@@tvojamama4888 ricks actors way older now, looking in his 50s probably couldnt pull off looking 20s again without sketchy amc funding level cgi ai shit
Only thing i would do is add in the tale tell story characters like Lee Clementine kenny Katya duck Aj javier etc who comes across the main comics characters like Herchel months before ricks group goes there and settles and they come across Glenn in the initial fall out before rick grimes wakes up from his gun shot wound coma when the out break begins and they meet Paul aka Jesus as Rick grimes group moves towards Washington dc Virginia. Also the michonne tell tale story is tied into the comics when she leaves Rick's group briefly.
No. 100 percent accuracy would not be suitable for most viewers. The prison arc is beyond twisted and would be a huge turn off for many ppl who’ve never read the comics
I would trade a brand new TWD show for the upcoming Rick/Michonne show, eyes closed. I'm so burned out of the way AMC and gimple decided to tell this story.
Same here bro. I stopped watching after they "killed" Rick in season 9. Rick is literally the main character of the Walking Dead you have no show without him. It's like what Luke Skywalker is to Star Wars or Iron Man/Captain American to the MCU. AMC just should've ended it after season 8. They already strayed quite a bit away from the comic. Not covering the whispers arc would not have been that much of a stretch.
i like how you mentioned the robert kirk man red carpet story because it’s so wild that rick finally got so far into the apocalypse that he dies because he believes he’s so safe he doesn’t have to lock his doors anymore
I feel they should reboot the main show and FTWD as they both were good but as they got to their halfway point the plot armor was absolutely mental,I mean look at all the storm troopers in the later seasons
The killing of carl can be considered a mistake but it was beautifully executed, carls could have been bite fighting more walkers but that was the only complaint i had, the messaging the acting, the themes was all there and how rick failed his son and for carls death to mean anything, death must be stopped.
Gimple killing Carl had only one goal, to continue TWD forever and make this show a new MCU, that whole Negan thing is BS. obviously HBO would have made this show a GoT or The Last of Us
Ngl if any version of TWD needs to be rebooted, it needs to be Fear (not the Season 4 reboot though omg 😹). I want it to follow the original plan and story Dave Erickson had in mind with everything he wanted from start to finish taking place in the comic-book/Telltale universe Also, just to avoid a lot of actors leaving due to obligations or gigs, have it be animated in a similar style like the comics.
it would be so good if they made an adaption to the twd telltale games like they did for the last of us, i believe it could even be better than amcs twd
@@hammywoods i really hope so. But how would they do it? Would hbo make it? Im pretty sure that amc has thought of making it, but it wouldnt work cus the amc universe is different from the comics, which the game is set in
@@Andr3NG honestly as much as I loved HBO's tlou, I wouldnt trust them to handle twdgs story. they did a bad job at building Joel and ellies relationship, I doubt they'd do justice to Lee and Clem. the pacing was also horrible bc they had so much flashback and sidecharacter-based episodes. And they had some questionable casting. (Kathleen 😬) from what the new spinoffs are like as well as the original walking dead, I think AMC can do it so much justice. I feel like they can just say its it's own thing, call it telltales twd and recast Glenn to further separate the two universes.
@@hammywoods i agree, but since amcs twd is different from the comics, maybe the adaption for telltales twd can also be different? they could def make lee and clem in the same universe as the amc universe and not make it its own thing. it would also be cool to see steven yeun again as glenn if they do this, they coud prob make him look younger somehow
I don't believe the rumor, but if I redid it I would just remove a shitload of weird filler, and shorten the seasons to 12 episodes, six per part to move things along more efficiently. I'd adapt from both the comics and the original series, still deviating from both to make it it's own thing like Kirkman and Gimple did the first time around. I'd also try to shorten the show by 2-3 seasons (it did not need to be as long). If I could I wouldn't do it at HBO because Warner is a shitshow. I'd try to do it at FX, AMC again, Hulu, something.
If I ran The Walking Dead, I’d have 12 seasons, the first one would be 6 episodes, and the other ones would be 18 episodes divided into 3 runs of 6 episodes. Each run would, of course, cover a volume of the comics. So instead of 2 runs of 8 weeks per year, you’d have 3 runs of 6 weeks.
12 seasons is just too much for a one to one adaptation of the comic. Twd can't do 16 episodes without fluff and stretching things out. 8 seasons with 10 high quality episodes would work better,
If it's on HBO, I think it's gonna have The Last of Us budget, like more budget than AMC, and also follows the source material, just like they did with The Last of Us
Great video! It would be cool to see HBO do something down the road. And being on HBO of course it would be brutal in the cursing would be off the charts LOL Also I agree about Better Call Saul! I consider BCS and Breaking Bad to be perfect television shows. There's probably only three or four shows I would put in the category as perfect
the cast is the only reason im still invested in amcs universe because they are beyond amazing, but kirkmans complete story deserves to be seen. whether it's animated and it looks similar to adlers lovely art or a new live action series. AMC really fumbled the franchise in 2018 but the story deserves a second chance to be told the wAy it was intended
i will say even though some of the story decisions were terrible the actors and production team never failed to execute what they were given to work with
Make a second part talking about casting or the season structure like how many seasons and how many episodes each season should have I could listen to you talking about a HBO Reboot of TWD all day just imagining TWD’s source material with HBO’s budget and seasonal structure is crazy
If I was the show runner for the HBO The Walking Dead I would change a lot of things that the show did have it more to the comics carls alive rick and Andrea are together Ezekiel and Michonne are also together rick is still around Rosita and Ezekiel die on the pikes some changes can be there but not a lot Sophia’s alive Andrea stays alive to I think you get my point lori and Judith die Jesus would stay alive Carl would have his comic storyline with Lydia Dante would be more of a character it would be better for rick I would have him die the same way by getting shot by Sebastian but also what I have in mind Rick would die in season 9 episode 5 and have Carl take on the main character role and leadership role because like you said it is rick and carls story’s the cursing I would definitely keep in to The ending would be the same as the comic ending with old man Carl Season 8 A: All out war part One Season 8 B: All put war part two Season 9 A: a new beginning/ whisperers into screams Season 9 B: life and death Season 10 A: No turning back/ call to arms Season 10 B: A certain Doom Season 11 A: lines we cross/ a new world order Season 11 B: the rotten core/ Rest in peace
Hot take. They could have done a certain dooms plot with Rick and Andrea if they had carol get bit leading the herd off the cliff. I personally think this would have been the best thing writing wise to try and somewhat mimic the comics larger story. Daryl and Carol was the closest thing to them and just imagine the acting from Norman Reedus going through that loss
I agree with you about Better Call Saul being better than Breaking Bad. For me, I couldn’t get past Breaking Bad’s third season. But Better Call Saul omg. Anyways, that’s a comment for another video haha. As of HBO remaking TWD, I can definitely see them or even another company doing it (since Warner is kinda going downhill right now…). I can see them bringing Chandler Riggs as a sheriff cameo or something when he’s in his 40’s lol. It’d be a huge mistake for them not to follow the source material again, especially since it is already done. But, I highly doubt it would have the same huge impact as it’s first live action run. With so many entertainment right now (and wayyy more 20 years the line), it makes you wonder if it would just drown itself after the first two seasons or something.
Make sure there’s no filler episodes as well id just keep Abraham alive I know that’s not accurate to the source material but he’s such a good character.
I personally would make it an animated series in an art style similar to the comics and while I would maybe switch around some character deaths or add some show exclusive characters I wouldn't go over board with it like AMC did. Also yeah killing off Carl was dumb as fuck but if you had to kill Carl off what you do is make him one of the twelve pike victims of the Whisperers
If the walking dead was gonna get retold y not do it in a comic animation style u could give it that comic book feel have really gorey moments and overall would it not just be a whole lot cheaper to produce
Rick is the posse comitatus. Nothing higher than the county. Daryl He is the young adult Carl. Carl was to cutesy. He would have made a great mini Shane. Long hair, eye patch, and hat? Ridiculous. Short hair. Baseball Cap. Shotgun. Cool Carl. Rick physical feats. Was he on PCPs.? Actors. They played characters far younger. Daryl 16 the boy. Carol should have been 24. So after ten years they are 50 and doing D&D stunts and feats. Optional. A redo. * Carol unsavory. Really? Repeats. * Carl lives as a mini Shane. * Shane and Andrea depart. * Otis might be valiantly overwhelmed but Shane was not a coward. No assassins in the lawful good party please. Overall I think the producers are scarred loser D&D characters. Comic Book with no bait and switch. * And little guys are tossed to the zombies .
So you're basically saying as "showrunner" you wouldn't change a thing from the source material. So no pesky writers or anything and the audience gets to know episode by episode exactly what's going to happen ahead of time? Can you say predictably boring? The one thing that the show did Right, was including the comics major scenes but having rearranged the characters and story arcs so that as a fan of the comics you knew what Could be ahead but because the writers/showrunner juggled things you can never be sure who is going to get what particular death or injury or even when a particular scene from the comic will be adapted for the show. It was constant edge of your seat viewing. And even though i am a fan of the comics if I saw a live rendition of everything from the comics i probably wouldn't like it very much because most of the characters from the comic aren't particularly likeable. Not to mention the extreme over the top swearing done in the comic. It was irritating enough to read the "dialog " let alone sit through an hour at a time be cussed at mercilessly.
I would like if they did a comics accurate show thats beat for beat and includes the graphic plots in the comics the show never did that includes the characters from telltales walking dead into the narrative as a spin off side story cause Clementine lee and kenny meets Glenn Herchel Whisperers and Paul aka Jesus and have it animated like spawn and invincible
I’m looking forward to seeing the walking dead done right. None of this AMC character bullshit. No Daryls or Carols. I wanna see Andrea being badass like she was in the source material and a one handed Rick. Cast an actors with dwarfism to play Carl and Sofia and follow the blueprint that is the graphic novels and deal with adult themes like Game of Thrones did and the walking dead source material. Michonne needs to get the Sansa, Rick needs to get the Jaime Lannister and Lori needs to get the red wedding treatment to capture the true walking dead.
I would just restart everything if I was HBO , fresh new cast. Shorter seasons , longer episodes, less commercials. Do the one thing needs to do is get rid of Gimple, I would cast a Tim Miller type as the position of Gimple , sure he ruined terminator but that wasn’t all on him. Deadpool 1 isn’t Deadpool 1 without him, Get a tax write off on the all of the spin offs including the Rick show. Then I would sit on the property for 10 years and then being with where all stories should start the beginning. I want Patrick Warburton as Negan. I want twd as a brand if it was under someone else to cast villains at b+ actors because then it should us a reason to hate them more. I’d want Rhea sheehorn as Alpha, Michel Shannon as govenor and beta can stay the same. But that’s the only casting of the entire franchise I’d keep the same but obviously handle that arch better. I think u admit ur at a loss with Kirkman and stop trying to have him involved. he clearly wants to move on from it I think universal has the most potential if amc is ever bought out. After all they got the theme park at universal which could be the start of beginning of dark universe again the right way.
Nope. No thanks. I saw what HBO did with The Last of Us. I'll take a cable friendly Walking Dead over that sissified woke crap that HBO peddled for us for 9 episodes. They had absolute gold in story, dialogue, and character build to work with. But they said, "no.....we'll do it our way instead." I know the Walking Dead eventually went woke and dried up too, but we at least got about 5 or 6 good seasons first.
@@tomjohnson8410 Woke basically means to have awareness to issues of racial and sexual discrimination, as well as awareness to social justice. Yeah, its a real made up thing, and its retarded. As far as the writers go, yes I also am aware that the social justice warrior of them all, Neil Druckmann, is the writer for the games and the series. That doesn't make everything good and right with the world. Here's something else that maybe you aren't considering. In the original absolute brilliant masterpiece of a game, there were additional writers that actually carried weight and kept Neil well in check. When the garbage DLC and sequel game came around, Neil had brought on an insane horribly woke activist broad who notoriosly ruined game franchises during that time. The other grounded writers who worked with Neil on the first game, had moved on to other projects basically leaving Neil completely unchecked. And what we have gotten since then is Neil's personal warped identity politics manifested in story form. Its hot garbage and a crime against the original game. He of course, carried this crap right into the wretched HBO series that I won't even acknowledge. So you see, I don't just say things. I have purpose and grounding behind my points. Its truth. You may not like it because you don't agree, but you can't deny it......well you can, but you'd be wrong, and you'd know it.
@@tomjohnson8410What is Wokeness? The short answer: identity-based Marxism The oppressors in this brand of Marxism are whites, straight people, men, and Christians Woke ideology sees oppression from these groups in every aspect of Western life: free markets, law and order, home ownership, the family- you name it. The Utopian goal of Wokeness is a mirror image of what was attempted in Mao's China and Stalin's USSR- equal outcomes for all, regardless of merit, skills, or effort. They call it "equity".
@@tomjohnson8410 First off.....wouldn't that be enough? And on that note, the original game did a phenominal job of portraying a gay character in Bill. Not so much Ellie, but definetly with Bill. The game created a gay character that was human first and gay as a single trait and not the complete identity. I would think any rational gay person would respect this representation. The show completely shit the bed with Bill. Aside of that, lets see; One way race swaps with Maria and Sarah (Always black for white, but never the other way. And neither added anything to the show) They made Joel and Tommy complete pushover soy boys.(Can't have white guys playing an assertive lead role, can we?) They added that weird female militia leader that wasn't in any of the games. She was shoehorned into a role that she would never exist as in any universe other than SJW Neil Druckmann's world.( Just a cheap addition to fabricate unearned female empowerment) Sam was rewritten as deaf. (Not a problem if he was originally written that way in the game, but it added nothing to the story in the series. Just more pandering) Tommy and Maria's community was absolutely a nod to communism. (I imagine this is just another idiotic concept that Neil champions) Not to mention, the show was boring as hell. This is all that I can recall on a whim, as I haven't and won't be seeing the show since its original airing. I'm going to take a short leap and assume you are of the liberal mind set. I assume this as I had to itemize the woke infractions this series committed. I'm also assuming that you're ok with everything the show changed and represented. The fact is that it was a bad show that survived on the lore of the original game. Without that endorsement, we wouldn't be talking about this right now. It was a massive betrayal of its source material and it alienated a good chunk of its fanbase. Now I've offered a comment and two replies that fully and coherently explain my point. If you wish to continue talking, I ask that you rise to my level and come to the table with some content as I have. If you're going to continue to challenge me to explain myself while you make generalizations about me in turn for my explanations, then we can be finished here. I've done my diligence on this topic with you. Its your turn to bring something to the table.
Wow really original and great no new ideas just recycling the same crap what’s the point of watching your show if you can just get the same experience from reading the comics don’t you want something new something unique not just some one for one reboot garbage
The best option would be a full comic book adaptation except: 1. Don't make Rick a one-armed invalid 2. Don't make Carl a one-eyed invalid 3. Leave Andrea alive and don't put her under old Dale
Your making great points tonight jerry but like me , I would write this all out . then do a three part video, u can take the idea just give me a shout out. I’ve never done it but I’ve wanted too. U should Get an editor to add photo shop imagery of what details u would want. the third part being on the week of the season finale of the Rick show. It would be sooooooo good. Please Jerry ❤
They should have Shane run away with Andrea and hook up with Michonne and then Shane could have three kids and Daryl needs to get laid alot more with the hershie daughter
As much as I would like to see a faithful adaptation, there’s just so much from amc version of the tv show that made people fall in love with the show, but there’s also ALOT of what made people fall out of love. If we could see them fix their mistakes like not killing off Carl, making the survivor war shorter, seeing more of the original characters like Rick and Carl in the whisperer war. But then there’s stuff we also wouldn’t see such as possible Daryl, Merle, negan being more of a bigger character after the war , and honestly just the actors themselves. I could never see anyone fulfilling the roles as good for characters like Rick, negan, Shane, (possibly Daryl and Merle) carol, Glenn, Abraham, Eugene… idk man I would like a 3rd canon and have Kirkman fix a lot of mistakes from the show and even his comic run of the universe and be heavily involved with it
here is what i would do: 1. i'd make the story have some elements from both the comics and tv show 2. i'll do away with some useless characters and put a spotlight on the more important ones. too many characters makes stories hard to follow and too complex in my opinion. 3. it would be truly rated TV-MA. the orginal Walking Dead is gory, but they don't so that many bad words, which is unrealistic and inconsistent since Merle said a racial slur in the first season and Daryl started saying bad words later on. the only bad word they ever seem to use is "ass", "shit", and "damn." 4. Carl would survive till the very end. 5. The seasons would be shorter, though the episodes would be long. Kind of like Game of Thrones. 6. Some of the villains, like Negan, would be less over-the-top and more grounded. 7. Characters would act more consistent. 8. Character roles would be more in line with their character. I don't like characters like Daryl taking up leadership positions. Daryl is a good soldier. He's not a good leader like Rick, Abraham, Shane. comic Tyreese, and Glenn. 9. When a character is done, they will either die or just sort of go on to do their own thing. Abraham dying was good because his character was finished and his death made sense. Same with TV Hershel, TV Shane, and even TV Andrea's death (though more could've been done with her character). I think Carol should've been sidelined and I think Daryl should've died. I think the reboot should have more balls with what they do with their characters. 10. I would make some plotlines unique and introduce unique ideas while also maintaining plotlines faithful to the original source. 11. I would make the zombie virus still a mysterious thing. I'd even make it unclear if it's an Earth-made virus due to how weird it functions. I find it stupid how the only way you turn is from a bite or scratch. Apparently you wont get sick if you rub zombie blood all over your skin (funny because most characters have scratches here and there on their faces), or if you wear their skin. My new rules would make it so that there is a risk that getting bit, scratched, or contaminated with zombie blood or anything zombie related would cause you to get sick and die, likely from the virus mutating. 12. I'd make the zombies scarier by change #11 but I'd also make it so that fresh zombies make sounds similar to the Runners from The Last of Us. I'd keep their season 1 intelligence, and I'd make them run or quickly shuffle like the infected in TLOU. though as a zombie rots, they'd get dumber, make raspier noises, have a decrease in apatite, and they'd walk and would be called Walkers at that point. I feel like calling them runners when they are fresh would be a bit too close to TLOU and would present copyright issues, despite the term being more common than people think in terms of fiction. 13. Zombies would be somewhat a bit more vampiric. Now you may be wondering what i mean by this. And it's simple: i think they should be "undead" but not completely. I think their stomach acid and digestive organs should half-way function for a while rather than being prone to exploding if they over eat. I mean, of course, that is possible. But that would mean full, exploded zombies who can hardly even walk should be a more common sight than it is in the show. though as they rot, their brains, and other organs become more and more disintegrated, obviously making their organs non-functional. 14. Finally, I'd make the story shorter and get rid of stupid shit. You aren't going to see a rip-off of Ulysses from Fallout New Vegas with a giant pet TIGER (which is the most dangerous land predator in the world, aside from the polar bear). There isn't going to be a whisperer arc. The story will end much sooner, likely with the death of Rick and/or Negan at the end of All Out War, with Carl or Glenn being the one who kills Negan. The whisperers are stupid. The Commonwealth is stupid. The Kingdom is stupid. Eventually, all the zombies will rot away and people would evolve. And I think this will be the main difference between the comics and the reboot. the reboot would demonstrate humanities ability to adapt and how temporary pain and suffering is in the grand scheme of things. Whereas the comics seem to imply - at the very end - that the zombies took over everything, as you watch the stature of Rick Grimes being obscured by a gargantuan horde of walkers. Not only is this a bit too grim for an already grim story, it's also stupid. Because, if you haven't noticed already, even in colder climates, the zombies ROT. if they rot, they will eventually disappear. and 99% of anyone who lives long enough to see the nigh-extinction of walkers would know to to prevent themselves, friends, and foes alike from turning into walkers.
