Who Will Win? Spearmen or Kislevite Warriors in Warhammer Total War 3! 

Who will win: A centuries-old elf who has spent his life training to master the spear and fight in perfect military order vs a slav with a pointy stick ... the answer may surprise you

The power creep in this game is starting to become a bit overbearing. High elf spearmen used to be some of the best low tier infantry, and now they're getting knocked around rather handily by regular polearm humans who don't even have shields.

I'm never not annoyed by how poorly elf (HE, DE, WE) units perform. Gameplay necessities aside it's just ridiculous. Dudes should be absolute monsters compared to most races. Instead they are fancy wet noodles.

Shielded elven spearmen should wipe the floor with these guys.

Dont trust an elf To do a Man's job

Its fucking ridiculous....

HE need love

It always confused me that the spear militia of the high elves are called Spearmen and not Spearelves.

Well, when you're on the Frontline of chaos, you either become strong or die

I think campaign-buffed spearmen with spearwall points would win this

It has no lore sense at all... by far... Not only Elves have more training and technique, they also have better armor and spears.

Kislevite warriors got nerfed in patch 5.0

This is the biggest issue with WH3, it’s all unbalanced garbage with every new DLC unit being stronger than the last. They no longer consider lore, tabletop sheets, unit type and roster functionality when adding new content. Wh2 wasn’t perfect but it was close enough for modders to simply fix it with a handful of tweaks. WH3 is completely broken and requires too much of an overhaul to fix.