Palps:Who are you and why you look like a droid? Vader:Master im your apprentice Darth Vader Palps:Since when did i have a half droid apprentice and why darth vader that sounds ominous
Winning at Hoth would be morale boosting for sure. Could even play against the Imperial propaganda if they’re clever. However, the dilemma is they’d still have to ensconce because now the empire knows where their base is and would send more bodies and equipment.
@@jakstorm3180 yes, that was the battle objectives but people tend not to think of retreat as a victory objective but winning the field would be seen as a victory. All winning the field does is give time for an organized withdrawal.
"What if Shaak Ti managed to redeem Starkiller (Galen Marek) and turned him to the Light Side?" "What if Darth Vader and Starkiller managed to kill and overthrow Darth Sidious?"
@@TheMimiSard Possible since war is always expensive. During Wars, the CIS forces could had taken the loots from the Republic worlds that they've invaded. Dooku obviously didn't want to rely on Palpy for cash to fund the war. But more importantly hard assets instead of just credits. Dooku obviously didn't trust Palpy and likely kept reserve fleets, shipyards and automated droid factories.
Something you could have added. The Rebels had time to winterize and adapt their military assets and infrastructure to the extreme conditions on Hoth. The Imperials didn't. Some of their mighty walkers shut down, making easy targets.
Day 70 of asking for one of these ideas. 1. What if Jyn Erso survived and went onto fall in love with Luke Skywalker? 2. What if The Sith returned during the High Republic era? 3. What if cal and Merrin had a daughter? 4. What if Bo-Katan and Din Djaran fell in love? 5. What if the Jedi didn't forbit attachments? 6. What if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the galactic civil war? 7. What if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the First Order-Resistance war? 8. What if Kylo Ren never destroyed Luke's Jedi order? 9: what if Omega was force sensitive? 10: what if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the Clone wars.
If the Jedi allowed attachments, their cult would have been exposed and outlawed galaxy wide, long before Palpatine. Cult training 101. The point is that the Jedi are EVIL, subtle and insipide, but EVIL nonetheless. That's part of why Star Wars is so popular, it's daily hidden soul crushing EVIL vs blatant bold in your face evil.
I vote for #10 The Yuzhan Vong are an extragalactic species that had been preparing to invade the Star Wars galaxy for a long time. They were actually having skirmish’s with the chiss in the unknown regions as early as the clone wars (according to the Outbound Flight novel) They use biological tech, and absolutely hate droids and any other tech that can lead to droids, as their home galaxy is said to have fallen to droids long ago.
1. What if Mina Bontiri fell in love with Obi Wan? 2. What if Sabe fell in love with Anakin? 3. What if Cody fell in love with Ahsoka? 4. What if Galen Merek was trained directly by Sidious instead of Vader? 5. What if Dooku trained Galen Merek as a grayish force user? 6. What if every force sensitive being had a life as big as there midichlorian banks, bankers, bank, or bankings?
This was amazing. I’ve been a fan of your videos for a while and it’s always fun to see your interesting SW what if’s. It was also fun to see the Rebel Alliance winning the Battle of Hoth getting shown some love. This is definitely an interesting scenario and it should definitely get shown some more love. Plus I think we can all agree that this is probably one of the most interesting/unique scenarios in SW…but it’s a welcome one. Also if the Rebel Alliance did win at Hoth…then it would definitely be an interesting opportunity to show another side of the story and make it even more interesting. It was also nice to see the Rebel Alliance gain this crucial victory have a huge impact on the galaxy getting shown some love, since they usually never gets these huge victories that much and it was a nice change of pace to see them take the initiative and definitely made us all impressed. Plus it was nice to see the Rebels get that opportunity to prevent a brutal conflict from continuing…afterall it was nice to see them have a solid plan, afterall this was probably the smartest course of action they could take, so it was nice to see them come up with this plan to shift the power balance of the galaxy, since they know that there’s still opportunity and hope in the galaxy. Also it’s always nice to see just how determined the Rebels truly are. Plus it was nice to see them win the decisive battle on a snow planet…I don’t know why but it just feels fun. Great job as always and I can’t wait to see what you do next. I do have a few ideas for some possible what if’s: 1) What if Rey was a Mandalorian…essentially what if Din Djarin found Rey and took her in as a Foundling. 2) What if Ezra was a Mandalorian…something like how both his parents were Mandalorians who left Mandalore and went to start their own lives (you could still keep most of Ezra’s backstory) and potentially make Ezra and Sabine a couple (since Disney won’t, we have too…#ezrabine4ever. 3) What if Jango Fett and/or Boba Fett Joined the Republic…I think something interesting could happen with this. 4) What if Rey, Finn and Poe went back in time to the Clone Wars…this would make the World Between Worlds even more of an important focal point and I could also see them get along well with Anakin, Ashoka, Rex and the rest of the 501st (it would be fun to see Rey, Finn and Poe join the 501st) I hope these are some amazing ideas for some potential What if’s
The Rebels holding Hoth was tenuous at best. They were still setting up on Hoth, and were having supply issues. Okay, the Imperial fleet came out of hyper space too close to the system. But, the Rebels needed better shielding and more ion cannons. Had the imperial probe been intercepted cleanly, with no transmission, then things would have been more in the Rebels favour. An Imperial investigation force could have been dealt with by exsisting resources on Hoth.
This is easily one of the best what ifs yet! I love the use of Empire at War and giving the Rebels plenty of tanks and a fleet to fight the Empire with. That was a great choice for the Battle of Hoth itself.
this will probably fall on deaf ears, but (and hear me out) what if the four great armies in the past, present, and future of Star Wars series/movies (the republic, CIS, first order, empire, rebels etc.) all got sent to the same time period somewhere and had to face each other in some way. This is a crazy idea but it would be fun to see something like it. something big and crazy
Technically the rebellion won the battle of Hoth. The objective was to evacuate the base. Most of the rebellion left the base, and the Empire just conquered a planet already considered inhospitable to human life.
@@CharlesTaylor-o9p they did. But remember the main objective for the empire was to end the rebellion right then and there. They could have if they played their cards correctly; or at least dealt a massive hit to the alliance. I would have spread death squadron to cover the entire planet’s orbit. Nothing gets through. We blockade indefinitely. Bombard the ion canon continuously even with the shield on; whenever the rebels shut off the shield to use the canon the star destroyers could easily destroy it. Food and supplies shouldn’t last longer than a few months. Perfect siege opportunity.
Can you do a What if Rahm Kota Died but Shaak Ti Survived The Duel On Felucia and took Rahm Kota’s place as Starkiller’s New Master and took over what was left of Rahm’s Militia?
Yes a Pente What if on my Birthday! Listened to this while eating was perfect. Glad to have an OT what if starting on Hoth. There are not many of those, glad rebellion just straight up called themselves the New Republic during the war with the Empire, it was good way to get the Galaxy on their side. I figured Leia wouldn't want Anakin to apart of her or her son's life but at least Anakin returned to the light and Luke became a much better Jedi. Loved this Pente.
What if Padmé didn’t accept Dooku’s deal in S4E4 of Clone Wars. Anakin and Weasius, sorry Grievous die. The war outcome would change drastically. You can find where that snowball goes.
Small issue with the concept of the video: They already DID win the Battle of Hoth. Yes, they retreated, but they accomplished their strategic goal of getting out from under the Empire's attack with minimal casualties in doing so. They intentionally abandoned the base in order to preserve their organization. The instant that Han mentioned the Empire's Probe Droid self-destructed, they were planning on getting the heck outta dodge because they knew their location was compromised and needed to find a new place to hide.
"What if Darth Maul killed Owen and Beru Lars?" So basically, he reached the homestead before Kenobi, killed them, and took Luke. Kenobi interrupted him, however, and fought Maul for Luke's freedom. Kenobi won, and Luke was freed, yet with no guardians, Obi-Wan became the new guardian. This means Luke begins his training at probably roughly the same age as Anakin - so he's not gonna be a perfect jedi, as in all the other "Obi-wan trains Luke" stories, but one with much anger and sorrow.
I would definitely love to see Satele training Anakin…I feel like she would make a great teacher for him. It would essentially be one badass powerful Jedi training another badass powerful Jedi. Also Satele is one of my all time favourite Jedi from SW.
It's interesting to see the effects of this conflict when it truly involves everyone and drags on for so long. Cracking down so hard on the everyday citizens really did the Empire in if you ask me, I guess that's the part where the ruling philosophies of Tarkin and Sidious really show their fatal flaw and prove why fear alone isn't enough to keep an empire alive. Well, at least Anakin got his son back, because yeah, he's lucky Leia loves Luke and has pretty strong morals or he'll be getting a very loving orbital bombardment from her. Luke and Ezra building up the Order? How to Goober is about to become a core class. What if, instead of Sidious and Dooku, Tenebrous and Plaeguis were the ones to start the Clone Wars?
What if the first order appeared during the clone wars, making the clone wars into a 3 way war? But instead of palpatine being in charge of the first order it's the supreme leader? 😎
Love all the classic legends artwork you used here and the different ship classes! You've played Empire At War with mods haven't you? Specifically Thrawn's Revenge and Fall of the Republic? And the much less cool Remake mod. :P
What if Darth JarJar trained Anakin in secret? What if Darth JarJar seized control of the CIS to confront Palpatine? What if Anakin became a Nihilus like wound in the force after Mustafar?
What if jocasta nu helped obi wan with anikan training providing texts and knowledge on the force and the original version of the code. Were obi wan can provide training about combat he does not possess knowledge of the higher mysteries which nu does such as force healing which would be useful in attack of clones. Plus it would anakin greater resources for learning and may become a consular or at least a sentinel instead of a guardian. All this could happen because of instead of sending anakin to his room where he just tinkers they send him to work in the library where nu will give him more discipline and may take a maternal interest.
I heard the bit about the Rebels having hidden weapons and thought, Hera is there, and one of the weapons in question is Chopper. The only problem with that is I imagine Hera was keeping Jacen away from major bases, keeping him on planets like Lothal, and depending on how safe it was, Ryloth (if no dispute happened with her father about how human Jacen is). Jacen is probably around 4-6 at this point, so very young, I I wouldn't blame Hera for wanting to keep her potentially Force Sensitive son away from places that might get Vader turning up, and keeping her Cataclysm right by Jacen to guard him.
As we know darth vader was a natural engineer and could use mechaguru or whatever so what if he used skill to create nanobots to repair his lungs and burns while also making limbs that could conduct the force to make lightning. This could relate to inquisitor baris as she used nanobots in the bomb and he may remember nanobots and their uses. He could could also conduct experiments diguised as torture to fool sidious, learning to heal wounds, make force sensitive droids/limbs and using nano bots to manipulate mididclorians to strip or enhance the force in individuals. What I was thinking was that he used nanobots to remove scar tissue especially around the lungs and he would be dipped in bacta or bacta would be applied this would allow him breath which means he can meditate more deeply. And for the limbs, it is possible to make material force sensitive and I was thinking he make limbs skeletal looking like in attack of the clones but would then cover the we either grafed flesh from his body or flesh made from his blood and other ingredients like perhaps kyber crystal this would make the force flow from him easier and perhaps with the sith alchemy in the limbs making his force lightning more powerful. Basically an uber vader who is perhaps stronger than full potential anakin.
What if darth vader went to darthomir to learn. New suit or perhaps more unique powers. Resurrect talzin maybe. what if Vokara Che became a mentor to anakin as anakin was being treated for bullying and trauma from being a slave. What if anakin fell in love with luminara unduli, serra keto or bultar swan. What if anakin was taught by agen kolar or sasee tin or adi gallia.
"....And the Yuuzhan Vong came!" Sorry, couldn't help it! Actually that could be an interesting follow up to this story. What would a version of the Yuuzhan Vong war be like in this new continuity? A completely united New Republic, no imperial remnants?
What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin fell in love with mon montha. Also what if Anakin was looked after Bobba Fett
Video ideas: What if Din Jarin met Arthur Morgan from RDR2? What if Darth Vader discovers a wounded G1 Megatron from the Transformers movie after the Death Stars destruction?
A lot of these stories are cool, but always very conflicting to some characters. Specifically, Anakin, because he’s the Chosen One. There’s no replacing him like Obi Wan thought, because Lucas even stated that Anakin’s the one born from the Force and destined to balance the force. It limits some stories with his involvement, but it is true. Unless you don’t involve Anakin at all then it minimizes his establishment into the lore.
What if Vader reconstructed his suit to be cortossis. This would be a good idea for the skills of ppsw please do this you'd do this idea a great compliment
1:22 It’s Ozzel, not Hozzel, and he wasn’t a defector. A defector is someone who abandons their faction for another, usually seeking safety from persecution and bringing useful intelligence.
What if anakin spirit in the world between worlds saved padme by making her a force ghost or new mother if the ones. She could make him help ben solo and others saying you got to help people who are suffering from your past actions. What if anakin was piloting before attack of the clones and sensed ventress fall to the darkside as her master died and took his ship to the planet to investigate. Perhaps starting a romance as they are very similar in their stories. Also what if ahsoka taught ben skywalker as she saw him as history repeating itself. What if anakin was a jedi watchmen or wayfinder. What if anakin went with kenobi to face maul and savage instead of adi gallia. What if anakin fell in love with luminara or your own version of aayla secura romance. What if oppo rancis trained anakin. What if anakin met and fell in love with ventress just before the clone wars just after her masters death. What if anakin became a jedi sentinel like a watchmen or one of those who find younglings. What if evan piel became a mentor or second master to anakin. Or anakin became a healer either before or after his mother death could be related to his friendship with offee or alternatively what if he was trained by tra sa who taught windu and actually did not forbid attachment as shown by her relationship with tholme , they could become like a pseudo parents to anakin and train him away from the temple in azati martial arts and from trasa the living force as she is a plant lady so imagine anakin controlling plant life.
It's great to have game footage for space and ground now, definitely a good way to show how the battles go. Can't say I'd want to watch you play Outlaws though, it comes across as garbage to me.
So ideas similar to this I guess? In that what if the rebels won at yavin 4? Like say the emperor was on the death Star during that fight. And in doing so kill the emperor and either killed Darth Vader or left him alive but badly hurt. And to see how the empire flails with such an early death of the emperor. Compared to what we have in Canon for how the Battle of yavin brought people to the rebellion. Imagine what something like this would do so early on.
