Тёмный

Why did 70+ Congress Leaders Quit the Party in 8 years? | Akash Banerjee 

The Deshbhakt
Подписаться 4,5 млн
Просмотров 704 тыс.
50% 1

Ghulam Nabi Azad joins the long list of Congress leaders who have quit the party in the last 8 years (more than 70 have quit our quick research shows - the comments are extending that list)
Either the Congress has been infested with rotten, opportunistic, worthless leaders - or the the message that all of them are sending must be true - but are the Gandhi's even listening. How is it that almost EVERY Congress leader who is quitting - saying the same thing???
🇮🇳 SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE VIDEOS 🇮🇳 - / thedeshbhakt ▶️
⛔️ BECOME A DESHBHAKT MEMBER - / thedeshbhakt ⛔️
Unlock MEMBER ONLY: 1) Chats 2) Discord Server 3) Special Episodes
👕 DESHBHAKT MERCH - India's First Line of Socially & Politically aware tees 👕
kadakmerch.com/collections/th...
📧 BUSINESS ENQUIRIES - contact (at) thedeshbhakt (dot) in 📧
** SUBSCRIBE / FOLLOW US **
RU-vid: - / thedeshbhakt
Twitter :- / thedeshbhakt
Web - thedeshbhakt.in/
Instagram :- / akashbanerjee.in
Facebook :- / akashbanerjee.in
Podcast - anchor.fm/thedeshbhakt
Credits :
Research : Rishi & Avishrant
Writer : Akash
Edit : Shivam & Tushar
Thumbnail : Khursheed
Associate Producer : Sahil
Producer: Avishrant
#ghulamnabiazad #rahulgandhi #congress

Опубликовано:

 

25 авг 2022

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 3,2 тыс.   
@thatswhatshesaid7935
@thatswhatshesaid7935 Год назад
Congress Party is perfect example of: "1st generation makes it, 2nd generation maintains it, 3rd generation destroys it"
@thedeshbhakt
@thedeshbhakt Год назад
actually rahul is 4th gen :)
@thatswhatshesaid7935
@thatswhatshesaid7935 Год назад
@@thedeshbhakt i know but i only count Sonia Gandhi mam because Rahul Gandhi is not interested in politics 🙃
@manoharchandrashekar2085
@manoharchandrashekar2085 Год назад
@@thedeshbhakt brother what desh jodo yatra this kinda negative people r hatin this people expecting some things like kejariwal we will make no1 i hope so kejriwal give tuff fight 2034 brother congress katam
@kanganajokerranaut667
@kanganajokerranaut667 Год назад
Destroy toh Indira ji ne he kar dia tha jab desh ko paros ke beton ko dene ki koshish ki thi
@abdeo777
@abdeo777 Год назад
@@thedeshbhakt destruction started with Rajiv and Soniya. Rahul is just making sure it’s 6 feet under.
@Ven435
@Ven435 Год назад
BJP to its party leaders : Rahul Gandhi ko Out mat karna.
@leyvithanTech
@leyvithanTech Год назад
Sahi kahe sabse main reason Rahul gandi he bjp victory ka sabse bada key factor h INC
@praz45
@praz45 Год назад
Lol
@roshnikutty1839
@roshnikutty1839 Год назад
Either choose a life battling legal cases or do nothing for your party - That's the choice Modi must have given Rahul on the night he went in as opposition leader amidst the opposition ruckus over demonetization. When he came out after the meeting, Rahul's decibel had come down considerably! That's when i knew Indian democracy was doomed.
@neetubajpai2136
@neetubajpai2136 Год назад
@@roshnikutty1839 typical librandu,when your favourite party doesn't win democracy is in danger.
@jitendrabopche3659
@jitendrabopche3659 Год назад
@@neetubajpai2136even now they won't agree on what u have said.. moreover will put nonsense without logic.. brainwashed librands filled with so much of hatred
@gauravkumargupta9622
@gauravkumargupta9622 Год назад
Rahul : BJP is destroying democracy Also rahul : Destroying the opposition which itself is a major pillar of democracy
@ajanthamusicgadag2435
@ajanthamusicgadag2435 Год назад
Perhaps true, Rahul perhaps nt able to maintain a strong opposition bt right wing ideology of sangh bjp itself is most dangerous thing for a constitutional democracy.
@timelord2024
@timelord2024 Год назад
@@ajanthamusicgadag2435 You guys support a dynasty type one party system
@gauravkumargupta9622
@gauravkumargupta9622 Год назад
@@ajanthamusicgadag2435 BRo what is the characteristic feature of monarcy? Dynasty
@subhankarbose7857
@subhankarbose7857 Год назад
@@gauravkumargupta9622 Correct bro...May be that's why Jay Shah is the BCCI Secratary and Jyotiraditya Scindia's son is Vice president of GDCA. Sure they are not active in politics currently but are in similar power. What say..?
@judepinto3328
@judepinto3328 Год назад
@@ajanthamusicgadag2435 Why you blaming only Rahul, it's not your duty also? Even in first term the BJP failed in Governance but you gave more mandate to them in second term, who's fault? Even though BJP's contributions for Independence struggle is ZERO still they went on to saying Congress mukth Bharat we did not do nothing, why? Now with power BJP is sitting on your head now you realised Congress bure din really Ache din & Mr.56" Ache din is really bure din. In my view people misunderstood Rahul mainly because of BJP's personal attack on him and mainstream media, otherwise he will be a better PM than the current Mr.56".
@santhoshnarasimhan7117
@santhoshnarasimhan7117 Год назад
Without strong opposition Indian democracy was dead from 1947-1989
@manishbasak20
@manishbasak20 Год назад
And now 2019-present
@nananou1687
@nananou1687 Год назад
so janata dal in 78 was no opposition?
@hello-il3fg
@hello-il3fg Год назад
​@@nananou16873 saal 😂
@roflgandhi.
@roflgandhi. Год назад
Modi promised Congress Mukt Bharat in 2014. Congress is trying hard to fulfill that
@aryanyadav3690
@aryanyadav3690 Год назад
RSS full form - Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh You guys watching Banerjee listen RSS Anthem Then you'll come to know more about them 🇮🇳🙏🏻
@abbasabdeali3239
@abbasabdeali3239 Год назад
@Kanwar Wander we are realising everything brother....and we shall revolt very soon.
@Magnet423
@Magnet423 Год назад
Rof NO !! Don't blame BJP or Congress. The VOTERS are the problem. If you say, AAYEGA TOH MODI HEE .....it is your decision. hahaha
@sumedhabhardwaj2474
@sumedhabhardwaj2474 Год назад
@Kanwar Wander agree with you...feku ka kya bigadega...74 ke already ho rakhe h...or moz me kat ri h zindagi...suffer to India krega...ye bevkuf logo ko smj hi nhi aa ra
@het6618
@het6618 Год назад
@@abbasabdeali3239 plz don't do revolt cause the revolts you community does is very much world wide famous. We just saw so called "peaceful" protest by you guys in the prophet controversy. If this is your peaceful protest then what would be your revolt? 26/11 2.0? That's what your community can do. You do riots, kill people just because of blasphemy you create disturbance in the society & then cry for freedom, liberty & unity. Stop this non sense. If you can do revolt then we can also do 2002 again just don't take us lightly. And this time it won't be limited to Gujarat but rather it will happen at a national level. Congress is dead they won't come to power 2 years later just like in 2004 after 2002 so just mind your own life don't mess unnecessaryly. If you want abuse us abuse BJP abuse Modi whatever the hell you want to do on social media but don't even dare to do anything in real life cause remember your mom can also become Bilkis.
@VishalKumar-ww1jt
@VishalKumar-ww1jt Год назад
Being a bjp supporter,I think we must need a strong congress now competition is like (india vs Zimbabwe 😁)
@bikramjitroy6155
@bikramjitroy6155 Год назад
Don't worry, AAP party is fulfilling that space.
@Jay1Shrivastava
@Jay1Shrivastava Год назад
@@bikramjitroy6155 😂😂Aap 1st they say Nitin Gadkari & Arun jethali is corrupt Nobody but this aap is corrupt Punjab will proof last nail in their coffin
@bikramjitroy6155
@bikramjitroy6155 Год назад
@@Jay1Shrivastava let's see. But u know, in politics, u can't predict anything. But I personally believe that AAP has potential to replace Congress in opposition.
@Jay1Shrivastava
@Jay1Shrivastava Год назад
@@bikramjitroy6155 Only right wing like shivsena can defeat Bjp... Or kejriwal have to be more right Winger
@manoharchandrashekar2085
@manoharchandrashekar2085 Год назад
@@bikramjitroy6155 till not proven anything brother kcr , trs lot better than him ok
@malikaa148
@malikaa148 Год назад
Joining other parties for personal gain with completely different ideology is not the answer as many have done.
@user-wq6mk8vk6q
@user-wq6mk8vk6q Месяц назад
To wo kya karte? Rahul aur Sonia Gandhi ke chele ban jaate?
@MeenaKumari-lj7yc
@MeenaKumari-lj7yc Год назад
Congress couldn't maintain its dignity and power in return BJP and other parties took the advantage and came to power That's smart and acceptable!!👏👏👍
@RBK01
@RBK01 Год назад
I'm a BJP supporter but I think there should be a strong opposition to maintain democracy
@shawnmichaels4767
@shawnmichaels4767 Год назад
Same here
@bhavinjain9367
@bhavinjain9367 Год назад
Same Here.
@eddyboy8048
@eddyboy8048 Год назад
strong oppositions chaiye toh fir oppositions ko support krna.
@mohammedamerimtiaz7998
@mohammedamerimtiaz7998 Год назад
@@bhavinjain9367 Gand Fatte toh Fatte per Aakad na toote. 🙂 Isn't? You mean yea Secularism & Congress a Muslim party wala label chalta rahe aur tum Sangh(RSS) ko VOTE dete raho. 🤣 isn't? Aur Musalman bewakoof jaise tumhara Secularism wale totle mei aakr Congress ko vote 🗳 dei.
@GajananPalande
@GajananPalande Год назад
@@eddyboy8048 koi acha option toh bane
@subhankarbose7857
@subhankarbose7857 Год назад
Without a powerful opposition..democracy is merely a word and INC has contributed enough to keep it that way.
@ulala9729
@ulala9729 Год назад
Don't worry wait for thirty years, Muslim party will emerge as national party there will be no secular party after islamic takeover of india
@subhankarbose7857
@subhankarbose7857 Год назад
@@ulala9729 That will happen IF we live for 30 more years. Thanks to inflation, taxes, ED, CBI, IT and so on.
@subhankarbose7857
@subhankarbose7857 Год назад
@@ulala9729 Our Double engine ki sarkar has merely become AA Ki sarkar and you are talking about 30 years.
@thelivingphantom2584
@thelivingphantom2584 Год назад
@@ulala9729 do you actually believe in that shit? I thought u people said that as a joke
@shivamkamra2428
@shivamkamra2428 Год назад
@@subhankarbose7857 lol a typical librandu as usual, can you tell me what is the average inflation rate of INDIA since 2014 to now? i know avg inflation b/w 2014 to 2019(before corona), it was 4.85%.
@PoojaSingh-tb1ps
@PoojaSingh-tb1ps Год назад
Not only congress is losing its position because of their leadership but also Indian democracy is downed due to this.
@sudipjatav5175
@sudipjatav5175 Год назад
Mam opposition bhi BJP khada kra kya 😂😂
@shivamishra2338
@shivamishra2338 Год назад
@@sudipjatav5175 mast plan hai.. 🤣🤣🤣
@savitashankar8575
@savitashankar8575 Год назад
Would be interesting to flip the argument and ask ourselves: Would these 70 leaders have left if Congress continued to remain in power? We talk about these leaders feeling disrespected, however we all know that there is no other party who insults its leaders openly and brazenly like the BJP yet not a single one has the guts to say a word against the Modi-Shah duo. Why? The answer is simple - they win elections for the party. The easiest thing to do is to desert a sinking ship, the hard thing would be stay in and fight it out, even if it means fighting with the Gandhis. Let's not kid ourselves - even if the Gandhis step down today, will the party miraculously transform and start winning elections ? You need people with integrity and selflessness to stick their neck out and fight for as long as it takes. BJP / RSS is an extremely powerful force with money, media and muscle and Rahul Gandhi stepping down from Congress is not going to change anything.
@vinayaktrivedi9375
@vinayaktrivedi9375 Год назад
The first sign of an idiot is doing the same thing again and again and hoping for different results. Keep in mind this statement. The congress needs to reinvent itself in order to win elections; Rahul Gandhi has not shown that he is capable to win elections, so shouldnt it be obvious that someone else should be given the chance.
@pranavkumarraghuvanshi7977
@pranavkumarraghuvanshi7977 Год назад
Nobody will care for the sinking ship if the captain is haphazard. Yes if the leadership shifts to someone more capable in Congress for instance kanhaiya kumar, party will definitely improve. Even for BJP it took only 8 years to be at this position.
@antoniosaldanha3294
@antoniosaldanha3294 Год назад
Absolutely correct...must know that fighting this Polorise political party BJP RSS won't be easy for anyone
@Red13093
@Red13093 Год назад
Inversion doesn't really work here as 8 years is a long time in politics. We've seen a lot of liberal leaders step down after two election defeats world over. You cannot expect to lose two elections and hope the party workers will stay onside. Resigning and retiring to the background is the dignified option in this case. I don't know Sonia Gandhi but she absolutely wants her children to hold power. Reminds you of Game of Thrones 😂
@sachink0899
@sachink0899 Год назад
Women ☕
@AdityaMishra-pv4eh
@AdityaMishra-pv4eh Год назад
The downfall started back in 80's, after 80's congress never got more than 50%+ seats in loksabha.
@Anonymous-ux1ve
@Anonymous-ux1ve Год назад
Actually after babri masjid demolition, that actually gave big blow to congress and bjp emerged as a national party in true sense before that it had 3,4 seats in loksabha.
@leyvithanTech
@leyvithanTech Год назад
@@Anonymous-ux1ve I don't think so Indra Gandhi aur Rajiv Gandhi jaise koi bada leader aur influencial leader aya he nhi congress me jo the unko kabhi face nhi banaya gya
@asifkazi2782
@asifkazi2782 Год назад
अबे गधे राजीव गांधी का रिकॉर्ड हे लोकसभा मे सब मे ज्यादा सीट वो 80 के बाद 2009 तक समजा।
@dealopedia11
@dealopedia11 Год назад
Main reason is sayara Bano case Rajiv jii have 400+ seat but still UCC didn't came and showing its baised to muslims Then Babri happen BJP emerge as new power and congress started to fall
@Dragon_Ball_Z70
@Dragon_Ball_Z70 Год назад
@@dealopedia11 I agree with your point
@nzm7993
@nzm7993 Год назад
As PK said, congress can win, but only when Gandhi family leave their positions.. and restructure congress...
@sairaj3052
@sairaj3052 Год назад
Who is PK?
@blistering2900
@blistering2900 Год назад
Entire party will collapse ...if Gandhis leave. G-23 and new leaders will create factions and it will crackdown further.
@sairaj3052
@sairaj3052 Год назад
@Alexios I Komnenos I thought Amir Khan 😂😂
@nzm7993
@nzm7993 Год назад
@@sairaj3052 PRASHANT KISHORE
@zahednow
@zahednow Год назад
@@blistering2900 that's true.....but there's no other option. The party is anyway heading for doom and loose all relevance unless it revamps itself. The ideal scenario would have been for sonia to stop acting selfish and arrange for elections in the party to choose the next president
@prateekjain9842
@prateekjain9842 Год назад
This really shows a trend! One more thing, we need to understand that these are public statements and may vary slightly from the real reasons for them leaving the party. We should consider this aspect as well. Even then, issues like inept leadership, lack of direction & democracy within the party are pretty clear from these.
@ShivamGupta-qi1me
@ShivamGupta-qi1me Год назад
Yes,we want 2nd part of this video asap,because your analysis is five 🌟.
@aero-sumit2056
@aero-sumit2056 Год назад
The incompetency and Idiocracy congress is displaying also contributes to the fall of democracy in India.
@AjitJoshi686
@AjitJoshi686 Год назад
Ravish Kumar, Akash Banerjee, Dhruv Rathi should be made congress leaders. They are doing better job than Rahul Gandhi.
@Azhar_shaikh1
@Azhar_shaikh1 Год назад
Even if RG isn't the best, you should ask the question, is he better than modi?
@sachinbhujel909
@sachinbhujel909 Год назад
संघर्ष बड़ा है और कठिन भी। लड़ेंगे, चलेंगे गिरेंगे उठेंगे दौड़ेंगे, पर हार नही मानेंगे। वादा रहा बहुत कुछ बदलेंगे।
@chhatrapatishivajimaharaj5165
@@Azhar_shaikh1 not at all,modi is much more better than him.
@admiralgeneralaladeen7445
@admiralgeneralaladeen7445 Год назад
😂
@LoveIsLifeTurkishIndia
@LoveIsLifeTurkishIndia Год назад
@@chhatrapatishivajimaharaj5165 not at all
@DeepKumar.
@DeepKumar. Год назад
It's a Good thing that oldies are leaving, and those who came to make money are joining the richest party, There will always be new faces who'll join the party and they will start a new revolution...
@thepeacefulwarrior2879
@thepeacefulwarrior2879 Год назад
So long as GNA was part of the coterie it was superb. Now that he's no more part of it, he sees a problem with another coterie. Mr GNA had a wonderful career and now that there's no room for him, it's sour grapes, and he's deigned to stoop so low. And those who have moved over to the BJP have clearly been traitors to their own values. Quitting Congress is acceptable, but embracing the antithesis of the Congress ideology is an absolute treachery.
@Harsh-iu1il
@Harsh-iu1il Год назад
This Channel teaches me the broader perspective to look into the politics, it teaches me that as a democratic country citizen it is not about to be biased towards a party but it is about every element of it doing its part leading to a holistic development of the democracy and of the country. Thank you sir. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
@thedeshbhakt
@thedeshbhakt Год назад
thats one of the core aims of the channel - think nation not party
@Harsh-iu1il
@Harsh-iu1il Год назад
Yes Sir 🙏
@premprakashmoyal3682
@premprakashmoyal3682 Год назад
@@thedeshbhakt 😃😃😃 Jai hind🙂
@omkar7372
@omkar7372 Год назад
Everyone know that akash is biased ...
@AmitKumarsays
@AmitKumarsays Год назад
@@omkar7372 biased towards...?
@WBSchoolOfMaths
@WBSchoolOfMaths Год назад
In West Bengal both congress and left got zero seat in assembly elections and Shashi Tharoor expressed his happiness on social media because bjp lost in West Bengal,now imagine the level of intectual in congress.
@dds3016
@dds3016 Год назад
Tum power ka soch reha ho
@bhavinjain9367
@bhavinjain9367 Год назад
🤣
@WBSchoolOfMaths
@WBSchoolOfMaths Год назад
@@dds3016 Do you know in West Bengal people making fun on congress, for example In school a child ask his teacher how to write one hundred and teacher replies Put two congress after one ,it's makes one hundred.
@bhavinjain9367
@bhavinjain9367 Год назад
@@WBSchoolOfMaths Is it for real?
@WBSchoolOfMaths
@WBSchoolOfMaths Год назад
@@bhavinjain9367 Yes
@krishrajput7425
@krishrajput7425 4 месяца назад
Thank you sir for giving us a detailed and unbiased video. 🙏 Dhruv rathee ne toh brain wash kar rakha hai😂
@sambitswain2377
@sambitswain2377 Год назад
This man must be knowing some internal stuff. Such a loyal member. Plus it's perplexing how he calls a few people who joined TMC and Shive Sena to be loyal and who joined the BJP to be greedy. 👏👏
@AnshulSingh1
@AnshulSingh1 Год назад
If I was Rahul Gandhi, I would have taken a long sabbatical from politics watching this analysis.
@wasilshaikh909
@wasilshaikh909 Год назад
He is nothing but a Pappu for politics.
@praveerranjan7979
@praveerranjan7979 Год назад
Samaj ni atta ye bjp ki itni state mai sarkar hai par kabhi maine inke state leader ko apas mai ladte ni suna aur congress ki 2 ke ilava kahi sarkar ni hai par ladai bahot hai
@benazirislam680
@benazirislam680 Год назад
The problem is not Rahul but Sonia who wants to stay in power.
@shivam6410
@shivam6410 Год назад
40 seats out of 543 is itself a sabbatical leave.
@navneetdhal5986
@navneetdhal5986 Год назад
And do what
@rameezrazaansari4105
@rameezrazaansari4105 Год назад
I know there is something wrong with Congress high command but it's the negligence, arrogance and oversmart attitude of these senior leaders which gave a walkover to BJP in 2014..and today these senior leaders are blaming RaGA for everything...
@sheikhabdullah8549
@sheikhabdullah8549 Год назад
Thanks viewers
@DevadasPuzhukil
@DevadasPuzhukil Год назад
Good Job ..... really appreciated your efforts as a team 👍👍🇮🇳🙏🙏
@Ttttttttttt23
@Ttttttttttt23 Год назад
I support BJP and yet I agree with you that a strong opposition has to be there.. It is scary that there is no good opposition now.
@MyRihankhan
@MyRihankhan Год назад
Hi Akash sir, definitely we want part 2. A perfect case study what a political party should not do.
@shaileshghogare9857
@shaileshghogare9857 Год назад
One of MLA in maharashtra who was cabinet minister for 15 years just resigned bcoz alliance party didn't replace the seat for his son , and in resignation he write rahul is incapable of handling party 🤣🤣🤣 brother akash jo aaj bika hai wo kal bhi bike ga ..... sabka time ayega.... ✌✌
@yashshetye721
@yashshetye721 Год назад
For a party that constantly talks about democracy its so ironic that its entire machinery is controlled by just 3 people. BTW congrats Akash, you are officially an "Aapiya" now for showing the cold hard facts of the congress decline acc to the congress lovers
@ashim_
@ashim_ Год назад
Akash Banerjee ki dukh halka halka dikh bhi raha hai video me,,🤣😂
@mkvcyiitr
@mkvcyiitr Год назад
संघर्ष बड़ा है और कठिन भी। लड़ेंगे, चलेंगे गिरेंगे उठेंगे दौड़ेंगे, पर हार नही मानेंगे। वादा रहा बहुत कुछ बदलेंगे।
@kartikchauhan3209
@kartikchauhan3209 Год назад
🤣🤣🤣
@aarav1037
@aarav1037 Год назад
Bas ye line hi bolne ko baki rah gye thi🤣
@ashishtiwari87
@ashishtiwari87 Год назад
Monu Verma ko president banao congress ka... abki baaar, monu sarkar!
@tariqff3757
@tariqff3757 Год назад
@@ashishtiwari87 🤣🤣🤣 सख्त जरूरत है
@biologyhunter6053
@biologyhunter6053 Год назад
😂😂😂😂😂😆😆
@jessygeorge3928
@jessygeorge3928 Год назад
You can’t blame the Gandhi’s only for current state of the party. To some extent you have to blame these spineless leaders who doesn’t have the guts to fight or create a revolution within the party , they should learn from mr narendra modi how he side kicked all the senior leaders and became a prime minister. All these Congress leaders they don’t want to fight but they prefer to quit and then they blame their problems on Gandhi’s.
@inderjeetsingh9609
@inderjeetsingh9609 Год назад
Nice approach and analysis
@raangnambar8816
@raangnambar8816 Год назад
Lol... Modi sidelined others "after" he was made a leader..!! NaMo didn't do anything...!!! He was made by all others... Then he kicked out all. Gandhis are not doing such mistakes..!!
@garvinpandya6266
@garvinpandya6266 Год назад
@@raangnambar8816 well u seriously need to know how Modi rose to power. Half knowledge is dangerous my friend
@venkatachalamramasamy4823
@venkatachalamramasamy4823 Год назад
With the three modi used against all opp parties from 2014.Most of the persons became THROGIS to their own party and blame all because of Gandhi family.
@Akash-tz7bt
@Akash-tz7bt Год назад
Don't compare Rahul idiot with Narendra Modi. Modi has Hindu rashtra vision. Rahul has no vision.
@dexterroy
@dexterroy 6 месяцев назад
This is not the grand old party of India, it has been split many times. This latest iteration was created in 1969. Original Congress had merged into Janta party.
@mrchoudhury6611
@mrchoudhury6611 Год назад
Now I realised current Ghandhi never love the nation , they loves Power... Now its time for their real mukt from India...
@rakeshkukrety1059
@rakeshkukrety1059 Год назад
आकाश जी का विश्लेषण हमेशा श्रेष्ठ ही रहता है...पर सच यही है कि कांग्रेस विचार ही देश के लिए सर्वोत्तम है...कांग्रेस जनों को संघर्ष करना होगा लोकतंत्र की मजबूती के लिए...
@vishruthsvhebbar1708
@vishruthsvhebbar1708 Год назад
Just love the work you do mann!! Very few people left in our country who put forward the news in a neutral point of view
@MrSaviour
@MrSaviour Год назад
He is not neutral!! He is slightly left of center but nevertheless produces good content!
@souravbhattacharjee4031
@souravbhattacharjee4031 Год назад
If Congress can't come out from the hangover of 'Gandhi's, future is bleak.
@arindamghosh8220
@arindamghosh8220 Год назад
Yes yes we need part-2.Due to this congress party uff Gandhi Family we have left no option on national level against BJP. 😭
@sudipjatav5175
@sudipjatav5175 Год назад
Keep crying we will make hindu rashtra
@sympathiser_of_Germans_in_40s
@@sudipjatav5175 🚩🚩🙏
@Sandy_2709
@Sandy_2709 Год назад
@@sudipjatav5175 yes
@inamullahansari5332
@inamullahansari5332 Год назад
" गलत का विरोध खुल कर कीजिए , चाहे राजनीति हो या समाज...... " इतिहास टकराने वालो का लिखा जाता हैं , तलवे चाटने वालो का नहीं ....💯💯❤️❤️❤️👌👌🙏🙏
@ulala9729
@ulala9729 Год назад
Har ghar burqa, har ghar hijab
@ManishKumar-wb7vj
@ManishKumar-wb7vj Год назад
sahi kaha tumhare idol to isis hoga takeane wala h vo
@someshkandara3642
@someshkandara3642 Год назад
@@ulala9729 😂😂
@praveerranjan7979
@praveerranjan7979 Год назад
Samaj ni atta ye bjp ki itni state mai sarkar hai par kabhi maine inke state leader ko apas mai ladte ni suna aur congress ki 2 ke ilava kahi sarkar ni hai par ladai bahot hai
@entertainerboy7347
@entertainerboy7347 Год назад
@@ulala9729 har ghar gobar har ghar gaumut 😎
@nik_rangari7600
@nik_rangari7600 Год назад
I know that opposition is weak but what we as a people can do? Neither can keep quiet Because other side is no normal side they are scary
@kashinathmaharana7422
@kashinathmaharana7422 Год назад
So funny.. democracy definition is of the people for the people by the people.. When people choose something., It is declared unconstitutional.. 🤣🤣 How can you people even sleep straight with that much hypocrisy
@sympathiser_of_Germans_in_40s
Ye daar hum ko achha laga.
@ABhattacharya
@ABhattacharya Год назад
Good video. informative and well-researched. Presented well. Yes want a part 2.
@Apex1008
@Apex1008 Год назад
Really hope for a good opposition , else its a sad situation . Very well researched content.
@sachinbhujel909
@sachinbhujel909 Год назад
Dear Akash, I really loved this video.A day without Deshbhakt's video is like a battery-less phone.Please keep uploading videos everyday. Thank you
@gamipolizin9115
@gamipolizin9115 Год назад
Agreed 💯
@thedeshbhakt
@thedeshbhakt Год назад
its a massive task- for me and the team - will keep trying
@qwerty9889
@qwerty9889 Год назад
@@thedeshbhakt tu landoooru soniya pappu ko politics sikhayega ,,, soniya pappu ko politics sikhane ke liye isi samet aur bahut organisation hai...wahi feed lene pappu soniya Pinki videsh gayi hai....idar G23 milkar G70 banayenge ,,Naya party banayenge election ladenge ,,,
@sunnyyadav4509
@sunnyyadav4509 Год назад
@@thedeshbhakt We want part 2 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯 💯💯💯💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 PLS SUPPORT THE DESHBHAKT We want part 2 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯 💯💯💯💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 PLS SUPPORT THE DESHBHAKT
@clashofclanswarriors4572
@clashofclanswarriors4572 Год назад
@@thedeshbhakt whenever Congress lost just i open RU-vid and search deshbhakt and see your vedio opinion on Congress
@lokeshupreti6378
@lokeshupreti6378 Год назад
Top quality content and unbiased analysis ! Kudos !
@adarsh5343
@adarsh5343 Год назад
Lavde ka unbiased Last video freebies ke upar banaya tha.... Aur the epitome of freebie offerings party AAP ke baare me ek sentence v nahi kaha, jab ki total 3-4 baar Modi ke 15 lakh waali baat bola
@IamSad56
@IamSad56 Год назад
Han bas topi wale khilap kuch nahi bolte hain Bangali Babu !!!!
@nishantraj7975
@nishantraj7975 Год назад
Unbiased🤣🤣🤣😂😂 Joke of the decade.
@RohanKumaar
@RohanKumaar Год назад
@@nishantraj7975 Better than being a Hindu andhbhakt
@omkar7372
@omkar7372 Год назад
He is biased
@pzamwar
@pzamwar Год назад
First time agree with U & liked ur video... Don't b Baised against BJP..
@vlogswithsrk3014
@vlogswithsrk3014 Год назад
Very good explain dear.
@AM-hs7in
@AM-hs7in Год назад
I do hope the congress leadership introspects and rejuvenates the party in time cos we badly need a strong opposition now, when democracy is facing an existential threat. It's easier for a once-upon-a-time national party to do it rather than for a regional party like aap or tmc per se trying to woo voters from all over India to oppose the bjp. Either ways it's a far shot. Unlikely by 2024.
@who-Am-I-Here
@who-Am-I-Here Год назад
😂😂
@Magnet423
@Magnet423 Год назад
AM The problem is your .....LAST 3 WORDS !! 2 years is a lot of time....work to improve Congress.
@raghave1043
@raghave1043 Год назад
@@Magnet423Congress even today holds 15-20% core vote base... But looking at how things are unfolding, AAP, TMC and others are trying to acquire this space.. This is the most worrying factor ..
@AM-hs7in
@AM-hs7in Год назад
@@Magnet423 ji, I am also hoping 2 yrs is time enough. They have to work really hard if they want to invigorate themselves in 2 yrs
@zahednow
@zahednow Год назад
@@Magnet423 the problem isn't that 2yrs is short time. The problem is that Congress is still hell bount on not acknowledging the elephant in the room and look to solve the issue. Because they know if they do so then gandhi's will loose control of the party
@lagnajitpatnaik1
@lagnajitpatnaik1 Год назад
Brilliant analysis..and such a sad state for Indian democracy... is there light at the end of the tunnel ?
@Sanskar05
@Sanskar05 Год назад
AAP Have The Potential,But Not Happening in 2024 General Elections.
@rahulpratap3459
@rahulpratap3459 Год назад
@@Sanskar05 They are also incompetent, they aren't focusing on industrial sector like Akhilesh/Lalu. They aren't allowing private sector to grow like BJP. India needs capitalistic reforms.
@jatin9070
@jatin9070 Год назад
@@rahulpratap3459 here people and most of the politicians whether in opposition and ruling part are still pretty much high on socialism. So it is difficult to business or organisations even they aren't Ambani and adani to create new infrastructure projects, transport system ,freight corridors, scientific projects ,etc without fearing protests due to mostly misinformation spread by political parties and many NGOs that are foreign funded .
@psroutine7132
@psroutine7132 Год назад
Shehzad poonawala is a gem. Gald to have him in BJP ❤️😅
@ishkenabi6531
@ishkenabi6531 Год назад
Sir aap jo beech beech mein आ आ bolte ho ye bahut best hai
@user-mj1bz3qw4z
@user-mj1bz3qw4z Год назад
आकाश बैनर्जी साब आपके वीडियो का बेसब्री से इंतज़ार करता हूं में आप सच्ची और अच्छी बात करते है 🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏👌🏼👌
@krish_w0030
@krish_w0030 Год назад
Girija tickko ka rape kyu kiya tere bhai n
@prabalsahu1120
@prabalsahu1120 Год назад
I'm from Assam and Himanta Biswa Sarma is one the most talented politician I have ever seen.
@PD_1096
@PD_1096 Год назад
Very thought provoking video. Thanks for the wonderful analysis of the situation. It's unfortunate to see the incompetent opposition led by a a sinking party. Congress needs to get rid of nepotism. RG is practically berozgar without politics. His hunger or rather need for politics and incompetence are the only reasons for the decline of the otherwise wonderful party. Other regional/national parties are too small to form a credible opposition. If Congress wants to save democracy, it should first look inward and democratize the dictatorial party structure led by sycophants and a childish, foolish and incompetent leader. A weak Congress is not good for the country. Congress needs to press the reset button.
@AaronBiswas
@AaronBiswas Год назад
Man new videos almost everyday. Hope you're not overworking yourself Aakash keep it up!!
@Diglose1962
@Diglose1962 Год назад
Of late, what has Azad done for the party on his own ? Does that man tweet in favour of either the party or his own community when they are being attacked ? What guarantees do we have that a new president will not sell out the entire party to the BJP just like the others have done ? Examples galore.
@letsknowthetruthtcrc3868
@letsknowthetruthtcrc3868 Год назад
He enjoyed 50years, but when he was rejected rajya sabha seat, he left.....
@REVIEWSONTHERUN
@REVIEWSONTHERUN Год назад
Thank you for sharing it. ✌️
@smishra.04
@smishra.04 Год назад
Happy Ganesh Chaturthi to all. ❤️❤️❤️
@aravinds123
@aravinds123 Год назад
The analysis is spot on, and as always, well presented too!!
@atishkhodke1207
@atishkhodke1207 Год назад
गर्व से कहो हम "देशभक्त" हैं...🇮🇳
@IamSad56
@IamSad56 Год назад
Ye Deshbhakt nahi chatukar hai !!! Isiliye to itna Rona aa rahi hai !!!
@sameergad3254
@sameergad3254 Год назад
😊बीजेपी हटाओ देश बचाओ बीजेपी हटाओ संविधान बचाओ बीजेपी हटाओ किसान युवाओं की जान बचाओ आंदोलन अभियान चलाओ जय भारत जय संविधान जय भीम 💞🌹🙏 जय जवान जय किसान 🙏🚜🌾
@rushabhyedke6185
@rushabhyedke6185 Год назад
Supporters of BJP proudly say that they support their leader Narendra Modi but Congress supporters never say they are with Congress leader Rahul Gandhi. That's the issue Congress should work on.
@bittushaw5257
@bittushaw5257 5 месяцев назад
India rejected Congress
@ceciliaantony8645
@ceciliaantony8645 Год назад
God save the democracy of this country 🙏🙏
@jioboy2676
@jioboy2676 Год назад
Frankly...situation seems dark for Indian Democracy
@user-ey3dh8gs4j
@user-ey3dh8gs4j Год назад
i am not able to understand why u guys say this as u guys openly criticize ruling party, u have a lot of opposition parties and even on critisizing u r not prisoned, then how r u considering ruling party is destroying democracy.
@Ajaypal-hq3gb
@Ajaypal-hq3gb Год назад
@@user-ey3dh8gs4j To create a building or structure one has to first create foundation, similarly to destroy a structure, first one need to destroy foundation. Foundations are not as easily noticeable as buildings. Moreover, activities targeted at intangible foundations needs vision of extra length with hard work, patience, objectivity, impartiality to be identified.
@neerajsingh5358
@neerajsingh5358 Год назад
@@jioboy2676 *situation seems dark for congress not for Indian democracy, there are many state level party, which are emerging with more potential then Congress, so till 2032 enjoy Indian politics under BJP rule, during 90s RSS opened more schools then Indian gov. now that youth has been prepared for BJP, congress never reached that levels neither they have that much strong pillar nor any visionary leader, so they will never come in power till Rahul alive* 🙏
@sachinkumar-rk9df
@sachinkumar-rk9df Год назад
@@Ajaypal-hq3gb ok give examples
@Vijaydv
@Vijaydv Год назад
Those who cant be with Cong and cant win a seat on their own can move out to clear the way for youngsters!!? But, joining hands with enemy and mocking the party and heads shows the nasty nature of the quitters!! Shame!!
@sumanekka1704
@sumanekka1704 Год назад
Very good criticism... 👍 When the party was in power no one left the party?
@loveall69
@loveall69 Год назад
Maharaja Pradyot Bikram Manikya Debbarma. Former Tripura PCC president. Current chairman of TIPRA Motha. Left congress as Congress was playing Majority-Minority game in Tripura refusing to look after Tripuris. While whole India & also Tripuris were protesting against CAA, Tripuris were also demanding NRC in Tripura. Which both Congress & BJP didn't support as Tripuris are minority & Bengalis (mostly Bangladeshi refugees) are majority. Thats why he left INC & formed a party to represent Tripuris. Today his party is governing Autonomous Council (2/3rd area of Tripura)
@vaibhavvnaik
@vaibhavvnaik Год назад
Kudos just for the fact that you actually have taken the pain to list every damn name!! Tip of the hat 😎
@apg3214
@apg3214 Год назад
We keep cribbing about not having young representatives in politics and then lament the retirements of 70/80 YOs who have ruled for decades and amassed wealth for themselves & their families (slightly generalizing it). Churn in any organization is good and regardless of whether Cong survives or not, it’s good that such oldies are finally quitting politics in hope of better prospects which doesn’t anyways exist for them ! The young ones, they will of course change parties just like we change jobs, we all want a better pay and a meatier job profile - can we blame politicians for that ?
@iceman1125
@iceman1125 Год назад
+1
@zahednow
@zahednow Год назад
Not all old politicians are useless, you need them for their experience and for moving the masses. And greed can be in both young & old, so cannot blame only old for others. Changing parties is not equivalent to changing jobs because some parties opposite ideologies, how can one change his ideology in 1 day?
@DwindlingLamp
@DwindlingLamp Год назад
I am not a political person at all, not supporting any party. But I know that if the old people go away, they take away their experience with them. You loose access to their huge reservoirs of experiences. It is like memory loss. And when you loose memory, you don't know what to do next....
@topicsnow7014
@topicsnow7014 Год назад
Gurgaon They ,are elect because of Hindu Muslim votes and now we also want our two , Mla constituency with Gurgaon ,so that only they do not be small population all the way ,we also want rights
@astromash94
@astromash94 Год назад
The assasinations of Indira Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi were a major blow to Congress. But trying to maintain leadership within the family after this led to its downfall. If the party members don't have confidence in the leadership, and the sheer numbers including those who were long serving members have cited this, it says a lot. Post-independence, it was only Congress at the time that could lead India out of the shambles. Sadly, its a lost cause now!!!
@ashutoshshirke
@ashutoshshirke Год назад
All the leaders who have left the party- what efforts they have taken to connect with the people? Just blaming doesn’t work.
@joyid
@joyid Год назад
Congress - Monarch BJP - Company TMC - Gang Shiv Sena - Ex hardcore Gang Communists - Scam
@jawad9494
@jawad9494 Год назад
AAP
@sudikshasingh304
@sudikshasingh304 Год назад
@@jawad9494 AAP - destroying economy
@kartiksuryawanshi4035
@kartiksuryawanshi4035 Год назад
@@jawad9494 underdog company
@lemonboy21
@lemonboy21 Год назад
@@jawad9494 jhaadu
@rest4peace
@rest4peace Год назад
Rahul Gandhi of Congress team on strike batting, hits every kind of ball from the BJP team .... Gives a call to the non striker but does not take runs....... Non striker is RUN OUT.......
@pdeep3524
@pdeep3524 Год назад
Do you ever think that why this all happened after 2014 😃😃😃
@sayyedayeshaali7945
@sayyedayeshaali7945 Год назад
Idk why I'm keeping so much hope in Congress for a better future of my country but then these hard facts are impossible to ignore.
@stxfdt1240
@stxfdt1240 Год назад
Gorkhaland nhi milega
@stxfdt1240
@stxfdt1240 Год назад
Get lost.
@saurabhsharma7522
@saurabhsharma7522 Год назад
Or option b kya h 🖤🖤
@Scientist1351
@Scientist1351 Год назад
Future is hindutva go cry elsewhere
@syhuhjk
@syhuhjk Год назад
U can go to Pakistan
@anishchit7090
@anishchit7090 Год назад
I am a RSS Swayamsevak since 1999 Bro & I had firm consent on the need of Healthy Constructive Opposition with Diverse Ideology & different Opinion, But its liability on the Course of Leaders of Opposition or their Volunteers working for their Ideology. if they(Volunteers/Workers of Congress) aren't aware of their rights, what can an Outsider do? 1 last thing.... it is not RSS nor Sanghparivar who decided who will be the next BJP President alike J.P. Nadda, It Is Incompetency of Rahul Gandhi & Smt. Sonia Gandhi who made it quite Comfortable.
@vargheseb8602
@vargheseb8602 Год назад
Welcome CHADHI GANG, the true ANTI NATIONALIST
@anishchit7090
@anishchit7090 Год назад
@@vargheseb8602 thanks for your compliment😘😘😘
@saikatghosh9073
@saikatghosh9073 Год назад
Loda Let the congress die and we should establish a Hindu Nation
@user-xe9xi6il2y
@user-xe9xi6il2y Год назад
andbakto se bahas na kare khujli wala kutta smj kr dur rahe 😜 😜
@anjalichakraborty3071
@anjalichakraborty3071 Год назад
Thanks Akash Banerjee for the effort you have taken to make this video. If there is provided the names in written clips, it would be a readymade reference for us.
@ravinarikp
@ravinarikp Год назад
I remember when I was in school I have read a cartoon of Sitaramkeasari kneeling at SoniaGandhi's door and pleading and singing famous telugu song of susmithasen " Sonia sonia sweet sweet sonia" To takeover the INC now......??????
@idealfarming5089
@idealfarming5089 Год назад
Only Deshbhakt Is Proving Information With Real Facts❤️❤️
@praveerranjan7979
@praveerranjan7979 Год назад
Samaj ni atta ye bjp ki itni state mai sarkar hai par kabhi maine inke state leader ko apas mai ladte ni suna aur congress ki 2 ke ilava kahi sarkar ni hai par ladai bahot hai
@fazeelzubair2787
@fazeelzubair2787 Год назад
@@praveerranjan7979 bjp me bhi LaDai hai. Sunne me kuch hi cases aye hai... Pata nahi chupe hue kitne hai. Eg sidhu, subramanyam swami, shatrugan sinha
@praveerranjan7979
@praveerranjan7979 Год назад
@@fazeelzubair2787 aree bhai ye 3no toh chote chote neta hai mai badi ladai ki bat kar raha hu aisi ladai jisme sarkar hi gir jaye🤣 jaise madhya pradesh, karnatka aur rajasthan mai sachin vs ashok
@fazeelzubair2787
@fazeelzubair2787 Год назад
@@praveerranjan7979 dusre factors bhi dekhna padhta... jitna paisa aur power bjp k paas utna Cong k paas nahi k bjp k mla ko qareede ya ED CBI IT raid karwaye
@praveerranjan7979
@praveerranjan7979 Год назад
@@fazeelzubair2787 maine suNa hai ki bjp ke pass electoral bond se bahot paisa mila hua hai. Aur bjp har ek distric mai bade bade office banwa rahi hai
@warwanvalley-atranshimalay2124
This is quite a game, politics. There are no permanent enemies, and no permanent friends, only permanent interests.
@manojaneja1623
@manojaneja1623 Год назад
I am totally agree with you sir. For proper functioning of government there must be an opposition which may protest against dictatorship of ruling government.
@The_Phoenix_61
@The_Phoenix_61 Год назад
The difference between BJP and congress is that former party leaders works for the party's progress while latter party works for leader's progress.
@sanskarsinghpawar2146
@sanskarsinghpawar2146 Год назад
Being a chhattisgarhiya Ajit Jogi leaving INC was one of the most shocking things which happened although he too even after being a great leader had some dark secrets but still it was shocking, Second was Scindia RaGa will never be even 1% of what his father Dadi or Pardada had they think that they can still win everything with same old strategies but Ig till Gandhi family steps aside INC isn't going to comeback ever
@naturelover8121
@naturelover8121 Год назад
I am also from chattisgarh .....what about baghel leadership ....will he be able to survive next year elections
@sanskarsinghpawar2146
@sanskarsinghpawar2146 Год назад
@@naturelover8121 hell yeah bro he isn't losing next year Yeah if at the end time if TS Singh deo leaves for BJP it's gonna be a tough night for INC but otherwise he is winning clean
@naturelover8121
@naturelover8121 Год назад
@@sanskarsinghpawar2146 kaash aisa hi ho ....but sometimes I don't know why ...I get this gut feeling that something is not right .....or something might go wrong .......
@sekhark5480
@sekhark5480 Год назад
The moment congress party is in the hands of non Ghandhi family bjp will buy the Congress party and dissolve it. Then keep aap in opposition which is in the bjp B team.bjp and other parties had buyed 70 congress leaders for power or money . But for bjp it is impossible to buy Ghandhi this is the main reason. Bjp had created Ghandhi must resign president of congress because they want only one party in india that is bjp
@avvn9331
@avvn9331 Год назад
Good episode hope these people get their act soon and become a good opposition and get some balance in democracy
@_ASWJ_
@_ASWJ_ Год назад
I deside that i leave Indian citizen in future
@endwestimperialism637
@endwestimperialism637 Год назад
Good plz jldi nikalo sab gaddar😠🚩
@_ASWJ_
@_ASWJ_ Год назад
@@endwestimperialism637 mai niklega lakin mari property hai na
@csabhisheksharma5184
@csabhisheksharma5184 Год назад
First time ever i saw this guy speaking honestly
@iamsidshaikh7085
@iamsidshaikh7085 Год назад
Brother I have just a sentence for this video.. *It's all about power and money". politics used to a social working but today politics is just a business..
@human6729
@human6729 Год назад
Except aam aadmi party where money is not involved
@sympathiser_of_Germans_in_40s
@@human6729 🤣🤣🤣
@judepinto3328
@judepinto3328 Год назад
I don't know abt others but in Mr. Azad case it's purely personal PM showed some crocodile tears on Azad's last day in Parliament then gave Padma Bhusan award so he forgot Congress simple. Now mark my words he will hv his own party in J&K with backing of BJP. I'm sure he will be a another case like Araminder Singh.
@Dadspenis
@Dadspenis Год назад
Himanta biswa Sharma (cm of assam) is doing his best to develop assam,I'm glad he resigned from Congress
@ShridharPhadke
@ShridharPhadke Год назад
We are not worried about the congress party loosing or BJP getting stronger but the trend is going to destroy the world’s democracy in India. Too much power to any party is always dangerous.
@victorray9369
@victorray9369 Год назад
Of course. For that reason, USA is there. USA will act.
@ShridharPhadke
@ShridharPhadke Год назад
@@victorray9369 why USA ? People of India need to realise this. They need to be educated for protection of so hard earned system of living.
@shanebond1975
@shanebond1975 Год назад
Salute to energy of Akash Bannerjee 🙏
@praveerranjan7979
@praveerranjan7979 Год назад
Samaj ni atta ye bjp ki itni state mai sarkar hai par kabhi maine inke state leader ko apas mai ladte ni suna aur congress ki 2 ke ilava kahi sarkar ni hai par ladai bahot hai
@yashokbabu
@yashokbabu Год назад
For all those who joined BJP by quitting Congress, no excuse or criticism is acceptable for joining BJP because it is not Congress they left but they ditched Congress Ideology and embraced exact opposite ideology.
@jayprakash11223
@jayprakash11223 Год назад
final statement was very true..ruling party is must but important roles is majorly played by opposition party to make new changes and oppose everytime.. very well said Mr. Akash
@sanjeevchadha7493
@sanjeevchadha7493 Год назад
Rahul is not fit for political life. He is not so clever like politicians.
@devenrananaware8923
@devenrananaware8923 Год назад
Congress lost PM faces like Mamta Banerjee, Hemant Biswa Sharma....Gandhi cannot lead congress ..Rahul Gandhi as PM is a nightmare even for Modi haters
@subhambhattacharjee4826
@subhambhattacharjee4826 Год назад
Burnol Moment for Akash 😂😂😂
@anuragsoni3433
@anuragsoni3433 Год назад
The people right now think to protest on there own without involving congress in it as they think congress's involvement will make there protest against govt. weak...think abt it congress...
@manishdhariwal8689
@manishdhariwal8689 Год назад
अभी 25से 45लोग और छोड़ देंगे, यह मोदीजी का एजेंडा सेट करेंगे,
Далее
Free 'Revdi' Culture Destroying India? | Akash Banerjee
16:10
It works! #beatbox #tiktok
00:15
Просмотров 2,9 млн