Тёмный

Why is AMD better than NVIDIA at supporting multi-monitor setups? 

HUB Clips
Подписаться 17 тыс.
Просмотров 32 тыс.
50% 1

Today Tim and Steve get into why NVIDIA has so many issues with supporting multiple monitors compared to AMD
What's the performance difference between running 4 sticks of Ram as opposed to 2?
Join us on Patreon: / hardwareunboxed
Join us on Floatplane: www.floatplane....
Buy relevant products from Amazon, Newegg and others below:
Core i5-11600K - geni.us/jlEP
Core i7-11700K - geni.us/4s6Flp6
Core i9-11900K - geni.us/pq4sO
Core i5-10600K - geni.us/Rrku
Core i5-10600KF - geni.us/IH7l5FP
Core i7-10700K - geni.us/hNx1
Core i9-10900K - geni.us/tH9y
Ryzen 9 5950X - geni.us/NsJEp
Ryzen 9 5900X - geni.us/h38MFeB
Ryzen 7 5800X - geni.us/AkRU1R9
Ryzen 5 5600X - geni.us/Vyz5
Ryzen 5 3600 - geni.us/w5Q4k6F
Disclaimer: Any pricing information shown or mentioned in this video was accurate at the time of video production, and may have since changed
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may also earn a commission on some sales made through other store links
FOLLOW US IN THESE PLACES FOR UPDATES
Twitter - / hardwareunboxed
Facebook - / hardwareunboxed
Instagram - / hardwareunb. .
Music By: / lakeyinspiredg. .

Опубликовано:

 

12 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 232   
@scavengerspc
@scavengerspc Год назад
Because Nvidia doesn't give us what we want. They tell us what we want.
@po1odo1o
@po1odo1o Год назад
Shut up you. When Nvidia want your opinion, they'll give it to you.
@RobBCactive
@RobBCactive Год назад
The worst was them telling a load of us our GeForce cards were for Win8 and refusing to fix their driver install or Experience, so had to fall back to WHQL within 3 years of purchase.
@simon6658
@simon6658 Год назад
They also tell people you need CUDA and AI back in 2006. That's why Nvidia worth more than the combination of intel and AMD now. Back in 2006 AMD told people they need to separate the floating point from the CPU to GPU and almost bankrupted.
@Dark88Dragon
@Dark88Dragon Год назад
Right, the 1070 was and is my last card from Ngreedia for a long time I guess...switched 2 AMD in 2021 and got a huge boost for my system and its runnin very fine since then...plan 2 go with a 8800 or 8800xt for rock-solid native 1440p Ultra-Gaming in 2026, we will see
@RobBCactive
@RobBCactive Год назад
@@simon6658 Intel were bribing OEMs and had an illegal rebate scheme to stymie AMD sales. CUDA was originally about using the GPU for doing fp calculation, so your point is a total fail.
@badadvice787
@badadvice787 Год назад
AMD/ATI had the a multi monitor marketing campaign for a long time, before ultra wide monitors were available. A lot of work was put into “eyefinity”or whatever the branding was.
@datapro007
@datapro007 Год назад
I run multi-monitor setups with up to 4 monitors using both AMD and NVidia (3060). I haven't seen greater problems with one vs the other. Yes, I've had some monitors not wake up from time to time, but not more on one brand or the other. I'm wondering about the interplay of certain monitors with the GPU.
@fengxii
@fengxii Год назад
Very encouraging to hear that you say that AMD performs just as well with Premiere, I think that solves it then for my next graphics card
@ARedditor397
@ARedditor397 Год назад
It doesn’t watch the tech guy, he is a creator based channel
@mareck6946
@mareck6946 Год назад
@@ARedditor397 you have to enable it - and configure it for premiere etc. which is default on if you have a cuda capable card. for amd you have to specifically enable hw acceleration per feature - then it runs very well. just compare on last gen Masc pros with full amd gpus.
@carpelunam
@carpelunam Год назад
I had to get an AVI plugin to make my files work because Im going to be using the AV1 encoder. Dont listen to these negative nancy's its not even the GPU technically.. its the encoder. NVIDIA NVENC is topdog, but AMD has caught up a lot in the past 1.5 years and there not too far behind. (Other than Export speeds)
@NipahAllDay
@NipahAllDay Год назад
@@ARedditor397 No offense, but that youtuber is the last guy I'll trust with AMD info. Dude just comes off as an Intel and Nvidia shill, which I don't like to say, but he does give that energy.
@upfront2375
@upfront2375 Год назад
@@NipahAllDay Just like these creators here aren't well known "AMD fanboys" lol Dude everyone have their biases and AMD's least issues is multi monitors configs... But If you're happy with once in a while black screens and weird restarts (coz of drivers) and will blame some other part on your machine other than AMD cards, sure.. to hell with NVidia ;)
@JoshM7
@JoshM7 Год назад
I have issues with multi monitors but I partly blame the different resolution/refresh rates. But still feel like that could be fixed with optimizations. I was playing a game the other day and watching RU-vid on the other monitor. RU-vid dropped frames like crazy and this is on high end gear which is stupid. Enabling "media foundation" in chrome://flags seemed to have fixed the dropped frames though. Not even sure why it was an issue.
@noahbirdrevolution
@noahbirdrevolution Год назад
Are you using the nvidia Super Resolution to upscale web browser video? If so, the gpu doesn't like running games while upscaling and you'll have to uncheck it in nvidia settings.
@Bianks84
@Bianks84 Год назад
I find disabling hardware acceleration in general in any apps used while gaming can help with things like this. I've had youtube tank performance in Forza Horizon 5 until narrowing it down to that setting helped.
@JoshM7
@JoshM7 Год назад
@@noahbirdrevolution I don't use that but thanks for the suggestion. I might double check to see if somehow something like that was enabled. But I generally don't use that kinda stuff.
@JoshM7
@JoshM7 Год назад
@@Bianks84 That didn't help and I kinda was getting annoying when I was googling and seeing that being suggested and it not working. I wish it was just that. But what worked for me was the thing I mentioned in my main comment. I seem to always get the weird obscure problems that are a lot harder to find a quick fix for.
@Bianks84
@Bianks84 Год назад
@@JoshM7 I use Firefox so didn't have that issue but forgot to mention I have other weirdness as well for different resolution & refresh rate. Definitely made worse when going from AMD (5600XT) to Nvidia (3080).
@lc9245
@lc9245 Год назад
The card vendor is definitely the key here, I encountered problems with AMD and hardware acceleration while my old NVIDIA card was fine. Yet, I also had the multiple monitor not waking up/not showing up, black screen with sleep with NVIDIA. I think these little bumps have to have a systematic testing bench for them when a card is reviewed. As it is now, there’s no way to tell if the card will play nice until you have it on the system.
@Alex-zi1nb
@Alex-zi1nb Год назад
vendor shouldnt matter as they need to meet minimum nvidia specs and use nvidia bios
@LeegallyBliindLOL
@LeegallyBliindLOL Год назад
@@Alex-zi1nb Sry, what are you talking about? 😂 What you're saying has nothing to do with each other. Implementations can and will vary, even if they meet specs. You clearly don't work in this industry, do you
@mareck6946
@mareck6946 Год назад
prtoblem is theres so many dif configurations. as with ones default the other might not cope. such as 59.59 hz vs 60hz and such wierd shit.
@magnusnilsson9792
@magnusnilsson9792 Год назад
AMD GPU's definately have better drivers for multimonitors and I think the main issue is than Nvidia card will just push out the frames ASAP, not caring if the monitor can cope with it, while AMD asks the monitor for what IT would prefer. The effects showing is that on Nvidia cards, turning on my second monitor, makes the 1st monitor go black for a couple of seconds. Regarding sound, I have speakers on both my monitors, so when turning off the monitor who's speakers that are currently active, Nvidia still tries to use the speakers of the turned off monitor, while AMD senses that the monitor is off, and jumps to the 1st monitors speakers (or headphones) which ever was the previous speaker used. My 2nd monitor also has an issue with pixels hidden in the fram so I prefer scaling down a couple from 1920x1080 to 1824x1024 or something like that, AMD does this much smoother by useing percentage, while Nvidia only has rough stepping, albeit Nvidia allows for not linking the X & Y axis. This is based on comparring a 980Ti against a 6600, so maybe the 980Ti is just outdated, but a friend of mine seems to have the same issues with a 2060.
@cmgm6027
@cmgm6027 Год назад
Can confirm, had those problems with both a 2060 S and a 3080ti, I just assumed it was normal until I bought my 7900 xtx and never had problems again.
@saudqawam9835
@saudqawam9835 Год назад
@@cmgm6027 just out of curiosity how is ur experience with the 7900 xtx? I'm considering getting one and was just wondering (also if u have a VR headset does it work well since I've heard AMD struggles with VR)?
@syko846
@syko846 7 месяцев назад
​@@saudqawam9835 I know I'm 10 months to late on this question, but I run VR with the an ASRock 7900xtx Taichi and I play ACC daily VR high settings at 90hz locked. And if you know anything about ACC it runs like shit in VR, so the fact that it runs this good is all you need to know. Every other game runs flawlessly btw.
@gameplayers_cz9778
@gameplayers_cz9778 Год назад
I have bought nvidia rtx 4070 ti only because AMD rx 7900 xt has issues with multi monitor setup. I have 2x 1440p 165 hz monitor and 1x 1080 144 hz monitor. And on AMD i had power consumption on idle 100W, when on nvidia i have 30-35W on idle. AMD has not fixed this issue to this day.
@TheFyend
@TheFyend Год назад
I've had the opposite experience with AMD being a pain in the butt with multiple monitors where my games get horrible frametimes and slowness while still having decently high FPS as soon as I fire up RU-vid on my 2nd monitor and I've never had the same issue with NVidia. At work I swapped from a 1070 to a 6600 and ever since my main monitor won't wake up unless I turn it off and back on first, didn't happen with the NVidia GPU.
@leezowghi7974
@leezowghi7974 Год назад
i ran a 7900 xt 4 monitors g9 neo and 3 27-inch msi 1440p. The amd card would jump to 60c while idle but when I switched it back to single monitor it ran at 39c. My 4090 runs at 35c single or the four monitors while idle. As for not waking up from sleep mode I have had triple monitor setups running for 10 years all nvidia never any problems. Power draw on nvidia was always lower as well. So, from my point of view AMD has the problem. I was going to get the 7900xtx for my new build. But when the 7900xt did what it did. I went back to Nvidia for my multi-monitor setup. Refresh rates were 120 on g9 and 165 on msi monitors. as low as 60 on all and.
@johndelabretonne2373
@johndelabretonne2373 Год назад
Steve, I know you said you tried all kinds of different cables, but I remember back in the early days of AMD Eyefinity, at least one of the three monitors had to use an active cable rather than a passive cable.
@328aghdsamcb90asgn
@328aghdsamcb90asgn 9 дней назад
Something that's poorly documented, but I saw mentioned on an Nvidia page somewhere was this idea of monitor heads(?) or something like that. It seems that Nvidia GPUs have 4 monitor heads but they have a max bandwidth limit and when you exceed that limit you then use 2 monitor heads instead of one, even for a single monitor. This is where DSC causes problems, due to generally being used on high resolution, high refresh rate monitors. So when you're using 2 heads on a single monitor a lot of problems can result, and features like VRR may not work as well. In addition, it limits the total number of monitors. I don't know where the cutoff is, but in my testing a 4k 165hz monitor will use 2 heads, thus limiting the total monitor number to 3, you cannot connect a 4th monitor. But a 4k 120hz monitor uses a single head, and thus you can use 4 total monitors. AMD may use a totally different system, or their "heads" might support higher resolutions and refresh rates, or they may have more "heads" total. On AMD I can connect 4 monitors, even when one is 165hz 4k, but it's not possible on Nvidia in my testing.
@Rogerraybemsleyjr
@Rogerraybemsleyjr Год назад
Yeah my 3090 was flickering on my 4k monitor but my 1080p was fine.
@ivayloi736
@ivayloi736 Год назад
Not sure how anyone can claim that, when RX 7900 consumes 100W in idle... I personally use 2 monitor setup in the last 10+ years and had no major problems with either AMD and NVIDIA. Aside from high idle power which I think happens from time to time to both NVIDIA and AMD, now with Intel too...
@MN12BIRD
@MN12BIRD Год назад
I've had issues with both my previous RX 5600 XT and on my current RX 6750 XT running two Gigabyte M27Q 1440p 170hz monitors (both on DP) I was often getting a black screen crash. Sometimes if one screen went black I could get into task manager on the other monitor and kill the AMD drivers and it would recover but sometimes I'd have to reset the PC. I fixed the issue by downloading a registry hack from an NVidia forum of all places that disables any web browser acceleration and it hasn't happened since. I guess my CPU usage is probably a little higher now playing RU-vid videos but seems okay. The black screen crash would often happen when browsing facebook marketplace that was the easiest way to replicate the issue. 5-10 minutes on there and it would very likely happen.
@Fate025
@Fate025 Год назад
I've been using the 7900xtx on dual monitors and I've been experiencing issues with this AMD card too. If I run my bluestacks android game emulator on my 2nd monitor and start another game (Apex Legends or Overwatch 2) on my main monitor. The graphics drivers will crash and restart, crashing my games along with it. However I didn't have this issue with my older Radeon 6800 nor RTX 3080 cards.
@matthias6933
@matthias6933 Год назад
how do you know it’s a crash caused by your graphics driver?
@zwenkwiel816
@zwenkwiel816 Год назад
@@matthias6933 cuz the graphics driver crashes?
@lordofreason549
@lordofreason549 Год назад
I had the exact opposite problem. Amd 7900xt 3rd monitor would not wake up. Sent back and got 4080, never have an issue since. All 3 monitors are same too Also had a 3070 before the 7900xt ans it never has issues. Almost made me never want to try again, but I think im going to get a cpu that has integrated graphics to run monitors 2 and 3 and run main with gpu.
@Pasi123
@Pasi123 Год назад
I run 4x 1080p monitors on a GTX 1080 and it's always pulling more than 40W because it never drops to 2D clocks (currently running at 1190MHz). I had the same thing with my previous GTX 960, and probably with my GTX 660 but that was too long ago to remember.
@florian8194
@florian8194 Год назад
This is working as intended. The higher power draw doesn't really come from a higher gpu clock but a higher memory clock as with multiple monitors the memory clock always runs at its highest frequency. This is because the memory clock can only be changed between frames as you would get artifacts otherwise. The problem is, these timings don't align if you have 2 monitors with different refresh rates so there is no opportunity for memory clocks to adjust to the current workload in that case. Also keep in mind that even 2 monitors with the same refresh rate often don't have the exact same timings so even in this scenario the memory clocks don't adjust like they would when using only one monitor.
@BitZapple
@BitZapple Год назад
thats 5W per Monitor Pretty sure AMD had far worse issues with power draw specifically and very recently as well.
@depth386
@depth386 Год назад
It can also be the monitors. Someone I know and I have just ONE of the exact same ASUS 28” 4K 60Hz monitor and he has an Nvidia GPU i have an AMD GPU and we both have to power cycle the monitor, sometimes multiple times. Bizarrely this does not happen on iGPU with an intel CPU because we tried that.
@96kylar
@96kylar Год назад
Since launch, my 7900xtx pulls 120 watts at the windows log in screen. One monitor or two. No matter no care. No driver update has helped. (Samsung g7 27” and 32” both 1440/240fps). It’s on their “know issues board” but man, I wish it would get resolved. (7900xtx/7950x) Edit- and im not going to turn my 240hz monitor down. Like I said. It does it with one or two connected.
@noahbirdrevolution
@noahbirdrevolution Год назад
I've never had a dual monitor issue with the 1060, 2070 or 4070ti. I've ran different resolutions & refresh rates on them as well.
@cmgm6027
@cmgm6027 Год назад
I had this problem with my old 2060 Super and 3080ti, from time to time one of my 2 the monitors wouldn't wake from sleep, had to restart the pc or unplug the cables to fix it. Also had problems with both cards sometimes turning on the wrong monitor(turning on the secondary instead of the main one and vice versa). I'm now using a 7900 xtx and never happened again.
@joe_ferreira
@joe_ferreira Год назад
I have 3 monitors. 1 4k in portrait, 1 4k in landscape, and 1 ultra wide on a 4080. I have not had these experiences. Maybe it's because I have set prefer max performance in the Nvidia control panel?
@evankirschenmann4653
@evankirschenmann4653 Год назад
I run a 1440p 144hz monitor and a 1080p 144hz monitor and I have never experienced this issue with either my 980ti or 3060ti
@taotie86
@taotie86 Год назад
There's an issue with AMD and multi-monitor too. While playing a ame on main screen and YT video on another screen, the performance in game drops heavily. Quite often the framerate fixes at 30fps until video is paused. Disabling hardware acceleration has no impact.
@Sorrocasharked
@Sorrocasharked Год назад
never had that issue on my 6700 XT
@Pokums
@Pokums Год назад
Can confirm. If there's any motion or screen updates on my 2nd or 3rd monitor, performance on the main drops significantly, to around 30 fps from 300. It is possible due to the fact that my main runs on 144Hz and the rest are 60Hz, not sure. It also causes some glitch-like artifact for a couple of frames on main screen. Happened on both 5500 XT and 6800.
@yukisnoww
@yukisnoww Год назад
@@Sorrocasharked i have a 6700xt to hold me while i get a 4k card, running 2 4K displays, it runs fine, but i do get random hard freezes (every other day: like the display driver just chokes and i got to restart my rig via power button) i dont do work so its whatever, reboot takes 20s max, so its not a bother. It happens mostly when i have an active game client running on my secondary screen while playing content on my main screen.
@WyattOShea
@WyattOShea Год назад
Never had that issue with my 6900xt and I run 3 screens of different resolutions lol.
@BKHD605
@BKHD605 Год назад
This was an issue with windows and was fixed in Windows 10 2004 20H1. I've never had any issues since on both AMD and NVidia. The only problem I had was the grey screen after waking the computer from sleep but disabling MPO fixed that.
@daniellogiudice725
@daniellogiudice725 Год назад
I have 3x 4k 60hz monitor that I am setting up for sim racing. These monitors only run 4k 60hz on the Display Port. I'm looking at an 7900xtx (as they have dropped in price in my region and NVIDIA have lost the plot). The two cards I am looking at are the Sapphire Nitro+ and ASROCK gaming OC. The Sapphire cards have 2 x DP and 2 x HDMI 2.1 ports vs the ASROCK with 3x DP and 1 x HDMI 2.1 ports. I prefer the Sapphire card as I read too many user complaints about the ASROCK but I will have to run 1 monitor using a HDMI to DP cable/adaptor (Trying to find a cable that can do 4K 60hz at a decent price). Do you think I'd be better off with a card with 3xDP ports or with the right cable/adaptor it should be trouble free? Thanks.
@alainveenman6571
@alainveenman6571 4 месяца назад
Would go for 3 dp ports I do simracing as well on triples 32inch msi curved 1440p 165hz on a 4060 ti not the best card bud it works
@truth2life_
@truth2life_ Год назад
ive never had that problem with my GTX 1080 cards. im running 2 120hz lg 32 inch monitors and 2 Samsung G9 49 inch ultra wides at 240 htz. for a total of 4 monitors in one system. I could show you how well they run. so im not sure whats going on, but it sounds like a configuration issue and the cards themselves.
@Coffeeenjoyer31
@Coffeeenjoyer31 Год назад
Not sure why, I had issues running 2 displays on my 6000 series gpu. When I upgraded cpu made sure to get iGPU and just run 2nd display off that.
@mckrackin5324
@mckrackin5324 Год назад
My 3080 flickers on and off and has weird color issues for almost a minute when I turn on a second or third monitor. It also doesn't wake them up. I have to turn them on manually. My AMD mini PC with a 5500u APU runs the same displays with absolutely no issues. Just another reason this is my last Nvidia GPU.
@devinisentol6224
@devinisentol6224 Год назад
I've got a 3080 12gb with 4 monitors, 1 for desktop gaming and 3 for sim racing, I guess I'm lucky I've had no problems
@Fearless13468
@Fearless13468 Год назад
I've got a 4 display setup with an RTX 3070. 900p 60hz 1080p 60hz 1440p 240hz 4k 60hz (TV) I do have problems every now with detection issues, but most of my problems seem to stem from windows itself. My displays will randomly and unprompted, try to reformat themselves. It causes unwanted flickering, and lag whenever it happens. I think it's the TVs fault. I turn it off when I'm not using it, and that is when the issue is the worst.
@slizzle.280
@slizzle.280 Год назад
Hear me out: AMD doesn’t have issues with multimonitor setups because it uses 120W on idle. :) -A 7900XTX owner
@fatidicusaeternus6498
@fatidicusaeternus6498 Год назад
Maybe you should update your drivers, mine idles at ~15w
@goldenheartOh
@goldenheartOh 3 месяца назад
My 3090 rarely wants to wake up with just ONE monitor! Once in a while, not even a reboot will get it to display! Been that way over many driver updates.
@hoffyc.h393
@hoffyc.h393 Год назад
Disable MPO, fixes 90% of the time the multimonitor problem, fixed my AMD 6700XT Red Devil tho :)
@Seacle14
@Seacle14 Год назад
Strangely I have had the opposite situation. My LG OLED would not wake up correctly with an AMD video card
@Todor7771
@Todor7771 Год назад
Triple monitor setup, msi rx 6950 xt for 4 months, previously msi rx 6600 xt for 9 months, never once did i have a problem with monitors
@MenWereOnceBoys
@MenWereOnceBoys Год назад
My experience is the opposite and I've built like 5+ systems over the 30 series lifespan. AMD is the with the issues with different resolutions and frame rates with multiple monitors while with Nvidia i didnt have any. 6800xt, 6700, 6700xt, 6600xt, 3060, 3080 and 3090
@connectingupthedots
@connectingupthedots Год назад
Same. 6900xt was far worse with multiple monitors than any of the Nvidia cards I've tried. I tried two different models of that card because I wanted it but it couldn't do two monitors while on a zoom call without infinite driver crashing.
@codelinx
@codelinx Год назад
Love the content. Have always had AMD GPUs and a predominately Intel CPUs, but just went straight AMD this build. I have no regrets as the new drivers fixed my issues with game crashes.
@erickelly4107
@erickelly4107 Год назад
I have a dual monitor set-up (1 - 27” 2K 240HZ 1- 27” 2K 165HZ) both are ViewSonic; my primary 2K / 240HZ is set to run max 240HZ as I use it for gaming but I run my 2nd monitor at 60HZ because I don’t use it for gaming, don’t see the point in using more power to run my 2nd display at over 60HZ. My RTX 4090 hasn’t had any issues here nor my GTX 1080Ti prior.
@jasonnicholas3722
@jasonnicholas3722 Месяц назад
I actually have the same problem with my 2nd monitor on a sapphire RX 5700 XT nitro+ when I turn it on. I'm using 2 1440 curved monitors currently but I have another 1440 curved monitor and 12.3" stretch bar display to add using the 2 display ports, and I am undecided on whether to fit the 7" display either in the motherboards hdmi port or usb. As far as I know there is current issue opening with amd' adrenaline software not opening and has been doing this since their last update. I believe it is problem plaguing many people across a wide range of amd gpu's. I'm hoping it won't affect what I'm about to add, but I'm contemplating an upgrade from the ryzen 5 3600x to the 7 7800x3d and possibly the powercolour 7900 xt hellhound. My budget cannot quite stretch to the sapphire rx 9700 xtx nitro+.
@gucky4717
@gucky4717 Год назад
I do have one small Issue with my Nvidia card. I use a Monitor and a TV. It runs fine, but when I turn off the TV the PC still recognizes the TV as ON. Might be a TV Problem and not a Nvidia Problem. In that case I use the shortcut Win+P to switch to a single Monitor.
@unclekraken21
@unclekraken21 Год назад
Its not non of them as a long a ur tv is connected on your Graphics card it will always identify your tv as the second monitor .So by turning off your tv that doesn't mean that you gonna switch back to single monitor. It practically still plugged in is just your tv display is off and u cannot see it
@georgwarhead2801
@georgwarhead2801 Год назад
thats not realy a problem. TV´s are build in a way, so that they can controle or beeing controled over HDMI/DP, but a GPU ( doesnt matter wich brand) doesnt support this features. for a TV it is normal to still send a signal over HDMI to show a conected device its presents , so when you turn on sayed device, it can turn on your TV and ajust the signal input and maybe the sound output too ( depending on wich devices are conected) and accept the remote inputs of a other device. gpu´s just see a conected HDMI device and pretend, that it is a display and try to use it as such.
@dralord1307
@dralord1307 Год назад
I had a 1070 until a few months ago, switched to a 6700xt. I have been running dual monitors since 2010. My 1070 never had the monitor wake issue or any of the other common problems. I did suffer heavily from microstutter when playing games if I had ANYTHING that had animations on the second monitor. This was with every driver. My 6700xt "and at work I have a rx560 in my work computer" I rarely "1-2x a month" get just static on a monitor. This happens with both 1 monitor and dual monitor setups. But only happens on Non DP monitors. The 6700xt does get some microstutter on main monitor but its much less than my 1070 had.
@ovedach
@ovedach Год назад
i had issues with AMD 6900xt with DP connected zowei monitor along with the valve VR headset - also on DP ... had all sorts of issues with blank screen and no signal on boot and VR not working etc. its drivers related all of it for sure. Also had degraded FPS issue with the VR connected... i simply ended up just disconnecting the VR when i dont use it...
@RaufZero
@RaufZero Год назад
From simracing perspective where triple or more are in use, theres not much competent information in this vid. Problem with turning on monitors may be related to firmware of the panels and this is the most common reason, also the quality of cables, especially those longer than 3m, is decisive as Dispaly Port standard has its limitations. Moreover described problems of "my buddy" is rather a small research attempt, isn't it? Basic setting of the monitor at 60Hz is obviously justified as being safer for troubleshooting potential problems, it is better to have a stable 60Hz and switch to higher Hz than to risk having no picture at all with higher frequency. In multimonitor setup software support is key factor, is Eyefinity better than Surround, how do you connect monitors with different frequencies, different sizes in a horizontal or mixed layout like PLP, can you quickly switch merged modes into a single monitor whether you can manage the taskbar and desktop icons. You don't mention anything about it, because I assume you've never used such a solution, and yet you release AMD to NVIDIA comparision even in title, suggesting your preferences.
@diegoaccord
@diegoaccord Год назад
Running 4090 with (1)Acer 4K60 and (2)Asus 4K144. Sometimes monitor 2 (Asus) doesn't wake. Not an issue all the time, but enough to irritate at times. The big issue when this happens is that my settings/control panel is on the sleeping monitor, that can be a pita.
@kerotomas1
@kerotomas1 Год назад
Yup same, happens with my 3070Ti and 3080 too. I always lmao when people cry about AMD drivers and things like this happen on Nvidia for years now. If only AMD had better RT support i would jump ship in a heartbeat I wouldn't even care about DLSS anymore as almost all new games come with both DLSS and FSR.
@rossmclaughlin7158
@rossmclaughlin7158 Год назад
Both have there share of driver issues it's good to hear someone actually saying this stuff rather than just saying amd driver bad lol I've ran multiple PCs in my house for many years now using both amd and Nvidia from as far back as 770 from Nvidia and hd 7970 from amd right up to modern cards and issues have always been pretty evenly split. On windows On Linux it's totally different story Nvidia always been absolute nightmare
@cash_banooca17
@cash_banooca17 Год назад
Tbh I haven't experienced any brand specific multi monitor issues. Every GPU I've owned and my brother has owned on his PC experienced multi monitor issues so I think it's at least in part a windows issue
@luxemier
@luxemier Год назад
It is a windows issue for sure. When i was running ubuntu on wayland everything rand perfect with some unrelated issues and bugs. Multi monitor on windows can be a nightmare sometimes
@aboveaveragebayleaf9216
@aboveaveragebayleaf9216 Год назад
After switching to amd I was pleasantly surprised when it defaulted to 144hz with freesync active. I had to set all of that up on nvidia. I did not know I was running 60hz for the first little bit when I got my first high refresh rate monitor a few years ago.
@RobBCactive
@RobBCactive Год назад
To think I stopped multi-monitor because on AMD with multi and current drivers the VRAM frequency cannot drop to save power, so it uses more power for something that was a bit naff with W10 anyway and caused confusion for Steam so games would grab the wrong display. A reason to try W11 is it is supposed to save the multi-monitor window layouts you setup.
@nyctasiaselesq
@nyctasiaselesq Год назад
So that is my problem with my 1 monitor not waking up until I pull the HDMI cable out and out it back in? But I am on a 1080...
@ryanliew3372
@ryanliew3372 4 месяца назад
I run 6 x 2k monitors with 2 Nvidia Quadro T600. First T600 died in less than 18 months and the 2nd T600 died 2 months later. Crazy failure rate for a Quadro card. Previously i run 4 full HD monitors with AMD Firepro card. No issue!
@magfal
@magfal Год назад
I'm looking forward to getting a few DP MST hubs to arrive so that I can get my 8 30 inch 2K monitor wall to be a lot less janky. I acquired a cheap top spec rx580 8GB card and there are conflicting information regarding whether they support 6 monitors or not.
@julianB93
@julianB93 Год назад
I have a lot of problems with my multi monitor setup. waking them up isnt a part of it gladly. One is an msi wqhd 165hz and the second is an LG 4k 60fps. When hovering above the task bar (dark mode) the bar creates artifacts in form of clouding and if im using the search bar on the second monitor instead of the main one the whole setup starts flickering and showing content from minimised windows.
@kaisersolo76
@kaisersolo76 Год назад
Not Really although the following issues happens with both AMD and Nvidia. High memory usage at idle with multi high refresh monitors has been an problem for ages . Its not cool having your vram fully loaded when your not doing anything. Workarounds include reducing 165hz to 120haz and 144 to 60hz then it drops to 7w from 40w originally on 32" 1440p 165hz & 1080p 144hz monitor.
@mrchillgreen
@mrchillgreen Год назад
@HUB Clips maybe its not only the gpu to blame and also motherboard vendors. i rellay never had any of the problems youre talking about but iam also not running 4k displays i had 970 with triple screens and currently run a 2080 with triple screen and the only single problem i ever had was that at some point one of the secondary screens i was unalbe to change bit-depth and dynamic output in nvidia color settings. but yeah i noticed that clocks in general seem to increase compared to 1 screen and my gpus for some reason do not downclock as much as i was used to on a single screen.
@taranagnew436
@taranagnew436 Год назад
does the problem happen on laptops with a 29" momitors?
@myyoutubecommentschannel8784
Never had an issue with my 1080ti. Is this only for 30+ series?
@markus1351
@markus1351 Год назад
Running a 7900XT and I have massive issues on a double monitor setup with 4k each,... especially with video playback on 1 screen it get#s very very jittery
@markus1351
@markus1351 Год назад
@Sam Ross it's listed as a know bug on the current AMD drivers,... and I had no problems with my 3070 before,...
@WiFeYBurGLeR1
@WiFeYBurGLeR1 Год назад
My 6900xt couldn’t handle multi monitors with different refresh rates for some reason. It would not allow my OLED tv to be my third monitor. I swapped in my 4090 with the same monitor setup and i have no issues. The 4090 had issues with waking up monitors though, had to flash the bios on the card.
@wuuduu609
@wuuduu609 Год назад
5700xt - main LCD is 16:9 at 120Hz HDR Dell and secondary one is 60Hz 16:10 Dell... different resolutions, without a single problem, at GOOD CABLES. At standard cables, got sometimes a black screen
@WiFeYBurGLeR1
@WiFeYBurGLeR1 Год назад
Same here have good cables as well, from Micro Center rated for 8k 60hz. With the 6900xt the 2 monitors ran fine (Samsung 4k 240hz and LG 4k 144hz) Once I hooked up the LG OLED Tv 4k 60hz it was just a black screen. It identified it just no picture. Swapped cables, no luck. Did some digging seemed to be a known issue. Anyway, sold that card and scooped a 4090 at launch runs everything no issues.
@joseguevara184
@joseguevara184 3 месяца назад
I looked for a video like this but to me is the contrary. I have a PC with amd 580 8gb and 3 monitors 24 in, and another PC with 1060 6gb with 2 24 in. monitors and one 21.5. Everytime I change from some screen to another in AMD I get a flicker and screen reconstruction which does not happens with Nvidia. Latest drivers, Win 11, 32 RAM and Nvidia works better. Strange.
@GTR72
@GTR72 Год назад
I have 4k 144hz as main, 2k 144hz as second and 4k 60hz tv as my 3rd. Had both the 3070ti and 3080 act weird whenever I have 3 monitors plugged in. Random flickering, monitors turning on and off, and mose importantly, made my mouse stutter like crazy to the point that it was unusable. Unplugging the 4k 60hz tv was the only solution. Disabling the monitors in windows didn't do anything.
@manoftherainshorts9075
@manoftherainshorts9075 Год назад
I have a minor issue with my 6800XT. It doesn't recognize both of my monitors right away. I had to swap connectors around 1 or 2 times, after that it's flawless. With my previous GPU, 1070ti, one of my monitors did flicker after waking up.
@Drewkungfoo
@Drewkungfoo Год назад
I haven’t had any issues with my 3080Ti’s in my Multi-Monitor Setup
@jGRite
@jGRite Год назад
Vega was the only exception. If I had multiple monitors connected things like "grub" (bootloader) won't show up.
@Gustavo_Robles
@Gustavo_Robles Год назад
I have a single 1440p ultrawide monitor paired with a GTX 1060 6GB (soon to be upgraded) and every 100 or so wake ups I have to unplug and plug again my display port cable in order to get video. It’s rare, but it happens.
@arpanConYT
@arpanConYT Год назад
don't you need Nvidia's Cuda and mercury engine for Adobe apps? even Illustrator 3D needs RTX for lighting..... im confused... should I not get 3070 and instead go for 6800XT?
@anthonyrizzo9043
@anthonyrizzo9043 Год назад
So I got this Alienware dwf monitor and it's the best monitor I ever had, but the issue is that HDR doesn't work right on amd cards for some reason, so unless that gets fixed I can't even switch. Also odd that the DW with the gsync module, does HDR fine on amd cards but the freesync premium dwf does not. It's all sorts of messed up. Would like the option to switch to amd.
@ZenataUSA
@ZenataUSA Год назад
My GTX 970 has been having a similar issue where my primary monitor connected via displayport just doesn't wake up, while the two over HDMI do. They each have different resolutions and refresh rates though. I wonder how AMD/Intel would fair with that setup.
@shadybeatsCarbon
@shadybeatsCarbon Год назад
Watching this on a triple Gigabyte M32U 144Hz IPS 4k setup connected to a RX 7900XTX, OS is Linux Fedora 38 beta release, can confirm it just works.
@westonallen116
@westonallen116 Год назад
My rx 7900 XT has a weird issue where the screen lags after the pc sleeps. But this only happens if the pc sleeps on it’s own. If I make it sleep and wake it there is no issue
@mee_ehow5106
@mee_ehow5106 8 месяцев назад
My experience with 4090: 360Hz 1440p + M32U (4k 144) + M27U (4k 144h) + 1440p165hz is absolute garbage. My side monitors more often do not work at all rather that work, even though it is supported frequency/spec. Nvidia/whole DSC bs is straight up garbage
@CharlesTembo
@CharlesTembo 8 месяцев назад
is this a quad setup or dual monitor setup and you've just put the different refresh rates for the dual monitors at lower res?
@mee_ehow5106
@mee_ehow5106 7 месяцев назад
@@CharlesTembo quad monitor setup, these monitors have different supported refresh rates, 1440p 165 I've connected to iGPU (Ryzen 7950X3D), the other 3 are connected to 4090 and these are really really flaky, not reliable at all.
@CharlesTembo
@CharlesTembo 7 месяцев назад
thank you for the feedback, much appreciated@@mee_ehow5106
@Zysperro
@Zysperro Год назад
RX 6600 user here - I also have wake up issues - my main 165hz monitor won't turn on.
@smudge2021
@smudge2021 Год назад
Tbh I've never had issues with mine running a 2080 and igpu for 5 monitors, the only problem I encountered was when I changed refresh rates on my main monitor in the nvidia control panel it disabled my two screens connected via cpu which was a little strange but i just had to go into intel graphics command centre and enable them again.
@HCMORGI
@HCMORGI Год назад
why In hell would you run 5 Monitors? D: is there any production benefit beyond 2 or 3?
@ElSkeppo
@ElSkeppo Год назад
@@HCMORGI stock traders tend to have anywhere between 4-8 monitors
@HCMORGI
@HCMORGI Год назад
@@ElSkeppo that doesnt Sound like a fun job :(
@smudge2021
@smudge2021 Год назад
@@HCMORGI Im not a stock trader but I have 3 monitors used as 1 display for racing simulator, Main monitor and secondary monitor for playing games whilst watching streams or youtube and a tv by the sofa for movies or playing games with friends!
@AndrewB23
@AndrewB23 Год назад
No issues running a 1080p 180hz monitor and 55 4k120 OLED tv together on my Nvidia gpu
@paidquartz
@paidquartz Год назад
I gave AMD a chance and bought an ASRock 7900 XTX Taichi only to realize that it has problem booting up my system when three monitors are connected. I returned that card in exchange for an RTX 4090 with a top-up.
@TheBoyCalzone
@TheBoyCalzone Год назад
I did this but AMD drivers are just so awful that I experience more problems than I would experience these issues they talk about for the GeForce gpu’s. I wish AMD would fix all their card and driver problems because they really do make good cards just looking at the prices and stats 😢
@TheHighborn
@TheHighborn Год назад
i have 2 1080p screens, been using a vega for 6months after release. Never had this issue. It's really sad that it's hit or miss for both vendors.
@WyattOShea
@WyattOShea Год назад
@@TheHighborn Yeah weird thing for me is I've never had issues with using 2 or more screens with my gpus (both nvidia and amd but currently with amd on a 6900xt). I use 3 screens all of which are different resolutions lol.
@aeleraju2205
@aeleraju2205 4 месяца назад
Gigabyte H610M S2H ddr4 Mother Board mein Frontech Gt 610 2gb ddr3 Graphic Card insert kare tho 7 Monitors at a time Display Or Not... For Trading purpose Budget PC
@connectingupthedots
@connectingupthedots Год назад
This is a trash take. I usually like HUB but this is a generalization that is backwards in my experience. I had multiple different 6900XTs that would have infinite driver crashes on multiple monitors but 1080ti, 3070, 3080 and 3090s all worked on the same set-up without issue.
@AdamLarson23
@AdamLarson23 Год назад
Woah I thought it was my monitor. I found changing cables or switching from using HDMI to DisplayPort sometimes helped. I have a 4 monitor setup with a 3070. 1 4K with 3 1080p
@bobbybafett9132
@bobbybafett9132 Год назад
That 3070 really is screaming for help 😂
@train3616
@train3616 Год назад
Another great Q&A.
@GLOCKRIVERSTV
@GLOCKRIVERSTV Год назад
I had the complete opposite experience. I’ve had more problems with my AMD setup than I did with my Nvidia setup. I do want to stress how important proper cabling is. It’s so easy to get fake or scrap cables that are not truly HDMI or display port level. Cables have almost 0 regulation, and can cause all kinds of problems.
@seirodor
@seirodor Год назад
I have two 1080p monitors, one 144hz and one 75hz... if I set it to 144hz, the gpu is sitting at stable 1560mhz on core sitting at 60°C and using good chunk of vram. If I lower the refreshrate to 120hz, it drops to 130mhz and no usage on vram whatsoever nice and cool 42°C. I tried possibly everything and just resorted to capping it to 120hz and when I boot up game I let the game use the 144hz framerate. GPU is 1080Ti and I've seen good chunk of people complaining about this and Nvidia is just playing ""LA LA LA I don't hear you game"".
@Umbra_TuSlayer
@Umbra_TuSlayer Год назад
I've had the Nvidia multi monitor issue and I found it so bad, the default windows VGA driver worked better...
@crossvadar249
@crossvadar249 Год назад
Might be a more happened over the Nvida but personal experience it never happen at all. Running Triple since 2022 Summer
@mosamaster
@mosamaster Год назад
Monitor frequency issue has been a problem when I used multiple display settings on nvidia.
@JMatrx
@JMatrx Год назад
The problem with Radeon cards is that often ram goes to 3D clocks as soon as you use more than 1 monitor. Throw in any secondary and if it's not the same frequency/resolution, 3D vram clocks go there fixed all the time. Especially if you throw into the mix the HDMI connector. It has been like so since Radeon HD 5000, i don't know what is needed to AMD to be like Nvidia that generally won't move from idle clocks on both vram and GPU core, unless you hook 3 or 4 entirely different resolution/refresh or again, you add an HDMI monitor.
@JJFX-
@JJFX- Год назад
IME even many 2 monitor configs can settle at a low P state but still above the lowest. There are a lot of potential factors and but Nvidia have had problems in the past. Pascal had big issues with DP 1.3/1.4 which was still finnicky even after a firmware patch.
@JMatrx
@JMatrx Год назад
@@JJFX- Had some DP fw bios for a Gigabyte 1080 G1 Gaming but that was for DP wake up and to fix the fact that it defaulted to another monitor for bios boot. Other than that multi monitor is fine on Nvidia Gpus since at least 500 series, haven't tried with previous ones or it's too long ago. :)
@JJFX-
@JJFX- Год назад
@@JMatrx Yeah the issue affected most Maxwell/Pascal based cards and I believe some older SKUs that were probably Maxwell rebrands. I've still seen intermittent issues with some Pascal monitor setups but overall it doesn't seem to be a big problem. I have a 1200p:60hz/1440p:265hz GTX1080 work system with occasional flicker at idle on the 1440 and it definitely doesn't idle in the lowest P-State but for the most part it works perfectly fine.
@H20-Water-Pro-LLC
@H20-Water-Pro-LLC Год назад
I wonder if the same issue spreads over to g-sync ready monitors as well. Or does nvidia have a reason to not address this known issue because they want you to buy their approved branded monitors.
@sickheadracing
@sickheadracing Год назад
Personally I have never used any kind of sleep status for my monitors and being a sim racer, NVIDIA has been the way to go for triple screen racing with iRacing. NVIDIA SMP is a great feature with more performance and AMD simply can't match it there.
@user-cz9pr1uj1g
@user-cz9pr1uj1g Год назад
This happend to me with one monitor. One! It was with dell laptop. Laptop monitor always used integrated intel GPU, but when I plugged one of the monitors using HDMI, it just doesn't start. Had to use type-c to DP adapter to enable use of this monitor with this laptop. HDMI in this monitor directly connected to Nvidia GPU
@jacobakers8041
@jacobakers8041 Год назад
I'm running (3) 1440p monitors - LG 27GP83B's on a 6700 XT. I really need to upgrade to a new GPU b/c I initially was only running one panel on that GPU. Now with all the extra pixels, it's time for a bigger GPU. For the past month I have been going back and forth on a 7900 XTX vs a 4090. I'd rather not buy a 4090, and I really like the AMD software, but is there a reason to go with the 4090 over the XTX? I am only gaming. DLSS3 is an irrelevant point with FSR3 around the corner, and I'm not doing any productivity work. I have a 1000 watt PSU with the 12V high power plug that I bought in anticipation of possibly an NVIDIA GPU. Do I go for the 4090, or will the XTX carry me for the next 5 or so years? I'm only considering the Nitro XTX or the MSI Gaming Trio X 4090.
@thelonelytimbit
@thelonelytimbit Год назад
I have an XT and am very happy with it, and you can see a pretty solid improvement with an undervolt, and overclock. My card will easily drop from 1100mv to 1020 while pushing target clocks from 2750mhz to 3500mhz seeing actual clock speeds hitting highs of around 3200mhz on and optimized games, and that's all on a reference card with a gimped power limit.
@jodiepalmer2404
@jodiepalmer2404 Год назад
Can some give me an answer to my question about the fact in my screen resolution that it has 3840 x 2160 shown but it has 1920 x 1080 (recommended) but my 32" Sanyo LCD TV 60hz (13 years old) is only FULL HD 1080p. Does that mean I can run 3840 x 2160 on my TV because people was saying to increase my resolution to 2k to fully utilise my 1080ti?
@jodiepalmer2404
@jodiepalmer2404 Год назад
No need to answer Someone on Reddit said no and that I'm better off buying a monitor (IPS or OLED) or 4K OLED TV 120mhz +
@mmmark8737
@mmmark8737 8 месяцев назад
I have been running 8 monitors with 2 750ti cards for many years. Very few issues.
@dededede9257
@dededede9257 Год назад
Multi monitor king but 100w in idle with it
@atnfn
@atnfn Год назад
I don't know if this is the same thing, but occasionally this seems to happen with my laptop. But I suppose a laptop connected to an external monitor sort of is multi monitor. I know that sometimes I have to unplug and reconnect it to wake up the monitor.
@RobBCactive
@RobBCactive Год назад
When I tested a game crash with a driver that would happen, the monitor had no physical on/off so I used a power strip to cut electricity. AMD driver talks direct to the hardware, making it harder to recover from some issues down to cabling or software faults. When it's working I like knowing it's not fallen back to some degraded mode or is stealth restarting a virtual display, but you need a proper power switch for convenience, for when you do hit trouble.
@maozedowner5915
@maozedowner5915 Год назад
I had issues with multi monitor on both RX580 and RX6600 On RX580 it'll keep the memory clock at full steam all the time if I plug more than 1 monitor into it, making idle power draw 4 times higher than normal. On RX6600 when I game the second monitor will flicker like crazy if I alt tab out of game. That was fixed on later drivers tho. Definitely not issue free for AMD.
@djchotus1
@djchotus1 Год назад
Triple 144hz 1440p with 2 different 3070s. Then a 3070ti. A FE 3080 Then 4070ti Actually never had a problem. At all like this. Seems like either I'm. Lucky. Or others aren't? Or cable choice? Triple FULL DP here
@gamingclan4651
@gamingclan4651 Год назад
Ok for me going from 60 to 165 it was incredibly noticeable in the desktop and Minecraft noticeable in seige and then certain other games not at all though they all were running at 165 FPS but they were all slow motion games or very little motion such as astroneer
@m4yd1e86
@m4yd1e86 Год назад
My wifes 3080ti can't wake up 3 monitors to save its life. It's an absolute mess pretty much all of the time. Absolutely no issues with my 3 monitors on my 6950xt.
@marcelosoares7148
@marcelosoares7148 Год назад
Reading the comments, this seems to be all over the place, both with Nvidia and AMD tbh
@JonathanS89
@JonathanS89 Год назад
If possible can you guys keep HUB Clips vids to under 5 minutes or less, I mean do whatever you want with your channel I'll probably watch anyway but I would love this to be a short (not shorts) videos channel
@mightyakkylex
@mightyakkylex 8 месяцев назад
I have 1 32" ultrawide 3440x1440 monitor and a 27" 2560x1440p wide monitor and if I had a game running on the ultrawide (even a low requirement game like Rocket League) my 3060 would struggle to also display a 2k yt video on the 27" without stutters. Hope I won't have this issue on a new RX 7800 XT
@BGKTeam-gf1wg
@BGKTeam-gf1wg Год назад
I have a 6700XT, the only problem I have is when I play games and the game is in a different resolution than my 2nd monitor and when I alt+tab it glitches a little bit.
@mareck6946
@mareck6946 Год назад
use borderless windows mode
@dewimccar9780
@dewimccar9780 Год назад
5 screens plus a VR headset, 2 GPUs, all that running in 1 PC, and never has an issue with Nvidia, running the setup for years. Go figure!!
Далее
Will Radeon ever actually compete with NVIDIA?
10:15
Просмотров 10 тыс.
NEVER install these programs on your PC... EVER!!!
19:26
БЕЛКА РОЖАЕТ?#cat
00:28
Просмотров 314 тыс.
What do gamers actually think about Ray-Tracing?
15:18
Don’t buy a QD-OLED if…
13:33
Просмотров 167 тыс.
AMD Anti-Lag+ | We Need To Talk
14:41
Просмотров 145 тыс.
Nvidia G-Sync vs AMD FreeSync vs Adaptive Sync in 2024
16:42
Is it Time to Make the Switch? OLED vs IPS & VA
14:54
Просмотров 879 тыс.
Who was right about Zen 5? LTT vs HUB
11:06
Просмотров 35 тыс.