What If Shadow Didn't Break Infinite - Sonic What Ifs 

Please before you comment READ THIS because I'm sick of correcting people Infinite's real name is NOT Zero. That is a FANMADE name. According to Ian Flynn, he asked Sega what Infinite's real name was so that he could use it in the Sonic Forces prequel comic and SEGA told him that Infinite's real name was just Infinite.

You know, there’s something ironic about having Shadow, a creation of the Robotnik family, be the one leading the charge against Eggman. (Talk about your awkward family reunions.)

Epiloge: After the defeat of Metal Sonic, Null Space ceases to exist. Eggman falls from the sky and lands back into his old base, letting out a dull "Ouch."

I can totally see this version of infinite joining team dark as they’re 4th member

I’ve been watching your Sonic vids for the past week or so and they’re honestly of stellar quality, especially for such a small channel. This concept for a potential new Sonic What If series isn’t exactly original, but the more I’ve thought about it the more intriguing it becomes: What If Dr. Eggman stayed as Mr. Tinker? Now I know the events of Mr. Tinker and beyond are within the IDW comics and not the games, but it is confirmed that the IDW series is canon to the game continuity, so it wouldn’t be out of left field to make something out of those comics. Part of the idea came from a fan-comic based on this concept as-well as a dub of it. I’d imagine Eggman’s willingness to ditch his old life would mostly likely chalk down to him losing spectacularly in Sonic Forces, where the one time he succeeded conquering the world for 6 months was shattered by Sonic and The Resistance in only a few days, in addition with the genuine admiration and positivity he’s garnered from the Windmill Village residents as Mr. Tinker after the fact. Starline, Rough and Tumble however, wouldn’t be having any of it, especially after all the effort and dedication they’ve put in to this whole plan to try and bring back the old Eggman. Capturing Metal Sonic shortly later, Starline makes a slight readjustment to his programming to make him align with Starline after the figurative death of Eggman. Mr. Tinker treks back to Windmill Village and tells everyone (including the Chaotix and the rest of the Sonic crew present) what occurred when he was kidnapped. Sonic’s thrilled to hear Eggman truly deciding to turn over a new leaf, but Shadow is highly skeptical. The rest of it though, I’ll leave you to decide.

I loved this whole thing. I would’ve never imagined this would be so good or all the turns this what if took, but I would make one change: a more obvious and impactful final boss fight like every other Sonic game. That’s all I have to say.

Awesome video bro! And did you know that as Sonic is a LOZ fan Infinite is basically Sonic's version of Skull Kid/Majora's Mask? And when people first saw Sage in the trailer they actually thought she was Infinite's daughter but since Sega likes to make Zero sense with Eggman being her father. People now say he would be a second father figure to her. People even said that Sage looks like a mix between Infinite and a Seedrian like Cosmo.

Yoooooooo I'm in love with this video, The writing, The dialogues a S-tiers omg The Voice-Acting, one man only carring the whole cast so perfectly, I had a BLAST Thank you so much

Glad to have helped with the thumbnail!

Meanwhile Egggman: So uh.... Oh I know! SEGA! SEGA! BRING ME BACK! U CANT MAKE ANY MORE SONIC GAMES WITHOUT ME! SEGA?! SEGA!..... Welp there goes our franchise.

Honestly this seems like the best outcome Sure Infinite cant Dragon Balls people back to life(though the emeralds can) but with the Phantom Ruby's power he could use his illusions to rebuild the world back to what it was before Eggman took over

Epilouge: Infinite was kicked out of the resistence shortly after these events after interrupting Shadow's binging of Kill La Kill to show him the contents of his Sonadow file.

4:39: So Infinite never gets to meet his true love, Ian Jr? Truly tragic.

IDW hire these men

Also idea coming your way What if the master emerald was gone In this au the master emerald is permanently destroyed Except for one shard that contains a surprise for sonic aka the person who will be holding on to the shard Knuckles would blame sonic for it all even though sonic was trying to help (This could take place at any appropriate time) Sonic being the the only one to find and hold on to the last shard he soon discovered inside the shard contained no other then Tikal the echidna Seeing as how the master emerald and chaos were no more she promised to protect sonic and his friends from now on That's all I got The rest is up to you

0:23 I got jumpscared by myself because I forgot I suggested this

I did like infinite more here than in the video game, but I still enjoyed the music from the game.

This was great By the way I kinda wanted to ask you about your opening of this series One of the parts where knuckles is standing in front more echidnas Is that a video idea you guys are planning?

Now this would've been a much better story

This is literally the best story ever If only this could have been sonic forces

I like to see other franchise get what if!

Or what if Dracula becomes the main villain in smash bros ultimate!

If shadow didn't call infinite weak will sonic forces be different game

7:56 I was half expecting Infinite to reply, "criminal? You mean like you, Mr.Property Damage?" Just a small jab at some of Sonic's exploits, like City Escape and all of Unleashed.

Lemme just say, I loved EVERYTHING about this "What If"! though the only thing that I thought didn't make sense was, Infinite lost his squad to Shadow who supposedly killed them... if that is still the case here, why would Infinite accept to be recruited into the resistance with Shadow? surely he would hate his guts after what happened! the only thing I could think of to make sense of this would be that Shadow didn't kill them, and just left them like he did with Infinite. and the squad would leave Infinite because they thought he wasn't worthy of a leader because he couldn't take on Shadow. either my theory is correct, or what's the deal?

I could definitely see Infinite be in the IDW Comics

You earned my subscription

Umm Dude not to be that guy But his real name is zero Zero the jackel Infinite is the name he was given after being given the power of the phantom ruby

Your voice acting is incredible and the What If is amazing

We need more what ifs like this one

Awesome video bro! Infinite's real name is Zero.

I want this to be a game or at least a remake of a game like you know call it I don't know Sonic forces ultimate or something

What if Dracula from Castlevania become the ruler of all hell/underworld.

this was really good! there was another guy who did sonic what ifs but idk what happened to him

His name isn’t Infinite, It’s Zero the Jackel. He only became Infinite when he put on that mask.

Good video but one thing I would change is infinite’s name the reason he’s called infinite in sonic forces is because of the Jackal he became which is why he says in the main game *you may call me infinite* not *my name is infinite* but to give him a regular name you called refer to him as Zero jackal as Zero is his real name

Piz continue with what if shadow Didn't broke infinite

What if Tanic was a official character?