Who Did It The Best? Surf Mesa, Emilee “ILY”, Frankie Valli “Can’t Take My Eyes Off Of You”  

Frankie can not be beat.

Either 1982 or 1967 they have so much instruments and it really builds up the excitement

Every version has its own and unique feel, but classics are my favorites

1998, 1982, and 1967, the vibe they all give off it’s just…… oh my god man perfect

the last two are just *chefs kiss✨👌*

1982 and 1967 are just ✨ PERFECTION ✨

1982 & 1967 are the bomb!❤

Morten Harket of A-ha fame also had a memorable cover that made several movie soundtracks. I think he deserves a mention over some of the recent ones

Lauryn and Frankie...something about their versions are timeless

Frankie and Lauryn. Their voices are iconic, and hearing them both bring a smile to my face.

Honestly my favorite version on the boys town Gang, I just love the energy and it feel like they're happy to love someone

1967 pulled me back to the year

The 1982 version is iconic but the 1967 version is hard to beat!

The Frankie Vallie version will always hold a special place in my heart because me and my grandma used to listen to it RIP 1955-2021

My favorites: 1st) Boys Town Gang 2nd) Morten Harket 3rd) Berk and the Virtual Band 4th) Muse

From 98 back it was such a classic

Frankie's iconic

The Boys Town Gang version is always my favorite. Mainly because I really like disco music

2019: Chill Teenagers Music 2016: Young Adults Music 1998: Mostly Uknown 1982: Iconic And Well Known 1967: Old But Bold

1982 one was so ✨✨✨✨

1982 and 1967 have that special energy which just sends chills of nostalgia even though I wasn’t alive then

Franki and Lauryn have always been out here and there. There sounds are never dead

Is it just me or is it a shame that modern music can’t get me as exited as the older ones

Frankie hits different! Just chills bro

1982 for me. Remind me my childhood ❤🥰

My favourite is when Heath Ledger sings this in 10 things I hate about you. I've watched that part many many times (also he was my first celebrity crush because of this movie and especially that one scene).

1982 or 2016...both r damned ❤

I honestly like Joseph Vincent’s one the most, I think this song works really nicely in an acoustic setting where the vocals can shine more

Franki is the OG but Lauryn’s is so soulful

Frankie Valli for sure! Love The Four Seasons!

As much as I love old music. The most recent version of this is lovely.

All are good but 2019 hit different 😊

Frankie Valli's version will never be beaten

I think Frankie Valli did it best

Frankie is a icon..HES THE BEST😃

I was born in 90s and give it to Lauryn because she introduced this song to us 90s kids and has significance, but Frankie has a flair to it.

Frankie Valli... WHAT A VOICE. 🙌

1982 and 1967 just because I hear them all the time when there's a party.

i grew up with all of these versions dude like they played on the radio 24/7 when i was 4-5 back in around 2015-2016

The Surf mesa version is my favorite. It helps bring an easy sense of calm and comfort in my mind. I love it! Emilee’s voice is so soothing

Frankie Valli is the best!!!! His voice, the band with that driving beat, is just phenomenal. Though the other versions have also become favorites.

frankie valli is musically indestructable

I like 1989s style, but 2019 and 1982 are my fav.

Everyone brings something a little different to their versions and at the same time you can't really Beat the originall and I also have an appreciation for the modern iterations as well.

Surf mesa is really calming and relaxing but Frankie did the best!

the horn section in the original is unmatched,, so damn good

1982 is lowkey the best it makes you feel GOOD

1998, it's for me at least, iconic

67 and 98. The original and Lauren hands down for me just depends what mood I'm in.❤

I like 1982 a lot cuz it has that upbeat vibe that I relate with buy I simply love the original

The last 2 definitely win, but my personal favorite is Heath Ledger in 10 Things I Hate About You

I've only ever heard the 67 version... and I still prefer it 🤘

boys town gang is really fun and energetic, my favourite 👍

Lauryn's has so much heart and soul.

Frankie Valli is an amazing artist. I wish I could've seen him live but his final tour ended in my area right before I heard about it...

1982 is so nice to hear😊

The original one just hits different 😂

Everybody knows Frankie, he’s a legend

1967 1982 and 2016 would give a listen🤩

The OG wins buts the 80s version is a close second it’s so catchy. I also like how echoey and haunted the 2019 version sounds

1982 and 1967 are just something else, 1967 has a great voice, same as 1998, angelic voices, and I love the upbeat tune of 1982.

Lauryn is always my favorite, listening to her music while riding a motorcycle is such a vibes 💚

Well surf mesa circulate on my beach playlist while Lauryn hill’s version circulate on my rnb playlist and I love all versions❤❤❤❤❤

1982 and 1967 will always be the best. Im not saying this because theyre old theyre just good

Personally, I enjoy Lauryn Hill's version, but I love how they all have such different takes. Another cover I love is the one Solar of Mamamoo sang. She did sing it to fans, so it feels softer, more personal and intimate.

67' reigns all day. There is none like it. 💯

I grew up the 1998 one it played on the radio a lot

2016 has a great voice but the original 3 are perfect

Frankie's didn't need to be covered.. it was perfect. Lauryn is second prize.

muse's cover is amazing as well

1982 is sooo good and 2019 is the one i grew up to so im used to that

Frankie Valli and the four seasons will always be the best

i mean, they’re ok but lauryn and frankie killed it

Please do "killing me softly"

1982 because the girl confident is just wowwww

tbh I like all of them except for the 2019 ver.

love all of them, they're beautiful in their own ways

1967 : run 1982 : jump 1998 : sit 2016 : sleepy 2019 : sleep tight

2019 one has a special place in my heart.

1998 and 1982 I have listened to multiple times

I still live for Frankie Valli.. Joseph Vincent did an amazing take on this Frankie Valli song.. Honorable mention to Lauryn Hill.. She just has melodic creativity and Im there for it❤One time.. Two times.. If ya know then you know.. lol sending best wishes always

Frankie Valli had a hell of a voice!

I will admit 2019 and the original version are both very good

The deep feeling of Frankie is imbatible the perfection the only really heart of this wonderful iconic song

Joseph is my favorite, he sounds so genuinely in love throughout the whole cover😊

Lauryn, then Frankie 😊

Not here, but my favorite is Muse’s cover! The rock instrumental and Matt Bellamy’s vocals were incredible and so fitting!!❤️

I love the instrumentals of 1982 version and i love the voice of the singer in the 1967 version

Idk why but I love the 1967’s one.

My mother grew up with 82 but as a child she had 98 Lauren hill on REPEAT 😂

2019 or 1982 or 1962 Its hard to choose they all are very good

67 and 82 respectively.

2019:nah 2016:nah 1998:alright 1982:HOLY SHIT THIS GOES HARD 1967:love this a lot

I’m a tad partial to the 1982 version myself!

1982 & 1967 the best.... The beat the tone everything is just erfect classic song.

The last two are no doubt 2000 percent the best

Middle and second to last are by far the best

Old is Gold....

Nothing beats the original (Though the 1982 one is also really good)

82 & 67 is tied IMO