Why is the West Questioning India's Achievements? | Vantage with Palki Sharma 

i love palki madam , she is so inspiring her thoughts in the beerbiceps is too good.

Yes absolutely

Here we go again. Media spreading morbid negativity and hate. Generalizing millions of (the west) good people based on one or two opinions. Bill Nelson, the NASAs President, congratulated India personally on this achievement. The UK Space Agency quoted: "History made! Congratulations to ISRO". Josef Aschbacher, the director general of the European Space Agency, described the landing of Chandrayaan-3 as an “incredible” event. Almost every american news outlet reported about the landing and described it as a significant achivement. Why did you not report on that? Shouldnt you be obligated as a journalist to produce a balanced report?

Hiring Palki Sharma ji was your best decision till now. 🔥❤

Great Burnol Excellent Analysis eagerly waiting for this video.... Flat earthers and Brits are Another species don't know facts still arguing. India's is largest Industrial employers Mittal and TATA running their country's. UK literally begging for FTA with india. They Appointed Indian origin UK's PM for appeasing india.. 😂 India is have upper hand here but still we understand it's geopolitics. There colonial white supermacist hangover is still on 😂

🇵🇭🤝🇮🇳

Lots of love from india for Philippines people's.

We all are one come let's celebrate together 🎉

Babuthe Pare 🎉

Hows that brahmos for you guys I hope you are loving it so far ❤❤❤❤ 🇮🇳🤝🇵🇭

@limbate29 Thank you to our friend from Africa....you are learned man, a man of wisdom & high intelligence....thank you for your kind words of praise for India.... However, over the next 5 yrs, we'll be hearing more & more about Africa's rapid development....with its abundance of natural resources ( minerals, metals etc ), fdi in manufacturing , agri industry , tourism etc will pour in on a huge scale, especially from USA & this will be a catalyst for rapid progress....with relatively low wages, Africa would likely become a manufacturing hub for supplies to the Western markets in competition with India....This is the era for India & Africa to rise & shiw to the what they are capable...both should avoid internal & external conflicts.. be united & give a single- minded focus the developmental needs of their respective nations....Africa is now ready for take- off.... Best wishes from India to our great African friends

@@rajnikantchande2677 Thank you very much!

​@geranienbaum ...We can all see who is ranting...Ur days are over..Islamic Republic of Britain is on tour doorsteps.. Deal with hat first. M

​@geranienbaum i bet your german this is expected of you.

Delusional has been lot .England

🇮🇳❤️🇯🇵

The fourth moon mission is going to be collaboration of India 🇮🇳 and Japan 🎑

Japan is always India's friend they helped Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose Indian freedom fighter to form an army against British during India's freedom struggle. Thank you Japan...love from Isha foundation

First free Japan from the US influence.

Thanks, Nibita

Thanks 🙏 love ❤ from india

❤Thank you ......

Thanks brother! We are confident that you will do it too!

Thank a lot

Hell no! Absolutely needs to be rebutted

Grateful to whom?? To those colonial racist hitss🧐🧐

Grateful to whom and why ? ISRO has on their own merit send the Chandrayaan 3.. No one owns us, except ourselves...

🇮🇳🤝🇪🇨

​@@surajgupta1228Greatful to ISRO scientists

One day Equador could do the same, aspire and you acheive

West means mainly we refer America and UK...as you know America is thinks they are world police...And UK think us a a former colony so can't digest..

Good to know

Herzliche Grüße. 😊

@@SushR-aj Hey Schätzeli

@@CugnoBrasso Oh Danke. 😊

We rise high together in this hippocratic world 🙏🇮🇳🇵🇭 we are always with you

Thanks bro 👍🏻

Thanks brother 🙏🏻

I wish u r pakistan pm IND and Pak realationship more happy

👏👏

If indo-pak relations get better, both countries can prosper better.

Thanks brother

🇮🇳❤️🇷🇺

Russia😍

As an Indian , whole India is sad when Lunar 25 crashed.

Thank you Russia , but let's get out of Ukraine , let us not create wars

🇷🇺🇮🇳❤

You should be happier if India would end the caste system and be working on reducing the population.

​@@dunexapa1016For your information every country and civilization has a caste system . They just give it a different name. And caste system helps stability of civilization.

Thank you for such good words, Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam

@@dilipshah5882 *WOW!* An apologist for the caste system. As long as you are not the *DIRT* I guess it is okay with you.

@@dunexapa1016good you invented something to try and discredit India. Are you a happier person now? 😂

We love all our Arab brothers

We love ❤ all our Arab Brothers. True friends of India

Thanks friend 🇮🇳🙏😊❤

And Russia failed because we Indians are smarter and better than war like Russians. Do you agree with me?

Perfect! 😁✨

Dead right. Love from Scotland, in the UK! ❤️🌖🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇬🇧

Thanks ❤ from india. As an Indian, we love all american except your politician 😅 because they always give lecture to india.

@@tanya3508 Maybe if you listened your median household income would be higher than war-torn Iraq.

By West , she targeted the UK and not any other country Specially not the US

​@@stevem437Well after plundering Oil from Iraq or before that? I mean US sends troops in Iraq. Why is US or NATO holding back when it comes to Ukraine. I mean they can easily take down Russia or ? Well O saw Mugshot of Trump. He looks great in it.😂

oh no, it's mostly the brits who are pissed off. never would have ever imagined the country whom they colonized and impoverished for centuries is now leading the world's socio-techno-economic situation, the horror!

U guys r the sweetest much love 💗

My Sister & My Father work for ISRO..Thank you so much Sir..

The scientists and people of science community in general understand that India's or any other country's successful space mission is a progress for the whole of humanity. It's the media and politicians who are bitter and cynical.

@@j1407bmoon In a true democracy, we should act as one humanity. India's achievement should acknowledged and appreciated. Well one India 👍

There are 4 directions . North South Hypocrisy East.

I wonder why India direly needed the validation. I'd say enjoy your success India, its yours for the taking. But don't appear as though you are doing something to please the West, as this commentary does. Of course, hopefully that isn't really the sentiment of India but just a few journalist who wants to get more subscribers. ❤

With all due respect Nigel farage actually had a good point, half of India is still under poverty and that should be the primary objective.

True,great work by Palki Ma'am👍🇮🇳

​@@reezabacawe don't want any validations but its a basic human nature that if someone tries to do something difficult to achieve and actually achieves it then they tend to share it with fellows. USA was formed in late 18th century and they did moon program in 20th century. India only achieved all this in 75 years of independence . We *ONLY SHARED OUR ACHIEVEMENT OUT OF HAPPINESS* . Was it that difficult to congratulate or at least appreciate us?? We are not boasting but only shared what our mission did. Even our Prime Minister said *"This success is of entire mankind"* . Was it that difficult to at least speak a few good words or still act all high and mighty when they are no more??

🇮🇳❤️🇺🇸

You might not get more pictures, I read somewhere that this mission is for finding the presence of ice or water on the dark side, but you might get some ice sample pics. I'm not sure

@@darrelldsa What do you want to prove?

human here and i feel ashamed of the attrocities england did to india , the british empire dosent qualify to be called human... they are a shame on humanity the lowest point of humanity

lndia is 10 years ahead of USA in space technology. Jai Hind

​@@__daddy__ what is hell? It's not true. Don't spread misinformation. USA's space program is way ahead of India.

Thank you, brother 😃🇮🇳 🇺🇸 & please avoid some hate comments as they are trolls

@@__daddy__ India is 50 years behind US in every field. But the good thing is India is picking speed, and cracking missions at low cost and high precision.

🙏👍

Gaganyan is upcoming mission where isro going to send human on space.

Americans are friendly and brothers of Indians we know it 😊

Media sells the narrative to consume.., it's just you who is exception but many thinks what they see in Media

​​@@SamratCharvak ohh bhai 1 comment dekhke pure desh aur logo ko achha mat bana. Terko pta nhi kitne nich aur ghinaune log hai yee

Why isn't their footage looking up and around the moon? Why do we get footage of just going down a ramp? Fooled by cgi.

​@@freshprince3891look, you probably don't understand how images from the moon are sent to earth, it takes quite a long time, so the quality gets lessened. I also read that this mission is for finding ice on the moon, so you might not get pics.

​@@freshprince3891awww go sleep baby boy.

Hey, the figure of 45 trillion dollars was calculated by a Marxist economist named UTSA Patnaik, using a flawed methodology of compounding the loot taken by the British with a 5% interest rate. This method is inaccurate as the inflation rate in the 1950s was around 3.68%. Additionally, Patnaik arrived at a figure of 9 trillion pounds using this flawed method, which was then converted to dollars by multiplying it with 4.68. You can find these details in her article. Furthermore, Patnaik made an exaggerated claim that the British killed 1.8 billion people in India, which is obviously false. It's puzzling that channels like Vice and Wion omitted her outrageous claim of genocide. Unfortunately, spreading lies and misinformation is not uncommon in India. For instance, some stories claim that the Vikramaditya Empire controlled 40% of the world's land, or that India had airplanes 7000 years ago during the Vedic period. These are clearly baseless claims. There is also a story that Shivakar Talpade invented the airplane 8 years before the Wright Brothers, but that the British stole his idea and gave it to the Wright Brothers. India needs to stop perpetuating such false claims.

Really. She is the voice of India.

I applied the same approach as used in the 45 trillion calculation to the investment done by British before 1850s. The estimate of 200 million pounds sterling as the total investment in infrastructure by the British government in India up to the mid-19th century is based on various historical records and estimates. It's worth noting that there is some degree of uncertainty around this figure due to a lack of comprehensive records from the period. That being said, one source that provides an estimate of the British investment in India's infrastructure is the book "The Economic History of India, 1857-1947" by Tirthankar Roy. According to the book, the British invested around 200 million pounds sterling in Indian infrastructure up to the mid-19th century, including the construction of roads, canals, and railways. Another source that supports this estimate is a report by the Indian government's Planning Commission, titled "India's Five Year Plans: An Overview". The report mentions that the British invested around 200 million pounds sterling in India's infrastructure up to the mid-19th century.Using compound interest formula A = P*(1+r/n)^(nt) putting A= 0.2 billion pound, n = once per year (conservative!) and 0.05 interest (as per the India calculation and t=223 years Putting into Microsoft Excel (other spreadsheets are available) tells me that: 10622.914 billion i.e 10 trillion sterling was invested in India which can be converted to dollar by multiplying with 4.68 as done by Patnaik which shows that British invested 46 trillion dollars in India. Now you might have understood how Patnaik lied about it. The way Patnaik calculated it is through a false method.

I applied the same approach as used in the 45 trillion calculation to the investment done by British before 1850s. The estimate of 200 million pounds sterling as the total investment in infrastructure by the British government in India up to the mid-19th century is based on various historical records and estimates. It's worth noting that there is some degree of uncertainty around this figure due to a lack of comprehensive records from the period. That being said, one source that provides an estimate of the British investment in India's infrastructure is the book "The Economic History of India, 1857-1947" by Tirthankar Roy. According to the book, the British invested around 200 million pounds sterling in Indian infrastructure up to the mid-19th century, including the construction of roads, canals, and railways. Another source that supports this estimate is a report by the Indian government's Planning Commission, titled "India's Five Year Plans: An Overview". The report mentions that the British invested around 200 million pounds sterling in India's infrastructure up to the mid-19th century.Using compound interest formula A = P*(1+r/n)^(nt) putting A= 0.2 billion pound, n = once per year (conservative!) and 0.05 interest (as per the India calculation and t=223 years Putting into Microsoft Excel (other spreadsheets are available) tells me that: 10622.914 billion i.e 10 trillion sterling was invested in India which can be converted to dollar by multiplying with 4.68 as done by Patnaik which shows that British invested 46 trillion dollars in India. Now you might have understood how Patnaik lied about it. The way Patnaik calculated it is through a false method.

​@@jeanettewee8805No

​@@jeanettewee8805okay so return the 10 trillion if patnaik even multiplied with 4.68 atlet return that you all can't... Let's forget and stop defaming each other ... Enjoy the life you got

@@bide2505 compounding with 5% interest rate itself is a false method.

Video shows Rover landing on the moon where there is sunshine. But the South Pole of moon is always in dark. Seems fake landing story.

Who said reduction in ISROs budget? Check your knowledge on latest budget allocation

​@@parvathamma1 Department of Space was allotted ₹12,500 crore for year 2023-24, which was 8% less than previous year while the expenditure for space science, which included the Chandrayaan 3 mission, was reduced by 32%. So, yeah, maybe stop embarrassing yourself like this in public? ☺

@@imadeyouwaste1.84secondsre6 Requirment will be different every year. When it increased for specific reasons you will not be appriciative, but when decreased for speicific reason as enteir Isro concentrating on one project you guys will criticize. enemies or not some where outside but inside sadly

@@suryasurya-ge1vw can you read? I just corrected him, didn't criticize anybody

@@imadeyouwaste1.84secondsre6 Budget will be alloted according to the magnitude of projects, stating partial truth is nothing better than lying

Thanks Brother

Thanks bro. I know times are tough there, but you can do it too!

This time , A majority of Pakistanis are supporting this and we Thank u for that. ❤

We have believed it. How can Muslims appreciate Kafir's achievement? You are a big liar!

Most beautiful comment of 2023

Thank you ❤

white supremacy is the reason they behave in such a way but they arent supreme at all

.... We indians believe that whole world is one family... All love ❤🙏

@@priteshpadarat8191 we need to get out of that mindset. Bhay bin hoye na Preet the west China Europe only respect power and brute force this Gandhi wadi stupid philosophy doesn’t work on them

@@NylonStrings83 true 💯

Hey, the figure of 45 trillion dollars was calculated by a Marxist economist named UTSA Patnaik, using a flawed methodology of compounding the loot taken by the British with a 5% interest rate. This method is inaccurate as the inflation rate in the 1950s was around 3.68%. Additionally, Patnaik arrived at a figure of 9 trillion pounds using this flawed method, which was then converted to dollars by multiplying it with 4.68. You can find these details in her article. Furthermore, Patnaik made an exaggerated claim that the British killed 1.8 billion people in India, which is obviously false. It's puzzling that channels like Vice and Wion omitted her outrageous claim of genocide. Unfortunately, spreading lies and misinformation is not uncommon in India. For instance, some stories claim that the Vikramaditya Empire controlled 40% of the world's land, or that India had airplanes 7000 years ago during the Vedic period. These are clearly baseless claims. There is also a story that Shivakar Talpade invented the airplane 8 years before the Wright Brothers, but that the British stole his idea and gave it to the Wright Brothers. India needs to stop perpetuating such false claims.

​@@jeanettewee8805shameless still defending

I'm slightly confused. Can you elaborate on the statement that you are a minority in your country? And how is that information related to you applauding India for their achievements?

Really??? I would have though, there to be a sh!tload of Americans in America.

bot

needing to qualify yourself as a minority in your comment is CRINGE AF, from another minority in my country. people so desperate to be seen as victims

@@alansokelisatruehero8520 what are you talking about? A minority with an opinion is getting you mad? I guess I should have also wrote that I'm a US Army veteran as well huh? So say whatever you want, I served so you have the right too.... smartguy...

So diplomatic

Have courage to talk and solve your border issues with China first ...Can you ? 😂 No

Where r border issues? That's a political agenda don't fall for it

Being an Indian , I must say we dont have border dispute :)

I didn't know we have any border issue. But I know China claims many Nepalese territories.

Thanks brother! You will do the same!

Ecuador?

@@ashi6552 Uganda

just a cartoon representation.

Hey, the figure of 45 trillion dollars was calculated by a Marxist economist named UTSA Patnaik, using a flawed methodology of compounding the loot taken by the British with a 5% interest rate. This method is inaccurate as the inflation rate in the 1950s was around 3.68%. Additionally, Patnaik arrived at a figure of 9 trillion pounds using this flawed method, which was then converted to dollars by multiplying it with 4.68. You can find these details in her article. Furthermore, Patnaik made an exaggerated claim that the British killed 1.8 billion people in India, which is obviously false. It's puzzling that channels like Vice and Wion omitted her outrageous claim of genocide. Unfortunately, spreading lies and misinformation is not uncommon in India. For instance, some stories claim that the Vikramaditya Empire controlled 40% of the world's land, or that India had airplanes 7000 years ago during the Vedic period. These are clearly baseless claims. There is also a story that Shivakar Talpade invented the airplane 8 years before the Wright Brothers, but that the British stole his idea and gave it to the Wright Brothers. India needs to stop perpetuating such false claims.

​​@@jeanettewee8805aww! Still having the guts after 200 years of loot and atrocities! Literally 'great' in the field of jealousy. What Britain did with India will be the darkest example of colonial atrocities in the history of mankind. Read more real content and not fake fabricated ones given by your ancestors

​@@jeanettewee8805lol. U mean " We didn’t loot 45 trillions only a few trillions". So guys u see we are not that bad afterall. & lets not mention Africa & all.

I applied the same approach as used in the 45 trillion calculation to the investment done by British before 1850s. The estimate of 200 million pounds sterling as the total investment in infrastructure by the British government in India up to the mid-19th century is based on various historical records and estimates. It's worth noting that there is some degree of uncertainty around this figure due to a lack of comprehensive records from the period. That being said, one source that provides an estimate of the British investment in India's infrastructure is the book "The Economic History of India, 1857-1947" by Tirthankar Roy. According to the book, the British invested around 200 million pounds sterling in Indian infrastructure up to the mid-19th century, including the construction of roads, canals, and railways. Another source that supports this estimate is a report by the Indian government's Planning Commission, titled "India's Five Year Plans: An Overview". The report mentions that the British invested around 200 million pounds sterling in India's infrastructure up to the mid-19th century.Using compound interest formula A = P*(1+r/n)^(nt) putting A= 0.2 billion pound, n = once per year (conservative!) and 0.05 interest (as per the India calculation and t=223 years Putting into Microsoft Excel (other spreadsheets are available) tells me that: 10622.914 billion i.e 10 trillion sterling was invested in India which can be converted to dollar by multiplying with 4.68 as done by Patnaik which shows that British invested 46 trillion dollars in India. Now you might have understood how Patnaik lied about it. The way Patnaik calculated it is through a false method.

India and Indians love Africa. ❣️ By the God's Grace, Africa will emerge as a strong, prosperous and independent continent, free from western hypocrites.

This has been possible due to assistance from NASA & Russian Space agency period.

No,,, u r wrong,, I have found her news fake many times

She always tells a lie about pakistan,,,,

​@@UmarFarooq-ni2tlandhnamazi will decide 😂

@@mka2032 yes ,,, she is lier in many cases,,,,,

​@@UmarFarooq-ni2tlfact ke saath baat kr bro hawa mey nahi

But thats its name like its not political its purely a geographic term

@@ryandanngetich2524 Who Added That Name? Britain Itself,So She Just Took A Taunt On Them

@@TheMayank18 And you think Great Britain cares what she says or who she is

@@ryandanngetich2524 They Do Actually, That's Why They Poked INDIA First......As Representative Of Indian Media,She Just Gave A Mouth-fitting Reply......

​@@TheMayank18 No you see that was international news... not this and especially not her 😂

Thanks for support

What is so great about India's achievement? Do you believe the science fiction Earth people are going to colonize other planets? And what for? To trash another planet?

India/China/Russia etc should join forces economically/financially and don't allow the West rule the world currency markets as USA with its Dollar plays its hands in international markets and benefits hugely every year getting richer at the expence of other countries. its time developing countries have their own currency and replace the US dollar and be independent of the US$

@@4628mb , Does that mean India and China will reduce their population?

Idiot there is nada on lua fact nada but pedras muito lixo ok

🇮🇳❤️🇦🇪

Thank you bro. Indeed we should realize the west is very cunning

India UAE brothers always🙏

You too can achieve greater heights if you eradicate the pernicious arabic i-virus mental disease.

❤

any science development to achievement all humanity in world Not only specific country

yes😄🤣

Thank ypu sir . Because of pf people like you i will say not every white person is bad .

@@benhughes6507 If you see QUESTIONS of BBC reporters to indian reporters on old space projects which is available on youtube . THEY HAVE ASKED SAME QUESTIONES . THOSE BRITISHERS ARE ASS HOLES .

I resent your comment about ':17 the British ' as if everyone here agrees with the comments made by a couple of people. If you live in the West you are done too! We are all in decline together!

Australians are friendly from a beautiful country

As a rich country with educated public why Australia is not trying for these type of mission. Because they are not fool.

India/China/Russia etc should join forces economically/financially and don't allow the West rule the world currency markets as USA with its Dollar plays its hands in international markets and benefits hugely every year getting richer at the expence of other countries. its time developing countries have their own currency and replace the US dollar and be independent of the US$

if Indian power grows too fast, would NASA sanction Indian ISRO like did to China?

❤🙏

Thank you, I wish post-colonial nations collaborate in tech fields

It's a Victory for Every humanity you are also one among this..Come let's celebrate.🥰

Love you brother ❤❤❤

Babuthe Pare!! 🙏