Thanks, Leo! Retired dev here. Used MS products including Visual Studio Enterprise for decades! My battle cry was always "Microsoft! Stop! Helping! Me!" LOL! :)
@@WrecklessSandwichthere are still far more people who don't really understand computers but they're using them anyway than people who actually understand how they work. So it's no wonder software is "evolving" to serve the masses
In a region with a language other than English, the confusion is even greater. The folder names are translated to native names on the desktop, but if you click on the path on the top in Explorer they are still in English, as they are in a cmd shell.
Ohhh yes. That drives me absolutely nuts. Especially since they like to drop the "My" in the translation, making it even more obscure. Also, even the explorer path can lye by now.
The absolute worst part is if those folders have accented letters in them. Like, imagine a folder named "Képek" (Hungarian word for Pictures) Good applications will save their stuff right there. But _most_ apps will instead do one of these: - kepek - k?pek - kÄ&$pek - kpek And eventually, every single variation will be created in your user folder by all those shitty apps.
@@hundvd_7 Well you kinda deserve it for giving your country's name to the worst programming naming scheme (Hungarian notation). It's just karma at this point.
I've done this for years for similar reasons. Microsoft's idea of "backup": Send a copy of your data to us for safekeeping and we'll delete your only copy.
Facts. Google just as much if not more than Microsoft. Bing and google: censorship ChromeOs, Android and Windows: making monopolies, data collection, required online account Google docs, slides, etc. And Microsoft 365: bundling text editing software with their cloud and other services. Google and Microsoft accounts: bundling with their other services.
Switching to Linux was the best decision I ever made. Gradually built up my knowledge to be able to usd Arch and its amazing to finally feel like im actually the one in control of the computer
Another downside to using OneDrive as your main user folders, is what happens when your internet goes down and your files aren't actually on your computer. Or what happens if something goes wrong with your Microsoft account, and you can't log in.
we all are forced to sign their huge document before installing windows , and i think clearly that it has an clause that forces you to accept these behaviours of ms
@@canalmaidebao-5197 - that's what comes when you have a monopoly with more than 70 percent of market share. That's doesn't make it right and that doesn't mean you can't do something about it. Just take a look at the document you are required to sign with the "free" Onenote program that comes with Windows 11. The government curbed MS two times but failed to keep them under control as time went on.
Simple. Nothing happens. Set one drive so that full files are kept on your hard drive locally. Don't use the "space saving" features that had proxy files on your computer. This is a zero issue you can resolve just by looking at the options screen. I think this might be even the default setting, and you have to choose for proxies. If something goes wrong with your MS account then you can't get into windows if you've got 11 which requires an account. (yes I know you can get around that, but if you're asking about these issues chances are you don't know how to)
I've done this for about a decade. The reason is that I don't store my data on my C-drive. On the drive that I do store my data, I made folders called 01 Pictures, 02 Documents, 03 Music and 04 Videos. The numbers prefixing the name ensure that they stay in order and stay at the top of the directory. I also have nothing to do with OneDrive. There is actually no such thing as the "Cloud" - it's just a fancy term for "someone else's computer".
I forced myself to become proficient with Linux by not using it in a VM, but instead by deleting my Windows10 and using Ubuntu and later fedora as my desktop PC. ...not regretting it one bit, despite the learning curve and the occasional hurdles every now and then
@@marloelefant7500 A couple years ago I started having to use Windows again for work and I was surprised how many things were more user friendly in Ubuntu! Things like the lock screen, multiple desktops, and even text highlighting work so much better by default on Ubuntu than Windows 10.
yeah, I switched to Linux back in middle school, there were many reasons but Linux seemed overall more straight forward, it doesn't hide things from you (making things more confusing) and it gave my old cheap hardware a second life I started with Ubuntu, now I run Manjaro - my last Windows was XP and I get genuinely confused whenever I'm forced to use Windows, like at work, it's just a foreign world to me
Did it 5 years ago... first thing I noticed was how silent my PC was under any Linux distro. And the fact that HDD or SDD didn't need to be read every second as ib Windows.
Another reason I avoid saving my documents in the Microsoft default folders, is that the default folders are in the C: drive (where the OS is installed). I've learned since my first pc days, back in 1996, to always create at least a second partition where to save my documents, that is to immunize my documents in case a virus would infect my OS drive. And also I find it easier to backup my documents this way and clone or make image of my OS drive separately.
I had a machine with a relatively small windows drive, but a much larger second drive. So I wanted to store all my documents on that second drive. Really would be nice to easily point all those special folders to the D-drive, but windows makes that unnecessarily hard. (And even once you do that, various programs will still manage to store things directly on the c-drive)
Yes, I save all my documents, pictures and music on a separate drive (also on a nas backup), so if I need to re install windoze everything is safe and in the same place.
Asked the bot whether data on a separate partition is safe. This is the output. That after me being aware that ransomware can encrypt your backup external drive if connected to your system during encryption. "Virus Spread: A virus or malware that infects the OS partition can still potentially access and infect files on other partitions. This is because the virus operates within the OS environment and can typically read/write to any partition that the OS can access. Partition Isolation: While partitions are logically separate, they are not physically isolated. If a virus has the capability to spread, it can do so across partitions on the same drive. Access Permissions: Properly configured access permissions can help limit the damage. For instance, restricting the OS from accessing certain partitions can reduce the risk, but this is not foolproof." I have seen malware escaping a virtual machine, too. So I wouldn't be so certain.
One little known feature of Windows is the ability of the user to redirect My Documents to any folder on any external file volume. You can do this simply by changing the Location field in the Properties dialog of the My Documents folder in your User account. This is a completely separate consideration from the problematic behavior of Microsoft OneDrive discussed in this video.
You have made my day - I got so confused with the one drive thing I accidently deleted a heap of files to free up space - only to realise that I had actually deleted the document folder files as well. I actually reinstalled the Windows and Office and uninstalled the One Drive App full stop. Your video is perfect in explaining this. Well done
You went to a lot more trouble than you should have. Those files you deleted are still recoverable off of Microsoft OneDrive. If you're using the personal One Drive account then I think you have 30 days of recovery. You go online into your Microsoft account, then one drive and there's an undelete or restore option. Then you can reinstall OneDrive and have the computers files both in the cloud for safety and on your computer.
@@SpaceCadet4Jesus in fairness, Karen felt that the bigger priority was to make sure that it never happened again, and totally nuking one drive was an effective way of achieving that goal. I agree however that retrieving the lost docs would have been worth doing had she known how to do it at the time. The issue here is that One Drive is not effectively explained to users: it's just encouraged strongly without really making sure the user understands all the consequences. And the degree of persuasion is increasing to the point where for an uninformed user it can feel like coercion. And finally, you only have those 30 days. If you lost a file that you don't need till you do end of year accounts in 9 months time, then it's too late
@@trueriver1950 the remedy for the time limit of 30 days is to buy the paid version which gives you, I think, six months or one year? You're right they don't explain it very well. I turn it off for all my clients except for the ones that actually use it knowingly.
Other thing that most people do not know: If you delete data - it comes not in the desktop 🗑️ - but into the 'web' OneDrive 🗑️. And 'only' the website of OneDrive is the place to get your 😅deleted files & folders back 😂 [ the OneDrive App does not have / show the 🗑️ ]
Boy did microsoft screw me up a decade or two ago, to the tune of THOUSANDS of contract files. When the path length was too long for the new OS version, they just blew it off. You would think the older OS would have the shorter path length limit than the new OS version. I had created a taxonomy way back in the AT pooter days and paths could get long, so I was not vigilant enough. And just to be thorough, when the OS got updated all my files were given the same date as the OS change which made it really difficult to figure out which contracts the files were associated with because the contract number was in the file name as part of the path. Of course, not a reversible mistake. Lesson learned: When I got a new Windows 11 machine recently, I did not want everything crammed into my C drive so I put a folder called DOCUMENTS on the D drive and the MUSIC, PHOTOGRAPHS and VIDEO FOLDERS on a 4TB solid state drive. I maintain two USB drives for backup that I can unplug and put into a safe or take with me. I disabled the One Drive for a lot of the reasons you mentioned. I do not like losing rights to my own data because a contract expired. MS had taught me the hard way not to trust them to be transparent about their changes. After this video I did find some docs in my One Drive that I was surprised were there, so I appreciate the warnings in the video.
I had a lot of problems years ago with "path length" too long. Which was a pain having to rename folders to shorten them messing up my orginization. Does Windows 11 give you longer path lengths?
I simply don't organize stuff the way MS programmers think; I certainly don't name stuff the way MS programmers think; I also think that content data (low access frequency, low change volume etc) should be subject to the same mechanical risk as operating files. A bit like flying on an original Boeing 737-10 MAX... Low probability of it having a problem but catastrophically unrecoverable when it does.
@@colt5189 There might be a way to enable longer file paths. I believe a youtuber named Theo Joe put up a video about it not long ago. I'm not 100% sure that it works but you could try it.
@JariNestel OneDrive is not an offline copy. Actually OneDrive is an attack target. Even without access to your computer an attacker could get your credentials, and slowly replace all your files with garbage, and your computer will sync it the next time.
I was born with a keyboard and mouse in my hands. I’ve been on windows since I was sitting on my dad’s lap playing Duke Nukem. I had one drive installed as a recommended tool by my university (Fullsail). I didn’t think anything of it at first. I used it to store my video files while I was traveling the world. Then, it became very apparent how big of a mistake that was. Not only do I not have those video files anymore. My documents, downloads, etc had become so jumbled I had to completely format my PC and avoid one drive like the plague. The moment you have one drive, you go from C>user>my documents to C>user>my one drive> my documents. You can wind up not only filling up your one drive space but also wind up filling up your hard drive quickly because there’s multiple document/download folders. I can’t express how much that system and its invasive nature infuriates me.
It really bothers me that those "Documents/Downloads/etc" buttons don't change your explorer path to C:/Users//Documents, etc... but leave them as those special folder names. This means you can't bump up a direcotry to get to /users/ and then down to whichever other subdirectory you want. As for the one-drive mess, at one point I somehow ended up with 2 Documents folders in that qucik-access, neither of which showed the real path and I had to guess whether I was in the one that was acually /users/username/Documents or the one that was /users/username/One Drive/Documents
I removed OneDrive after I lost months’ worth of work creating data files that were saved to OneDrive by default. Never could figure out where they went!
While I don’t touch one drive with a 10 foot pole, I have heard that you can access OneDrive files online if you have a Microsoft account which apparently you must if you have used one drive. So your data files are most likely available on the OneDrive website Even if you can’t find them locally. I don’t know how long ago that was but they might still be there.
You made a RU-vid? Gained my sub! I used to actually get your newsletter in email from 20 years ago when I got into tech, you were a great resource during the early internet when i started my career in IT. You just randomly showed up in my feed. Its nice to see you are still around!
I use my own set of folders for over 10 years now, mainly because of ease of making back up's. Can't stand the assumptions of Windows, other software and AI to decide how and where to handle my files.
@@SpaceCadet4JesusYou definitely can. You don't have to store your files in the Linux user folders. Most of mine on my linux machine are still stored on a different physical drive entirely. But Linux isn't moving your files to the cloud and risking them getting deleted, their user folder is much more dependable.
I often did this, but MS has made it a huge hassle over time. Correcting default download locations like Leo mentioned, has to be done in every app. There's also the 'Places' shortcut list that apps use in their save/open dialogs, fixing those to point away from the library folders has become less and less consistent. Ultimately, I'm happy with using those default folders and simply never allowing Onedrive to exist on my machine.
@@valasdarkholme6255 Goodness, I have to get very specific, don't I? It’s generally NOT recommended to store personal files in system directories like /bin, /sbin, /lib, /usr, and /etc. These directories are reserved for system binaries, libraries, and configuration files. Storing files directly in the root directory (/) is also discouraged. This directory is meant for the top-level structure of the filesystem and should remain uncluttered For personal files, it’s best to use directories like /home/yourusername or /tmp for temporary files. This helps keep the system organized and ensures that you don’t accidentally interfere with system operations. Of course, you can keep your files on another drive, there's no limitation there unless there are quotas and limits on amount of space, restrict where you can store, or permissions disallow.
@@valasdarkholme6255The only thing that bothers me about the home folders is that Linux programs don't seem to ever agree on how, or at the very least where to store configs and user preferences, so you get jumpscared with tens of random folders and files when enabling hidden files on the file explorer, but at least it has never messed with my Docs, Pics, Music, Downloads, etc.
I've never ever used any standard Windows folders. They are just inconvenient for me and I've never dug deeper. All I want from Microsoft when I buy a new comp: clear OS, no additional apps, games, soft or folders. I would also prefer that the OS has all extra services off by default or unavailable. Just give me the naked OS. It takes time to delete all extras that come together with Windows. And some freaking sh@t cant be deleated, something like Playstation console or whatever it may be called. I am not using it so don't remember the exact name. 😊
Junctions? You mean link files? You can do them on windows. Its possible to do all kinds of things same as linux, you could make an app install under program files on c while its really on a ram drive etc, its just a hassle
@@jovetj mklink /J ? Since 2k? Works only on local drives(symbolic link works on any targets) Tho ntfs provides ways to do it user dependently too and have active code.. Which gets messy
I never use standard folders. I don't store any data on my C drive. Never use Onedrive. Don't do anything Microsoft wants you to. Eventually all software and data storage will only be available online. This is Microsoft trying to "help" you by owning everything. Most people will say "what's wrong with that?"
Yup, the harder they try to cram things like ondrive and windows11 down my throat the more determined it makes me to never use them. F MS! Don't even get me started about their AI spyware.
@@judmcc When an SSD or HDD goes South then the value of online storage will be evident. For my documents I use OneDrive, and Google Drive for my backups. Thus, regardless of my location I will have access to my documents. If they are on my computer, and I was not at that computer, then when the file(s) is need I would not have access. Another consideration, when we search the web from our computer the entire web is not on it, it is online in server farms strategically place around the world. we all have access to web information and for the most part is search and retrieval is extremely fast. Our banking, medical records, DMV, government stuffs, the list goes on is all online, not on our computers. Oh, for those saying "I would never do online banking" be aware your date is 100% available online created by the financial institution. YMMV.
Reading through the comments so far, I don't get the impression people are understanding what Leo is suggesting. He's not talking about moving the "documents" folder to another loacation. He is saying to ignore it outright and make your own folder in a different location for your documents. The best way to do this is to partition your drive in to C: and D: Windows won't go into D: as long as you don't try to move the folders. On D: make your own documents (pictures, videos, music, etc) folder. If you don't partition your drive you can simply go to C:\ and make a folder that is completely outside the C:\Users hierarchy ... eg. C:\Home ... then inside that folder make your own documents (etc) folders. As Leo explains these self-created folder hierarchies are beyond Windows reach, so you can organize them and maintain them as you wish... without any meddling from automated processes. That is .... don't move the Windows folders... Ignore them .... Make your own... Then move your files to the new folders.
I've tried deleting them many times in the past and haven't been successful. Maybe there's a way to disable/hide them? Win7 still runs great with Updatepack7.
That means you will have to browse for your folder every time you want to save something. In an environment where productivity is important - that's not very productive. Disabling onedrive is the preferred method, along side with moving the default folders OUT of Users nightmare that m$ created. That way you can easily back up those folders and not fear that someone might reinstall windows which will just delete all folders in Users and re-make them empty.
@@Ludak021 No browsing .... if you open the file by association (click on the file, windows loads the program with the file open) you just click save when done. Trust me, it is no more difficult in your folders than in the Shell Folders.
It’s fine to use the user documents folder structure, as it preserves user security if multi users are using the PC. If you create a c:/ or d:/ folder, other users who log into that PC may have access to those folders, unless you try to use additional utilities to secure those folders, none which are easy or convenient for average users. I always have a good back up routine for my key files.
When I used Windows, I always partitioned the HDD and used D: as my (D)ata / (D)ocuments place. Everything I cased about and would backup was on D:, and I don't care if I need to nuke and rebuilt C:, it's just the OS and Program Files.
I totally agree, and have been keeping my files in non-default folder for decades. The only one I use is the “download” folder, but just temporarily during a download; right after finished downloading I then move the file to another stable destination. But in your video I found some additional valuable advice anyway, for which I thank you. 👍
I kept almost everything yet non-backupped in the Download folder for some years. I remember that someday (Win XP era?) people got severe trouble because M$ recommended to delete old files from that folder as a "cleanup" measure because they considered it a kind of Temp. Later they fortunately undid that stupid decision. (Firefox asks for similar crap when the browser wasn't used for few months.)
#1 I don't use a Microsoft account. #2 I long ago deleted One drive. #3 I have 2 other SSDs in my PC where I save everything. #4 I have a 4TB external SSD where I keep weekly backups of all files I give a fk about. Yes, I'm paranoid.
@@MarcusCactus Gee, where should I start. SSD means Solid State Drive, PC means Personal Computer, 4TB means 4 Terrabytes, which is the equivalent of eight 500 gigabyte drives. Is there anything else I can clear up for you?
<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="160">2:40</a> What sane person would touch OneDrive? I usually root it out of the system even during installation.
I do, and have for years. In fact, I often have multiple OneDrive accounts on a single computer. You do need to understand the behavior, especially the default behavior. The file loss Leo describes is easily avoidable if you watch your storage and act accordingly.
@@frankus9999 Same here. I have a personal laptop, a personal desktop, and laptops from two different employers. I don't put everything on OneDrive, but I do have everything I like to access from wherever I am in a couple of OneDrive accounts. OneDrive does have its uses. Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater.
Dolphin is the best file program.. Of course, I use Linux so .. but yea.. 2nd partition out of the OS partition to save info.. Everyone learns this lesson sooner or later.. I have not used Winders for 25yrs... My KDE Kubuntu is smokin fast..
@@kansascityonline *_"lol.. touche~.. I am so happy I freed myself from windows after 7.... 25 yrs using Linux... Heck.. I don't even own a cell phone.. !."_* RU-vid: Linus Torvalds on why desktop Linux sucks
Completely agree with you. I'm doing that since ages... saving MY stuff in MY folders. Didn't even know that Microsoft had the audacity to move personal files into a cloud folder, what the heck?! This is outrageous!
Oh. Yeah, the first thing you say. I've always made my own, sometimes silly-elaborate, doc & pic & download, etc. folders on non-operating system drives. Just... because. I've watched MS increasingly try to "pay attention" to my data for years, casually from their sidelines, while I handled my own stuff. Good advice, Leo.
I just don't like to see a computing device as a repository or anything. It's a machine to do exactly the thing it's set to do, and uses local COPIES of the masters its working with. That also helps because limited storage won't just "fill up", it gets deleted (rather, marked as writeable) and archived when it's no longer USING that data. Nothing "sits" on the work desk, the work desk ought to be empty for new loads to arrive.
When Windows introduced "Libraries" I folded up the library options and never touched them again. Instead, I installed a new drive and created documents, music, pictures etc in a folder structure there and created shortcuts to them in Quick Access. I changed the default storage folder for all software installed to point to the new path on the new drive in a new folder. I did the same for any software I installed. The new drive was/is backed up to an external drive periodically. I changed the This PC landing page to reflect the new setup. (but that's a whole other story)
@@D.von.N I worry that one day a M$ bug will reconstruct AI hallucinations of your documents in OneDrive instead of giving back the real files created by you.
@@cyberyogicowindler2448 And therfore I am gradually switching my MS machines to Linux, only planning to use MS from a usb if needed, with files backed up separately on 2 different drives. There is one more PC left, running Win10 and having HDD that seems to be developing issues. I'll replace it for ssd and probably install Linux there too. I have heard somewhere the 22H2 version is losing support in 2 months. Microsoft is doing this to themselves.
@@D.von.N I also expect that M$ is mainly a slave of national intelligence and therefore wants us to give away all our documents to be scanned (but that do antivirus companies too). One day they may censor everything without notice. I am writing on a movie script about an AI based unhackable internet successor with legal ban of all private offline data media, that gradually turns into a kind of dictatorship doing personalized censorship.
The current default folders didn't exist in XP. The current default folders are under your user folder in the "Users" folder. That folder hierarchy didn't exist in XP; at least not any XP installation I saw. The current default folder locations were introduced, I believe, in Windows 10. In XP, Windows 7 and 8 there was a "My Documents" folder in the root of C, which was not specific to any user. I'm not sure the other default folders even existed somewhere in older versions of Windows. There may have been a default Downloads folder somewhere, but it was shared by all users, unlike with Windows 10 and 11.
@@wildbill4496good old Documents and Settings I'm pretty sure we had folders for pictures, music and video back in XP, however its been so long I don't remember the exact path. We didn't have libraries though. I believe those came with either Vista or 7, with the default folders included being these new folders.
I keep a separate data volume in case I ever need to rebuild the system volume. when I have had to rebuild the system volume, I MOVE the following folders from their default C: to my data volume and move my data into those folders: Desktop, Documents, Downloads, Favorites, Music, Pictures, Videos. I also keep a folder for Office 365 templates and dictionary on my data volume, then I change settings in 365 to point to the templates and dictionary. I am so glad the need to hack the registry is in the past.
Cracking video, Leo, so many people are completely lost about folder location, locally and OneDrive that they just dont attempt to do anything, just leave all alone. You have given a brilliant insight into how to take control of the situation, with useful caveats. Thanks for this.
I never understood why these folders existed. I already had folders for videos, pictures, etcetera. The explanation is appreciated and I’m glad I never used these default folders. I’m so tired of being jerked around by Microsoft that I’ve started transitioning my computers to Linux-starting with the Windows 11 one. I’m enjoying getting control; Computers will be fun again.
They exist so people don't have to create them every time they get a new computer. And if you don't use those folders you don't have to, nobody's forcing you, you can just delete them. Computers are fun even with the Microsoft operating system, you just got to know how to use it.
They exist for the numpties who would otherwise bung everything onto the desktop in a chaotic mess. They also exist so that browsers know where to put downloaded stuff if they are not told otherwise, where a word processing program is to put it's output if not told otherwise, and so on All these things are configurable, but they exist for people who can't be bothered to do learn how to set up their own folders; and for big organisations that want a standard system on all their staff computers. Remember Windows is designed for use by people who do not think of themselves as knowing about computers. The Linux desktops terms to follow the same ethos (annoying for us geeks, but an important part of making Linux accessible to the non-geek majority).
@@trueriver1950 I had a client whose computer needed some physical and logical cleanup. When I brought it back, the client complained about missing files. I said I did not go through your files, they are all there. I asked him to show me where he stored the files and he went directly into the recycle bin. He said he saves files he might need in the future there. I asked him how long have you done this? Oh...for a long time. I scolded him for saving his files in the trash can and said do you store your money or your keys in your trash bin at home? Just one use of CCleaner would wipe all the files out. I could write a book!
And when “your control” is actually just submitting to what a bunch of unknown guys have decided will be in your version of Linux??? Then what. And what will you do, when your version turns out to be worse than one of the other ones, where they have fixed some of the clutter in the old one, you change again “to get control”, and now you can’t find your stuff?
MS doesn't help the situation when these standard folders are for the C drive. My C drive is only 256 GB. I don't keep my music or pictures there. I keep them on my RAID 1 HDDs which is safer than the C drive.
@@pedroferrr1412 Just because he doesn't mention that, doesn't mean that he doesn't know. I'm 100% sure he knows, and for your information, moving them a different drive doesn't change much, OneDrive for example will be aware of the change because of a registry settings that was changed once the move was initiated, and still find your files.
Exactly, these can be relocated but that doesen't solve the initial problem of programs controlling your actual "important" documents. As for why a shortcut to them on your desktop or explorer is better in some cases.
Not only have I never used M$ folders, I have Added deny permissions to all of them since NT file system became default and made the S, H, R previous to that on folders they tried to control.
I like to keep all my "stuff" organised under a single root folder - called [path]\data of my choosing. Rather than deleting the shortcuts to documents, pictures, etc, I modify their locations under properties to point to my "data" path. In this way, most apps will take my preferred location settings as default. It's then easy to backup my "data" root folder using e.g. something like FreeFileSync for speed and convenience.
I do this too. Not sure if that would stop one-drive from moving the files though. I don't have one-drive installed, but it's possible that M$ installs it by stealth in the future.
When I ""upgraded"" to Windows 11 without knowing the perils, I naively used the standard folders (Documents most especially), as they'd always worked how you described they should before. Until one day I noticed the stuff in the documents folder was being backed up to the cloud (something I never opted into nor wanted to happen), and Microsoft complained at me for running out of space on my free account, so when I went to delete some cloud backups of things, luckily I noticed they were also being REMOVED FROM MY PC. Eventually I learned that, even though it looks just the same as always, the Win11 Documents folder is NOT stored on the local disk (even though it's in the C: directory like everything else in the User folders); it is actually on the cloud. I'm so glad I noticed this early, so I could move everything out of the fake, not local Documents "folder," and into a folder of my own creation, like you did in the video. Thank you for spreading the word; out really freaked me out and pissed me off, and I want for no other soul to become a victim of this insidious little change and its potentially huge consequences.
Since 1994 I decided that ALL 'my documents' go on a separate partition, and then later (as it became reasonable) everything went on a separate PHYSICAL drive (D: , E: , J: , whatever). I only use the Windows \Downloads, then evaluate > MOVE or DELETE from there.
For me, I mainly only use the desktop, which has temporary files i'm working on, and shortcuts to my other folders like C:\Documents and C:\PortableApps and leave it like that.
Same here. Every stupid software author writes in "My Documents" and Microsoft keeps changing their access and locations. I just make a folder on my data drive and keep all my content there.
@@CathrineMacNiel because hardly all of the files being stored are actually documents. The best example off the top of my head is games that store their save files there instead of appdata. Its frustrating how completely disorganised things are where there are many different "standard" locations that programs store their stuff. Out of all of them Documents is the one that makes the least sense
@@ultimate9056 But when you look at it like a savegame being something you work on to complete, then storing them in my documents make total sense. Also that way, when you sync for files by using the default folders, your savegames also get sycned. AppData is hardly the right location.
To follow up on this you should mention users should use a 2nd drive or partition, for when windows breaks, all the docs will be left alone during the install, then you can re-add your quick links to them after installing a fresh windows. The other benefit you didn't touch on is ransomware targets the documents, desktop, music etc default folders. meaning you are 99% likely to want the things it encrypts.. but if you use your own drive and own folders, they rarely touch other drives. On this topic, a 3 2 1 backup is required to make sure your data is actually safe. Onedrive, dropbox, google drive are all able to be used for very important backups, but nobody should put their entire collection of random docs on them and you should choose what to upload, 5gb or 2gb of space isn't a real lot.
I always have every one of my computers set up as C: OS and D: Data with an E: DataBackup Robocopy backup drive. Plus my Data drives are Robocopied to my local NAS and to my offsite NAS. I don't put any data on the OS drive, ever. Plus OneDrive wants to always hijack the User folders which I don't want, so I will never use either.
@@patrickcardon1643 The core problem is that MS (and others) think some users are computer illiterate. Every one using a computer is literate, maybe not to vaunted level of thinking in Assembly which is a bit like being able to actually converse in Latin...
The default folders are potentially shared folders. Use private personal folders on your hard disk to avoid cloud reorganization from shared folders. Shared folders are supposed to be for unimportant stuff you forgot to put in your private personal organisation folders on the hard disk partition. Backup important files to an external hard disk or usb
The idea that you have to use "Save As" is only for new documents. Rather than loading a program then opening a document in that program.... go to the document itself and click on it. The Windows file associations will open the program for you with the file already loaded. Now your program knows where the file is and you can save it just like you're used to.
A very annoying aberration to this is windows paint. It ignores where the document is that you are editing and always uses the last place you saved a file to even if that's from 2 weeks ago for something completely unrelated.
This was a common practice before MS Windows starting using standard simple folder names such as Documents, Music, Video, Games, etc. People used their own naming schemes for their folders. Part of the reasoning was if someone got into their computer(s) they'd have to spend time to hunt for stuff. When standard folder names were first introduced, some people like yourself decided to avoid using them for the same security concerns. Others didn't really care. Businesses loved having a uniform folder naming scheme as it was so much easier to know where certain types of files were likely to be located and thus was easier to train new employees on. I know this seems trivial in hindsight, but lots of things that made sense in the early days of computing don't always age well.
Thanks for the heads up about creating our own folders for our documents instead of windows default folders that they mess with and we are out of control with . Very good ideas
Some time ago I moved the default location of my Documents, Music, Videos and Pictures folders from the C drive to a new D drive. Do you think I should restore them back to C drive, create new folders on my D drive and use libraries to combine them?
Seems like 90% of the comments are saying the same thing lol. But probably those are the people that would watch this video so probably much less in general population.
OneDrive can be useful, but it really needs an option for 'Leave on this Computer Only'; so we wouldn't have to make separate folders to hide files from OneDrive.
One important thing to add, especially since you are talking about losing files: BACKUP is essential. Always make sure to make regular backups of all important files. If you do not use OneDrive, which is ok, use a different method, be it an external USB drive or flash media, a NAS, another cloud storage, or anything else... But always do backups :)
If you are diligent about keeping user files off of C:, when there is a glitch, rather than tracking the solution down, just restore your most recent image of C:.
I used to do all that, but as I've gotten older I decided the hassle just isn't worth it. Though, the only "standard folder" I use is the Documents folder. But I am also not infected with the Windows 10 or Windows 11 virus.
Thank you for sharing this. I was troubleshooting a computer with OneDrive backups enabled and couldn’t understand why no files were being saved to the local Documents folder.
Never keep document files on the C: drive. You are asking for trouble if you do. The C: drive is what crashes most often. If you reinstall Windows on the C: drive you may lose your data. I keep data files on other hard drives and in my own folders.
I had many computers with that problem(comp eng.), and could always restore the files to another drive. To be unable to restore the files, is because you have a very bad drive(cheaper) or the drive was very old or suffer some form of "violence". You should always do backups of important files, does not matter in what drive the files are.
Really stupid advice. Reinstalling Windows is not a thing and has not been for about 15 years. Partitioning only leads to wasted space. As Dan said above, backup is a must, regardless of the location of your stuff.
not sure which version of windows you are using, but is has never been too unstable and the edge cases are really rare. people will continue to use windows because they muscled world domination. there is no reason to say the operating system or your programs will delete all your files, and not being in a library can't stop them from being deleted. if you have used a modern operating system then you have used a normal bog-standard journaled filesystem which prevents many manners of data loss.
Yeah. I think it's great for businesses, companies, and even home use if you need that accessibility from device to device, but it's really a ticking time bomb. If Microsoft decides to change their ToS, or change something to "help" you because they think they know better, if there's a bad update, server outages, hacking potential by parties that want to attack Microsoft, or hold your accounts hostage by ransomware, ...there's just so many things that can happen that only needs to happen ONCE for your whole account to disappear. Nevermind any personal information you've uploaded to be used to ruin your record financially, lawfully, or otherwise. ALSO nevermind the ability for law enforcement to snoop any personal information you've uploaded if they just ask Microsoft and scratch their belly. I use Onedrive only when I have to for class or needed for work, my personal answer is an external HD at home and I honestly need to get at least 1 more (I just don't have the funds now). The service to hold your data and do what they want with it is what they're offering. No thanks.
Not "if" they change their ToS, "when" they change it out from under users _again._ I've already seen >10000 people left without Google Docs access during a convention, when anyone who hadn't used a desktop interface to accept the new terms that month, became unable to access their files, all on the same morning. Microsoft did the same thing less than a year later. Services are not something to rely on, they're a convenience. If you're _reliant_ on a service, you're using it wrong.
Ive worked in IT for40 years, and I have always avoided the MS pushed folders preferring my own way of organizing my files. Whats really annoying at work is that when you get a new laptop, they use One Drive to setup your new machine, and of course they assume we will use those MS folders.
Thanks for the info. I want my Word files to be easy to find and to access for sharing. Ever since my war against Onedrive started, organizing my files has not been easy.
The biggest problem I have had is when I do a fresh Windows install using a offline account, you have to go through hoops trying to figure out how to access those folders and files and windows will tell you that you are not the OWNER. Sometimes it has taken me 10 minutes trying to figure out how to get privilege access to the folder. It has only been those special folders I have had to deal with.
My biggest problem with the quick access folders is the lack of expansion. I like a directory tree, not a buffet. Also, the one time I tried to embrace one drive, years ago, is still haunting me.
Yup. this happened on my father's Windows10 machine. It started to move everything to the cloud and it stuffed up not only where his CAD files were saved so that his CAD program lost all it's settings and didn't know where that files were, but it also stuffed up Outlook too. But the idea that they would take your files to the cloud really irked me as some files can be confidential and it poses a huge security risk.
<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="67">1:07</a> You mean like when you do a Windows update and your files just go "poof", great feeling huh? So great to have to back up your files BEFORE every update just to be sure you won't lose them... even better when it's a "surprise update" and the pc update on his own like a grapist and then you just pray to the god of ssds and motherboard for your files not to be deleted...
In the case of application making assumptions, you can definitely make a shortcut folder with the original names. This can be helpful in cases like video games that save the progress in the Documents folder
Back in the Win2000 days, I compulsively formatted and re-imaged my boot drive, so I got in the habit of storing everything in folders on other drives. That was obviously a while ago. I never use OneDrive or anything like that, so I never even knew they were pushing it as hard as they are. Thanks for the video.
As an old greybeard going back to CP/M I used to keep directories based on the program needed to deal with the files. I had a PDFs directory, a GIFs directory a JPEG directory a MIDI directory and of course a GAMES directory. When "my documents" first happened, (XP?) I resisted but by the next version of windows I relented. I thought it was better to know how to work with the paradigm than to fight against it.
Here's another oldy. I have a similar structure on my data drive (different physical drive) , also installed programs on a different drive, a library of installation (os, drivers, progs) files on yet another drive, a special download drive and a backup drive. Easy to maintain, if any of the drives run out of space, get a new one, copy all content to the new drive and problem solved. On linux I also use separate mounted drives for home, logs, data and progs. Never had any data loss in my 40+ years of pc experience. However, I still use my own system, never used the ms dirs.
@@ruben_balea why ever enable one drive in the first place? Microsoft bombards me with messages to enable one drive and I love it because it's confirmation that it's not been enabled.
Also beware that Disk Cleanup can delete your whole Downloads folder if you check the wrong box. That might include stuff like decompressed archive folders with application data, saves files, etc.
Not only that, if you get malware, ransomware or get hacked, they may target the docs folder. I have a separate folder on a non-OS drive where my important files and docs are kept.
Good video, when I came to this same conclusion what I ended up doing was to make a new clean (empty) D:/ Partition and create folders there (documents, downloads, etc) so when my pc needs a new OS installation I can simply backup my files and wipe the whole C drive without having to search for and extract every personal file spread all over windows default folders.
why would you want to scatter your stuff all over the partitions? Whats the reason for that? You can also let windows point those standard folders to different places, there aint a need for them to be inside your %USERPROFILE%.
We can actually move all of the location of all standard folders to new folders. When click my document, it will move to the new folder. Even the desktop folder can be changed in windows 10 and 11. We are not forced to use the backup feature of OneDrive. I never backup anything to my 1TB OneDrive.
If you use "restore points" is another reason. These folders are treated almost as "system" folders, mainly the desktop, so it is very likely that you will lose files restoring the system to a previous state. The desktop should be always used as a temporary intermediate for files, never their permanent destination.
You know what, I noticed that with my Windows 11 laptop that I bought last year. I was surprised why it kept saving to OneDrive until I realized Windows made OneDrive Documents the default My Documents and it took me a while to fix that up. I still could not get to show the My Documents icon on the local My Documents after that. I know it's a cosmetic issue, but if you know how to fix that, let me know cuz it really bugs me. Because I have Office 365, I have the 1TB version of OneDrive so thankfully, it didn't become a problem. That said, Microsoft deleting files, like bruh, wut? I'd rather be told I can't save files anymore so that I can look for files I no longer need and delete them.
My Win 7 SP1 Ultimate - My folders: C/#: # # System (color yellow) # Net (color blue) # Text (color pink) # Graphics (color red) # Audio (color cyan) # Video (color purple) # Data (color white) # Emulator (color light green) # Game (color orange) color is fast (than text)
@@donjindra then don't enable it... I'm just saying that what they do makes sense. IF you use MS to backup the files, it would only work if you backed up where your files are.
A major problem with OneDrive backup is that it doesn’t do a backup. It does a move. So it’s deceptive, you could say fraudulent. See Leo's video on this.
I personally have a NAS that I set as default for all my personal data. Makes it a lot easier to just not have any personal files on my computer so if it crashes I just reinstall the OS and programs then pin my data folders back to Windows Explorer. 😁
With encrption on default the MS assumes quite correctly the vast majority of people have no clue about the bitlocker and the forced MS account is there for them. For their own good. The small minority of just suffer along.
@@D.von.N Yeah, the vast majority of people don't need Bitlocker. It's only useful if you travel a lot with a laptop, live in a bad neighborhood with a lot of home breakins or have a bad living situation with people you don't trust, who might have physical access to your computer. Its purpose it to prevent data theft via physical access to the computer and/or drives contained within the computer. Most people don't have that concern and don't need Bitlocker, but Microshaft wants to force it on people by default. There's nothing wrong with having a Microsoft account, so long as you're not using it as the log in account for your computer. There are benefits to having one for other purposes, so long as it's not controlling if you have access to your computer.
You do have the "nuclear option" choice of saying some rude words to M$oft and downloading Linux While folk tolerate this abuse, and complain while still using their system, M$ are not going to change. They don't want happy users, they just want users (happy or not) as bait for their advertisers
Now this is an interesting topic! Certainly one I haven't seen before. As an MCSE, I've always used the Windows default folders, understanding they receive special protection to avoid inadvertent deletion and data loss. I've also avoided OneDrive like the plague. Your approach is excellent.
Onedrive is the first thing what i uninstall. If i want to backup something i use USB HDD. There are some small file (just some notes) I use cloud just for that, but that it just some small document.
A backup (sync) feature is Not supposed to move files at all, but to simply copy them to a destination. From my own experience, OneDrive copied my files to cloud storage and didn't delete any local files. Something must have triggered OneDrive to move them to the cloud instead of just simply syncing them. I use drive imaging software to create backups and don't bother with live sync software. The Windows "Common Folders" are available to developers in the Microsoft development environments, using those keeps things consistent where defaults are concerned across many types of software, we use them mainly to store application data and software licenses. If a backup strategy includes backing up user profiles, then that data is included, not a bad thing. Myself personally, I have always kept files important to me on a separate hard drive or a separate partition for the reason if the OS gets corrupted I can restore it from a backup image and not have to worry about losing any important files. I've been using that strategy since the DOS days.
Excellent vid. Thanks. Microsoft defaults its folders to the OS drive (where the operating system) is. A lot of people don't understand how risky that is. The OS drive takes a lot of 'punishment' with regular read-writes, crashes and so on. It is not uncommon for it to become corrupted - and with resulting data loss. The default folders can be redirected - as I do - to a separate internal storage drive which does not take the constant 'punishment'. I then configure OneDrive to backup and sync those folders cloud. Video and Music folders become usually hefty and if left on the OS drive invariably cause Windows to slow down.
Storing documents in another folder is not a replacement for fixing the buggy Microsoft OneDrive software which should be uninstalled if not being actively used. Programs often put their data in the documents folder instead of appdata; users of the documents folder can work around that with an extra step of making a documents folder in the documents folder; programs will only write their data into the first level keeping the second level clear. You can also mess with Windows users' paths to point documents to a different non-document folder but with the catch that all programs trying to use documents folder for any purpose, including real documents, ends up there. I remove pinned locations as they take away screen space from the folder view and hide where I am actually going when clicked.
Oh, yeah. You reminded me of how OneNote clutters up my Documents folder by putting shortcuts to all my notebooks in the root of the Documents folder, not even in a subfolder.
I do use OneDrive alongside Google Drive, for which I have a paid subscription for additional space, and the fiest thing I do is move all cloud storage folders to a dedicated SSD, which moves the location of all windows default folders including my documents, pictures, and everything else. I never had any issues as long as I don't open or save files directly from OneDrive and just use it for backup. These locations are constantly being tracked for changes, no matter what service you use, so obviously, they are not meant to be working directories.
My main reason was always that they get cluttered by files from programs and other stuff. Also the paths are way too convoluted, just better to have them in my own folders.
The worst is, if you install software in a different language for any reason (because it detects your current location), it doesn’t go in “Program Files” but in “Programme” or whatever the local translation is.
I'm using 128GB SSD. 70GB for Windows OS 10GB for Games or Experiment for Linux The rest for Batocera For document, download, music, photos, and videos i move their path from default folder in user (drive C) to HDD (drive D) 😅 When I experiment with Elementary OS, I accidentally deleted all my SSD partitions so I had to reinstall Windows and install the applications again but my important data is safe because it is stored on drive D.
These folders are indexed in a way that searching in the "start menu" will find these. Imagine someone else using this and bumping into your files... Imaging Windows performances when these folders are 1To large, very slow, and "simple" users might never understand why (btw no MS warnings or notification which is easy to implement) . However it is good to put software shortcut in my documents (so it can be found by a search in the search bar).
I think that this is good advice for now. But it's really important to note that behaviour of tooling can, and will change. The relevant changes that I'm expecting to see in the coming years: * One drive will start acting on more of/the entire user folder, not just the current specific sub-folders. * One drive will start honouring the specified custom replacements for the folders. So if you've updated the defaults that applications pay attention to, chances are that onedrive will start using those soon.
That is Very good advice. You have earned a new subscriber. When I installed my Windows I created a local account without ever logging in to my Microsoft account. The absence of a Microsoft account prevents me from using one drive. and it prevents a whole lot of unnecessary apps from functioning. Lucky for me I have never experienced Microsoft managing my folder content. Even with my setup, one can never be careful enough. I will definitely consider your folder advice as having total control of my folders content and location is of the highest importance to me
Like others, first thing I do on a new pc is to partition the drive to C: E: and F:. All my data is on E:, archived stuff is on F:. C: has only opsys on it. I keep D: as a drive letter for usb plug-ins etc. Means I know where everything is, can restore an opsys backup image without worrying about data files, etc etc.
Back when I used Windows I was doing that too. I'd have a separate partition just for all my files. The reason is mostly the same as yours, but with the addition of that I also need more folders than those given by default, and by having some folders be "special" and others just made by me, inconsistencies are made, and I absolutely despise those. So instead, I had separate folders on a separate partition where I put all my files, as well as also some shortcuts to the AppData folders and My Documents, as those are often used by external programs Now however I use Linux, and with Linux it's far easier to have your files on the same partition as the system, because of how the file tree is with Unix. Now I have a directory "My Files" in the home directory of my user, and then the directories there are the same as I had folders on Windows Oh by the way, on Windows, you can set a certain folder to be one of the default folder that external programs would use. Forgot how it's done, but it is possible
he key is in the "free account" you mention. Instead of knowing what you are doing and acting in correspondence, most users will take a paid account to prevent that data loss. Over the years I see my screen and Windows functionality become mainly dedicated to the mindless.
I always install Windows with a local account (no Microsoft account). Never had this problem, although I usually use those folders as a dump of downloads and saved docs, but everything important is in my personal server where I can access from anywhere in my network (nextcloud or just a shared folder)
I'm with you on this one. I started with Vista to put nothing in those folders - at first because of name length problems. Those folders were just too deep into the structure.
Same here. Among others because I consider the system drive a place where you put your programs, and not data. This also protects my data from Windows doing weird things with them. I always put my data on a separate internal drive so I can create an image of the system drive using Image for DOS, for easy recovery in case of disk failure or corruption, without the image being bloated by tons of data. Then I have another internal drive for backup of the data drive of the same size, mirroring the data drive, not RAID but using Second Copy to backup dynamically whenever files are added or changed. And of course, also a third, removable drive for en extra backup of the data drive. Easy and fast to recover anything that way, if necessary.
Being a long time user too, I do something very similar since I don't bother with one drive. Being a gamer, one thing I hate is when games save your game in "Documents\My Games" or worse still in the app local folder -- I would like to specify my game saving location so I can easily back them up up with my daily backup routine....
