The resale amount is always a positive for self-owned! For the Lease car- you calculated tax rebate on fuel, and maintenance, and interest on downpayment value. For Loan Car- Calculate the resale amount also, this will give what you have after 3-4 years in your hand.
I have covered it in video and resale value has been accounted for. Please check line number 17 on excel saying Residual Value. 06:46 Residual Value Calculation
You haven’t factored the coat required to own the vehicle after lease . You should include that too for a fair math. As it is earning after selling the owner car to buy a new one
I work with Big4. The car lease pm quote without GST is much higher than loan EMI. Now leasing draws 28% GST charges on rental amount hence 30% tax benefit is almost evened out.
Well, not really. Working with Big4 doesnt make any differenxe to what is on offer. There are a number of parameters which effect your Lease Rent and the numbers I have shown in the excel are the real number including GST that I got and am personally using.
Very informative video. However I had a few queries : 1) After the lease period is the car transferred to the user as a second owner registration. If not then say for a 3 year tenure what would be the additional 'buy' cost of a small car for the user to become the owner after the lease period is complete. 2) Would it be fair to say that if a person is planning to buy a car to user for 8-10 years, then loaning for 3 years with 20% downpayment would be a better option than leasing for 3 and then buying from the lease co. Can you share any such standard calculations to help understand the costs better. TIA.
2 things make leasing even better. 1) Interest rates - You cannot get for 7.5% these days so it would be costlier to own 2) Oppurtunity cost of downpayment. If we invest that 1.3 lakhs in fd we get 30k as returns in leasing case.
For someone who is looking to own the vehicle eventually, is leasing beneficial? I don't see the residual value to be paid to leasing company to own the car at the end of lease added to the excel. Can you clarify that please?
I have a question here. I understand leasing a better option than loan. what about downpayment vs leasing. The investment oppurtunity will be in both cases. Like for a 20 lakh car, in downpayment you wont be paying anything else and you will have 50k (assuming monthly lease) to invest monthly. However in case of leasing you will be paying around 50k per month and invest the 20 lakhs
Why was this comparison even done? When you opt to buy a car on lease, you'll first pay the amount for the allocated years and then after the timeline passes, what? Are you *again* going to spend much amount for a new/lease car? Though leasing a car will cost you 10-20% less than buying it on loan, but isn't it a foolish decision to buy your liability again and spend 80% of the amount again (as you've already paid for the leased amount). Take a think!
Excellent video. Although I'm not eligible for a lease where I'm working but I have always been looking for this information. Excel sheet se bahut acha samajh aaya. Very well explained I must say.
Very informative video. In the spreadsheet, on the "New Lease" tab, the cell C12 formula needs to be revised. You considered 60 months instead of 48 months for the calculation. Revising it makes Leasing a more lucrative option! 😀
@@EveryPaisaMatters It does make it better but I really doubt that the rental would be so low for such an expensive car. Can you please share the company from which you got the quote? I am checking different companies and the quotes are much higher than what you have mentioned. Also, can you take Input Tax Credit on the rental? If yes, on both GST and Cess component?
Can you please tell me how much in hand salary I will get in the below condition: Example of my current monthly Salary: Take whom per month: 130000 Tax deduction per month: 33000 After a car lease of monthly rental 25k, how much do I get the salary per month?
Very informative video sir. Just wanted to know which part/amount in the video u mentioned or excel would be final amount to be paid to company , at end of lease period, in case i want to keep the car myself.
Namashkar Ji, mai finance wala bannda nahi hu, buss gadi chalake jeeta hu. Mujhe sab samajh aaya par main points nahi samajh aaye...jaise Cost of Ownership(E) se Income Tax Rebate(F) minus kiya..mujhe kaise pata chalega ki kittna percentage mujhe rebate hoga? Aur Fuel pe tax rebate..yeh kaunsa company deta hai..kya hai, nahi samajh saka. Yeh do main points the jo samajh nahi aaye...Agar aap inn points ko elaborate kar sake mere jaise audience ke liye toh kareyega. Dhanyawad iss zarrori topic ko discuss karne ke liye 🙂.
sir, your calculation is wrong............ager hum 3 ya 4 saal ki jagah ..........8 saal se compare karo ....then.....resut kya hoga ............self-owned car win hogi
Can you explain which IT Act provision provides a rebate on lease cost? Does the tax rebate apply to both salaried individuals and businesses? Please explain the rebate on fuel costs as well
If you are in 30% tax bracket and you are paying a X amount as monthly income tax than leasing can reduce it considerably. Meaning your effective monthly salary will deprecate by 30% of X.
Wonderful and very Informative video. Especially the excel spreadsheet was very effective. My company does not offer lease. it would be very helpful for reviews on the leasing companies too - tips and tricks-please one video on that
Thanks for your feedback. There are only a handful of leasing companies and since every corporate typically has different tie-ups, so doing one video to cover all the aspects is quite challenging. However, will certainly try to cover points which may be useful for junta.
Can you explain the calculation used for After Income Tax Rebate (F)? I see that you use "Cost of Ownership (E =C-D)" - ( tax bracket /100 & Cost of Ownership (E =C-D)) .... after which there is 0.04 * ( tax bracket /100 & Cost of Ownership (E =C-D)) + some value * tenure
Not useful. If you purchase a car for 6-8 lakh then after using it for 4 year you can sell it.. India has a huge used car market. 40-50% resell ker ke mil jayega.. What you get after 4 year in subscription model??
Hello , i must say my search for info regd car lease ends with your video. Really appreciate !! Also, i am planning to go for corporate lease offered by my employer, can i send quotation to you for extra pair of eyes….i dont trust these car sales guy🤓
My company doesn't offer lease option. I am thinking to get a car on lease from leasing companies directly. Ignore the investing the downpayment option, would leasing be still a better option?
Hi, the video is nice however my company does not offer car lease program yet. Can you tell me which company your employer has tied up with for car leasing? Or are you leasing the car yourself because quotation I've received on internet is pretty higher than the emi amount. Again thank you for your content
Great content and very well explained. Thank you. Have downloaded the spreadsheet so that I can formulate the details based on lease offered by the company I work for. One question - the EMI mentioned for lease seems to be calculated at the same ROI of car loan. Is this right? The reason I ask is, normally the company adds EMI+GST , fleet maintenance charges+GST in addition to the EMI so all together it will cost around 52k for a 3 year plan for a vehicle with on road price 22.5 lakhs.
The monthly EMI for Lease I have mentioned includes the Fleet Maintenance and GST. 🙂 These are not made up numbers but something I am actually personally using - both of these options. My most of the content is based on personal experiences and not just sharing a Funda for the sake of it.
You didn't consider the things that the the lease company doesn't pay for. 1.If you are driving interstate you have to pay more as it will be black plate no. 2. The wear and tear parts like tires, clutch plates, wipers, etc won't be paid by lease companies.
1. No you dont have to pay for interstate taxes. This is normal number plate. 2. They pay for all of the parts in service if you have taken that as part of lease. This video is not based on any ideal representation. I have been using exactly this lease for more than 10 years and it is about sharing of experience.
Hi there, Very informative video. I am working for a corporate company where leasing is offered to me. I am planning to buy the car after the lease period is over. My company is offering me the following two options - 1. Operating Lease and 2. Finance Lease. Which one is better and which leasing option would you suggest for me? Thanks in advance!
Can you please provide car and model name you are getting for 35K pm, just checked the leasing options available none of them are below 42k for 22Lac car also if you opted for buyback then monthly amount will be increase by almost 28-30% around 54K. So if we calculate the owing of car after leasing period then its costlier than taking loan, the calculation you made does not stand out even after taking the Tax benefit in 30% slab.
Nice Info sir . Please try to take interview of person who has actually done this for 4-5 years. Then only we can really understand whether leasing is really useful
Hi Amit, thank you creating this video. Very helpful and something that I was looking for. I have some very specific information that i would like. Is there a way to connect with you personally?
This is primarily offered by leasing conpanies such as Avis and ALD via their respective Corporate companies. Of late some manufaturers have also started this directly but some of the benefits may differ in that case. www.marutisuzuki.com/subscribe?gclid=Cj0KCQjw_4-SBhCgARIsAAlegrXvZoqgjLy8oaI0pbQY8iEcaDpZDc5QKG18g4pGKNLEeV8ct1bucwcaAoJfEALw_wcB
Wah Santro ka insurance 25 k ka hoga humne to 26 m new baleno top model ka showroom se le liya jisme 3 saal third party bhi h jiska premium 15 h agar third party nikal de to..mtlab
Which company? I just took one 2 months back. Zero Downpayment done. I hope you are referring to Corporate Lease offered by Private Companies to their Employees.
I have calculated it based on the 30% tax Slab. As an example 30% Tax plus 4% Surcharge on 2Lakh is 62,400. and that makes me realise I calculated slightly wrong values but with this formula the deal becomes even sweater.
The excel is not accurate. The lease amount itself maybe 7.5 or 8% but you will be charged GST and Road tax recovery will be atleast 35% on top of it. Hence the entire excel is moot.
simply concept is useless, let me tell you, Why ? let me explain, even if it's tax money. Reason one, you never own so you can't sell. Second, for any tension everyone's taking zero-dep and extended warranty at time of buying, so no tension. Also there's a lot more, what if you change your company that gave you the car-leasing option. Today everyone before buying a car knows that it's max life is 10 years on road so no point buying your car when lease is over in 3-5 years which is max. in other words, no matter what's your financial situation..lets say even if you dont have money for downpayment (and you're working) this looks twisted in india.RTO and these minimal charges after on-road are one time and like nothing(why because people spend more than that on fuel itself within every 3 to 6 months for the same car) Anyway sharing my understanding about this all to your other subscribers. Help us understand lets say even if it hurts to pay 30% taxes for someone, and financial advisor says these EMIs annual amount could reduce your Gross CTC and it's basically your 1/3rd(30%) tax money that you're paying as EMI (long story short). Getting the option to buy the same car after 3-5 years (when you've saved money by car-lease using fixed resale value or something like that)...is it profitable ? any real numbers for someone leased a car like this ? What if company has finance partner (providing lease at 11%) is it profitable any way ?
Hi sir, currently maruti/other car companies are also providing the lease option..so the same calculation will apply on that or it will be different..plz clarify.. thanks
How do we apply for the tax exemption? Also the lease seems to be very low...can you please tell me which leasing vendor you got the quote from?...i understand your talking about employer lease program...i work with lti currently not sure how to reach out for this program
@@EveryPaisaMatters one more thing sirji theres a subscription program for maruti suzuki as well which seems to be vfm...agar employer ke through approach nehi kiya toh tax benefits ka umeed chorde kya?
simply concept is useless, let me tell you, Why ? let me explain, even if it's tax money. Reason one, you never own so you can't sell. Second, for any tension everyone's taking zero-dep and extended warranty at time of buying, so no tension. Also there's a lot more, what if you change your company that gave you the car-leasing option. Today everyone before buying a car knows that it's max life is 10 years on road so no point buying your car when lease is over in 3-5 years which is max. in other words, no matter what's your financial situation..lets say even if you dont have money for downpayment (and you're working) this looks twisted in india.RTO and these minimal charges after on-road are one time and like nothing(why because people spend more than that on fuel itself within every 3 to 6 months for the same car) Anyway sharing my understanding about this all to your other subscribers. Help us understand lets say even if it hurts to pay 30% taxes for someone, and financial advisor says these EMIs annual amount could reduce your Gross CTC and it's basically your 1/3rd(30%) tax money that you're paying as EMI (long story short). Getting the option to buy the same car after 3-5 years (when you've saved money by car-lease using fixed resale value or something like that)...is it profitable ? any real numbers for someone leased a car like this ? What if company has finance partner (providing lease at 11%) is it profitable any way ?
The govt tax on a leased car is very high.. I do not think this calculation is right.. I am aware of the value of a car from Avis car lease, and it adds taxes that takes the total value of the car to close to 1.5 times the original price...
@@anindyodutta8247 Its already accounted for. The lease price shown is inclusive of all taxes. If you want breakup, email me at feedback@everypaisamatters.com
@@mehulyadav3051 I think you have not watched the complete video and checked both cases I covered. Please rewatch the same. What I have shown is based on REAL data and not hypothetical as I am myself using these. Rest, if you can share some info on what you have got, that will help me as well as others.
Yeah calculation theoretical, in practical Life everything depends on the way of you own the things either is car or something else and the re sale value depends the condition, also owning a car you could be make change in your own way, i didn't agree that this is the right time in India to lease a car a lot of development need to be done in a way.
Right now company give you a time period with fix amount of km, you can't do any upradation in a car , once you own a car maybe you can cost cutting by fitting CNG kit if your Driving is a lot, there is multiple factors, Right now leasing a car in India is costly then owning and as you said investment your money not everyone can take risk to invest in mutual fund stock gold bond for higher return it's all about skill there's no guarantee too that you can have a good return , the concept of leasing car very new, price isn't justify currently
