад

It is a sad thing when you are working poor, as they don't count the time you could have used for yourself to make ends meet, when out of work, i found i really was not "out of work" i just wasn't working at peak level....i still had to compensate.

@jamesmunafosr.1900 5 лет назад

Supernova please stop getting your food stamps if $180 of taxpayers money is scuffed at by ingrates. Obviously your total income is more than what's deserving of more snap money? Duh.

@laurierios5547 5 лет назад

Beans and rice 🍚 only cost $3!

@davidtaylorsr 5 лет назад

Just heard an interview with Andrew Yang, running for prez 2020. UBI is on his agenda, but he's calling it a "freedom dividend." He has some interesting ideas on how to pay for it. It's on the freakonomics podcast.

@vinniechan 5 лет назад

Freedom dividend is an ingenious way to packaging UBI in right wing jargon lol

@russellm2555 2 года назад

Should be called the Extortion Dividend

@garrycole9187 3 года назад

I find your videos so informative and unbiased even though a lot of people would disagree.

@chadcolomb4260 2 года назад

Just recently discovered your content. It’s AWSOME! So informative. Thanks!

@Zootycoonman223 5 лет назад

Uhhh.... you can definitely use EBT on candy and sugar. So long as there’s a nutrition label you can get it with EBT. Reference: know from a job I worked that accepted EBT where people regularly purchased chips, candy, soft drinks, energy drinks, and even water. It doesn’t cover stuff that’s made in house though like salads, sandwiches, and the ilk. The only requirement for EBT is that the store carries a certain variety of the base foods. So long as you carry a certain number of vegetable/fruit, grain, meat, and dairy products your store qualifies for EBT.

@wabisabi3343 5 лет назад

Yeah I thought that was weird that he claimed that. I'm curious where he got that idea. Also, I think the requirement has been simplified to include any business that sells food. I know basically every gas station in my town accepts EBT, except for the 2 we have that don't sell snacks.

@EvoBastard 5 лет назад

Perhaps the rules for what you can buy with SNAP vary in each state, but so long as it isn't hot, you can buy pre-cooked foods (such as rotisserie chicken and sausage, egg, and cheese biscuit, etc.) here in MS with it.

@Zootycoonman223 5 лет назад

G.R. Street: I think it’s the same in my state but we also can’t sell anything made-in-house. What I suspect is there are ways to dodge the laws in this case. At the store I was at there was a separate POS for EBT and you just put an amount in and ran the card and then rang out the sale on the main register, meaning if the company wasn’t honest they could sell anything they wanted on EBT because it’s not like the separate POS knew what was being sold, only the register knew. Obviously it’d be an auditing problem if the IRS or any other government body showed up but it’d be pretty easy to cook-the-books so that it looked like you were selling EBT-approved items.

@6fthighgetlifted 5 лет назад

in Jersey you can't buy anything hot. everything else goes I'm pretty sure. And then there's the program where you can only get certain predetermined things (snap maybe? - haven't finished the vid lol)

@tshred666 4 года назад

Zootycoonman223 in LA and PS I’ve seen people buy those precooked 7-11 pizzas and McDonald’s using EBT cards. He is right about the booze though. But on the flip side I’ve seen drug dealers take EBT cards as payment for drugs. It’s rare, seeing as how most would rather have cash in hand, but those selling meth and heroin are always in a rush to move their product and most of their customers are low income, so they take what they can get.

@tskmaster3837 5 лет назад

This video is a great example of why we don't have Moderates anymore. Reason and thoughtfulness? What are you, some sort of socialist? I was a 99er... I did not know there was a name for it... and I support all of these programs and more. Grew up part of this program, part of that one...So many acronyms, too many TBH. These days, I don't qualify for any of them... though just barely? I probably should look into it... but I'm glad to know they're there for those who do need them. Keep on passing the knowledge, maybe it'll even reach ears that need to hear it. Sorry, I'm many things but I'm far too pragmatic to be an optimist.

@suserman7775 5 лет назад

So you express no obvious limit as to when the government SHOULDN'T provide? More is always better, right? That's why you, and this video, don't qualify as "moderates".

@tskmaster3837 5 лет назад

@@suserman7775 I'm not a moderate, I myself am a socialist. My opening comment was a sarcastic take on why the "moderate" economic stance is dead. It's either "Yeah, Government intervention!" or "Government should stay out of where it doesn't belong... provided I get everything that's coming to me as defined by the Government." My own take is that only Government can solve Government sized problems and that certain things should not be run for profit. Example: The point of healthcare should be a healthy populace, not profit. This OBVIOUS stance makes me a socialist.

@suserman7775 5 лет назад

@@tskmaster3837 You mix intention with results. Capitalism yields higher technology and better results when its intention is PROFIT. Socialism reduces incentive for investment, risk, and work. Its result is equality of poverty.

@ZacMemesZ 5 лет назад

@@suserman7775 looks like the result of capitalism is having more empty homes in the US than homeless people

@mickeyg7219 5 лет назад

Late to the party here, but hardcore socialists (not social democrats or something like that) aren't exactly fans of welfare either - they saw it as a stopgap measure but not a solution, and said without other plans, it's not sustainable in the long-term. Instead, they're pushing to remove the reason to be on welfare in the first place by "owning the means of production." Basically all businesses should be run by everyone who work there rather than shareholders - every businesses are worker co-ops (and yes, this kind of business do exists in capitalistic societies, but socialists want to make it as the only type of business).

@kevinmahernz 5 лет назад

Thank you for another great video. Your argument for a universal benefit is the best one I've seen so far.

@ohsosmooth01 4 года назад

What I love about this channel, the segue into the sponsors.

@TheBigRedskull 5 лет назад

The complete moderate’s guide to the political spectrum

@trident1125 5 лет назад

that sounds like a fun one, especially now in these polarized times

@BIONICLECLAYPOKEMON 5 лет назад

I like it!

@lordleedom 5 лет назад

@Sean H. Antifarts--------Chill Dudes--------Natsees. *fixed

@Chiyenworkout 5 лет назад

Left is betabicth, right is alpha. That is moderate guide of political spectrum

@cupwave2 5 лет назад

I want to see this one haha :)

@pengwin_ 5 лет назад

That ad segway at the end, while funny, is ABSOLUTELY one of the best reasons to have UBI, now people could take time from work to skill up and become more advance and valuable members of society.

@namelessjamestaylor9482 5 лет назад

That ad transition was raw. I wasnt ready

@FrogLehane 5 лет назад

Actually my one grandma just removed her land line and the other one still has it in addition to the mobile. Video DEBUNKED!

@nadineo1983 5 лет назад

I have had lifeline and Obama phone. My mom has had both. You CAN'T have both at the same time. They run your information to make sure you don't. I'm sure some people fall through the cracks. But this is how it's supposed to be

@stephj9378 4 года назад

lol

@Serenity_yt 3 года назад

Almost everyone I know including myself has a landline...... thoroughly debunked (and yes I live in a rural region where mobile internet is a catastrophie and sometimes there is literally no signal at all not even for normal calls but still)

@septimas71 5 лет назад

I honestly cannot understand how you don't have more people watching your videos. They're well scripted AND well researched. I'm also very grateful for all the sources in the video description for further research or verification. Thank you for all the hard work!

@jayasuryangoral-maanyan3901 5 лет назад

There are some very poorly researched videos so many people are turned off from watching other videos unfortunately. It's why I'm not subbed

@thatoneguy7792 5 лет назад

He got stuff wrong

@inspired4more 5 лет назад

Actually, in some places you can use food stamps for prepared food, like for cold subs at Publix or Subway. I don't know if That's nationwide, but it's true in Florida. They have signs at the deli advertising "ebt approved". They just can't heat it up.

@rasmus7748 5 лет назад

i do actually think sandwiches etc. are allowed due to them being served cold.. xD

@tcornettomaha 4 года назад

Fountain drinks can be purchased if you don't put the straw in it. There was a woman in line very upset because she forgot and put the straw in and had to pay cash.

@jesseback3536 4 года назад

@@tcornettomaha You can definitely use EBT to buy cigarettes and alcohol. You just have to find a store that is crooked enough to do it. Usually these will be small "corner store" places and usually run by foriegners (at least in my area.) I know of two of them right now. Used to be three but one got busted for fraud and the owner got deported.

@goofiestgoober4648 4 года назад

In new Orleans you can buy any cold cut sandwich and you can buy candy with your food stamp card

@lukesolsbery8258 4 года назад

Full-on fast food usage in California... large signs in the windows at KFC “welcoming” EBT use. It is disappointing.

@eduardonava6284 4 года назад

You’re awesome man, this is one of my favorite pieces.

@_CinnamonKitty 5 лет назад

"...yOu DiSaBiLiTy..." Yes. I disability.

@Terestrasz 5 лет назад

"If you filled out FAFSA you likely received a Pell Grant" Unless you're me.... then you got $0.00.

@jonathanhauck1591 4 года назад

Most Veterans are denied as well due to their GI bill and if you used the post 911 I still have to work to keep my family afloat do to not recieving any benifits such as Base housing assistance like I do when im in school. So now im disabled fighting to keep my mill retirement and attempting to better my life while having to take jobs that worsen my injuries from the army this is all to make ends meet and it sucks but I do it because there is a light at the end and I have faith in myslef to move up.

@briancrawford8751 4 года назад

I didn't get any Pell Grant either. You had to be dirt poor to qualify when I applied to college in 1991, and it was only $2000 per semester anyway. I only qualified for subsidized Stafford loans, but only enough to pay for about half of the cost of attending the school I did. It was a private school, but hey, at least it was an Ivy. My parents weren't wealthy at all. They got a windfall inheritance at just the right time that allowed them to send me to college and my brother to a private secondary school.

@EagleVireo 4 года назад

For the first three years I didn’t get any Pell Grant money, but my last year of college I went to, since my brother also went to college, I received some Pell Grant money, guess the government thought I was considered poor after my brother went to college, and it didn’t really help because the bill was over $30,000 :(

@TacticalOtter2 4 года назад

That’s because you’re rich haha

@aryanbhuta3382 3 года назад

@Cherry The average in the US is 60K.

@katywinchester2459 5 лет назад

I've never thought about UBI this way and I really appreciated this new take! Thank you!

@Madkalibyr 4 года назад

I’m really enjoying this video and the context you provide is really helpful when it comes to correcting any previous incorrect notions I might’ve held. That said, I have been on snap myself, grew up in a quintessentially poor family, leaning towards trailer trash if you know what I mean. I would like to correct one thing, when it comes to the snap benefits, you can buy junk food, it’s not going off of the food pyramid. You can buy sodas, you can buy energy drinks, and in some stores, you can purchase cold Starbucks drinks/food if they have a Starbucks inside of the Safeway or Kroger store . You most definitely cannot purchase cigarettes or alcohol, though it is a fairly common practice amongst the least trustworthy people, to trade food stamp benefits for money. You can get food stamps as soon as you turn 18, just say your couch surfing or your parents kicked you out or what have you and you’ve got them. Say hey, I’ll give you 20 bucks in food stamps if you give me 15 bucks so I can go get some beers or whatever, it’s not uncommon. Is it widespread and rampant and worthy vitriol that it inspires some? No I don’t think so. Maybe I’m nitpicking I just wanted to bring that up because my experiences growing up and having used these services throughout my life, I know that there is some shady stuff going on. (I’m in Oregon btw)

@hc9372 4 года назад

Love this ! Would've been ever cooler if it was a 3+ part series!!

@rnavashen4635 5 лет назад

How many of you realised that part of the video is from Cities Skylines Best game 10/10 IGN

@leo2panzer643 5 лет назад

I Know at the moment i hear donoteats voich

@ryanthomson6756 5 лет назад

Dude, you are a legend....pretty sure I'd be failing my High School Social Studies class if I didn't find your channel Love from Scotland

@bruggeman672 4 года назад

FYI regarding the basic income project in Canada. It was in the 70s in Dauphine Manitoba i believe and lasted only 3 years. Since then it has seldom been readdressed. For a time a similar project was taking place here in Ontario but was ended prematurely by the incoming Conservative government as a means of cutting costs. Notably the same government covertly gave themselves raises and extra living expenses with the ppl of Ontario only finding out months after....

@thenoodledrop 3 года назад

I love how I’m just listening along only for Rizzo/donoteat01 to make a voice cameo 23 min in. What a nice surprise

@Islandswamp 5 лет назад

I'm a liberal and I support these programs, but I also understand why a lot of people dislike them. I have been working at a job in retail, waiting on people I KNOW are drug addicts who choose to avoid work at all costs (I live in a small town and actually know that's the truth, I'm not just guessing and judging). It's annoying to be slaving for a shitty paycheck and serving someone who seems lazy and ungrateful. What people don't see is the stories like my family. My mom was a single mom and welfare programs helped us survive while my mom went back to school and worked. Eventually we got back into the middle class. The reality is that many decent people fall on hard times. One more thing; I think we need to work on programs that educate and train people more. Throwing money at the problem isn't always the best. A goal of self sufficiency should be strived for, instead of the current welfare trap system we have now.

@reactedgnat9344 5 лет назад

This is what welfare should be, a method to get people back on their feet. It shouldn't be some redistribution scheme, otherwise you end up hurting very nearly everyone. The rich and middle class have less money, and the poor have money but they have no incentive to work or to work harder, which hurts themselves as well as everyone else.

@franciszekdo 5 лет назад

i dont really understand your point at the end, the majority of these programs are means-tested and a lot of contingent on being employed, in training or actively looking.

@tskmaster3837 5 лет назад

@@reactedgnat9344 "The rich and the middle class have less money" Sorry, explain please. I keep trying to picture that as a problem but "the rich get richer" and "the end of the middle class" headlines keep getting in the way. Is there such a thing as "living wage" in your mind or that people can work for hours and hours a week in multiple jobs and still not be paid enough to live? "The poor have no incentive to work" Is that a code for something? Because I feels it has to tie in somewhere with people who live "paycheck from paycheck". It's a carrot and stick method where they dangle a carrot but hit you with the stick... do I have do spell out who "they" are?

@janramos3050 5 лет назад

Tskmaster elaborate further

@tskmaster3837 5 лет назад

@@janramos3050 There's very little Middle Class left or so I've heard; I'd consider them to be the savings class... not people who are giving a huge sum of money and just live off the interest, these aren't those people... and as savings are at an all time low, there's more to the "end of the Middle Class" then just a headline. There's too much concentrated wealth for capitalism to work; What is their incentive to make more money if they already have that much of it? Greed, are we supposed to rely on the Goodwill of Greed? No, ignore the super-rich and ignore super-corporations and focus on the small businessman, there's where the Conservatives love to say where the action is, where the focus is... where the votes are, honestly as corporations can't vote YET. I don't see them as villain or victim, just caught in an unfortunate situation of extremes but they just happen to vote with people who want the same things, just for more nefarious reasons. Wait, aren't they being used as hostages? "Vote for no minimum wage increases and low taxes or the small businessman gets it!" "What about the large corporations who employ far more people?" "Pay them no heed, they're just trying to make a buck, same as everyone else! There just HAPPENS to be more of them." My own thinking is, argue with if you like: Don't rely on Capitalism to make life better, rely on it to make money. Take PART of that money and do something positive with it towards improving society. "That's what charities are for!" No, that's just another form of tax havens, if you want to call it a redistribution of wealth rather than simple taxation, so be it. Just do it. I fully support the idea of a living wage and whatever means exist to bring it about. Take money from places where there are too many zeroes and bring it to places where there are only zeroes. Don't worry, it'll end up back there in no time because that's how money moves. "But they'll just have to do it again, year after year." or "What if it goes to people who'll waste it?" or "What if it goes to people who don't need it?" 1 Yes. 2 There's no such thing as waste spending, only waste saving 3 Then they don't need it but they have it anyway? If it's the right amount all around, it shouldn't matter in any case.

@Wysiwyg43 5 лет назад

Knowing Better and Donoteat01 is better than I deserve in 2019 . . . but I'll gladly take it! PEACE

@HAMID___ 5 лет назад

By far my favorite video of yours. Keep up the good work

@DiamondDogVenomSnake1984 2 года назад

Oh hey donoteat hell yeah, did not expect you but delighted to hear your voice

@Starbrahan72 5 лет назад

So glad you’re back and this is the topic you uploaded about, and yes, I would like to know more

@w.h.johnson404 5 лет назад

Love your videos! Always a treat when I see a new one!

@cookies23z 2 месяца назад

wooooow, going back to videos ive missed, hearing donoteat threw me for a loop

@Horesmi 4 года назад

25:25 #yanggang noises

@TheOriginalduMan 5 лет назад

Now *that* was a slick Skillshare pivot. (Also a great video, as usual.)

@erynlasgalen1949 5 лет назад

Um, when you have a Section 8 house in your neighborhood you generally know it.

@toadstooltadd3843 4 года назад

I’m in one of those “find someone and binge all the videos you’ve already seen” kicks. I’ve watched like half your old videos in the last week

@thygrrr Год назад

Thank you for your service. As in, thanks for your fantastic and educational RU-vid content! Gives me hope that I'm not the only ex military who really ended up with a critical and analytical world view, and learning more than a little towards what people call the left.

@MatthewTheWanderer 5 лет назад

As someone who receives SNAP, you most certainly CAN buy candy with it. Also, in my shitty state (Oklahoma), EVERYTHING has Sales Tax applied to it, including all food, no exceptions. However, sales tax is removed when you use SNAP.

@SplotPublishing 2 года назад

LOL Underwater basketweaving is everyone's favorite "worthless" skill people love to pick on. But in reality, it's not only a real, and very difficult skill, it's not at all what most people think it is. It's not scuba diving while weaving a basket. It's a process of weaving done in a tub or body of water. You wet the material so that when it dries, it's extremely tight, watertight, and can keep the contents inside remarkably well. Such baskets are extremely useful, and if you are one of the very very few who still possess this skill, you can charge a lot for those baskets. It's a real way to earn a living, actually. Now, stop using it as a punchline.

@MatthewMcVeagh 4 года назад

Excellent video. Researched, in depth yet concise, sprinkled with humour.

@Rpglover456 4 года назад

Your transitions to the ad are amazing. 😂

@annajane8890 5 лет назад

lol, I kind of love how you can never see your sponsors coming.

@InstigationFixation 4 года назад

“Commercial’s over” *starts a commercial*

@GrimmSpector 5 лет назад

I love seeing your ferrets play at the end of this video, reminds me of my own, they're just fantastic pets.

@joshjohnson2844 4 года назад

You broadened my thoughts. Thanks. Not sure I agree on several points but stuff to consider.

@SkeledroMan 5 лет назад

4:15 Ring ring ring ring ring ring ring, obamaphone

@Tahoza 5 лет назад

BOOP BOOP BUD DOOP *uhm...* BI DOOP!

@DAAraiz 5 лет назад

SkeledroMan i hate you, I’m at work and I had to suppress laughter with such difficulty when I read this I got a headache, this is too freakin hilarious.

@nickdahl203 5 лет назад

I like Obamas, because they have no bones.

@DIsmayedConfuse 5 лет назад

Telecommunications Act of 1934, dipshit. Updated to cover cell phones while Bush was president.

@chrismofer 5 лет назад

am i the only one that sees this joke's racism?

@bvsement1217 4 года назад

Love the cities skylines gameplay footage half way through. The game nearly looks realistic to someone unfamiliar with it. 😊

@angela8188 5 месяцев назад

Tanf = pronounced like tariff but with an n. This is ANOTHER GREAT VIDEO. LOVE your work. Outstanding, thought-provoking, and in places, side-splitting!

@MrAlexanderTheG8 5 лет назад

Ha, now I know where Andrew Yang got the 12,000 figure from. Knowing Better might like Andrew Yang's plans for America then!

@felixbeutin9530 3 года назад

he supported Bernie

@ericjohansen7505 5 лет назад

Great video. Thanks for making this. Would you consider making a video about a government shutdown? I'm a federal employee and feeling the pain of working and not getting paid right now, but I know there is a lot of confusion about shutdowns and what they mean. Also, how the USG funds things (appropriations). Thanks for the great work!