What if Cappy Chose the Other Head? [Pilot Ep.1] 

If you take suggestions, then I've got one for the Kirby series. What if Kirby was hit with a Jamba Heart?

This story is actually great! I like the concept of captures taking energy instead of just being a random thing.

I like where this series is going! This is extremely promising!!

Ngl I feel like this would make more sense(especially when realize that Cappy's ghost form looks similar to Bowser's hat).

Time… Space… Reality… It’s more than a linear path, It’s a prism... Of endless possibility, Where a single choice can branch out into infinite realities... Create alternate worlds from the ones you know… I am the watcher, I am your guide to these vast new realities, Follow me, and ponder the question... What if…?

This seems like a fun series so far, looking forward to more!

This was so cool! Cappy makes for an interesting villain and it's cool to see what would happen if he teamed up with Bowser and if Tiara helped Mario. I also really liked how the Cloud Kingdom and Ruined Kingdom were more substantial in the story, something I wish the original game did. I really hope you continue going in this direction with your content, you're a great storyteller!

I hope Nintendo sees this

This would make a sick mod! I wish that we could play this alternative story

There should be a game called "Shy Guy Oddysey" where you at first have a normal shy guy mask at the start, and you are in this dreamlike reality. It's a red shy guy with his friends, like other shy guys, Wart, Mowser and Birdo, and of course his girlfriend Shy Gal. They have veggie fights using Warts veggie spitting machine, then they do a little weeding, and have fun throwing weeds at each other. Whilst they are, Shy Guys finds a potion, he throws it and a door appears leading them into a Shadowy 2D section, then somebody locks them in, so they dig and did the sand, until they find the sacred emergency key. Which picking up is used as a flag for when your in a serious emergency, shy guy picks it up and Phanto comes to the rescue, informing him that Mario had locked them in and stole the machine, he also kidnappen Shy Gal. He then wore phanto for his journey and the key untrapped them. Mario had seen a few mushrooms comne out of the machine too, so he had stole it. You needed to use Phanto to capture your enemies, and also capture friends like capturing Yoshi instead of Birdo and you capture ladybugs in the tutorial to climnb really high and fast. You residents like shy guys and some friends like Wart and Mowser. And you must take down Mario and his living mask, the Mario Mask from Majora's Mask and throws turnips sometimes, to restore that veggie machine and save shy gal. During the game you get cherries and red coins as currency. You can customize your shy guy colour and also your mask, so you could have a sniffit phanto mask, or have the majoras mask, or a Corona Mask. And the 2D bonus areas, are like the bonus areas in smb2 and you enter them by finding magic special doors. You get the jist

Level Up: What if Mario ate 'dese sus-shrooms and/or had these powerups SMG4: What if Mario ran out of toilet paper, and other toilet humour Nin10doland: *Tells this (True meaning of) epic oddysey story that could have happened and gets us hyped for Mario Oddysey 2 an- all. Starting this very epic video series*

Nintendo: write that down WRITE THAT DOWN!!!

What if Luigi’s Odyssey, King Boo kidnaps Princess Daisy and Luigi has to save her with his new friend Capster.

this plot would make a good base for an odyssey 2

I enjoy watching Marvels What If, and this series was a great idea! Keep up the great work!

Idea - what if bowser was a hero and Mario was evil?

I have been waiting for someone to make a Nintendo what if for a long time

I LOVE this MCU inspired video and I want more nintendo what ifs. what if red agreed to join team rocket on nugget bridge? what if link decided NOT to wake the wind fish? what if samus' parents were never perished. I want this so bad. If you haven't thought of one of those what ifs please make them. no credit nessicary. I NEED THESE VIDEOS

Idea: What If… King Dedede was the protagonist and Kirby was the villain? That would be interesting to see.

Wish this was how Odyssey played out.

I hope Nintendo does something like this in super Mario odyssey 2

More Suggestions: -wWhat if Kamek took the other Baby (Baby Luigi in Yoshi's Island) -What if Yoshi's Island was about Baby Peach riding Birdo, or Baby Bowser being carried by Kamek and then being dropped and riding Rex) -What if Birdo was in Yoshi's Story, or Yoshi was in smm2 (It's funny how Birdo is Yoshi's GF, although yoshi thinks Birdo's minions, the shy guys taste yummy) -What if there was another 3D switch game released that was inspired by SMM2 -What if Frisk had a different soul colour in Undertale or what if in Undertale you play as Asriel and fall into the light world (Undertale is technically a Nintendo Game) -What if in Deltarune they didn't fall into Dark World just because of a monster who ate chalk and a human who couldn't talk (Yes, they save a whole world, just because of a monster who eats chalk [so they had to get the chalk from the closet] and a human who couldn't talk [So he/she couldn't tell on her to stop them from going in the closet])

This is a very promising series. This version of the story reminds me of Paper Mario: The Origami King.

“If Zelda never fell off Skyloft in Skyward Sword”

in episode 2 you could make what if peach was the hero

The living caps (whatever they're called) seem to each have a boo in them or something, and seem spirit like, and how they aren't the worn caps themselves, but they control other non-living caps, in order to then control something else Double capture haha 😀. Like it's a spirit going into a cap lol. Kinda remindsme of the kwamis in mircaulous ladybug lmao! 😆

Yeah, I Remember When Knuckles Used Tiara To Capture Kirby And Kill Stewie Griffin

My god this was good! I hope maybe a potential Odyssey 2 will have a similar story to this!

Some parts don't feel Nintendo-like, but this isn't supposed to be anyways so great job!

THIS WAS SO ENTRETAININGGGG Cant wait to see more Mario What Ifs 👀

Then the game probably wouldn’t be E for everyone ;)

Honestly, I feel like Nintendo should do alternate universes of a few of their games now, this being the first. I say Nintendo should make it because we know how much they hate fan games.

If someone had the time and determination to mod this What If story into Odyssey, then I am playing that without a freaking doubt.

This is so cool! I would love if this was a game!

This is far too complex and story-based for anything that Nintendo would ever do with any first-party game, much less a Mario platformer.😅 Even Paper Mario in its prime wasn't even remotely this intricate with its story. A for effort though, but maybe tone your imagination down a bit next time to something more realistic for a Nintendo game.

When will you continue this??

I think the ancient threat could be named top bonneter he could have tried to destroy the planet but failed by being sent the the dark side of the moon and when bowser landed the crystal cracked thus letting him escape and continue with his plans(note his world ending plans could have taken place during ancient time during the year 1576 and the odyssey could have been top bonneter’s old ship and that’s probably why it looked so beaten up.

What if Bowser Jr wasn't raised by Bowser?

Wait wasn’t Tiara already captured when Mario was battling Bowser? Bc if so then the beginning makes no sense

When they try to copy marvel what if... but it's better then marvel what if: Marvel : You are hired.

Idea (Splatoon 1, 2 and dlc): what if agent 3 said no, or, never existed in the first place?

What if Metroid prime 4 actually happened

I like this because come on, this isn't the first time Mario teamed up with female characters before to rescue Peach. 😅

Wow! Great video. I can also see a similar recreation of "Bowser's Inside story" as the second part

This actually sounds better than the actual game. Nice job, dude!

somebody shoud turn this into a mod

Well now Nintendo doesn't need a story for odyssey 2

on par with The marvel show. The twist blew my mind. this is amazing

What's your intro music?

But isn't Tiara captured at the beginning of the game

Great video and an idea What if Paper Luigi was in Paper Jam?.

Make what if link never rested for 100yrs in botw

litterly if this were a mod i would play this

So basically I decided to plan a what would happen if Bowser didn't come to marry Peach...but something far worse. So here it is! Cap kingdom: Our story begins above the skies of the Mushroom Kingdom like the original Odyssey game, but Bowser didn't come to marry Peach. Bowser came along to destroy the kingdom and kill Mario...unlike the original Odyssey, Mario manages to escape as he climbed into one of the airships (the one from Super Mario Bros: Wonder) and tries flying off into the distance. But Bowser shoots a bullseye bill straight at the airship which cuases the engine to overheat and explode: causing Mario to plummet to the surface quickly, Bowser knowing well Mario is still alive decides to travel down to the Cap Kingdom so he could find him abd finish him off. Meanwhile in the kingdom of Bonnenton, the cap kingdom. Cappy rules the kingdom as it's king...keeping the union between the other kingdoms stable and taking care of his baby sister Tiara. At the end of the day, Cappy notices an airship crashing into the field outside of Bonnenton. He discovers Mario hidden underneath the ruins of the airship while he was still alive...both of them begin talking about their experiences and getting closer together...meanwhile in downtwon Bonnenton...several of Bowser's airship began attacking the Cap Kingdom, but luckily for the Cap Kingdom Cappy had already formed an army just in case of scenarios like this. Bowser's soilders win in the end but both sides are damaged in the end...the koopa king begins going on a rampage throught the streets of the Cap Kingdom capturing the bonneteers who weren't quick enough who weren't quick enough to flee into their house, without Cappy noticing the koopalings rush towards Bowser clinging to Tiara who was continuously bawling trying to get out of their grasp...eventually they get sucked into the mothership via a laser (like a UFO in movies). Then suddenly Cappy notices the Koopalings entering the mothership holding poor Tiara as it slowly begins travelling towards the Sand Kingdom...Cappy, knowing well that he'll never see his little sister again starts to break down knowing well that he had failed to protect his people and more importantly Tiara. Mario deocdes to comfort him and persuaded him that both of them will save Tiara from the evil koopa king...Cappy starts cheer8ng up as both of them decide to team up together. And thus Mario and Cappy begin running towards the Hat Tower, once they arrived at the Hat Tower and entered inside...they found a frog and Cappy explained to Mario about his capture abilities. Mario uses Cappy to capture the frog and they go on their merry way. While jumping through the tower they encounter enemies like Mini Goombas, Koopa Troopas and Hoppycats...qfter a quick advebture Cappy and Mario travel to the top of the tower and then they notice a strange portal appear at the very top and Lemmy appeared from the portal and the forst boss fight started...Lemmy throws Bobombs, balls or saws at Mario while constantly using his ball to bounce all over the place. After every pound on the head Lemmy enters his shell and vertically dashes across the arena. Eventually after three hits Lemmy is defeated and Mario and Cappy use an electrical line that appeared after the boss fight and they travel to the Cascade Kingdom along with several Bonneteers to give them a brand new home. To be continued

What if Mario Odyssey had this in the form of a New Game +

I'd really like to see a full game of this, it's such a good idea!

Super Mario Odyssey: Hard Mode DLC

Wait...this sounds like the origami king plot...

in a nother universe, this is the normal mario oddysey.

10:28 Did anyone else see the Mare on the Moon

Ello mate. I got some ideas or a What if... episode. What If: Bowser captured peach in Super Mario 3D World? What if: F.L.U.U.D was never found in Super Mario Sunshine? What if: Mario was never shot down to the Lost Kingdom in Super Mario Odyssey?

What if Link got controlled by Gannon

I would love to see second part of this

Have any of you heard of hyper Metroid ?

This story is way better than the original

IS THIS GONNA A GET A PART 2 OR WHAT?!?!?!

This needs to be Mario Odyssey 2: Warped Time!

Not my own original idea, but I saw a comment from one of Ragged Knowledge's community posts which asked us what we would like to see from a Nintendo What If? Original commenter was Gil Olaes, who asked, What if Fox McCloud was orphaned and taken up by the Chozo instead of Samus?/What if Samus after losing her parents to Ridley founded her own "Star Fox" like team?

PLEASE!!Make a part two❤

Next episode what if mario’s mansion

I do genuinely like this concept, but I feel like the new boss battles are a bit too complex for a new Mario Odyssey. Maybe for the king lakitu fight, it could be like the mechawiggler boss, where you use the lakitus to throw spinies at king lakitu to knock its crown off before ground-pounding him. For the Lord of lightning fight, maybe make it like the Knuclotec fight, where you have to ram Lord of lightning bowser to knock him into the pillars while dodging his lightning attacks. These are all just how I would do these bosses though. I'm amazed that you even went out of your way to think of these new bossfights in the first place!

This'll be an epic series

Wow that was incredible! I was closing my eyes and could imagine what the actual game would look like! When peach escaped, it could be like paper Mario where peach sections of the story happened. This was actually amazing, I really hope you do more in the future this was awesome!

I don't like that Cappy was able to overtake Bowser in the Cap Kingdom or that HE got to conquer the kingdoms Bowser visited. The Koopa King would NOT accept a deal where he's essentially just doing Cappy's legwork. Cappy should have still defeated Bowser's fleet at high cost, but been defeated by the king himself as no matter what he possessed to fight him with Bowser was still more powerful, even defeating all four Cap-tured Broodels and their Mama 5 on 1 when Cappy's generals tried to help. Cappy tries to possess Bowser, but the Koopa King anticipated the maneuver after seeing how Cappy would always possess his minions by landing on their head and conjured a giant brick ball above his head which he slammed into the Cap Prince like a steel chair in a wrestling match, defeating him in a single mighty blow. Seeing use in the Bonneters' possession powers, Bowser offers Cappy mercy if he becomes his vassal and helps him steal the treasures for his wedding. Not exactly having a choice, Cappy accepts, but he wants to go further and outright conquer the kingdoms on Bowser's "shopping list". While the general idea sounds good to Bowser he doesn't find the smaller kingdoms like Lost or Cloud worth conquering, considering them mere table scraps, but Cappy is more than happy to rule them himself.

Someone needs to make a odyssey mod for this

This reminds me of a certain marvel show....🤣

Bro I wish that was what the game was like. I mean I did like the way how Nintendo did it but your way was more creative

ngl, if cappy was a evil lackey, then he would have WAY more interesting dialogue. like:"your show ends here, mustache."

Dude this is great

This is my first time watching these mario what if videos AND I ALREADY LOVE IT keep up the awesome work my guy👍

this is so much better than whatever Marvel was trying to do with What If. Don't get me wrong I love the series but they're just answering the wrong questions in that show. This is something the fans would really like to see play out.

Nintendo what if idea: What if bowser and Mario switched roles (Mario and Luigi would kidnap peach and bowser would save her)

He would still know Tiara because Bowser had both and used Tiara for Peach

This is really creative

Is this a marvel what if...? Parody?

Nintendo What If? Ideas: 1: What if.... Bowser Stole the Banana Hord from Donkey Kong? 2: What if.... Mario Was Kidnapped by the X-Nauts instead of Peach? 3: What if.... Princess Daisy Was Kidnapped by Count Bleck? 4: What if.... Pit and Dark Pit Swapped Places? 5: What if.... Cackletta Won? 6: What if.... Sora Came to the Mushroom Kingdom? 7: What if.... Diddy and Cranky Kong Were Captured by King K. Rool instead of Donkey Kong? 8: What if.... Bowser jr. Became a New King? 9: What if.... Kirby Became Corrupted? 10: What if.... Link Was Brainwashed instead of Zelda? 11: What if.... Nintendo Heroes and Villains Swapped Roles? 12: What if.... The Shroobs Won? 13: What if.... The Dark Star Become Dark King K. Rool? 14: What if.... Antasma and King Olly Teamed up? 15: What if.... Ganondorf, Not Bowser Stole the Star Rod? 16: What if.... Sonic Saved Princess Peach? 17: What if.... Link and Sora Swapped Places? 18: What if.... Cackletta Become Dimenletta? 19: What if.... Fawful Save King Mickey? 20: What if.... Peach. Daisy and Rosalina Were Raised Together? 21: What if.... Antasma Helped the Snowmads? 22: What if.... Mobius Lost it's Hero? 23: What if.... Infinte Become Good? 24: What if.... Wario Meet F.L.U.D.D? 25: What if.... Kamek Kidnapped the Wrong Baby? 26: What if.... Rosalina Rescued Mario and his Friends? 27: What if.... Daisy and Luigi Were kidnapped by King Boo instead of Peach and Mario? 28: What if.... Pokemon Rescued the Sprixie Princesses?

I have 2 ideas for what ifs. 1. What if... Zelda slept for a 100 years. 2. What if... Taranza took kirby

I Like This Video, But There's Still One Unanswered Question *What If...?*

Episode idea: What if Giovanni had defeated Red in Pokémon Red/Blue?

This series is amazing!!!

The story is so complex it feels more like a mario rpg. Not that I'm complaining

After the intro I was like, did u click the wrong video, because I wasn't paying attention to the intro

Nintendo hire this man

The broodle bot reminds me of a mixture of the ghostly galaxy boss who i cant remember the name (the one where you had to throw bomb boos at him) and the mecha broodle

cool idea! but i have an idea. there could be sections where you can play as peach/bowser just like in paper mario!

this needs to be a mod

I think the Nintendo needs to move on from What If’s and get down to business. It’s time we start packing a punch again

If you are taking request I don't know if this is going to make a big change but what if luigi was the main character 🤔

This how I want Odyssey 2 to be like, Mario and Cappy vs Bowser and a evil bonetter

When I first read that title I thought “other head” meant something else 😳 Magical Condom.