Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s RU-vid channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ru-vid.com/show-UCuyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdAjoin
Gupat ji, Next time you make a claim of being unbiased, impartial, non-hyphenated etc etc, please watch yesterday's episode on Chinas missile attack on Japan. There was no need, no context to reference % of votes for BJP. But you did. Saying something like nearly 55 / 60% people didn't vote for BJP. Mr Gupta, Nehru in his first, second and Third term got 45, 48 and 45% votes respectively. Did you you should have shared this as a context ? Or presenting inconvenient truths is against your principles ? Secondly, you present twisted news we know. But you have started forging numbers as well. 20 nautical miles is not 22 kms but close to 37 kms. But if it's China who is firing missiles, it can be 22 kms I guess. Just like firing missiles on an "imaginary targets" as Guptaji likes to call it. Ultimately, you have to protect interests of those who fund you.
@@anandtilaksg bhau saheb why are you so worked up just because your example of beloved BJP?, for the record you are upset because he didn't cite an example which is almost 70-80 years old?, how absurd it is? , for the millennial audience, who also happened to be larger chunk of audience of this program can relate to more current example, isn't it? frankly you got offended because he has given credit to Mr Modi ji for being incredibly influential, or one of the most influential politicians in India. but you want Shekhar Gupta to cite nehru . what is your love affair with Nehru ji? unbelievable, this even more stupider bringing in a politician who was relevant good 80 years back and by any stretch of imagination this is nuts. get well soon buddy with your infatuation with Congress it's not going anywhere. I don't exactly remember the part where he mention 22 nautical miles etc but even if he has made some mistakes I think you may feel free to point that out. I think he will show wisdom and accept his slipups in the next episodes . now funding part, foreign funding sources are non existent in India there to modiji, revenue sources which are coming from outside of India are either effectively blocked or highly regulated. what remains is 'internal subscribers' which are monitored by government machineries with iron fist. only this area where Modi is really doing great job.
Too late Shekhar ji, Yesterday results of 271 panchayats came out BJP got 80 , NCP 53, Shinde Sena 42, and Uddhav Sena 27. This is despite of Aditya Thackeray doing rounds of these panchayats actively. Delhis political pundits might be thinking the split is vertical , but looks like Shinde Sena is real Sena now, at least in the eyes of common voters in Maharashtra
U should first check total number of panchayats in Maharashtra and then come to a conclusion. Even if Bjp wins Bmc that is not an indication, key is assembly election. High chance bjp will win bmc but it's not going to reflect state assembly.
Goes against the ideology saar....he will keep berating bjp even a BJP councillor does a corruption of 1000 rupees ....but Prince and Rajmata are untouchable.
Shinde has no stake in BMC. He would want the BJP to won. He'll craftily put candidates to divide votes and benefit the BJP. Nevertheless, even if they lose I doubt it's a life and death issue for them because there are other options to keep the flock in place.
BJP was very, very close in the 2017 BMC election itself. SS had won 84, BJP had won 82 - just 2 behind the SS. The election was so close, one ward in South Mumbai had to be decided by a draw of lots. With the BJP being too close behind the SS for the latter's comfort, SS went around poaching corporators from the MNS and the INC and the independents left right and centre. 6 out of 7 MNS corporators joined SS, one of whom, Dilip Lande, went on to become the MLA from Chandivali, by a wafer-thin margin of 409 votes. (Fun fact: Dilip Lande is one of the 4 Mumbai MLAs in the Shinde group).
Sad that all municipal corporations are good for is political power flexing and symbolisms. We could have been so much better with governments (lower levers) solidly connected to people, and their REAL concerns, and perhaps that could make our cities livable.
Shiv sena has done a hell lot for Mumbai. Ask any mumbaikar. Shiv sena doesn't have footprint in whole of maharashtra, ncp is better but it's fort mumbai is the strongest .
Mumbaikar here, I'd agree with Pranav, Shiv Sena has indeed given us a lot in the form of crippling infrastructure, pathetic educational and health facilities and terrible public transport (I'm looking at you BEST). All this while having the largest municipal budget in the country, quite a remarkable achievement!
I agree with you but that was old shivsena. Now i think marathi votes will go with MNS and non marathi Hindu votes with bjp. Uddhav thackrey infact will fight for Muslim votes with Congress 😂😂 It will be an interesting election for sure
Nowadays I have to always check if a Shekhar Gupta video is an old recycled one with a new headline, or actually a new one. Sochna padta hai, analyse karna padta hai before deciding to watch or click.
I disagree, BMC election will be largely between BJP vs Sena (UT). Shinde is largely a leader who can get things done in Rural Maharashtra, most defecation in Shinde camp are not from Mumbai City. Fadnavis will manage BMC election & not to forget the rising MNS factor
100+ officers of so called rising MNS factor have already joined Shinde Camp yesterday, giving a big blow to Raj thackeray. BJP has made a shinde a puppet to dissolve both SS and MNS. SS and MNS has both goals different from BJP.
@@premgajare8125 Sena will play all Marathi Asmita Cards and Breaking Mumbai propaganda to gain support from the voter base so it's equally important to have an Raj Like connect in Mumbai/Thane region (I know it might not convert in votes but it will set the momentum)
@@TheDURWAS Sena can only play the cards it has. Seeing their new joinings from biharis, Parsis, gujaratis, muslims. I see Shiv Sena will sweep this election easily without any hardwork. Offcourse BJP will try hard and use of all thier victim cards from Gujarati card to ED CBI card to win.
It is interesting to how complex Indian democracy is, and political parties are using the provisions of the constitution to their advantage. Not to forget, video quality today is very good.
I don't think Indian politics is comlex. U just count potholes on roads, and u can get the exact figure they are getting. They will tar it,retar it, tar it, retar it .... Public loses money in many ways😎
In the last BMC election, BJP could have won it with support from independents. In the next election, BJP will win it with little support from Shinde group. Rest assured.
Unemployment keeps surging and bills wait for no one that’s why we have to figure new ways to make an income, I came here to learn how to trade after listening to a guy on radio talk about the importance of investing and how he made $210,000 in 4 months from $35k. Somehow this video has helped shed light on some things, but I'm confused, I'm a newbie and I'm open to ideas
Its last chance for udhav and his family to somehow hold the dynasty -family company alive as shivsena has finally became a democratic party and it will take some time for sena to emerge as a true democratic party
I totally disagree with your "If Uddhav wins BMC" assumption. I would be very very surprised if Uddhav Sena does remotely well in either BMC or the next Assembly elections, whenever they happen. Also, UT tried his best to postpone elections of any kind through his tenure. And we saw what happened when elections finally happened :) From a context perspective, people did vote clearly for Sena BJP in 2019. Also most SS MPs and MLAs had huge Modi posters in their rallies. Whatever UT did post elections was a desperate act of a desperate man who was doomed either ways. Even in BMC the score was 84 vs 82, ish, and SS then wooed MNS corporators into their fold to increase the number to 90+. Add to this the terrible 2.5 years of MVA Government. Highest per million covid deaths, policy flip flops, and to top it all corruption and yukky business that was kind of out of fashion between 2014 and 2019, BJP will do well in the upcoming elections across state as well as BMC. I in fact think the BJP are being overly cautious and they could have gone solo..
Budget of 46k Cr, bigger than 11 states and potholes as ATM's! - it's all about money. I wish Shekharji and The Print could do a National Interest on Party Fund - no further decluttering would be needed!
Shekhar sir is wishing out loud. Dont worry sir....people on the other side of the fence knows politics and they will play their cards as you have seen over and over. BJP and Shinde are quite capable to rule BMC
I would be glad to see an episode on SC's constitutional role on this. Why are they interfering so much in election commission. I hope people of India donot lose faith in the judicial system. We are already on the brink on mobocracy
The supreme kotha lost my trust when they held Nupur Sharma responsible for the killing of 6-7 innocent Hindu lives by those animals. It seems only a mobocracy is the way, since the democracy seems to be against the well being of the people.
I don't understand how can Municipal election take place unless the symbol issue is settled. Are both factions ready to fight as independents and without symbols? If not so, how can Udbhav Thakrey be willing for election? Strange logic!
@@mikeydmz1588 Who said they left the party? They claim they are the real party on the basis of the number of MLAs and MPs aligned with them. Hence there is a case.
Great decluttering video! I also learned about the term "Geery-Mandering". That's what Shiv-sena did in BMC and the same thing was done by BJP in Delhi. The objective is to stay in power by any means.
Shekharji, for a person who is born and raised and destined to die in Mumbai, the time to write obituary of Shiv Sena is due. With absolute power of BMC in the hands of Shiv Sena has corrupted the party absolutely. Considering the Marathi population of around 25% in Mumbai , not entirely is the vote base of Shiv Sena. The division of voters among the various parties gives a definite edge to BJP. Moreover the Shiv Sena has ditched the voters of Mumbai in the Vidhan Sabha elections of 2019 first by aligning with BJP and then to satisfy the personal ambition of it's chief to ascend the throne of CM, by forming alliance with Bhrashtavadi Congress and now virtually extinct Congress is not lost on voters. The voters are determined to teach Shiv Sena a lesson which will have a crippling effect.
Today Panchayat poll result are out in Maharashtra and out of 271 BJP has own 82 NCP won 51 Shinde has 40 and Thackeray got 27 only And others 47 People are with Eknath Shinde and not with Uddhav Thackeray.
@@garyish just compare shiv sena Uddhav with shiv sena eknath Shinde. There were a seats in Aurangabad n many other places where Aditya Thackeray held a Shiv Savad Yatra were did all that crowd has gone? Is adurya going raj Thackeray way? ( Getting crowd in rallies but not votes) If Eknath Shinde can win these seats why can't Uddhav Thackeray? Uddhav is loosing ground.
@@aaibhagwati8450 My point is for the thakrey family, interior rural Maharashtra was never their vote bank. It was Mumbai, thane and the entire Konkan belt. I can almost guarantee you when Mumbai and rest of Konkan votes, eknath Shinde won’t get those SS votes. The smart thing for the BJP was to preserve the alliance with SS instead of all this nonsense which will just fracture the Hindu Marathi vote
Money money money. BMC Councillors are all property developers and road contractors, a seat at BMC means they can pluck fresh money feathers from the golden goose.
SG had one dinner with Balasaheb loooonnngish time back and look at the debt he owes the family...one can sense his desperation in wanting the dynasty back. Balasaheb sure will shower his blessings. Never in history has one dinner created this impact.Long live dynasties in India...Lutyens want Monarchy back ...pat my back and I will scratch yours..as for real democraZy ...RIP.
Point is not to discuss electorate of BMC, but it's impact and relationship with higher up.......and control of shiv sena... BTW I think he has no understanding of shimla, dehradun MC , electorate and politics either..
Shekhar Gupta has proven his metal in the field of journalism since several decades. and his 'take' on any political topic is a point of view of a journalist. you may like it or you may not like, it is certainly based on journalistic framework. I think you are entitled to have your views on his understanding of MH and BMC etc . my only points here is, politics is a highly dynamic in nature and we cannot dis-regard any point of view just because they don't suit to the ones liking.
@@ajitwelling seriously my friend, are you for real? like I said, you are entitled to have your opinion, like shekhar Gupta and you think you can bring Clarity, please be my guest, counter him, just saying his commentary is foolish, in reality, makes you foolish without your counter, I'm sure you must have your own valid reasons to disagree with him, bring in your perspective.
Shinde is on record about the interference of a few powerful individuals in his ministry in the MVA setup. No contradiction from the other side !! So Shinde's decision now is his own, without external pressure.
Rashtravadi leader's connections with Dawood have come out in open and if Vora Commitee Report is opened SP will have no place to hide ! And the hindu voters of Mumbai are itching to teach a lesson to Udhav Thakre who has bedded with Congress and NCP who are known Dawood supprters and people have not forgotten Mumbai Blasts !
People of Maharashtra has to choose whether they want to support dynasty who has fooled them , deviated from their ideology of balasahab for power or they want to choose truly democratic sena
When it comes to the municipal election they're better off thinking ke unkey ghar ke aage ki road kon sahi tarah banvayega ya sewage kon sahi maintain karega.
Everybody is free to make their minds, but following are the results of Gram Panchayat elections: BJP 82 SS (Shinde groups) 40 (BJP + SS-Shinde) = 122 SS (Thakre group) 27 NCP + Congress 75 MVA = 102
@@nandi7772 Hey Abhi. Yes. I knew the word. Have been following US politics for quite a while now. Almost every state election this will be talked about. Republican governors of states will try to make Borders in such a way that black, Hispanic voters are either clubbed into one weirdly shaped seat so that the Republicans only lose one seat or will spread the blacks, Hispanics out in so many constituencies that their votes won't matter at all. I'm sure the Democrats do Gerrymandering too but to a lesser extent. I feel Gerrymandering will continue to exist in a first past the post (FPTP) voting system like we have in India, US, UK etc. Single Transferable Vote (STV; followed in France) and Mixed Member Proportion (MMP; followed in Israel, Iceland, Germany etc.) methods of voting do solve this problem to a large extent. If you're interested in the topic, CGP Grey (a RU-vid channel) has an excellent playlist explaining all of these different voting methods. Would highly recommend that. Have a nice day! 😁
@@eshaan1110 thanks. I am trying to figure out how people learn different languages and especially English. And yes Americans call themselves best democracy but their elections are also very fucked up. Their governers works like dictators and do many shenanigans.
@@nandi7772 For me, I learn mostly through RU-vid. I have my search history and viewing history off on RU-vid so I only see recommendations from knowledge sources (channels) that I'm subscribed to. Saves my time that I would've wasted on non sense videos and helps me learn new things
@@eshaan1110 My conclusions are also same. People learn new words and overall language through listening and not by memorising words, their meaning and grammar etc. These make very little difference. Most important part of learning new language is to listen and read.
I disagree to the speculation that current MH CM Eknath shinde thinks that his loss in BMC election will result in his MP's going back to Thackereys. And we cannot ignore the possibility of Shine's group winning BMC and changing future of ShivSena forever in MH.
Okay, a known secret. Good an open secret is being discussed so blatantly. Oh, “it is all about money honey” and in such cases how it is shared among stake holders - the public (for utilities etc.) being one stake holder. Tailpiece: Political,parties are NOT NGOs. It is another matter that most NGOs act like political parties!!! Public service? What is it? Just asking.
Municipal corporations are to urban area I.e. cities and towns what the Panchayat are to villages. Policies and political also thinkers are never tired of extolling the virtues of democracy at grass-root level. But we carefully look and take stock of ground reality, we would find the conditions appalling and miserable and deploying. We would fund degradation, which is the result of poor governance by the municipal authorities. Where do I citizen live?. Simple. I live in a place which is governed by a municipal corporation. But when I look around, I find that in most cases the discussions in public veer around the politics at state or national level with a sprinkling of international affairs. But hardly any one of us would remember the name of our municipal corporator. He is like a ghost for us. Little wonder our villages and towns are miserable places. All the problems are old problems waiting solutions since our gra d-fathers to.e. So what the he'll these corporatprs have been doing all these decades, is the pertinent question, we should ask these idlers
Shekhar got the picture wrong. Bjb won almost as many seats as Shiv sena last time, then thakare betrayed them joined cong ncp to form state govt. Bjp could not even get opposition post in bmc as they were together initially. Now thakare has to face bjp+ split shivsena and if he joins cong ncp with diametrically opposed ideology he has to face an enlightened mumbai voters population. Will be fun to watch
Shekhar Gupta has proven his metal in the field of journalism since several decades. and his 'take' on any political topic is a point of view of a journalist. you may like it or you may not like it. however he is certainly making sure his views are based on journalistic framework. I think you are entitled to have your views on his understanding of MH and BMC etc . my only point here is, politics is highly dynamic and we cannot dis-regard any point of view just because they don't suit to mine/your liking.
Same Politics Here in Bengaluru Urban Politics During Siddaramaiah time as CM he Wanted BBMP to be divivded into 3 Muncipal Corp But BJP opposed it and the Bill was sent to President of India and Its Languishing there itself then BJP came to power Increased the Seats From 198 to 243 and Dilimetation Starts and Does that in the Favour of them by Taking Many wards in old Bengaluru and assigning new wards at their strongholds and to take Benefit from that in this saga the Reservation and other issues came up its Been 2 years since then Bengaluru is languishing without urban Governance and Hell are the roads of Bengaluru its nightmare to travel in the City with Bike abba Babus are Controlling The BBMP with 7000 cr Budget and in return what we get is Deadly Traffic and SHITTY roads........
next bmc elections are litmus for udhav camp not for shinde camp. mumbai bmc half seats/corporators are of bjp currently.......thane municipality corporators are with shinde, navi mumbai corporators are with shinde. so bmc elections are not crucial as a do or die for shinde camp. congress & ncp along with owasi aimim will be party spoilers for udhav camp...............
Crunch time. The coming elections will tell us whether the people of Mumbai want to continue with a dynastic party or are ready for change . Sadly the development of India's commercial capital has never been a priority upto now.
Shekhar Gupta you should do your homework better. Even without Shinde Sena BJP had a very good chance of winning Mumbai corporation elections. The fall of Marathi voters. Gujarati and UP voters are with BJP. A chunk of educated Marathi voters also vote for the BJP. It's going to be very hard for Shiv Sena to keep Mumbai
@sg sir.. i feel you are quite focused on Municipal corporation.. but as you speak.... The results from grampanchayat elections are out in Maharashtra... N shinde sena did better than udhhav sena. No way it would be reversed in municipal elections
It is more likely that BJP-Eknath Shinde camp combine would win more municipal corporations in rest of Maharashtra. This is because majority of Eknath Shinde supporters are from Rural Maharashtra & outside Mumbai.
@@cpatil-vh5bw I agree.. actually on basis of merit, Raj should have been made head instead of uddhav.. but balasaheb made a mistake.. Despite that mistake and MNS split, Marathi people from Konkan have stood behind SS so far.. so I am not going to predict who people will stand behind after this split.
I just watched a video about semiconductors manufacturing process. Too much scientific for 1 day now will watch Indian news all day to cool down my brain
SG, excellent "then and now" comparison. Using your catch phrase "इस हमाम में सब विवस्त्र है." The only difference: Delhi has disrobed independent institutions (except judiciary to some extent). Unlike, prior to 2014.
SG the last BMC polls actually went to the wire. It was ८४ for SS and ८२ for BJP. What Munbai needs is a new deal. SS has proved to be visionless & corrupt.
@@afrinfodkar2866 You are entitled for your opinion. Point is none of them are here to do any Dharam Karam & to expect them to feed us is too much of an expectation. What's critical is do they provide/ enable to provide civic services which people are entitled to. They are clean water, good roads, breathable air, etc. The Municipal polls are more important than the State Assembly, national parliament.
Mumbaikars should vote for a BMC that can fix rain flooding problem. No one has solved it for 30+ years. How can your financial capital be so messed up when it rains
But after 2022, India is expected to outpace California GDP.. but until last year it was true. California is the Maharashtra of the US with the biggest GSDP (not gdp)
Based on what BJP did in Maharashtra I never want to hear about how they're a governance focuses rule of law party. They are the most Law of the Ruler party this country has seen since the British
No depth in the BMC/Maharashtra political situation. People who are genuinely interested in knowing should checkout Bhau Torsekar, Sushil Kulkarni, Anay Joglekar's channels on RU-vid.
SG deliberately forgot to mention that in both cases delaying the elections goes in BJP's favour. "This is politics" type commentary is not going to cut it anymore. Maybe when BJP suspends all elections, SG will do a "cut the clutter" saying "this is politics, Congress also did it in 1975."
@@pritesh0117 Is it that obvious though? He plays it like, it is a fight between old and new SS in MH. Two different political parties and never uttered BJP's name who actually orchestrated it. Then in Delhi, it is BJP and AAP. The reality is that it is the BJP who is deciding how and when elections to be held everywhere according to their advantages. It is not usually politics and not that obvious to everyone.
Sir with Vir Sanghvi on board the print won't be unhyphenated journalism anymore, everyone knows you are still in love with the Congress but please don't let this channel go down the NDTV road.
@@karankapoor2701 dude I never said I'm a Modi fan , I hate perpetual naysayers like NDTV who see the negative in everything the govt does , at the same time I detest those too who are always praising the govt (Godi media). I like the fact based journalism by the print (even though very rarely it does become a bit NDTV like, but that's still ok and often Shekhar also gives the disclaimer that he'll be opinionated)
@@code-o-maniac6033 that's what I'm also saying bro , very rarely it gets opinionated. Actually the most neutral, but I'm a little apprehensive if they can keep it up with Vir Sanghvi's show on it, the guy has been a perpetual naysayer.
Very little substance, just semantics verbosity and drama to fill the time. Real content was only worth ~5-8minutes!! What's happening, SG?!? Loosing your mojo?😅
