What If Aang Was Raised In The Fire Nation? 

What videos should we make next?

I'm so glad that after 12 years, we are still watching and talking about ATLA. Avatar definitely passed the "Timeless show" test.

Imagine, Aang didn't freeze and lived his life along side around Azulon's time. And then died normally at an older age. And the Avatar cycle will continue on and what if the next Avatar happens to be Sokka. Haha.

The Books titles - Book 1: Lies Book 2: Truths Book 3: Guilt

I like your interpretation of Kuruk. He's usually brushed over, but in your version his "go with the flow" style is actually appreciated.

I don’t think Kyoshi would have held Kuruk in low regard, because she knows the struggles he had with spirits because of Yangchen’s mistakes. I also don’t think she would have insulted Aang. She is direct but not unkind.

I can see Aang being friends with a young Azulon. Just like Avatar Roku was friends with Sozin.

Who else loves Avatar?

I don't think the Avatars of the past would've trained him. Just because they never did it so far, even in Aangs timeline when Jeong Jeong didn't want to train him Rokku never made a move to train him. I think they would rather make him find someone for each element, as even air normads proably survived somewhere.

I love this! What a cool “what if” scenario. I love the level of detail you went into, and how you kept the essence of who Aang is the same. You also managed to have an emotional pay-off ending and a redemption. I’m impressed. Kudos! I actually wrote a fanfic with a similar premise of what if Aang was found by the fire nation and raised as Ozai’s son. It was cool to contemplate. Anyway, love your content! Keep it up!

For lack of a better word, I think the Avatar just asking the past lives to help him is not only a plot-hole but also is deritivative to the entire point of Avatar. Meeting new people, learning culture, and gaining understanding.

I think Sozin would use Aang to get wants then eventually see him as a threat and try to dispose of him / backstab him

I love the parallels between how Toph and Kyoshi would train Aang. It's such a good example of world building because both teachers reflect the fortitude it takes for earthbenders to control earth, giving the element itself a character!

What if Aang Was never bald

Kinda funny when you realize in this timeline Aang is Ozai uncle

Since the avatar literally has Raava “the spirit of light” I don’t think its possible for him to get brainwashed/mislead into doing pure evil. The avatar is just born to be good

I think the nature versus nurture debate can bring up a good point here. Some people might be inclined to believe that Aang cannot be evil because he is the Avatar and has Raava the spirit of light. But Aang is indoctrinated into believing the same thing that Zuko was in the series, that the fire nation is spreading prosperity through the war. This inherently does not make Aang evil, for the same reason it didn't make Zuko evil. They were children led to believe in an amazing lie, for the purpose of propaganda. Being fed lies your entire life does not inherently make you evil. In fact pretty sure evil doesn't truly exist in this case because even Sozin couldn't actually kill Aang or Roku in this scenario. Whereas Ozai, for example, had absolutely no qualms about trying to kill Aang what so ever. The difference with Ozai and to a lesser extent Azula, is that they have diagnosable mental health issues. So even then it's a grey area about whether or not Ozai and Azula are 'evil'.

That was a really great "What if" story, it sounded like it was indeed a part of Avatar's canon. Loved it!

I think the past avatar’s teaching him makes everything seem a bit too easy, but I really like the set up with Sozin.

Honestly I thought I’d get bored and do something else 5 mins in but you actually provided a pretty capturing and entertaining story that kept me till the end without realizing 😂 great video

What if Sozin was the avatar? (He shared the same birthday as Roku, so it could've been a possibility)

The timeliness here makes no sense. Sizing was already very elderly when Roku died and you're saying that he had Azulon 10 years after he wiped out the air nation. Sozin had to have had Azulon years prior

This is my favorite Last airbender what if of all time. That bit with Sozin at the end sold the entire thing for me.

What if Zuko joined Team Avatar in Book 2!?

when amagi posts a video you know the find info and make the video enjoyable.

That honestly pulled on my heart strings there.

2:50 made me realize why I keep rewatching yo vids u make em so fuckin good

Man I love what ifs/fanfiction. I loved this story. Stayed true to Aang, redeemed Sozin, the whole fight and redemption scene is just beautiful. Plus super good ending!

This story is so beautiful, I literally cried in the end

im so happy your still do avatar vids

In this version of events, Aang would be Zuko's grunkle.

Wow this was really good! ❤️

its nice for the amagi to post avatar every now and then reminds me when they used to be an avatar only channel

It's a shame that you didn't use ANY of the Canon material from the Avatar Legends tabletop RPG. There's so much during Roku's Era that you could've used, like Sozin's sister Zeisan, or the rogue Airbender political group "the Guiding Wind". Thr could've worked _beautifully_ into the propaganda Aang would've grown up with.

That is a very interesting video, and i like your optimistic tone in regard to Aang convincing Sozin to come back home so to speak. Now, in a world where Azulon was groomed to become a normal person, i would really like to see a sequel video with Ozai's comment. Knowing Ozai, he would've probably use Azula to conquer Ba Sing Se and start a civil war within the fire nation. Either that, or he would've murdered his own father using his wife like in the canon, and then the next avatar (after Aang) would've been a waterbender who just happened to bend air. If there is such a sequel video, let me know. If there is not, i would be glad to help you with ideas for it.

what would have happened if aang was raised in the earth kingdom

This “thought experiment” is basically a fan fiction, and I’m here for it

Honestly when I clicked on this video I expected to hate it. But as a genuine die hard fan of the Avatar CU I fully loved this. It was way better thought out than I thought it would be. While there are flaws in my head I do fully believe this is a reasonable way to see his life going

What i think would happen next: After Aang visited all the Temples he would catalog and write everything he learned and find any register about the air nomads, he wouldnt live all day on the palace but ocasionaly going to visit Azulon and he would be traveling the world trying his best to help others in need and he would train Tenzin in airbending and maybe have more two children and maybe go to find the White Lotus and be a member, but it doesnt matter because this is legitimate peace, no Fire Nation attacking means no Jet parents dying, No bloodbending invented (yet) And basicaly in the future Kya and Hakoda would be still raising Sokka and Katara as a whole family and well the only possible evil that could happen is Ozai but unless he somehow takes Azulon and Iroh out of the picture

Wow this is amazing work 10\10

I want to see a part 2 of this, where Aang uses his life to start rebuilding the air nations after the war, eventually dies of old age, and Katara becomes the next avatar

Me at 2:43: then he got an idea. An awful idea. Sozin got a WONDERFUL, AWFUL IDEA!

I'm gonna be honest, I definitely think this is how AtLA should've gone. The original story was great and I loved all of Aang's teachers but Aang being taught by his past lives is absolutely phenomenal 💖

If that was the case we'd have one "hotman"......I'll take my leave now

Very beautiful story you’ve told

bro i swear to god you are the GOAT

There is a fanfic on this thats named the hand that rock the cradle its actually realy good imo

keep up the good work

Sooo good ! I love This

Just * a question in my mind . " What have happened if sasuke's mom actually adopted naruto ".

Wait wouldn't Sozin be an old man by the time he kidnapped baby Aang?

This was so entertaining!

i would be weird to see aang had no arrows

I love your vids❤

I like how all the last avatars help him learn the elements.

Kuruk wasn't actually a go with the flow avatar tho yang Chen did most of the things for him already BUT she forgott to take care of the spirit world and kuruk had to clean up the mess she left him with in the spirit world which also kinda made him die faster

U are mistaking Sozin and Roku were already old so surely their children are already grown up

Keep up the what ifs they are 🔥

I'm glad with how the show went and this would not have made a better story in my opinion no matter how much fun it is to think about.

This timeline theory shows elements of a Prince of Egypt story.

I love that the previous avatars are teaching him. I wish this happened in the original. honestly, I think I like this idea more than the origional.

Best what if yet!

I love the mini story but in the show aang found it dufficult to kill sozin even tho he wasn't his father and this version acpeted it quickly secondly the past lives you could only visit on a solcitis or in a spiritual area but in this version they are like masters on command

This is pretty creative.

Do a video on what if Zuko was never banished from the fire nation

I can't with the fire bending soldier's goofy eyes.

Correct me if I'm wrong but would Aang be able to master and learn firebending before air? Isn't something bad supposed to happen if he doesn't learn the elements in order?

god I love these videos

Good episode idea

What do Aang & Kiryu have in common? "THEY NEVER KILLED A MAN"

This is a lot better than the What if Aang never ran away one, since Sozin redeemed himself

kurama first love make it 1 hour long man i love your vids who agree

This wouldve been the most emotional take on aangs journey and a lot more personal. I honestly wouldnt mind a fanmade animation of this what if.

Ah yes, the most important training any avatar could receive. Flirting 😂

It'd be interesting. Being trained as a fire bender, he'd obviously excellent at that, because bending is tied to the art the bender is performing. However, being born an air nomad, he would have to be naturally gifted in that. Being unskilled in the more free flowing nature of air and water bending would also make water bending, the fire nations biggest obstacle, extremely difficult for him to learn, making him less of a threat to Sozin and Azulon. Controlling Aang would likely lead to the destruction or subjugation of the water tribes, since the fire lords would have no need to focus so much of their efforts on the air nomads. Edit: The alleged remaining air nomads. I was implying that they could come out of their shells, maybe even joining the white lotus.

i like the idea of a past avatar spirit teaching the current avatar, thats pretty cool i think he shouldve had a loyal dragon instead of a sky bison though..

That was an emotional one

This story is really interesting

love this series!!!

This is a very good fan story

I don't think Aang should have been able to learn the elements from the past Avatars.. There's a reason why, in the original show, Roku couldn't teach Aang fire bending himself. Roku even insisted on Jon Jon, The Deserter teaching him, which shows Roku couldn't do it because he was incorporeal.

I'm kinda like this " what if ",honestly it's pretty cool to see Aang as a fire prince,but i dislike the idea the past avatars teaching him i'm think Sozin would rename him Anzai to fit in fire nation prince, Anzai ( Aang ) in this au is NOT a pacifist. Anzai personality would be arrogant,mean and sometime selfish, but he's not evil. Anzai is obsessed with being the perfect son and the perfect heir due to him want Sozin's attetion and love,which made Anzai flame's blue. When Anzai show his first fire bending, Sozin forcing him to do rigorous training that almost broke his bones with his firebendinng teachers,which make him the second strongest fire bender (after Sozin) at his time. After escape from the palace, he would be likely teach air bending by Gyasto,who some how surived from air nomads genocide and the others, during learning air bender, he would still had Appa as his spirit animal. When they're on the way escape from a fire nation ship by Sozin sent, Anzai and Appa get caught in storm and frozen in the ice berg for 100 years and found by Katara and Sokka and rest happened to be most like in the canon , expect Zuko to be redemped earlier than in canon Anzai would be shock,terrified or even deny to believed that he's the avatar,cuz the avatar is the biggest threat to the fire nation,his family, to h i s f a t h e r . Anzai's suffering and saddness will be explored in throughout the series,i'm kinda think when Anzai realize that 100 years has passed,he'll had a mental breakdown like Azula when she's lost agni kai with Zuko. Because he realize that he had TRULY LOST EVERYTHING , he lost his position as a prince; he lost his family, his friends; the man who he called 'father' want him dead; his whole life has been a lie, and he don't ever know who he really is . But during his journey and the help of his friends, he eventually get over it and defeated fire lord Ozai, and marry Katara like in the canon.

I just found out you’re from Wisconsin, that’s fucking rad!

Imagine A fire lord was born as the avatar

I wanted Bummy to train his earth bending

anng named his airbending child after gyatso his father figure gyatso's first name was tensin and thats why so i think it would have been sozion or maybe a fire bender name

I don't like how you missed the perfect chance to make aang and boomi friends and since he wasn't raised as an air nomad boomi would a perfect teacher and sozin could have sent azulon to capture or kill aang that would have been an emotional dynamic that would make the conclusion of the story a lot better and not so lovey dovey "Ohh we can solve all our problems with words" really I just hate the fact that he made no friends on his journey and relived on the pass avatars too much to teach him in the show they never stay around for any long period of time because I don't think they can unless he goes in the spirit world and there messages are always vague and thing he gotta figure out on his own or by simply living life with friends other than that cool video

Azula wouldn’t be born because ang wouldn’t be frozen for 100 years

You are so awesome 😄😁👍

I’d love an avatar kurick show he’d be a great protagonist

the second he said "valuing his country more than his teachings" i immediately thought, what if the avatar was american

if Aang was Raised in the fire nation it still would've ended the same just more arcs and seasons, Uncle Iroh would've taken Aang somewhere and they would meet Soka and Katara in the water tribe.

Very good

Dude ur what if’s are fucking awesome

make what if sakumo hatake the white fang lived what if kakashi was uchiha or kept the dms what if danzo and orochimaru were not evil please you can make does

That was fing awesome

Wait is it cannon that bumi or earthbenders can crystal bend :D or possibly sugar bend? cause bumi said " these rocks have crystal candy in it"

Amazing

Image if the water tribe princess was supposed to be the avatar and aang was supposed to die but he ran away and then the moon spirit came to fill the void in the princess

Do a what if instead of the fire nation genociding the air nomads they invade and take over the 4 temples and force the air nomads into submission