What If Anakin Skywalker Told The Council About Darth Plagueis The Wise? 

Check out Ownasaber's INSANE Christmas sale before it runs out! - www.ownasaber.com/FantasyF

That was I think the biggest issue, Anakin couldn't trust the jedi council. And honestly, he had every right for that

Anakin “Have you never heard the tragedy of Darth Plagues the wise?” Jedi Council “No” Palpatine “ wait wait, I love telling this story it’s my favourite one”

The voice actors in this are absolutely phenomenal!! Great job to everyone who worked on this!

If we are to trust what Dooku experienced in his years with the Jedi after he became a master. ''Curiousity, a trait becoming less and less appreciated in the order'' we cannot rule out that the Jedi council might have dismissed the story of Plaqueis as a mere myth or story told from Sith to Sith and nothing more, the only part that might get them to think the matter over is that it was Palpatine who told the story. But that would also require them being able to become curious and wanting to investigate further, but at that point, the Jedi pretty much blindly followed their code and the war effort and nothing else.

What if Bo Katan joined the Protecters instead of the Death Watch? What if Thrawn became the Supreme Leader of the First Order? What if Ashoka Tano was raised by Mother Talzin? What if the Separatist Council discovered that Palpatine was Sidious?

What if Ahsoka was secretly a Sith Lord ? What if Luke and Leia were not Force sensitives ? What if the Death Star was never built ? What if Boba Fett never worked for the Empire ?

Palpatine: 'it was all AI, bro!'

here are my what if ideas carried over from last time, I think the sixth day of asking. 1) What if the Sith Empire Returned during the High Republic era? 2) What if Din Djaran and Bo-Katan fell in love during Mando season 3 and chose to become joint rulers of Mandalor 3) What if Han Solo was rescued from Jabba but Leia was unable to kill Jabba and was left behind whilst the others escaped meaning she remained a slave? 4) What if Padme was Enslaved during the Clone wars? 5) What if Cal and Merrin had a Daughter (for the fact it's a Jedi Nightsister hybrid)? 6) What if Avar Kriss and Elzar Mann had a child? 7) What if Padme was forced to marry for the Republic during the clone wars? 8) What if Jyn Erso survived Rogue one and went on to meet and fall in love with Luke Skywalker? 9) What if Luke and Leia found out they were siblings earlier and both became Jedi? 10) What if Leia finished her Jedi training? Merry Christmas to you all and a happy new year. Love to see one of these fir a Christmas gift but I understand if your busy or if you don’t have time. my personal favorites are 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 9, and 10

What if Plagueis killed Palpatine instead of Palpy killing him? So you know how the force creating Anikan was a response to their trying to manipulate the force and the force sort of struck back, what if the force didn't care and just let Plagueis and Palpy be?

Plo koon sounds like optimus prime and im here for it lol

Wowww big props to your Mace Windu voice actor! That guy was spot on

The Mace Windu actor is on point

What if Anakin looked after Bobba Fett after genosis

I am SO HAPPY that you did this. Was one of my old guilty questions when I first saw Revenge of The Sith. Day 19 of my list. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?

Windu: I knew I couldn't trust you! Anakin: I'll give you a new generation of powerful Jedi Windu: Ok no problem

The voice acting is excellent! And as always, the story never disappoints!

Windu was like...."I KNEW IT"😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

The problem with this story is that it requires Anakin to believe the council totally. He did not. Not only did Anakin not trust the council fully but Obi Wan had two minds on the council often having been trained by a roguish Jedi himself. Being told that the dark side never achieved such a thing is insufficient. This is why the original story line was so very good. If you remove such a subtle but important part of a story, you must replace it with something of equal weight or the new story is weaker.

Well Anakin did do his thesis on Darth Plagueis...

a truly fabulous job on the part of your voice actors! Well done!

I requested this one so thanks for doing it.

Amazing work in this story! I love that there are voice actors!

Holy crap, this might be the first time Bale Organa isn't selected to replace Palps as the chancellor in these Anikan never joined Palps scenario's. I do love these ones, I really don't think the council (except Mace) would have cared too much about Padme and don't think they would have exiled him. I think this is a pretty spot on reaction to the news the council would have had especially with Ki-Adi-Mundi having multiple wives.

The part where Palpatine tells Anakin about Darth Plagues the wise always bugged me. It's pretty clear that Palpatine is revealing his hand and admitting to being a Sith, and it's only at a point when he has sewn resentment in Anakin towards the Jedi council and he has Anakin to where he doesn't care about anything aside from saving Padme. In the story Plaguis had told his apprentice, who is clearly Palpatine everything that he knew about using the force, but he doesn't know how to use the power that he describes, and he also expans why he is not trustworthy.

Great vid!! Hey…”What If..Anakin remained a slave on Tatooine?” This is the way. I have spoken….

Props on the Mace voice acting

What if Ahsoka found out about order 66 and told anakin

Exceptionally nice work! Great storytelling and use of images.

Whoever is doing y'all's voice work is amazing

This is definitely one of, if not THE best fanfiction you wrote on this channel.

I've been watching your channel since you had maybe around 10k subs or so, crazy to see how far you've come man, Love the content and listening too all the stories on here always makes me wanna listen too more lol, keep up the awesome work my guy and have a great day🔥💯

The rub is that, by the time you are far enough into the dark side to keep people you care about from dying you are far enough into the dark side to not care about anyone dying.

i like how you put the most similar voices to the characters good job dude

Just imagining how he gets mad after they denied him the rank of master and to take a seat, but instead he says to Mace and the council, "Have you ever heard the tragedy of Darth Plagueis the Wise? It's not a story the Jedi would tell you."

Im not sure how you did the voices of the other council members, but they're the best I've ever heard

Mace Windu voice actor was on point

The voice acting on this is on point I like this , keep going man 🔥.

After Palpatines arrest would have been the perfect time for the force ghost of Qui Gon to address the council and convince them to change their ways to the old where they were keepers of peace through out the galaxy, to trust Anakin and the force, and to encourage attachment to bring balance

What if Anakin join Dooku in Geonoses What if Venrtess and Qui-lan Vos kill dooku settled down start family, achive balance in force and start new force order and train Luke, Leia, Mara Jade Galen Marek, cal cestis and Merrin ( Luke start family with Mara, Leia with Galen and Cal with Merrin)

2:53 Chris helmworth: palpatine have a seat sorry I had to

"What if" the love of Qui-Gon's life didn't die?

Other than Windu, these Jedi Council voices are great. Brilliant work.

This was SO GOOD!!!

Ayy, Anakin does very well when people actually support him and involve him in plans and discussions !

Fantasy folklore first of all thanks for another awesome what if you bring us fabulous🙌 secondly, did you get my comments yesterday? Just because of a what if has more likes or views doesn’t mean it’s the strongest, most powerful version of Anakin Skywalker, or any other character, right Also, I still remember the time you told me what ifs of what if Anakin Skywalker went to the wellspring of life and what if Anakin Skywalker went to ahch to,they will be released in December or January so I can calculate or theorize, that what if Anakin Skywalker was trained by the force itself? And what if Anakin Skywalker was Jedi Sentinel? At the end of January, and the beginning of February Or am I mistaken? I know there are so many what is on your list I know I just wanted to make a guess. Is that OK?😊 Well I should go have a nice day My friend👋

What if the Jedi Council listened to Qui-Gon and more jedi went to Naboo with him

Star Wars has so many If scenarios which gives it endless possibilities and scenarios

2:46 ,,Yes anakin, but HOAE?"

Love this! and it makes me wonder...What if Palpatine was brought before the senate and this recording was played for ALL the republic to hear?

I enjoyed this video. The voice acting was excellent.

I enjoyed this video alot and think that there's room for it to be expanded upon. What about ahsoka tano. Does she return to the jedi order to complete her training and take up the path of the jedi wayseeker or not. What of the crime syndicates that maul was in the process of uniting. What of the mandolrians, the darksaber and deathwatch. You could make it into 2 or 3 episodes of about 15-20 minutes each. This story is entertaining and well worth the time and effort to make. It was also more than worthy of my time to watch it. I just whish Disney love star wars as much the content creators on RU-vid do. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

He wrote his Jedi thesis on this!

Day 38: What if General Grievous was secretly a Republic spy?

"Darth Plagueis the WHAT?"

Great Video 😊

Darth Plaguise really achieved it he used midichlorain manipulatipn to ressurect the dead body of his rival Darth Venamis so that Darth Plaguise can have entertainment by torturing the ressurected rival

Near the very end where he gets the rank of master I was getting crazy Optimus Prime vibes from the voice acting

I feel like this dialogue would have been very plausible if Anakin let go of his need to control the situation and through his duty to the Jedi he trusted the council. What's also compelling about this situation is in either case he still brings balance to the force. Good or bad

I always imagined that Palpatine probably had a plan to flee and take control of the separatist army and try to directly conquer the Republic if a scenario like this happened.

What if Obi Wan fell in love with Padme instead of Anakin

Anakin vs Windu would be an insane fight

10:30 Imagine how a Obi Wan felt, knowing the boy he trained, reached his full potential

For me, Anakin's happy ending would involve a battle 1v1 against Sidious after overcoming his insurance, trusting the Force, remembering Jinn and coming clean to the counsil about his marriage and seeing for the best to leave the Order. And now he could live with his wife and children. Seeing as the Chosen One, and the influence of Jinn view kver the Force, the council would realize the attachment to the Republic grew too far and now on would return to it's roots instead of a Republic everyday work force. With clones and other regular forces, they would have enough even to look upon Hutt territory. Maybe in a campaign to free slavery Galaxy. After all, it's Star WARS. After that, well... Who can tell what would happen.

Of course he told the council of Darth Plagueis the Wise. He wrote his Jedi Thesis on the use of dichotomy within the tale.

The fact that Anakin was willing to risk everything and reveal about Padme, likely made Windu more trusting of him. Honesty goes a long way and this would been true with a person like Windu.

THIS WAS INSANE

This is a amazing video

What if Anakin tried Life cereal and he likes it?

THe picture is so funny at 9:51

"I thought not. It's not a story the Jedi would tell you. It's a Sith legend." "Wait. How do _you_ know a Sith legend?"

I wonder if Maul forms his own Sith Order afterward. He was not trained to become a true Sith, but is still the last of those trained under Sidious. Ventress is also out there, but she has learned to embrace balance through both sides of the Force, and has personally redeemed herself.

I, always wondered what Luke life would be like. In, a timeline where the jedi order never feel, and Luke was raised in the jedi order. Obviously, he'd become super powerful, being he has chosen one potential. But, I'm hoping for a more descriptive answer.

Where could I get the picture you use at the end

Anakin: Dear Grand Master, dear members of Jedi Council, have you ever heard the tragedy of Darth Plagueis the Wise? Mace: Take a seat, young Skywalker. Kiadi: What about the Droid attack on the Wookies? Yoda: Go, I will. Good relations with the Droids I have. Mace: It's settled then. Council dismissed.

What if Anakin was resurrected in the Sequel trilogy in his episode 3 look? (Prior to the battle of Mustafar look.)

And lastly, fantasy folklore are these what ifs on your list what if quinlan vos trained Anakin Skywalker what if Anakin Skywalker became Jedi battle master what if the clone army was force sensitive? And also because your friends and pals with pente patrol why not make what if young Anakin Skywalker reached his full potential and many of his others in your own way because if anyone can do it is you, my friend because out of every Star Wars channel you are my number one my favorite really ☝️👍

5:52 I feel like this point, Papa Palps would have sniffed out Anakin’s treachery. “They don’t trust you, because you’re a traitor, aren’t you Anakin?” Force-spin (just like the Ep III confrontation), lightsaber right through the stomach, Anakin dies. “How ironic…” (end scene)

What if anakin was piloting before attack of the clones and sensed ventress fall to the darkside as her master died and took his ship to the planet to investigate. Perhaps starting a romance as they are very similar in their stories. Also what if ahsoka taught ben skywalker as she saw him as history repeating itself. What if anakin was a jedi watchmen or wayfinder. What if anakin went with kenobi to face maul and savage instead of adi gallia. What if anakin fell in love with luminara or your own version of aayla secura romance. What if oppo rancis trained anakin. What if anakin met and fell in love with ventress just before the clone wars just after her masters death. What if anakin became a jedi sentinel like a watchmen or one of those who find younglings. What if evan piel became a mentor or second master to anakin. Or anakin became a healer either before or after his mother death could be related to his friendship with offee or alternatively what if he was trained by tra sa who taught windu and actually did not forbid attachment as shown by her relationship with tholme , they could become like a pseudo parents to anakin and train him away from the temple in azati martial arts and from trasa the living force as she is a plant lady so imagine anakin controlling plant life.

What if Quinlan Vos Trained Anakin Skywalker?

What if Mace had pocket sand?

I think a side effect of this would be to allow jedi to have families/relationships/children. Good video. It's kinda sad seeing how close Anakin was to a longer being happy.

It would have been funny if upon hearing that anakin and padma are married, Mace mentioned that he just lost a bet because of him.

What if Anakin was in full control and took over the Jedi and Sith Order?

you should add "and then darth vader woke up" at the end of the theory

I have one question how did the council find out about the clones and order 65 ?? U forget this part and its very important...

What if the droids rebelled against the cis

What if when Count Dookoo cut off Anakin's arm in attack of the clones he got the same model as General Greevis.

I love this story

What if Count Dooku decided to "adjust the plan" by having the Separatists use clones instead of droids due to embarassing defeat at Battle of Naboo where droids couldn't beat primitives and ragtag resistance, thus forcing the Republic to make due with mass conscription?

It seems more likely that an arrested Palpatine would argue in his trial that the recording was fake news and, given that he had replaced much of the apparatus of government during his time as Chancellor, have a reasonable chance of being acquitted.

Vader is such a relatable villain, he turns to the dark side out of desperation to save the woman he loves, he damns himself in the hope that she might be saved, of course we know how it turns out, but could any of us say we would do any different if we had the risk of losing someone we loved? I love Vader as a villain because he is so relatable, he's the type of villain who you look at and think there but for the grace of god I go. I love a good villain with a good backstory besides the dull I'm evil because evil.

What if Anakin Skywalker fell in love with Bo-Katan

Does anyone know the music that starts at 07:38 ? I've been looking everywhere for it.

Plagius was presented to Anakin as legend not as fact. Palpatine wasn't specific as to when Palgius existed. The only thing he could say was "Palpatine told me this weird story." It doesn't follow from what Palpatine told Anakin that he must have relations with the Sith. He could have heard the rumor from anywhere. If I tell a story I heard about Bigfoot it doesn't mean I have inside knowledge of Bigfoot.

What if Darth Vader returned in episode IX instead of Palpatine

I have a hard time imagining Palpatine wouldn't sense Anakin's emotions being a bit off

What if Anakin wasn't burned on Mustafar and kept most of his potential?

What if Tarkin joined the Rebellion with the end goal of overthrowing Palpatine and replacing him as Emperor? What if Mon Mothma joined the Empire and became Grand Moff?

What if Padme cheated on Anakin with Jar Jar