When Yoogeun missing his SHINee appas 

As many ppl wrote in their comments that they wish Yoogeun is remembering his SHINee appas, I decided to make this video to let you know he always remembers them… 🌸🍀✨ …… It was tough to make the 2017 part of this video, but I thought I shouldn’t make an incomplete video… I wanted to tell the whole story and include everything… I wanted to show how lovely Yoogeun is. 🌷 …… 2009 0:00 2010 4:07 2015 13:44 2016 14:19 2017 16:39 2018 18:14 2019 20:39 ….. When I was 10 (the same age as Yoogeun in 2017) I lost my favorite uncle (who was 27) in a car accident… he lived in another city and I remember how I couldn’t sleep on our long trip to that city to participate in his funeral… I was recalling all my memories with him on the way… I remember him crystal clear… I even saw him in my dream a few days ago… I’m telling you this to let you know, it’s always weird for me (from 2017 until now) when ppl say “Does Yoogeun remember Jonghyun?” … Sure he remembers him… when someone creates beautiful memories for you… especially in your childhood… you never forget them.🌼

When Jonghyun said in that video to older Yoogeun that je wants to meet him again I cried So much hh 😭 oh godd

Jonghyun "i wish we could watch this together...." is making me cry... its 2020 already..

i cried at the part when they left messages for 20 year old yooguen, hello baby always holds a special place in my heart for getting me into shinee i dont know where i would be without them

i cried when yoogeun's mom said he cried about jonghyun passing away and his ig posts about jonghyun came up. i am definitely still not over it 'til this day

😱 😢 I remember watching this and thinking Jonghyun is going to be a great dad 😭

I'm sad knowing that jonghyun won't be able to see yoogeun in his 20s

So sweet to know that Yoogeun remembers his Appas especially Jonghyun to this day. May he continue to grow up well n may his memories of Jiong be mainly good ones..Was also missing my dear Arezoo. Thks for the memories of Jiong n Shinee n Yoogeun. Please keep safe Arezoo. Much love n virtual hugzz across the continents.⚘😘💐🌹🌻🥰

And the fact that Yoogeun still calls them his SHINee Appas after so long is heart warming but hearing that when he found out about Jonghyun's passing and just cried 'Jonghyun Appa' all night was so heart breaking

This show made me a true shawol

I don't even know Jonghyun personally, my knowledge about him is limited, and I didn't have the chance to stan Shinee when they were still active. But my heart aches everytime I heard or watch anything about him, I miss him and long for him when in fact I have no memories with him. I cannot imagine the pain of those people who are close with him, whom he once shared his life with, I bet the pain will never fade away thus they will just find themselves get used to it.

& Minho never forgot him, just 1 glance at him at the age of 15 and he alrdy knew it was his son 🥺😭❤

"Hi, yoogeun. You're already 20. It seems like the days you cried for us to hold you were just yesterday. I become happy just imagining you to already be a grown up 20 year old. When you're 20, let's share fun memories and old stories with the appas, and I hope we can watch this video together. I love you" - Jonghyun appa

We are now on 2022, I recently watched Soshi Tamtam and the 15 yr. old Yoogeun was there and met Appa Minho via video call it's so heartwarming. Just like what Shinee wish, Yoogeun grew healthy. I wish Jonghyun was happy wherever he was right now. 😇

I HATE THE FACT THAT JONGHYUN WOULDNT BE THERE FOR HIS 20TH BIRTHDAY

rewatching shinee’s hello baby episodes,... I got to appreciate it sooo much mooore when I realised that it gave an opportunity for Jonghyun to experience being a father even just for a short moment... he got to experience preparing a meal, buying clothes for a child that considered him a father 😕 💓 because of the show we got a glimpse of his dad side

Thank you Yoogeun for letting Jonghyun experience how to be a dad even for a while 😔 rip jongyun appa, you are really missed even up to these days 💔

It breaks my heart thinking how Jong won’t have the opportunity to see yogurt turn 20...

When he said " I like Jonghyun appa more" 😭 , and that's true he always love Jonghyun appa and other appa 😭😭 omg I miss Jonghyun

Yoogeun "I like jonghyun appa more" I know you love them all equally 💗💗💗 Thanks for the video dear Arezoo. Beautiful memories to share🙂🙏

I miss Shinee as a whole group.

The memories he made with shinee and jonghyun will always be remembered and will always be treasure..

When jonghyun said to yoogeun he wants to meet him again and watch that video together makes me cry.😭😭 I REALLY MISS SHINee and JONGHYUN.😭

Beautiful video.i miss shinee member too.for all the moeslim from all around the world happy RAMADHAN.

i already watch yoogeun with snsd, he really grow up❤️

I want to see yoogeun and shinee appa reunion !!

When Minho Appa and Key Appa were both emotional on the last episode. 😭

Yoogeun truly is their biggest fan 🥺 no one can ever take that special place of his. Also, the fact that he is not that far from 20 , makes me feel so old myself bc I remember watching the show in 2009 😩 Time really flies. Hope to see a reunion in the future as well. It hurt me to see his IG posts after what happened and I’ve just been praying for his happiness. He’s grown to be such a sweet boy who will never forget his SHINee appas ❤️❤️ I wish him well.

i’m sitting here crying bc he’s grown up so well and he just loves SHINee so much and i just can’t believe he had to go through all of that but i’m so proud of him and the fact that he still supports SHINee in everything they do warms my heart

"I don't think i can ever forget you" and there's Minho really recognize his son when SNSD video calling him

*Why am i crying like a baby??* *Why???* *When jonghyun said let's watch the video together i couldn't hold it anymore..* *And Minho telling him to be honest and good like a caring dad..* *Key being his vulnerable self..♥️* *I can't stop crying..* *We miss you jonghyun ♥️♥️*

I feel down to think that when Yoogeun watched the message video for him, Jonghyun is no longer here. At least he still remains in our heart.

Jonghyun message makes me cry😭 I can't wait to see them watching it and opening the time capsule❤.

Jonghyun oppa, why did you go??? Won’t you comeback?? Jonghyun is one of the most beautiful hearts in this world😥

When his mom said Yoogeun cried himself to sleep.. it's just broke my heart :(

his was one of the first variety shows I watched because I loved shinee so much when I first got into kpop. this was such a cute show and I loved seeing them fight for his love

I came back here after their mini reunion thru video call of Yoogeun and Minho 🥺🥰❤️

This is great that he still remember shinee appas , they had a lot of fun together. This is so sweet bitter memories ❤️

it's May 21, 2020. i just finished watching hello baby earlier. honestly while watching i cant help but to listen to everything that jonghyun has said. as far as i remembered he mentioned about getting married and of course seeing yoogeun grow. i may not know him personally and i didn't get the chance to be his fan when he's still with us, but watching this kind of show made me know him a sense. we all cant help but to be sad, but at least we have this to remember the kind of person jonghyun was, someone who is funny, caring, loving, and selfless.

You know whats the most heartwarming in this video that boy show how he loves his appa so much not as a fan but as a family to support them its like the connection they have since they mate shocks im cryiiiiiiin SHAWOL must be proud of this boy😭😭😭

seeing this get recommended to me again after seeing yoogeun in SNSD's show and his video call with minho

i miss this family so much

They should meet again with this child. He's so cute and supportive of them, I want to see a reunion ❤️🥺

When Yoogeun said that he likes Jonghyun appa more, I can't imagine how broken hearted he was when he heard the news about Jonghyun's passing. I cried a river with the part when they were giving message to 20yr old Yoogeun and also when his mom said that he won't be meeting his appas anymore. 😢😢😢

SHINee was such a huge part of my adolescence and I always feel like 1/5 of my heart is missing without Jonghyun. I can’t imagine what Yoogeun feels like, having had so much of his childhood influenced by these father/brother-like figures...

This is the show that made me fall in love with Shinee.

Thank you hello baby for making Jonghyun experience being a dad ❤️

He is so cute and adorable. It is a shame what happened to one of the ShiNee members, because it is not the same. He is and will always be the best and will very much be missed.

10:01 i started crying so so much. They were such good 'appas' to him and it's very heartbreaking

i came here after I watched the interaction of yoogeun and minho from SNSD reality show.

I'm still crying so hard, when I watch this. 💔

These days every night I'm watching hello baby shinee version..... always remembering them so much..... love you forever shinee and yoogun💎💎💎💐💐💐💐😘😘😘

I criedddddddd during their messages for him 20 yrs later 😍😭

I'm so glad this video was recommended to me! It's heart warming to see that he still remembers them and still loves them❤❤❤

This is best memory of SHINee and yoogeun ever it makes me a true shawol 😍😍😊💎🌹💖

I seriously want him to dance the Ring Ding Dong with his baby version ❤️❤️😂

Damn god....he does growing up ended to looked alike minho 😅

i was crying when jonghyun said let's meet again when you'll be 20 .😭😭😭😭😭

It's May 21, 2022 and still watching it. 🥺 I miss them.

Omg yoogeun is so handsome now and looks more like minho jsjsjs. He can join NCT XD

It feels like yesterday watching this show, waiting for engsub and being extremely happy with only 480p quality video. Time flies but my love for SHINee never fades. Love you SHINee-deul..

I went 💔 when it reached 2017

I have never seen this before. I know that they did that show, but never saw it when he got older. I cried when I saw that they did messages for him when he becomes 20, but not as devastated as when he learned about Jonghyun's death. The tears really started then.

I feel sorry for Jonghyun

Im crying while watching this! 😭💔 My angel Jonghyun. 😇❤ My SHINEE be healthy. ❤

Jong hyun can't even meet yoogeun when he became 20 years old.

When I say I cried I cried this was so sad and sweet 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 w w rest in peace jong R. I. P jonghyun I can't right now my eyes are Turing up and I can bearly see ummmmmmm this still t tea (3s a troll on me I just can't believe it still after so long I hope he's resting in peace rip jonghyun Farewell 😭😭😭😭💞💞💞💞💞💞💞💞💞💞💞💞💞💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💘💔💖💗💞💞💞

and finally in 2022 he can meet mino appa via video call , he grew so fast

The group was five, unfortunately one, loved forever, is gone. But thank God we have four and Shinee, despite all the pain of absence, continued and still warms our hearts with new music. Thank you Choi Min-ho (Minho), Lee Tae-min (Taemin), Kim Ki-bum (Key) and Lee Jin-ki (Onew) for continuing the path. Admiration, respect and much love for you 💖🌼🙏👏 I miss you Kim Jong-hyun (Jonghyun) 💖😢✨👏

i started crying when i saw yoogeun’s comment on his live & his reaction to his death. it literally broke my heart.

i hope someday they meet again 🥺🥺 the love and bond between the members and yoogeun is the most precious thing ever.

Beautiful memories ❤😢

Jonghyun touched so many people. This pain got passed to the people that love him.

❤This Is The Best Memories Ever We Miss You Shinee💎

Our yoogeun is big now... 😊😍

When will I be able to hold my tears when I see him? Jonghyun you did your best.. this world doesn't deserve you.. REST IN PEACE🙏

As someone who’s always listened to Shinee but never stanned I’m upset I missed this when it was fresh. Thanks for posting this!

I still can't overcome from jonghyun death... Only the name is enough to make us cry

I KEEP WATCHING THESE OLD VIDEOS. I MISS JONGHYUN SO MUCH. MY BRAIN STILL CAN'T PROCESS IT. YOOGEUN GREW UP SO WELL.

How one child at the time had such an effect on all of them, such purity.❤

I really hope that all the members also remember him and they can meet from time to time

Does someone know if they have actually met after the show Hello Baby? In the video there are only messages sent to SHINee by Yoogoun but, has SHINee answered to them in some way?

Ah ...why am I crying? .... ㅠㅠ

I just realized.... Yoogeun will never see his Jonghyun Appa ever again

The thing is I was never a fan of shinee and I didn't even know who Jonghyun was until I saw the news of his death. But every time I see Jonghyun, I just cry and I feel so sad.

Nooo I wasn’t going to cry but I got to Jonghyun’s message to 20 y/o Yoogeun and I started sobbing

Oh! I'm dehydrated! 😭 I can't believe he's gone. But It's healing to know that he lived a life full of love, joy and friendship. I hope the kid keeps that beautiful memories in his heart forever (like Shinee and Shawol do) 💙

This made me so emotional, omg this kid is precious. also, rip Jonghyun oppa, the day you passed away will never be forgotten

Aww I’m still watching Yoogeun family until now. Miss them much n love them lots. 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰💎💎💎💎💎💖💖💖💖💖

Im crying 10:18 "i hope we can watch this video together" -jonghyun

It might not seem it but I am a huge SHAWOL especially when they debut. When Jonghyun died, I cried so hard that I was almost out of breath. My mother noticed me and she told my brother to get me water. My friends also know how much I love SHINee and he is my bias. It was a dreadful December for me.

I really hope Yooguen gets in contact with the SHINee members.

until now i still miss jonghyun

Omg second time was jonghyun 😭❤

Yoogeun must be really missed Jonghyun oppa. RIP Jonghyun..we all missed you🥺🥺🥺❤❤❤

:( Shinee was the first group of which I became fan of when I first entered kpop and I remember that watching this brought me a lot of happiness. I love to see how much he has grown.

It’s really sad because this show was my escapade from the griefs I had when my dad left me and I had to live such a hard life without him. This show made me happy and watching this back in 2022 really impacted me with all the jonghyun is not around anymore , the messages for yoogeun and the fact that this show was just in a past. That past when I had a hard life but things were better at such a young age when I had less stuffs to worry about other than just watching hello baby . Now that I am 25 years old and I have so many responsibilities and problems till I nearly forgot about the sweet memories that this show used to give to me Thank you for making this video because it reminded me of my bittersweet childhood ❤️❤️

I think that because its a time capsule, they are supossed to meet again all together when Yoogeun turns 20...but wow he looks like a mix of Minho and Key! ♥️💎💎💎💎💎

It's so heart breaking that he will never see his Jonghyunie appa again😭😭 but don't worry baby he will always watch you from the heaven❤

Arezoooo thank you so much for this compilation 😘😘😘 Love you😍 Love SHINee ♥️ take care dear