Why Inline 5 Cylinder Engines are an Anomaly

Подписаться 440 тыс.

Просмотров 533 тыс.

50% 1

Here's a look inside a Volvo 5 Cylinder engine, how it works, what caused it to fail and why inline 5 cylinder engines aren't that popular anymore!
The engine in this video was taken from a 2005 Volvo S40 and suffered from oil starvation and coolant mixing with the oil. In this video, the B5244S4 inline 5 cylinder engine is torn down to take a look and what caused it to fail, how it works, the component setup, a discussion on its integrated lubrication and PCV systems and engine balance.
Skip to the sections in this video:
0:00 Introduction
1:14 Teardown
7:54 Engine Lubrication
11:17 Positive Crankcase Ventilation System
13:57 Engine Balance
The Volvo B5244S4 is a modular design that scalable from inline 4, inline 5 and inline 6 applications on the same production line. It features an aluminum design, with a lubrication system integrating the valve cover and oil pan. The head is wide, having dual overhead cams situated far apart from each other. The version shown here is naturally aspirated and has variable valve timing on the intake side only. The valve-train is driven off a timing belt.
The cooling system integrates an externally mounted oil cooler, while the PCV system uses a unique oil separator to extract oil from the crankcase before venting it back into the intake plenum.
Make sure you maintain your vehicle so the engine does not become like this one! You can get replacement supplies and parts here:
Engine Oil:
amzn.to/3epigx1 (US)
amzn.to/32gzmL0 (Canada)
Oil Filter:
amzn.to/2Wfv4zG (US)
amzn.to/2BZMaLg (Canada)
Engine Coolant:
amzn.to/2C4M70s (US)
amzn.to/2ASo5oS (Canada)
3/8" Ratchet set for common repairs:
amzn.to/3gVMKbK (US)
amzn.to/2Ww4eDR (Canada)
OBD2 Diagnostic tools for scanning codes and engine lights:
amzn.to/3gSStPq (US)
amzn.to/3fpqPJF (Canada)
This is the Camera I use:
amzn.to/2Y24ixX (US)
amzn.to/2Yhb3eo (Canada)
Link to Etsy shop where you can purchase speedkar99's brother's socks, t-shirts or hoodies:
www.etsy.com/ca/shop/Speedkar
Check out the speedkar99 Facebook page:
/ speedkar9
Check out the speedkar99 Linkedin page:
/ speedkar99
Follow speedkar9 on Instagram for behind the scenes coverage:
/ speedkar9
Subscribe for more videos just like this:
ru-vid.com_...

Авто/Мото

Опубликовано:

31 май 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 1,4 тыс.

@matpagnolo7041 3 года назад

Outstanding. No daft music, quick editing, top knowledge to share, and the toothbrush! Just brilliant.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

That's my style. Simple.

@user-ki9ez8wx7f 3 года назад

Absolutely brilliant

@PaulB__ 3 года назад

Totally agree!

@Hitherto90 3 года назад

The friggin toothbrush is legend.

@esatd34 3 года назад

hes faster than Red Kit.

@o0julek0o 3 года назад

Ah, the toothbrush. The pinnacle of pointing tools.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

I love it

@mrsauce9307 3 года назад

lmfaoo

@FtanmoOfEtheirys 3 года назад

Hey, it's not just ANY toothbrush. It's a COLGATE!

@Autunite 3 года назад

@@FtanmoOfEtheirys I believe it's most likely his brother's toothbrush.

@ronhaworth5808 3 года назад

"Four wasn't enough and six was too many" -- Audi on why they developed a 5 cylinder engine.

@mstar501 3 года назад

Mighty Audi 5 cylinder engines from the eighties, early nineties...

@SandyMcInnesMagicMemories 3 года назад

“When four are a bore and six are a nix, Audi thrives with five.”

@georgiahoosier 3 года назад

For their commercials they had some lab coat clad "engineers" saying "Four is too small, six is too bulky"

@mstar501 3 года назад

@@georgiahoosier true, they did not want the length of a six cylinder but still the smooth running of it.

@TitoLukason 3 года назад

AUDI is nazi crap!

@DannyHDpsn 3 года назад

17:20 holy shit that's the best diagram i have ever seen about explaining primary and secondary forces in an engine! INSANE QUALITY!

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks

@vanitatoftby 3 года назад

Agreed. I would like to see how a 3I and a V8 is in comparison with these in the video.

@jannejohansson3383 3 года назад

That guy is genius, and he can "see" how the other people's understant those things what he want to show or learn to us.

@Your_username_ 3 года назад

Janne Johansson That is the definition of a good teacher.

@michaell3711 3 года назад

@@speedkar99 ,, Is this the same engine as the Honda Inspire of the 90s?

@Forgan_Mreeman 3 года назад

when I tell people that I like cars, this is what I mean. the sheer amount of engineering that goes into designing an engine is mind boggling

@TheLiamis 3 года назад

Bikes have the same or more. 1 of the hest bike engines was a honda v5.

@damionlabounty7116 3 года назад

the terrible engineering is mind boggling, i see way too many solutions to no existent problems here, like why incorporate cam bearings into the valve cover, it’s very useful to be able to check things with cam and lifters with the cams still bolted into the engine

@David-lr2vi 3 года назад

@@damionlabounty7116 Yeah. Basically they design engines now to be a single use disposable item. Servicing isn’t thought about at all and if anything happens to an engine now you basically throw it away and put a whole new engine in (or dispose of the car altogether).

@neo_falcon 3 года назад

Your channel name and pic had me cracking up 🤣💀

@funfun5656 Год назад

@@TheLiamis V5? Please explain how an uneven number of cyls are in a V config

@MichaelPolymhxanos 3 года назад

17 minutes, 52 seconds of full information, fast and slick editing, and no worthless bla bla bla. Well done, I learned many things from this video, thanks.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

That's my style

@cuckingfunt9353 3 года назад

This dude is the bollox. Max respect from the UK.

@cuckingfunt9353 3 года назад

@@speedkar99 The amount of stuff I have learned from your channel . Top quality .

@thebustosfamily 3 года назад

I own a Volvo S60 with a 5 cylinder and never understood about the balance issue until now. Thank you.

@stormchaser2007 3 года назад

Let's just say the engine has excessive vibration

@reallyhappenings5597 3 года назад

@@stormchaser2007 Stick with the factory engine mounts and subframe bushings, they got them just right. Avoid polyurethane. These 5 cyl Volvos are very smooth cars, I own two.

@soundseeker63 3 года назад

@@stormchaser2007 I've driven a few 5-cyl vehicles and never noticed that. If it's well maintained and running properly there should be no noticeable vibration.

@lshurr 3 года назад

Maybe this is the best, most cogent explanation of engine vibration I've ever seen. He even remembered to include the inline 4's vertical shake, but he didn't mention the problem with torsional vibration in an inline straight six. Reminds me of a documentary elsewhere on RU-vid about the history of racing at Mercedes Benz. Mercedes started racing again in the 50's. Torsional vibration is usually managed by including a vibration damper at one end of the crankshaft, but Mercedes thought that if they put the power take-off in the middle of the crankshaft, then they could also shorten it and reduce torsional vibration that way, but they were wrong. In an interview with one the engineers who designed the new engine, as he chuckled, he explained how they ended up having to put vibration dampers at both ends of the crankshaft, resulting in a longer shaft than they would have had otherwise.

@trevor311264 3 года назад

My Korean-built car (It has an MB 5 cylinder engine made under licence) has vacuum engine mounts that adjust themselves dependant on the engine RPM. When idling there is very little vacuum and they lift up and dampen the vibrations more. But as you rev the engine harder the vacuum in them builds and pulls them down compressing the internal springs making the mounts become stiffer as the engine movement is less of a problem. So to surmise, Low RPM, wobbly mounts with the engine sitting a few inches higher, high RPM, engine mounts pulling engine down stiffly to the chassis.

@brettkirkpatrick464 3 года назад

Fantastic explanation of many tricky points. The detailed breakdown of the oiling system was phenomenal and the pcv box disassembly truly demonstrates how that system can (and does fail). The explanation of the firing order and comparison to other engines is what puts the video over the top. I originally viewed the Subaru engine teardown and now I'm convinced that speedkar99 is doing something unique. The editing is the key and it makes the subject matter fly, all while allowing the audience to appreciate the detailed research and clarity of the presentation through the voiceover. Thank you very much for all the effort, many people will benefit from this video!

@speedkar99 3 года назад

I'm glad you appreciate my efforts. I have alot of teardown videos like this on various parts of the car. Feel free to check them out and share. Thanks

@brucea550 3 года назад

Yup, made 18 minutes seem like 5! I didn’t expect a complete tear down AND amazing explanation in that timeframe. Got the same oil filter setup on my Benz diesel 5 cyl, it sucks.

@MrDogeking 3 года назад

totally this 18 minutes just flew by. I actually should be doing other stuff but this video got me hooked.

@englishmuffin5274 Год назад

It's been 4 years and I still miss my 3.7 i5. Should've never sold it. Never seen the guts of a Volvo 5-cyl before, this was very interesting stuff.

@sebofo 3 года назад

We had a Volvo V70 with a five-cylinder naturally aspirated for many years. A wonderful motor. Never failed. We sold the care because it was simply getting too worn everywhere.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

I can understand haha

@Godgiveninsight 3 года назад

I am flabbergasted by the complexity of engines and completely mind blownen by the fact that anyone could possibly understand it.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

It sure is complex but wait until you see a transmission

@OrcaBoat3 2 месяца назад

I have a 3.7 liter five-cylinder engine in my 2011 Chevrolet Colorado and a love it. It's been running great for 13 years!

@markiangooley 3 года назад

The 5-cylinder Audi engine based on a VW inline 4 had a reputation for reliability. I had an 1988 Audi 5000 turbo. Almost everything on it broke except the turbocharger and that engine.

@renatakosir8402 3 года назад

Of course these Volvo 5 cylinder engines are not know for reliability they are trash. Haha not realy.

@Thurrock91 3 года назад

The Volvo 5cil design comes from porsche. Anyway i have driven a Volvo S70 2.5 10v 144hp sold it with 500.000km. A Volvo S60 D5 163hp sold it with 420.000km A S80 2.4 20v 170hp almost 300.000km on it. All 3 cars are still running.... never had any engine problems.

@fuckenoathcunt4230 3 года назад

@@Thurrock91 VW's PD Engines were the first engines to conquer half a million miles and are literally fucking bullet proof. Fuck Volvo

@michaelmertin4018 3 года назад

Had the vw/Audi 5cyl years ago,380k startet sumpcommresson.with additive to oil 4500.have now vw t4 with 5cyl petrol.lasts for ever.....

@hagglundguy 3 года назад

@@fuckenoathcunt4230 VW PDs have their issues. Volvo engines however will run forever if serviced. I'm not saying the VW engine is shit, theres tons of them here in Finland that have been driven +600 000km but theres more Volvos that have done the feat. I think it comes down to how expensive the car around the engine is. People are less likely to fix a cheaper VW whilst a more expensive Volvo might get better service which in turn will keep it on the road longer.

@skitzvitz 3 года назад

The amount of knowledge you cram into a short video with so little fluff and a little comedy is incredible. Hat off sir hat off!

@realshona263 4 месяца назад

I have owned the T5 engine for over 3 years, S40 and C30. To be honest, this is the best video teaching me of my engine I have watched. I now know it way better. Thank you.

@speedkar99 4 месяца назад

Glad it helped

@blakejanischh3091 3 года назад

Thoroughly impressed with your videos on all these different types of engines. Like others say, no dumb music, no over talking, just plain informative explanations on the engines and how they work. I would love to have a tech school with you as a master.

@aboyd1988 3 года назад

Your videos are great. Quick, clear, to the point, and full of useful information! This one is particularly useful to me as I own a '95 Volvo 850 with a suspected clogged PCV system. I can tell that you know A LOT about engines. You earned a subscriber.

@jeremymurphy7320 3 года назад

Barring a head gasket failure, which wasn't apparent, I'd say the oil cooler failed internally and allowed a mixture of oil and coolant. Edit: Another great video. Keep 'em coming.

@neathway382 3 года назад

That was my guess as well.

@reallyhappenings5597 3 года назад

That's disconcerting. Oil cooler failures are a rarity on these engines (Volvo "white block") and not treated as a maintenance item. I have two of them. Ford bought Volvo mainly for this engine and used it in some early 2000s models.

@fiveable 3 года назад

Oil cooler failure is actually not that much of a rarity. The external oil cooler failed on my whiteblock at under 100k miles. Fortunately I caught it quickly. I’m at 266k+ miles now on the same bottom end. Daily driver, 2000 V70 B5244S.

@redneckswitwheels 3 года назад

The ford 6.0 diesel engine is the same. Many 6.0's died this way 😢

@bbbnnuuuhgg7016 3 года назад

I don't know why they need an oil cooler on that motor

@andrewkatz3845 3 года назад

This video has probably the highest info per minute factor of any I've seen on RU-vid. Fantastic, and no stupid distractions. Thanks.

@UncleBiscuits97 3 года назад

I love this guy's subtle humor in these videos. I don't know why, but I lost it when he said he had to remove one million bolts when he was takig off the cover.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Haha thanks

@armandoguillen8101 3 года назад

For some people, this would be a 14pt series.

@The_Touring_Jedi 3 года назад

🤦‍♂️

@CarlosGlatzos976 Год назад

Great to the point video. I love these engines, hate to see that drivers let them take so much damage and discard the vehicle instead of taking care of it better. I owned two of them (B5244T5 and B5244S2) and both were running smoothly and reliable for over 300.000 km, last one still in use waiting on completing the next 300.000. The 2.4l engines are a little better to service, as the oil filter is top-down and the PCV trap is separate.

@zzoinks Год назад

Great! One issue I'm scared of is there is a PCV banjo bolt in these engines that has a metal ball inside and it has been known to unluckily break and cause the metal ball to get sucked into the engine and cause damage. They released an updated banjo bolt, but it seems like either a snapped timing/accessory belt or a broken banjo bolt can be the immediate death to the engine! Pine Hollow Auto Diagnostics made a video on the Volvo where the banjo bolt broke. (there is an updated banjo bolt that doesn't break)

@CarlosGlatzos976 Год назад

@@zzoinks thanks for sharing. I changed my pcv trap a while ago, did not know about that failure.

@clayreal 2 месяца назад

I normally set my playback speed at 1.5 or 1.75, but I liked your presentation so much that I was willing to back up almost to the beginning and set it to normal speed. And I don’t know if this is a compliment, or a critique, but even with you on normal speed, and listening to it a second time over, I had trouble following! Bro, this is actually totally a compliment. I am so grateful for your interest in following the oil circuit through the PCV valve and dis-assembling that valve assembly. I really enjoyed following along with your narration, and your frame of mind was very refreshing , also therapeutic. This message coming from everyone who struggles with aggravation during complex mechanical projects. Keep up the good work!

@priyanga0 2 года назад

This guy is fantastic!!!!!! There's no nonsense. He gets to the point. He knows his stuff. He has a unique style as well :-) Toothbrush, wife's t-shirt, brothers towel...etc.

@fluffsmagruffs9310 3 года назад

anyone else cring when the held the valve cover over the engine and all that crap fell in

@simonwarren8856 3 года назад

The engine failed

@ollie42 3 года назад

Yea I cringed... But then remembered it was a totaled engine anyways 🤷‍♂️

@2004helloWorld 3 года назад

yes, very much so. that's when i paused to read the comments.

@esatd34 3 года назад

Thats when you realize this engine isnt going to have a life anymore

@beaterbikechannel2538 3 года назад

It made me cringe too.

@3RTracing 3 года назад

so many folks miss one of the outstanding values of a 5 or 10 cylinder motor. It has extremely flat torque throughout the curve and the dynamic balance is exceptionally good. You have ignition every 72 degrees. What we seem to be missing here is that Benz, EMD, GE, and many other significant prime mover manufactures have done very well with variants of the 5 cylinder engines.

@comradeglogi 3 года назад

Such an informative video, no-nonsense, loaded with knowledge and well-edited. Fact that this 18-minute video felt like it was 6 minutes long says enough. Liked and subscribed!

@petemaravich2245 3 года назад

If only this guy was everyone's mechanic, the world would be a better place

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Im not a mechanic I am an engineer

@furionese 3 года назад

45min worth of information crammed into 18min lol Well done sir and thank you

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Glad I'm able to save you time

@sephiros9883 3 года назад

Such an underrated channel. I love the humour too!

@bubblehead78 3 года назад

One of the best explanations of engine balancing and moments I've seen. Great video.

@richb.4374 3 года назад

The Atlas engine is also an excellent 5 cylinder. These are also known as the "Vortec" engines and they were found in SUV's. They were made in 4,5 and 6 cylinder versions by GM at their now defunct Moraine Ohio plant. I love the Vortec 4200 in my Trailblazer, great running inline 6 with plenty of power for a daily driver.

@ridinmontana4k554 3 года назад

Dude you are second to none for breaking down an engine. Great videos!

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks. I also break other car parts down too 😉

@test40323 3 года назад

Thanks for the breakdown. I especially like the explanation on engine configuration and balance - this is the clearest I've heard!

@cuckingfunt9353 3 года назад

Those diagrams.... I never thought about it but clearly someone has.

@texannationalist5887 3 года назад

fantastic video. the diagrams of the forces in different engine layouts were super well done and really help the viewer understand what's going on.

@neonalon 3 года назад

The older versions of these engines use steel oil pickup tubes. Know a few people who worked for Volvo back in the day and by the time Ford had more influence they did some cost cutting (though I wager the cast saving is minimal if you factor in the price of a mold to make the plastic parts for the pick up). No extra chain to oil pump - nice Big oil channels, easy to clean, because of the bed plate construction also very easy to manufacture (no deep holes to be drilled) Bed plate construction (the upper oil pan) make the engine block really stable. I remember the bearings reside in steel inserts? 10 bolt connection to the flywheel - beefy Steel water pump impeller, probably still the original pump too. Cool to see the insides of the RNC 5 cylinder (RNC = Revised N Compact?), only seen the older ones!

@CatonsvilleCentralRwy 3 года назад

“Oil is not a good coolant” *Mutters angrily in air cooled*

@calvinnickel9995 3 года назад

And oil still isn’t a good coolant. That’s why they are _air cooled_ engines, not oil-cooled. Spent many a summer day waiting for takeoff in a light aircraft with oil temp edging towards the red, 60 weight oil pressure almost nothing, hoping that the plane would still climb with the extra 20 knots I was going to add to climb speed to try and keep the the engine from overheating. Then the opposite... coming down at 200MPH in icy winds and unable to reduce power to increase descent rate without shock cooling. Oil is best for lubricating.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Oil does a minor degree of cooling to the piston heads, but the it's not as effective as coolant

@2strokepower803 3 года назад

In a 2 stroke it actually cools

@zacharyclarke4240 3 года назад

@@calvinnickel9995 oil cooled engines also exist

@dangerousdoggo5465 3 года назад

Some pitbikes have oil cooling. (including mine)

@rex_s80 3 года назад

The plastic style pick up tube actually has better flow and doesn’t clog up as easily and is considered an upgrade on older engines. I’m guessing it is difficult to create that shape with metal in mass production so they used plastic. It works well and has proven to not be an issue. I had a metal style that I swapped for a the later plastic one and it improved oil flow significantly.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Good to know

@AnAvgJoe 3 года назад

You are absolutely amazing at explaining how everything works! Fenominal job! Once you explained the unbalancing of forces along the horizontal axis, it made me realize the wobble I'm getting under acceleration in low gears might be caused by worn engine mounts. That will be my next repair and I'm keeping my fingers crossed that worn engine mounts were the suspect and it's not something else because I'm not sure what else can cause it. Thanks for the great information!!!!

@whogavehimafork 3 года назад

The ruthless efficiency of the editing in this video has made me a fan

@broke123 3 года назад

The amount of knowledge that got thrown at me in this was awesome

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Glad you could benefit

@rioscdodat 3 года назад

I love how much you teach about the engine, so much valuable information for free thank you

@Valhorde 3 года назад

Brilliantly explained and edited, thank you so much for boiling down all this precious knowledge for us !

@steamerjohn9212 3 года назад

Wow, I have no need to know anything about a 5 cylinder engine but this video was filmed and edited so well I enjoyed viewing every bit of it. Well Done!

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Glad you enjoyed it!!

@InFiD3ViL1 3 года назад

Damn, this man has his ICE knowledge nailed! Impressive. I will have to disagree on the top mounted cartridge oil filter setup being more prone to messes. I find that it is a much more efficient and clean way to change a filter. The oil drains out when the engine is off, rather than pooling inside the filter like your typical steel canister style. Also, most of them come out with the cap. But for filtering I still prefer the spin-on canister type filters.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks. Sure it drains but your still open to a dripping filter in the engine bay as opposed to spinning it down the Bottom into a drain pan

@jeremytucker8853 2 года назад

@@jimmer411 awesome life hack!

@leighriley6277 3 года назад

Great video....you can't beat the sound of a five cylinder symphony, my Land rover discovery 2 has a TD5, 5 cylinder turbo diesel, brilliant design, powerful, tunable and reliable 👍👍

@Obsidian369 3 года назад

Hey man you are the most fluid speaking person on even a complex topic. Nowhere have I ever heard such smooth informative talk.. PLUS i love the toothbrush... Dont ever lose the toothbrush.

@PeteBetter 3 года назад

I've been speeding up most of my RU-vid videos. Not this one. Intelligent, concise and interesting.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks. You are right, lots of time wasters out there

@TheBandit7613 3 года назад

I have a 4.0 inline six in my old Jeep. Still runs like it did 28 years ago. Wish I still did! Inline six engines are my personal favorite. Silky smooth torque, like the hand of god.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Nice, I love the Inline 6.

@zachsteele6964 3 года назад

@Mississippi Ditch Fisher put a better motor in it I suppose

@Greatdome99 3 года назад

The Jeep 6 has an interesting history, starting out as an AMC six in the 1960s for various models. They then cut off two cylinders off to make a straight four for the 1984 Cherokee (a GM V6 was an option). When GM pulled out, AMC was forced to create a "new" six by adding two cylinders to its four.

@faustin289 3 года назад

Everyone swear by the smoothness of i6 engines. Why have we then been stuck with crappy inline 4s?

@justinmartin8887 3 года назад

Inline 6 is the king of engines. Most industrial engine companies are now focusing on inline 6 and v12 engines, as the parts crossover between the two are excellent. Manufacturing is supper efficiency. And of course; efficiency, longevity, balance and torque go hand in hand and are top notch out of an inline6 or v12

@drsuffcatr8319 3 года назад

Dang, lack of maintenance killed this Volvo. I have a 2004 S60R and around 220,000 miles now on it. On these, the sandwiched cylinders is only an issue on the 2.5 blocks, namely the 2.5 in the r. Under high boost, there is a chance for the cylinder wall to crack, expelling exhaust gases into the coolant system. The fix is usually either shimming the block, in the thin space between the cylinders or resleeving the block with new Darton sleeves. The head gasket can be replaced with the r/t5 one for better reliability, as they are used for the all out high HP builds. The PVC system is notorious for issues, you can use the glove test method to see if you may have an issue. These Volvo 5 cyls are only as good as the maintenance. If you are on top of it, they last forever, however if you are a slacker, it will die. You can't treat it like a Honda/ Chevy. On turbo Volvo's, the turbo isn't integrated with the manifold, so swapping is fairly easy. Also, the Volvo 5 and 6 cyl motors have many swappable with minor modifications parts, ie pistons and such. Since they are a modular design. It's common for people to take the t5 pistons and swap them into the t6 motor. The valve cover has a liquid gasket. In the end, these are absolutely fantastic motors for people willing to do the work. They, with some modifications, can be absolute monsters and fairly reliable, it's just you need to be a stickler for maintenance.

@veoverse4286 3 года назад

Yes they are great engines, i have the 2.5T in my ford focus st and it sounds awesome! :)

@SilasHumphreys 3 года назад

Yeah, that needed better oil management (fully synthetic, and changed on schedule) and it looked to me like it needed more long trips. Volvo designed these engines to be used; short trips will kill them if you don't go for an Italian tuneup every once in a while. They're not as tolerant of neglect as the old red blocks, but when looked after and treated well, they're just as durable.

@gustavmeyrink_2.0 3 года назад

Ferdinand Piëch, Porsche heir, VW chairman and later owner of VW Group, designed a 5 pot diesel for Mercedes (in between leaving Porsche and joining Audi) which was renowned for it's reliability. Million milers without rebuilt were common. Later he used the 5pot concept for Audi as a gasoline engine which powered the legendary Audi Quattro WRC car and the Audi 90 IMSA race car.

@chriswilliams2652 3 года назад

Very well done. You clearly know your stuff. Even more impressive that this is the first time you've seen this particular engine.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks and yes it was a learning experience for me

@mprice323 3 года назад

great video, just want to say I love top mounted cartridge filters if you let them drain a little before completely removing and you have a vacuum extractor you have no-mess oil changes that you never need to get underneath the car for

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Good idea. But not everyone wants to wait overnight for an oil change

@gcrauwels941 3 года назад

I have the B5254T4 in my '07 VR, very similar. Those slits between the cylinders can be shimmed for added strength.

@hasebase7227 Год назад

Such a underrated engine that one.

@connorc9585 3 года назад

I can’t remember the last time I saw such an informative video with awesome explanations like this one. Well done to you sir

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Check my Subaru boxer engine video

@BYENZER 3 года назад

Your video editing is THE BEST I'VE EVER SEEN!!!

@sandiego7625 3 года назад

The table thing just cracks me up along with his wife's dress & his brothers toothbrush, underwear, shirt, socks, blanket & twisted screwdriver. I got my eye on you SpeedKar

@timjohnson1199 3 года назад

Wow. That's a lot of information in a few minutes. Now I'm an expert on that engine.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks

@sbcavo4332 3 года назад

This is an insanely high quality video. No fluff, just interesting and relevant info.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

That's my style, short and to the point why waste time

@mojbr704 11 месяцев назад

i just opene this video to see the movement of a 5 cylinders engine but then i got exited seeing you doing all this and it looks so easy for you, well done

@NICKELGHANDI 3 года назад

Very nice video. I like your editing style. Volvo did make some very solid 5 cylinder engines. Look pre-1999 and you'll find gold. PCV issues were still present, but other than that they were basically bulletproof.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks. Yes they did have some solid motors. Too bad the rest can't be said for everything else

@kw9849 Год назад

I'd argue Volvo's Mid-2000's 5 Cylinders were better designed. A lot of the annoying or inadequate aspects of this generation (plastic thermostat housing, vertical oil filter, sealing issues, etc) were improved upon or solved.

@brianhind6149 3 года назад

Your descriptions are excellent. A great help would be to speak more slowly. Great video.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks. I try to be as concise as possible

@jwsoaresjones1560 3 года назад

@@speedkar99 You succeed.

@CarmenGabrielAvle 3 года назад

use the playback speed dial, under settings, to slow the speed

@bluetorch13 Год назад

When you least expect, you find another freaking awesome youtuber. Looking to replace the timing belt on a T5 I found this gem. You are incredibly good explaining.

@patrykmazurkiewicz3866 3 года назад

The technical juice squeezed into as little time as possible - I love it! But you made me palpitating when I saw the amount of dust you poured onto the camshaft in 1:27, seriously :D

@hereigoagain5050 3 года назад

Another great video. Its almost as though the engineers get tired. "Well, we are 95% done with this super complex engine. Let's finish it off with some cheap, plastic bits."

@makecba 3 года назад

that's wasn't the engineers, blame accounting...

@lehelzelenka207 3 года назад

Generally the plastic parts-given they are quality made- tend to serve the engine through it's lifetime. It makes the engine lighter, cheaper and all other stuff that matter like how quickly can an engine warm up to operating temperature. An 80Kg engine warms up faster than a 90Kg engine.

@ameunier41 3 года назад

Those plastic bits didn't look cheap by any means. They seemed in perfect working order. Even the PCV look in good condition, it's the seals and valve that goes to ghost.

@josephdragojevich7041 3 года назад

i love these engines, they used the same block for nearly 25 years, meaning you can go to a junk yard and find parts very easy. the bottom end of these engines are nearly bullet proof, its the valves you have to worry about, if the valve stem seals are allowed to leak then you will burn an exhaust valve leaving you with no compression.

@EricTheGreat508 3 года назад

This video is key for anyone who doesn’t understand how a 4 stroke engine works!!! So much detailed info!!

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks

@floydbush5675 3 года назад

P9åää0

@johnburgess4941 3 года назад

Hands down the best breakdown videos come from you man, Love your work! I totally want to see something on the new aluminum f150s. 2015-2020 models.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Glad you enjoyed it. I'd keep my eye out for scrap engine and transmissions to do a teardown on

@jessewildman1292 3 года назад

Great vid. Was looking forward to this one. I have 6 volvos and 5 of them are older than 1998. I honestly don’t like these newer versions of the 5 cylinders. The original N version from 93-98 was the best. The oil pickup was metal like you were saying it should be, there weren’t as many oil passages because it didn’t have VVT, and the cylinder walls were a little thicker. The RN 5 cylinders that came after were ok too, but they introduced VVT, and for whatever reason, it seems like the tolerances were much tighter and therefore they were much more prone to throwing rod bearings plus the cylinder walls weren’t as thick, so the higher HP models were prone to cracked blocks. I love the original N 5 cylinders. Best reliability, durability, and longevity. I currently daily drive a 94 850 with 328k on it.

@rex_s80 2 года назад

Depends on what motor you got. The older 2.4L turbo N was 83mm block as well. The later RN 2.4 T5 (not 2.4t) has 81mm bore. It’s really dependent on which bore block the motor used rather than N vs RN. the 2.3L t5 used 81mm. I would say the move from hydraulic to solid lifters for the Rn as long as mechanical tensioner was an improvement. I do agree about the rod bearings for the 04+ RN when they did a semi engine facelift for the p2 models. The cylinder heads for the RN have more flow than N head. Even more than a stage 1 ported N head. Ups and downs of both. But we can both agree the RNC is just a mess in comparison 🤣 . (The one in the video)

@jessewildman1292 Год назад

@@rex_s80 Yeah, it does depend on the trim model for the motor. I was mostly referring to the R line of the P2s and also the 2.5 T5 RNC motor. Yeah, the solid lifters, mechanical tensioner, and better flowing head were nice, but the benefits kinda outweigh the cons for me. But yeah, RNC is the pinnacle of garbage. 😂

@kellyherald1390 3 года назад

I owned a 2007 Chevy Colorado with a 3.7L 5cyl inline. That engine was smooth and had good torque.

@PetesGarageandperformance 3 года назад

I used to work at a Hummer dealership and worked on a ton of the I5 engines. They were relatively smooth, but for some reason would always break exhaust manifolds and manifold bolts. I always attributed it to the 5cylinder design. Although it could’ve just been crappy manifold castings.

@khoov48 3 года назад

Mines a 2005 3.5l l5 Chevy Colorado. Supposed to be famous for soft heads and leaky valves too...? (Updated from 3.5l to the 3.7l in '07-'12 models) Mline has 160k miles on mine and it's all original engine parts, head and manifold even. I love my 5 cyl Colly, gonna run her till she can't no more. Thing does run smooth, like new everyday. I really run my pickup, keep up with the maintenance, possibly even just luck of the draw.. I change oil via oil life indicator, tells me when to "change oil soon" and I run Quaker State full synthetic 5w30 and change the spin on filter every oil change, sometimes every 5k m. The oil change indicator usually runs 10k and no more than 12k intervals

@Ephoros 3 года назад

I currently drive a first gen C70 coupe, with a 2.0 liter 5 cilinder "high pressure" (as Volvo call this modification) turbo. Literary cant say anything bad about it. The car itself is comfortable, and the engine... Power: plenty, and can be tuned to be even better. Fuel economy: great. Smoothness: on idle it's barely audible. Exhaust note: with rear mufler deleted, and replaced with a resonator, it's still not loud, yet gives it a nice, low grumble. In one word, awesome. And the turbo flutter... Cant get enough of it. I think i will stick with the anomaly for now, thank you. :D

@gregorytimmons4777 3 года назад

My friend has a silver one imported to the U.S. Pretty rare beast over here I guess.

@Ephoros 3 года назад

@@gregorytimmons4777 If i recall correctly, there were like 24 000 first gen coupes made. Not super rare, but rare enough to be interesting. And it's a good car!

@Stringfellow-xo6do 3 года назад

I recently sold my 2006 ford focus ST which has the turbocharged version of this engine. Seeing it stripped down was something I always wanted to experience. Split cylinder lining was an issue until the 2008 face-lift model. Cool vid.

@danielsylvester3725 3 года назад

god damn, your editing and videos are perfect

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks

@WoodLox 2 года назад

Very descriptive and informative. I appreciate that hearing the language. Not many can, thank you. That over lap makes due in a Colorado pick up or rally when torque needs to be. Well spoken. Thank you.

@donovanlucibello379 2 года назад

Brilliant tour through that engine, happens to be one of my favorites (in the turbo variety).

@vijayvjn6874 3 года назад

13:34 according to vida that is a resistive element to heat the oil vapor in very cold climate to aid better separation of oil from combustion fumes

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks for the clarification. I was wondering what that was about

@vijayvjn6874 3 года назад

@speedkar99 Was looking forward to this video ever since the subaru engine video,where you showed a sneak peak,My brother has a volvo c30 with the b522s4 engine in it that failed, started producing a lot of blowby in the crankcase causing the intake cam seal to pop off, after replacing the seal as we assumed the crankcase pressure might be because of a faulty pcv membrane,it still started pushing the cam seal and we later found this was due to scoring on one of the cylinder leading to excessive pressure in the crankcase (the cause of the scoring which i intially assumed was when the cam seal came of and he lost oil pressure, but when we tore it down, all the main bearings had no damage and everything indicated there was no drop in oil pressure as he caught the leak quick enough. I saw a small chip of metal missing from the piston crown and welded back on the side of the piston crown causing it to score deep lines in that cylinder liner,Such a weird failure mode, I realized later that,once when someone else was driving the car one of the vaccum lines on the upper intake plenum leading the a evap purge solenoid valve broke off and the engine was suddenly exposed to a massive vaccum leak on the highway, which may have caused a few detonation to remove a small sliver of material from the piston crown and weld it at the other end of the piston causing it to score the cylinder. (the theory is that fuel trims couldn't adjust quick enough to control the massive lean condition caused by the vaccum leak on the highway leading to the detonation that killed it as described, thought i would share that because that was the very first time i encountered one of this

@ghostwrench2292 3 года назад

That engine doesn’t have an EGR valve.

@lordjaashin 3 года назад

@@ghostwrench2292 lemony snickets series of unfortunate events

@vijayvjn6874 3 года назад

@@ghostwrench2292 i meant to say evap purge solenoid, i edited the post

@paulwells4203 3 года назад

I appreciate your attention to detail. I finally understand what the term spun bearing refers to after all these years lol. Subscribed.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Same here. When I first saw a spun bearing in a G35 engine it was quite interesting to think how something like that could happen. That engine was worse and had a cracked crankshaft.

@blubase06 3 года назад

These are so damn interesting and I didn't know I was actually able to keep up quick enough to actually learn how this engine operates.

@marwanhamadi275 3 года назад

Absolute clear explanation..as a DIYer, I thought that I've already bought all kinds of tolls until you showed up with that toothbrush.

@alexstromberg7696 3 года назад

The turbo engines do not have a in head manifold. You must remember that they made this engine for like 20 years, so you have to specify which year you're talking about.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Good to know. Most modern turbo cars integrate it

@jur8831 3 года назад

The older models have the oil filter on the bottom of the engine with really easy acces. The oil pick-up line also changed from metal to plastic apparently. And im guessing this is a 2,5 liter engine which has thinner cilinder walls compared to the older 2,3 liter ones. The cilinder walls on the 2,5 liters will crack when tuned to much.

@The_Touring_Jedi 3 года назад

@@jur8831 2.4L 4 inline natural aspirated engine with multiiport injection is where reliabilty begins. Yes, it consumes little bit more, but lifespan of such engines is great.

@publicmail2 3 года назад

I'm guessing you work or own a junk yard? Great channel 1 of a kind!!

@stevewilson7857 3 года назад

One of the most informative videos I’ve ever seen. Thanks!

@olafv.2741 3 года назад

Amazing high information density. And it is so much nicer to show a real engine.

@facusan2339 3 года назад

8:53 Actually replacing the oil filter is not messy at all, you can remove the filter without leaving a single drop of oil on the engine. Spin-on filters, at least to me whenever change them on a Chevy express, those are a mess EVERY TIME. Source: I do my oil changes on my S40 and C70 BTW: Great video and nice editing.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

I've got cars with both. The cartridge always leaves you open to dripping oil, not to mention cleaning out the housing and Changing the o-ring. Many manufacturers have gone back to a spin on style

@johnroberts1505 3 года назад

@@speedkar99 then you must be doing something wrong. I have two autos with top mounted oil filters and I have never spilled a single drop. You just have to wait a little while so that the oil drains down. Autos; BMW 330i, Ford F150.

@CEHepp 3 года назад

speedkar99 Before draining the oil, loosen the filter and let it sit. While you’re doing other work, like draining the oil, the filter housing will drain. No mess.

@MrWeisbrod 3 года назад

I love the cartridge filter of my s40. Much better for the environment (less waste), and I find that it drains just fine. You just have to be patient, as the others have noted. In fact, it is a much "less-messy" oil change when compared to the downward-pointing filters on my wife's Honda. It also allows you to "prime" the filter a bit with new oil (which I can do on my Honda, too), unlike older upward-pointing screw-on filters.

@233kosta 3 года назад

I like the cartridge ones, they're less hassle. Also, for some reason, manufacturers seem to think that less filter should cost more... the mind boggles...

@whitehorse1959 3 года назад

This teardown makes me really appreciate the freakish reliability of the 4.0 ltr straight-six Barra engine in my Australian Ford Falcon. Similar 4-valves per cylinder, oil-operated variable valves, but with a timing CHAIN and a very simple PCV system on top of the engine cover. Oh, and a water pump that is easy to replace. 512,000 km's so far since 2003, and the oil stays clean (LPG).

@SkiRacingOz Год назад

Barra’s and intechs mate, unbreakable

@soundseeker63 3 года назад

Nice teardown and explanation. Very thorough especially the the bit about engine balancing and power stroke overlap. One little point about the editing though. It might be good to pause for breath once in a while. Twenty minutes without a full stop is a bit hard to take in! lol That "5-cylinder coffee table" made me smile. Reminds me of the time when Top Gear made a V8 powered rocking chair! :-D

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Thanks, the coffee table came out great! I do take breaths but I edit them out to take time.

@steveb.6267 3 года назад

Excellent video couldn’t stop watching. Packed full of interesting information. Used to have an Audi Quattro Gt with a five cylinder engine, loved that car. Greetings from Canada 🇨🇦.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Greetings from Toronto Canada as well

@Dwrecksk8Yo 3 года назад

Yea those plastic pieces are actually made from a glass and plastic mix which makes it relatively strong and it lightens everything for emissions and it dissipates heat very quickly. It’s the same type of plastic ford used for their thermostat housing on ford escorts and I’m sure other cars and trucks. But couldn’t the oil cooler have failed internally which mixed oil and coolant.

@cdjhyoung 3 года назад

The standing water in #3 bore suggests head gasket failure.

@looncraz 3 года назад

@@cdjhyoung I think someone removed the spark plugs and this engine was left out in the rain, I've seen the 5-cyl gasket failures and they're clearly visible... this one was fine, AFAICT. In fact, nearly every issue with this particular engine came from using the wrong oil. These engines REQUIRE high quality synthetic. Mobil 1 or better. I tore down my 850's engine at around 200,000 miles (for fun) and didn't have even a tiny amount of sludge.

@johngroberts952 3 года назад

The “plastic” parts in high temp area are Pa6-glass fiber reinforced which can be stronger than metal. Also much less susceptible to heat cracking.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Good call. How about warping and leaking due to heat?

@MrWeisbrod 3 года назад

That's good to know! However, the plastic tubing that makes up large parts of the cooling system gets very brittle after 100,000+ miles. I love my s40, but miss the simplicity and durability of my 850 (same engine, basically). While my favorite engine to drive is the inline 2.8L straight six from BMW, I must say I love the unique feel and sound of 5-cylinder engines, especially Volvos.

@derekinbritishcolumbia1449 3 года назад

The plastic coolant hose from BMW's engine block disintegrates after about 20 years. I was not impressed when my daughters 318i overheated after loosing coolant. Removal of the intake plenum was required just to gain access for replacement. Not a fan of plastic engine parts.

@shodanxx 3 года назад

@@speedkar99 My 2001 XC70 has 650000 km and this plastic oil pickup tube so I'm going to go with "it's not a problem"

@rampage3337 3 года назад

@@derekinbritishcolumbia1449 yeah plastic is not a good material for those kinds of parts. it's used becaus it's cheaper

@JackRussell021 3 года назад

I had a Volvo 850 back in the day - it had the 5-cylinder engine with a 5-speed manual. Never had any engine trouble - I kind of regretted ever giving the thing up. As soon as I saw the video title, I knew it must have been the same engine as what I had.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Yep they've had this family of engines since the early 90s

@5052Kevin 3 года назад

Excellent explanation of the primary and secondary forces acting on the crankshaft.

@ScubaCat3 3 года назад

I'd like to see a Yugo 3-cylinder breakdown. That'd be next level!

@miralemnermina142 3 года назад

Yugo never had a 3 cylinder engine, the weakest engine was a 903cc 45hp 8v 4cyl

@danh2134 3 года назад

Geo metro had 3 cylinder

@esphilee 3 года назад

Amazing. Cars are really cheap given the complexity. Good talking hand style of presentation.. that tooth brush is going to be famous.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Cars are very cheap compared to the engineering and manufacturing that have to be put into them! But think of the scale of production, once they've tooled up they are paying off for it very quickly

@leandrolaporta2196 3 года назад

Excellent explanation and the diagrams.... Awesome, thanks

@brettryan3298 3 года назад

Thank you for being so clear and concise with your teardown. Very nice

@TopEntertainmentNation 3 года назад

So many parts of an engine, aka many moving parts, you really just have to hope nothing breaks or messes up that causes damage

@speedkar99 3 года назад

One part fails, it can take out the whole engine

@kasperkjrsgaard1447 3 года назад

Well, i love my Volvo S60 2.4 S with 480.000 km on the clock. Keep the oilchanges and they run forever.

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Nice, what year?

@kasperkjrsgaard1447 3 года назад

speedkar99 A 2001 I spoke with a guy who previous had a Volvo with the same type of engine. He sold it with over 800.000 km on the block and it’s still running. Giving the proper maintanence they’ll run forever and sounds fantastic. 😊👌

@peterscheer3295 3 года назад

A really great tutorial of engine balance... This guy is an outstanding teacher..

@charlesdavid5137 3 года назад

Great work speedkar99! Beginning to love what I find here. Thank you for creating and sharing.

@AlexxanderOnYoutube 3 года назад

8 dislikes come from VW engineers who think that only VW has the inline 5 cylinder engine

@speedkar99 3 года назад

Maybe

@brentboswell1294 3 года назад

I'll take your Inline 5 cylinder engine and raise you a (Europe only) VR5 🤣

@calvinnickel9995 3 года назад

Ah yes. I drove one of those 2.5s in a rented Passat. It takes special German engineering to combine the power of a four cylinder with the fuel efficiency of a six.