WHICH IS BEST? MagMod MagSphere vs. MagBounce Comparison

Подписаться 3 тыс.

Просмотров 51 тыс.

50% 1

Choosing which MagMod modifier is best for your shoot can be tough. I compare the MagSphere against the MagBounce, plus a handy little pro hack using the MagGrid combined.
Do you use MagMod gear? Let me know in the comments what you prefer and why!
#magmod #magbounce #magsphere
Affiliate links are below (Amazon)
Intro music by Dyalla Swain
www.soundcloud.com/dyallas/
GET THE ITEMS IN THIS VIDEO:
MAGMOD PROFESSIONAL KIT: amzn.to/3oIi6qt
MAGMOD BASIC KIT: amzn.to/35Jn2UA
MAGBOUNCE: amzn.to/35GOEK8
MAGSPHERE: amzn.to/3qqPanw
MAGGRID: amzn.to/3bGG7KX
FLASHGUNS: amzn.to/3nIt0Lr
2M POP UP BACKDROP: amzn.to/3ieGeyu
PRODUCTION EQUIPMENT:
4K MIRRORLESS - Fujifilm X-T3: amzn.to/3oRlnUC
SUPER WIDE LENS - Samyang 12MM f2.0: amzn.to/3nKglrr
REFERENCE MONITOR - Feelworld MA5: amzn.to/35JxWts
AMAZING AUDIO - Rode VideoMic Pro: amzn.to/3oZN3X6
TRAVEL TRIPOD - 3 Legged Thing Punks Corey: amzn.to/38LHzcS
VIDEO LIGHT - Godox SL60W: amzn.to/39PQR7l
SUPER SOFTBOX - Phot-R 80cm Octabox: amzn.to/38IQuvL
3M STAND - Phot-R Studio 3m Stand: amzn.to/3inizvR

Опубликовано:

28 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 57

@papsny 2 года назад

For an expensive modifier, the yellowing on the MagMod makes you cringe

@MikeT-yy3 3 года назад

Many thanks Jon

@jasonbodden8816 2 года назад

Both of these do not give very soft light. They're still very small light sources on their own. The MagSphere gives a harder light than the MagBounce. The only time the MagSphere's light would look soft is if it has neutral walls and/or ceilings to bounce off of. Nothing wrong with harder light, though. I just see a lot of people saying these types of modifiers give off very soft light. They don't. It's a nice quality of light they both give off but to say it's very soft is grossly overstating it. Physics say otherwise.

@JonSparkman 2 года назад

100%! Can’t fight physics.

@RayValdezPhotography Год назад

Still a lot better than bare flash

@dinarakhairova Год назад

Thank you!

@Avectwigg Год назад

nice one - great video

@edwinscott6500 3 года назад

I had magnets drop out only after using it three times, help desk got back to me when the warranty runout.

@AE1PT Год назад

I note that the MagSphere appears yellowish in places. I have noted such in other solutions (bought and self-built) due to the action of the intense burst of xenon light acting on the molecular composition of the opalescent media used for the flash modifier. I had also wondered about the ability of silicone based solutions (such as these) to resist that decomposition. Can anyone comment as to whether this yellowing seen here is the result of the flash energy, or something more mundane such as staining from the oils and soil from the hands? I find that the case with CPAP masks due to facial oils.

@buidoi72 2 года назад

Thank you! Great comparison. For wedding photography, would you recommend having the sphere and bounce?

@JonSparkman 2 года назад

Just a sphere should be fine

@MikeT-yy3 3 года назад

Hi Jon, Really well delivered video, great info direct to the point, looking forward to seeing your work outside with these units. Question if I may. The main reason I am interested is when backlighting a portrait outdoors, rather than struggle on my own with reflectors, I want to provide a nice fill light and catchlight to the face. I know OCF is better but the look I am after is that of the straight on, raised up style of my studio beauty dish. The magbounce will give me a higher angle than the sphere I believe, but with more distinct shadows as you pointed out in the video. Which do you think would be most suitable for this run and gun style? Many thanks.

@JonSparkman 3 года назад

Hmm interesting one. The sphere will have a radial fall off, you might end up with a darker lower half of a body if doing portraits. The bounce will give more even coverage which would be better as a fill unit. Sphere substitutes softboxes, bounce an umbrella. As a beauty dish is closer to an umbrella in light quality, I’d say use a bounce.

@ERoossien 2 года назад

I'm planning to use either the sphere or the bounce for an informal corporate meeting. Partly inside partly outside. Which would be the better option for an on camera flash?

@JonSparkman 2 года назад

Probably bounce if you want sheer coverage of light. Sphere is better if you want to pinpoint the light in specific areas

@alexandrataylor3452 2 года назад

Very helpful video, thanks. Nice sphere has begun to slightly turn yellow. It’s hard to tell if my pictures have been effected by this yet. Is it pretty obvious? And I’m assuming there’s no fix other than getting a new one?

@Visualsthatgohard 2 года назад

For a nightclub photographer which one of the two would you recommend?

@JonSparkman 2 года назад

Bounce

@MrMkariniot 11 месяцев назад

I have the sphere with the flash . The flash is pointed up . I have noticed that with maggsphere it makes the images more bluish more cool . O I increased my temperature . With the others diffusers didn’t have that problem . Have you noticed that .? Thanks

@JonSparkman 11 месяцев назад

Yes - I think the material creates a colour cast. I don’t think they control that too much in manufacturing however you’d need to contact them to clarify

@MrMkariniot 11 месяцев назад

I have contacted them but no response . So you have noticed that too .? I increase the temperature and it is ok but :/

@AlergicToSnow 3 года назад

I’d love to see more outdoor examples. I think these would be a great solution on windy days instead of a softbox or umbrella…If they do a decent job.

@TheJuniper366 Год назад

Amazing video! Exactly what I needed. You answered my questions as I thought them!

@GIRAFLASH2 5 месяцев назад

🤔 both loose many power , the magbounce must not goles through by light , allí light must go forward 🙄

@Cozsmik 3 года назад

Video is very precise, straightforward and informative. I have both MagSphere and MagBounce, and now know the difference between them...thanks!

@SÉBASTIEN-formateur-CSE 3 года назад

Every body says MagBounce produces hard light, very white and specular, but did anyone try to add something to soften the light ??

@JonSparkman 3 года назад

You can’t cheat physics - to get a soft light it’s got to be big, or diffused, or both! Magbox 24” is ideal.

@mariannanewman8493 9 месяцев назад

What layer is the gel ( colored)? There is no gel in the flash kit 2 but I was thinking of getting one. Also, Nice presentation

@chocloditelensman 11 месяцев назад

It would be nice to see some actual model tests - even a mannequin head would be helpful ?

@GIRAFLASH2 5 месяцев назад

🤔 would be similar to put the flash upward to White roof😬

@shortybaker2668 Месяц назад

Great vid!!

@Alex-nt8nq 3 года назад

Love your work mate. Thanks so much!

@filipruzicka8607 Год назад

The quality of intro music is bad, i would change it. You have a good mic, dont ruin it with that music.

@JonSparkman Год назад

I’ve been looking for something new!

@GIRAFLASH2 5 месяцев назад

What do hoy think about flashbrackets 🤔🙄😬

@JonSparkman 3 месяца назад

They're great! I really want the Boomerang bracket.

Год назад

The video ended and I never saw how the accessories work with a subject or an object. Waste of time.

@JonSparkman Год назад

I never set out to show it on a subject, only its pure output. I plan to do a comparison on a model eventually

@cronufc 5 месяцев назад

Dude it was Covid times

@cronas2 2 года назад

did you ever make that video of doing portraits using these two... I have both and would like to see your take on them,, cheers..

@JonSparkman 2 года назад

Hey, I did but have taken it offline since. I’ll upload another this year I hope.

@forgewire 3 года назад

@9:55 they will start collapse if you keep folding them like @9:50, but they indeed go yellow as they age which is a shame for such expensive product.

@cronufc 5 месяцев назад

Great video, thank you

@marilynzanca7712 2 года назад

Hi, I do real estate photography and for couple I weeks I have been using the magsphere and have found using the canon 580 ex ii. The photos seem to have dark spots. I used to use gary fong diffuser and never a problem with it. Might go back to Gary, if I can't work it out. Do you know about the circles it produces?

@JonSparkman 2 года назад

Hey! Yeah, it has a hotspot because it's directional. The Fong shoots in to the lid, and then out, making it bounced light, which generally has no hotspots or dark points. Maybe pointing the sphere into a wall or ceiling would be best bet!

@marilynzanca7712 2 года назад

@@JonSparkman Thanks might try that . Bless you heaps.cheers mal

@rcdhi1g 3 года назад

Waiting for review with models for portraits photos with this flash mods .

@JonSparkman 3 года назад

Not been able to get that arranged yet, but hopefully in the next month.

@zolganboss Год назад

Thank you

@Matias-cx3wg 3 года назад

I want one of them to use on portraits outdoors. Which one you say it's better for that particular situation? Thank you for the answer!

@JonSparkman 3 года назад

Sphere!

@sz2474 Год назад

@@JonSparkman in an outdoor situation, we point the sphere towards the subjects? Sounds like a dumb question as I am typing. But please confirm : )

@JonSparkman Год назад

Yes always point the sphere at a subject, and the bounce away from a subject

@sz2474 Год назад

@@JonSparkman omg thanks for the prompt response.

@jwp2166 3 года назад

You certainly know your stuff, you communicate quite clearly, and -- owning both the sphere and the bounce -- you have helped me better understand how they work and when I should use them. I take a lot of dog & puppy photos and find the bounce quite excellent for that. Thanks so much for your videos.