I mean that would just make anakin go to the Jedi temple the literal day of his birth since every kid from birth basically had there midichlorians tested. And if his didn't get tested a lot more Jedi still go there compared to tatooine so there's no way they wouldn't sense him in the first year of his birth
Yeah, I just wonder what would like the characters from I don’t know like season for something of the clone Wars like the Canon version of Anakin and Ahsoka would think of this and other what-ifs I would love to see Anakin reaction to this. What if like clone wars season 6 or just sometime like in the middle of the clone wars would think of this wallet and basically everything about it
I would love to see this story redone, but the younglings treat both anakin and ahsoka as outsiders. Because of this they become super close friends, heck maybe even more than friends (assuming the age gap is lessened so its not weird).
I’m sided with Anakin on this one tbh. I can’t imagine the insanely immense disappointment and resentment towards Ahsoka. Heck I kinda felt it with him
“Ah so concludes the life and times of aniken skywalker, a fitting end to an existence defined by futile struggle. Never destined for freedom. Doomed from the very start… AND I DONT REGRET A SECOND OF IT!
Always wondered why Anakin wasn’t taken more seriously! Instead of handed to a brand new night instead of a established Master?? But great job again! I know your page would start blowing up! Congrats
This is a really cool concept. Something I’ve wanted from you for a while. I think a more interesting scenario would be where Palpatine corrupts Ahsoka and Anakin has to fight her.
I so wish they treated Anakin the way they treated Ashoka in this story! I always wondered why master yoda didn’t take Anakin as a student. Someone with Anakin’s potential shouldn’t have been given to someone who just became a knight. At least Anakin should have been chosen by a master! I mean how wouldn’t you have someone much more experienced to train a possible “chosen one” btw im so bad with computers so I couldn’t figure out how to enter my name but that’s ok. I really enjoy your stories! That’s why I subbed, not for free sabers which is really cool of you for your fans! And can’t say I wouldn’t want one..lol but Bravo once again! I can’t tell you how great it is that you do full stories! Not half stories with if you like it I’ll finish someday! Who wants to hear half of a story with no guarantee of hearing the end…THEORY!! I do enjoy his page but he never finishes stories and it is maddening!
These stories really illustrate how hilariously ill-prepared the Jedi were to handle a special case of any kind. Like, frick, American public schools in the 1940s were better prepared to handle people with disabilities than the Jedi Order was prepared to handle ONE KID who joined their order later than most. It's amazing how badly they just screwed this up when they had so many options to consider. Adjust their teaching methods to account for the fact that Anakin joined older than most? NOPE! Collaborate with a competent educator who handles non-Jedi children to make a more efficient teaching program for Anakin so as to take his "normal kid" mindset into account? NOPE! Perhaps even schedule a "transitional period" where Anakin's education shifts from "normal" to "Jedi training"? NOPE! Just put Anakin in the class where his skill level is at? NOPE! Accept the fact that it's too late for Anakin to not have attachments and instead train him to be able to keep a clear head in spite of them? NOPE! Accept that he needs additional training in regard to controlling his emotions and pair him up with a tutor with a gift for helping troubled Younglings? NOPE! Keep his status as "The Chosen One" on the down-low, especially around him, instead of risking him becoming blinded by Dark Side-y things like pride and arrogance? NOPE! Give him to a teacher more experienced and patient than Obi-Wan? NOPE! Raise a brow and step in to say "No" when a shady old politician like Palpatine randomly summons a teenage boy to his office? NOPE! (Oof! That last one has "scandal" written all over it.) Like, wowzers, man.
Interesting tale of Ahsoka I liked it, found liking Anakin being a little jealous of Ahsoka and turning to darkness sooner was surprising. I think Ahsoka did make a great jedi
nice one , i love ahsoka. seeing clone wars in theater and following that with the series put her in my heart without me even realizing it . so when she turned up on rebels it took me by surprise , i wasn't expecting it. i was crying like a baby . i hadn't realized how much i cared about her and how happy I was to see her , that she was ok. and then the last season of clone wars was breathtaking . a truly powerful conclusion to an enormous chapter in the star wars story . so I absolutely love this "what if?". i'm 47yrs old and have loved SW my whole life , i appreciate and thoroughly enjoy your channel . you treat the characters and creative space with dignity and honor.
A couple things... 1: AMAZING!!! 👏🏼 2: what abt padme? 3: Did she really just cake walk Maul, Savage, & Ventress without breaking a sweat?? Like holy sh!t dude! 4: RIP Yoda. The dyslexic frog will be missed... 5: again, amazing 👏🏼 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Fun fact: this was the original plan for Star Wars, but George Lucas thought audiences weren't ready for Ahsoka to be this cool. Also, strictly speaking, weren't Sidious' lightsabres made of lightsabre resistent phrik? Although perhaps the phrik part wasn't the part of the lightsabre that got cut.
No they were made from electrum which was meant to be added to Jedi lightsaber as a sign of greater mastery and advancement. It was an insult to the Jedi radiation which is wh he did it.
@@adventwolfbane I do suggest you look again. While they were plated with electrum as well, the actual design incorporated phrik. You are technically correct, it's just that I'm also not wrong
I believe they are because Ahsoka has a unique force connection to Anakin she can literally sense him across the galaxy well up till he is Vader and not the the same....
I believe if Ahsoka and Anakin were trained around the same time and her being the chosen one Ahsoka would still be somewhat interested in Anakin because of how different he is. His past and all would raise questions because children are natural curious.I can see a moment when Anakin is picked on by the other younglings because he was a slave and Ahsoka standing up for him mainly because she understands because she is the chosen one and others are jealous and envious. They would be two black sheep around white ones.
Why not expand this Story?: Ahsoka recieves visions about Ilum's Kyber Forest and decides to leave the Temple in the middle of the night (against Plo Koon's Wishes) towards Ilum to undertake the Trials to get her two White Kyber Crystals and build her Lightsabers. By the time Yoda and Plo Koon (with a group Younglings) arrive to get Ahsoka back to the Temple, she shocks them by igniting her Lightsabers (White Kyber Crystals are so rare)
What if the Cone Wars inhibitor chips malfunction and instead of order 66, it's case the Clones to want to burn everything in Republic Territory. Indirectly helping the Separatist. Example while Anakin is in the temple, he hear something and go out to see Coruscant burning and the senate building bombarded from orbit with Palpatine and Padme inside.
Nute Gunray and the rest of the separatist Council would think this was part of Sidious plan and watch the fire show while celebrating their assured victory. Also Anakin would not be happy at about the situation he finds himself in.
"What if Ahsoka was the Chosen One?" is basically the same question as "What if Dave Filoni was given even more creative control than he already has?".
Subscribe and share or Ahsoka will delete your Old Republic account Support the Channel: www.patreon.com/ppsw Join Our Community Discord: discord.gg/RdBUUrKRJT Twitch Account: www.twitch.tv/pentepatrol Lightsaber Giveaway (06/04/22): docs.google.com/document/d/1C0Jb95iY_kWJ-iq_mNcLNFOJS8y0Hc_q_-looDcyIxw/edit
This video is awesome and love how path of being chosen one was so different when you think but wish Anakin was her master that only thing can say negative about because love Anakin and Ahsoka relationship but this video is great 👍
What if General Grievous found out about the truth of his creation? Basically the idea is while still maintaining his hate towards the Jedi. Which is well earned by the way check out MetaNerdz's channel where they have two videos going over all of Grievous's major story beats both legends and cannon. Basically the warrior inside, Qymaen jai Sheelal, manages to fight against his programming just enough. For the general to question his current condition and look into what really happened. He was told it was the Jedi who blew up his ship with his best warriors and it was their fault that he had to be outfitted with a body that was mostly non-organic. But reality being his body was mostly intact after the explosion and that it was Dooku and the banking gland he's partners with that caused it to happen. I see this going down an interesting path. The general discovering what had actually happened causing him to hate both the jedi and the sith. Making Qymaen swear vengeance on both and with his warrior spirit reignited he is able to carefully plan behind the separatists and Dooku's backs. Finding a way to get revenge against both sides. Perhaps finding a way to combat the force as well other than overwhelming opponents with sheer unrelenting force.
What if earth was in the Star Wars universe What if anakin was a foundling of the true mandalorians What if Luke became a foundling What if anakin was revans reincarnation or descendent What if shmi was a former Jedi either exiled or left the order
Crazy Plot Twist: Ahsoka is impressed by Sidious humiliating Yoda and Plo Koon, her mind warped by the war, backstabs them and says "Show me." "Kill him," Sidious commands, indicating Skywalker. Vader now completely overwhelm with betrayal and rejection (like Ventress when she was cast aside and left for dead by Dooku) fulfills the prophecy of the Chosen One as Qui Gon said and annihilates Sidious, Ashoka and himself in a red storm of force lightning.
I thought of a Few interesting ones... What if Yazel Poof trained Anakin? Something about Anakin working in the Jedi Archives (I can't think of how exactly to word the question, but basically it's that age old trope, A person who's all alone isolates themselves with knowledge...) What if Anakin and Satine fell in love ?(You've done Obi and Padme and Anakin and Ventress already) (A memey one taken seriously) What if It wasn't a Happy Landing? (Anakin, Palpatine, and Obi-wan all die when the Invisible hand crashed down on Coruscant) (this one is mainly legends) What if Darth Tenebrous killed Plaguies ? Thanks and love the great work
Really wished that you talked about ahsoka found out about the inibidor chips that would have been cool. Also what happened to count dooku and general grievous? did they do a rebelion or did they just chill
I feel like you could make a good story on either Darth Maul or General Grievous Discovering Anakin and raising him into a killing warrior and Anakin having a father/son bond which maul has been shown to protect family seen with savage he wouldn’t want harm to Anakin but maul would train him brutally and Grievous he would be more of a calmer Master along with a better Deulist Making Anakin be a better deulist then training with maul ever would grievous was stoic and bold to the ones he loved and kept them close so Anakin and him would be a lot closer then maul and him but still either idea is good
What if anakin met ashoka during his pad wan training and had a friendly rivalry What if starkiller (before facing darth Vader at the end of Star Wars force unleashed ) was alive during episode 3 and faced anakin on mustafar instead of obi wan What if Luke and leia used the world between worlds to travel back in time to episode 3 and stop the rise of the empire and bringing their father back to the light
Bravo bravo 👏👏👏 excellent story Ahsoka is my favorite character when she first appeared in 2008 in the clone wars movie she became of interest to me through out the clone wars she became my favorite character I like how you used the youngling from the clone wars episode might I suggest that since Ahsoka took the young rodian I think Kenobi would have take Petro or young kanan as a replacement. But again great story I loved it. What if mother talzin killed count dooku and Darth sidious
Have you thought about doing a what if Anakin had been born and Raised on Coruscant? Like he could even have been living with his mother in the 1313 area just so he wasn't living the carefree high life most on the topside of the planet did. I think it would be an interesting take.
I think this would have been a little more interesting if it would have been the normal timeline. The dynamic of Anakin having a train the real chosen one would have been interesting
Awesome video just a small nit pick sideous was not a duelist he was good but his main power was his force abilities I get kinda tired of people thinking he’s god trier and keep putting him in duels when he was stated as to not like dueling.I enjoyed the video has some spins that were interesting! What if qui gon left the order with Anakin and Obi wan (maybe he could redeem Dooku since they were old friends?)
I personally liked this story but read a few comments that do kinda make sense. You could've kill two or three birds with one stone. If you raised Ahsoka's age up close to Anakin's the two could've bonded and grown close as children. Then the padawans could've become more, not lovers they were to young then as the war progressed lovers they could become. Then if you really wanted to stick with anti-Anakin Sidious could've poisoned Anakin's mind and the duel of fates could've been the two beings thought to be the chosen one. Star Wars is all about those redemption arcs Anakin could then be redeemed by losing his life star wars style while helping Ahsoka fight Sidious.
hey friend love your content, however one suggestion i think you should implement is with the intro subscribe section, inplement it with the new subscription counter now that your at 13.5k it doesnt make sense to still use the 735 follower count
Yeah what if the night sisters had an alliance with the Jedi that would be interesting having two force groups helping each other.Almost like a republic but with just magic and force users.
If you think about it, she kinda is the chosen one. The Daughter...the pure imbodiment of the light side of the force, gave up her life essence to Ashoka. Making her the new Daughter of the force. Pretty sure the light side didn't extend itself that far to Anakin, and he was fairly easily swayed to the dark side. Ashoka was so perfectly balanced in the force, she was able to purify sith crystals. One would think that the force willed her into being the direct counter to the sith uprising...and she was a main player in their destruction.
Ngl you should do what if Ezra was the chosen one I mean its perfect and I can see some parallels Ezra-Anakin Kana-Obi wan I mean its a perfect what if
I have some what if ideas think you find interesting and fun to do and hope you like these ideas of my What if Plo Koon had a nephew What if Anakin Skywalker had a twin brother
Yes I know but want Plo Koon uncle have son and Sha Koon to have a twin brother thought interesting him being trained either Plo koon or Aayla Secure kinda like favor to Plo Koon for help getting her memories back or maybe master Yaddle because no ever use her in what if and feel she underrated and I always like Plo Koon with orange lightsaber more then his blue one don't know why but I do
How strong do you think this? Ahsoka is at the end of the story compare to Palpateen considering she was able to defeat three Mual Ventress and Sarvarge at the same time easily while he was able to to defeat mual and Sarvarge easily so who do you think it’s stronger? Also sorry for my pronunciation is spellings are incorrect
And if he trained the chosen one aka Ahsoka you probably would be more powerful than in the original timeline because he was training someone with such a high potential
Really feel you screwed Anakin in this for no reason. If there was another student that was younger than him that was just as talented or even more talented than him then when she was advanced Obi-wan would have looked into it and checked what kind of progress Anakin had made. This would have caused Obi-wan to notice that Anakin was also ready to advance and would have requested it. Instead Obi-Wan apparently never once checked on Anakin's progress and ignored the other obviously talented Youngling going through training as well. Also when Anakin finally did snap not only did Obi-Wan, Plo Koon, and Ahsoka never once ask him why the entire Jedi Council also never questioned him and kicked him out with no regard whatsoever. Yes, the Jedi of that Era were arrogant but they weren't stupid enough to not ask basic questions. Nor were they cruel enough to abandon Anakin without trying to figure out what happened.
So long story short it was a joke in high school, a couple people who kept a stalker away from me, I called them the Pente Patrol. I had a channel called The Anthony Pente Show (now Pente Patrol Reacts that's an inactive channel) and I decided to make a second and third channel.. this Pente Patrol Gaming and Anthony Music Production (AMP). Long-story-short I decided Gaming wasn't a passion thing like Star Wars. I made a bunch of vids private, focused on what if's and PPSW was born. :) My long term goal is to have a bunch of other channels with Pente Patrol in front of it. And eventually my music channel just called Anthony Pente. (I turned AMP into PPMP -- Pente Patrol Music Production)
@@PentePatrolStarWars thank you for getting back really quickly. I love how you’re name just came into being. You didn’t focus on trying to find a cheesy name. You went with your own inside joke. It’s nice to see!
