Тёмный

Why don't we feel the Earth spinning? 

Dr. Becky
Подписаться 760 тыс.
Просмотров 118 тыс.
50% 1

The Earth rotates on its axis at 1,000 miles per hour (at the equator) - so why don't we feel it?! Go to brilliant.org/DrBecky and sign up for free. The first 200 people that go to that link will get 20% off the annual premium subscription.
Check out Sarah's channel (‪@SarahLavenderASMR‬) if you like ASMR or want to try it out to aid concentration, relax, or ease symptoms of anxiety or depression: / sarahlavenderasmr
Here's the collaboration we did with Sarah where I sent her some space facts! • ASMR | Fascinating Fac...
Timelapse of Earth rotation from ‪@art_only‬: • Earth's Rotation Visua...
My "Astrophysicist at work" playlist on Apple Music: / astrophysicist-at-work
and on Spotify: open.spotify.com/playlist/0So...
----
📚 "Space: 10 Things You Should Know": bit.ly/SpaceDrBecky
📚 US & Canada version: "Space at the speed of light" (same book, different title): www.penguinrandomhouse.com/bo...
📚 German translation "Das kleine Buch vom großen Knall" : www.dtv.de/buch/becky-smethur...
---
🎧 Royal Astronomical Society Podcast that I co-host: podfollow.com/supermassive
---
🔔 Don't forget to subscribe and click the little bell icon to be notified when I post a new video!
--
The artwork in the background is a scientifically accurate map showing the orbits of more than 18000 asteroids in the Solar System, created by Eleanor Lutz. Find out more and buy one here: eleanorlutz.com/mapping-18000...
---
👩🏽‍💻 I'm Dr Becky Smethurst, an astrophysicist at the University of Oxford. I love making videos about science with an unnatural level of enthusiasm. I like to focus on how we know things, not just what we know. And especially, the things we still don't know. If you've ever wondered about something in space and couldn't find an answer online - you can ask me! My day job is to do research into how supermassive black holes can affect the galaxies that they live in. In particular, I look at whether the energy output from the disk of material orbiting around a growing supermassive black hole can stop a galaxy from forming stars.
drbecky.uk.com
rebeccasmethurst.co.uk

Наука

Опубликовано:

 

11 ноя 2020

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,3 тыс.   
@DrBecky
@DrBecky 3 года назад
A fun short one from me this week, filmed before I went away on holiday last week. A much longer Night Sky News coming next week 👍
@stellarhorizons01
@stellarhorizons01 3 года назад
Becky, I have a question concerning black holes. If no light does not escape a black hole, how do we take an image of it owing to the fact that some of the light should be reflected off it to be detected by our equipment?
@Shenron557
@Shenron557 3 года назад
Thanks for the explanation in the video. However, I have few questions. 1) Since the surface of the earth undergoes circular motion, won't we feel the centripetal acceleration? Or the force pulling us towards the equator due to the centripetal acceleration if we are away from the equator? 2) If we are in a merry-go-round, we can feel our head spinning after a while. Shouldn't that same thing happen to us on the spinning earth?
@silo_fx3182
@silo_fx3182 3 года назад
Whoops. think your link to Sarah's channel is going to Owl City. Edit: The RU-vid link at the end of the paragraph.
@ws1982
@ws1982 3 года назад
Good video Becky. Wait for the flat earth trolls.
@DrBecky
@DrBecky 3 года назад
@@silo_fx3182 whoops good catch!
@marxbanger2886
@marxbanger2886 3 года назад
i only feel the earth's rotational spin when i'm drunk.
@josephd27
@josephd27 3 года назад
Haha
@nazeerabdulazeez8896
@nazeerabdulazeez8896 3 года назад
പൊളിച്ചു മച്ചാനേ ♥️♥️drink enjoy 👍
@saul_goodman15
@saul_goodman15 3 года назад
Hhhhhhh
@frankdimeglio8216
@frankdimeglio8216 Год назад
Think about TIME (generally and basically) using common sense. Carefully consider what is the Sun ON BALANCE. The stars AND PLANETS are POINTS in the night sky ON BALANCE, AND consider what is the speed of light (c) ON BALANCE. Consider TIME (AND time dilation) ON BALANCE !! GREAT. Think about what is THE EYE, AND think about outer “space” ON BALANCE !! TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE !! Great !!!! Have a LOOK at what is the ORANGE (AND setting) SUN. CLEAR water comes from what is THE EYE. Consider what is the TRANSLUCENT AND BLUE sky (ON BALANCE), AS WHAT IS THE EARTH IS ALSO BLUE !!! GREAT !!! TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE, AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE) !!! (BALANCE AND completeness go hand in hand.) GREAT !!! It ALL CLEARLY makes perfect sense ON BALANCE. Total perfection. ACCORDINGLY, ON BALANCE, the rotation of WHAT IS THE MOON matches the revolution !!! By Frank Martin DiMeglio Consider what is THE SUN. Consider what is E=MC2. Keep it simple. Gravity/acceleration involves BALANCED inertia/INERTIAL RESISTANCE. GRAVITATIONAL force/ENERGY IS proportional to (or BALANCED with/as) inertia/INERTIAL RESISTANCE. TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE, AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE) !!! Magnificent. ACCORDINGLY, ON BALANCE, the rotation of WHAT IS THE MOON matches the revolution. “Mass"/ENERGY involves BALANCED inertia/INERTIAL RESISTANCE consistent WITH/AS what is BALANCED electromagnetic/gravitational force/ENERGY !! This necessarily represents, INVOLVES, AND describes what is possible/potential AND actual (ON/IN BALANCE), AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY (AND NECESSARILY) proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE); AS TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE !!! WHAT IS E=MC2 is taken directly from F=ma, AS TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE; AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE) !!! WHAT IS E=MC2 IS dimensionally consistent !!! It is FULLY consistent with why what are OBJECTS may fall at the SAME RATE !!! Great. WHAT IS GRAVITY is, ON BALANCE, an INTERACTION that cannot be shielded or blocked, AS TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE; AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE) !!! GREAT !!! By Frank Martin DiMeglio
@frankdimeglio8216
@frankdimeglio8216 Год назад
WHAT IS GRAVITY IS, ON BALANCE, an INTERACTION that cannot be shielded or blocked. WHAT IS E=MC2 IS dimensionally consistent, AS TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE; AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE) !!! BALANCE AND completeness go hand in hand. GREAT !!! WHAT IS GRAVITY IS, ON BALANCE, an INTERACTION that cannot be shielded or blocked. (WHAT IS E=MC2 IS dimensionally consistent.) Consider what is the man (AND THE EYE ON BALANCE) who IS standing on WHAT IS THE EARTH/ground, AS touch AND feeling BLEND; AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE); AS TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE !!! BALANCE AND completeness go hand in hand. WHAT IS GRAVITY IS, ON BALANCE, an INTERACTION that cannot be shielded or blocked. WHAT IS E=MC2 IS dimensionally consistent, AS “mass"/ENERGY involves BALANCED inertia/INERTIAL RESISTANCE consistent WITH/AS what is BALANCED electromagnetic/gravitational force/ENERGY; AS TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE; AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE); AS gravity/acceleration involves BALANCED inertia/INERTIAL RESISTANCE (ON BALANCE). INDEED, GRAVITATIONAL force/ENERGY IS proportional to (or BALANCED with/as) inertia/INERTIAL RESISTANCE; AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE); AS TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE !!! The stars AND PLANETS are POINTS in the night sky. WHAT IS E=MC2 IS dimensionally consistent !!! Accordingly, ON BALANCE, THE PLANETS (including what is THE EARTH) sweep out equal areas in equal times. Consider TIME (AND time dilation) ON BALANCE. WHAT IS E=MC2 is taken directly from F=ma, AS TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE; AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE). WHAT IS GRAVITY IS, ON BALANCE, an INTERACTION that cannot be shielded or blocked. WHAT IS E=MC2 IS dimensionally consistent !!! CLEARLY, gravity AND ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy are linked AND BALANCED opposites (ON BALANCE); as the stars AND PLANETS are POINTS in the night sky. Consider TIME (AND time dilation) ON BALANCE. INDEED, TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE; AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE) !!! GREAT !!! ACCORDINGLY, ON BALANCE, the rotation of WHAT IS THE MOON matches the revolution. GREAT !!! WHAT IS E=MC2 IS dimensionally consistent. GREAT !!! It is a very great truth that the SELF represents, FORMS, and experiences a COMPREHENSIVE approximation of experience in general by combining conscious and unconscious experience. INDEED, the INTEGRATED EXTENSIVENESS of THOUGHT AND description is improved in the truly superior mind. BALANCE AND completeness go hand in hand. By Frank Martin DiMeglio
@Rubrickety
@Rubrickety 3 года назад
Of course, when we move north or south, our velocity due to earth’s rotation does change (because the speed of rotation is zero at the poles). Hence the Coriolis “force”. This is why toilets in Australia have trolls in them.
@williamswenson5315
@williamswenson5315 3 года назад
Really? We just have them on the internet here.
@martinphillpot2010
@martinphillpot2010 3 года назад
Naaah, crocodiles ate all the trolls.
@glendownton
@glendownton 3 года назад
Toilets in Australia have spiders in them
@williamswenson5315
@williamswenson5315 3 года назад
@@glendownton Are they brown and reclusive?
@williamswenson5315
@williamswenson5315 3 года назад
@@martinphillpot2010 Probably true. Crocs will attempt to eat just about anything.
@michaelphillipps4318
@michaelphillipps4318 3 года назад
Ok that time-lapse video with the fixed star position was wicked cool.
@d.t.4523
@d.t.4523 3 года назад
👍
@ithinkthonkthunk5333
@ithinkthonkthunk5333 3 года назад
I agree it was cool! Thats what a mechanical gyroscope should do but it doesn’t...
@zwiddeldum
@zwiddeldum 3 года назад
This one is even better: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-DmwaUBY53YQ.html
@bgi142
@bgi142 3 года назад
But doesn't the earth rotate around the sun that would make the timelapse not possible
@ratataran
@ratataran 3 года назад
@@bgi142 no, the earth rotates against its axis. We revolve around the sun.
@frankowalker4662
@frankowalker4662 3 года назад
That fixed star time lapse blew me away. What stunning photography.
@dangmangcarpenter8800
@dangmangcarpenter8800 3 года назад
I feel it spinning every Friday night.More so on Saturday morning.
@Oatmealyum
@Oatmealyum 3 года назад
?
@stlrepper711
@stlrepper711 3 года назад
@@Oatmealyum drunk then hungover
@Oatmealyum
@Oatmealyum 3 года назад
@@stlrepper711 oh.. LOL
@robertjhall5844
@robertjhall5844 3 года назад
“Let’s physics the hell out of this.” - Love it!
@jamescollier3
@jamescollier3 Год назад
yeah. then she used no physics and conflated speed and acceleration. Doesn't she have a phd?
@frankdimeglio8216
@frankdimeglio8216 Год назад
@@jamescollier3 Gravity AND ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy are linked AND BALANCED opposites ON BALANCE. Consider TIME AND time dilation ON BALANCE. Great. GRAVITY AND TWO DIMENSIONAL SPACE ARE CONSISTENT WITH E=MC2: E=MC2 is taken directly from F=ma. TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE. The TRANSLUCENT blue sky is manifest as (or consistent with/as) what is BALANCED BODILY/VISUAL EXPERIENCE. Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the TRANSLUCENT blue sky is true/real QUANTUM GRAVITY. THINK!!! ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE). Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the rotation of WHAT IS THE MOON matches it's revolution. Importantly, what is gravity cannot be shielded (or blocked) ON BALANCE. Great. You didn't forget to consider what is the orange AND setting Sun ON BALANCE, did you!!? Magnificent. I have FUNDAMENTALLY and truly revolutionized physics. (Lava is orange, AND it is even blood red.) GREAT !!!! Obviously, carefully and CLEARLY consider what is THE EYE ON BALANCE, as it ALL CLEARLY makes perfect sense ON BALANCE. (BALANCE AND completeness go hand in hand.). Fantastic !!! By Frank Martin DiMeglio
@michelle_h
@michelle_h 3 года назад
"Let's physics the hell out of this" Literally my favourite line ever! That just made my day😂
@mindbomb9341
@mindbomb9341 3 года назад
Did not physics the hell out of it at all.
@jamesduncanlinch6322
@jamesduncanlinch6322 3 года назад
She did not, it’s circular motion there is acceleration. She used a false argument deliberately to avoid using maths calculating the acceleration and showing that is negligible, in particular compared to gravity. She knows that the argument is false.
@elymayer4860
@elymayer4860 3 года назад
@@jamesduncanlinch6322 she did.
@godsbeautifulflatearth
@godsbeautifulflatearth 3 года назад
Provides no proof.
@mopar_dude9227
@mopar_dude9227 3 года назад
I felt the Earth move last Friday, but it could have just been the Bourbon.
@filopat67
@filopat67 3 года назад
I have a vivid memory from the time when I was five or six years old and I was alone lying on my back late in the evening among the pine trees near our house, watching trees pointing to the starry sky above me and physically feeling the earths rotation. It's a strong and important memory to me and no matter how much math and physics you throw at me, you can't convince me that I wasn't able to feel the rotation. I did feel it!
@compulsiverambler1352
@compulsiverambler1352 2 года назад
I've had that too, after too many glasses of wine.
@rayquaza396
@rayquaza396 3 года назад
You just answered my question that's been lingering me since I was a kid! Thank you do much!
@duderoony
@duderoony 3 года назад
Nice little topic Becks. I enjoyed it. Enjoy your break. And thank you for another one.
@condorboss3339
@condorboss3339 3 года назад
1:40 That's the FIRST terminal velocity. The _second_ terminal velocity is after you hit the ground because you kept your eyes closed and forgot to open your parachute. ;P
@hang_kentang6709
@hang_kentang6709 3 года назад
that's the terminus est.
@bierrollerful
@bierrollerful 3 года назад
Those timelapse videos are amazing. Also: dogs sticking their heads out of cars for some mysterious reason. Great job, Editing Becky!
@dewiz9596
@dewiz9596 3 года назад
Dogs are sampling the different smells.
@proformahaul6274
@proformahaul6274 3 года назад
I’ve seen so many videos about this topic but this did it for me , thank you
@Divedown_25
@Divedown_25 3 года назад
Great short video Dr. Becky. Keep them coming.
@Edsbar
@Edsbar 3 года назад
1000 miles per hour at the equator, less in sunny Oxford at about 52.5° north. An angular speed of one revolution per day or 0.000694444444 rpm doesn't quite have the racing car appeal does it.
@Naifukiti
@Naifukiti 3 года назад
Tell that to a flatearther
@Edsbar
@Edsbar 3 года назад
Having said that It was a very good video. I'm surprised a scientist would get tripped up on the difference between linear speed and angular speed; I do hope Becky isn't becoming a flatard.
@Stydorf
@Stydorf 3 года назад
Rpm doesn't matter when you are not on anywhere on the axis of rotation.
@Edsbar
@Edsbar 3 года назад
@@Stydorf Distance/Time is linear (a straight line) and a Revolutions/Time (a constant arc until you arrive back where you started is one revolution). If you stand on the equator you are traveling 24,000 miles in a day but if you stand 1 metre from the North Pole you are travelling about 6 metre in the same day and that is why revolutions/Time is more suitable way of measuring something that is rotating.
@Stydorf
@Stydorf 3 года назад
Your argument was that rpm is negligible. But I'm saying it's negligible only when you're on the supposed axis. The surface at equator is approx 4000 miles away from supposed axis. 1000 mph speed is what matters at the surface not rpm.
@thomaskositzki9424
@thomaskositzki9424 3 года назад
I fund this video actually a bit... badly explained? 'Badly' is too hard a word, but I am just a German, I haven't got any better at the moment. :) Additions: 1) One of the reasons why we don't feel constant movement (the one that matters here I think) is a biological one. It is connected to how the inner ear's organ for detecting movement, the semicircular canals with their otoliths, are set up. They are basically little calcium carbonate crytsalls moving about in little canals - that movement is detected by hair cells and send to the brain. So they can only detect acceleration and deceleration. 2) Also there is one very distinct field where you are confronted with the movement of the earth very directly: military gun ballistics. Already back in WW2 and before the gun ranges were such (for artillery, but also for tanks) that the Coriolis effect was noticable enough to be included in training manuals. When you fired along a north-south-axis, you had a sligh deviation to either side, depending on direction. Firing eastwards, shot fell a little short; firing westward, shot went a little longer. Hope you don't mind me being picky. ^^
@torytrae1974
@torytrae1974 3 года назад
1) Your implication seems to be that with appropriate biological senses we could feel this movement. This is false. The reason why we do not feel it is based on physical laws not on biological. At a constant speed there is no force applied that anything could detect (any biological or mechanical sensor included). It is true that the earth rotation follows a curve thus there are ways to measure this drift - but this is another point as you referred specifically to constant movement. 2) The coriolis force / effect direction depends on the hemisphere. The correct example is: In the northern hemisphere a projectile fired northward (away from equator) would appear to drift eastward due to coriollis effect and those that are fired southward (towards the equator) would appear to drift westward.
@thomaskositzki9424
@thomaskositzki9424 3 года назад
@@torytrae1974 You are right on point one, I didn't think it through. Thanks for the correction! On point two, I think I put it in a unspecific way, didn't want to write for too long. :)
@darlabenz3097
@darlabenz3097 3 года назад
I always wondered about this. Thank you for clearing it up!!!!
@expchrist
@expchrist 3 года назад
Such a great opener! I love this channel.
@gerrie2477
@gerrie2477 3 года назад
3:45 WOW, firken WOW what a great concept, and a supremely fantastical video representation of this concept . . . incredible
@SarahLavenderASMR
@SarahLavenderASMR 3 года назад
Loved this so much! Super interesting. I'm still in awe that you listen to my videos while working. 😊❤️ Cheers!
@DANGJOS
@DANGJOS 3 года назад
You ASMRtists may have a few other, even more famous, people watching you, and you wouldn't even know.
@mikkj1
@mikkj1 3 года назад
@@DANGJOS Well, they do say that they're watching, but they say it VERY softly, so...
@d.t.4523
@d.t.4523 3 года назад
👍
@frankdimeglio8216
@frankdimeglio8216 Год назад
Gravity AND ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy are linked AND BALANCED opposites ON BALANCE. Consider TIME AND time dilation ON BALANCE. Great. GRAVITY AND TWO DIMENSIONAL SPACE ARE CONSISTENT WITH E=MC2: E=MC2 is taken directly from F=ma. TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE. The TRANSLUCENT blue sky is manifest as (or consistent with/as) what is BALANCED BODILY/VISUAL EXPERIENCE. Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the TRANSLUCENT blue sky is true/real QUANTUM GRAVITY. THINK!!! ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE). Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the rotation of WHAT IS THE MOON matches it's revolution. Importantly, what is gravity cannot be shielded (or blocked) ON BALANCE. Great. You didn't forget to consider what is the orange AND setting Sun ON BALANCE, did you!!? Magnificent. I have FUNDAMENTALLY and truly revolutionized physics. (Lava is orange, AND it is even blood red.) GREAT !!!! Obviously, carefully and CLEARLY consider what is THE EYE ON BALANCE, as it ALL CLEARLY makes perfect sense ON BALANCE. (BALANCE AND completeness go hand in hand.). Fantastic !!! By Frank Martin DiMeglio
@patrickrochel9827
@patrickrochel9827 3 года назад
This is awesome, your channel is fantastic!!
@JanRautiainen
@JanRautiainen 3 года назад
Came over from SciManDan podcast and subbed, great field of study you have, hope to learn more myself, thanks for sharing your knowledge and experience
@duprasi8144
@duprasi8144 3 года назад
Actually the spinning of the Earth has some (small) effect on Earth's surface. Namely the centrifugal force "pulls" us away from Earth's rotational axis. For this reason at the equator gravity appears about 0.034m/s² weaker than it would be on a still Earth (or at the poles). Furthermore, because the centrifugal force is't necessarily aligned with the gravitational force, the apparent center of gravity shifts slightly towards the equator, depending on where you are (up to 0,595° at 26,3°N/S). It took me way too long to calculate this ....
@alphonseraynaud976
@alphonseraynaud976 3 года назад
wow, great that you calculated it, I actually wanted to point out the fact the we feel the centrifugal force
@RM_VFX
@RM_VFX 2 года назад
It has effects you can see as well, like the coriolis effect, which causes water to rotate as it goes down the drain, rather than flow straight down.
@frankdimeglio8216
@frankdimeglio8216 Год назад
@@alphonseraynaud976 Gravity AND ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy are linked AND BALANCED opposites ON BALANCE. Consider TIME AND time dilation ON BALANCE. Great. GRAVITY AND TWO DIMENSIONAL SPACE ARE CONSISTENT WITH E=MC2: E=MC2 is taken directly from F=ma. TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE. The TRANSLUCENT blue sky is manifest as (or consistent with/as) what is BALANCED BODILY/VISUAL EXPERIENCE. Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the TRANSLUCENT blue sky is true/real QUANTUM GRAVITY. THINK!!! ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE). Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the rotation of WHAT IS THE MOON matches it's revolution. Importantly, what is gravity cannot be shielded (or blocked) ON BALANCE. Great. You didn't forget to consider what is the orange AND setting Sun ON BALANCE, did you!!? Magnificent. I have FUNDAMENTALLY and truly revolutionized physics. (Lava is orange, AND it is even blood red.) GREAT !!!! Obviously, carefully and CLEARLY consider what is THE EYE ON BALANCE, as it ALL CLEARLY makes perfect sense ON BALANCE. (BALANCE AND completeness go hand in hand.). Fantastic !!! By Frank Martin DiMeglio
@frankdimeglio8216
@frankdimeglio8216 Год назад
@@RM_VFX Gravity AND ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy are linked AND BALANCED opposites ON BALANCE. Consider TIME AND time dilation ON BALANCE. Great. GRAVITY AND TWO DIMENSIONAL SPACE ARE CONSISTENT WITH E=MC2: E=MC2 is taken directly from F=ma. TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE. The TRANSLUCENT blue sky is manifest as (or consistent with/as) what is BALANCED BODILY/VISUAL EXPERIENCE. Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the TRANSLUCENT blue sky is true/real QUANTUM GRAVITY. THINK!!! ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE). Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the rotation of WHAT IS THE MOON matches it's revolution. Importantly, what is gravity cannot be shielded (or blocked) ON BALANCE. Great. You didn't forget to consider what is the orange AND setting Sun ON BALANCE, did you!!? Magnificent. I have FUNDAMENTALLY and truly revolutionized physics. (Lava is orange, AND it is even blood red.) GREAT !!!! Obviously, carefully and CLEARLY consider what is THE EYE ON BALANCE, as it ALL CLEARLY makes perfect sense ON BALANCE. (BALANCE AND completeness go hand in hand.). Fantastic !!! By Frank Martin DiMeglio
@MustafaAlmosawi
@MustafaAlmosawi 3 года назад
The three beats of watching this video. 1. Some dude singing. Wait a minute, this a Dr Becky video, right? Did I click on the wrong link? 2. Dr. Becky, mug in hand, taking a sassy sip. What’s going on now? 3.. Lets Physics the Hell out of this. Mood.
@cobinasaur
@cobinasaur 3 года назад
I thought that was an ad.
@lustechsource5197
@lustechsource5197 3 года назад
Thanks! This has been very infromative!
@DavidBeckwitt
@DavidBeckwitt 3 года назад
Your editing is on point! Nice video! :)
@TotalRookie_LV
@TotalRookie_LV 3 года назад
One rotation per 24 hours isn't exactly a mind blowing speed that would confuse our senses.
@TotalRookie_LV
@TotalRookie_LV 3 года назад
@xrm160xqw Well, recent study suggests, even if neutron stars have some imperfections to their shape, it's below a thickness of a human hair, or else gravity waves caused by rotation of such bodies would be detected.
@atmostud39
@atmostud39 3 года назад
We are only moving 1000 mph at the equator. Zero at the poles. And somewhere in between, in between.
@Chris-hx3om
@Chris-hx3om 3 года назад
The "somewhere in between" is 1,000 multiplied by the cosine of your latitude (north or south, makes no difference).
@atmostud39
@atmostud39 3 года назад
@@Chris-hx3om That sounds right!
@CaptainXJ
@CaptainXJ 3 года назад
My favorite was sitting no the front of the carrier watching the sunrise. You felt still while the horizon just moved up and down continuously.
@pbutler0731
@pbutler0731 3 года назад
Love your playlist!!
@Candesce
@Candesce 3 года назад
Hi Becky, I just want to say you have helped inspire me to follow my dreams and I'm currently enrolling back at University to pursue a bachelor's in astrophysics. I'm 29 and currently make six figures so it's so scary but my boss is letting me work part time while I work on my degree. Thanks so much for being an inspiration.
@DrBecky
@DrBecky 3 года назад
That’s awesome Karina - all the best!
@bobgreen9897
@bobgreen9897 3 года назад
@@DrBecky Hi, please help me. I posted a question here 4 days ago. Help 🙂👍 oh and you're really brilliant!
@lumity6production532
@lumity6production532 3 года назад
Wow....im 26 and thinking to do the same...!!!!
@frankdimeglio8216
@frankdimeglio8216 Год назад
@@DrBecky Einstein never nearly understood gravity or time. He was lazy. It was always (and it still is) clear that he was not a high level genius. Here are the facts. Modern physics is political. It is far more about making money (and asserting control) than it is about truth and making sense. You cannot understand the fundamentals of physics apart from what I have mathematically proven. The mainstream US m ass media is parasitic, and they are ruinous and untrustworthy. We never got the full truth out of Einstein, and we never will. What is E=MC2 is taken directly from F=ma, AS TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE; AS ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE); AS the rotation of WHAT IS THE MOON matches the revolution. FACTS. By Frank Martin DiMeglio
@frankdimeglio8216
@frankdimeglio8216 Год назад
​@@DrBecky Gravity AND ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy are linked AND BALANCED opposites ON BALANCE. Consider TIME AND time dilation ON BALANCE. Great. GRAVITY AND TWO DIMENSIONAL SPACE ARE CONSISTENT WITH E=MC2: E=MC2 is taken directly from F=ma. TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE. The TRANSLUCENT blue sky is manifest as (or consistent with/as) what is BALANCED BODILY/VISUAL EXPERIENCE. Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the TRANSLUCENT blue sky is true/real QUANTUM GRAVITY. THINK!!! ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE). Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the rotation of WHAT IS THE MOON matches it's revolution. Importantly, what is gravity cannot be shielded (or blocked) ON BALANCE. Great. You didn't forget to consider what is the orange AND setting Sun ON BALANCE, did you!!? Magnificent. I have FUNDAMENTALLY and truly revolutionized physics. (Lava is orange, AND it is even blood red.) GREAT !!!! Obviously, carefully and CLEARLY consider what is THE EYE ON BALANCE, as it ALL CLEARLY makes perfect sense ON BALANCE. (BALANCE AND completeness go hand in hand.). Fantastic !!! By Frank Martin DiMeglio
@agargamer6759
@agargamer6759 3 года назад
Huh, I thought this video would be about calculating the (tiny) radial acceleration due to the earth's spin, and how it would change based on latitude and stuff.
@samiam.402
@samiam.402 2 года назад
I was hoping this would be addressed.
@sorcerykid
@sorcerykid 2 года назад
@@samiam.402 Me too, but nobody ever seems to want to address that point conveniently. Because obviously there is acceleration occurring, but everyone just dismisses that and says there is no acceleration.
@JugalKishor001
@JugalKishor001 2 года назад
Thanks for this useful knowledge
@DanSmithBK
@DanSmithBK 3 года назад
Without wanting to sound like I know what I’m talking about, I read somewhere that earths rotation slowed down a bit when the flooded the Three Gorges Dam in China? And aircraft do travel a bit quicker when headed east, because the prevailing winds come from the west, due to the rotation of the earth, and the atmosphere not quite keeping up (and I’m ignoring the jet stream for this purpose!)
@gib666
@gib666 3 года назад
ASMR is like fingernails down a blackboard for me, the opposite of a relaxing and calming noise.
@Equiluxe1
@Equiluxe1 3 года назад
Same here, I prefer absolute silence when reading, my wife likes the radio all the time as she cannot stand silence, sometimes I feel like taking a hammer to it.
@ScorpiusZA.
@ScorpiusZA. 3 года назад
I jumped onto an ASMR channel or video in the past and I just didn't get it. It neither annoys nor helps me, it's just... there. Never gotten any sensation from it at all.
@desther7975
@desther7975 3 года назад
I find it creepy and bizarre.
@iritantNL
@iritantNL 3 года назад
Same here. Just like relaxation excersizes make my anxious
@DANGJOS
@DANGJOS 3 года назад
I love ASMR!
@marcusdirk
@marcusdirk 3 года назад
Though if you were in a car moving at a constant speed _in_ _circles_ you could feel it - depending on the speed and the size of the circle.
@justme-hh4vp
@justme-hh4vp 3 года назад
Most of the video reinforces an easily understandable point of relative motion but then glossed over the detail about flying east-west, versus west-east. They don't take the same time because the rotation of the earth makes the air move at different speeds hence you experience headwinds and tailwinds
@pswish2163
@pswish2163 7 месяцев назад
Thank you. Just shared this with my 8 year old girl. She smiled at your 'let's physics the he'll out of this' comment.
@tiredoldmechanic1791
@tiredoldmechanic1791 3 года назад
The speed the Earth's surface is moving differs depending on latitude.
@Chris-hx3om
@Chris-hx3om 3 года назад
Yes, by 1,000 times the cosine of that latitude.
@RideAcrossTheRiver
@RideAcrossTheRiver 3 года назад
Moving relative to what? A fixed point in space? We use RPM for that; not MPH.
@VeritasGames
@VeritasGames 3 года назад
Interesting to consider your horizontal momentum when you skydive out of an airplane... It doesn't feel like you're falling or being pulled down in the same way as a rollercoaster because you're not stationary when you jump, your momentum just gets translated from horizontal to vertical.
@TehMinTzHD
@TehMinTzHD 3 года назад
Im I the only one who noticed you on here
@mina86
@mina86 3 года назад
It doesn’t feel the same way because when you jump off a plane you’re weightless (if we ignore air resistance), whereas if you’re on roller coaster, you’re constantly being pulled and pushed by the seat you’re in.
@davemmar
@davemmar 3 года назад
Semicircular canals in the inner ear are designed to sense acceleration/deceleration or change in direction. Because of the design of this mechanism we can feel a sense of motion but only temporarily. Once the fluid in the inner ear matches any change in motion , the cilia assume a stable position and we no longer feel motion. I do this experiment with a Barany Chair but an office chair works well too. Have someone spin you around and you will feel the acceleration for 15- 20 seconds and then nothing. Try it with your eyes covered, and then uncover them to see you are still spinning.
@harpoon2445
@harpoon2445 2 года назад
There is an acceleration we experience from the earth rotating. The reason we don’t feel it, is because it works in the direction just opposite of earth’s gravity and it only makes us feel slightly lighter. But since it is always there, and changes only very slowly when we move away or closer to the equator, we don’t notice.
@hobypd
@hobypd 3 года назад
But wait: a change in direction (rotation) isn’t acceleration itself? I always thought that we don’t “feel” the rotation because it is actually very slow: indeed you have to wait 24 hours for a complete circle; was I wrong?
@TNaizel
@TNaizel 3 года назад
You're right, Earth's rotation has been measured using sensitive enough gyroscopes
@anlumo1
@anlumo1 3 года назад
It essentially “pushes” us against gravity, and so it's not a separate sensation.
@MidnighterClub
@MidnighterClub 3 года назад
Yeah I was going to say the same thing: centrifugal force is also an acceleration,why don't we feel that? I assume because it's small compared to our mass, our perception and to gravity, but it would have been nice to see it covered as well.
@anlumo1
@anlumo1 3 года назад
There's even a paragraph about this on Wikipedia: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centrifugal_force#Earth
@peperillon
@peperillon 3 года назад
Exact, on n'est pas dans un mouvement rectiligne uniforme. L'explication n'est pas terrible.
@LA-MJ
@LA-MJ 3 года назад
I think this video is technically inaccurate on a few (more or less) interesting points. * Atmosphere is a fluid. As all fluids it suffers from surface effects but I doubt one can say it is 'stuck' spinning exactly as the Earth does. I don't think you would have the Coriolis effect, if it was. This is obviously somewhat altitude dependent. * Force, acceleration and velocity are all vectors. Hence we must take change of direction into account. Napkin maths says centripetal force adds (or subtracts? screw this concept) ~0.03 m/s^2 to our perceived gravity. We could presumably measure the difference, if the Earth was not spinning. How this squares with the whole geodesic spiel in GR is beyond me. * There is no vacuum in space. Even if it were, see vacuum energy. * Earth spin is winding down, hence leap seconds. How much of this is due to Sun, Moon and other bodies vs atmosphere vs solar wind vs interplanetary space is beyond me. Earthquakes affect it too. Presumably due to conservation of angular momentum vs changes of moment of inertia. What's happening closer to the core is beyond me. Feel free to add or remove ideas.
@M4RC90
@M4RC90 3 года назад
The atmosphere touches the earths surface, which creates friction, if they're moving at different speeds. The "outside" of the atmosphere touches nothing (there's a vacuum in space), therefore nothing to stop it from rotating with the earth. Don't you love it when you reply to a comment and suddenly they edit it without you noticing?
@IIoveasl10
@IIoveasl10 3 года назад
Great video Dr Becky!
@leslie7387
@leslie7387 2 года назад
I just found your channel! Love it! And I listen to ASMR too!!!
@alexwright6038
@alexwright6038 3 года назад
The flat earth community did a great job of proving the earth spins with their laser gyroscope. Surprise, surprise they picked up a 15 degrees per hour drift.
@Chris-hx3om
@Chris-hx3om 3 года назад
#thanksBob
@ithinkthonkthunk5333
@ithinkthonkthunk5333 3 года назад
Lol! Right👍🏼
@alexwright6038
@alexwright6038 3 года назад
@@Chris-hx3om Bob Super Noodle Knodel
@tbrown3356
@tbrown3356 3 года назад
Dr. Becky just argued everything turns/drifts with the earth. You are arguing that the earth tur/drifts underneath the gyroscope. Which is it? Does earth drift or not in your imaginary model?
@alexwright6038
@alexwright6038 3 года назад
@@tbrown3356 The gyro is attached to the earth, the gyro was moving 15 degrees per hour which super noodle knodel said " was picking ups 15 degree per hour drift". The drift was the movement of the earth as the gyro was in the same reference frame as the earth, The model has productive abilities which science illiterate morons don't understand despite wishing to use equipment based on the same science and engineering that created the internet and computers, travel to work on roads designed using newton's laws . The majority trust because it works. Would have thought this channel would be far app advanced for a flattard.
@Torrriate
@Torrriate 3 года назад
There is some constant "radial acceleration" - as in "spinning" though (as the question implies) . The actual answer is, that the angular change is too small to notice!
@thontor
@thontor 3 года назад
Right? I wish she would have mentioned that.
@Fishman550
@Fishman550 3 года назад
Big respect for having Bad Moon Rising on your Astrophysics playlist, one of the greatest songs of all time.
@jcas
@jcas 3 года назад
Data science and economics student here. Space sounds when reading, and classical music/jazz when I’m doing random stuff like coding, googling or writing an essay. Rock/pop when doing woodworking in my shop. My favorite space sound video is here in RU-vid and it is 10 hours long.
@Sam_on_YouTube
@Sam_on_YouTube 3 года назад
Short answer: We do, but its just a small correction to the gravity we feel.
@HebaruSan
@HebaruSan 3 года назад
How much? Should be pretty easy to calculate a percentage, no?
@gsvick
@gsvick 3 года назад
@@HebaruSan Yes: "the total (the apparent gravity) is about 0.5% greater at the poles than at the Equator." en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_gravity (The correction at the poles is zero.)
@DANGJOS
@DANGJOS 3 года назад
@@HebaruSan You can measure it yourself, interestingly enough. I've actually done it. I weighed a very accurate 500 gram mass where I live in Maryland, Canada, and in the Caribbean. It was 500 grams in Maryland, 500.12 grams in Canada I believe, and I think 499.44 grams in the Caribbean. That's if I remember correctly.
@IamGrimalkin
@IamGrimalkin 3 года назад
The issue with measuring gravity to do this is the same effect (the centrifugal force) also changes the shape of the earth so it bulges in the middle, which also causes a change in surface gravity. A more reliable indication is the Coriolis force.
@DANGJOS
@DANGJOS 3 года назад
@@IamGrimalkin Yes, but then you notice a larger reduction or enhancement in gravity, than you would have expected from the bulge alone.
@Morbacounet
@Morbacounet 3 года назад
Foucault pendulum is also a nice way to visualize the earth's rotation.
@kruleworld
@kruleworld 3 года назад
or an analog clock. the Earth spins at half the speed of the hour hand...!
@tbrown3356
@tbrown3356 3 года назад
If earth turns underneath a pendulum then it would turn underneath a drone, helicopter, or airplane. A drone or helicopter could hover and have destinations come to them. A flight from Charlotte NC to Los Angeles California would take an hour and a half. That doesn't happen however because earth doesn't turn. Not logical to think earth only turns underneath a pendulum.
@frede1905
@frede1905 3 года назад
@@tbrown3356 Foucault' pendulum works because of the Coriolis force, which causes a small deflection of anything moving along earth's surface. This deflection is really tiny, and usually not noticeable, but when you have something moving "forever" (like the pendulum) then this effect can add up to eventually cause a precession of the pendulum (but this preccession is really slow. Except for the poles, it's gonna take more than 24 hours to complete a precession, and towards the equator, this time blows up to infinity). The Coriolis effect works because of a combination of inertia (or equivalently conservation of momentum), and small differences in the rotational speed of the earth along its surface. A helicopter can't wait for its destination because of this same conservation of momentum (it retains the momentum it had while standing on the ground).
@tbrown3356
@tbrown3356 3 года назад
@@frede1905 The coriolis effect is an apparent (not actual deflection). It requires having 2 separate reference frames (inertial and non inertial). The Pendulum is claimed to drift because earth turns underneath making it appear that the pendulum has drifted. If earth turns underneath a pendulum then it would also turn underneath a hovering drone or hovering helicopter and airplane. We don't experience or observe earth turning underneath any of these objects because earth doesn't turn.
@frede1905
@frede1905 3 года назад
@@tbrown3356 "The coriolis effect is an apparent (not actual deflection)". Except that the Foucault pendulum proves it's there. Also, it's the reason why the wind often goes in circles around a low pressure point during a storm. And often when shooting a bullet long range, this effect needs to be taken into account when aiming for the target. "The pendulum is claimed to drift because earth turns underneath". That's a simplification of what's going on. On the north and south pole, the plane of the pendulum will indeed appear to stand still relative to something that doesn't rotate with the earth, like the stars, but that's again because of the Coriolis effect. And the Coriolis effect works partly because of conservation of momentum, which again explains why a helicopter can't wait for its destination. I think the Wikipedia article on the pendulum has an animation showing how this works on the poles.
@bonkonthetronk1810
@bonkonthetronk1810 3 года назад
Great playlist!! And the reaction to that weird sip-noise is hilarious!
@rocketschamp
@rocketschamp 3 года назад
Dr Becky. I can't tell you how much your videos mean to me. I grew up in a Fundamentalist Christian environment where I believed God created the universe in 6 days and any talk that the universe was over 6 thousand years old was just crazy talk. Of course, I never respected science and thought it was Satan's tool to turn people away from the truth of creation. Your approach, though, continues to break many ceilings for me. It continues to teach me just how rigorous and meticulous the science process really is. All the things in high school I discredited...you have made me realize I should've listened. I'm forever grateful for your dedication to your work. I feel as though you have been instrumental is rescuing me from ignorance. Thank you!
@Eclipse-pf5hs
@Eclipse-pf5hs 3 года назад
"lets physics the hell out of this" is now my life motto
@zetacrucis681
@zetacrucis681 3 года назад
A "physics the hell out of this" explanation should at least include comparison of centripetal acceleration due to rotation with acceleration due to gravity. Acceleration due to Earth's rotation: a = v^2/R = (1000 mph)^2 / (4000 miles) = 250 miles / hour / hour = 0.03 m/s/s. Acceleration due to gravity: g = 9.8 m/s/s. Acceleration 'a' is 300 times smaller than 'g', which is too small to notice. Even if 'a' was significant it would only amount to a reduced apparent gravity, as e.g. in an elevator accelerating downwards, without any other distinguishable sensation of spinning. At places other than the equator, the direction of this 'apparent gravity' is also affected, which is indeed why the Earth is a (slightly) oblate spheroid rather than a perfect sphere.
@glarynth
@glarynth 3 года назад
Centrifugal. The centipetal acceleration is toward the center.
@zetacrucis681
@zetacrucis681 3 года назад
@@glarynth The acceleration is indeed centripetal, pointing towards the centre of the circular path. Standing on the equator you are accelerating towards the centre of the Earth due to circular motion about the Earth's axis.
@glarynth
@glarynth 3 года назад
If that were true, then the effect of rotation would add to gravity instead of opposing it.
@jursamaj
@jursamaj 3 года назад
You *might* actually be able to sense the .003 G difference, if it happened by flipping a switch (near-instant). Since any real attempt to feel the 2 different apparent gravities would occur over a gradient spanning hours, it's imperceptible. Many of our senses can detect small increments if they happen fast, but don't notice slow changes. This is the basis of the blink comparator, and other attempts to spot differences by switching back and forth rapidly between 2 stimuli. Similarly, humans can directly sense spin rates, but not down to 1 rev/day.
@zetacrucis681
@zetacrucis681 3 года назад
@xrm160xqw Newton is more than good enough for us in this instance. ​@@glarynth The acceleration is downward so just like in an elevator accelerating downward you will weigh less, ie acceleration towards the centre will subtract from your weight. If you were accelerating upwards you would feel heavier (think elevator going up). Consider taking the speed of rotation all the way to orbital velocity: there your centripetal acceleration is equal to gravity and you become weightless.
@alanguile8945
@alanguile8945 3 года назад
An old film was on this weeK "The man who could work miracles" not too many problems until tried stopping the earth rotating! First saw it as a child but never forgot it.
@lwalle00
@lwalle00 3 года назад
Hey Star Girl I checked out your playlist. It's Good As Hell and Ain't Nothing Wrong With That!
@RodrigoPalmieriMusic
@RodrigoPalmieriMusic 3 года назад
Carole King does.
@DrBecky
@DrBecky 3 года назад
😂
@WhatAboutTheBee
@WhatAboutTheBee 3 года назад
But only with her feet
@ldbarthel
@ldbarthel 3 года назад
If the sky is tumblin' down (a-tumblin' down), wouldn't that be evidence of gravitational collapse and imminent black hole formation?
@trigonzobob
@trigonzobob 3 года назад
But only when you're around.
@timbeaton5045
@timbeaton5045 3 года назад
I love this little chain of comments. Kudos to you all!
@pauldhoff
@pauldhoff 3 года назад
To take 24 hours to turn around once and wonder why you don't feel it is so stupid.
@ojkolsrud1
@ojkolsrud1 3 года назад
That's all flat Earthers=P
@rocketboy50
@rocketboy50 3 года назад
Well it depends on how far you are from the equator. At the poles you relatively stationary compared to the equator.
@wellwell5559
@wellwell5559 3 года назад
Darlin' you physics'd the heck out of it...i understand your explanation so well don't know why...thank you doc
@rbkstudios2923
@rbkstudios2923 3 года назад
1:35 You don't need a terminal velocity to feel weightless The whole freefall is weightlessness
@KeithMilner
@KeithMilner 3 года назад
Yes, but terminal velocity doesn't feel weightless (I don't think anyone said it does). The feeling of "weightlessness" is due to a change in velocity. When you reach terminal velocity, you no longer feel weightless. In fact you don't feel like you are moving at all, because you are travelling at a constant speed.
@KeithMilner
@KeithMilner 3 года назад
@xrm160xqw I agree (I think) but inertial motion and "weightlessness" are sort of orthogonal. The orbiting astronauts don't feel their weight because the outward force (centrifugal) balances the inward force (gravity). (Strictly speaking, these are the other way around: gravity is an outward acceleration and the inward force is centripetal). That's different from someone who is travelling at a constant speed (relative to the Earth) who isn't subject to balancing forces, such as someone falling to earth from an airplane at a terminal velocity. In that case although their speed relative to the earth is constant, they are subject to the accelerating force of gravity which means they can "feel their weight". That will feel different from being in free-fall.
@KeithMilner
@KeithMilner 3 года назад
@xrm160xqw Yes, understand all that (which is why I used some of the language I did). My point was, there's a difference between being in "free-fall" and having the earth accelerate toward you (or, as we would see it, accelerating towards the earth) and "falling with terminal velocity". In one there is acceleration and with the the there is none. And they feel different.
@KeithMilner
@KeithMilner 3 года назад
@pjd412 yes and no... You are correct that terminal velocity is the speed at which an object's drag force balances the force due to gravity on it and, therefore, it no longer accelerates. Note that drag is a function of (amongst other things) the cross sectional area of the falling object, so if the cross-sectional area changes, so does the velocity. For instance, a sky diver can speed up or slow down by changing their shape/angle. The drag force is also related to the square of the speed, so it is much higher at higher speeds. But, assuming you are talking about the escape velocity of Earth, I believe the speed of impact of an object falling from very far up with no atmosphere is unrelated to the planet's escape velocity. The escape velocity of the Earth (or any other planet) is a fixed velocity dependent on the radius and mass of the planet. (It is possible there is a component due to height above sea level, but it's probably negligible, just as the mass of a falling object is negligible when computing the speed it will fall at, as the mass of then earth dominates). The escape velocity of the Earth is around 11.2km/s. To reach that velocity (with no atmosphere) an object would need to be falling for around 20 mins.
@gladiatormechs5574
@gladiatormechs5574 2 года назад
i dont see how the air can move along with a rotating earth at EXACTLY the same speed.. Their for a plane flying west to east should not be at the same speed/TIME as it flying east to west. .. The air is not physically attached to the solid mass of the EARTH.. it can not rotate at exactly the same speed
@wowitsshit9734
@wowitsshit9734 2 года назад
that's because these s*** people are lying to you and mocking you at the same time.
@okicu81too
@okicu81too Год назад
Star trails tell us much. For example, if you watch any video of star trails with the moon, you will see that the moon @ .02 light seconds away travels the same distance as a star 500 light years away. That a serious parallax problem. In the current model, the earth is chasing the sun @ 448,000,000+ mph while orbiting the sun @ 66,000+ mph. Photographing star trails is very difficult. Any movement, even a light breeze on the camera will be seen. The fact that the mach 550,000+ movement is not felt or seen in the star trails is solid evidence that we are stationary.
@marissacrespo8514
@marissacrespo8514 3 года назад
4:18 I know she was talking in a very literal way but it did hit the feels
@theorixlux2605
@theorixlux2605 3 года назад
I feel like the inspiration for this video came from a heated forum debate with a flat earther :/
@garman763
@garman763 3 года назад
Say it LOUDER for the Flat Earthers in the back!
@PJF62
@PJF62 3 года назад
Sadly it doesn't matter how loud you shout it. You cannot convince those who do not want to believe it.
@thomaslance5428
@thomaslance5428 3 года назад
This has been explained to them for at least two years lol. If they didn't believe or understand it back then, they won't from a non flat earth debunking channel lol.
@stusue9733
@stusue9733 3 года назад
@@PJF62 You know what they are going to do with your use of the word "believe" don't you?
@DANGJOS
@DANGJOS 3 года назад
Yep, flat Earthers never seem to understand this.
@Naifukiti
@Naifukiti 3 года назад
Flatearthers have the hardest time wrapping their head around How BIG things really are especially the Earth.
@randallbrander8157
@randallbrander8157 3 года назад
I thought it was my monitor watching your video at 50p but you have the heat on at your fire place. It reminds me when I lived in cold weather seeing the heat from car exhausts.
@wildbill7267
@wildbill7267 3 года назад
After I polish off a bottle of wine, I swear I can feel the earth turning! Seriously though, I’ve seen it for myself when looking through a cheap telescope and having the image in the eyepiece move, due to focusing on a tiny section of the sky than you take in with the naked eye.
@aemrt5745
@aemrt5745 3 года назад
Ya gotta be careful with wine and Earth's motion. A little too much and the Earth will quickly move towards you!
@aemrt5745
@aemrt5745 3 года назад
...and I agree, it is pretty cool seeing the motion thru a telescope.
@frankdimeglio8216
@frankdimeglio8216 Год назад
@@aemrt5745 Gravity AND ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy are linked AND BALANCED opposites ON BALANCE. Consider TIME AND time dilation ON BALANCE. Great. GRAVITY AND TWO DIMENSIONAL SPACE ARE CONSISTENT WITH E=MC2: E=MC2 is taken directly from F=ma. TIME is NECESSARILY possible/potential AND actual ON/IN BALANCE. The TRANSLUCENT blue sky is manifest as (or consistent with/as) what is BALANCED BODILY/VISUAL EXPERIENCE. Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the TRANSLUCENT blue sky is true/real QUANTUM GRAVITY. THINK!!! ELECTROMAGNETISM/energy is CLEARLY AND NECESSARILY proven to be gravity (ON/IN BALANCE). Accordingly, ON BALANCE, the rotation of WHAT IS THE MOON matches it's revolution. Importantly, what is gravity cannot be shielded (or blocked) ON BALANCE. Great. You didn't forget to consider what is the orange AND setting Sun ON BALANCE, did you!!? Magnificent. I have FUNDAMENTALLY and truly revolutionized physics. (Lava is orange, AND it is even blood red.) GREAT !!!! Obviously, carefully and CLEARLY consider what is THE EYE ON BALANCE, as it ALL CLEARLY makes perfect sense ON BALANCE. (BALANCE AND completeness go hand in hand.). Fantastic !!! By Frank Martin DiMeglio
@kennywebb5368
@kennywebb5368 3 года назад
But you *do* notice when you're rotating. In my head I've always guessed that basically 1 rotation per day is such a slow rotation rate that our biological systems don't notice it or have been designed not to notice it. Is this right?
@PieterPatrick
@PieterPatrick 3 года назад
No, you also don't feel the speed of the earth, solarsystem or milkyway.
@conors4430
@conors4430 3 года назад
There’s probably a good chance that some animals mutated he could feel it and it either wasn’t useful or was actually harmful to them so they died out. So the only animals who could pass on their jeans were the ones who didn’t feel it. It’s just relativity
@PieterPatrick
@PieterPatrick 3 года назад
I think it is something like 0.01 G Go to the south pole and come back... ...Tell me if you feel a difference.
@kennywebb5368
@kennywebb5368 3 года назад
@@PieterPatrick I understand that an inertial observer in constant velocity won't *feel* like they're moving (except in reference to stuff around them). But if you're accelerating or rotating, you will be able to tell you're moving. We're on a rotating planet, but we don't *feel* like we're rotating. And I suppose likewise, we're rotating in the galaxy. But we don't feel it. My question is, why?
@PieterPatrick
@PieterPatrick 3 года назад
@@kennywebb5368 Rotation of the earth is to big and to slow. Impossible to feel such a small force. Try to sit the small indicator (hours) of a very big clock and see if you feel any movement.
@Grimlock1979
@Grimlock1979 3 года назад
But we are not going in a straight line. We are going round in a circle.
@grahvis
@grahvis 3 года назад
The change in direction is far less than the body's ability to detect it. There is a thing called a graveyard spiral that can occur when an aircraft pilot gets disorientated and doesn't realise they are flying in a spiral.
@TNaizel
@TNaizel 3 года назад
@@grahvis yes, but the point of the video was that there's nothing to feel because we move at a constant speed. The reality is that by rotating we are constantly accelerating, we don't feel it because the angular velocity is to slow
@ayushsinha7300
@ayushsinha7300 3 года назад
"Let's physics the hell outta this" should be your tagline. Loved it!
@HuggieBear39
@HuggieBear39 3 года назад
Thursday right before I went to dialysis at 5:30 am CST I saw the toe nail moon then I looked to the lower right of it and there it was VENUS just sitting there. I toed the nurse what I had seen and she went out and has a look too. :) Thank you Dr Becky for pointing it out for me.
@spazbog123
@spazbog123 3 года назад
Or you could just say 1 revolution per day. Doesn't seem so fast then.
@M4RC90
@M4RC90 3 года назад
1 revolution per year is even slower.
@118Shadow118
@118Shadow118 3 года назад
or 1/1440 RPM
@xilnes7166
@xilnes7166 3 года назад
Flat EARTH ARMY is on standby.... so far 20 plus dislikes...
@BoldrepublicRadioShow
@BoldrepublicRadioShow 3 года назад
This was a good video but I need longer ones to go with my daily workout a the gym.... THANK YOU :)
@piotrpeter3162
@piotrpeter3162 3 года назад
I love you Dr.Becky !!!
@Earthislife1031
@Earthislife1031 3 года назад
I bet the flat earthers are triggered right now!!!
@markrobertson6664
@markrobertson6664 3 года назад
Prepare yourselves: flat-Earthers are coming. But seriously, can you a video on why galaxies are flat? I’m 90%sure it’s because of the conservation of angular momentum but I do t know for sure.
@Sam_on_YouTube
@Sam_on_YouTube 3 года назад
Yo are correct, but I imagine if she does it she'd go into interesting things about the central bulge and other aspects. Would be a good video.
@grndkntrl
@grndkntrl 3 года назад
"why galaxies are flat?" dwarf spheroidal galaxies enter the conversation...
@anlumo1
@anlumo1 3 года назад
I'm pretty sure that she has videos on galaxy shapes. Just look through her library.
@markrobertson6664
@markrobertson6664 3 года назад
@Ross Coe nope. Never have. I guess I could look it up but it just occurred to me while I was watching the video that Dr. Becky would make a great video about this.
@ministryoftruth8499
@ministryoftruth8499 3 года назад
Yep. The Earth's spin is just one of the many things flat earthers can't wrap their mind around. They actually think it's an argument in favour of flat earth...
@staraqua4942
@staraqua4942 3 года назад
Great topic!!
@elymayer4860
@elymayer4860 3 года назад
It is actually a little faster flying east than west. It’s easier to notice on longer flights. From San Francisco to London, it’s about an hour quicker heading east. But that’s based on the jet stream.
@weldabar
@weldabar 3 года назад
I arrived here too early -- the flat-earthers haven't had time to flood the comments section.
@GrayBlood1331
@GrayBlood1331 3 года назад
Yeah but we're not moving in a straight line, the earth is spinning. I figured addressing specifically this was going to be the main point of the video.
@camilotorresf1
@camilotorresf1 3 года назад
I thin you are correct. As I understand linear velocity, it is a vector, meaning it as a direction and a magnitude. So if you are near the earths equator at dawn you are moving "approximately towards" the Sun, but that same day at sunset you are moving "approximately awat" from the Sun. That is a change in the velocity vector, meaning a change in the velocity. As expressed by many others, the change in velocity is done by a force, in this case the curvature of pace and time by the gravity of the Earth is what causes the change in velocity. Angular velocity in the other hand does not change. But it is too slow to feel it.
@mathmusicandlooks
@mathmusicandlooks 3 года назад
I think it’s worth noting that being on the surface of a rotating body, we ARE accelerating. Sure 1000 mph (linear speed) sounds really fast. But it still takes 24 hours for earth to finish one rotation. If you imagine a flea on a tennis ball that is spinning slowly enough to finish one rotation in 24 hours, would you expect the flea to feel the spin? Not really. Similarly, our radial acceleration is the linear velocity squared, then divided by the earth’s radius, so (at the equator) the maximum radial acceleration to be “felt” would be ~0.03 meters/sec^2 (That’s small. You’re not going to notice that.)
@dukenails7745
@dukenails7745 3 года назад
Great clear explanation
@russchadwell
@russchadwell 3 года назад
Well, *I* feel the world spinning [hick]. And, I'd like to get off!
@mattfinchdesign
@mattfinchdesign 3 года назад
I’ll slow it down, give me a minute!-- better?
@themeatpopsicle
@themeatpopsicle 3 года назад
It's spinning so fast sometimes I have to hold on to the ground
@russchadwell
@russchadwell 3 года назад
@@mattfinchdesign so that's what that was!? Now I feel heavy!
@crism7470
@crism7470 2 года назад
We dont feel it spin because it does not spin.
@warmachineuk
@warmachineuk 2 года назад
"A 15 degree per hour drift." Thanks, Bob!
@primoroy
@primoroy 3 года назад
The best example of high speed motion without the sensation of moving is in a large passenger jet liner. A 747 cruises at over 900 kilometers per hour, but except for the faint sounds of air, you don't feel the motion.
@sapelesteve
@sapelesteve 3 года назад
Thanks for that explanation Dr. B as I had always wondered about that. Now I know....👍👍😉😉
@tetrisgoat
@tetrisgoat 3 года назад
Would appreciate proper measurements rather than imperial units, at least complementary.
@tonyornelas9374
@tonyornelas9374 2 года назад
If you think jumping straight up on a plane or train proves the earth is spinning then get on top of it and try it there. Preferably and the rear. 😆
@codegoblin7740
@codegoblin7740 2 года назад
assuming there would not be air resistance you would fall at the same spot that you jumped.
@zaphodb777
@zaphodb777 3 года назад
Funny, in your Brilliant ad, you mentioned them... But they are a way, to indirectly feel the earth moving, the Coriolis effect! Hurricanes and Tropical storms are a great way to experience the rotation of the earth!
@chupposity
@chupposity 3 года назад
Actually the jet stream typically helps airplanes fly faster from west to east than east to west. Not sure if that varies by continent but in North America that shows up in the flight times.
@Hotdogbun96
@Hotdogbun96 2 года назад
Because we aren’t spinning. Earth is flat and stationary.
@cryptob6259
@cryptob6259 Год назад
Cool story
@cortexmarketing
@cortexmarketing 3 года назад
Thanks, Dr Becky!!
@AthAthanasius
@AthAthanasius 3 года назад
Of course it's not only speed you need to consider, but also velocity, i.e. direction as well. But a quick calculation shows that at 360 degrees per 24 hours (don't @ me about sidereal versus other rotation) that's about 4/1000th's of a degree per second, so we're never going to feel that slow acceleration as our velocity vector changes. Just our head's movement due to breathing will swamp that, never mind how we move around otherwise in our normal lives.
Далее
What If The Earth Stopped Spinning - Minute By Minute
17:06
Why People Think the World is Flat
18:43
Просмотров 12 млн
How Earth Moves
21:37
Просмотров 29 млн
An Astrophysicist's Top 10 Unsolved Mysteries
22:00
Просмотров 737 тыс.
#engineering #diy #amazing #electronic #fyp
0:59
Просмотров 2,4 млн
ЗАБЫТЫЙ IPHONE 😳
0:31
Просмотров 20 тыс.
#engineering #diy #amazing #electronic #fyp
0:59
Просмотров 2,4 млн