Тёмный

When Fraudsters Do Science | The Rise and Fall of Celebrity “Scientist” Paolo Macchiarini 

Nerd Nite
Подписаться 12 тыс.
Просмотров 353 тыс.
50% 1

For as long as we’ve known of them, we’ve studied stem cells in the hopes of exploiting their regenerative properties to grow new tissues and even whole new organs. And for a time, it seemed Dr. Paolo Macchiarini delivered the miracle that would make tissue regeneration therapies a reality. He earned prestigious grants and renown across the world, but Macchiarini was a medical con artist. And before his final verdict was rendered he would ruin the lives of his whistleblowers and take the lives of over half his patients. What drives scientists to commit fraud and how did someone like Macchiarini get away with it for so long?
The presenter, Kris Sunderic, PhD, is a freelance Science Writer and Science Communicator. He graduated from Boston University in 2007 with a BS in biomedical engineering before entering the pharmaceutical industry as a research scientist working on vaccine formulations. He went on to earn his MS in biomedical engineering at the City College of New York in 2012, researching the effects of mild heat shock on the osteogenesis of mesenchymal stem cells and continued his research as a PhD candidate, studying the effects of heat shock and ultrasound on stem cells grown in mineralized polymer scaffold before earning his doctorate in 2018. Kris has given talks at both professional conferences and science outreach events and continues to pursue his passion for science communication. In his spare time, he enjoys stargazing, volunteering to teach STEM curricula, and winning trivia competitions around New York City. You can follow Kris on Twitter at @peer_revue.
Nerd Nite is a monthly presentation series held in nearly 100 cities globally during which several folks give fun-yet-informative presentations across all disciplines... while the audience drinks beer!
Find a Nerd Nite near you (or become a presenter!): nerdnite.com/
Like Nerd Nite on Facebook: / nerdnite
Follow Nerd Nite on Twitter: / nerdnite

Опубликовано:

 

26 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 954   
@curliefro
@curliefro 3 года назад
Beautifully presented! This was much better than the 20/20 report yesterday. This was to the point without sensationalism and highlighted many ethical issues!
@NerdNite
@NerdNite 3 года назад
Thank you!
@waterbabe415
@waterbabe415 3 года назад
Completely agree!!!!!
@egormc5919
@egormc5919 3 года назад
I fully agree. Just watched that one and left with more questions, until I found this one!
@dreamingtree6093
@dreamingtree6093 3 года назад
Yes, this was exactly what I was looking for. The 20/20 footage was redundant and low brow. I'm more interested in the scientific side of this
@charliecharlton9782
@charliecharlton9782 3 года назад
People need to get over their awe over doctors as if they are God. No they are not. They are often assholes.
@mio7464
@mio7464 3 года назад
I feel really bad for the team of doctors who tried to reveal the truth.
@citticat2
@citticat2 3 года назад
No justice for the whistleblowers. The doctor as well as the Institute should have been held accountable -- it is all about $$$$$.
@yurttgjk
@yurttgjk 10 месяцев назад
Same. It's just not fair..
@PM-pc7ql
@PM-pc7ql 9 месяцев назад
Covid vaccine and origin anyone.
@cerambyx-8
@cerambyx-8 Год назад
Just to show the scale of this, he was in my biology textbook when I was 16 doing my exams, I still have the textbook. It is in the chapter on cells, tissues and organs, and on the page about stems cells there is a photo of him and his transplant patient who is now dead. An entire cohort of biology students where wrongly taught about the capabilities of stem cell technology. The exam questions were always about the ethics of stem cell research, which is ironic.
@paddlefar9175
@paddlefar9175 11 месяцев назад
There are ethical applications of stem cells for Cancer patients at least.
@cerambyx-8
@cerambyx-8 11 месяцев назад
@@paddlefar9175 Of course, Hematopoietic stem cell transplants are widely used to blood cancers, various blood diseases and certain rare autoimmune diseases. There is a lot of promising research in novel stem cell therapies in cancers (even solid tumours) and autoimmune diseases. It is not the same as the stem cell therapy offered at cosmetic clinics to tighten skin- which lacks any good evidence.
@terryjones573
@terryjones573 10 месяцев назад
@@paddlefar9175 No duh. They never implied otherwise.
@paddlefar9175
@paddlefar9175 10 месяцев назад
@@terryjones573 I never implied either, that he implied otherwise. Cerambyx-8 stated, “ An entire cohort of biology students where wrongly taught about the capabilities of stem cell technology.” Since cerambyx could have been either referring to the incorrect science presented by rogue doctor Macchiarini, or perhaps saying that there aren’t good applications for Stem cell technology ( I don’t think he meant this one), but to clarify, I just added that there are still good scientific applications for Stem cell Technology.
@terryjones573
@terryjones573 10 месяцев назад
@@paddlefar9175 So your answer to my question is “a huge moron”.
@pshehan1
@pshehan1 Год назад
I was a whistleblower at the University of Sydney and had my career destroyed. When I said to the gentleman from the NSW Ombudsman's office that I had thought that universities were places where honesty and integrity mattered, he laughed out loud. The fact is that these organisations are run by careerist bureaucrats who are only interested in covering for the organisation and themselves. A few years later the department I had warned about collapsed like a house of cards.
@Nique25
@Nique25 Год назад
In this situation do you have any recourse after the fact, considering you attempted to make them aware of whatever the problem was beforehand?
@pshehan1
@pshehan1 Год назад
@@Nique25 No. The fact is I have wearied of the whole thing.
@coimbralaw
@coimbralaw Год назад
Or maybe you were just envious of the success of the establishment or other alumns, and you were looking for any reason to undermine them and so you resorted to what most enviers do: moralizing
@pshehan1
@pshehan1 Год назад
@@coimbralaw I was part of the success of the establishment but could no longer tolerate what was happening after one colleague, a surgeon doing his PhD, told me that if he did not take a year off his candidature he would be clinically depressed, and another told me he was resigning, his wife adding that he hated going into work in the morning. My initial plea was for people to modify their behavior for everyone's benefit.
@bevis5372
@bevis5372 Год назад
​@coimbralaw Usyd been investigated by the state independent commission against corruption as recently as at least 2020. It's turned out a few big wig politicians and the sort. Almost all of Sydney's major universities have been caught doing underhanded shit.
@kristinmeyer489
@kristinmeyer489 Год назад
There should be a special kind of prison for practitioners of medical fraud, especially the kind that treats human beings like objects, and truth-tellers like criminals.
@vidal9747
@vidal9747 11 месяцев назад
I say this as someone who is involved in research. Scientific fraud should be a criminal offense. No matter the area, if you commit fraud in science you should go to prison. The amount of resources and time scientific fraud throws away is mind blowing. One of the areas in which you can cause the most damage to mankind as a whole is in scientific fraud.
@TheEmmakathryn
@TheEmmakathryn 3 года назад
That friend who clearly went 'oh hell no' and actually bothered to do the briefest of searches to check the pope's schedule is the real mvp
@debbiemac1923
@debbiemac1923 3 года назад
I first learned about this on a podcast, then the 20/20 program. I question why this allegedly savvy, sophisticated, intelligent TV producer believed every word - and her "friends" - with no research into his background or claims at all. Then she makes her story public on multiple platforms. Crazy story. What was his end game?
@angelicamimosa
@angelicamimosa 3 года назад
@@debbiemac1923 Ask Elisabeth Holmes what her end game was and it will be the same answer. As for how does an intelligent successful woman get blindly involved with a con man ; he was a good con man, he conned the medical world for years.
@matheusjahnke8643
@matheusjahnke8643 Год назад
Imagine if the guy was slightly more competent at lying and the whole story managed to die down without the thing blowing up.
@selmahare
@selmahare 8 месяцев назад
Lol yes.
@TheOtherBoobJustDropped
@TheOtherBoobJustDropped 4 месяца назад
@@debbiemac1923 when you love someone, people will believe a lot of crazy things - especially if the person you love is a good liar and manipulator. It’s the same reason people stay in abusive relationships
@MikeRyzhikov
@MikeRyzhikov Год назад
The Karolinska institute should be be scrutinized further. As a biomedical scientist, ethics courses were a requirement throughout my education to receive a PhD or a MD/PhD. Apparently Karolinska institute does not understand the concept of ETHICS.
@Matt_10203
@Matt_10203 9 месяцев назад
Yep. This incident really calls into question their credibility across the board. Research coming from them really needs a deeper inspection from this point onwards.
@ArtU4All
@ArtU4All 8 месяцев назад
No. They do. But the lawyers know how to get around this to keep the $$$$$ flowing
@hugomikaelsson4055
@hugomikaelsson4055 2 года назад
The name of the hospital is not "Narolinska" as the narrator says from time to time but rarher "Karolinska." Btw, Machiarini was yesterday sentenced to five years in prison after being convicted of medical fraud.
@mustangnawt1
@mustangnawt1 Год назад
5 years:(
@johnjohnson3709
@johnjohnson3709 Год назад
5 years?? That’s all?
@Kisel228-fp8iz
@Kisel228-fp8iz Год назад
@@johnjohnson3709 It's actually only 2 years...
@c99kfm
@c99kfm 11 месяцев назад
@@Kisel228-fp8iz 2 years and 3 months. And in Sweden, he'll serve 18 months, or 2/3 of the full time, before being set free. Don't ask.
@atp5400
@atp5400 10 месяцев назад
That dude needs to be careful somebody doesn´t come after him after he is released.
@williamlitsch5506
@williamlitsch5506 Год назад
A specialist in esophageal surgery performed an operation on my dad. He traveled cross country to do the rare operation and was clearly excited. It was performed so badly that my dad never left the bed and fell into a coma from the infection the doctor gave him. Two weeks later he walked into the hospital chapel and went on and on about how the operation was a success and that as a result we should definitely unplug our dad so that he can die properly. I tell this story to point out that this piece of cr@p, hghmm, I mean surgeon was rewarded and praised regardless of the outcome of patients. This isn't an outlier. It is standard practice of surgeons and the AMA in the US. I don't know about elsewhere.
@lunam7249
@lunam7249 Год назад
surgeon : "the operation was 100% succesful.... patient dies; surgeon : "the operation was still 100% successful"
@mustangnawt1
@mustangnawt1 Год назад
I’m so sorry about your Dad. Would be yelling about him from the rooftops. How long ago was this? Past the 3 yr malpractice point? IMO and allegedly of course
@williamlitsch5506
@williamlitsch5506 Год назад
@@mustangnawt1 20 years or so ago.
@TheQueenRulesAll
@TheQueenRulesAll Год назад
I am so sorry for your loss.
@sandstorm8874
@sandstorm8874 Год назад
I am sorry for your loss, it's heartbreaking. Thank God I haven't lost anyone like that yet, but I keep telling people that doctors can be scammers too and that modern medicine is money -driven, so it's not only surgery but the whole field is plagued by this corruption. They think I'm crazy, they say I'm a conspiracist. They don't understand how the science and medicine industries so they rather have blind fate in the white coats., and trust the doc that ended your dad instead of the victims that suffered the loss.
@insearchoftruehappiness9214
@insearchoftruehappiness9214 3 года назад
It made me angry, why they dragged the poor doctors down who helped expose his lies. This is the reason ppl stay away from such scandals and ignore such misconducts.
@sam-fc9ky
@sam-fc9ky Год назад
question is why did it take so long before they stopped his experiments?? The karolinaka institute is more to blame than He!!!
@goffe2282
@goffe2282 11 месяцев назад
@@sam-fc9ky I'm Swedish, and you won't get any argument from me.
@lawanapoopoksakul7072
@lawanapoopoksakul7072 9 месяцев назад
Seriously those courageous doctors need to be rewarded
@jensanchez3646
@jensanchez3646 7 месяцев назад
The first doctor to tell hospitals about germs was kicked out of medicine, and ridiculed. He went around telling hospitals about it, but he was treated horribly.
@jensanchez3646
@jensanchez3646 7 месяцев назад
Look at how they reacted to Lucy Letby. They hold alot of the blame for her murder spree. They even made whistle blowers apologize to her. Hospitals don't want to be known as the murder hospital, so they will often facilitate these monsterous acts.
@staceya7870
@staceya7870 4 года назад
The fact that he did NO testing on animals FIRST, is insane and he should have his medical license revoked for experimenting on humans, first.
@arizonahighways7287
@arizonahighways7287 3 года назад
The fast-tracking for this Covid vaxx is the same- skip the animal testing, go right for the sheep-
@katarinaj.6830
@katarinaj.6830 3 года назад
And be in jail too..he killed people
@Deer548
@Deer548 3 года назад
@@arizonahighways7287 just stop comparing the Covid vax to this. You don’t sound normal,
@kimanderson2342
@kimanderson2342 3 года назад
@@arizonahighways7287 stfu
@augurcybernaut4785
@augurcybernaut4785 Год назад
@@Deer548😂😂😅
@juliadagnall5816
@juliadagnall5816 Год назад
9:41 I just finished reading a book on whistleblowers yesterday and my takeaway was: people love to shoot the messenger. The stuff these guys went through were classic intimidation tactics- the goal isn’t just to discredit them and make them go away, but to cow anyone else who might have information and stop them from speaking up. Sadly a lot of whistleblowers never get to work in their chosen field again because, even if they are proved correct, they’re forever marked as being malcontents or not ‘team players’. For some reason a lot of organizations just don’t seem to like the idea of having an observant and principled person on their staff. Can’t imagine why.
@celiacelisally
@celiacelisally 11 месяцев назад
💯
@miawmiawcat1838
@miawmiawcat1838 10 месяцев назад
what is the name of the book?
@juliadagnall5816
@juliadagnall5816 10 месяцев назад
@@miawmiawcat1838Crisis of Conscience by Tom Meuller
@erinmok6334
@erinmok6334 9 месяцев назад
If that's the case, that's how human nature are. Human don't like to listen to truth. Don't want to be truth. They want to hear what they "need" to hear. That's how the world is detoriating.
@ohhoneystop
@ohhoneystop 8 месяцев назад
I need the book name!
@taiya001
@taiya001 9 месяцев назад
What is insane is how he still has his medical license.
@MM-qp4pd
@MM-qp4pd 9 месяцев назад
Follow the science they said. Take your weekly boosters they said. Btw who were the medica and media professionals who worked with him through this and never said a thing????
@selmahare
@selmahare 8 месяцев назад
And is probably practicing in some developing country.
@addictedtochocolateandcoff9582
@addictedtochocolateandcoff9582 8 месяцев назад
yep plus only a year jail
@MM-qp4pd
@MM-qp4pd 8 месяцев назад
@@selmahare 😭😭😭😭 who is allowing this? Are these people who allow this the same people who told the masses to follow the science and take your weekly boosters???
@miroslavaquinones4437
@miroslavaquinones4437 3 года назад
very well explained. It is crazy how some of these people literally get away with murder.
@citticat2
@citticat2 3 года назад
Happening today - on so many levels.
@juliametcalf2660
@juliametcalf2660 Год назад
In its effort for God-like accomplishments..complete cures & recovery ..murder IS being committed
@katiebarber407
@katiebarber407 Год назад
god is the master of murder - after all. trillions and counting. @@juliametcalf2660
@Avarcirith
@Avarcirith 9 месяцев назад
I know I'm late to respond here, but yes, it literally is murder. Tragically, a lot of these cases are even worse than what many killers are in prison for-- Macchiarini's patients (especially Yesim Cetir) suffered extremely for long periods of time and underwent incomprehensible mental anguish before they died. Almost anyone in their situation would take dying from a gunshot wound or stabbing over any of what they went through. Macchiarini easily deserves life in prison.
@kristincappiello2598
@kristincappiello2598 3 года назад
Perfect guy for Elizabeth Holmes
@SHHEMP1
@SHHEMP1 3 года назад
that also crossed my mind.
@TheJillscott1
@TheJillscott1 2 года назад
Definitely!! I thought the same thing.
@elenazaslavsky5268
@elenazaslavsky5268 10 месяцев назад
Some of Macchiarini's patients, like young & beautiful Julia from Krasnodar (Russia), could've lived without this surgery but instead went through what turned out a prolonged and agonizing pain following her transplant procedure performed by Paolo Macchiarini. He literally talked Julia to do the surgery, and as a result she died young, living her small son behind motherless. Doctor from hell treated his patients like they are his lab rats, no regards for human life, no remorse, this is wrong & scary on so many levels!
@MM-qp4pd
@MM-qp4pd 9 месяцев назад
Follow the science they said. Take your weekly boosters they said. Btw who were the medica and medial professionals who worked with him through this and never said a thing????
@fedfan3079
@fedfan3079 9 месяцев назад
@@MM-qp4pdif it wasn’t for science polio, the plague, measles, tuberculosis, infections would still be killing millions of people. If you had cancer would you get treatment from a dr? Science needs to be followed. Just like in life there are psychopaths/enablers in the science field.
@sanafahad6578
@sanafahad6578 10 месяцев назад
The fact that he only gets to serve 30 months in prison. He killed 8 patients that he performed surgery on. Initially court dismissed two out of three patients that died during the procedure. Its absurd to see that he will live as a free man even after knowing and killing 8 patients
@justinwillingale2086
@justinwillingale2086 8 месяцев назад
well shorten their already short lives
@kimberlygaray7860
@kimberlygaray7860 2 года назад
Tragic that everyone learned about this through the fraud marriage scandal. I'm grateful that this goes into the issues in academia and the medical field that allowed him to get away with being a fraud and killing people for so long.
@karinagodzina5028
@karinagodzina5028 Год назад
I just want to aknowledge the pain of patients who died in cause of this huge lie. These people trusted this man- Macchiarini and did not know it was a scam for his famousity and grandiosity. They suffered a lot and all died ( except t one who had this trahia out) R.I.P
@MM-qp4pd
@MM-qp4pd 9 месяцев назад
Follow the science they said. Take your weekly boosters they said. Btw who were the medica and media professionals who worked with him through this and never said a thing????
@Reddotzebra
@Reddotzebra 10 месяцев назад
I remember still working in molecular diagnostics while this guy made his first wild claims about being able to do this, the subject came up around the lunch table at work and my first reply was basically "horseshit, there is no way he can just spray some stem cells on there and have it grow to shape because he's trying to do it in one of the most exposed areas of the human body. Even if by some miracle he would get it to work, there would be serious infections going on throughout the entire process." I don't understand why all the experts that hired him and let him do this crap weren't as skeptical, but hey I guess once you reach a certain level in academia you can just lie out your ass and nobody will question you until bodies start piling up.
@Krassiana
@Krassiana 25 дней назад
I am no doctor and my first reaction was the same as yours. The whole idea of just bathing plastic in stem cells and then it magically gets approved but the body seems ridiculous 🤣 If only it was so easy.
@caroldixon7796
@caroldixon7796 3 года назад
I don't understand why his medical license has not been revoked. Or perhaps I missed that? Fantastic presentation, thank you very much. Sometimes the audience reaction seemed inappropriate though.
@MM-qp4pd
@MM-qp4pd 9 месяцев назад
Follow the science they said. Take your weekly boosters they said. Btw who were the medica and media professionals who worked with him through this and never said a thing????
@kittygirl_thetortie498
@kittygirl_thetortie498 10 месяцев назад
Whistleblowers - the morally upright and ethically people all over the world are always punished for their honesty and refusal to stand by corruption. This is massive injustice and in summary what is wrong with this world we live in. Stay strong whistleblowers.
@MM-qp4pd
@MM-qp4pd 9 месяцев назад
Follow the science they said. Take your weekly boosters they said. Btw who were the medica and media professionals who worked with him through this and never said a thing????
@dreamingtree6093
@dreamingtree6093 3 года назад
For the people criticizing the laughter: this is a really common thing in these kinds of presentations. As a scientist, I go to them often. It's just sarcasm regarding the ridiculous and obscene nature of this doctor's behavior along with the incompetent people who blindly supported his decisions without attempting to falsify anything. Believe me; everyone is acutely aware of how grave the doctor's misrepresentations were. The laughing is just a way of expressing how absurd the situation was.
@NerdNite
@NerdNite 3 года назад
Thank you for the context!
@powerfully_confident1739
@powerfully_confident1739 3 года назад
@@NerdNite not to mention you being funny af! It’s your boyyy! Hahahaha 😆😂🤣😂😂🤣😂😆😂🤣
@Carylina1
@Carylina1 3 года назад
Disagree with your audience assessment.
@dreamingtree6093
@dreamingtree6093 3 года назад
@@Carylina1 Thanks for the comprehensive reply.
@auzieblo
@auzieblo 3 года назад
I get your explanation. However, i also found this over the top laughter distasteful. It would be more acceptable perhaps, if no people died in the process. But they did. And these audience members are reacting like in some cheap, "who's the baby daddy" Jerry Springer type show.
@Dmanz67
@Dmanz67 11 месяцев назад
The documentary about this surgeon is harrowing, the suffering of his patients who you get to know on camera. Absolutely horrific.
@aperfectcircle0219
@aperfectcircle0219 11 месяцев назад
If you feel bad for the doctors who got dragged, you can always start by supporting academic whistleblowers now. The gentlemen at Data Colada need our support!
@boots4yew
@boots4yew Год назад
Yeah. I've experienced this first hand. Back before I gave up my PhD studies, in Korea, my professor was so desperate for a publication that he forced me to publish a near replica of the work a previous graduate student had done. He sold me on the idea that I would be creating at least 30% new content in the re-analysis. This after, I had begged him to not push me into this. In the end, he rejected nearly all my additional content on the grounds it was merely adding complication to the publication. So, in reality, the paper published was mostly just a summarized translation from the original Korean version of my lab-mate's thesis version into English.
@chossenone730
@chossenone730 9 месяцев назад
😢
@iamjenniferveee
@iamjenniferveee 10 месяцев назад
Who's here after watching Bad Surgeon on Netflix? 🙋‍♀️
@snbalaji1
@snbalaji1 3 года назад
Many research head are like this. My Ph.D. supervisor is also manipulating data just to get publications. He is a faculty in reputed institute in India. I am helpless, and almost left the research career.
@marial3231
@marial3231 3 года назад
I’m sorry you’re going through that.
@angelathach555
@angelathach555 3 года назад
Report him, expose him. Saying it on a RU-vid comment is not enough
@cesarebachelli
@cesarebachelli 3 года назад
@@angelathach555 probably not powerful enough to do so especially when someone is just doing degree or masters.
@citticat2
@citticat2 3 года назад
That is why you have to look at research very carefully because studies are often done with an outcome in mind.
@fathimamuhammad3799
@fathimamuhammad3799 Год назад
@snbalaji1 I have noticed the same thing and so many of my classmates are doing the same thing, in India and in US. I had to leave for my own sanity and go into industry
@zamiadams4343
@zamiadams4343 3 года назад
Fantastic presentation, I was watching the 20/20 episodes and wanted to know more on this fraudster, thanks.
@debbiemac1923
@debbiemac1923 3 года назад
So many tragic stories connected to this criminal, including a three year old child who died after his surgery.
@teaclaypot
@teaclaypot 10 месяцев назад
Who”s here after watching the Bad Surgeon Netflix documentary?
@choboutube
@choboutube 2 года назад
If his theory of using a scaffold with stem cells to reconstruct a trachea had come up to a panel of his peers, it would have been immediately kicked out. Even if the scaffold became viable/ vascularized, there would be no way of making it turn into rigid cartilage (substitute). It was a complete load of twaddle. But I don't blame the surgeon so much as the Karolinska, they were just trying to cover it up. Total unscrupulous and everyone involved should have been made to resign.
@CloudyObsession
@CloudyObsession 11 месяцев назад
There's a lot of high-production documentaries about fraudsters on RU-vid nowadays but I really appreciate the tried-and-true Talk format, all you need is well-conveyed facts on good slides and a guy who presents the story in a fun and engaging way
@MFK1967
@MFK1967 Год назад
The slideshow is actually more informative than the 2020 piece
@victoryismine9297
@victoryismine9297 3 года назад
He stuck huge fake plastic tracheas into sick people? That is horrendous.
@Maja-cu3xk
@Maja-cu3xk 9 месяцев назад
Also in healthy people
@cheekarp2180
@cheekarp2180 Год назад
I was a whistle blower at a bank, they punished me so hard that they made me mentally ill.
@dcole2133
@dcole2133 10 месяцев назад
So sorry, you had a traumatic experience due to corruption
@TheQueenRulesAll
@TheQueenRulesAll Год назад
I recently saw a report about using stem cells to reduce rejection in organ transplants. One hint as to whether it is true or not is in how much hype and drama is added instead of explaining the science behind it.
@fredriko.zachrisson9711
@fredriko.zachrisson9711 Год назад
Him being based here in Sweden i can see why he wasnt exposed earlier. Swedes are afraid of confrontation and at the same time thinks the best of everyone generally. I am sure there were red flags early but you dont want to damage relations by accusing somebody
@Pepperman86
@Pepperman86 9 месяцев назад
I just wish that netflix would be as objective as this guy instead of focusing on the romance with the dumb reporter that believed that he was friends with Bill Clinton and Barack Obama
@blackfishbones
@blackfishbones 9 месяцев назад
Exactly like I did not care about their relationship
@GreyException
@GreyException 9 месяцев назад
I was like "slap the bimbo out of her please"
@clarkeeeee
@clarkeeeee Год назад
It's frustrating for any institution to say "It would be better for people to keep suffering and dying than to get caught up in a scandal."
@91Vault
@91Vault 9 месяцев назад
Yesim Cetir's episode (Dr Death Season 2) was such a hard watch I had to skip through half of it. Truly heartbreaking.
@Starbuc1
@Starbuc1 8 месяцев назад
That was really difficult to watch…especially knowing that she did in fact have 191 additional surgeries including the complete removal of her esophagus. These implants were basically rotting in these poor people. Jail is too good for him… in my world he would get a bio-synthetic trachea…a few millimeters short… just to be fair.
@carolinemullan2781
@carolinemullan2781 3 года назад
This is fascinating and horrifying. Great work. So sad about his patients especially. What widespread damage. Your presentation is hilarious and incisive.
@saltlifegull4091
@saltlifegull4091 9 месяцев назад
Good job. Let me get this straight: 'Bonita' (type of fish) jumped at that shiny bait and swallowed it hook, line and sinker! She knowingly jeopardized and traded her integrity, career and reputation for the glitter of gold; violated terms of her contract with an employer who trusted her; left her daughter with whomever while jet-setting all over the world and thoroughly enjoying thousands of dollars being spent on her by Paola. Who are the real VICTIMS here: The patients, the doctors who tried to stop him, Paola's wife and kids, her friends who lost thousands of dollars. Benita is continuing to line her pockets and boost her new-found "celebrity" status via her con man, thru interviews, tv shows, etc, that stem from her bad decisions and basic stupidity.
@ganymede
@ganymede 2 месяца назад
i disagree. he is a classic narcissist who takes advantage of people. lots of women fall prey to these type of men who offer them the world, it was all a grandiose act to swoon her and use her for his needs. i'm not surprised that she got trapped in it and i wouldn't blame other women for it either. these type of people are manipulative and evil. i'm just glad that she got free and she deserves every right to milk it and get a life that supports her family, while also bringing awareness.
@RedBlue-pn7rv
@RedBlue-pn7rv Месяц назад
​@@ganymedeshe needs to take accountability since she touts her investigation skills!!! It was stupid of her to not do her due diligence. I am from Hollywood and no one there does this! Everyone does their due diligence. Benita of all people knows not to believe the hype. Otherwise she is much dumber than she ever thought. She also needs to move on. Take accountability and move on. No one put a gun to her head. Come on! She is old enough to be someone's great grandma.
@Kwize652
@Kwize652 10 месяцев назад
Do I understand that this correctly? After all the damage done to lives, both patients and doctors , he gets 2.5 years???
@andyanderson5303
@andyanderson5303 3 года назад
That laugh caught me off guard.
@ShellyBomb
@ShellyBomb 3 года назад
I agree, wholly inappropriate and callous!
@אילייןלוי
@אילייןלוי 3 года назад
Caught me off guard as well,its disgusting laughing about this!!
@Bearsie413
@Bearsie413 3 года назад
Well the audience is drinking beer while this lecture is being done. (Read the description)
@citygirlingraham
@citygirlingraham 3 года назад
Well, this speaker encourages the laughter, sometimes people laugh at inappropriate times.
@SunriseFestival
@SunriseFestival 3 года назад
Paolo Maccharini, a real expert in the materials compatibility.
@gessicatomazini9244
@gessicatomazini9244 3 года назад
????????????????????????/
@SunriseFestival
@SunriseFestival 3 года назад
@@gessicatomazini9244 Yes. Why on earth would human stem cell's accept bonding with a polymer?
@kittygirl_thetortie498
@kittygirl_thetortie498 10 месяцев назад
The problem with the refusal of any instituition investigating and exposing these frauds even being warned by whistleblowers is that it will reflect very badly on them. If they expose the fraudster and their crimes or misconducts, they inexplicably are exposing their own incompetence, credibility, carelessness etc.
@90loneeagle
@90loneeagle 3 года назад
This is like a standup comedy night!
@toughcookie6109
@toughcookie6109 3 года назад
Who else came after True Lies part 5 unfinished saga ?
@kelle345
@kelle345 3 года назад
🙋🏽‍♀️
@DJ-nk4dq
@DJ-nk4dq 3 года назад
Man....I was on S5 E10 until I found this. Wish I saw this first and went on with my life.
@entitleddocs
@entitleddocs 3 года назад
Those editors can go straight to hell
@bartonempire
@bartonempire 3 года назад
Me
@bartonempire
@bartonempire 3 года назад
After part 5, I found a the whole episode, and just ff to where part 5 left off, right when she went to Spain to the house she knew secrets were kept. *****spoiler alert**** He was there with another woman and 2 kids.
@lampenfieber
@lampenfieber 2 месяца назад
The guy presenting this is so confident and in general great to listen to! Not boring at all!
@av8054
@av8054 3 года назад
This is not funny 😡 People died under this doctors hands!!!
@purplegalaxies2149
@purplegalaxies2149 11 месяцев назад
As a Swede, it’s disappointing to see one of our most prestigious universities will fully ignore all the warnings and findings. Because of what? Fame?
@monicarose2135
@monicarose2135 10 месяцев назад
Funding, fame, opportunity to win a Noble Prize
@docrocket7393
@docrocket7393 5 лет назад
What a fascinating story and an excellent presentation!
@debbiemac1923
@debbiemac1923 3 года назад
Agree. Fascinating; and incredible how he got away with it. Similar to the Christopher Duntsch story.
@giovannisantostasi9615
@giovannisantostasi9615 8 месяцев назад
The lady laughing at every single mild joke is unsufferable, we are talking about the death of several patients here.
@NikeZ-mr727
@NikeZ-mr727 3 года назад
When you meant to go to a comedy club and accidentally went into something else but still laugh through it anyways
@susiecreamcheese5830
@susiecreamcheese5830 3 года назад
I read where Grenemmo was fully exonerated. It took three years however.
@rachelgooden9981
@rachelgooden9981 3 года назад
Happy to hear that. Sigh
@LifewithMae2023
@LifewithMae2023 3 года назад
Finally Find Something More Sense than being in a Roller Coaster Episodes of True Lies.
@joe-dl6ep
@joe-dl6ep 10 месяцев назад
If medical establishment was blind to this for years what else could they be turning a blind eye too?
@carolinesubromani8187
@carolinesubromani8187 3 года назад
Well done... Your explation is on point and precise and your voice kept us listening to the very end... 100% to this video
@TacoLlamaYES
@TacoLlamaYES 6 месяцев назад
I feel like I can always tell a good scientist by how goofy they are. The world is extremely grim, and science doesn't always provide answers, or answers that anybody will listen to. It's extremely demoralizing. But humor makes it easy to cope with the rediculousness of that reality, and shows why a good scientist keeps sciencing: they have hope
@pamela7462
@pamela7462 3 года назад
The laughing's innappropriate. People died, were scammed.
@millyday
@millyday 3 года назад
Yes and no. I laugh at the ridiculousness of spending the 1st 30 odd yrs of my life in a Cult! At the same time it's very serious as some suicided as their lives were destroyed by the Cult!
@Deathtofrogleghorn
@Deathtofrogleghorn 3 года назад
They’re not laughing at the folks dying but at the stupidity of the people that allowed this fool to continue on doing what he was doing.
@zzulm
@zzulm 2 года назад
This case is ridiculous all over the place it's a normal reaction to laugh this is not a memorial it's information being shared.
@elihinze3161
@elihinze3161 11 месяцев назад
What a fascinating talk. I wish this channel was still updating!
@jasoncoomer1226
@jasoncoomer1226 10 месяцев назад
*Do one on Fauci and Neil Degrasse Tyson next!*
@tota0523
@tota0523 9 месяцев назад
He did the first surgery with a donor and stem cells and it worked and then he thought he could do the same with an artificial trachea with stem cells but that wasn't good because it wasn't organic and the production process itself was bad.
@ritaranee4787
@ritaranee4787 3 года назад
Please give us a follow up on the first patient who recovered
@Mari-go1cs
@Mari-go1cs 3 года назад
I believe no one recovered. The only one who lived had the transplant removed.
@Suburp212
@Suburp212 2 месяца назад
Good presentation. Well done. Pity for the victims that were operated by him.
@starofairdrie
@starofairdrie 3 года назад
great talk -- why weren't his articles peer reviewed?
@anonvideo738
@anonvideo738 Год назад
They are. But peer reviewing is about investigating the methods and if all bases are covered. So, they check whether you used statistical analysis on your data to make sure its statistically significant. And if you did, did you use the correct analysis. They dont check the data itself (they assume you know how to run an experiment and youre not lying about it).
@peekaxu4352
@peekaxu4352 3 года назад
Well i guess ina way he got what he deserved....Unfortunately the families never got justice on earth This is so much better than waiting on NBC to put up the rest of the story
@Frakka475
@Frakka475 Год назад
That’s really shocking and dreadful for the reputation of the Karolinska!
@Т1000-м1и
@Т1000-м1и 10 месяцев назад
10.6k subs with 265k views. Really shows that this was made 4 years ago
@sam-fc9ky
@sam-fc9ky 2 года назад
He was mad.. so was kaolinska because they did not check his work first
@chrismanspeaker9372
@chrismanspeaker9372 10 месяцев назад
This is the problems with MDs in general. They are taught in med school to stick fingers up an ass and determine cancer or not, not how to perform research. The MDs that do, typically have the a PhD as well, where they actually learn to do research and development. So every time you see a MD wearing their little white lab coat with a stethoscope around their neck selling you some miracle, just know, they are conning you. I also think one of the major reasons medicine has lagged so far behind most of the other STEM fields is that MD school never teaches you research nor requires you to perform research. Every other STEM field, to become a PhD (a doctor), you need to move the knowledge of mankind forward, even if it’s a fraction of a hair. We need to see MDs as body mechanics and your skepticism of your auto mechanic trying to sell you a gas saver he’s developed should apply equally to a MD doing the same as demonstrated here.
@Trinny1978
@Trinny1978 3 года назад
Really, really well presented and highlighting the important stuff in this horrendous mess. Yeah, he's a lying megalomaniac and a doucebag who tricked a naive woman but that's not criminal. What he did to his patients are what matters and their stories needs to be told.
@thomasofnowhere
@thomasofnowhere 10 месяцев назад
2023 update he was sentenced to prison for 2.5 years in Sweden.
@rockwellcollins6768
@rockwellcollins6768 Год назад
Interesting but could do without the puerile laughter and sniggering at someone's name. This is life and death, not comedy. The cackling from the peanut gallery made this unwatchable.
@jacobishii6121
@jacobishii6121 10 месяцев назад
Imagine being so dense you need a private investigator to tell you the Pope isn't gonna do your wedding
@heathercook5642
@heathercook5642 2 года назад
This was a great supplement to the Dr. Death Podcast discussing the crazy man.
@ncooty
@ncooty Год назад
Strange that he couldn't decide between "Naralinska" and "Karolinska".
@carolmartha8449
@carolmartha8449 Год назад
This is brilliantly explained, as a physician. The other drama with a lady falling in love to marry him completed the other side of the sociopath that the doctor is.
@superyachtchef
@superyachtchef 2 года назад
Freelance medical professionals is actually a thing!
@TreeLuvBurdpu
@TreeLuvBurdpu Год назад
Centralization is monopolization. It doesn't improve accountability. It prevents accountability.
@CandyGirl44
@CandyGirl44 Год назад
This is one true case of a doctor with a God complex!
@user-mh5xq3ik9u
@user-mh5xq3ik9u Месяц назад
Bravo. Loved this.
@networthassoc2006
@networthassoc2006 3 года назад
I’m unable to continue watching bc of the stupid loud untimely laughter throughout. Ridiculous. People died and lives have been changed negatively forever and people are laughing!!
@Louie.Oxford
@Louie.Oxford 3 года назад
IKR. Very inappropriate
@SaraH-wt7dx
@SaraH-wt7dx 3 года назад
Same here. People have suffered after this. How can the laugh at others misery??
@mbekka1
@mbekka1 3 года назад
Don’t u know the world we live in ? It’s called: nobody cares .
@alandela6330
@alandela6330 3 года назад
Agreed.
@DJ-nk4dq
@DJ-nk4dq 3 года назад
Yes! The crowed sounds like bunch of narcissistic sociopaths as well. Ugh
@MagicPlants
@MagicPlants 11 месяцев назад
Great storytelling! Excellent presentation. Debunk all quacks.
@zoelhek1789
@zoelhek1789 3 года назад
That audience laugh insensitive most of the time
@latonyagreen-warner7402
@latonyagreen-warner7402 3 года назад
Yeah. That is so insensitive
@auzieblo
@auzieblo 3 года назад
Yes it's terrible. I wanna see this person and tell her off (I think I'm mostly hearing 1 female voice there). What an idiot, with no ounce of tact.
@greveeen
@greveeen 3 года назад
@@auzieblo What a complete psycho, who laughs at something like this?
@auzieblo
@auzieblo 3 года назад
@@greveeen exactly:-(
@michaelkarnerfors9545
@michaelkarnerfors9545 11 месяцев назад
Followup 2023-10-30: The Swedish Supreme Court will not bring up the Macchiarini case, meaning his conviction for three cases of aggravated assault - totaling 30 months in jail - stands.
@hkrohn
@hkrohn Год назад
It's funny how he switches between calling the institution Karolinska and Narolinska.
@hiroyoshi00
@hiroyoshi00 Год назад
I thought I was hallucinating
@pahvi3
@pahvi3 Год назад
It was so distracting 🤯
@antoinesilva1527
@antoinesilva1527 11 месяцев назад
Probably lisping. I have a tendency to do so when speaking without double-checking with my brain as well.
@qrstw
@qrstw Год назад
What is it with these people laughing like if it were some stand up comedy show?
@selmahare
@selmahare 8 месяцев назад
It’s shocking how this guy got away with experimenting on people with an idea that a 6 year old could have come up with, stick a plastic tube down someone’s throat, literally… literally just that. There are no words for it. You don’t need a PhD, and even less go through I don’t know how many years of med school to suggest that and obviously be told “ f..k NO, what’s wrong with you, are you okay!? So I seriously just lack the words. I really don’t know what to say about the people who let him do it. He is a psychopath, obviously, but what are the people who said yes to it!? Really!?
@marial3231
@marial3231 3 года назад
The laughing is so distasteful. Sounds like it’s coming from just one person too. A little humor is fine mind you. This man is a murderer. Falsifying medical research data should be punishable by jail!
@ryshellso526
@ryshellso526 Год назад
Some woman...
@natalianakoriakova8084
@natalianakoriakova8084 Год назад
On 21 June 2023, he was sentenced in the court of appeal to prison for two years and six months for three cases of maltreatment. His lawyers lodged an appeal to the Supreme Court, and were granted time to present new evidence.
@arizonahighways7287
@arizonahighways7287 3 года назад
Did you pipe in the laughter, it's wholly inappropriate to say the least-
@cornellynch730
@cornellynch730 10 месяцев назад
Why did the hospital even let him perform these surgeries
@LiveFreeOrDie2A
@LiveFreeOrDie2A Год назад
How do you think that international regulating body wouldn’t become corrupt itself?? So now instead of just individual journals becoming corrupted you can corrupt them all at once
@inthefade
@inthefade Год назад
Where else have we seen a medical technology fail in animal testing yet be expected to work in humans and be used on humans?
@blixten2928
@blixten2928 Год назад
It was so very embarassing for Karolinska! Disgusting cover-up. And horrible for the patients. ("Narolinska" is a bit of a light touch in the presentation, thanks for that. They deserve that.)
@judi4078
@judi4078 9 месяцев назад
His German assistant got never blamed and continued medical career. That is a shame
@yellowglider
@yellowglider Год назад
Interesting, but you missed to explain why the patients were moved to another facility, what *exactly* was done to these patients, what was that was implanted and the reasons why it failed…
@bosorot
@bosorot Год назад
It is likely a deceased donor organ and without immunosuppressive drugs it will rejected.
@starlettdragon
@starlettdragon 10 месяцев назад
The grown trachea was implanted. The patients were moved because he was trying to keep it quiet that there were massive problems with the implants and they did not work.
@stanleykubrick8786
@stanleykubrick8786 8 месяцев назад
Isn't it mind boggling to what extent people will go to playing out 'the charlatan' to self-promote themselves. Even academics who delude themselves into believing that their intelligent colleauges will never discover their tricks. Vanity of vanity, everything is vanity.
Далее
Самая сложная маска…
00:32
Просмотров 962 тыс.
Brilliant Budget-Friendly Tips for Car Painting!
00:28
The scandal that shook psychology to its core
29:35
Просмотров 363 тыс.
"The World in 2030" by Dr. Michio Kaku
1:04:01
Просмотров 7 млн
The Drug Trial That Went Horribly Wrong
58:16
Просмотров 12 млн