Тёмный

Why Communism Hates Religion. 

All Things Humanities
Подписаться 24 тыс.
Просмотров 30 тыс.
50% 1

On social media, we often hear conversations about communism, how it killed millions of people and how it hated religion. Karl Marx, the father of communism once said that ‘Religion is the opium of the people’. He also thought that religion is the ‘sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world and the soul of soulless conditions. Marx thought that despite the suffering that comes from capitalism, religion provided an outlet to that suffering. People could worship deities and attempt to understand that their own sufferings originate from their own sinful lives.
Why on earth did the Communists hate religion so much that they burnt and closed down churches and mosques, enforced atheism in schools and sent priests into labour camps? This video is dedicated to understanding Why Communism Hates Religion.
Sources:
The ABC of Communism:
www.marxists.org/archive/bukh...
sphweb.bumc.bu.edu/otlt/mph-m...
education.nationalgeographic....
Das Kapital, Karl Marx
The Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx
John Anderson. The Council for Religious Affairs and the Shaping of Soviet Religious Policy. Soviet Studies, Vol. 43, No. 4 (1991), pp. 689-710
Father Arseny 1893-1973 Priest, Prisoner, Spiritual Father. Introduction pg. vi - 1. St Vladimir's Seminary Press ISBN 0-88141-180-9
Dimitry V. Pospielovsky. A History of Soviet Atheism in Theory, and Practice, and the Believer, vol 1: A History of Marxist-Leninist Atheism and Soviet Anti-Religious Policies, St Martin's Press, New York (1987) pg 46
N Vozenesensky, 'Imena i sud'by' and 'Materialy k istorii Akademii nauk', Pamiat', a historical miscellany of samizdat (respectively: no. 1, Moscow, 1976- New York: Kronika Press, 1978; and no. 4, M., 1979 - Paris: YMCA Press, 1981) pp. 353 and 459.
Helene Carrere d'Encausse, The National Republics Lose Their Independence, in Edward A. Allworth, (edit), Central Asia: One Hundred Thirty Years of Russian Dominance, A Historical Overview. Duke University Press, 1994.
www.hrw.org/legacy/campaigns/....
Marx, Karl. [1843] 1970. "Introduction." A Contribution to the Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, translated by A. Jolin and J. O’Malley, edited by J. O’Malley. Cambridge University Press. - via Marxists.org.

Опубликовано:

 

18 янв 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 474   
@vasilijrappana2335
@vasilijrappana2335 7 месяцев назад
No one likes competition.
@egrintarg230
@egrintarg230 20 часов назад
Not unless you are good at it. Then you love it.
@vylbird8014
@vylbird8014 Год назад
It's a bit of a generalisation. The thinkers who founded communism certainly opposed religion, as a general rule, and the early soviet union was intensely anti-religious. Up until the 1940s, anyway. As WW2 drove people towards religion as a source of comfort, government figures realised that religion was, regardless of any truth is may or may not hold, a useful tool - a way to give the state a deeper moral authority and make more loyal citizens. So the oppressed Russian Orthodox church was resurrected, brought under state control, and encouraged. The situation would reverse twice more before the soviet union fell - and in modern Russia, the state once again courts the church in a mutually beneficial arrangement. The church supports government positions, and receives state support in return. China takes a similar approach: They have government endorsed churches, but harshly punish non-approved religious organisations. Religion is fine, so long as it's under state control.
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 Год назад
Great points there!
@archravenineteenseventeen
@archravenineteenseventeen Год назад
Naaah religion should not be controlled by the state, the 2 should be separated
@jonjonboi3701
@jonjonboi3701 Год назад
@@archravenineteenseventeen No religion and the state should be together. Separating the two is a big mistake
@archravenineteenseventeen
@archravenineteenseventeen Год назад
@@jonjonboi3701 I'm fine with separating both
@mariussielcken
@mariussielcken 10 месяцев назад
​@@jonjonboi3701'give to the emperor what is the emperor's, and to God what is God's' Jesus was an early secularist.
@BeingHumane173
@BeingHumane173 14 дней назад
Q : Why communism hates religion ? Ans. : Because, communism itself is a religion. And almost all religions, covertly or overtly hates other religions.
@zachhiebert7926
@zachhiebert7926 3 месяца назад
"They Tried to end religion as they saw it as a tool of oppression"... that's the most ironic statment ever
@kitcloudkicker14
@kitcloudkicker14 2 месяца назад
Where's the lie tho? The reason the United States is the country with the biggest jewish population (apart from Israel) is due to the persecution they suffered from christians in Europe and they escaped to the very place that prohibited politicians to establish a national religion that could be used to persecute people not inside said religion like the jews. You would have a stroke when you find out how much catholics and traditional christians supported Hitler from Spain, to France and even to far Croatia and collaborated in the Holocaust and other atrocious massacres across Eastern Europe. Note that their supposed "moral and superior" religion didn't prevent them from committing violent or murderous acts against other human beings. Religions value autocracy, violence, fear and supremacy because the main objective of religions is to expand and effectively control all spheres of society, not to promote "god-given rights" to individuals, that's a bold lie made up by conservatives that ignore every single absolutist christian monachy and every dictatorship with a christian right wing dictator on top.
@craigchronicles5130
@craigchronicles5130 Год назад
Thanks for the content
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 Год назад
Hope you’re enjoying it! How long have you been a subscriber for?
@fkj6356
@fkj6356 6 месяцев назад
very informative man, thanks
@Rodluvan
@Rodluvan 2 месяца назад
70% of Russians described themselves as orthodox christians in a study from 2017, way more then western europe, dunno why u r sayin that there "barely are religious people left" in Russia
@GregorySmith-xq8yt
@GregorySmith-xq8yt Месяц назад
Soviet Russia is no fan of Karl Marks… think about it.
@NatTurner328
@NatTurner328 24 дня назад
@@GregorySmith-xq8ytTF are you talking about?
@acercandonosadios3723
@acercandonosadios3723 8 месяцев назад
“The book of Genesis was written to alíviate the suffering of the Jews in Babylon” - you lost me right there. By the time Jews arrived to Babylon they already had a doctrine of atonement and sacrifices for sin. Which is unmistakably taken out of the Law to include Genesis of course.
@heyyou1366
@heyyou1366 7 месяцев назад
Yeah, I guess Moses was alive at the Babylon captivity.
@acercandonosadios3723
@acercandonosadios3723 7 месяцев назад
I don’t think you understood the argument that I just presented you. By the time the Jews arrived to Babylon they already had a full blown doctrine of atonement worked out and that comes straight from the Law. Not to mention that the book of Judges also asumes the background of the Law. Also Ezra, Nehemiah and Daniel all mentions Moses by name. There is zero evidence that none of these guys knew Moses personally at the time of captivity. The whole reason and explanation that the Biblical writer give for the captivity of Israel is precisely because Israel forsook the ancient Law, which requieres that the Law existed BEFORE the captivity to Babylon.
@willemvanstaden3292
@willemvanstaden3292 3 месяца назад
1stly Genesis was written by Moses - a Hebrew, NOT an Jew. The Kingdoms of Yehudah and Yashar'El were inhabited by Israelites - NOT Jews. The Edomites who converted to Talmudic Judaism are what you people call "Jews". Jews are descended from Esau and not Jacob, as we Israelites are. Today's Jew-state is inhabited by a mixture of different peoples - even some actual Israelites.
@Jamhael1
@Jamhael1 Месяц назад
Until the Captivity of Babylon, the Torah was all oral.
@acercandonosadios3723
@acercandonosadios3723 26 дней назад
@@Jamhael1 That makes no sense. Please read my arguments presented before in this thread. in the entire corpus of the Old Testament whenever the Torah is mentioned, is mentioned as codified and written, not as a loosely code that lives in an oral tradition. Remember , just because we don't have a manuscript of a document prior of a particular date, that does not means that there were not other copies of that very same manuscripts circulating before that particular date. And yet, we do have verses of the Torah in pots of clays that predates the Captivity.
@sophiaiftakar533
@sophiaiftakar533 Месяц назад
When there is no state or police or law and order because of some catastrophic event. There is always God. When you are alone and have no food to eat, there is God. When your love one passes away, there is God. The bottom line is, no matter what happens to you, what travesty takes place, you will always have God. He is your comfort in all things. The Holy Spirit will fill your heart with joy even when you are at the worst of your life! Never forget that!
@owretchedguy07
@owretchedguy07 День назад
Religion does not alleviate personal suffering. Religion only promotes one's own advancement in a free society.
@projectbirdfeederman5491
@projectbirdfeederman5491 9 месяцев назад
But it's great slave control... religious / spiritiual people do nothing to oppose tyranny, as they just sit there meditating or waiting on their saviour to return and do the hard work for them. Perfect for the abusers in power. New Age is the same, they're trying to manifest their way out of this mess, or boost on up to the 5DLand. It's cringe.
@nem900
@nem900 2 месяца назад
Religions are not pacifist and it’s proven by some of it telling its followers to “spread the word and news”. Well some do beleive that their leader’s actions are “God’s will” but the catholic church did help Jews from Hitler and the Greek Orthodox Monks of Mounth Athos did the same by hiding them.
@Moses_VII
@Moses_VII Месяц назад
You think religious people don't oppose tyranny? You know nothing about the Twelver Shia, the only religion which matters, because it's the only religion which really achieved anything in human history, especially in modern history.
@chrisgavin2794
@chrisgavin2794 Месяц назад
Because god isnt god. The state is god. There ya go
@Maria-gv9ot
@Maria-gv9ot 9 месяцев назад
The fact that karl marx(the father of communism)was German i wonder how he will react to Germany in world war 1 and 2
@novinceinhosic3531
@novinceinhosic3531 8 месяцев назад
Was is not the father of communism, since there are communist thinkers who predate him with nearly a century. As for Germany in the two world-wars... he'd not be surprised about the development of Germany.
@commissarmax4832
@commissarmax4832 8 месяцев назад
Like every marxist - it was capitalists wars.
@_Mr.Tuvok_
@_Mr.Tuvok_ 10 месяцев назад
I think Marx was right about religion being born of suffering, but he had the source of the suffering wrong. Religion offers relief from the suffering of existence-no social advance can alleviate that entirely.
@lisalatham4389
@lisalatham4389 9 месяцев назад
Do you have the writing where I can find that ?
@novinceinhosic3531
@novinceinhosic3531 8 месяцев назад
The suffering that you are alive?
@alexjames6747
@alexjames6747 8 месяцев назад
No. The suffering introduced by religion. @@novinceinhosic3531
@reiismycope
@reiismycope 7 месяцев назад
​@@novinceinhosic3531life always contain suffering. It is impossible to live without suffering. That's something that philosophers like Schopenhauer realized
@novinceinhosic3531
@novinceinhosic3531 7 месяцев назад
@@reiismycope that's his opinion.
@TerryTappArt
@TerryTappArt 5 месяцев назад
I thought communism was an ideology which advocated workers owned the means of production as Marx wrote, not that the state owned them. Maybe the other Marx wrote that, his brother Jimmy? An religion means many things, many different religions, for instance. Was this video created from school notes?
@mrsentencename7334
@mrsentencename7334 4 месяца назад
A state is a politically organised group on a piece of territory. If the socialised man collectively rise up and seize the factory off the private owner (the governor), they become the government of the factory, plural. The public is society and society is the state, that's why it's called the public sector. It's doing nothing more than transferring private control to public control. Social control or state control of the means of production who in turn control the public sector hierarchy of the society. Its just an excuse to steal stuff and implement totalitarian control.
@NatTurner328
@NatTurner328 24 дня назад
That’s socialism. Communism also involves everyone being assigned material goods based solely on their needs
@robokou
@robokou 7 месяцев назад
This is like asking, _"Why Atheism Hates Religion"._
@ubuntuposix
@ubuntuposix 6 месяцев назад
"Why Spirituality doesn't need Religion". Because Spirituality fills that void that religion used to fill.
@robokou
@robokou 5 месяцев назад
@ubuntuposix , "religion" is essentially mass-produced spirituality, but spirituality nonetheless. Without the guidance of a superior spirituality, "spirituality" _is_ the void.
@ubuntuposix
@ubuntuposix 5 месяцев назад
@@robokou Spirituality doesn't mean a greedy person asking for personal benefits and then an afterlife.. Its when you identify with people, putting yourself in their shoes, that's when you're more than your own person..you're spiritual. Religion is made for greedy, unspiritual people. They bribe them with candy in heaven and every good deed they do, its for their own benefit bc they think there's a god up there who notices and gives rewards.
@robokou
@robokou 5 месяцев назад
@ubuntuposix, _all_ things are spiritual-PERIOD. There's nothing that isn't spiritual because Spirit surrounds all of existence like an inescapable wall. 💯 That said, religion is merely a vessel for someone else's spirituality to carry the spiritualities of others-like a crutch or other support system. If your spirituality doesn't even allow you to see that all things are spiritual-"God" aside-then clearly your spirituality has failed you. 💯
@ubuntuposix
@ubuntuposix 5 месяцев назад
@@robokou Religion hates other religions and has always gone to war for its monopoly. So your argument of "caryying the spiritualities of others" goes off the window. Also you can't equate everything with spirituality. That's like equating with sh!t.. "see this piece of sh!t? this is spiritual.. as spiritual as Budda or Jesus".. Spirituality is something special..that humans CAN have. Not rocks.. Rocks cannot be spiritual.. otherwise again I can equate Jesus with a piece o sh!t..
@Vayu_Aksh
@Vayu_Aksh 2 месяца назад
Religion have no right to exist in the world you can be religious without following a religion -osho
@PirateRadioPodcasts
@PirateRadioPodcasts 8 месяцев назад
A - b/c It doesn't like COMPETITION. Doh!
@Hiphopdatruthnohate
@Hiphopdatruthnohate Год назад
Just work with each other and be all wealthy . But ignorance, envy, jealous, fear keeps us apart like dumb f***s.
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 Год назад
Well said!
@kippgoeden
@kippgoeden 9 месяцев назад
Greed keeps us apart. When working people are unable to support themselves and billionaires own multiple homes off the backs of our labor, it isn’t envy. It’s truth.
@saintsone7877
@saintsone7877 9 месяцев назад
@@kippgoeden Yes, but socialism/communism gives real equality - everyone is equally poor(except of course the ruling party participants).I cannot believe people have over the ages loved Marx etc for advocating different versions of the very thing they claim they are replacing. And of course it is all for the common good of people. Either way the majority become the slaves of the minority whatever coat you dress it up in. I am not a lover of capitalism but it walks all over the other isms in that your destiny can be determined by you yourself whereas in all the other systems YOU are the SLAVE 100% of the ruling class/system and you have little opportunity to make a life of your own choosing. YOU MUST CONFORM whereas Capitalism allows you (within the context of the laws of the land) to be your own master. And as stated as much as I dislike capitalism I despise the alternatives even more so. Anyone with any intelligence would unless they believe they will be amongst the rulers of their ideal system. Until man/women develops to the point where he/she has no ambition except to obey a master NO alternate system to Capitalism is even contemplatable. ALL other systems rely on dictators and obeyance. Any independence of thought is punishable by re-education or death. Hardly enticing ideals.
@70AD-user45
@70AD-user45 9 месяцев назад
​@@kippgoeden Marxism /socialism had been rejected by every nation that it's gained a foothold in. It's an evil ideology that crushes the will of people to thrive, compete, and better themselves by claiming, "all employees should be equal". This goes against human nature to compete in the free market which is an economic system that has been embraced by the world. Marxists see the state as god which is partly why they hate and have persecuted Christians. ✝️
@matterasmachine
@matterasmachine Год назад
Is it possible to get to your channel with my own "god"? Is there way to contact you?
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 Год назад
Hey, what do you mean?
@matterasmachine
@matterasmachine Год назад
@@allthingshumanities5328 Probably nothing that makes sense. I have a possible theory of everything (partially) and just posted what god would mean in this this theory - simple discrete machine. So I search for ways to show it to the world. But probably you post about "old" gods only.
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 Год назад
If you’d like, email me at thinkinguniversity1@gmail.com
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 Год назад
How are you finding the content?
@matterasmachine
@matterasmachine Год назад
@@allthingshumanities5328 You mean my content? It's my "theory". I find it by "investigating the world".
@daskritterhaus5491
@daskritterhaus5491 7 месяцев назад
capitalism is at its worst, horrible. communism at its worst, is very deadly for millions. take yer pick.
@tommy5456
@tommy5456 6 месяцев назад
capitalism kills people every day....
@mek101whatif7
@mek101whatif7 6 месяцев назад
3.2 billions dead under capitalism. Another youtuber did the math
@eu_bebo_oleo
@eu_bebo_oleo 6 месяцев назад
@@mek101whatif7 who
@NatTurner328
@NatTurner328 24 дня назад
@@eu_bebo_oleoEverybody affected by European imperialism, under the banner of capitalism.
@eu_bebo_oleo
@eu_bebo_oleo 24 дня назад
@@NatTurner328 no, who asked 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸💪💪💪🦅🦅🦅🛢️🛢️🛢️
@khfan4life365
@khfan4life365 9 месяцев назад
It hates religion because the rulers want to be the only gods the people worship. Unfortunately for them, the true God will always beat them.
@optimus3515
@optimus3515 2 месяца назад
If God asks to kill non believers then it is better to not follow such god.
@blue_wolfproductions12
@blue_wolfproductions12 2 месяца назад
Amen
@harryscristianvieri7916
@harryscristianvieri7916 Месяц назад
What tue God by the way? He never make himself being visible to us. So, what kind of "God"
@serecmoon
@serecmoon 12 дней назад
Does He have to? A. Is no because you can know his existence just by looking at His creations.​@@harryscristianvieri7916
@kimchiwasabee
@kimchiwasabee 2 месяца назад
"The state is god." The rulers may not say it explicitly,but that's what they want us to feel. See also:" fascism. Idolatry of the state." by James Lindsay,here on YT.
@nyx2875
@nyx2875 4 месяца назад
It hates competition
@andrewreynolds912
@andrewreynolds912 6 месяцев назад
is it maybe possible that religion and communism could possibly peacefully coexist without all the horrible inequalities, relying on gods, and more including not having the horrible stuff it's done and such in religions history?
@KnownNiche1999
@KnownNiche1999 3 месяца назад
Atheist regimes did a lot more evil in shorter time frames than religious ones could dream of
@covenawhite4855
@covenawhite4855 21 день назад
There has been communist religious groups The Diggers in America The Khibatz in Israel The Hutterites in Canada
@_theaxiom
@_theaxiom 10 месяцев назад
Yall wont look into Moses Hess though who helped form this hatred for Religion, due to his connection to Zionsim: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-bVWp1_JMmak.html
@TheProphetMonk
@TheProphetMonk 21 день назад
This is what the Freedom From Religion Foundation wants to do in the United States. When it happens, I’d be honored to be the Protomartyr. ☦️
@gorgamantos249
@gorgamantos249 7 месяцев назад
1:07 "while communism is a political and economic system that aims to create a classless society, where the means of production is owned by the state[...]" clicked on the video because I have been very curious specifically about the religious aspects of communism. here, very early in the video, the creator already fundamentally misinterprets the whole communist ideology. "owned by the state"? yes, this is what happened in the hands of Stalin, but anyone who has done any form of communist analysis of the USSR would know Stalin did MANY things outside of communism to take control for his own leadership. communism, in its most basic form, is to give power TO THE PEOPLE. the means of production to be owned by the WORKERS, not the state. if you, the creator, sees this, just know this is merely constructive critisism. i understand you would want to create these types of videos when you have done research upon a topic, but I would suggest diving deeper before doing so. that's the whole reason you would be more qualified to make a video, in comparison to viewers who just make a quick google search. if you do the same, you actively harm movements aspiring to help by spreading misinformation
@cxarhomell5867
@cxarhomell5867 2 месяца назад
You just proved that communism cannot ever work according to your response. By saying that people like Stalin attempted to apply communism to where they ruled and failed to do so is evidence of that. For the means of production to be owned and regulated by the workers would be socialism, not communism. Thank you for verifying the unrealistic approach of communism.
@robertcarpenter7486
@robertcarpenter7486 5 месяцев назад
There is no 100% correct way to figure our way out of this mess.
@Gilbert.Suhendra
@Gilbert.Suhendra 5 месяцев назад
it's fact
@MAHAMADAMAHAMADA-wb2ep
@MAHAMADAMAHAMADA-wb2ep 9 месяцев назад
OWN HUMAN INVENTION TEACHING
@Javier-zg3sv
@Javier-zg3sv 2 месяца назад
I can’t fucking defend this shit anymore
@chriskappert1365
@chriskappert1365 Год назад
They hate competition .
@Alireza_farhoudi
@Alireza_farhoudi Год назад
That's right motherfucker
@GearZNet
@GearZNet 10 месяцев назад
Basically 😂. The state is to be your God, your parents, your lover. The state is your all, your one and only.
@Anarchist_syndicalist
@Anarchist_syndicalist 8 месяцев назад
​@@GearZNetcommunism is moneyless ,classless, stateless society
@kitcloudkicker14
@kitcloudkicker14 2 месяца назад
@@GearZNet You are speaking as if right wingers or christians never ever used the state to impose their own agendas. You have tons of absolutist monarchies, colonial empires and right wing dictatorships across history that disprove the idea that "right wingers are all about individual freedoms and small government"
@Whateverxo56
@Whateverxo56 5 месяцев назад
Simple answer. It oppresses people.
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 5 месяцев назад
True.
@miladmoradi9987
@miladmoradi9987 3 месяца назад
I think it is extremely ironic how you of all people say this. But I'll humor you.
@danielkingsley7142
@danielkingsley7142 6 месяцев назад
The Communist belief of denying people The Right to religion is ridiculous And not right, I am a Utopian which means I believe in Utopianism a new Ideology that stands against Communism For we Utopians Strongly believe in and Support The right to freedom of religion Forever one in the world But we do Support the separation between church and state And we only support religions that believe in good and stands against evil And therefore we do not support evil Cults And we Utopians plan to destroy them For the common good of the human race.
@ronald.pickering
@ronald.pickering 10 месяцев назад
'You'll own nothing, (have no God, nation, or family) and you'll be happy', because we say say so.
@kippgoeden
@kippgoeden 9 месяцев назад
You are mistaking, as communism allows for personal property. What you quoted is our future under capitalism.
@saintsone7877
@saintsone7877 9 месяцев назад
@@kippgoeden No. Those proposing this are avowed Communists/Socialists. But they can only bring this in by controlling Capitalism which is where I suspect you get the impression it is Capitalistic thinking. Under Communism NOTHING belongs to you as EVERYTHING belongs to the state. You simply have the use of it till the state wants it back. I remember the Russian Heavyweight Weight Lifter who broke World record after World record and was given by the state houses, cars etc each time he broke said records. When he finally got to the age a younger lifter beat him ALL houses and cars etc were striped from him and slowly given to his successors. Were you correct he would have retained at least one house car etc. He ended up suiciding as was living in the street as had no qualifications and his weight without training daily prevented him from working a normal job. Under Capitalism there is ALWAYS the opportunity to make a mark no matter your birth status. ALL other systems condemn the vast majority to servitude of the elite ruling classes.
@projectbirdfeederman5491
@projectbirdfeederman5491 9 месяцев назад
but if you own nothing then there's less material stuff to distract you from god... and the McBug burger with flies is going to entice us to fast and be a good spiritual slave.
@BuddhistRaffaele
@BuddhistRaffaele 5 дней назад
That's Also The Goal Of Buddhism but For different Reasons of Course
@rgx0015
@rgx0015 Месяц назад
In my opinion communism goes against human nature and the laws of nature, with humans there is always this thing that comes up in the minds of people that is the "what if" "what if things were different". I think its natural for humans to engage in hierarchys much like all the other animals on earth. The problem i have with communism is its against people being farmers and being able to forage from nature and distribute it ourselves to our families. Wether people wanna believe it or not people seem to be designed to prioritize their family and bloodline over others even if it is on a subtle level. Lemme know what yall think
@BuddhistRaffaele
@BuddhistRaffaele 5 дней назад
In Those sense Communism it's Very Similar To Buddhism But In Buddhism You do It Because You Want To Get a Better Next Life or Achieve Nirvana In Communism you do It For No Particolar Reason that's why it's failed
@ninga926
@ninga926 4 дня назад
Communism is the only doctrine that respects human nature: cooperation and communal prosperity opposed to the thriving of the one. Hierarchys are natural and good if done in a more liquid matter: creating and dismantling hierarchys according to the specific needs of the situation, something communism isn't against. The problem arises when hierarchys are taken as absolutes and never thought critically: eteronomy. Communism dosen't deal about this directly, but a passage from the German Ideology talks about the capacity for humans in the communist society to be fishermen, farmers, criticizers and in general have a more universal approach to human experiences. That said, the family is already part of society and cannot be treated as an isolated unit. People are designed to value and prioritize those who they have either an emotional connection or those who they are indoctrinated to prioritize. Communism simply makes us able to value, respect and prioritize not only who we know, but also other people. Be more empathetyc and communal.
@missypead2293
@missypead2293 3 месяца назад
Sounds like whats going on here.
@sherryqiang0917
@sherryqiang0917 Год назад
As a Chinese convert Muslim,I understand both ,you can say communism is a ideal institution even Islamic requires the peaceful country it should be ,I still think Islam is included communism ,but actually modern Muslim can’t do it well ,tolerant pain rely on Allah to change ,don’t against oppressor ,but communist are doing a lots of practical things ,want to change by themselves ,after that Allah will help them more ,communist are more brave to against capitalists,I just wish modern Muslim can be as good as 1400 years ago ,to prove Islam is best ,don’t keep misunderstanding on others
@mariussielcken
@mariussielcken 10 месяцев назад
Sharia is not peace. Quran denies the Crucefixion, Death and Resurrection of Jesus, so it is anti-Christ. According to Islam in the endtimes the true jesus will fight against the false jesus. Islam is the false jesus.
@explorer8851
@explorer8851 8 месяцев назад
China oppressing Uyghur muslims
@commissarmax4832
@commissarmax4832 8 месяцев назад
Aren't you grown up enough not to believe fairy tales?
@user-ri1ti6go7s
@user-ri1ti6go7s 8 месяцев назад
If we all could be the best version of ourselves acting with deeds if kindness and words of care to each other what a wonderful place the world would be. We all can hope, act for this to make it real. And there are some special people in the world, our everyday lives. Not necessarily great religious or political figures.
@xS146roar
@xS146roar 7 месяцев назад
​@@commissarmax4832 And you are believing in communism ?
@fortunatomartino9797
@fortunatomartino9797 Год назад
It closed down churches and mosques But not Synagogues? Who founded communism
@eduardorosales5042
@eduardorosales5042 11 месяцев назад
Karl Marx and he was Anti Jewish
@GearZNet
@GearZNet 10 месяцев назад
Did the social planners get the memo? 🤔@@eduardorosales5042
@JohnathanWilliamson849
@JohnathanWilliamson849 10 месяцев назад
@@eduardorosales5042 Karl Marx was Jewish. So was Frederick Engles and apparently Lenin had Jewish heritage.
@user-ck5pc3vh5n
@user-ck5pc3vh5n 8 месяцев назад
There is a supposed fact that Stalin persecuted Jewish inteligentsia since he thought of them as being pro-Western spies which were planning to murder him (this is known as the Doctor's Plot). But let's be honest: the main statistic (About 90%) of the Cheka was irreligious Jews, and they hated Christian Russians in general. Some people can call me a "wingnat", but IF Lenin had comrades like Trotsky (Bronstein) or Kamen'sky (ethnic Jews), they would seem to give reasonable suspicion to me.
@BuddhistRaffaele
@BuddhistRaffaele 5 дней назад
It's persecuted every religion but Jews and Buddhist were a Small Minority in Russia compared to Christians and Muslims Also Many Jews were not religious and Buddhism It's more Similar To Communism than Christianity or Islam so They Persecuted More The Problematic Part of The Religions of Russia
@Gvprtskvni
@Gvprtskvni 2 месяца назад
Because Communism is a religion and they don’t want competition.
@baronghede2365
@baronghede2365 Месяц назад
"I Want To Detrone 'God' And Destroy Capitalism" (Karl Marx) Blessed Be.
@alexzen751
@alexzen751 7 месяцев назад
becuase it's also a religion
@lethanhminh8001
@lethanhminh8001 9 месяцев назад
Because it is a religion. It doesnt want competition
@tanmoynath2688
@tanmoynath2688 6 месяцев назад
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@llamagames6803
@llamagames6803 4 месяца назад
I beg to differ, watch lady izdihar islam and communism
@juanbarbosa1405
@juanbarbosa1405 Год назад
ok, genesis being written during the time of the babylonian exile. you are smoking a fact stack my man and makes me call into question everything you said :(
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 Год назад
Sorry! My mistake.. was supposed to say during Egyptian slavery. Correct me if I’m wrong.
@juanbarbosa1405
@juanbarbosa1405 Год назад
@@allthingshumanities5328 it was most likely written during the exodus in the time that they were in the dessert for 40 years and it was most likely written by Moses. Point is, that whatever credibility you're trying to build comes into question with little mistakes like this, please be more careful going forward.
@leonardobuitrago7161
@leonardobuitrago7161 Год назад
@@juanbarbosa1405 it is universally accepted among scholars that Moses didn't exist, the egyptian slavery period didn't occur and the hebrews always lived in Canaan. Also most books of the old testament were all written or refined during the exile in Babylon. They needed a powerful foundation myth during those difficult years
@juanbarbosa1405
@juanbarbosa1405 Год назад
@@leonardobuitrago7161 hahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahagaga
@ionelflorea2116
@ionelflorea2116 Год назад
@@juanbarbosa1405 sorry but history shows no proof for the foundation myth of the Hebrews
@johnm7267
@johnm7267 Год назад
Communism doesn’t hate religion but realises that religion is “ the opium of the people “ much like football etc. when I lived in England there was much discussion on the decline of religion. This was during the years of the USSR. There was a documentary on the BBC about this and a prominent Bishop went to Russia to look at religion under Soviet rule. He went to a church In Moscow and was astounded at the beauty of the church, which was packed with worshippers. He asked the head honcho where did they get the money to maintain the church and he said the government. The bishop said he would give any thing to see those numbers in a church in England and have the money to maintain the churches. So another lie was exposed about Russia and communism. Certainly religion was discouraged and I should think not taught in schools, but you can hardly call not teaching something brain washing. I am not trying to argue that everything was alright between church and state in Russia, just that we were being lied to about certain things in Russia just as we are today. In El Salvador 6 Catholic priests were shot dead by gangs sponsored by the govt and the Vatican remained silent
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 Год назад
It’s a fair point, John! Thanks for your input!
@Animalis_Mundana
@Animalis_Mundana Год назад
Religion is an ideology, one of many. He forgot to mention these noble atheists tortured and murdered anyone who didn't fall in line with their dictatorship which basically was God as the state. Socialist believe in communism with a cult like fanaticism. As an ideology with its adherents and "theories."
@jonjonboi3701
@jonjonboi3701 Год назад
No communism does dislike religion
@kimberlypalmera3558
@kimberlypalmera3558 Год назад
​@@jonjonboi3701 Tell that to the people who disappeared in Nicaragua or the countless burns to our churches. I agree with what's being told and teaches about communism and church, but this would be the case in Russia and China... because over here, in the American continent, situation shows harsh and sad.stuff. No tolerance at all
@ihl0700677525
@ihl0700677525 Год назад
1. _"There was a documentary on the BBC.. a prominent Bishop went to.. went to a church (in USSR).. (where) the head honcho said.. that the (Soviet) government (pay for the maintenance) of the church"_ Are you arguing that because Soviet government build/pay for the maintenance of a beautiful church in Russia, therefore Lenin's, Stalin's, and Khrushchev's persecution against Orthodox church was not true? It is more likely that USSR closed/repurposed/demolished 100 churches for any single one they choose to keep for propaganda purpose. Those anti-religious policies are well documented, including in various publications during Soviet time (as mentioned in this video). 2. _"Certainly religion was discouraged and I should think not taught in schools, but you can hardly call not teaching something brain washing."_ Soviet commies created a educational programs to ridicule and attack religion/religious beliefs. They were actively anti-religion, *NOT* just passively atheist. 3. _"In El Salvador 6 Catholic priests were shot dead by gangs sponsored by the govt and the Vatican remained silent"_ How's this even related to or somehow proves that there was no persecution against religion in Soviet Union??
@Polit_Burro
@Polit_Burro 3 месяца назад
"communism" doesn't "hate" religion. "Communism" is a theory, and is incapable of "hatred." Certain communists may hate religion, but the attitude, ior theory of communism regards religion as an "opiate" - or distraction - a consolation for workers who are oppressed by Capital and who, having no escape, find an imaginary "escape" in the belief in an afterlife -a "big rock candy mountain" where all of the things they are denied on eareth and in life are granted to them. Communists who are actually cognizant of theory are more akin to public health-workers who are trying to control the spread of STDs - we don't hate the disease, or look down on those who are infeected, we simply want to cure the disease and eliminate the conditions under which it proliferates. I hoipe this helps.
@cxarhomell5867
@cxarhomell5867 2 месяца назад
Communism advocates for state atheism to be strictly followed in the government and for religious activity to be cracked down on. By your brief explanation on communism attitude against religion and its alleged effects on the population, you verified that policy. In any situation with a lockdown or an epidemic or a pandemic, communism would undoubtedly make the situation worse.
@Polit_Burro
@Polit_Burro 2 месяца назад
@@cxarhomell5867 Marx merely suggested that religion was a cheap substitute for, and a diversion from building socialism. Read Marx and Engels, starting with Das Capital, Vol. 1 in which they discuss commodity fetishism. Religion is a symptom of the problem, not the problem itself, which is capitalist exploitation. Religion only seeks to justify the exploitation and pacify the populace. The Communists opposed religion on purely practical grounds for theh same reasons that they opposed drug and alcohol abuse. But they didn't blame drugs or alcohol abuse for the social problems caused by capitalist exploitation.
@vlndfee6481
@vlndfee6481 5 месяцев назад
How the west is down the same path.... hellfire
@pastorpresent7774
@pastorpresent7774 7 месяцев назад
Religion has declined in most countries in recent times, not just former soviet countries.
@donjindra
@donjindra Год назад
It doesn't hate religion. It _is_ a religion.
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 Год назад
Explain
@donjindra
@donjindra Год назад
@@allthingshumanities5328 I doubt you're unfamiliar with the concept: Nikolai Berdyaev, Walter Benjamin, religiously motivated communistic communes, Marx writings as sacred scripture, etc. For a good overview there is Murray N. Rothbard's "Karl Marx: Communist as Religious Eschatologist."
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 Год назад
@@donjindra I’ll check it out! Thanks Don!
@acbacbacbacbacb
@acbacbacbacbacb Год назад
communism is atheism
@keatonmccarthy8677
@keatonmccarthy8677 11 месяцев назад
True
@m.k.muhammedfazil2675
@m.k.muhammedfazil2675 7 месяцев назад
I am from Kerala and I like the idea of Communism and Max's ideas have influenced me a lot but when Max talks about religion he says that all religions are the same. He only looked at Europe and it was not the same as in Europe. If he had looked at that one thing in Asia he would never have said that while admitting that Communism is a failure and saying that the only idea in the world that opposes empire is Communism and Islam. That's why I am a communist and a Muslim.
@Jesus_Christ_loves_you_alot
@Jesus_Christ_loves_you_alot 7 месяцев назад
Hi there! Jesus Christ loves you. He is the only way to heaven. With Him you'll never be truly lonely. He is the best friend you can have. May God bless you! 😊 Jesus says to you today: “Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest." -Matthew 11:28
@zhengjy5401
@zhengjy5401 6 месяцев назад
Lol, he would rather be a christian
@ashranbakth5861
@ashranbakth5861 5 месяцев назад
Islam goes against communism. You don’t worship the one and only communist leader, only Allah. Whoever goes toward communism is basically embracing the dajjal.
@jameslabs1
@jameslabs1 Год назад
whatever.
@JohnathanWilliamson849
@JohnathanWilliamson849 10 месяцев назад
*tips fedora*
@sergesiweck1825
@sergesiweck1825 7 месяцев назад
religion nin komunisem is quit simple. headshots compet numeries, elements compet situations, period.
@HegemonicMarxism
@HegemonicMarxism 28 дней назад
There are some inacuracies in your commentary, which seems rather biased. Communism calls for the means of production to be owned by the working class, not the state, necessarily. The State can be used to advance socialist goals or as a mechanism to represent the interests of the proletariate rather than the bourgeoise, as is the case in capitalist societies. Marx didn't believe that "the state owning the means of production would alleviate all suffering", but that would be a necessary step in the improvment of material conditions of the people by easing the exploitative conditions to which workers are subjected to. You didn't explain how "religion undermines people's loyalty to the party or the state". On the contrary, religion could be a useful tool to promote obedience and justify the authority of the state, which is what religion is used for in any state. Organised religion is a tool for social control that works to justify state power. The reason Communism rejects religion is not because "it fears alternatives" or because it undermines it necessarily, but for ideological reasons. You cannot liberate the people without dismanteling the old delusions of the past.
@militantmick
@militantmick 3 месяца назад
Communism is none religious and was not anti religious Stalinism was anti religious
@cxarhomell5867
@cxarhomell5867 2 месяца назад
Communism advocates for a policy of irreligion and state atheism. It is anti religious.
@mrsentencename7334
@mrsentencename7334 4 месяца назад
because it is a religion. The original title of the manifesto was the communist confession of faith. He's just a deceitful weasel
@SatyanarayanaNandury-ih9ks
@SatyanarayanaNandury-ih9ks 6 месяцев назад
Any 'ism' including Communism thrives on one God - one Gospel theory. For Communists Marx is the Prophet. 'Isms' are intolerant towards any discussions or questioning of the doctrines. The 'ism' promotes those who blindly follow them and punishes those who don't. Such concepts stifle creativity & intelligence and finally lead to Bigotry. Sanatana Dharma is Not an 'ism'. It welcomes discussions, questioning, and never castigates those who oppose it.
@llamagames6803
@llamagames6803 4 месяца назад
No, that's just wrong, let's talk about it
@aaronosrs
@aaronosrs Год назад
The reading that Marx hated religion and its influence is really wrong. There is really no reading of Marx without the general understanding of monotheism - as without Monotheism, there is no Marxism/M-L, its a fundamental aspect of Marx's ideas. For Marx, the highest insight of philosophy relates back to the lowest reality of humanity - they both belong to one common reality, this is otherwise known as Marxist humanism. If you read into Marx without that context, especially when reading his critiques of Hegel, nothing makes sense. Religions aren't about dogmatic beliefs in supernatural objects - the language religion uses to express its ideas are purely ontological. It's a way in which theology and philosophy can give expression to our reality in a more fundamental way. For example, the word God isn't supposed to represent multiple supernatural realities with human characteristics, but rather just being. As to why some communist thinkers/politicians specifically opposed the positive public influence of religion, that is a completely new discussion and one that warrants a lot more research into the core beliefs of those individuals - many of which had not even read Marx in the first place. (That is not to say that all of the communist leaders opposed religion, Stalin for example was fond of Islam's philosophical and metaphysical views).
@sheesh--boi268
@sheesh--boi268 7 месяцев назад
As a Sharia-Communist, I can say that this person has not read the book properly (if he even did read), In Karl Marx's book, it said "Religion is the opium of people" then he did not say that religion is bad or something, Karl Marx is not that stupid to just say that and the next sentence is different to that. And my advice to not search anything about Communism on google or any American site, as it spreads capitalist thoughts so people can avoid Communism, ask a pro Communist who has read Karl Marx's book.
@tommy5456
@tommy5456 6 месяцев назад
"sharia-communist"... really? religion is pure idealism, it crashes with the materialistic views of Marxism.
@Rodluvan
@Rodluvan 2 месяца назад
Simple, communism and religion aint got nothin to do with each other. You can be a christian communist aswell as a atheist capitalist.
@Phuwanggg
@Phuwanggg 4 месяца назад
Soviet union better thann alll religion
@DREADNOUGHT-se6fp
@DREADNOUGHT-se6fp 22 дня назад
Cry harder
@Hitman-206
@Hitman-206 26 дней назад
I just saw your video on Islam “satanic verses” and you turned off the comments. Your whole video was based on lies disrespecting the religion. You taken small verses about the pagan gods in ancient Arabia and put your own narrative not allowing viewers to have full context. You sound educated but you are a clear liar that ruins your whole credibility.
@allthingshumanities5328
@allthingshumanities5328 26 дней назад
I turned off the comments because I was being abused and a lot of the comments were not constructive. You can check my source for the video if you’d like. I didn’t make any of it up.
@Hitman-206
@Hitman-206 26 дней назад
@@allthingshumanities5328 did you not think to verify the source? Have you not read the chapter of the verse to gain context and to get the interpretation and meaning of the verse? There is no evidence that prophet Muhammad (saw) has praised or worshipped any other god. Your aim is to “educate on history, philosophy, religion and politics, but based on your video you have a biased agenda or too naive to talk on any subject. If you can give me your source that would be great (if you can find it).
@artemshevtsov6062
@artemshevtsov6062 18 дней назад
Because there can be no one else to follow but the party There is no other god than the great leader. Stalin Ho-chi-min Mao Pol pot Lennin Castro
@joshfriesen1981
@joshfriesen1981 3 месяца назад
Religion brings together under a common belief and goal whereas communism separates and makes people aimless and listless under no higher beliefs.
@polyseed12
@polyseed12 3 месяца назад
Opposite. Not even Christians amongst themselves are united. There are over 40,000 different variations of Christianity.
@haraldsamak9494
@haraldsamak9494 2 месяца назад
Then why people nowadays kill each other for the sake of religion??
@BuddhistRaffaele
@BuddhistRaffaele 5 дней назад
Well Racial Segregation was Made By White Protestant Christians..... So Even Christians are Not So Good
@watchtowerremembers167
@watchtowerremembers167 2 месяца назад
"Means of production owned by the state". I'll clarify this for you: "Means of production controlled by the workers" . It's fixed. Communism- you keep using that word. I don't think it means what you think it means.
@FrittenFritzgerald
@FrittenFritzgerald 7 месяцев назад
Marx was a Freemason... Yeah, he hated religion... xD
@mr.lavander7145
@mr.lavander7145 7 месяцев назад
I'm socialist and I get it the church gives people hope of the hereafter so they don't recognize their plight under capitalism. The problem is they have nothing to replace it with. I think people need spiritual practice of some kind. Maybe China has done a better job of filling peoples' lives with other types of meaning than the Russians did.
@mrgreenminaj
@mrgreenminaj 3 месяца назад
🚩🚩 🤝 ✝️ as a catholic and communist
@TheWarrior68
@TheWarrior68 8 месяцев назад
I love these leaders! 🚩🚩
@alexjames6747
@alexjames6747 8 месяцев назад
Ideology is accepting the certain set of rules different from other people views. Any ideology paves the way to atrocity
@tommy5456
@tommy5456 6 месяцев назад
well, you should know that politics is inherently ideological.
@katherinekelly6432
@katherinekelly6432 8 месяцев назад
The state does not want competition. Eliminate God and the people are easier to control.
@tommy5456
@tommy5456 6 месяцев назад
history disprove you point. states used religion as a tool to control the masses, it's way easier to tell the ignorants that a big man with a beard is always watching them from above.
@JoeBuck-uc3bl
@JoeBuck-uc3bl 7 месяцев назад
You’re conflating “Religion” with “Religions that have a deity as their center.” A religion that does not have a deity isn’t NOT a religion. Ergo…I would instead say “Why Communism hates deity based religions”
@clementokoro5563
@clementokoro5563 Год назад
Basically, they are against religious because they see it as a threat to their authority. However, I was waiting to hear that religion lacked spirituality and truth but I’m glad that’s not the case. Jesus is the way, the truth and the life. Whoever is reading this now, please give your life to Jesus and he will perfect all that concerns you, he will also give you the peace of mind that passes all human understanding. Shalom!
@vinaykunisetty8179
@vinaykunisetty8179 Год назад
We too love jesus and his sayings, but in reality, those who are following him are the most exploited sadly by the upper class people and this is where the conflicts arise because jesus adviced people to forgive the trespassers which in turn is giving them a easier path for them to extort, for your kind information, those trespassers who advocate religion, they don't even follow it, because had they been strictly doing it, why would there be any exploitation or extortion? Those who take this very religion seriously are the victims and that's what Karl Marx clearly mentioned
@ihl0700677525
@ihl0700677525 Год назад
While both Marx and Jesus are arguably "Socialist", they are not the same. Marx is the exact opposite of Jesus on many things: 1. Spiritualism vs. Materialism: - Jesus said that "His kingdom" is not in/from this world, hence His followers should waste their time pursuing material wealth, but spiritual wealth. - Marx said religion and spiritualism is useless (or even counter-productive), and that material prosperity is the only thing that matter in this life. 2. Wealth gap: - Jesus said that there will always be rich and poor people in this world (one of Jesus' parable is about how God give 5 talents (gold coin/bullion) to one guy, 3 talents to another guy, and just 1 talent to another). The rich should care for the poor, while the poor should not envy the rich. - Marx said we should pursue equality by expropriating or otherwise taking the wealth away from the rich and put them all under collective management. 3. Hierarchy and politics - Jesus said we should support and pray for our leaders and government. So that thru their good governance, we shall enjoy peace and prosperity. - Marx said we should abolish hierarchy thru a popular revolt/revolution, to create an egalitarian society under the "Dictatorship of the Proletariat" (effectively an ochlocracy). 4. Social Justice - Jesus said we should look inward. We should better our inner-self, to be light in the dark. Bottom-up approach. - Marx said there's inherent injustice in the current (mostly "Capitalist", but also Feudal) system. Rather than be a (singular) light in the dark, we should actively make the room brighter thru collective action. Top-down approach.
@ihl0700677525
@ihl0700677525 Год назад
@@vinaykunisetty8179 _"those trespassers who advocate religion, they don't even follow it, because had they been strictly doing it, why would there be any exploitation or extortion?"_ I guess not that different to those self-declared Marxist/Socialist *hypocrites* in Communist Party? People like Stalin, Mao, Tito, and all the members of the Politburo in Socialist countries who live in luxury (compared to average citizens). They get better cars (often custom made just for them), better housing/apartment, and better access to resources (e.g. prioritized access to resort/sanatorium, etc). _"Those who take this very religion seriously are the victims and that's what Karl Marx clearly mentioned"_ For Marxists who prioritize physical/material wealth, dedicating one's life to follow religion (or "superstition") is foolish and useless. For religious people who prioritize spiritual wellbeing over mere worldly possession, Marxism is stupid and useless. Why waste your time and corrupt your own mind and soul with hatred, in pursue of something so temporal? Inner peace is much much more important than material wealth.
@TheWarrior68
@TheWarrior68 8 месяцев назад
Lmao Jesus doesn’t exist sweet heart! Grown up
@commissarmax4832
@commissarmax4832 8 месяцев назад
They've seen it as something that is exploiting people using fairy tales.
@critikasalihmeylani
@critikasalihmeylani 8 месяцев назад
It seems to know the problem, but has the wrong solution. The dogmas religions revolve around are indeed bad for the questioning mind, but completely removing the concept of competition out of the society to solve the problem is a very bad solution. People are born with different skills, and if they don't get recognized and treated differently and get eduction during early childhood to polish their skills, they won't reach their true potentials, and it will be humanity's loss. I do agree that religions are a tool to numb people's suffering, and silence the questions they have about the world. It was always like that, ever since the beginning of humanity, humans needed a way to maintain the society with a set of rules. But without the laws of human rights or security cameras to watch over people, how can leaders prevent society from collapsing? Indeed, religions are useful for this. However, we have new, more 'modern' ways of maintaining the society now. Like Sigmund Freud said, we don't need religion anymore. My suggestion is to establish a system of competition where people all across the world are being given best possible eduction they can get, and be supported by governments of their countries when they want to walk on a path that is beneficient for science and humanity. We can build a galaxy conquering civilization as well as slowly close the gaps in science if the 8 billion of us focus on trying to improve.
@robertcarpenter7486
@robertcarpenter7486 5 месяцев назад
A galaxy conquering civilization?
@0smundSaddler
@0smundSaddler Год назад
Because it's based
@Flags.crosses.trailerparks
@Flags.crosses.trailerparks Год назад
Don’t blame it on Communism. I think religion is perfectly ridiculous……
@JohnathanWilliamson849
@JohnathanWilliamson849 10 месяцев назад
*tips fedora*
@JohnathanWilliamson849
@JohnathanWilliamson849 10 месяцев назад
You replace religion with government. You believe in Government and that it's there to support you.
@eu_bebo_oleo
@eu_bebo_oleo 6 месяцев назад
"Don't blame it on Communism, m'lady" *tips fedora*
@Godinnumbersdevilindetails
@Godinnumbersdevilindetails 3 месяца назад
Lol that's just trash society taught
@moonsharn
@moonsharn 6 месяцев назад
The greatest trick the devil ever played was convincing the world he didn’t exist. “Devil” or “communism” can be used interchangeably. Who wants to see the end of religion most of all? He whos power is most challenged by its existence.
@tommy5456
@tommy5456 6 месяцев назад
you are the perfect example of how religion works against the people's interest.
@moonsharn
@moonsharn 6 месяцев назад
⁠@@tommy5456how? I’m not religious… at all. It doesn’t take a genius to see why communist rule wants it gone though does it? Communist dictators want to be the god figure. How many times on repeat have we witnessed that? More than enough to learn the hard lessons. It’s the most dangerous and evil philosophy on earth, hiding behind a false narrative of “equality” and “fairness”.
@FalangeRevolutionary986
@FalangeRevolutionary986 6 месяцев назад
​@@tommy5456 Ok commie
@richardque1036
@richardque1036 2 месяца назад
Marx atheistism come from hegel.
@coolbuddydude1
@coolbuddydude1 Год назад
Cause Communism is a competing religion.
@TheDarkIllumination
@TheDarkIllumination 9 месяцев назад
More accurately, as Christopher Hitchens said when he abandoned Marxism, it was an attempt to create a rational alternative to religion.
@muhammadhamad8764
@muhammadhamad8764 2 месяца назад
You have tried to say things on behalf of religion but I think you actually have not done proper research on religion's perspective of suffering because in Islam(don't know about other religions) sufferings are actually a test from Allah Almighty not a misalignment with Him
@sumit2302
@sumit2302 Год назад
I like communist ideology because match with our ideology " shath shatayam samacharet " but I also hate that they opposing other beliefs if they do any peaceful works like islam whereas except islam all religion believe in violence we are not peaceful community like islam
@Gvprtskvni
@Gvprtskvni 2 месяца назад
Because Communism is a religion and they don’t want competition.
Далее
Is Religion the Opium of the People?
5:57
Просмотров 174 тыс.
когда повзрослела // EVA mash
00:40
Просмотров 1,9 млн
Спасибо Анджилишка, попил😂
00:19
What has Marxism to do with religion?
39:50
Просмотров 26 тыс.
Chinese vs. American Political Philosophy
21:28
Просмотров 967 тыс.
All religions explained in 10 minutes
9:25
Просмотров 4,1 млн
The Problems of Secularism
12:19
Просмотров 14 тыс.
Jordan Peterson's Critique of the Communist Manifesto
29:41
Why I'm Not a Socialist
8:28
Просмотров 24 тыс.
Soviet Style Economics Was Insane and Here’s Why
25:12
What Is Marxism?
32:05
Просмотров 467 тыс.