Who sings Mozart's "Va', l'error mio palesa" best? 

My vote goes to Nathalie Stutzmann.

Nathalie Stutzmann. The most sonorous, vibrant, full-bodied singing - counter tenors simply cannot achieve that luscious sound. I find her also to have the most elegant, sophisticated phrasing. Simply magnificent!

Stutzmann en el primer lugar, su registro grave no tiene parangón. Y Dumaux también me gusta, tiene un color vocal muy distintivo, y le imprime gran dramatismo.

Nathalie Stutzmann, of course! She recorded that aria when she was young and had the best vocal abilities. Her high G (G5) is amazing for contralto!

Nathalie !!!!

Christophe Dumaux!!! Non lo conoscevo, è molto bravo.

Nathalie Stutzmann

Paul-Antoine 👍In my opinion, this performance is the most "even". Because it is not only about the singer, but also about the impression that the orchestra gives and its harmony with the singer. I would like arias of the "divine Saxon" - Johann Adolf Hasse. Mozart was a fan of his work. He wanted to be through his works just like Hasse immortal.

Nathalie Stutzmann.

Nathalie Stutzmann.

Christophe Dumaux

1. Christophe Dumaux 2. Nathalie Stutzmann

Christophe Dumaux is staying unbitten, hi's great! ❤

Bejun Mehta

Stutzmann, but in absolute I prefer the Kowalski version (1994)

Jochen Kowalski .

All three voices are wonderful ❤

Despite being a lover and follower of the countertenor voice I have to admit that I did not know Paul-Antoine. I shall now put him on my list to investigate. Thank you BB for his inclusion.

Paul-Antoine Bénos-Djian, tiene mucha fuerza interpretativa y un muy buen caudal de voz sobre todo en los agudos (2:15 min). Su interpretación me recuerda mucho a Filippo Mineccia.

Can’t decide here. They are so good, tonally, interpretation and technique, all different but gorgeous.

Dumaux sans doute .

Buenisimos pero yo prefiero al primer contratenor el finado alfred deller" en alos 30s

Les 3 pareil

Paul-Antoine Bénos-Djian