Western denial today ‘far more sinister, outraging’ than during Nakba: Ilan Pappe

Подписаться 14 млн

Просмотров 32 тыс.

50% 1

Ilan Pappe, the author of The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine, joins Al Jazeera's live and highlights the enabling role of Western countries in Israel’s war on Gaza, describing it as “even worse” than their stance during the Nakba. He explains that in 1948, the lack of television and smartphones made it easier to cover up the ethnic cleansing, but today, with the events displayed on screens, denial is far more sinister and outrageous.
Subscribe to our channel: bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#Palestine #Gaza #Israel #GazaHumanitarianCrisis #GazaWar #IsraelHamasWar #IsraelGazaWar #Nakba #Nakba76 #GazaGenocide #WestBank #NorthernGaza #SouthernGaza #NuseiratAttack #GazaDestruction #GazaUnderAttack #IsraelWar #Rafah #GazaBombardment #GazaRefugeeCamps #Jabalia #GazaCity #DeirElBalah

Опубликовано:

11 июн 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 229

@AbidAli-bv2gl 27 дней назад

Ilan Pappe knowledgable Jewish scholar

@andrew_owens7680 26 дней назад

I pray he isn't killed for telling the truth. Peaceful protesters are getting hospitalized. Pappe already can't live in Israel. If things keep going in this direction he won't be safe in America either.

@karwanraza7047 27 дней назад

Ilan Pappe a great, honest and brave scholor.

@andrew_owens7680 26 дней назад

Emphasis on brave.

@roxannamarinak3156 27 дней назад

Thank you Soooo Much Ilan Pappe You are a wonderful humanitarian! Many Blessings your way❤️

@mariahewitt9787 25 дней назад

Stephen Kapos, 87 year old Holocaust Survivor, is another very honourable gentleman who speaks the truth...

@thundercatt5265 27 дней назад

More like western enablers than denial....as I was saying earlier Palestine reminds me of what was done to the Native American. I'm glad the students have woke up to what's going on

@Colleen222 27 дней назад

Indigenous Peoples the world over- Suffering human atrocities for Western Oligarchs and Western Hegemony!

@JP..5-. 26 дней назад

So brave, so virtuous!! You two should move to the middle east or Africa and make a difference!! Stay strong sisters!

@andrew_owens7680 26 дней назад

Ze'ev Jabotinsky compared the Zionists to the Puritans in his 1923 essay "The Iron Wall". He makes clear that this is an ethnic cleansing project and that the Arabs won't be pleased to be forced from their homes. My whole life I was brainwashed to accept this horror.

@dsm7014 26 дней назад

@@JP..5-.Make an case as to why their convictions are irrational or misguided, this isn't an argument. If we were having a debate on the subject of abortion (I assume intuitively you are anti-abortion though I could of course be incorrect), do you think me making a point of your failure to kill abortion doctors or women who sought them ought a fair and reasonable response to the question of the ethics of abortion.?

@estellewarren62 26 дней назад

Thank you! Such encouraging words ! Free palestine @@JP..5-.

@attilanagy4993 27 дней назад

"The aim has always been, and it still remains, to have as much of Palestine as possible with as few Palestinians in it as possible." Ilan Pappé

@loo6837 27 дней назад

The Nakba, too, has been downplayed and misrepresented, time and again, in the mainstream media across the world. And beyond that, it is in fact the official policy of the state of Israel to systemically and consistently deny Palestinian suffering. In fact, the whole Israeli settler colony is built on the denial of the very existence of a Palestinian people, let alone their Nakba.

@srsmopar3808 27 дней назад

LOL, the 'Palestinian' official policy is systemically and consistently deny they want a second 'final solution'.

@sunny_zeddy_cy 27 дней назад

wise courageous voice

@haifatirawi1563 27 дней назад

My father and mother told about the brutality of the zionists. We lived our lives hoping to go back and see our home land so far we never could while it's two hours drive away. Free Palestine 🇵🇸

@jarbasfranciscopintopinto5939 22 дня назад

Mentiram pra vc . Terra é de Israel otario

@fightback397 6 дней назад

Keep faith , you will see your land FREE ❤

@ananda111 27 дней назад

Great Ilan Pappé, thank you, Sr.!

@Robert-qh3ok 27 дней назад

Mr. Pappe you are my hero...continue your incredible scholarship...

@MyPlantsAgainstTheWorld 26 дней назад

Man, how I adore minds like Ilan Pappe and Noam Chomsky

@az-rule84 27 дней назад

I read the ethnic cleansing of palestine by ilan pape. Its a great book to read

@frazel22 26 дней назад

What an Intellectual Giant !

@Littlehorn210 27 дней назад

If you can’t do it without america then you shouldn’t do it at all. Go Fund yourselves

@drumultabereim5 27 дней назад

Palestine can't feed themselves without Europe, stop having 10 children

@kjw6383 27 дней назад

Today I saw a long commercial for the federation of christians and jews asking for $45 for food boxes for war displaced israelis. Now if they are really hungry, why are they taking a bus ride to catch up with food trucks taking food to Gazans? The squatters portrayed as being under bombardment in the commercial, destroyed truckloads of food and burned trucks. So are they in need of food? Or does their government stage these performances?

@estellewarren62 26 дней назад

@@kjw6383omg where did you see that

@fightback397 6 дней назад

@@kjw6383 They are greedy , using every opportunity to make a buck

@Robert_Bob_Bobrob 27 дней назад

Free Palestine!

@myfatherschild5820 27 дней назад

Too heartbreaking, I love you AJ and Palestinians!❤💚🖤🤍❤

@nevertoolate6653 27 дней назад

Thanks Ilan of ur great contribution Some books and articles written by some distinguished Israelis Jews and West Historians of the tragic Palestine 1. The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine by Ilan Pappe 2. The General’s son : Journey of an Israel in Palestine by Miko Peled 3. On Palestine by Noam Chomsky, Ilan Pappe, Frank Barat 4. Tantura documentary 5. Belfour declaration 6. Norman Finkelstein 7. Dr Gabor mate 8. Sheikh Jarrah 9. Abby Martin

@mariahewitt9787 27 дней назад

And the Palestine Laboratory by Antony Lowenstein is very informative...

@karimb972 25 дней назад

The 100 years war on Palestine by Rashid khalidi

@coleengoodell7523 27 дней назад

🙏

@ungratefulninja4535 27 дней назад

Currently reading Ilhan Pappe's book 'The Biggest Prison on Earth'

@GladiatorDravenADC 27 дней назад

Pakistan 🇵🇰 support Palestine 🇵🇸 India 🇮🇳 support Israel 🇮🇱 Salute 🫡 to all supporters of Palestine 🇵🇸 Free Palestine 🇵🇸 🇵🇰🤝🏼🇵🇸🤜🏼🇮🇱🇮🇳

@CallThemAllOut 27 дней назад

You mean the biggest open air toilet in the world

@user-bh6ox7oz2i 27 дней назад

@@CallThemAllOutYou mean gaza😂😂😂😂

@yashmin786 27 дней назад

This Indian supports Palestine.... Pakistan doesn't fo enough for Palestine, they don't protest and Eat KFC and McDonald's....Pakistan does nothing for Gaza

@user-sn2ng3wj5t 27 дней назад

0000 o00⁰⁰@@CallThemAllOut

@xs3282 26 дней назад

@@user-bh6ox7oz2i why are you being a knobjockey

@zarinakhokhar9423 27 дней назад

Legend... 🤲🏼🤲🏼🤲🏼Many Blessings... InshaAllah a Free Palestine for all. 🤲🏼

@user-ic8if7pw4p 27 дней назад

When the "doors" of Gaza will open, people among whom those "denial" journalists, will be so stuned and horrified to discover the horror of that disaster that they will remain traumatised for a long time

@nurulnadiahazmi1156 13 дней назад

Yes. Exactly.

@The-Man-Right-Chea 27 дней назад

😮😮😢Can someone please explain to me again why no European nation including the US wanted these people in their country before during and after WWII????? What did they know that we are now finding out???? 🤔

@xs3282 26 дней назад

Exactly… maybe look at the Bolshevik Revolution a Zionist idea that led to the starvation and genocide of over 120,000,000 human beings, yes Zionist did that….Wake up World

@hichampensif1987 26 дней назад

They wanted to establish a western entity to control the Suez canal and exploit the entire Middle East and finally to get rid of Jews.

@huckleberryharrison6248 27 дней назад

It is astonishing to see something that will be remembered as truly damning unfold.

@johndoe-zz1nr 27 дней назад

Palestinian resilience is admirable and with all the hardships that they are going through you don’t see them angry

@efi13efi 26 дней назад

Yes! They are sticking to terrorism no matter what 😂

@oldjack-mi8gk 27 дней назад

Because the Harlot is now riding the Beast

@yashmin786 27 дней назад

Love Ilan Pappe

@TahmKench4life 27 дней назад

🇵🇸🤜🏼🇮🇱🇺🇸🇬🇧🇮🇳🇯🇵🇹🇼🇦🇺🇵🇭🇺🇦

@thebesttruth4659 27 дней назад

Pakistan stop killed innocent pok Muslim Kashmiri family😔 May Allah protect innocent Muslim family😔 in Kashmir pok

@user-iv7ju3oi2d 27 дней назад

chosen ones, are the evil ones

@user-wc5fi8bt2z 22 дня назад

I agree with mr pappe he’s so honest. Abut the facts that took place

@xs3282 26 дней назад

Forget to mention unarmed Palestinians

@user-fr2fo3wm2i 27 дней назад

No wonder god never granted land for them..

@alexisf22 27 дней назад

Read the Bible revelation 2:9 they aren’t God true chosen people

@myrtillesm3532 27 дней назад

They learned form their previpus oppressor

@abdishariff5967 27 дней назад

Somalia 🇸🇴 stands with Palestine.

@gentianmihaj4957 27 дней назад

Free Palestine from Albania

@thebesttruth4659 27 дней назад

Pakistan stop killed innocent pok Muslim Kashmiri family😔 May Allah protect innocent Muslim family😔😔in Kashmir pok😔

@aftonair 27 дней назад

Hasbara is very active in the comment section today.

@kidd7359 26 дней назад

It looks to me that each Israeli generation commits a "nakba".

@adamtx1131 27 дней назад

The Resistance is active and very powerful

@johnsmith7140 27 дней назад

Lol

@LamarPassmore 27 дней назад

How is the plan for a greater Israel different from that of As Sufyani?

@andrew_owens7680 26 дней назад

60 is the same size as one of the most remembered massacres of Jews, the 1929 Hebron Massacre. There are 3 Hebron Massacres per day now in Gaza.

@loo6837 27 дней назад

Israel didn't win anything, the resistance has never been so powerful

@RickMartin-vk8vl 27 дней назад

💀☠💀☠💀☠💀☠💀☠💀☠💀☠💀☠💀☠💀☠💀☠☠💀☠💀☠💀☠💀☠💀☠💀

@rickymartin875 27 дней назад

@srsmopar3808 27 дней назад

Soon they will might win a large stretch of wasteland.

@drumultabereim5 27 дней назад

Hahahaha ok

@johnsmith7140 27 дней назад

😂😂😂

@thebesttruth4659 27 дней назад

Pakistan stop killed innocent pok Muslim Kashmiri family😔 May Allah protect innocent Muslim family😔😔in Kashmir pok😔

@marielambert7441 27 дней назад

Are they more protected in India?

@thebesttruth4659 26 дней назад

@@marielambert7441 May Allah protect innocent Muslim brother sister😔 in Pakistan Pakistan stop kidnapped and killed innocent family😔

@bliss448 27 дней назад

I demand justice for Palestine!

@johnsmith7140 27 дней назад

Israel is administering justice as we type

@mariahewitt9787 27 дней назад

@@johnsmith7140 Revelation 2:9 and 3:9... Judgement Day is Coming...

@dassa0069 27 дней назад

Since Deir Yassin April 9 1948

@rdx823 27 дней назад

Justice for Aisha..she was only 6...

@love_579 27 дней назад

May God guide you before your last breath

@rickymartin875 27 дней назад

@@love_579

@mdamirulislam7653 27 дней назад

Ayesha did not have any objection about the marriage. Marriage is valid in Islam. But the people who hate marriage and born without marriage(bustard) only put an objection on marriage of people.

@mariahewitt9787 27 дней назад

Read the Jewish Talmud.

@rickymartin875 26 дней назад

@@mariahewitt9787 The Talmud is bs.

@mookiewilson4166 27 дней назад

What a joke.

@Nk_shorts777 27 дней назад

Free free Palestine🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

@Jon-cb9dt 27 дней назад

What’s said is the mis translation of the chosen people, it was not a group of individuals of one faith, it was when god called his chosen people no one religion.

@TahmKench4life 27 дней назад

🇵🇰🇹🇷🇵🇸🤜🏼🇮🇱🇫🇷🇮🇳

@thebesttruth4659 27 дней назад

Pakistan stop killed innocent pok Muslim Kashmiri family😔 May Allah protect innocent Muslim family😔 in Kashmir pok

@Western-imperalism 27 дней назад

Glory to the westerners who participated in the nakba , thank you for your humanity ❤❤

@aftonair 27 дней назад

That is actual hate speech. Do you really think of yourself as a decent person?

@GladiatorDravenADC 27 дней назад

💩🕉️💩🛕💩

@GladiatorDravenADC 27 дней назад

🏳️‍🌈🕉️🏳️‍🌈🛕🏳️‍🌈

@rdx823 27 дней назад

☪️ancer.....Aisha was only 6 when momad was 53...shame on Mohammad....

@rdx823 27 дней назад

💩☪️💩🐷🐖🇵🇰💩🏳️‍🌈

@rdx823 27 дней назад

🏳️‍🌈☪️💩🏳️‍🌈💩🇵🇰💩🐷🐖

27 дней назад

If someone starts an explanation about apples by claiming that apples are oranges, is there any point in listening to the rest of the explanation? Ilan Pappe is an academic joke, everything he says is nonsense.

@timcastle1844 27 дней назад

Not at all. Your qualifications are? Or, most likely, you are an Israeli troll.

@attilanagy4993 27 дней назад

"Ilan Pappe is an academic joke" Why?

@timcastle1844 26 дней назад

@@attilanagy4993 Because this nobody doesn't agree with him or history or facts, Just believes his Zionist masters. Pathetic he is!

@Hlth-cn4fh 27 дней назад

You were told. Now you weep. There will be no ceasefire, Israel has spoken. Your obedience is mandatory. Bless you.

@jonathanchester5916 27 дней назад

Thank you Darth Maul.

@johnsmith7140 27 дней назад

@@jonathanchester5916lol

@user-oi6zd3lq6e 27 дней назад

Pappe just a little court zhid a revisionist historian .

@user-ck1of4ex4d 27 дней назад

I see the numbers have come down.......

@oliveoil5789 27 дней назад

Wrong

@CallThemAllOut 27 дней назад

Yes 600,000 in 2nd ww

@CallThemAllOut 27 дней назад

According to Benjamin H Freedman 1961 speach

@user-ck1of4ex4d 27 дней назад

@@oliveoil5789 well then take that up with the UN because they debunked the Hamas numbers by 59%

@NicolasHaufe 27 дней назад

Dont start wars you cant win 🤷

@MichaelSmith-ph5oe 27 дней назад

You might take your own advice to heart, if the U S doesn't bail them out they will be toast!

@NicolasHaufe 27 дней назад

@@MichaelSmith-ph5oe 6 days war left the chat

@samehalaa1348 27 дней назад

@@NicolasHaufe Did you think all these weapons that have been used since they were shipped to Palestine in 1948 was theirs in the first place? UK and the U.S have been sending them weapons and 100s of billions of dollars. Without all the support from the West they would have been toast against literally a weakened Arab states. Consider yourself lucky that you have support of the West and still ain't going to live in peace for eternity as long as the Middle Eastern countries exist around them which they will always exist (lets see how the Israeli tourism is going to continue, their own citizens are moving to the U.S and Canada) 😆

@MichaelSmith-ph5oe 27 дней назад

@@NicolasHaufe Do you speak English?

@NicolasHaufe 27 дней назад

@@MichaelSmith-ph5oe yes i can why are you asking?

@ntme9 27 дней назад

Gazans should stop aiding and abetting Hamas

@dickschlau3592 27 дней назад

zios should stop aiding IOF.

@youngeagle5953 27 дней назад

Zios should go home, to EU

@Hlth-cn4fh 27 дней назад

@@dickschlau3592 Plot twist: Israel stays and a new sheriff has moved in. Not like the old, nothing like the old. Enjoy. Israel has spoken.

@Hlth-cn4fh 27 дней назад

@@youngeagle5953 Plot twist: Israel stays and a new sheriff has moved in. Not like the old, nothing like the old. Enjoy. Israel has spoken.

@Retalak 27 дней назад

Maybe if the hateful and ethnonationalist ideology of Zionism did not exist, resistance forces would also not exist.

@Hlth-cn4fh 27 дней назад

I told you lesser thans 7 months ago you messed with the wrong PM. You messed with the wrong PM. Israel has spoken.

@bonbonz3011 27 дней назад

Please support Israel 🇮🇱💋

@shasha14779 27 дней назад

1948 what Israel doing There crimes against Palestine people . shame on you . steal people land . . justice for Palestine. . . Israel is nothing without united states support with weapons bom warplanes helicopter anything

@MichaelSmith-ph5oe 27 дней назад

Stockholm syndrome?

@johnsmith7140 27 дней назад

@@shasha14779👈🤡

@timcastle1844 27 дней назад

Only if you have absolutely no morality.

@jh5174 27 дней назад

I don't get it, weren't Arabs also offered statehood so very long ago, but the majority Arabs refused, while Israel aceepted and created a productive society, a highly rated group of people of more than Hebrews and including Arabs that contributed favorably to Israel over the years. 🕊️🌱

@christopherwall2121 27 дней назад

They were "offered" a pittance of land that they were all being shoved onto anyways. Much like the Reservation System was to Native Americans, those proposals were meant to shove a broken people onto poor-quality land while the colonizers took all the arable land for themselves.

@stopdeforestation 27 дней назад

Stop spamming the "subscribe to al Jazeera" at the end of every video. Every time i see it, i thumbs down the video. You are supposed to be concerned with the environment. Tacking that at the end of every video takes up gigabytes online, & uses more electricity per user. U r hurting the planet with that useless waste. Correct your green footprint & stop it. Everyone's intelligent enough to know how to subscribe. Stop talking to us like we are in kindergarten.