What's the difference between both Airfix Spitfire Mk. Vc model kits?!

Подписаться 45 тыс.

Просмотров 25 тыс.

50% 1

Airfix recently released 2 versions of the same Spitfire. Both represent a Supermarine Spitfire Mk. Vc in 1/72 scale, but one is a starter set and the other is a normal (more "detailed") version. But why?
Join me in this video as i take a look at both kits, the differences and what I think about it - what would I have done differently?
For a more in-depth look at both kits take a look at those unboxings:
Airfix Spitfire Vc Starter Set:
• Brand New Airfix Spitf...
Airfix Spitfire Vc:
• Brand New Airfix Spitf...
Take a look at the products here if you want to get one for yourself:
amzn.to/3kVn2sa
amzn.to/3qRLZsp
Please consider pledging your support to help keep the channel growing from strength to strength. Find out what's in-store and how to unlock additional perks here: / modelminutes
Join the channel to get access to perks:
/ @modelminutes
If you like what I do, why not buy me a coffee over at ko-fi.com/modelminutes
Come join the live conversation over at Discord, chat to other modellers in real time! / discord
If you want to buy any of the kits i've built or recommend - take a look here (it helps support the channel):
www.amazon.co.uk/shop/modelmi...
Subscribe with notifications on to help support the channel!
/ modelminutes
I have a second channel where I like to upload other videos - take a look:
/ @mattssecondchannel
Let's get social!
/ modelminutes
/ modelminutes
/ modelminutes
This video is intended for adult scale model enthusiasts.
Model Minutes holds no responsibility for any accidents, damage or injury that could occur as a result of attempting to replicate any steps depicted in this video. This video is intended for entertainment only.
Unless specifically indicated, all products have been independently purchased.
Music used from Epidemic Sound:
www.epidemicsound.com/track/C...
#Airfix #Spitfire #Modelkit

Хобби

Опубликовано:

27 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 203

@lyndonbull3581 2 года назад

I think that the starter set is just made simpler, for obvious reasons. And Airfix are capitalizing on their investment to offer the other kit, with more options for the more experienced modeler. This makes total sense, but for the fact that they did this with their recent small scale tanks, offering one piece or multi link tracks in the same box. Having said that, its probably not practical to do the same for aircraft models, so I applaud them for the 2 offerings. I must say that I fancy one in US markings, so having recently completed the starter set version and being reasonably impressed, I have just ordered the other boxing. Matt, your video has inadvertently made me make this purchase, but in a good way, keep up the good work mate.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Thanks for watching!

@johnalecritchie8646 2 года назад

Watching this while listening to the LIV ARS match. Very thorough! I don't build up planes but enjoy all your vids. Cheers!

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Much appreciated!

@lpjmodels 2 года назад

That's a very helpful overview thanks Matt !

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Glad it was helpful!

@dwightgouin3889 2 года назад

I agree in that it would make more sense to make the Vb as the starter set then as your skills develop you could go on to the Vc or go back and start the Va and so on. Great video today and always look forward to the next one!

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Absolutely! Thanks for watching!

@lilchris26 2 года назад

Hi there thanks for your video on these kits. I started making Airfix kits in the late 50's/60's has a kid, I have not made many since, apart from a kit of a old Mini I made last year. I found your channel when looking for video's on airbrushing, but I recently found out about the Airfix mystery box deal so I ordered one. In it is the new Spitfire kit, a kit of the P51 Mustang and a starter kit of the F15 if I remember correctly. I decided to have a go and get my hand in and build a few kits before I try building a kit my son bought me 2 years ago. A kit of a Honda 400-4 one of my favourite motor cycles, I used to have one for real in red. The main modelling I have been doing is my N-gauge model railway which I started when I retired, I can be found on the n-gauge forum under the same name. I am on my third layout, having scrapped the first two has I found out more of what I wanted ie to watch trains go by. I have subscribed now and plan to watch your video on the spitfire for tips. I have invested heavily in a new compressor and airbrush and this time a spray booth. For years I have sprayed into a old cardboard box using my 30 year old 150L Badger airbrush, I did wear a mask but I have a proper one this time. The paint for the Honda kit has solvents in it, it is Japanese, ie Mr Hobby/Mr color, but is a perfect colour match, so I thought it a good idea to play safe. Chris.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

thanks for the info and for watching :D

@melvinjohnson7033 2 года назад

Excellent video and only 15 dislikes and 450 likes, the sign of a solid RU-vid channel.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

thanks :D

@HotelPapa100 2 года назад

My thought of Airfix's decision process: We are 1) retooling the Vc to current standards. We also want to 2) make a beginners kit, where we remove each and every possibility to make a mistake and make the parts breakdown so that less cleanup is required (I think the way to mount the canopy with less risk to get gluey thumbprints all over it is brilliant, so is the integrated cowl an exhausts. The difference in the wings, btw, is mostly the internal structure, which is molded in for the beginner). With current CAD design processes we can get 2) out of 1) with little additional effort. Making the Vb as a simplified version would have meant more CAD modeling, more development effort. Also the advanced modelers would have moaned that they want the Vb in a non-dummy version.

@Simon_Nonymous 2 года назад

My thoughts exactly.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

yeah, maybe

@Gremlins_Modelling_Mayhem 2 года назад

Totally agree, having built a much earlier version of the Vb than you have Matt, it would have been sense to retool the Vb not a 2nd Vc and why not a mk 9 or 15?

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

well said, i would have liked an accurate spitfire prototype too even!

@foreverplastickits138 2 года назад

*It's very interesting to compare this different models from a single brand, sometimes managers took some decisions that we can't understand! Whatever, thanks for this video!*

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

thanks for watching!

@mikemodels928 2 года назад

I think the starter set giving you a simplified model is a good idea. When you gain more skills you tend to build more complex kits.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

yeah, the idea of the starter set is great, i just dont understand why they did 2 different versions of the same exact aircraft type

@Kickback-dm7zt 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes with all the spitfire kits they have released over the years I'm surprised they haven't done a Tr Mk9 variant

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

@@Kickback-dm7zt it would be interesting

@lewispowell1681 2 года назад

im guessing the reason they have two of the same kit is that they didnt want to do a full redesign as well as full new tooling for a new product range that they haven't trialled before (ie a genuine basic model for starters as opposed to a normal kit plus some paints). it probably takes as much if not more investment to create the virtual model. once you have that its trivial to chop it up in a different ways. from a business point of view they probably assume the majority of hobbyists are not really interested in easy to build kits with essentially no options and limited detailing on some parts, also they don't actually know how big the market is for true easy build starter sets so this is them stepping into a new area. if only 10,000 easy build kits actually sell then they wont recover the £100k tooling cost. you need to remember these are two different products aimed at two different customer groups if they were to do a different mk of spitfire they would have been doubling at least the cost investment and not increased the sale estimates. and while you may say it could eat into sales of the existing Vc id like to point out that you have it in your stash and wernt going to buy it again.... and i bet money that a good chunk of your viewers have it in their stash or on display already.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

I bought both versions to make a video about it, if I had been building for me I wouldn’t have bought either I imagine

@jorgereixach9509 2 года назад

I have 15 of the 22 versións of the Spitfires in 1/72 the "american Spit " got the "abukir" filter used in África front. Thank you for your review of the two Spitfires.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Thanks for watching 😊

@dcmchugh99 2 года назад

Completely agree.The old vb would have made a good starter set. Admittedly it's been a very long time since I made one but it was simple to build and went together well .The new vc looks a good kit with lots of options but I won't buy one yet as I have a Revell vb .If Airfix wanted to re tool another of their spitfires they should have re done the mk 9 tooling. Having never built one before I got the chance to a couple of years ago and it was woeful !

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

That's a good suggestion

@VFCproductions 2 года назад

Good comparison and good points made so thank you. But if I can try to defend Airfix a little... The starter set will probably be around in the same form for a very long time, but that wouldn't sell to the intermediate or higher modeller (I'm certainly not interested in a plane with a big hole in the wing for a display stand!) The tooling for the regular Vc is done in such a way as to have potential for a Vb amongst others and I would expect (and hope) to see it re-released in lots of different forms in years to come. I assume they tried to find a compromise in tooling for both ranges and couldn't. Why release both as a Vc from the offset? Don't know. Do we need another Spitfire? Yes, Matt. Always yes.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Hmm, good point, they could provide a sprue with a different wing for the Vb

@Slycockney 9 месяцев назад

I've made the tropical version with American markings and have to say it's a lovely kit.

@ModelMinutes 9 месяцев назад

Awesome! I've not made mine yet, but have done the starter set version which was alright

@tomburley 2 года назад

Since Airfix are not focused on "competing" with their own products you need to look at the versions being offered by competitors. A starter kit is offer to entice new customers to the joys of model building or simply offering a complete "rainy day kit" that is a self contained fun one day build - again to stimulate a new modeler. The "standard kit" offers options in both paint schemes and version "variants" - some people actually like to build up multiple versions of the same aircraft and might even build different manufacturers versions of the same aircraft. Good on Airfix for creating additional incentives to increase sales opportunity.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

I have a follow up video to this coming soon

@PiperStart 2 года назад

In the time I have been waiting for the video I have bought both kits myself.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

nice

@franktozier3184 2 года назад

I agree with you. The starter kit MK.VC should be a V B.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

that would be cool :D

@jimbraiden2094 2 года назад

Hi Mat, thank for another objective review, I can understand Airfix's method, it's probably cheaper to alter a few parts of an exiting mould than make a complete one, and at the end the day it's about a spratt to catch a mackerel! And spitfires are quite possibly the best seller on the world market? Keep the reviews coming, like the comments and other peoples point of view.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Thanks , will do 😊

@carolthomas794 2 года назад

To me the overall concept of an easy version AND a conventional version makes sense in that Airfix quite rightly wants to encourage would be modellers into the hobby and the best way they can do that is make kits that are as simple as possible so that they aren't discouraged by "over engineered" kits but still have a bit of a challenge that "gives them" a Spitfire. The more modellers in the hobby means that it has a better chance of surviving which benefits Airfix and existing modellers. This two track way is the most cost effective way of achieving this - apologies retired accountant speaking, I now have a life!

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

as mentioned, the only real issue i have with this is that people who build one version, wont necessary want to repeat it by gettting a duplicate

@tcandle695 2 года назад

I agree with you. Airfix has a lot of classic kits that really need an update to today's standards. The only reason I will buy the standard Vc kit is the decal. I love shark mouth liveries.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

@yvesdubois4964 2 года назад

Yes, I agree too. We are still waiting for a very good spitfire mkVb on this scale, and Airfix could have built a new mold for this version, it had the tools and the way to make it! I hope it's just a matter of time.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Perhaps they will

@PaDDy7389 2 года назад

Revell has a new Mk Vb (03897) in its range that might be something for you.

@stompieandsuzie 2 года назад

Looking forward to watching this one. Hope it's not just different set of decals, and box art! Lol

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Surprisingly . . . it isn't

@fiftiesbinman2083 2 года назад

i bought the starter kit after watching this will skip the SuperMarine one,, will pick a different one.. cheers for the info...

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Glad I could help

@AAOMorpheus 2 года назад

interesting video, from what I've seen it may be that the tooling used with the Vc will allow interchangeability to other marks, past and future, for example like you pointed out the lower part of the cowling to allow the different filters, and the different wings. it may just be a futureproofing exercise. I do wish they would use different pilots though, different uniform, parachutes etc would be nice to see.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Apparently the pilot is underscale in this, which I didnt notice in the review

@buildingmymodel 2 года назад

Interesting video. Fully agree that it would make more sense with one 5b and one 5c.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

thanks! :D

@TringmotionCoUk 2 года назад

I think you and airfix are both valid in the ideas. For airfix, you have a progression where you can do 2 the same but different to improve modelling skills OR this could be an adult and child model together idea (or indeed 2 friends), getting the less experienced modeller on the easier kit and making it a social. Your plan also makes perfect sense as the old kit is a level 1.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

thanks :D

@joesanchez979 2 года назад

Thanks mate ☺️

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

No problem 👍

@ModelMinutes Год назад

*UPDATE!* The designer of this kit agreed to do an interview with me regarding the reasons for creating 2 of these kits - take a look here: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-uSVA0KgGzIg.html

@EverythingsAndAllthings 9 месяцев назад

i really like the spitfire mk vc

@ModelMinutes 9 месяцев назад

Yeah it’s a nice plane

@Gibbo263 5 месяцев назад

Think part of it might be a naming issue. The Vb typically only had 2 cannons while the Vc usually had 4

@ModelMinutes 5 месяцев назад

The B and C refer to the wing types - C being "universal" and could have the same armament as the B, whilst the B would need modification to bring it inline with the C type. As mentioned in the video, you will ultimately end up with the same model built at the end - both being Spitfire Vc

@PaDDy7389 2 года назад

Had the starter set been a Mk Vb, even more experienced modelers might have been tempted to buy one. To me at least it sounds tempting to have all subvariants of the Mk V with a similar level of surface detail from the same manufacturer.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Well said

@julianmhall 2 года назад

Thankfully there's an open canopy version often nowadays. 30 odd years ago I made my own with a hobby knife, laboriously cutting a 1:72 cockpit into three sections and then gluing two of them. That was not a happy experience and if videoed the audio track would have many many bleeps!

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

yeah, i had to cut many of mine in the past too

@julianmhall 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes not a happy memory is it? *lol*

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

@@julianmhall nope

@yasirwaqar-et2dr 2 месяца назад

Both of them look good

@ModelMinutes 2 месяца назад

I've not built the desert version yet, so will have to see how it compares

@eddiebruv 2 года назад

Pretty sure the starter kit is the more recent addition. Its design process was featured on the recent TV series about Hornby. I can’t see what the problems are with these being ‘the same aircraft’, because they aren’t. One is the easier to build version, as well as the other one is tropicalised and has two finish options. Why shouldn’t those less skilled or just starting out have the opportunity to have this Spitfire?

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

i explain my reasoning at the end of the video

@stevemeulders7999 2 года назад

I was also thinking something like: are we not aknowledging the other one is the tropical version?

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

@@stevemeulders7999 I mention that in the video…

@stevemeulders7999 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes I must have missed it then. My mistake.

@andrewwalker9954 2 года назад

It does seem a bit bizarre to offer two different versions of the same mark rather than doing a Vc and a Vb as you suggest. I wonder if it's to do with the overheads for research and CAD modelling where they can reduce that by utilising the same research and model for both kits albeit by modifying the parts breakdown rather than the overheads associated with researching and modelling two different types of spitfire.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

yeah, maybe. Could be because they had all the research and design work that it was cheaper to get 2 tools made rather than having to put more time and work into doing a whole Vb thing . . . Edit - not an expert but I can't imagine the differences between a Vb and Vc being huge though in model form

@andrewwalker9954 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes Yeah, the theory does fall apart a little on the issue of how similar a Vb and Vc would be

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

@@andrewwalker9954 I was under the impression that the wings were the main difference, but as for airframe and other parts I don’t really know…

@andrewwalker9954 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes yeah, sorry I meant my initial theory kinda falls about because they are so similar that you'd imagine research and remodelling wouldn't be that extensive. I think the wing is the only major difference.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

@@andrewwalker9954 I guess Airfix does what Airfix wants 😂

@grantlassing7055 2 года назад

Airfix have made A decision whether it will be right or wrong only time will tell as the market will speak and sales will tell if they were correct in their thought process , I have yet to see the starter kit any where but I have already purchased 4 of the standard kit and have almost finished my 2nd one and have enjoyed both and will probably start on a third straight away I will build the non tropical version of which all the parts are in the kit except decals for which I will have to use my Xtradecal set . Happy modelling !

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Sounds like you love a spitfire :)

@ftumptch86 2 года назад

The designing of the bottom one was on the Hornby program recently.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

yup

@stephenpointon 2 года назад

the Vb would have been a good starting point (now i am not defending this decision) but it may have meant modifying an old mold tool and perhaps that would have been more time consuming than a new mold as well as making it no longer available for the "classic" series. Also is the older VB ok for fit? i know that airfix has improved its fit since the series 2 Vb was first launched. I know I have an airfix mkV but its in 1/48 (it's the one with the Douglas Bader decals)

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Their older Vb hasn't been in the vintage classics range yet as far as i know . . . Not sure it would sell well either when you can get other versions from other companies

@mrjockt 2 года назад

It’s a pity that Airfix only did the Mk.Va, the non cannon armed Mk.V, as a limited run a few years back, it would be nice to build a Va, Vb and a Vc, but getting your hands on the Va is a bit difficult and expensive nowadays, unless of course the wings from the retooled Mk.Ia will fit the Mk.V fuselage with little or no problems.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

I think the Va is basically a 1a with a different spinner on the nose, as far as the airfix tooling i have in the stash is concerned

@mrjockt 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes I did cross kit the Airfix Mk.Ia and Vb about twenty or so years ago to make a Va, the wings from the Ia fitted the Vb fuselage almost perfectly, the only change I had to do was remove the moulded on oil cooler under the port wing, far too shallow, and fit the oil cooler from the Vb, plus the prop and canopy. I haven’t had a look at the newer mouldings of the two aircraft that Airfix now do so I don’t know if the wings can be cross kitted as easily any more.

@Deadmau5l 2 года назад

I tried my first camo paint today and im ashamed of it haha, Talked myself into a sprayer hopefully i can get a better finish

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Good luck 😉

@Steelbackuk 2 года назад

The lettering on the marks refers to the wings. Well more accurate it's the ariment configuration. But I did notice you can build a European mk v as well as a tropical out of the box

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

yup

@julianmhall 2 года назад

Ref versions: Have they ever offered a Seafire variant, since that was 90% a Spitfire with an arrester hook? That would be nice to see, or a Harrier / Sea Harrier, Hurricane / Hurricat? Basically any kit where the airframe was 90% the same but had a naval variant. BTW that mk Vb you haven't opened yet has Polish markings (the red and white checked box). If memory serves the tail was a slightly different shape too, which was a so-n-so to carve.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

I think they did have a seafire, but perhaps in 1/48 and not 1/72, could be wrong though

@alessiodecarolis 2 года назад

Doing various versions of the same aircraft isn't a novelty, Fujimi started in the early '80s with the "Phantom Family", followed by the A6, JU87 and A7, plus some japanese fighters, it's a way to utilize a common mold for some parts, plus a way to collect the history of a certain aircraft.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

But these are different moulds

@PurplEWolFGaminG Год назад

They love the spitfire id like to see different versions of the hawker hurricane and the messrschmitt and the tiger tank

@ModelMinutes Год назад

maybe they are working on some new versions

@PurplEWolFGaminG Год назад

@@ModelMinutes lets hope id aslo like to see them bring back the hind a/d mil mi 24

@trainsontuesday 2 года назад

I think you missed Airfix's point. The starter sets are to introduce new modelers to the hobby with easier to build kits. The kit with more options are for the more advanced modeler that wants to personalize his (her) build. The other point is that had they just made one version, you would have spent £10.00 but they managed to get you to spend £20.00

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

I get that point, and I explore elements of them in the unboxing I made on each kit in previous videos…. Were I not a review channel I would have only bought one of these kits because I don’t really want two spitfires of the exact same mark just with different skill in construction… If anything, I think had they done my suggestion at the end of the video they would have opened up an even broader market

@seantaplin581 2 года назад

How do you get paint out of panel lines, its acrylic.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

could use a fine, pointed tool

@nicolastremerie1331 Год назад

Did you notice that the Vc starter kit has the same lettercode as the old Vb kit: RF•D ?

@ModelMinutes Год назад

It is possible seeing as they were squadron identifiers and not specific planes. When the Vb was replaced by a Vc it is possible they had the same identification code. There is even a Mk ix with the same code

@seppingtondestamina9398 2 года назад

Is this "simplified kit" thing a new idea or has it always been this say with starter sets? And is it just Airfix that does this? I've bought several Revell starter sets over the years mainly for their little double sided red and blue brush which I use when decaling for MicroSol and MicroSet. I can't say I've ever noticed any simplification (no comments about lack of accurate detail on Revell's kits, we know, we know...)

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Generally speaking, a “starter set” was just a normal kit from the range (usually an easier one) and some paints, glue and a brush thrown in. It would seem that whilst there are a selection of “easy build” kits out there, Airfix have decided to go the whole hog and tailor design a specific range of starter sets which will never be anything else

@pawelpw1161 Год назад

EVERY company has spitfire, bf109 and mustang in their range :-) and they are constantly improving them, especially pilot space, which makes me confused especialy with these little canopies

@ModelMinutes Год назад

Yeah, sometimes i don't bother detailing the cockpit . .because who can see it lol

@charlieboye2009 2 года назад

Do a double build, Make the starter set ala starter set rules and build the standard kit the usual way. Sometimes there might be something different in the construction that isn't quite apparent when just looking at bits of sprue.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

starter set is already built - video is already on my channel (i'm not buying another one lol)

@charlieboye2009 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes ooohhhh missed opportunities.....

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

@@charlieboye2009 well, not really, if you watched my build of the starter set kit you’d know that I hand painted it like a beginner, and when I get round to the “advanced” version I’ll do a more conventional build. I just don’t always have time to build lots of kits at the same time sadly, and have to build kits and edit videos when I can

@roryscarlett3952 2 года назад

I think Airfix are getting 2 kits fir the development costs of one. I guess they are aimed at slightly different markets.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

yup

@glyndaley5844 Год назад

Surly just add the parts and decals 4 both in one kit ?

@ModelMinutes Год назад

There is a follow-up video about these kits where I have a chat with the designer and he explains their reason for creating two kits: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-uSVA0KgGzIg.html

@ryanandtech3164 2 года назад

Good thing to point out is although they are the same price and yes one has more detail and one with paints and glue has less, but lets be honest has anyone ever had an airfix kit where all the paints where completely dried out lol, maybe just my bad luck but cant be just me.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

There is a Quality Control issue with the new paint pots - Airfix have made it known they are investigating the problem and looking at resolving it (the pots are designed in such a way that when the lids are pushed on, they will pop off slightly which allows air in to dry the paints out)

@yasirwaqar-et2dr 2 месяца назад

The clipped wing and one from the blackpool illuminations

@ModelMinutes 2 месяца назад

yes, these were announced and released a year or so after this video was made

@stuartrose3552 Год назад

I've got this kit to build, great kit but why not include a normal European version without the tropical air filter

@ModelMinutes Год назад

saving that for a future release version i'm sure

@yasirwaqar-et2dr 2 месяца назад

I have the starter set one

@chrissteadman4614 2 года назад

I suspect that it is about marketing, they may well have determined that the starter model will sell better to new or casual model builder, but not to the more experienced modeller who will prefer the other kit. I don't think they expect someone who has built the starter set to buy the other kit, but a kit of a different subject. And/or it might be about where they sell the kits. The starter model might be more attractive to toy shops, news agents etc. but not to model shops for instance. I expect that they have done some very careful research and determined that two models will net them more sales than just one.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

maybe

@Anlushac11 2 года назад

Spit on top looks like a Tropical with a Vokes air filter

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

it is . . . did you watchg the video?

@beccithompson250 2 года назад

Did you ask this question at you resent visit to Airfix?

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

i did - follow up video soon

@SullysScaleModels 2 года назад

Your right we dont need more spitfires😂 what you say dose makes sense mate

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Lol, too right :P

@modelheaven5471 2 года назад

Don't understand it either Matt, I get the starter set is a simpler build, but why waste thousands of pounds on a separate mould of the same variant when you could've tooled a lessor available mark!

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

i agree

@harriergr7728 2 года назад

Watch, Hornby : A model world, series 1 episode 5, (on Yesterday) it explains everything about the new starter kit.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Yeah I saw it when it came out

@jazmindeakin5644 2 года назад

we do need a mk5c so you can do a RAAF in South Pacific WW2 or RAF in Burma WW2 the mk5b was not use in these places so a has a New Zealand japan was more of a threat to use then Germany

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

I wasn’t really questioning whether we needed a Vc, more if we needed 2 in different skill level toolings when they will look objectively the same when constructed

@itsmeoli3705 2 года назад

It’s a game of spot the difference

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

it really is

@julianmhall 2 года назад

BTW ref the reason there are two kits.. I think it was a marketing / business decision rather than a model one. Why spend the money developing two entire kits when it's cheaper to make one kit, simplify it, and then sell the first as a standard kit and the second as a starter set. Spend less on design / development and get two kits out of it maximising profit.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

I'm currently in communication with Airfix regarding this, so perhaps I will make a follow up video with their answers when i find out :D

@ironman1294 2 года назад

I think your missing the point Matt. I watched Phil Flory's interview with Paramjit from Airfix who designed the Mk.Vc starter set and he said the entire decision around creating this kit was to bring a brand new and simpler starter set for brand new modellers to ensure their first experience in the hobby is an enjoyable one. This kit really wasn't really meant for modellers like you and I. Don't get me wrong there's nothing stopping us from buying 1 but they are 2 totally different kits meant for 2 totally different target audiences.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

I know why they made the starter set version, I discussed that in the unboxing and build videos I made on that kit and I actually think it's a great idea. The point I dont get, and as mentioned here, is why do 2 versions of the same one - why not do a slightly different version as the starter set and another as the more advanced version, that way if an more experienced modeller wants both versions of 2 different aircraft they can, same with beginners who got their practice in on the simple one. But if i were a beginner who had made a Vc, i might not want to do another one - there is not as much incentive there to do the same kit again . . .

@ironman1294 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes I agree but is there any feasible way to make or produce a Mk.Vc Trop using the Mk.Vc Starter Set?

@modelmagic9930 2 года назад

In all honesty this is just a 14 min video of Matt ranting about why Airfix made two of the same aircraft

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Yup, get ready for a follow up too because Airfix contacted me about it 😂

@modelmagic9930 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes oh wow I’m so excited for a follow up, I’ll have to attend the premiere for that one

@modelmagic9930 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes the big question is will they talk about it on the next sprue talk?

@maty1229 2 года назад

My basic complaint is that I'm more likely to buy the Starter Set as I've been needing an easier kit after a streak of complex ones, but the other Vc has the cooler livery and the open canopy option. Not sure why the starter set doesn't have that option, the Hurricane starter set does.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

If I recall correctly, the hurricane will be rebranded as a gift set (not being specifically designed as a starter set) and also the canopy is 2 part rather than intended to be displayed open (it doesn’t quite fit properly in the open position, being not designed for it and also not mentioned in the instructions)

@maty1229 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes That does check out. While it did not fit very well in the open position I did still install it that way so that the cockpit was visible. I figured it was an intended feature but it indeed isn't mentioned in the instructions so I guess not.

@EindbaasToad 2 года назад

I agree, this makes no sense. Also, whats the point of building a Mk. V, a Mk. Vb and a Mk. Vc? Can you tell the difference when all of them are displayed next to each other in the display case? I, personally, would rather build one Spitfire and (say) a Bf 109 and a Mustang (for example).

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

More importantly, how did you manage to watch this video when it’s still not been released yet? 😂

@EindbaasToad 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes LOL, there a card in the starter-set build video

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

@@EindbaasToad that’s insane, RU-vid literally informs me that unlisted videos will not get cards shown. I guess you are lucky, seeing this video before everyone else

@johnbollig2790 Месяц назад

Who cares, really now. I like both versions. and it's clear why they make both. Va , Vb, Vc, The next one is Vd, which is the one I don't want to get. I love airfix and it's various kits. God knows I am a glutton for them. I have over 500 airfix kits.

@ModelMinutes Месяц назад

Airfix haven't made a Vb in 1/72 since 2013 (and even then it was a limited edition) and it was a 1975 tooling

@yasirwaqar-et2dr 4 дня назад

Airfix made a 1/24 scale spitfire mk Vb

@ModelMinutes 4 дня назад

@@yasirwaqar-et2dr based on their ancient Mk1 tooling

@edwardjones6403 2 года назад

Just spilled paint all over my mousepad, pants, and carpet.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

oh no!

@travis_thompson 2 года назад

Because one is a basic starter set, companies need to make their money from the tooling and design process so multiple boxings are a must. Why not ask why Tamiya have been knocking out the same Mustang kit for the last 25 years.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

But it's 2 different toolings . . . Surely it can't be cheaper to make 2 different versions of the same subject using 2 different tools . .

@travis_thompson 2 года назад

Modifed yeah, maybe the sprues are on the same tool as the detailed kit? but obviously airfix think it's worth it. The Vc is the most requested marque, and there's enough differences if you know what you're looking at. It's why eduard can make a dozen different 109G kits, they are all different if you care to know how.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

@@travis_thompson I would imagine these are seperate tools to avoid mixing the parts up on the production line

@cursecat111 2 года назад

LOL.I remember back in the mid seventies here in Australia,My hobby shop had these as a series 1 kit in a plastic bag with the instructions as a folded up section closing off the top of the plastic bag with a hole in the middle at the very top.They had a big wall just above the front door that had hanging hooks that came straight out with a slight twist up at the end to hold the bags in place and these where about 4 kits deep maybe 15 kits across and 5 or so down.the lower section of the wall had larger hooks that where spaced next to each other to allow the series 2 kits in boxes to be placed 2 deep and maybe 10 across and 2 or 3 down..They then had a long gripper tool about 6 ft long that could grab what kitt you wanted.That was a lot of Airfix Kits back then.Bigger kits or boats/ships or cars were on shelves at shoulder level and below.The hobby shop is Loonnngggg gone but the memories remain!!.P.S. this was before starter kits with paints and glue.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

thanks for sharing!

@stevieb6173 2 года назад

have you asked airfix why ? trust me there will be a reason , money may be behind it usually is , plus matt, come on mate , let it go , 🤣🤣🤣🤣👍👍

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

i'm fine . . . . honestly . . . . Although i probably have a bit of a breakdown everytime i look at all the spitfires in my stash

@jamescooper2644 10 месяцев назад

One is a mk vc in Europe the other is a tropical one am. As the real thing. It nothing to do with one being a starter set.

@ModelMinutes 10 месяцев назад

despite the fact that it has everything to do with one of them being a starter set - they are completely different toolings! (or did you not watch the video?)

@WgCdrLuddite 2 года назад

Airfix made the right decision as a company. As one of their people admitted at the recent RU-vidr day "Spitfires sell more than anything else". You are deluded if you think they care about individual customers.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

it's funny you mention the RU-vidr day because I was there and actually had the chance to have a chat with the designer of this kit and address my concerns/queries about why they made 2 of the same models. Stay tuned for that interview coming soon

@brucegibbins3792 2 года назад

This is trying to understand the reasoning behind the Airfix decision to produce two kits of what are ostensibly the same Spitfire model. To aficionados of the Spitfire, no collection of piston engine fighters should be without one, this offering would probably be a rather welcome one, but to the modeler who wants but one example, two could mean a lost opportunity to produce a kit of another aircraft instead.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

exactly

@yasirwaqar-et2dr 2 месяца назад

Actually, airfix didn't make these 2 spitfires, they made 4 spitfire mk 5c's

@ModelMinutes 2 месяца назад

yes, but at the time this video was made there were only 2

@180791sanguinius 2 года назад

The starter set is a normal MkVc the other kit is a Tropical version, so one used in Africa and over the Med, with the big sand filter under the engine. I think that's the main selling point.

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

I can build a non-tropical version from both kits though…

@thedisabledwelshman9266 2 года назад

since when did the yanks fly the spitfire during ww2?

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

1942 Edit: They weren't widely used but there were many squadrons that had them in various theatres when their "intended" aircraft were either delayed, diverted, or simply not good enough for that theatre so they ended up using British aircraft that they knew would work

@naphaneal 2 года назад

maybe Airfix borrowed tools from other manufacturers. It's a common method in the industry...

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Nah, this is 100% Airfix tooling, they even made a tv program about the design process

@trikkke11 Год назад

Bloody luxury. Such drama.

@ModelMinutes Год назад

So much drama

@trikkke11 Год назад

@@ModelMinutes Exactly, glad you agree.

@kingozymandias8370 2 года назад

The starter set is aimed ageneral retailers and casual builders who arnt bothered about historical accuracy , the othe is for modellers who maybe want to build every version with every paint scheme , as an experienced modeller going into a shop to buy a present for a niece or nephew the starter set would win every time !

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

i understand the differences between buying a starter set and an advanced kit, my main concern was that it will end up with the same model in the end, it would have made more sense to me to do different versions of the same aircraft rather than the same, that way a beginner can get the other version of the plane after building the starter set

@orbitalair2103 2 года назад

Instead of asking US, why not ask AIRFIX ?

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

Because how would that promote discussion?

@Pr0tectAndSurvive 2 года назад

It’s just that Airfix is running out of ideas 😂

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

or repeating the classics lol

@Test-jn7wh 2 года назад

I’m very sure that you have the exact same old every single time apart from ww1 And modern and

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

not sure you quite finished your comment before posting it . . .

@Test-jn7wh 2 года назад

@@ModelMinutes I just put and for no reason

@theleninist4272 2 года назад

Because there stupid haha. I think its down to money , their logic must be if you buy the starter kit and you decide you like the hobby if you read or watch a review of the more difficult version then you might go and by it , the more kits they sell the more money they make . Oh yes i often ask myself what another bloody spitefire why , i do wish they would make something different , take a risk .

@ModelMinutes 2 года назад

I suppose this was a decision they made a few years ago seeing as these are technically 2020 range products, it's just taken that long to get them