She was 31 , finally her struggles were going to pay off , finally she was going to have a 'career' of her own as doctor , she was living her dream which she saw in her teenage years , her dream to work in a hospital in a white coat .... She never knew that in the same hospital wearing the white coat shell breath her breaths in intense pain , seeing her whole dreams shattered on that one night .. in the same 'White Coat'🌸
Your words make me cry !! A dream of every NEET aspirants that one day we will serve people with wearing that White Coat and Stethoscope, denying the fact that what if it happens to us too !!
As per some reports the main culprit is some jr and intern who belong to powerful background.... I am just crying to think about the victim...a proud doctor... And her brave parents....
What hurt me most is that she was working till 2am and when the patient load was less at that time, she went into the seminar with her books as her only belongings. She was still planning to study even when she was supposed to rest while waiting for emergency calls in the middle of the late night. She only had the determination to push herself to become a great doctor and how would she know some animal would simply destroy her
And Thannkkk goddd for the press media and all their protests!! Incidents like this need to be addressed at a mass level in India for getting the necessary justice!!
Not only she was murdered, she was brutally raped ,with pelvis ,chest bone ,hand ,fingers bone fracture ,blood gushing out from both her eyes ,mouth ,private parts multiple bruises,contusions over her body ,.., Similar trauma hitting me like the" NIRBHAYA " incident . This is how people treat there so called "2nd GOD ".😖
That’s because investigation is still going on. Reporting at this state of the incident will only spread rumours. That’s why no news channel is explaining anything.
Being a woman in India is so dangerous that I can't even begin to fathom. We live in this country, work for this country, pay taxes yet we can't step out at night, have to think twice before wearing any attire and are subjected to chauvinistic behaviours. This ideology of Alpha male is so ingrained in the Indian blood that they can't hear a woman raise her voice towards injustice. The female doctor is a sign of pride for all the women in the country. She came so far, gave her all to save people and yet she was subjected to the most inhuman crime ever. I have shed tears just reading about the brutalities she went through. May her soul rest in peace 🙏 We will not stop talking about this until she gets justice. We women, cannot & will not let this go.
This doctor was raped and brutally murdered was made an example to anyone else who was the whistleblower of a huge trafficking ring. Government officials are also involved, the man currently accused is a scapegoat as 150g of semen was found in her which is equal to around 15 men. There are people on x who are also pressured to keep quiet, her family too is threatened.
i am a doctor from NRS medical college in Kolkata. sanjay roy is a scapegoat. The real criminalS are roaming free. highly influential people are involved.
@@mhs1985yes , it is true...politicians and their sons are involved...some of them are even interns too...but government can go an extra mile to protect the criminals...The civic volunteer has just been used in the case...Even government is trying to demolish some of the walls of seminar room just to destroy the proofs in the name of construction...
but we don't know yet if they are the real murderer. they might be just an eyewash to save the real ones for some reason (most probably political). Let's hope for full truthfulness and justice.
This channel is known to jump into conclusion when the accused is not from a peaceful religion.. When the accused is from so called peaceful community they don't even disclose his name or image . Even when the accused is proved in court this channel tries to hide his name and sometimes they don't even talk about the incident 😂😂😂. This time as the accused is a Hindu they are happily jumping to conclusion ... Whatever, a murderer is a murderer whichever religion he belongs to ...
Don't try to jump on conclusion so soon it's not possible that only one person is involved in it. And first the police have also tried to hide case as a suicide
After Incident, 1. Victim Died 2. Media Got Content 3. Family in tears 4. Protesters on the road 5. People Posting for justice 6. Victim got justice after many years. And we can't say this type of incident will not repeat again because the system and people's mind set never gonna change. It's bitter but it's truth.
@@adilmk128 means it's just two people who rped he There are more people who harrased her in her workplace and planned this incident And obviously principal involved Because he tried saying that she committed suicide
Its not only abt doctors, its about entire female population of this country. Woman raise familes, work homes, raise children, give birth to kids, all woman are equally important and respected
Her dad found her naked, lying motionless on the floor with a broken pelvic girdle, disfigured limbs and shattered pieces of glasses in her eyes, bleeding incessantly. Her plight in those final minutes is unimaginable. Her parents were denied any contact with her dead body for 3 hours after they reached the crime scene. 15 mg of semen was found in her body, one man can only have 1 to 5 mg. A scapegoat is in custody. Dean said she was psychotic. After the transfer to CBI, renovation work started in the hospital. At this point it's not just a doctor issue anymore, it's just inhumane. We keep unlocking lower levels of inhumanity year after year. Fools were those, who even hoped there would be reforms after the Nirbhaya case. It's been 12 years. Nothing has changed. Saw some Instagram stories saying that it's a crime to be a doctor in this country. It's not a crime to be a doctor in this country, IT'S A CRIME TO HOPE IN THIS COUNTRY.
@@AamirKhan-bh7bw You said the truth brother. If Muslim were somehow connected in this rape case, then everyone would have seen how the indian's would have behaved. Asifa banu has not yet received justice. Because that doctor was human but Asifa was just Muslim for them.
Exactly i think someone other is also involved in this becoz she had 11 different injuries frm neck to hip then spine etc so it is nearly impossible just one guy to do it I don't I saw many comments somewhere in insta as there was 4 or something different semen etc idk my gut feeling is saying me somone who is senior intern or any other student is also involved in this he or they may be high influence people becoz police tired to burn her body without her parents concern they even made all the arrangements for it
In this video, many important informations are missing.⬇️ 1.She was brutally murdered and raped. When her parents were informed about this, the administration told them that she committed suicide. Which is a complete lie! 2. One of her neighbours who came to see her, she stated that when her father saw her for the first time, she was completely naked and her legs were torn and broken in right angle (90°). Just imagine, how much brutality she went through before dying! This is also available in some news channels. 3.Sanjoy is just a scapegoat. Someone very powerful is behind all this. 4. In local Bengali news channels, they showed that there are chances that the victim came to know about some serious crimes which had been happening in R G Kar Medical College. Therefore, it was a planned murder! 5. Renovation work was started to erase proof as suspected. 6. Last night (14th August), groups of attackers went into the college and destroyed the placed and left it in ruins. All of these are authentic facts. As a person who lives in West Bengal, I am seeing theses informations through local Bengali news channels. As a dutiful citizen if you really want justice for her sacrifice, please read this annd spread this as much as you can. We want justice and we will not stop until we get it✊🏻.
Solution for this all rape incidents is. Thinking of about the answer for the question "" Who is her silence encouraging ?!"" knowingly or unknowingly by the person in society. the answer is soo deep of course to think how we r responsible , but it's we who are responsible who forgets our "" duty"". And so the answer to above Question mentioned is it's us ( society) who keep silence Example:- abusive words about girls in friends as they are making fun out of it, making abusive words on private parts making fun of it, irrespective words referring to like m***chod etc to mother (this leads to degradation of showing respect to women out there by that rascal, one should stop and hit on mouth when girls topic came in bad way) , No person should make comment or make bad words to qirls who are outsmarting and exposing through social media. Just leave them instead comment it's bad and don't support for them to get likes or views by that... So they can change ( treat them as our family members though) And stop watching and supporting to 18+ memes out there report them, etc etc,,. So people can't get effected by knowing such in descent words or things. 2) society should be responsible at Watching out in the public places as women work out there has to be monitored by a person through CC tv( he/she who has this as there duty should work properly, that's it🤷♂️) ,as we see in Kolkata case if she has been monitored AS THEIR DUTY. It might couldn't happen😢. 3) ********important point:- teach the education u bloody society 🤬 not the commercial education but our history of like Mahabharata, ramayana etc irrespective of any religion etc... Referring to their own holy books learn good things, discipline, FEAR TO GOD as well as love and faith, love to nature, beings, animals, ... Say his/ her ultimate goal.., . As a being on this earth, respect towards girls, Not only for children of ur family for next generation but also organisational adoption and teaching to people out public who lost out of control and doin bad things who got into your eyes should also have to change, and we have to love them and change them equally by giving awareness, teaching, any possible way... SAY THEM ABOUT THE BAD TOUCH TOO, NOT ONLY FOR GIRLS.... * Say them to find goddess DURGA in every women and try to change them if they are bad and not to blame on that... So they can understand how to be out of this western culture or maybe anything. 4) drugs , alcohols, all which give that type of pleasure giving things which makes them got out of control and behave like an animal should be abandoned at time of using around u, people should make them caught and surrender them to police and police and govt. Should work strict🤬 to stop this drugs mafia to utmost point that making the drugs to enter into india is a great risky thing( And i am waiting for such india) Coming to alcohol i don't know what to say ... Okay let it be drink , but main thing the people around should monitor his actions,... Protests of candle march which is little worth but happens seriously after any rape and calms down after some time and no justice happen But none of the group or organization concentrate to stop the root causes of this giving birth to this bad people, Protest started to say no to drugs are started by someone, but no organization or govt. Take action because, protest is actually small, no public showing interest and saying kya faidaa hai... Hai bhaii, hai ,protest should be happen same big as a candle march and drug shouldn't come to India through any border. Gateways through borders should be high checking , strict. Etc.. So we can see good india🤷♂️ 5) there are people who r like pests like Sanjay roy who have psychotic nature and lusty thinking towards girls and ready even to die after doin such bad things, and like this people it's better we kill them after if any incident happens like this, as it happens out of our hands or catch him and surrender to police or society as we get to know it's seems to happen something bad if we leave such a person in society, That type of feeling and duty should be happen and got realized in society so and happen so we can stop such things. 6) Respect each and every girl, i can't say how to respect. There are many ways that whether you r showing respect or disrespecting , u🫵 have know it. I can't mention it everything, just learn, be a guardian to any girl around u, so that she can feel safe. 7) women should carry pepper spray, should be physically and mentally strong💪, like a pailwaan Women are like durga. Animal who came onto u should be shattered... Maybe there is a situation when women got freezed by the vulgar situation by that rascal, at the time society observing there should question him and should be published despite his whatsoever background he has... She has to be guarded... That's it., let's hope for an independent ( freedom for women) india.... 🥲 Jai Hind ✊ ALL I WANT IS, I WANT YOU ALL TO READ THIS POINTS IN COMMENT AND PIN THIS COMMENT SO THAT ALL MEMBERS SHOULD READ AND UNDERSTAND AND MAKE THEM SOCIETY UNDERSTAND AROUND THEM. ALL ARE COMMENTING ON THE VIDEOS JUSTICE, JUSTICE, KYAA FAIDAA HAI REY BHAII, LET'S SPIT OUT SOLUTIONS.... CONTRIBUTE URSELF... SPEAK OUT SOLUTIONS 🫵
#UPDATE: When the Principal of RG Kar Hospital Dr. Sandip Ghosh resigned from his post, within 4 hours he was reappointed by the state as principal of National Medical College Kolkata. The Calcutta High Court in its hearing yesterday expressed 'shock' that how a person can be rewarded with a post after such an incident and ordered an investigation on it. Hearing this Dr. Ghosh applied for 15 days leave. The court has further ordered that while the case is in motion, Dr. Ghosh can not be given any Principal or related post in this time. This case has been transfered to the CBI for investigation by the Hon. High Court yesterday.
@@Queendom. Apparently he showed lack of empathy for the victim, when pointed out he tried to act like he is resigning but then go immediately reinstated in another hospital. Even previously he was transferred but within a few hours his transfer order was cancel which basically means he is using some connections of his to remain on a post of his choice in a place of his choice
Details not mentioned: •150 gm of seven was found in the doctor's body •the dead body was kept for 3hrs before the parents could see their daughter •the principal was given posting in another college within a few hours
He is guilty, maybe there were more than one but his guy is guilty. Just as sure you are that he is scapegoat, I am sure he is guilty. you people want politics in everything.
Im from West Bengal, the Government is trying to hide this case .... My request to all the Indians is to share and spread this and not let this case be neglected just like the other previous cases .... Its a small request to all the men and women of India to come together and fight for the Doctors on Behalf of Independence day... Thank you 🙏🙏
Sanjay Roy is a scape goat in this incident. The actual culprit is Dr. Sandip Ghosh, who has a close relation with the ruling party TMC. So, he tried to fled away by giving his resignation. Though, he is again appointed as the Principal of Calcutta National Medical College. As of today 13/08/2024 around 8pm few people tried to tamper with the evidence at the crime scene. by breaking an adjacent wall to the seminar hall (where the crime took place). They gave a lame excuse of renovating the seminar hall. Tomorrow CBI is going to take over the case, so they are trying to destroy the evidences.
Always be careful of men who claim to be " like a father" and say cliche bs " she's like a daughter to me"to young girls .Some men are just natural predators.
There are so many things wrong with this 1.a doctor having to work 36 hr straight shift 2.a doctor not even having a proper resting room during night shift 3.the principal trying to blame the victim 4.the seminar rooms not having cctv cameras 5.random people being given free access to any rooms in the hospital. This is just so fucked up in many ways . How can anyone even think of sending their kids to become doctors in this country ? After studying for 2 yrs they compete with the best students to get admission in neet ug .then they study harder for another 5 yrs in college .then they spent another 1 yr preparing for another huge competitive exam neet pg entrance .after working hard for 10+ yrs .they finally get into good branch at a good government medical College and for what. For some guy to rape and brutally kill u in seconds. Who will pay for all her hard work ,all those sleepless nights ,all those times she couldnt even eat properly bcoz of duties,all those times she ignored her own illness and came to serve her patients. As a female doctor myself I'm very scared hearing this news and I'm pretty sure so are many of my colleagues.bcoz all of us have been in her position .On night duty, alone in that shady room with no lock , walking along those scary corridors at 2 am at night .It could have been any one of us. This is not even the first time this has happened .its not even been two years since another house surgeon doctor dr vandana das was also stabbed to death during duty infront of the police . Its very sad to see the doctors who work tirelessly without eating , sleeping ,during sickness being treated in this horrifying manner . I feel ashamed to be part of a country where this happens
And it's understandable if a normal college does not have cctvs at each and every corner or room of it , but a hospital where many unfortunate incidents can happen and such a risky place, no cctvs were there? Unbelievable..
Sanjoy Roy isn't the real culprit. He is only serving as a scapegoat for the real culprits. The case was handed to the CBI by the high court after Kolkata police showed no signs of progress in their investigation. On the same day there was an organized attempt made by the Hospital administration(affiliated to he state government) and the Kolkata police to destroy evidence and tamper with the murder site, under the pretext of "undergoing renovation work" right as the CBI was about to investigate. The principal of the RG Kar hospital, where the murder happened, is facing allegations of sex trafficking and trading of illegal/fake medication in coalition with big pharmaceutical companies and extorting money from students by blackmailing them about failing them in their exams, which the victim may have gotten to know and was likely killed because of it. The money from all these activities are directly funding the TMC's party funds(who currently form state government of West Bengal where the murder took place). Hence. there are allegations that the state government is directly involved and trying to hide the primary culprit. There have been mass protests across the state for the murder of a doctor who was dedicated to serving humanity and saving lives. Please voice your concerns and support this movement, do not let this movement die out. The state govt. and the culprits are certain that Sanjoy Roy will eventually be released due to a lack of evidence and the masses in the movement will have to return to their daily lives and work and another crime will go unpunished. Please raise your voice against this. What happened to the victim today could happen to any one of us or our loved ones if society remains the same!!! Edit: Similar case happened in 2001 with victim Souitra Biswas. See the striking similarities. timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kolkata/porn-ring-behind-students-murder-at-r-g-kar-medical-college-in-kolkata/articleshow/1900044424.cms
This makes so much sense now, there is no reason TMC would want save these rapists unless they are connected, this is just a tip of an iceberg, I also heard that the government hospitals are run by Mafia where patients have to give money to receive treatment, the level of corruption in WB is horrendous. I am from Assam and never have seen such level of corruption although corruption still exists everywhere
@@bandanachetry1357 In regards to the mafia and patients having to pay for treatment, outdoor treatment in govt. hospitals is actually absolutely free along with most of the medication(expensive medication is sometimes not available). About getting a patient admitted to a govt. hospital, there are mixed views and opinions. There are cases where individuals were admitted based on if they held or knew people in power. Whereas in other cases addition to the hospital is open for all (provided there are beds available). I can only share my personal experience. My father was implanted with a CRTD(cardiac resynchronization therapy defibrillator) device in his chest. A device that costs Rs. 9lakhs. Everything from the device to the treatment was completely free of charge, I am from a middle-class family and my meagre Mediclaim would not have been able to cover the costs. The hospital staff and doctors were such caring individuals. They have done everything for my father from feeding him to cleaning up after him in the ICU. They have done more than I could do as a son. THIS IS SOMETHING POSITIVE THAT THE TMC GOVT. HAS DONE. Again, this is why when a doctor, after 36hrs of duty was murdered in cold blood makes me feel as though we have all lost someone who was out there looking out for us selflessly. It falls on each one of us to question and carefully consider the merits and the demerits, but sheltering criminals and letting rape and murder run rampant cannot be the norm and crimes like this will keep happening until the culprits are brought to justice.
@@shajar2007 It is unlikely that Sanjoy Roy has any affiliation to the BJP, but instead he is likely being used as a scapegoat by the TMC to hide the blame from falling over the sons of MLA Soumen Mahapatra and Labour Minister Nirmal Maji.
After struggling for years and then saving patients at the cost of their health and in return doctors get this!? Really ashamed ….Justice for the dr and huge respect for her 🙌 Being a govt hospital they shld atleast have security protocols…so that this kind of horrendous activity can be avoided
This safety concern is there in All Indian states. Stringent law should be enacted to protect Medical community. Please refer Dr. vandana Das case in Kerala.
Simply because as far as i know, this case involves someone related to TMC. So ofc they are gonna say that there were no cctvs in order to try and save the person. Remember the police is under control of TMC and mamta.
There are report of hospital INTERNS involved in this. It's not a complete story. Why did the dean say it was a suicide??? What was he fearing??? There is something really eerie about this.
As per some reports the main culprit is some jr and intern who belong to powerful background.... I am just crying to think about the victim...a proud doctor... And her brave parents....
Police treated the case as unnatural death first, after pressure they changed it to homicide, police forced the family to cremate the body fast, even after high court ordered CBI enquiry the hospital started repairing work adjacent to that crime area which was stopped by protesters forcefully, isn't something fishy?
My mom told me that a few years ago, she was admitted to the hospital and undergoing surgery. She witnessed a disturbing incident where a nearly 60-year-old doctor was harassing a young trainee doctor. He was grabbing her, and she was struggling to break free. My mom felt helpless as she was under the influence of anesthesia and had a tube in her nose, unable to intervene. It's really heartbreaking to se world like this
This is very common. Male doctors assault female nurses. Young doctors are bullied, manipulated, abused & made to work for a meager sum. Patients & their relatives attack doctors if things don’t go their way Doctors are treated like scum in this country.
as a pakistani girl,i feel so bad for her.i can't tell how much i am depressed after hearing the news. it is my appeal to indian goverrnment please take an action against rapists.
There is more people involved. Now the case is under CBI. I want to trust the system but we live in a state where everyone is scared of politicians. In this case the police first told that it is suicide. Just because of her classmate the case is again investigated. There are more people. They are influencive people. Basically they have powerful family. Everybody who is reading my comments please support the doctors. In west bengal we are protesting and we want the real culprits. Support us 🙏
I'm doctor from Pakistan and i am already crying for her. Why nobody heard her scream? I used to sleep everywhere in hospital sometimes in ward because they were my safe place. But not anymore. I am scared of hospitals now
I agree.. being a doctor I was thinking I'm safe inside the hospital i shouldn't go outside till morning.. but from now I'm feeling I'm not safe inside as well
I am still trembling, i can't imagine what that girl must have gone through...as girls we work 10 times harder to make this world a little livable and then such things happen and on top of all this some people/ animals have the audacity to say " why was she alone at that time of the night, she should have been careful"... My heart aches .. may she rest in peace 😞
He can't rape torture her and know she was alone in similar room in span of 40 min , it's a gang rape by hospital staff and they are shifting blame as usual on any suspect's
Because politicians are behind the illegal business's of there. The girl came to knew so she was killed. They are not going to stand against crime because they're the one doing it.
@@grassofpeace *RG Kar Medical College use to trade Illegal Human Organs* *One of the murderers (also Intern) is a son of MLA* *Many Ministers and MLAs are part of the illegal Organ Trade business*
With a country that discriminates based on colour, spoken language, caste, subcaste, religion, wealth status, sexual orientation, gender,age; do you expect these shitheads to stand in justice? Majority of the people dont give a frick. No matter how many incidents happen, they are just a hot topic for the week or more than a week. Post that we all forget and move on. The only caveat I can think of is "stay safe, not even your home is safe".
The actual findings have been omitted in this video... The condition in which the lady doctor's body was found indicated without doubt that multiple people were involved in this crime... The civic volunteer is merely a scapegoat being used to hide the actual perpetrators... because these perpetrators are close to the ruling party. And the principal is aware of this and is keeping mum... and that is the reason why this ceasework of junior and senior residents is still going on in West Bengal and in many medical colleges across India...
As per some reports the main culprit is some jr and intern who belong to powerful background.... I am just crying to think about the victim...a proud doctor... And her brave parents....
It was a gang rape and Sanjay is not the only rapist and murderer..and the Principal did't resign.. it was just a transfer..just to save him from being arrested.. he is now the principal of national medical College.. it's just a shameful act
@@binhilabi that principal is a corrupted person from the beginning and He knows everything about that incident.. He is trying his best to hide the rapists.. At first He declared that it was a suicide.. then he said so many bad things about that lady doctor. It was not a resign it was a planned transfer.. now he is the principal of National medical College
He was employed by the police to assist officers admitted in the hospital. What kind of background check was done when he was employed. Total incompetence everywhere.
And how can someone involved with alcohol assumption post a duty as a civic assistant on the same night? he's not respecting the job the people and everyone.what were the higher authorities doing it's so pathetic.may justice be served in no time.
@@Dhruvdsilva where's the source coming from? By the accused? He was clearly caught on the cctv footage but why not the other four?maybe a trick to deny a justice?
@@love_cook *RG Kar Medical College use to trade Illegal Human Organs* *One of the murderers (also Intern) is a son of MLA* *Many Ministers and MLAs are part of the illegal Organ Trade business*
I am from West Bengal and I am requesting you to please stand with us, please be united, please bring more protests to save our "lakshmis".... Tilottama needs justice....once again I am requesting to each and everyone, please stand with that innocent doctor🙏
@@tarik9844 this case is directly related to TMC as the culprit has some connections with the TMC. Thus it's absolutely makes sense to "bring politics in this" as a political party has direct links to it(or atleast that's what i could gather from sources).
@@utkarshbajpai4628 Most of the henious crimes in this country are done by powerful people only, with connections. If we want to bring politics in this, then bjp, congress and every other major party will be in the same group.
How nobody even heard her screaming? And nobody came to the seminar room till morning? This is not done by one man there’re multiple behind this heinous act. So disgusted how the hospital admin handled it by saying it was a suicide? They definitely know something. The hospital administration should also bring to justice.
its a per-planned crime and r@pe was just a part of it. normally the place where she went for rest and study have people but that day others where diverted to not go to that location for some or the other reason.
@@Nini-u6iYeh toh kuch hi jab hospital ta senior ne toh yeh bhi kaha ki woh kyu raat ko wahah gayi😢agar room hi nhi hai toh woh kya floor me rest kare pata nhi log lakdi ko hi kyu blame karte hai aur CM bhi ek ladki hi hai woh kaise asa chup hai
Actually this man Sanjay is not main culprit of this murder. There is big influence behind it. They try to fame Sanjay is victim, but this is not truth. and Today 13.08.24 A Seized Room in RG KAR MEDICAL HOSPITAL where the incident took place, by breaking the wall of the room the main culprit behind this have removed the evidences. Question is how they have done? where all time police was active... BIG QUESTION LEFT! this is not a case of what you think. i am resident of Kolkata. I can say that.
@spdh6325 the timing of the 'renovation' is definitely sus and the authorities can quickly defend themselves calling it as an approach to appease the protesting students. But the construction has taken place in the vicinity of the seminar hall and not in the seminar hall per se. It is still sealed and guarded by police. There are a lot of rumours making the rounds which have not been confirmed yet. Too much speculation can be detrimental. Let's stick to the news that is being reported by multiple media and not just one or two.
@@debashruti4984 At least you condemned that something happened. The 'renovation' in very big sensitive area is not acceptable. very sus activities is going on. Last day Some mob were trying to vandalize the floor. but Somehow they did it in wrong floor. But They had a motive to destroy it. I am sorry to say. Our Govt is related somehow and they try to suppress our voice. I am just a normal civilian who can understand the overall logic of this incident but our Administration fails to understand it. Gradually i am losing my hope for Justice.
This independence day, I will be wearing Black, since I don't feel any pride being an Indian. I was FORCED to become NRI due to a similar incident. Being a woman myself and being a mother to a daughter, her safety and security is more important to me than khokhla Deshprem.
Mam agree with your most off opinion but before mocking khokali deshbhakti...being an NRI give you assurance about crime free country & environment?...look at what is happening in US , UK , Germany...crime rate is on peak... especially look at cases of sexual abuse , molestation of minor girls in veil of grooming gangs and so on...also kindly look at judicial verdicts pronounced by UK court on recent rape case which almost whitewashed crime done by culprit... Please go and study..i am not justifying crime and criminals..bt despite having 1.4 billion population such heinous crimes rate per capita level still lower than other so called developed countries....and second thing state government also responsible in it...if such crime happened in uttar pradesh , Yogi ji ne abtak encounter kr diya hota... Bengal is fallen under Mamata
At least in other countries be it president or president's son they will be dragged to court and prison@@irreplaceable2002 and cases are not low majority don't get noticed or FIR's are not lodged as police are fucked up bastards in India...just oike this case that bastard said suicide...so according to that illiterate superintendant doctor girl raped her self, injured herself and hung herself to death... Wah bai wah kya waihaat cheez hai
As a girl i humbly request to all girls please protest against it atleast spread that matter because today this happens with her it may be possible we are next
India is the only country that treats medical professionals, including doctors, as low-wage workers. No wonder most medical professionals go abroad for better jobs and security. It's a shame for the entire country.
@jetpark3743 What are you trying to say? I was pointing out the way the government and private hospitals treat medical professionals. For example, in some private hospitals, the staff salary is just under 20k. If the same nurse works in the Gulf, he/she will be paid above 150k with accommodation and other benefits provided. I am not degrading any daily wage laborers. I am disappointed by the Indian system where professionals like nurses, doctors, diploma holders, and engineers get less than 15k as a salary and no other benefits. As an engineer myself, my first salary was only 5k in India. When I moved to the GCC, my employer gave me more than 100k as a basic salary and other benefits like accommodation, a company car, etc. Spending a large amount of money and time to earn a degree in medicine or engineering is not worth it in this pathetic country.
@jetpark3743 Also, I am not saying that a country like India should provide a salary equivalent to the GCC, Europe, or other Western countries, but can't the government and private company employers provide even a safe working environment for these professionals? I have many friends who were working as medical professionals in India five years ago. Now, almost all of them have gone abroad only because of the reasons I mentioned in my previous comments.
Shame on West Bengal Police for misleading the case and framing the civic volunteer as scapegoat, the actual culprits are still outside the bars. The Chief Minister of West Bengal must resign
The fact that police earlier said that it was a suicide....i mean how??? After having so many years and cases of experience still they do not know how a murdered body looks different from that of one who did suicide.
As a father of a young daughter, this brings tears in my eyes. I cannot describe in words how dreadful I feel. How can we let these kind of incidents happen. We have to start first by accepting that their is something wrong in our society i.e. how women are seen, treated etc. Change is needed now. Also I do understand that given the size of the population, things are bound to happen. But what worries me is the brutality of these indicents. It just shows some serious lack of disrespect and anger.
educaton and training .....is the answer unfortunately even educated men and people look down upon women even today ....even now as I write as it happens ....I really hate to mention
This safety concern is there in All Indian states. Stringent law should be enacted to protect Medical community. Please refer Dr. vandana Das case in Kerala.
I refuse to celebrate independence day tomorrow, in a country where such things are happening with doctors, or anyone else This country first needs to be a Safe country, then independent
Our freedom fighters got us independence so that we could enjoy a brighter future… Is this what our system has got us into!!! Feels like we continue to be slaves of people who misuse their power and money!!! No independence yet!!!😢
@@Hillman-p9s Obviously I can't write a novel on this. This subhuman is obviously brazen enough to think he can do this. That tells me he has history of being inappropriate in all ways than meets the eye. There's a lack of management here......there should be someone overseeing the security dept as a whole. He is a volunteer from what understand which means he reports to someone. This is a reflection of a bigger problem that is unfolding
The management initially tried to suppress this case but everyone got eyes on this when med students and doctors started their protest... I heard that 2 people were involved and they also had some powerfull political connection..
It’s so shocking and heartbreaking 💔 . May Dr. Moumita’s soul rest in eternal peace and give comfort to family.🙏🙏✝️✝️😭😭 Demand Justice for Dr. Moumita . From Oxford Uk 🇬🇧.
@@mohammedraazi4943 can you not push islam everywhere? how does islam come into this picture? bhai r@pe hua hai its a serious fkin issue dont you get it?
@@mohammedraazi4943lol bro...Iraq just lowered their marriage age to 9(it means child marriage is no longer illegal or labelled as pedophilia act) as to honour your prophet's(Police be upon him) underage wife aysha...what you yapping? Here
I am from Pakistan and I am crying. I have no words. I can't imagine your pain my dear sister. I was sleeping peacefully in my bed when this was happening to you. I wish I could do something I wish I was there. I wish I was able to stop it. I wish you were alive. We failed you my dear sister from another country!
An innocent girl, the people should stand up against the corrupt police and the system. May she rest in peace, we Sri Lankans 🇱🇰 🇱🇰 are allways with you.
As an Indian, I'm appalled and deeply disturbed by what happened to her. Knowing all the horrifying details of those brutal 4 to 5 hours, I can barely sleep or eat. The thought of the terror and pain she must have endured is haunting. The fact that the Bengal police initially called it a suicide is outrageous. The TMC's silence on the matter is deafening, especially with rumors swirling that a TMC politician's relative might be involved. It's a blatant disregard for justice. What shocks me even more is the Congress party's silence. It really makes me question whether Rahul Gandhi truly cares about the Indian people or if he's just focused on his vote bank. It's a disgrace. Shame on Rahul Gandhi and shame on Congress for their lack of action and compassion. Mamata Banerjee must resign. Her inability to ensure justice and her silence on such a heinous crime is unacceptable. It's time for accountability.
I agree that Mamta is the worst. Also, r*pe cases are becoming so rampant in the entire country. This happens everyday but no one cares. We care about it only when politics is involved. But Men r*pe, kill, abuse, harass women everyday every hour. No outrage.
This safety concern is there in All Indian states. Stringent law should be enacted to protect Medical community. Please refer Dr. vandana Das case in Kerala.
@@abdulhaseeb3303 Again, Kerala, a state which is ruled by people favouring conversions and non-Hindus for votes, just like Bengal. Sorry, Bengal is a big AF mess, thanks to Mamata.
@@java2architect Ikr. These people love to mock their countries but when something like this or even worse happens in the west, I don't see them fkking being ashamed of their identity. Like bro, sh!t happens everywhere and we should stand against it, no need to attack your country...unless you are just projecting.
Shame on you calling for CM's resignation. Where were you when women of Manipur gang raped and paraded naked in public? Did you ask for CM, PM's resignation then?
Voice raise karne se kya hoga.. This is India ... this is what india as a country has become . Full of disfunctional law and order.voice cant do anything
U know that .. everyone in India is fake as shit person....no one cares ..no one ..... Even if she gets justice..what changes ? Nothing..we will continue be subject of such crimes ... because men who can fight against other men are acting faltu ka Sigma ..aur isi ka advantage le re h aise aadmi log .... Lete rahenge .. if u ask men to give us protection to humari feminism pe ajayega .... Bhai sote sote tum logo k sath ye hota na. .to samjh aata why women don't do achievements in life ... This fkig country is scary ..not just for me but for your own mother too...I can't even think of getting r*ped at my working place . .new fear unlocked..can u image the level of pain she must hv gone through????
We want justice not because she was a doctor, but because she was a woman, a daughter, a sister, a friend. It is about the entire female population of India. If the police, CBI, West Bengal government, and Central Government can't do anything or can't give justice; then it is shameful to call ourselves Indians, who worship goddesses like Lakshmi, Durga, and specially Kali Mata (which is so much worshipped in west bengal). Scared to be a girl in this inhumane world.
You scream and moan and wail......this country gives a shit.....the worst cheapest low life country in the world.....ok there maybe some other countries like that .....but this one is in that list for sure. Lawless with crooks working as cops,,.,,,,,every case is not straightforward dealt with,,,,,its always with a preliminary check of who is involved (so the law can change accordingly).....who they should shield and support.......then chk with higher officers as to how this case should be "framed" and upon whom,,,,then proceed. Bastards.
How does her family let her work at night as a doctor? Doctor is a hard profession on a woman. İ deeply grieve what happened, nethertheless - woman from loving family doesn't work THAT hard😢
Imagine finding out through media that your daughter is no more Such a brutal and horrendous incidence indeed!!! May her soul rest in peace and give strength to her family 🙏🏻🙏🏻
This is horrendous.As a doctor from Pakistan,please accept my condolence.Night duties are already tough for doctors . Can't imagine what the lady went through. I hope justice prevails.
Ni. I am from Pakistan 🇵🇰 and yay Pakistan may bhe ho skta hai. Yahan pay bhe bht baray baray haiwan (animals) baithay huay hain. Yay Mt bolo k yahan apki family/ladies safe hain. Motorway incident/zahir jaffer etc mat bholo
@@AamirKhan-bh7bwyou’re so dumb it’s unbelievable I’m a Pakistani so you can’t say I’m saying this because I’m Indian. Do your research and then talk genius
A few days later, we all will forget about it. Remembering a bollywood actor suiciding is a big deal in this country rather than a young doctor got murdered, raped and beaten by thirsty man. We, don't deserve good doctors in our country.
Well said Brinda. Such a great insight into the conditions prevailing in our country. You gave a wonderful solution to the conditions prevailing in our country. I like your response to the question that women are responsible for provoking men to behave thus. You did justice to this interview. More power to you and your ideals.
@@divyamishra4717 yes bar for women is very low here, a male old teacher said to me, Good u're trying to be a teacher (coz i was a teacher trainee), which is the safest job for women to do....I was so speechless..
Every young working woman in India needs workplace protection 1. Demand your employer to have CCTV camera wherevr you are working, provision of alarm bells in every conference or seminar room you are attending, intercom in every room with direct access to local police station number! 2.Keep a pepper spray at all times in your pockets! If wearing kurti or saree, you can wear a sharp hair pin on your hair. 3. Never enter the office parking lot alone. Always check the rear passenger seat of your car first before sitting in your driver seat. 4. In worst case, if you have to work alone in night shift, make a video call to any known friend or family. Ask the person to keep the video on thorough the shift.
Rehne do bhai.....This is india .....Jha women saalo se Sehti aayi hai chahe wo "sati pratha" , "pardha pratha" ya r@pa 😊 hume india me rehne ha toh Drr kr rehne hi pdega .....Please Girls take care of yourselves in Your House as well because jaise jaise case sune ha hum india me ghar me bi surakshit ni ha 😊 I am done with this yrr...Mbbs is my dream college Ik uss ladki ne kya kya spne dekhe honge jo kuch hi samey me complete hone bale thee or ab 😭🤌
Sorry but, The last point is useless. Instead of focusing on catching the culprit, u should focus on keeping urself safe. A video won't do anything if she dead. It will only be a prove.
@@KrishnaSharma-g1e average indian woke feminists mentality:- rather than look at the actual problem and try to solve it, just blame the country because it's easier to say that the system and culture is the one wrong and not the criminal and those actually accountable like those in power🙄
I am an Indian man living in another country with my wife. we both have jobs in this another country. I always tell my wife that after few years we should go back to india and she supported me on that..until yesterday when she heard about this incident .. 'I am fearful of going back to india' .. these were her words and that was the moment i realized, as a man, I would never never never know how unsafe it is for women in india. I have witnessed catcalling on my wife when we came on vacation to India last year. I felt helpless since I alone can not physically fight a group of 5 burly unsophistacated men.. I was angry to the core when Nirbhaya case happened, I wished for a batman-like superhero/vigilante for justice .. then this incident happened..my blood started boiling again..but i never could imagine a scenario before that what if something like this happened to a member of my family..my wife landed that finishing blow on me yesterday..I have no hopes from my country..I feel ashamed of my country when I have to face others in the country I am living in when they ask about such incidents. 'what would I do something like this happens to a member of my family? who would give the justice?' .. these questions have no answers..prevention of such incidents is not even on the cards.. In the end I concluded that these incidents will keep on happening and I only have 2 options: 1. don't go back to India. 2. If I did go back to India, hope this doesn't happen to my family.
@@nsnarayan1159 I don't care about rape cases in other countries. I care about rape cases in my country. It's not a competition to reach to the bottom. And if you want to compare anyways, can you compare about good things the other countries have and we don't?
Please please dont think of coming back. There's nothing left here for you guys. The jobs won't pay you as much and god forbid if there's ever a problem with you or your wife, the courts will never give you justice. Even in this case which is highly publicised and known, I'm sure they're going to try and fade it out in few days. I am still in university so I can't wait to graduate and leave this country because even though I barely leave home, I have been stalked and harassed so many times in broad daylight. There is nothing you can do to prevent it. I'm well aware that sexual assaults happen in all countries but its not to this extent and the authorities in other countries don't take such cases lightly and the perpetrator does get punished. Atleast they don't catcall and stalk you the way guys here do. Of course I can't force anyone because it is a big decision but do think a lot before deciding to come back. Not to mention, the entire society is so regressive and still victim blames. No civic sense either. Just prioritise your safety and convenience.
@@naenaeo I fully empathize with you and support your argument of leaving the country for safety. Deshbhakti cannot save you from such incidents. Such is the situation unfortunately.
Unfortunately, you're being misled into believing that this is a rape case founded on lust for sex. This instead is a case where a murder of a doctor had to be committed for reasons yet to be established. Any sensible person would like to go beyond the headlines and into the details, because the devil lies in the details. Since we're both NRIs, I can make a fair assumption that you have to operate on a certain level of professionalism at work, including diving into the details. So please extend that to everything in life in general. Murdering a practicing doctor, in a government hospital is an even bigger crime than raping her. 150gms of semen tells you it was many. You don't expect 5+ men to roaming around a hospital campus hunting for prey at 2:00am. If they are, then either they are the worst of the soceity, high on drugs hunting around OR they are people with a very strong background. It appears clearly to be the latter case. Which then makes this an intended murder including rape. She was being hunted by the powerful and rape and murder or murder and rape (whichever order, it is still being established, and makes a huge difference) were used either to avenge or to silence her. This is not some "boys will be boys" moment, as Mulayam Singh Yadav once said it, it is power corruption. So yeah, stay away from India, unless you want to cross paths with power. It's still not a rape country even statistically.
Why something feels off ? Why i feel like something is being cooked in that hospital management? Why would anyone call it a sucide ? Idk it just doesn't fit,there is more to the story
look at the injuries only. Bleeding eyes, mouth, privates, ankles, wrists, stomach etc. 150 gms semen. No single man can do all that. Plus police forcing the parents to cremate her body asap. Principal getting transferred to another school.
@@nightmarefury9308unfortunately, the real criminals will never get punishment. And I am pretty sure this guy will be released after the case has died down. Similar thing happened to the boy who caused the death of two engineers while drinking and driving. He and his family members has been released.
This Brut report doesn't state the fact that the hospital first tried to pass of the rape and murder as "suicide". This is a very important point but we know why Brut will try and ignore this point. Whom is Brut trying to save is the question.
There should be a law passed, that no one female doctor is left alone on a shift, that they work in buddies, pairs, or, groups, to ensure safety in numbers and also, they should be equipped with emergency contact numbers for assigned police, who work with the Govt. and specialise in this area of work. This should be enforced by the Government of India.
This is my request to the world media to stand with us and raise our voices because we are not safe in our Country . few months ago it was Manipur and now Kolkata . #ShameIndianGovernment #ShameKolkataGovernment #JusticeforKolkataVictim
Well when the world media tries to report then you have the Indian government tries to control the narrative and Indians online start calling the media biased, this and that. Fill the comment section with hatred etc. It is quite important that as Indians we do our soul searching first, try to be critical, learn to deal with criticism, otherwise things will remain as they are.
@@sanesanyo sadly you are doing the same . Focusing on haters . What am saying is stand together and raise voice because this is really very sensitive issue above anything . If world media write anything in in support of Kolkata victim then you should be happy that you succeed and your voice reached at some point and don't focus who is criticising world media for that . There is always few good things present in many bad things . Just be in good side and raise your voice ,it will create some impact . No need of arguments here
How can someone do this? West Bengal : The place where girls are treated as Maa Durga and celebrates Durga Puja with the highest respect and dignity.. 💔
@@madhumitamahato9012 other accused are from Bengal. Even the people saving culprits are Bengalis. Mamta Banerjee the biggest witch is also a Bengali. Come out of this all and start taking a molester as a molester
Im crying and feeling so much rage inside me due to this incident… I WANT THAT PERSON TO BE PRESENTED IN FRONT OF COMMON PEOPLE AND PROTESTORS AND LET PPL DO THE JUSTICE
He is just a scapegoat and even if he is involved, he is not the only one. There are some really influential people behind this and the police is just trying to cover up.
@@bhavyakhare2501 then ig all the persons who r guilty should be punished by the people .. by us bcz i dont have even a lil faith in Indian judiciary system
I feel so bad for the lady. We were discussing this case in the class. Our social science teacher said, "that it's good that they are protesting and demanding justice but why don't they also protects when they deal with these kinds of cases daily? Now a doctor suffered so the whole community is standing with her but why not the same doctors start protesting when a body of a rape victim comes to them.... after all rape is a crime which is same for everyone." Now these words of his are roaming in my mind. May the doctor's soul rest in peace
Examining a rape victim, collection of evidence and playing a part in the process of justice should also be given due diligence which is a doctor's job as well and they do it. Sidelining to perform the job and sitting on strike for every victim is not only a fraternity's task but required for every person of this country, why only doctors perse Does that mean you ask a police to start protesting once they see a victim of any such crime rather than performing duties Also how many non doctors are protesting alongside the doctor protesters
Please ask your intelligent social science teacher what will happen if doctors sit on strike or protest in every case of rape that comes before them ?? Will she accept it if anyone in her family is in the hospital waiting for doctor, but oh the doctor is on strike again today ! How many hospitals will be on a strike everyday ? How can a grown up teacher say something like that !!
It's not just rape, we examine all types of crime. According to the very intelligent teacher we should stop doing our job and just keep protesting. How absurd can someone be. If one cannot show support then dont. Atleast dont utter nonsense.
My Bengal has fallen. When India was once called Brazil of Asia due to Bengal, where most of the freedom fighters rose from, where Rabindranath Tagore, Swami Vivekananda, Vidyasagar, many more were born, that Bengal has fallen. Shame to politics which ruined my Bengal.
LoL are u only now understanding that Bengal has fallen? All our skilled people have to migrate in other states of India to find a job, no industry, no good infrastructure nothing!!!! Political violence is highest after any vote in Bengal. For past few decades we are only living in nostalgia of those golden days
@@Titas20059 yes very true, but you see the government is out of our control now and there are more Bangladeshis in Bengal than real Bengalis so the Bangladeshis vote TMC and TMC also encourages illegal immigrants and the cycle will continue until people wake up.
@@legoooo09 trust me, most of us hate TMC but it has became a dictator and even if we Bengalis don't vote TM C, their Bangladeshi vote will outnumber us. And we are afraid to admit the illegal things done by TMC as they threaten to end our families.
It’s horrifying to think about the kind of cruelty that was inflicted on the victim, and the thought that the perpetrator might still be out there, walking among us, is chilling. ✊ Justice must be served
I can’t imagine what she went through . Rest I peace . I just feel absolutely sad for that lady . It brought me to tears . The amount of pain and terror she endured
As a fellow Indian doctor i strongly condemn this horrific and heinous murder which took place inside the hospital. My heart goes out to the victim Doctor and her family. The government should ensure capital punishment of all those involved and should ensure the safety of all health care workers, especially women and such incident will never happen again.
This is india .....Jha women saalo se Sehti aayi hai chahe wo "sati pratha" , "pardha pratha" ya r@pa 😊 hume india me rehne ha toh Drr kr rehne hi pdega .....Please Girls take care of yourselves in Your House as well because jaise jaise case sune ha hum india me ghar me bi surakshit ni ha 😊 I am done with this yrr...Mbbs is my dream college Ik uss ladki ne kya kya spne dekhe honge jo kuch hi samey me complete hone bale thee or ab 😭🤌
@@hindurashtra5012 show me your bum, i will take "maje" and leave you in this same state. Do you like iron rods? Well, doesn't matter if you want it or not
Wow i remembered I was on a night shift and decided to have a nap alone in the hospital canteen. When I woke up there was a man who seemed to try to open the door but since it was on barcode he couldn’t. When I get out of the door I saw him nearby and he walked behind me. My paranoid self started running up the stairs instead of waiting for the lift . I may seemed crazy at that moment but I am glad I did , who knows what was that man thinking . Since then I never went to that place alone on a night shift.
