This is true open border is bad every day 50 nepali girls are sold and forced to work in nepali brothel and its 20thousands girls sold in brothel every year this got increased after 2013 if u search on google this is very bad and this is going on for 20 or 30 years this is very bad for our country and our guys kidneys eyes are getting stolen by these people there is a kidney village in nepal where half of people have only 1 kidney they are tricked and got their kidney stolen .
As a nepali living in Delhi running a small business made me realize that nor Indian or India is against nepal our only enemy is our mindset,governing bodies,educational institutions
Governing bodies and educational institutions vanna le koi ta parcha hola. Non living things ta hoina hola. And of course indian nai hola. Ani kasari neither indian nor india vanera vanna saknu vo?
Before liking this video, read this You discussed the problems of open border. But what about the advantages of open border ? Here is my observations 1. When you have medical emergency, you can easily cross border and get treatment in best indian hospitals. (Nothing is more important than health) 2. When this country has nothing to offer in terms of employment, you can easily cross border without taking any work visa and work in india. (No permission required for employment in india for Nepalese) 3. You talked about business ghata by Nepalese store. Nepalese will buy from that store who offers in less price. Because its there hard earned money. If they can save any small amount, then they will prefer to buy from indian market if they live in border area. It is the responsibility of Nepalese government to ensure balance in price of products in border areas. You have said nothing about role of government in this case. You just criticized open border. 4. You talked about industries and factories getting shut down in Nepal. They major reason is politics nor open border. Because if your product has quality no any international product can beat them in market. But sadly nepali product fails in front of indian because of less capital, less market. Indian products will always have edge over Nepali product because they have money from investors, they have better research team. Nepalese company need to figure out some way to beat them. Here, open border doesn't play any role in failure of Nepalese product. In fact Nepalese will prefer to ask for indian version even if shopkeeper will offer Nepalese version of it. 5. Student from nepal can easily cross border and study in india without taking any noc or permission. Just image children in border areas where there is no any school. If parents want to send school they will send their child to school by crossing border. And there are various others benefits of open border. But there is really some serious concerns about it like human trafficking, border tension and many more. Just wanted to say that cover both the side. Showing only one side of mirror is like spreading hate in the society.
Nice video! I'm from Bardiya and my dad runs a shop but due to indian market we're facing huge loss We've raised this issue to a lot of authorities but none of them seems to be serious about it!
This is true open border is bad every day 50 nepali girls are sold and forced to work in nepali brothel and its 20thousands girls sold in brothel every year this got increased after 2013 if u search on google this is very bad and this is going on for 20 or 30 years this is very bad for our country and our guys kidneys eyes are getting stolen by these people there is a kidney village in nepal where half of people have only 1 kidney they are tricked and got their kidney stolen .
which authorities bro , the same authorities that taxes our bussiness and product so much ..noone with a healthy mind will buy expensive stuff when they can travel few km and get it for way cheaper...the problem is not india ,the problem is our economic policies
Bro taso vaya धरै faida na khae saman bacha na ta. Mai dakha ko xu border bata 5rs ma lya ko saman 10 rs ma bachi rako hunxa. 1ta tatro sano saman ma tati ठूलो fida ta lina milda na ni. 😂 Hamro ta border sahi xa kasa la micha ko xaina.
Yes sell in less price it won't make u lose money but gain more (dherai nafa khayera dherai paisa kamauni soch hunxa tara testo hudaina thorai paisa ma bechnu pahila dherai faida navayeni paxi customer sanga ko biswos jitesi koi india jadainan ni )
@@aashishshah9386 taxation bhanne hunxa ni ta? Hamile india bata saaman lyaayo bhane daro tax lagaidinxa,hamilai india bata without tax lyauna dine ho bhane india ma bhanda sasto retail rate ma dina sakinxa kinaki india bata huge quantity ma lyauda sasto ma painxa,lyaune le illegal tarika bata pani lyauxan without paying the tax but we chose not to do that Nepali saaman kinera bechna parxa which is obviously expensive and people would rather buy poor quality products at cheaper price
thanks brother, we just finished the topic about free border in economics so this helped me a lot to further my understanding about the consequences of free border. keep of the good quality work.
This is true open border is bad every day 50 nepali girls are sold and forced to work in nepali brothel and its 20thousands girls sold in brothel every year this got increased after 2013 if u search on google this is very bad and this is going on for 20 or 30 years this is very bad for our country and our guys kidneys eyes are getting stolen by these people there is a kidney village in nepal where half of people have only 1 kidney they are tricked and got their kidney stolen .
This is true open border is bad every day 50 nepali girls are sold and forced to work in nepali brothel and its 20thousands girls sold in brothel every year this got increased after 2013 if u search on google this is very bad and this is going on for 20 or 30 years this is very bad for our country and our guys kidneys eyes are getting stolen by these people there is a kidney village in nepal where half of people have only 1 kidney they are tricked and got their kidney stolen .
As a resident of Dhangadhi , I can vouch for IDS . The business of local shops of dhangadhi is less to zero as compared to bangau , gaurifanta ( cities of india near the border ) .
This is true open border is bad every day 50 nepali girls are sold and forced to work in nepali brothel and its 20thousands girls sold in brothel every year this got increased after 2013 if u search on google this is very bad and this is going on for 20 or 30 years this is very bad for our country and our guys kidneys eyes are getting stolen by these people there is a kidney village in nepal where half of people have only 1 kidney they are tricked and got their kidney stolen .
This is true open border is bad every day 50 nepali girls are sold and forced to work in nepali brothel and its 20thousands girls sold in brothel every year this got increased after 2013 if u search on google this is very bad and this is going on for 20 or 30 years this is very bad for our country and our guys kidneys eyes are getting stolen by these people there is a kidney village in nepal where half of people have only 1 kidney they are tricked and got their kidney stolen .
it's a great video, but the research should be more in-depth because you are influencing a lot of common peoples. why 90% of Indian product, just ask your self will you trust Nepali brands? also just look at your household you will find 99% Indian product. if India will stop supplying or sell all things we gonna suffer a lot because of chain reaction. first our peoples need to learn how to bargain. 90% of our peoples go for immigrations to overseas. The main spending is women mostly, they are not that capable to bargain, also better to stop TikTok & Facebook fake news habits. all ppl should rise voice for pricing of products. It's my personal opinion.
कुरा एकदम सान्दर्भिक हो। यो बारे नेपाल सरकारले केही गर्छ भन्ने त फिटिक्कै विश्वास छैन। तर यो विषयलाई देशले अघि बढाउनु छ भने मेरो विचारमा सबैभन्दा पहिला भारतिय मुद्रा र नेपाली मुद्राको सटहि दर हालको दुवै देशको GDP को आधारमा कति हुन सक्ला त्यसको आकडा नेपालले निकाल्नु नै पर्छ। भारतको अन्तराष्ट्रिय स्तरमा दबदबा धेरै बढ्दो नै छ र कति देशले भारतिय मुद्रालाई पनि डलर सरहनै आर्थिक कारोबारका निम्ति प्रयोगमा ल्याउन सक्ने प्रबल सम्भावना पनि छ त्यसैले यो विषयमा पनि हामीले सोचेर खुला सिमाना बन्द होइन कि त्यसलाई दुई देशले कसरी नियमन गर्ने त्यो बारे सोच्नु नै पर्छ।
What do you mean? I am from the hills or I guess valley to be proper. Many people in western and far western regions and Eastern regions also totally understand this. You know we share similar culture to hilly people om the other side plus all out religious sites are across the border. Imagine where do people in kathmandu or anywhere go to treatment, going to other countries needs visa so even kathmandu go to Delhi.
@@prabeshhumagai yes its truth and everyone acknowledge the fact of importance of open border. It's not just the border that is down there, it also impact our currency. if only we seal our boarder then we will see how our currency falls from world's highest peak. if someone didn't understand then think why dollar is increases in Nepal but value of Indian currency remain almost same. this policy is helping our currency to sustain.
Daju I am from Nepal janakpur dham,I agree all this point beacouse my village is located in boder side.some time indian army distorb about land dispute. I am very happy you are making this type of video
यो सत्य हो म एउटा व्यापारी हुँ, भारतीय बजारले असर पर्छ तर उपभोग्यवस्तुहरुको मूल्य सस्तो हेरेर कोई पनि जान्छ, यसको लागि नेपालले आफै मा स्व- उत्पादन गर्नुपर्छ। भारत लाई दोष ल्याउन मिल्दैन, ३० भारु को पिठो ९० नेरु पर्छ कसरी महंगी खेल्ने?
Jati nepal ko army ma manxe xaina tyo vanda badi manxe chahinxa border security ko lagi.. So, wall is necessary. Ani most of the army chai Tibet border tira rakhnu parxa because wall possible xaina teta..
@@taakyaavibes I feel that this video is completely biased. I'll ask you a question. Do you know how many restaurant, liquor shop owners became rich overnight in bordering areas due to liquor ban in Bihar? Do you know how Indian tourists boost economy of cities like Pokhara due to easy access into Nepal? The relationship between the bordering areas are from medieval periods (as long as Ram-Janaki). This relationship is tied to culture which cannot be understood by the Khas/Aryas because they were never part of this region. Can you stop the trade deficit if you simply close the borders? Nepal is import dependent country and goods has to be imported through one way or the other. The new immigrants to the region who declare the native residents as foreigners are trying to change the rules to better suit them. This hatred won't improve anything.
@@SunilKumar-wv2sx I agree with you, Nepal can't live without India. The problem is all with politicians. If India stops exporting food in Nepal we will die for sure and India will not loose anything but a tactical Region against China, India bears different loss in maintaining relationship with Nepal from Proteroleum products to many things, India always wants Nepal to be the dearest brother but we all Nepalese have ego issue. We all should accept India is a soft power nation and maintain good relationship otherwise we will become Pakistan one day.
RIP for people who are commenting well researched video or your research is another level And its kind of funny IN-Depth story doesn't know the Story and are forcing opinion please lots of people see your video and I believe u should understand that responsibility. And for more clarification what are u doing To me it seemed like someone convincing me to buy things from Bhatbhateni although I have shop less than min away from my house and is cheaper. And people goes in Occasions only, when they have to buy for large sum of money. Because price matters even travelling 30 40 km it makes india cheaper then I don't think there is option. Second thing, it's not like open border is all what is impacting Nepalese economy. If u want u can make video on how other thing is affecting. Third thing you know nothing about economic blockade. India helped because it was the only way to stop person getting killed like goat. I have listened to bullets firing outside my window. was that a step towards economic progress? Can't talk much about this because at the end so called politicians from Madhesh wasted all it for money or mere seat. I still remember रुखबाट दुई चार आँप खस्यो भने फरक पर्दैन by Kp oli, so why now care about those आँप where ever it goes to buy product. and believe me people go outside border because its only the way to sustain. Every one doesn't earn to afford price in Nepal. And everything can't be found in Nepal. At the end I would say just understand the responsibility you have and was expecting more from u. this video could have been better if u have thought well. yeah it would have been long but better.
I feel that this video is completely biased. I'll ask you a question. Do you know how many restaurant, liquor shop owners became rich overnight in bordering areas due to liquor ban in Bihar? Do you know how Indian tourists boost economy of cities like Pokhara due to easy access into Nepal? The relationship between the bordering areas are from medieval periods (as long as Ram-Janaki). This relationship is tied to culture which cannot be understood by the Khas/Aryas because they were never part of this region. Can you stop the trade deficit if you simply close the borders? Nepal is import dependent country and goods has to be imported through one way or the other. The new immigrants to the region who declare the native residents as foreigners are trying to change the rules to better suit them. This hatred won't improve anything.
@@SunilKumar-wv2sx yeah its seemed like IN-Depth story felt lets make video and then it needed content everyone will support so they used Nepal is declining, india is affecting shit. Open boarder analysis could be talk of hours and it need research of months not the story that everyone want to hear. but no worries lets hope something better will come next time.
If Nepal sealed its borders areas then 50% problems like social, economical and political will be solved automatically. Boarders must be sealed if we want to live as a Nepali and our generation as well
yes must be sealed, but if we have to die as Nepali and our generation as well Also everyone can't afford to buy same thing at double price and everyone isn't fool too. Why including traveling for 20-30km makes india cheap. Let seal the border and solve 50% problem because 50% citizen will die of starvation. we don't earn as people in Kathmandu.
Prices differences between Nepal and India Masino rice price in India 1600nc and in Nepal 1900 to 2000 Sunflower oil rate 1700 in India for 10 litres and 2100 in Nepal 5kg atta price in india 240 and 380 to 450 in Nepal 1kg chini price 65 in India and 100 in Nepal Nepali shop keepers used to buy goods from Indian shops at cheap prices and sell at low cost If the border closes 80% of the population of Nepal will go into starvation because custom duties on the 1kg pack of surf is 60% Chini 40% Car 241% Rice 20 % And many more 1kg chini is
Open border is the greatest oppurtunity for Nepal if nepali business somehow can attract the Indian market the problem if nepali businesses is that they are convention in nature we Nepalese just like to complain about the things but don’t want to improvise
This is what i 'm scared off. " The existential crisis!" . Nobody cares but single step for lavish wedding influenced by bollywood culture happening these days are literally erasing our own identity. Let's back off before it's too late .!!
bhai ali badi reserch vaena yesma, yadi boarder banda vayo vane tesko parinam sochna ni sakdainau, mero bujhai ma open boarder bata badi nepal lai faida cha na ki india lai. desh afai ma nirvar na vaesamma yo sochnu nai na hune kura ho. sano na ramro impact haru chha jaslai timle explane garya chau vane faida lai highlight garna ma kami chha, india ma jun tarika ko development ra foreing investment audai chha tyo hisab le open boarder rahanu ekdam nai jaruri chha nepal ko lagi. aba ko aune 15, 20 barsa ma indian economy jun tarika le raise garchha tyo biswa samu euta udhaharan jastai hunhha ra open boarder le garda hami le kati yesbata faida lina sakchau. policy level ma kei change gare vane hami open boarder bata hune befaida lai yetikai tackle garna sakchau vane, faida chai anekau chha.
Import ra export ma tw saachai dherai thulo farak xa .. haamro deshma k gari export badhaunu.. sarkar lai tw TAX ma interest xa.. hjur le vannu vayo ni udaudo industries lai Nepal government le nai khaidinx.. kasari hola hamro deshko vikas .. jabo 1 litre khaney oil pni pari gayeri liyaunu parney.. anyway this video is totally at the point .. salute to team.. for such resaerches.. hope your more videos on problem ..
If only our politicians were as active in discussing such issues as they are active in choosing Rastrapati or playing games for power, our country wouldn't be in such a sorry state.
This is true open border is bad every day 50 nepali girls are sold and forced to work in nepali brothel and its 20thousands girls sold in brothel every year this got increased after 2013 if u search on google this is very bad and this is going on for 20 or 30 years this is very bad for our country and our guys kidneys eyes are getting stolen by these people there is a kidney village in nepal where half of people have only 1 kidney they are tricked and got their kidney stolen .
Teita bro 2/4 barsa dukha payera sovereignty bachha vane bacham Desh ko fertile land sab plotting garesi daam ta badi halka Nepal le Dhan nai import garnu parxa ra ramro technology use garyo vane farming ma?
Pros and cons of Nepali currency being pegged to India’s currency and I believe this is discussion when we talk about Nepal's open border policy so think about this video. Also don't propose theory what might happen when two country share open boarder that is its currency is pegged. Share what will happen in aspect of Nepal and India. India being Economic giant how our currency is saved. and what will happen if it's not. Don't say if India comes in economic crisis then it will impact Nepal because India is not coming in crisis like Nepal.
I am from madhesh and I see alot of people are under the influence of India in all aspects like political and religion. Recently when there is some Hindu-muslim case rose up in India, people of madhesh started to fought as I am nepali it makes me very sad.i saw a lot of house with indian flag over there terrace.Hindi language is being used by teacher during class in Many of the fomous school/college of our area .I also support your vision bro that boarder should be close Your videos are really awesome keep it up broo❤️
@@santani-hk5rj I feel that this video is completely biased. I'll ask you a question. Do you know how many restaurant, liquor shop owners became rich overnight in bordering areas due to liquor ban in Bihar? Do you know how Indian tourists boost economy of cities like Pokhara due to easy access into Nepal? The relationship between the bordering areas are from medieval periods (as long as Ram-Janaki). This relationship is tied to culture which cannot be understood by the Khas/Aryas because they were never part of this region. Can you stop the trade deficit if you simply close the borders? Nepal is import dependent country and goods has to be imported through one way or the other. The new immigrants to the region who declare the native residents as foreigners are trying to change the rules to better suit them. This hatred won't improve anything.
@@SunilKumar-wv2sx lmao. You are completely out of your mind. Are you telling me, for the sake of few businessmen, we should risk our culture and existence? By the way, Nepali market is the one which is at risk. Indian farmers and businessmen are the ones who are making more money. You have no idea how many local farmers and businesses of Nepal are affected by open border. Open border is a major reason for human trafficking and smuggling. Many criminals, terrorist fled from India have been arrested in Nepal. Our security is at risk as well. Open border should be closed for good. As said in the video, Entry (with a pass) from certain check points should be allowed so that the business and cultural aspect doesn't get hampered. People from the both countries will be able to travel freely but also legally. Most importantly, the border issue will be solved peacefully.
Advantages: Nepali citizens can actually join Indian Civil Service( Without any issues whatsoever). So Nepalis have full right and scope to influence India provided they prove themselves eligibile for that. And well, no problem of religion especially in eastern side. People also look similar. Culturally we are still part of one Big civilisation.
1.04 trillion bepar ghataa vane paxita.😲😲😲 Haami bidesh jaanu ra remittance pathaunuta indako laagi pathako jasto ra india lai dhani banai raa ko rahexau yar..😲😲 Haami indiako samaan kini Rahani , India lai rich banai rahani.. Ani haami garip ko garip , hepaima pareko pare sadai Concussion: (Hamley sikana parni paath/lessions and garna parni kura) 1)Close india-Nepal border 2) increase "Made In Nepal" products 3)vote to right qualify+educated+capable leader Like rabi, rajendra lingden, balen,harka sampang, gyandendra sah etc
The situation of businesses getting low in bordering towns is similar in Bhutan as well But Bhutan has proper border demarcations with India and no issues related with borders where as in the north the case is opposite with china this clearly shows how the two giants react according with the retaliation a country is having with them
नेपालमा महङ्गो र भारतीय बजारमा सस्तो मूल्यमा सामान पाइन्छ। स्वाभाविक रुपमा मानिसले सस्तो मूल्यमा नै पाइने सामान किन्छ। भारतीय बजारकै मूल्यमा नेपाली बजारमा सामान पाइए भारतीय बजार जान रोकिन्छ कि ।
This should be really considered by the government and the border cannot be closed immediately because it might impact nepal culturally and economically but it can be closed slowly in the span of decades which can help nepal to be economically more stable and less dependent to india and it will also help to decrease the marital ties of nepal and india slowly.also maybe they should make fence around the border and open it at only certain points while also regulating the no of people coming and going and their intention and their identity also.
the market of bhadrapur is completely dry too due to open border the debt of businessman is increasing consistently which has also played an significant role in current liquidity crisis.
Is there any formal documentation or oration from government authority stating that India imposed “blockade”? And about the language being “Hindikaran”, The Nepal government itself has done more harm. What did it do to protect its language and poet? Speaking Maithali (for eg) is rather being “Nepalikaran”, and many of us has amalgamated nepali words into our vocabulary. For eg jhyal, ekxin, sathi instead of saying khidki, kanik der, sangatiya. And many more nepalese slang. And there is nothing wrong with being Nepalikaran or Hindikaran, every language goes through evolution and rightly so.
due to open border farmers are able to bring fertilizers low income family who have 10000 income near border district they are able to survive nepal business man or bayapari simply they are too costly then actual suitable product . and regarding bad income in india of nepali , almost india and china are cheapest labour espically bihari and hindi karan language , bro all nepali almost know hindi , and where is army nepali , apf, ( forget about elephant nose map ) see bihar bsf how they are slowly becoming agressive , problem is every where only system employee is some how ill lgocial lets see own problem , too costly for 1 kg sugar almost 90 rupees , but in india 40 , 30 , see how middle class family of 10000 income buy 90 rupees sugar , at least see , 1 small copy is 100 rupees , in india 50 for fat copy lets see open order is for middle class not for rich , and so called .............................. every machine parts come from india but nepali shop sell that thing 4 times higher , , in depth bro open border encroachment is political problem and trafficking , not peoples problem , for middle class family and income of 10000 whom should i choose ???? nation ??? or to survive my family ???? and first get research in depth level not surface , talking against india , gorkhali jinda bad , and last LPG india Petrol India Salt india vegetable india car india delhi agreement india (rana regime ) maoist peace agreement india help political internal conflict india help first we should try to get practical not emotional now so called gorkhali (salt of india and gas of fuel of india ) becoming aggressive , bro what is the problem accept it and do some make in nepal at cheap price, bring good from india and sell in nepal but don't take too much profit , ris uthyo kya ho timilai !!!!!!!!!! 🤣
Hijo Nepalgunj Yamaha showroom ma gako bike repair garauna, atleast Rs.40000 lagx vanyo. India, Nepalgunj bata ekdamai najik x, tesaile hami tetai gayera sodhem, same genuine saman Rs.16000 (IC 10000) ma vai halx vanyo. Ati ko big difference x, hamro desh ma mahangai almost double vayeko karan le border ma basne manxe haru indian market dherai prefer garxan. I hope our goverment does something about it.
