What if Buddy and Jovie sang I Won't Say I'm In Love? (Mikey Mousaw and Katie Nieto) 

Mikey Mousaw and Katie Nieto played Buddy and Jovie (Elf: The Musical) singing I Won't Say I'm In Love (Hercules) at What If? Part 5, at 54 Below on August 11th, 2024.
What If your favorite musical theater characters switched songs for a night? (@whatiftheseries on instagram)
Music director/creator: Jorden Amir (@jorden.amir)
Guitar: Kenji Golden
Bass: Lindsay Rosenberg
Drums: Ethan Gueldenzopf
Filmed by Famous In New York