What if Shiny Froakie and Frogadier Looked Like Shiny Greninja  

I think to make it have a bit more color variety you should've put red on the bubble scarves like tongue scarf

I feel like you should’ve made the bubble scarf red like shiny greninja’s tounge

I like how Froakie and Frogadier look like they're from a 1920s cartoon and how shiny Greninja looks like he's about to go on a stealth mission.

I think you should've gone with a near black Grey rather than straight black. It just looks a bit too dark

The black and white on Froakie makes it look like an old timie cartoon and I low key love

If you gave froakie red hands it would look like Joker from Persona 5

The eyes on greninja were red so perhaps the pre-evolutions would’ve looked better with red eyes.

I like the original shiny evolution line more, because it gets darker as closer they get to become Dark Type

Could you do colors variation for Froakie's line based on venomous frogs?

I kinda like how this shiny path works, it’s like their slowly turning for freakiest shiny to greninja shiny, freakiest is light at first, fragsduer is both light and dark, greninja is then all dark with little light accents at the top

It can't have that lonely stroke of red somewhere like how Greninja has that tongue/scarf

New shiny froakie looked like he came out of a black n white Japanese movie

Froakie be giving some Bendy and the Ink Machine vibes like that, but not bad really

Love it with froakie and frogadier. If it was this color i would spend all my time shuny hunting it.

Shiny Frogadier with the shade of dark blue looks like a Ninja

i see many people saying you should've done the bubble scarves light blue, but i think you could've also done the line behind Froakie's nose light blue, to make some more color variety i think it could look good :3

Shiny Greninja looks so good, I like how it’s black like what a ninja’s clothing would normally look like

Ooooo the edited shiny Froakie looks like an old rubberhose cartoon character

With the white and black on froakie reminds me of an old Disney caricatures, especially the white gloves

Froakie lookin like Mr. Game and watch with those colors 😈

Shiny looks cool but i would love it to be darker and red spots ya know to make it cooler

Frokie with greninja's shiny looks like an old cartoon character

I really like this idea. I prefer the black froakie and frogadier tbh

This black shiny just made me think of something. What if at 12:00 am only for a single minute, there was a base shiny odds chance to encounter a silloette pokemon. Just 100% black.

Even though they’re simple, I really like the light blue on shiny froakie and frogadier and think a light blue or white shiny greninja would be awesome

I love the black shiny froakie it looks amazing!

I absolutely love your version of Froakie. It reminds me of an old cartoon.

Thank you, I feel the same. Greninja is always my favorite pokemon and my RU-vid account name is inspired by Froakie's frubbles "Frubbs"

Black Forgaider looks bomb I love it

Black shiny froakie looks amazing

I think what really makes shiny Greninja look good is the tongue which is hidden on the others

I think the stripe on froakie's head should have been that light blue that Greninja has

Froakie and Frogadiers designs are honestly one of the best shinies out there.

They officially learned full body haki

I imagine that if a regional variation of Froakie was made they’d inverse the shiny stages (first two being obsidian and the last being bright blue)

a lot of people say make the bubbles outright red which I think is stupid, I’d say make the bubbles for froakie a light red tint with the white, and for frogadier make it a little more vibrant.

Greninja robbing people now😂

I actually like it when the shiny forms of stage 1 and 2 mons arent that crazy and in stage 3 it turns insane Like greninja, charizard...

I think for a better contrast it wouldve been nicer if the lighter black color as swapped for a slightly dark grey instead which will help the jet black colors stand out better on the redone froakie and frogadier colors

greninja being my fave pokemon and shiny I'm so happy you did this

I think it is good for evolutions to have different colored shinies because it is a lot more exciting when you evolve it.

Looks like the design of an 80’s cartoon show. Pretty neat

froakie looks like an old cartoon character

Makes em look like old times cartoon characters

To me, if a shiny changed the actual color, I like it

Greninja is my top 1 favorite pokemon nice

Froakie be a full cartoon bro

You’re the best shorts creator on this platform 💯💯

I think the red is what makes Greninja shiny so good, it doesn't really pop otherwise and just looks muddy

Awesome. My suggestion made it. It’s interesting to see your turn on the shinies like that

the black shinies look way better for froakie and frogadier and it also becomes more noticeable making the shiny hunt a lot more worth it for froakie shiny hunts

I think the frubbles (I think that’s what they’re called, the bubbles on Froakie and Frogadier) should be colored to red to be similar to Greninja’s tongue

Bro is looks so much cooler than the normal shiny I think

Damn, everytime I see Greninja I wonder half of the company artists worked on it with so much care. That design is top notch.

Frokie looks like something from the 1900 like those black and white cartoons

i like the black froakie because it kinda reminds me of an old school cartoon idk i love old school cartoons lol

Both shines look so beautiful

I think froakie Shiny form would look better if its base was a light gray with the white staying the same then for frogadier a dark gray for the base then the white stays the same I think it would make it look good and I like the idea of the evolution shony from to start from a light gray then ending in black like its version of a tan or something

It really just makes those 2 look like an old cartoon

These look sooooo amazing

I think its perfect through his evo you see as he gets darker and darker

This recolor of shiny froakie looks like a cartoon character

Shiny froakie looked so cool

Shiny frogadier is gonna look very cool with greninja's shiny colours if you kept the Dark blue colour on its head

I’m not the biggest fan of Greninja, but I have to admit. Shiny Greninja is one of the top 5 best shinies. The black shinies always look so cool

My favourite Pokémon

Shiny Froakie looks like one of those old timey cartoons

Greninja has more details with separate color to break up the solid black. The red tongue in particular helps separating the head and body into identifiable parts. Froakie and Frogadier lack this and there's not many details too dramatically change that would alter the next evo. While looking radically different to base form color scheme. I think the shiny for all 3 was done well.

Having the light blue remain that color while changing the deep blue to black would've worked out better.

on froakie's design, the middle black stripe shouldve matched the light blue. and the bubble scarf probably couldve been red although idk if it would look better

SIR GET DOWN!?! GET DOWN!!! GET DOWN!!1!1!11!!!!11

I’d say keep them the same. Almost feels more rewarding when you get to that point. Like how Charmanders line is yellow/gold for ‘Mander and ‘Meleon, but the real prize is Charizard with the black color.

Shiny Greninja is by far my favorite shiny in all of the games.

That’s how shiny Charizard is red and black but his offsprings are different colors

Everyone talkin about the scarf, but the withe spots on the articulations, red eyes and blue finn of shiny greninja needs to be in the pre evos too

the black shinies are cool af

There are obvious spot where you could fit the light blue from Greninja, also keep the yellowish eyes from the original shiny Froakie and Froagadier

To be honest I think these recolor are great and actually out do them but thats just because black and white make everything look clean.

I tend to recolor this line into a Red~Orange and that always looks pretty nice

If ya made the scarf sorta monotone-red-ish on frogadier I think it could look pretty good

Froakie turned into an Oreo

They're oreos lol

Froakie looks like it was made back in 1920

Let the colorful tadpole turn into a emo frog if it wants to

Shiny Froakie became Bendy

I think they went the right route for this one, there just aren't enough colors on them for the black to not take too much of the pokemon

YOOO IT'S GREYNIGG-

*Real Ninja Wear Blue* 🎶

Froakie and Frogideer turn from the sky to cookies and cream ice cream

You made it look like a mime which is really fitting for the French region

This is my favorite pokemon line with all my favorite pokemkn. Froakie line equals the best

I honestly kinda love the black froakie but there r a few things to change

I think the bubbles around the neck should have turned red to reference the red tonge in greninja.

Couldn't say it better myself

Froakie is one of those pokemon with a cool mid evolution

The red tongue adds a ton to the shiny design of Greninja. It breaks up the white and black a lot. With the first 2 there is almost not enough to actually look at.

{THE COLOR RED AND LIGHT BLUE HAS LEFT THE SERVER}

Hood Froakie💀

All black they giving me Mime realness especially Froakie's white gloves

Froke he looks like Bendy