What if Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader Were DIFFERENT People? 

Vader: Your mother never told you what happened to your brother? Anakin: She told me enough... he died during childbirth. Vader: No, I am your brother. Anakin: No... that's not true, that's impossible!

What if anakin killed palpatine instead of telling mace windu about him?

The thing is Darth Plagueis would have felt the vergence of the Dark Side and likely would have been the one who'd raised the evil twin i.e Vader. Sidious finding him makes sense for sure but I'm pretty sure that it would have been Plagueis who found him.

This is a very interesting way to look at things. It’s like Anakin and Vader were like the Brother and Sister from Clone Wars that balanced the light and dark. 12:50 to 13:40 As this shows (like many other what-if scenarios) only together do the light and dark balance the Force, and therefore, life itself. 14:38 to 14:55 Anakin and Vader’s “Imperial Knights” were very similar to the ancient Ja-Daii Order, which taught the students to balance their light and dark sides and abilities. Anakin and Vader are (borderline) different personalities in canon. I know they’re the same person, but as Vader he’s selfish and a heartless killer, while he feels remorse and wants to do what is right as Anakin. So in a weird way, Anakin and Vader are different people.

In a way anakin and Darth vader both are the choosen ones meant to bring absolute balance to the force. As both of them would balance each other in the light and dark sides of the force, and bring balance between the jedi and the sith as both anakin and Darth vader can keep in check both the jedi and the sith. And in a way both being brothers balance each other out.

That Anakin-Vader Mustafar duel is the greatest lightsaber duel I've ever seen.

I cheered at this one. Anakin and Vader creating the Imperial Knights was an excellent twist. If Marvel can create a "What If..." series, Star Wars needs one as well. These alternate stories are fantastic.

The ending was too idealistic for me. I’d rather have the two brothers go there separate ways with the goal of improving both the republic and the empire to the point that they can reach peaceful co-existence. They’d still fight each other for awhile, but their hope would be strong enough to reach that dream

This is an ending for for anakin! It’s awesome. It feel like the best outcome for the galaxy. The Jedi and sith both go extinct…. And a new entity is born forged of both

Video idea: what if Anakin went back to the high republic via time travel or something

Interesting, because in this reality, Anakin never sees the nightmares of his mom and Padme dying. Which would lead to him not necessarily seeking power. He'd probably still kill the tusken raiders but he never fully commits to the dark side. Leading to the Jedi trusting him and giving him the rank of Master even though his apprentice never became a Jedi Knight.

this would make a great alternate universe star wars to explore.

Kreia, also known as Darth Traya, was a character in the video game "Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic II - The Sith Lords." She had a complex and nuanced view of the Force that differed from both the Jedi and the Sith. Kreia believed that the Light side of the Force was not inherently good, and that the Jedi's strict adherence to its teachings had blinded them to its true nature. She saw the Jedi Code as limiting and believed that it prevented its adherents from fully understanding the Force. In Kreia's view, the Light side of the Force was focused on selflessness and detachment, which she saw as a weakness. She believed that the Jedi's emphasis on selflessness made them vulnerable to manipulation by those who sought to exploit their altruistic tendencies. Kreia also believed that the Light side's focus on peace and tranquility was misguided, and that true understanding of the Force required embracing all aspects of it, including the darker aspects. Overall, Kreia's view of the Light side of the Force was complex and critical, reflecting her belief that both the Jedi and the Sith were flawed in their understanding of the Force. Kreia also had a complex view of the Dark side of the Force that differed from the Sith's traditional view. Kreia believed that the Dark side of the Force was not inherently evil, but rather a tool that could be used for good or evil depending on the intention of the user. She saw the Sith's embrace of the Dark side as a means of gaining power and control, but ultimately believed that it led to their downfall. In Kreia's view, the Dark side of the Force was focused on passion, emotion, and individuality, which she saw as strengths. She believed that the Sith's emphasis on these aspects of the Force gave them an advantage over the Jedi, who were often too detached and unemotional to fully understand the Force. However, Kreia also believed that the Dark side's focus on power and control was ultimately self-destructive, as it led its users to become consumed by their own ambition and desires. She believed that the true path to understanding the Force lay in finding a balance between the Light and Dark sides, rather than embracing one over the other. Overall, Kreia's view of the Dark side of the Force was complex and critical, reflecting her belief that both the Jedi and the Sith were flawed in their understanding of the Force, and that the true path to understanding lay in finding a balance between the Light and Dark sides.

Would be interesting to see Vader and Anakin both were trained as Jedi first before Anakin's brother would fall to the dark side while Anakin feeling a calling through the force after Order 66 and would travel to Atollan to learn from the Bendu

I wanna work on the theory: What if Anakin never became Darth Vader. Yours is amazing❤, but I wanna extend from Episode I to Episode VI! I've put notifications on, and I'll be there when I'm notififed. Good luck, this sounds like a challenge.

I think this is lowkey a better storyline than the actual series😂

OK, you got me. I like this one. Subscribed

You did an excellent job, and it was a good on this story, it was amazing, that you made Anakin have a twin brother...

Its sad that Anakin didnt remove Rex's chip like Ahsoka did

What if Dooku returned to the light at the battle of Geonosis?

fantasy folkore's channel is something incredible, like a What If Star Wars sereis that we never got, binge watching right now, love all the vids and voice impressions man

Another BANGER keep it going

Awesome video as always.

A part 2 is needed please

What if count dooko right before dying says palpitine is a sith lord

Ah yes... The Sith'Ari. The legend of the Dark Chosen One. A very nice piece of more obscure Starwars lore.

I just realized that Anakin and Darth Vader's new order os very similar to the "Je'daii" of old who used both the light and dark side of the force in perfect balance.

i rather enjoyed that mate, good job.....i find it odd that only 3k out of 64k views liked it though

This was the best!

This was an exceedingly curious "What if" story. nice job.

This was one of my favourites great work

Why is this so good

Nice my man 💪

Hey I wrote a story like this 😂 except that the two shared a body for awhile, I'm glad that this idea is being used because I've always wondered about it

Please make what if Anakin trained more on his force abilities than his lightsaber make what if Anakin was sent to kill do you know grievous and then Darth Maul killing three birds with one stone

I just wanna know the alternate take on, “You don't know the truth. Obi-Wan killed your father.”

Love this concept! And great job executing it💙💚

As fan and friend, this What if out of all the ones you've done over the series is by far the greatest and one that holds a special place in my life as a fan of Vader and Anakin. The idea of them being brothers and being two different people and how this story came together and in such depth you put into this struck a cord with me. The scene where the two learn of this and teaming up was bit teary eyed for me but knowing that Vader and Anakin being both the chosen ones to bring balance to the force was the best thing and I honestly would like to think that if it were to ever happen, this would go down as perhaps the great Star Wars What If film if ever made and it's inspired me a lot. I know I said about your What if Vader turned back early in that one fan fic you did was super well done but this one with Anakin and Vader being two different people and being twin brothers of two different sides of the force but united for the same thing took this to a whole new level and why this ranks at the top of my fave what ifs you've ever done that as left a super positive mark in the community. Well done.

I love how you come up with these what ifs that are not commonly touched upon despite the significance of the decisions being touched upon. I really enjoy listening to these theory's keep it up

Awesome! I still don't think light and dark can co exist in a group like that without ending in some horrible calamity.

I just noticed that Anakin's right hand isn't cybernetic in the thumbnail.

This would have made for a great movie

What If the Clones killed Anakin during Order 66

what if luke and leia weren't force sensitive

can't wait for next vid i am member now yay

I feel like if Vader was trained from birth by palpatine and had no injuries he would dog walk anakin in a fight and probably anyone else in the verse by ROTS (assuming he had the same potential as anakin)

This would be amazing.

Another Amazing what if! Great video! Friendly reminder, bc you said i should remind you: next the old republic what if with Meetra😊

In this timeline, Anakin probably wouldn't have killed Dooku since he was a jedi and Palpatine wouldn't try to get close enough to Anakin to persuade him into breaking jedi code

A great take on this saga. Nice.👏

Whoa, anakin and vader brothers. Noice my friend, noice! Twin Blades hmm I like that for a title for this fan fiction...

This is going to be epic

That’s a great fan fiction. Bravo!!

I really believe if this was done again but in like an audio drama type a great story of the use of the voice actors you've used before would make this really awesome as you had done with the story of what if Vader went back in time to save Padme.

one major issue in this is that sidious is incapable of killing Yoda

I mean the lie that "Anakin Skywalker died trying to protect Padme from Vader" could become true if they really were different.

Vader - no Luke I am your uncle Anakin - 🤣

I wonder who would win the full potential Anakin or his full potential twin???

What if Palpatine and Darth Sidious (Sheev) were two separate people? (example: Palpatine is a name of state, his true name is Cos Dashit. He's a weak-willed dullard with delusions of grandeur who had been elevated to Chancellor by Sidious. After Sidious's death following the end of the Clone Wars, he possess/manipulate Palpatine into becoming Emperor and eliminate the Jedi)

Excellent

this was wholesome

Best RU-vidr ever

Badass. Fan film someday gotta be done

lol, just born and already he's the most Evil Thing™ in the Galaxy, with a connection to the Dark Side that rivals fully fledged Sith Lords.

What if Jar Jar was the chosen one?

Question: is vaders suit now the same one he had after he burned or is it just a normal one that looks like vaders suit

A good vid.

Next video how about… what if Sidious cloned anakin dna to become Vader? That he’s doesn’t have to manipulate him but extracts his essence for new experiment.

I love this idea you should do one with general grevas

This is an interesting idea.

It feels very Dante and Vergil from DMC Also I sorta expected a fan fic revolving what Obi wan said in the ot how Vader was a pupil of his before he turned to evil and murdered Anakin, to go off that info and see how the story was shifted from that simple difference

You should do a what if anakin stayed a Jedi and obi-wan became a sith

This might be one of my favourite story's do think the battle with palps would not last that long though

I was not expecting this what if

What if Shimi was a jedi? (Video idea)

Great story

I love this FanFiction

Love the concept of this video, but I'm thinking, where is Mace in all this?

0:17 omg that's literally Gordon Ramsay as a baby, no wonder the dark side was strong in him

Darth Vader could've been a clone of Anakin Palpatine made in case if Anakin didn't turned to the dark side.

Instead of photo shopping two pictures to simulate Anakin and Vader fighting I would've suggested using footage from the PS2 game Revenge of the Sith since they are both playable in the versus mode. I can't take the fighting stickers seriously. It reminds me of the "If The Emperor Had A Text-To-Speech Device" parody series. If you're unfamiliar, give it a watch. Its hilarious and will cure any form of depression.

honestly id rather have this being the star wars story

😮 WOWERZ!

Darth Zion in alternate universe as Sidious master: " My mentor was Plagus, I finished him because he was stupid a shame. Sidious, there is no light nor dark side of the force there's only the force. Both sides of the force light and dark is an extension of our positive and negative emotions, a true Sith can use both sides of the forces flawlessly, I can even use Sith lightning without damaging my hands, I can use the dark side without losing my natural looks, I can cause both sides of the force to smile at me without turning against me. Power and control Sidious is pointless, your sense of humanity and logical thinking is what matters, that's what it means to be a living being, not destroying others for your own gain. If someone fall they fall by themselves."

What if Han solo turned kylo ren back to light side part 2

Plot whole: Palpatine doesnt recognize they are brothers even thought they are twins and Anakin is a well known hero. In all these years he doesn't know what Vader looks like? No curiosity over the fact that both of them are from Tatooine and around the same age? Two powerful vergences in the force, from the same place at the same time, around the same height but nothing? That's like throwing on a pair of glasses and tricking people into thinking you are a newspaper reporter from Kansas instead of a powerful alien who can leap tall buildings in a single bound.

If they were different people , why their lightsaber so similar? ( This question are base on this fanfiction , not related to the movies itself )

What if Anakin was adopted by his rich black uncle and moved into a big house

If he was a twin himself that would have made a good story plot

Vader won't have the mechanics and the mask if he was anakin's twin

I like this very nice

I was thinking the continuity was like Count Dooku turning into Vader, and he didn't have a sith name until the duel on Mustafar cuz he wanted to just be more of a grey jedi than a Sith during the Clone Wars...

Hmmm yeah I like this version lmaoo. This could be one hell of a fan made movie lol

But, what if Fives faked hes death to kill Palpatine himself (but then again, it would be an animated SW what if story, since Fives is a Clone wars character)

5:00 "...And surprising his superiors with his innovative strategies and impressive use of the force." And his many, many war crimes...

And thus, he felt annoyed in the presence of Skywalker. Which is what lead to the dark side. Along side the manipulation of Palpatine and that then caused the desperation of Anakin is what caused the death of Anakin Skywalker both metaphorically and literally.

Me: oh my god, you killed Obi Wan Stan and Kyle: You Bastard!

part 2 pls

Ok this leaves me with the question of what happens to ahsoka is she alive or dead Kanan probably remain the same and Ezra probably will remain on lothal and won't learn to harness the force

I do wonder if any of my what if Ideas might be done. The ones I like the most are number 1 (what if the sith empire returned during the high republic era), 2 combined with 8 (what if Jyn Erso survived met and fell in love with Luke), 3 (what if Padme was arranged to marry for the Republic), 4 for personal reasons (also it’s one of my predictions for the high republic era), 15 (what if the Yuuzhan Vong invaded during the high republic era) 19. (Because Luke X Ahsoka) and 43 (what if Padme was enslaved by the hutts during the clone wars)