We are Südbayern in my opinion. The rest of Germany that ISN'T bavaria ist Nordbayern, but Noone knows these details yet, needs some time and education
@@mrsalt548 Austria is German. Starting from its birth, which occurred through the Bavarian colonization of previously Slavic lands, Austria was always part of the Kingdom of Germany until the end of the Holy Roman Empire in 1806. And even after that it continued to be part of the German Confederation. Any objection based on the weakness of these state entities is invalid, since it is only evidence of the political weakness of Germany, certainly not of its non-existence. Continuing, even after the foundation of the German Empire, the Austrian emperor himself continued undaunted to consider himself a German prince, given that Austria's failure to enter the unitary German state was certainly not due to a non-Germanness of Austria itself, but rather to the presence also of vast non-German areas within the empire, areas which, remember, all separated from Austria. And in fact, once the war was over, everyone thought that, since these regions had gone their own way, there was no longer any reason to remain separated from the rest of the Germans. It was the victorious allies, that is, Austria's enemies themselves, who prevented it. Therefore the very idea of Austria as an independent nation is a ridiculous invention of Austria's enemies, which has no historical or ethnic justification, but which was only useful to them to maintain their domination. The only reason why Austrians developed a separate identity is to distance themselves from what they perceived as Nazi ideals. But: 1) the problematic aspects of Nazism don’t include pan-Germanism, which was supported even by many interwar socialists; 2) it’s an irrational reaction not based on actual facts.
Austrians being the worst nazis but all after the war they pretended to be victims and all moral and material blame went on Germany. We people of Serbia are aware that wermacht units executing 100 for 1 order killing thousands of hostages were Austrian.
Exactly! Austrians DO. MIND. As an austrian myself most of the time I think it's kind of ridiculous, but then when someone confuses me with a german I correct them immediately xD
@@marvin2678 You did not understand? German original here: "Der Deutsche sagt: Die Lage ist ernst, aber nicht aussichtslos. Der Österreicher: Die Lage ist aussichtslos, aber nicht ernst. Meaning, that Germans take all things dead-serions, but Austrians tend to be more relaxed - or if you are German, the Austrians are more careless.
@@GuyHeadbanger Less "careless" and more "carefree". In general, the saying is to highlight how Germans are dour, but they actually think they can solve their problems and try. Austrians tend to be more resigned to fate, but they also just take it with more humour.
@@blacktemplar2377 Two countries, two "languages" (different terms for sure), 2 cultures, different foods, different holidays, different government, different economy, different law, different weather, different location, Different mentality
You have the same accent and dialect. I had an Austrian flatmate. She always told when she met German customers they were always like what cute accent, this is where we go to ski
@@bomberdomme7308was hast du für Deutschland geleistet? Bayern ist sehr wichtig für Deutschland, schon immer gewesen, aber wer natürlich keine ahnung von der deutschen Wirtschaft hat, redet so ein Müll.
Naja wenn man ehrlich ist sind weder wir noch ihr so dermassen unfreundlich wie wir immer hingestellt werden. Bei euch ist es doch was das Thema angeht nicht viel anders wie bei uns oder? Wie man in den Wald hineinruft so hallt es zurück....
Austria is German. Starting from its birth, which occurred through the Bavarian colonization of previously Slavic lands, Austria was always part of the Kingdom of Germany until the end of the Holy Roman Empire in 1806. And even after that it continued to be part of the German Confederation. Any objection based on the weakness of these state entities is invalid, since it is only evidence of the political weakness of Germany, certainly not of its non-existence. Continuing, even after the foundation of the German Empire, the Austrian emperor himself continued undaunted to consider himself a German prince, given that Austria's failure to enter the unitary German state was certainly not due to a non-Germanness of Austria itself, but rather to the presence also of vast non-German areas within the empire, areas which, remember, all separated from Austria. And in fact, once the war was over, everyone thought that, since these regions had gone their own way, there was no longer any reason to remain separated from the rest of the Germans. It was the victorious allies, that is, Austria's enemies themselves, who prevented it. Therefore the very idea of Austria as an independent nation is a ridiculous invention of Austria's enemies, which has no historical or ethnic justification, but which was only useful to them to maintain their domination. The only reason why Austrians developed a separate identity is to distance themselves from what they perceived as Nazi ideals. But: 1) the problematic aspects of Nazism don’t include pan-Germanism, which was supported even by many interwar socialists; 2) it’s an irrational reaction not based on actual facts.
It's like when British people call all Americans "Yankees." But in the US the term Yankee refers to people from the northern part of the US, so calling a southerner a "Yankee" is an easy way to piss them off.
Austrians are NOT Germans i dont want to hear that anymore the language is different the culture is different and the german humor is insulting in austria
I am Argentinian and I can say this is false. Argentina and Uruguay feel as a brothers, we know that we are very similar, maybe they can annoyed if you start to talk about football.
I love the first part when the Englishman says "Hey, you alright mate" and the German stops and closes his eyes 😂 instant regret of greeting him, hahaha
Had to learn this the hard way. Worked in Germany for a while and later in Austria too. I was hanging out with an Austrian friend and I went on and on about my experiences in Germany. She ended up saying "if you like it so much there why did you come to Austria???" 😅
The starting is what gets me lol, bro just wanted to say "hallo" and move on with life but the other guy had to be annoying and ask "are you alright mate?"
na ja, depends on whom you met there... not everyone are locals or familiar with these (e.q. somebody from other parts of Germany, I mean not Bavaria).
As a German i don't agree. Austria brought always Trouble to Germany. Kaiserschmarrn made us fat, in Football they humiliate us several Times and they send us this Idiot from Braunau. 😂😂
Griaß eng! I ho do glab I a no a Wörtchen mitzumren 😁 so gnau gätz ja ba uns a ned gell, oba as schene Estareich sollt ma ned mit Deitschlond verwechseln gell?🇦🇹
Weil das alles Nestbeschmutzer sind, die ihre eigene Geschichte und ihr deutsches Blut verleugnen. Sie sind genauso Deutsch wie wir Franken oder Hessen oder Preußen. Noch 1938 waren alle glückliche Deutsche und heute wollen sie davon nichts mehr wissen. Selbst die Süd-Tiroler haben das den Ostmärklern voraus..
@@senfdazu2230 no, definitivly Beethoven. Born in Bonn, family partly from Rheinland, partly from Holland, but lived and composed for decades in Vienna, part of 'Wiener Klassik'. But that's academic. 50 years later Emperor Franz Joseph of Austria identified as 'deutscher Reichsfürst'. So what.
Gosh, Austrians hate this even more. They hate comparisons with Germans. Especially my Austrian wife. Once I said ‘In my German learning, I find that I can hear Germans more clearer than Austrians.’ She said ‘Well go live in Germany then! 😡’ 🤣🤣🤣 Never again.
Austria is German. Starting from its birth, which occurred through the Bavarian colonization of previously Slavic lands, Austria was always part of the Kingdom of Germany until the end of the Holy Roman Empire in 1806. And even after that it continued to be part of the German Confederation. Any objection based on the weakness of these state entities is invalid, since it is only evidence of the political weakness of Germany, certainly not of its non-existence. Continuing, even after the foundation of the German Empire, the Austrian emperor himself continued undaunted to consider himself a German prince, given that Austria's failure to enter the unitary German state was certainly not due to a non-Germanness of Austria itself, but rather to the presence also of vast non-German areas within the empire, areas which, remember, all separated from Austria. And in fact, once the war was over, everyone thought that, since these regions had gone their own way, there was no longer any reason to remain separated from the rest of the Germans. It was the victorious allies, that is, Austria's enemies themselves, who prevented it. Therefore the very idea of Austria as an independent nation is a ridiculous invention of Austria's enemies, which has no historical or ethnic justification, but which was only useful to them to maintain their domination. The only reason why Austrians developed a separate identity is to distance themselves from what they perceived as Nazi ideals. But: 1) the problematic aspects of Nazism don’t include pan-Germanism, which was supported even by many interwar socialists; 2) it’s an irrational reaction not based on actual facts.
Echt jetzt? Warum äfft ihr Ösis denn alles nach, was aus Deutschland kommt? Im Grunde seid ihr doch nur neidisch auf uns, verglichen mit uns Deutschen wollt ihr nur nicht , weil ihr Angst habt auch als Nazis diffamiert zu werden. Das Dilemma mit den Nazis hat uns im Übrigen ein Österreicher eingebrockt.
@@AlexanderLittlebearsHave to love the unprompted History lesson. Sound smart, but basically denying Austria its own existence. 🤣 ask Austrians if they want to be part of Germany. 🤣
people forgetting that Austria use to be in the German Confederation and had it not been for prussia and bismarck hatred towards austira and decided not to exclude the austrian from the Unification of Germany than mabye germany would might look different today, this comes from a German, who believe all German speakin nation should remain brothers and not enemies.@@AlexanderLittlebears
@@Dachsbeisser Germany and Austria are two different countries. Bayern is part of Germany. It's exactly what the video is about, it's not the same just because they speak the same language.
@@asterixur1335 but it is spekulated He was Born on what today is called Italian grounds. Thats why Italians claim him as their "property" even tho He was found in Austria.
When I was on walking group holidays in Austria we used to try to guess whether other walkers were Austrian, German or Italian so that we would know how to address them. The Italians were always extremely stylish.
@@cheerubebayonettaholopaine2638ich war vor kurzen in Jerusalem irgendwo im nirgendwo unterwegs. Durch die Deuter Tasche und den Socken und weiteren Merkmalen wusste ich direkt das sind deutsche Mitbürger und habe sie auf deutsch angeredet😉
@@kendrickbritto8556 austrians are basically germans who are mountain dwellers who also drank too much alcohole so they lost their mother language and made up a new one using their remaining knowledge
I'm guessing Liam had to learn the hard way. But usually it's us Austrians getting pissed if tourists call us germans. Edit *what have I done...💀* I an Austrian started yet another war in the comments. Lucky for me I am also Argentine🇦🇷⭐️⭐️⭐️😜 hold up...
@@dafyddlewis4738der österreichische Dialekt ist lediglich eine deutsche Sprache von vielen. Eben ein Dialekt. Die Österreicher sind genauso Deutsch wie die Menschen nördlich der Alpen
@@manuelbuhr84 Es gibt mehrere österreichische Dialekte. Die meisten gehören zur bairischen Sprachfamilie, genau wie viele bayrische Dialekte. Deutsch hat auch viele Dialekte.
Austria is German. Starting from its birth, which occurred through the Bavarian colonization of previously Slavic lands, Austria was always part of the Kingdom of Germany until the end of the Holy Roman Empire in 1806. And even after that it continued to be part of the German Confederation. Any objection based on the weakness of these state entities is invalid, since it is only evidence of the political weakness of Germany, certainly not of its non-existence. Continuing, even after the foundation of the German Empire, the Austrian emperor himself continued undaunted to consider himself a German prince, given that Austria's failure to enter the unitary German state was certainly not due to a non-Germanness of Austria itself, but rather to the presence also of vast non-German areas within the empire, areas which, remember, all separated from Austria. And in fact, once the war was over, everyone thought that, since these regions had gone their own way, there was no longer any reason to remain separated from the rest of the Germans. It was the victorious allies, that is, Austria's enemies themselves, who prevented it. Therefore the very idea of Austria as an independent nation is a ridiculous invention of Austria's enemies, which has no historical or ethnic justification, but which was only useful to them to maintain their domination. The only reason why Austrians developed a separate identity is to distance themselves from what they perceived as Nazi ideals. But: 1) the problematic aspects of Nazism don’t include pan-Germanism, which was supported even by many interwar socialists; 2) it’s an irrational reaction not based on actual facts.
Fun fact: He failed school, was rejected at art university on account of his being unencumbered by any artistic talent whatsoever, joined the Bavarian army, then participated in the Luddendorf coup attempt (he was just following orders, if only just), was arrested, and as a criminal foreigner he would have been extradited, but in court he impressed the judge with his fervent German patriotism so much that the judge repatriated him on the spot. So in Vienna he had been unemployed, in Munich he went to prison, and in Berlin he was made chancellor. (Against the then soon to be late president Hindenburg's better judgement, but still.) He entered politics at the behest of two people he met in prison: The director of the Bavarian police Himmler, and the Prussian minister of the interior Göring.
Which is pathetic, because at least the entire Lowlands of Scotland have been conquered and settled by Anglo-Saxons. Only in the Highlands you have mostly celtic real Scots.
@@hildebrandgotenland4823 And the whole British Isles were settled by Vikings multiple times, and England was once Celtic Britons, that blood didn't just vanish when the Anglo-Saxons invaded, not to mention the Normans came in after that and added their French/Viking genes into the pool. There is no such thing as a "pure race", especially not in fuckin' Britain of all places. This is more cultural identity than genetics, and the Lowlands are culturally Scottish.
@@pingpong_ Only because you are ignorant and uneducated doesn't mean it's the truth. If you feel like you are a 3 m tall Japanese women, it doesn't mean you are one.
@@pingpong_ They are not Germans, they are Germanics, that's a difference. What you feel doesn't change facts, just like transgender idiots will never really change gender.
An English guy wanted to know in which part of Germany I had grown up. East or west? He asked. I answered South. He asked again. Stupid prick I thought, but as this was a job interview, I played nice. Explained the South of Germany was part of the so called Western Germany. He wanted to impress me but he only showed he had no clue after living in Germany for decades. Bayern, Baden-Württemberg, Saarland are very down south, at Austrian, Swiss and French border. They were part of the American sector and still are today. Eastern Germany was Russian sector.
@@cheerubebayonettaholopaine2638 Vorarlberger sind nur Schwaben die von den Wittelsbachern und Habsburgern unnütz geteilt wurden an einer imaginären Grenze
@@jonnbinn2865aus deutscher Sicht sind die Schweizer und Österreicher arrogant und unfreundlich, die Schweizer sind aber zudem noch humorlos. Ich glaube wir haben die gleichen Stereotype über die jeweils anderen.
Ich hab kein Bock mehr auf Österreicher, die immer nur die Deutschen hassen (siehe Kommentar hier direkt drüber). Der Krieg ist schon' bisschen her, sucht euch nen neues Hobby
Can we appreciate the dedication that Liam took a whole new pair of clothing on this hike and changed his attire midway just to film this skit there lmao 😂
calling germans and austrians the same thing is like a warcrime and all acts against that person are allowed to break the geneva convention. Ich liebe deine Shorts :D
The cardinal mistake: talk to a German and get him out of his meditative hiking flow without justified reason. That alone can get you kicked down the hill.
Actually germans don't mind, they basically think of Austrians as "those other germans" anyway. Austrians on the other hand get irrationally upset if you tell them they're like germans
The Austrians welcomed Hitler with open arms in 1938, and now they’re crying rape. It’s O.K., though. They’re very charming people, and I like them a lot.
Trust me, Bavarians don't even like the fact they are forced share the same country with the other Bundesländer (federal states), and must thus share the overarching descriptor of "German" with them. Conflating them with Austrians is understandably fighting words. (Even if the Bundesland Upper Austria shares a lot of cultural and dialect similarities with Bavaria due to their geographical neighborhood. 😁)
@@edene.4870As Badenian, I actually agree with the Bavarians in this. We might be all Europeans, but I do not like our artificial, inefficient country.
As an Austrian i can just cite the famous Austrian actor Christoph Waltz who once said on the US show CONAN: "The difference between Austria and Germany is like the difference between a battleship and a waltz (the dance)" And yes he really said that...
Yes, Germans don't have the best reputation, especially in the holiday resorts, so you have to make it clear right from the start that you are Austrian ;)
