What If The Ninth Doctor Didn't Regenerate? 

I doubt Eccleston would want to, but with Big Finish doing a "First Doctor Unbound" series next year, there is a chance we could see them explore this path. I would love it if they did, and get Eccleston and Piper back working together for a series of possibilities...

he was my favorite and it wasnt even close

@@SaturnUmbreon He did say that he would consider coming back if everyone involved in the mess that was the production of Series 1 is gone. So that means if Bad Wolf gets axed. Sounds like a good proposition to me imo.

Wow nice info, was Rose still a part of the original series 2 plan? I heard she was kept to be a bridge between the two series since the Doctor was now different

@@carsforever4002 good question. 🤔 Perhaps the Doctor Who wiki knows or some other website…?

@@Lia-zw1ls7tz7o Yeah I’ll definitely have to look that up but I’m really glad we had Rose for both series 🙌

Unrelated but does that get explained in Torchwood?

@@Comicbroe405 I don't think it is but then again, I haven't seen all of Torchwood for quite some time.

You bow to no one

This made me beam 😊

That's fair! I did initially want to clarify throughout the video that he'd still be a much lighter 9, but I guess it just got lost in the writing process and I ended up emphasizing the dark side too much

@@HarboWholmes As I say in a crazy long comment, I think Ten is the darker of the two.

​@@HuntingVioletsPlease, the Eleventh Doctor is the Time Champion in the New Series.

@@mayotango1317 I'm not sure what that has to do with my comparing two other Doctors, but I'll bite. Who is killing the Eleventh Doctor?

@@HuntingViolets ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-iOFe9UvZ0Xw.htmlsi=SubldRkOUGgVd92L

Especially since wiping memory is part of his arc and he learns that is a terrible solution himself so didn't do this to Bill.

I'm sure Christopher and Catherine Tate would have a wonderful dynamic. They could even have her appear in the "runaway bride" while Martha is still a companion. Then she is the one who gets stuck in the Tardis and whisked away to the geneses planet in "the doctor's daughter" At that part Martha may choose to stay there with the Hath to help them rebuild. Maybe when Jennie dies, the doctor will not just let it go because Rose just died. So he works hard to make her regenerate and she becomes a new companion after that. Then split all the light-hearten episodes like "Unicorn and Wasp" from ones like "midnight." Donna would only be present for the first half of what would be series 3, before going home and leaving 9 and Jennie to have all the serious adventures like "silence in the library." However, once River Song dies, Jennie will become obsessed with finding out who she was and when the doctor refuses because of spoilers, she takes the square gun and the vortex manipulator and runs off on her own adventures in time. This leaves the doctor alone again for an episode "Midnight" until Kate Stewart calls him back to Earth for the "The Sontaran Stratagem" With no one else on earth he cares about, he calls Sarah Jane and Donna Noble to make sure they are safe when the sky gets poisoned. Neither one plays all that big of a role in the solution, but right afterward Donna collapses with apparent memories of "Turn Left" just appearing in her mind. They rush into the Tardis and the Earth disappears beneath them. In "the stolen Earth" the emotional reunion at the end is with Martha and not Rose. She has been recruited by the Shadow Proclamation because she is officially the last human in the galaxy because Earth disappearing in 2008 means that no human colonies ever went out into the stars. Again the doctor gets shot but he shrugs it off. Then he resolves the reality bomb in a similar way because Donna uses her second brain from "Turn Left" to learn the Dalek controls and kill them all. They fly the Earth home and The doctor erases Donna's memories of "Turn Left" and then goes outside to talk to Wilf to give him instructions on what not to do around Donna. There Wilf sees him collapse and regenerate due to the effects of the Dalek shot he was still suffering from. This leaves the specials to be either David Tenant's or Matt Smith's, whoever you prefer.

@@sanddagger36 The worst thing about Jenny being with a different Doctor would be David Tennant not meeting Georgia, but I'm going to assume they would have met anyway. :)

I feel like series 4 at least needed to be tenant, because tenant and tate are irl friends (and already were pre-dw) which is why they were so good together

@@wordart_guian Actually, David and Catherine knew *of* each other prior to working together on Doctor Who, but had never met before The Runaway Bride. And they didn't even get to meet at the read-through - Catherine couldn't make it to that for whatever reason - so they met on set when they filmed the rooftop scene, then quickly became very good friends irl. They've both talked about that in interviews. However, I completely agree Ten would have to be there for a season four with Donna! And if Donna met Nine first, it could be really interesting to see her reaction to a different version of the Doctor...

@@HuntingViolets Peter and David actually met during episode 1 of "The Mrs Bradley Mysteries" and Peter came to see David on his first day on set of Doctor Who. They have been good friends for longer than Doctor Who. I'm sure Georgia and David would've met at some point.

That’s what I immediately thought as well

That’s literally all this is he just made 9 into 12

It pales into insignificance compared to Susan getting into a relationship with David Campbell when she was just over 16!

​@@ftumschkand then her grandfather abandoning her with him even though they've barely met

​@@ftumschkSusan had more that 16 years old.

@@mayotango1317In the serial "Marco Polo" she states that she is 16 years old, and also has an interesting relationship with the 16 year old princess she shared a bed with

@@ses694 Please, she is a Time Lady. Maybe she had 160 years old.

de Pompadour

Not sure it would work tbh, I think she liked the doctor for his intelligence and rizz whereas Mickey is more of an everyman character

God, I have always wished Jacobi could have had a longer run as the Master. Thank you!

@HuntingViolets I agree, his portrayal of the master was so sinister. And yet, at the same time, there was some strange sense of elegance to him. Like he had somehow earned his arrogance. He definitely would've played off 9 quite nicely

And Sonic and Titles Screen.

I think some of the producers he had a problem with were still around. He said he would've been in the special if a certain director had taken part but Moffat said no as it was probably too late to change. I'm still very annoyed that McGann wasn't the War Doctor after Eccleston said no. He would've been the perfect bridge between old and new.

good question

Harbo already mentioned at the end that normal Martha would've been the one at Torchwood as a victim of the Cybermen in place of the cousin in the final version.

I thought that was because it was her cousin (also played by Freema) working for torchwood who died during army of ghosts?

@@PercyandDuckfan94 but why? The doctor bringing parallel Martha to the normal world should not make normal Martha not be at the hospital or be at Torchwood. They're 2 completely unrelated things.

@@ses694 In the final, yes. But in Harbo's take of S2, the cousin would've been that Martha.

I think that was a fakeout to make us believe Rose had died.