Тёмный

Why Buying a Home is One of the Biggest Mistakes Young People Make 

Sharon Winsmith
Подписаться 6 тыс.
Просмотров 4,3 тыс.
50% 1

Buying a home is one of the worst financial decisions people make. It is ingrained in us that we should save money and buy a home as soon as we can. In reality, this may be a really bad financial decision.
Buying a home too early in your wealth building journey can prevent you from ever achieving financial freedom. It can impact the types of investments you can make and the time it takes you to reach your wealth building goals.
Watch this video to understand why buying a home could cost you millions in lifetime earning potential. I walk you through a real world example of the financial impact of buying vs. renting a home in Austin, Texas.
Video Contents
00:00 - Intro
02:15 - 8 Reasons Buying a Home is a Bad Financial Decision
12:14 - Example of the Financial Impact of Renting vs. Buying
24:37 - Example with Additional Homeowner Expenses
💡 I do not work with clients or offer any consulting services. If you want to learn more about the best tax and investment strategies, subscribe to my channel and check out these courses ▶️ sharonwinsmith.com/courses/
The information provided in this video is owned by Winsmith Tax LLC and is solely for informational and educational purposes. It is not intended as investment, legal, or financial advice. Always consult with a professional familiar with your unique situation, or conduct your own research before making any decisions. We might receive commissions for recommending certain products or services.

Опубликовано:

 

5 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 54   
@daddyschainsjewelry
@daddyschainsjewelry 5 месяцев назад
The “I found a gem channel button” >>>
@WinnieBruiser
@WinnieBruiser 4 месяца назад
Seriously
@sunnyd4734
@sunnyd4734 7 месяцев назад
I have been following your strategy for the past 34 years and I agree with you 100%. Prodigious investor. I would never have the net worth that I do now if I had purchased real estate earlier in life. I live in Boston, MA and plan to retire in a less expensive state. People think I'm nuts to rent but I always believed that it would work in my favor in the long run. I'm so glad that you confirmed what I've always believed to be true. 😊
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
That's awesome! I love this! I remember in one of my finance classes in college I had a prof who was in his 60's and said he would never own a home. We always thought he was crazy but the older I get, the more I realize how smart he was. I would never be in the financial position I am in now if I had bought an apartment in NYC.
@lawrence4036
@lawrence4036 7 месяцев назад
Where have you been all my life? Thank you.
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
Thank you for watching!
@rafinsyed9284
@rafinsyed9284 2 месяца назад
Soo well spoken and very detailed discussions.
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 2 месяца назад
Really appreciate the kind words! :)
@victorvictor88
@victorvictor88 7 месяцев назад
I do not know how to thank you enough for your work!
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
Thank you so much for your kind words! Appreciate you watching 😀
@rishik9250
@rishik9250 4 месяца назад
Thanks Sharon, big fan of your advice. Would it be possible for you to share a Google Sheets version of this spreadsheet? I'd love to play around with numbers specific to my home.
@robcolbert4159
@robcolbert4159 7 месяцев назад
Could you provide a list of quality real estate syndicates / funds and or an agency that rates syndicates and funds. I will perform my own due diligence. Thank you! I really respect your videos as you do the homework and summarize the info/data in a practical equation!
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
I would suggest starting with this video ▶️ ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JBJTOXRb-1s.html It is an intro to a course I have about how I find good quality sponsors. I don't provide a list of actual sponsors but the course walks you through the process to get access to the same deal flow that I do where you then can do your own due diligence on sponsors and individual deals themselves. I share the process I use and show you how to find real estate funds/syndications (and even other types of funds as well if you are interested). Hope this helps and thanks for watching!
@danoyoung
@danoyoung 7 месяцев назад
Great video again, thank you! As far as accredited investor, do you have some material that outline more details on optional investments? How would one access such investments and how to find them?
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
Thank you! That's a great question and the most common one I get. I recorded a course where I walk you through how I get access to good deal flow (real estate funds, syndications, debt funds, etc.) for accredited investors. This video is a good intro to that course - I suggest starting there. ▶️ ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JBJTOXRb-1s.html Hope this is helpful!
@danoyoung
@danoyoung 7 месяцев назад
@@sharonwinsmith thank you! Keep up the awesome work
@Shawn.Tanaka
@Shawn.Tanaka 7 месяцев назад
Thank you for this comprehensive breakdown, Sharon! Would you be able to share that spreadsheet with us to play with the numbers? Thank you!
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
Thanks for watching Shawn! Let me work on getting that up on my website and will share the file.
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
Link to download ➡️ docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1gZMxxz5aYMFgThT3AgHBEe21-b4gwFQS/copy
@chayden1402
@chayden1402 7 месяцев назад
Great 👍 video and explanation. 🤔 would this apply too house hacking?
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
Thank you - that's a really great question! I like the concept of house hacking, especially for people who either live in an area where they just can't feasibly rent or have already bought a house and want to try to monetize a portion of it. I think house hacking definitely makes the financial downside to homeownership a bit better. However, in my experience, it usually doesn't outweigh the renting strategy. Of course every situation is different and it comes down to the numbers.
@scottjohnston9048
@scottjohnston9048 27 дней назад
Please comment on the tax advantages for home ownership.
@josephbsmithjr
@josephbsmithjr 7 месяцев назад
What is your thoughts on HELOC's? It reminds me alot of SBLOCs. The biggest difference I see is that it is less liquid and the former requires a good credit score to have access to.
@Pseudify
@Pseudify 12 дней назад
I don’t know much about SBLOCs other than what I’ve heard in these videos. But I suspect the interest rate is higher with HELOCs. And at today’s mortgage rates, it would be hard to justify using a HELOC to buy, say, stocks. You’d probably be breaking even. But I’m new to the buy, borrow, die concept, so check around for better advice.
@vincentwady
@vincentwady 7 месяцев назад
It's an eye-opening analysis. Could you share your research what's the average expected annual return as an accredited investor? Private Equity or Hedge Fund sounds great, but I assume investments are tied to the long term. So probably they are illiquid. Does accredited investments offer some cash flows to cover expenses??
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
Great question! Accredited investors can't typically invest in hedge funds. I have a course where I walk through investment funds and how I find good real estate funds to invest in and what returns I expect the fund to make before I consider investing. Real estate funds should typically make distributions to investors unless it is a development project or investment in raw land. The link to the course is sharonwinsmith.com/deal-flow-for-funds/
@omegaofgaia
@omegaofgaia 8 дней назад
I have an appalling criminal record, but have a good-ish paying stable long term job. Because of my record, nobody will rent to me. Its almost impossible to get respectable accomodations, without persecution, that are long term reliable. But the lending company had no problem loaning me/wife for a home of our own, so buying is our only real option. Now, considering the fact that i bought a home, would you recommend plowing my money into the mortgage to get the principal down quickly in the first few years, or instead put extra money into these other true assets? I assume you're going to say the latter.
@holson2112
@holson2112 7 месяцев назад
Being a 30 year real estate landlord in a US city i agree. Home ownership isnt worth it now. There are too many other ways to make money that work while you rent. Things have changed since bidenomics 😂
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
Completely agree on there being much better ways to use the money!
@yorbalindason
@yorbalindason 7 месяцев назад
All of the math may be true, but in the end, life is not a math problem. Otherwise Starbucks, eating out, new cars, fancy vacations and other “wastes of money” would not exist. I expect that you have never had a bottle of wine for more than 2 buck chuck at Trader Joe’s. At 57 my house of 30 years is hungry for $100,000 of repairs upgrades and renovations. So I agree, the math is not so clear on a home as an investment. My experience looking at suitable rental homes though is they are generally tired and kept in just good enough condition to be rentable. Is that the way you want to live? Just as someone shops for a Honda Accord (a $40,000 car anymore) over a cheaper Civic (I’m modeling most conservatively here) or choosing SUVs at all (less efficient hardly larger than a sedan), you make choices that play to your wants and needs, not the math. Add to that random life events such as the death of a spouse (yeah it sucks), kids moving out of state, inflation and general unaffordable rentals ($5,000/mo for a home here in So Cal) and who knows how your life would have turned out if you’d saved ALL your money and could admire a big number in a brokerage account. The example here assumes that every bit of money that you would have spent on a house is squirreled away investing to reap the harvest of compounding. The author makes a list of housing expenses but ignores the list of life expenses that your money might siphon off to if you rented. I’ve never met a dollar that didn’t tell me it was better used elsewhere. After saving all their life, people have another problem, feeling like they can spend the money they worked so hard to save. If your biggest mistake in life is having $3M at the end instead of $5M then you don’t have a lot of problems.
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
Thank you for your insights! I totally hear you on the point about there being other non-financial considerations. I actually think these weigh even more heavily to renting being the better option - but to each their own. I strongly disagree that $3M is the same as $5M. Someone with $5M net worth who doesn't own a home is a qualified purchaser. Someone with $3M is not. The types of investments a qualified purchaser can make and has access to and the returns on those investments is a whole new world. That can be the difference between financial freedom and not having financial freedom. Everyone is going to have expenses they don't expect in life - that is true whether you rent or own a home. I wasn't quite following your point about Trader Joe's wine. I don't drink so am not buying any wine. My apartment is quite suitable. If it weren't, I can assure you the maintenance team in my building would be here in less than an hour to fix whatever problems exist. You can't manage Class A apartments successfully otherwise.
@Pseudify
@Pseudify 12 дней назад
How would renting siphon off your money in ways that buying wouldn’t?
@benfranklin3638
@benfranklin3638 7 месяцев назад
I agree that home ownership as an investment is oversold…but….and a big but…when doing a comparison between long terms cost/benefit, I wish people would use realistic investment returns outside of real estate. The past 30 or so years we have had an unprecedented explosion that many doubt will continue as baby boomers retire and inflation soars. I’ve seen folks promoting renting use %12 returns as a risk free return in the market. I would like to see the comparison done with like a ~5% risk free return which is what many markets are paying now. And if the Fed lowers interest rates to fight a recession, that will be lower too.
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
I don't believe there is any investment that has a risk-free return. I definitely don't know how you would get 12% risk-free return. Even something like T-bills and govt bonds are not risk-free in my mind because you make returns that barely (if at all) keep up with inflation. I get your point - but getting an average of 10%+ returns is easy if you are willing to invest some time into learning how to invest your money yourself and not hand everything over to a financial advisor. This idea that you can't easily get 10%+ returns on average is a myth. With that said, everyone should model using their own returns based on their strategy. When I model for myself, I would be using a much higher return in the high teens because this is conservatively what I average every year. If you really are getting 5% returns on average, it might be time to reassess your investment approach because that is a really low rate of return.
@Pseudify
@Pseudify 12 дней назад
I suspect that if you limit your investment returns to 5% then you probably are better off buying.
@boyasia5874
@boyasia5874 7 месяцев назад
Homes are for raising a family... not for making money.. A home as investment is the secondary reason but not the primary. If one can afford to buy a home why not. It is an individual choice What is ingrained to peoples' mind is money money money...Making money lots of money which is wrong. In my opinion real estate works..Renting are for those who really can't buy a home, those who doesn't make enough. Would you be renting until retirement, not me. Home prices had been going up since time in memorial.. I know people who own 2,3 4 or even more. They live in one and rent the rest..
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
I would be happy to rent for the rest of my life. I don't have to worry about maintenance and repairs, lawncare, etc. Why would I buy a home when I can rent a home of the same value that I love and make a lot more money in the process? I recognize there are other non-financial considerations when it comes to rent vs. buy. But the point my video makes is that if your goal is to build wealth, buying a home too early can be a big mistake. I have owned vacation homes that were rental properties so that I turned a liability into an asset. That is a very different concept than what we are talking about here - which is putting a bunch of capital as a downpayment in a home that historically has had price increases that barely keep up with inflation (if that) even before you consider all the costs of maintaining the home.
@florianblondet1636
@florianblondet1636 5 месяцев назад
What is important is the usage of the home, not the ownership of the home. If you can use (rent) the same home & make more money over the LT, ok do it. Being a landlord is good for your ego and do well in society but it’s not what matters.
@Pseudify
@Pseudify 12 дней назад
Making lots of money is wrong? That’s an odd mindset that not many people share. Of course you can do what you want. But I would prefer to make lots of money so that me and my children and so on never feel like they MUST get a job just to eat.
@dee24298
@dee24298 2 месяца назад
Given how expensive NYC rents are now, do you think buying a home especially for folks in their mid-30s is still a bad idea (say, atleast 400k savings in the stock market)
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 2 месяца назад
I do. If building wealth and working towards financial freedom is your goal, I would never buy a home until I was a qualified purchaser and the down payment on the home wouldn't kick me out of qualified purchaser status.
@josephbsmithjr
@josephbsmithjr 7 месяцев назад
My home has increase 16% yoy since purchase.
@jcapitz
@jcapitz 4 месяца назад
Sharon drops facts and truth, but I’m here for the infinite new yorker rant against conventional wisdom 😂.
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 4 месяца назад
haha stay tuned for many more rants in the future! 😂😂
@polish2x91
@polish2x91 Месяц назад
If your home is going up 20% a year and your maintenance is 1% in not exactly sure how you’re hurting yourself
@williamarbelaez5382
@williamarbelaez5382 Месяц назад
Any products offered by the banks or the goverment is a RIPOFF like mortgages, loans, money management, subsidies etc. you'll pay dearly to pooverty.
@nohivega
@nohivega Месяц назад
Assuming you spend 44 000 a year on rent in 30 years you would have spend $1320 000. In rent. Is going to be more than that. How is it that it doesn't count. Or you did count it. I'm missing something? Ok. I got it! brilliant. Thank you.I had two replay it, to understand.
@samfurman8432
@samfurman8432 Месяц назад
I agree with her model did she figure in the interest that can be deduced on your tax return . this lower the income tax she will pay.
@mikep4869
@mikep4869 3 месяца назад
In 2052, you will have paid for two homes ($1,350,000 in mortgage payments).
@ELconomics101
@ELconomics101 7 месяцев назад
❤❤❤ Sharon
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 7 месяцев назад
😀
@rahulrane2075
@rahulrane2075 4 месяца назад
This should be taught to everyone in College!
@sharonwinsmith
@sharonwinsmith 4 месяца назад
Thank you! 😀
Далее
Why Most Financial Advisors Are a Scam
27:20
Просмотров 2 тыс.
Какую одежду я не ношу? 😱
00:13
Просмотров 453 тыс.
Renting vs Buying a Home: The Lie You’ve Been Told
24:50
Why You Should Stop Paying Down Your Mortgage
17:04
Просмотров 7 тыс.
NEVER Buy These Types of Houses
11:46
Просмотров 1,3 млн
Buy, Borrow, Die Tax Strategy: How to Repay the Loan
23:56
Why Everything We Are Taught About Finance is Wrong
19:32