Why Kolkata Is Not Developed Like Other Metropolitan City ? Is Kolkata City Really Dying ? New Town 

❤

Really nice video, people should support the video and force government to do some development

You deleted the comment of Soumyadeep Chowdhury who exposed you. And you're still denying this wasn't intentional ❓

🤲✨

Tum to gobar baba ka bhakt ho..😂😂😂 sirf Mumbai chod k baki city wale ka aukad hain Kolkata k bare main bolne k liye..🤣🤣🤣

Problem is there in each and every city, but most non-bengalis and some bengalis diss Kolkata as if it is dead city, just based on media perception. Come visit modern parts of Kolkata too understand we are not behind

Truly

​@@norendermoody6509 WB is Decades behind other indian states like Maharashtra, Karnataka, Kerala.

West Bengal needs a change of government. Development is in progress, but it requires rapid improvements, especially in cleanliness, bus , tram. and the redevelopment of backward areas. While New Town and Salt Lake are well-planned, other areas need major focus.

Being from Kolkata, many people here (especially the Northern parts) thrive in calling the old worn down buildings, infrastructure and public transport "aesthetic". This certainly affects the slow development.

Ghatia area

The cream of Kolkata has already left and settled outside the city. What is left are low-skilled, low-wage workers who refuse to realize that they are obsolete, and India does not care if they are alive or dead! 😂😂😂😂😂

But nobody is talking abt that....but Bengaluru's localities are world famous. Who doesn't know Whitefield, Electronic city, Koramangala, Manyata, Ecospace etc.....

@bibinbabu3317 But u guys like to stay in that water....that's why all bongs flock to Bengaluru....coz, there is no life in Bengal...

Saty matters as a metro city. You Kolkata bagged top rank in terms of safety

Bro less crime?data reveals something else.i don't think that our bengal culture is rich now bcoz Bengalis have gone into western style in much deep then any other state .note i m refering to state not only kolkata.really no religion based riots?should I show u data.what is the development rate of kolkata with respect to other metro cities of India? Bengaluru have overtook our city in terms of wealth.please dont tell me that Durga Puja is our culture see i m also bengali and no hate towards bengali but Durga Puja have now become business.everything is same but our mindset have gone wrong.now it's not 3rd bro it's 4th.yeah it very true that our city is affordable and low cost and please don't tell me that we have open mindset towards other culture.lower than south Indian but we don't accept others culture and I can spit u fact on all these topics .

thik bolechen dada!! it is more affordable than other cities too

Less traffic??? 😭😭😭😭

@@bidyutmanna3900 lesser than Bangalore, Mumbai, and delhi

@@sudiptadas101 Keep comparison always....look at Hyderabad they came from nothing to one of the best technology hub and better metropolis... Bangalore I agree... But Delhi?? No... Mumbai is having a huge infrastructure boom so traffic will reduce significantly very soon... But in Kolkata there is no sufficient project is going on to make city less congested...

Yeah I agree with you bro I am also from Kolkata but after staying in Bangalore I can say Kolkata is way behind other cities. This city still didn't start Akasa airline till now whereas other cities. Kolkata is lagging behind in almost everything Just Because I am from Bengal that doesn't Mean I will blindly support people of Bengal what is true is true it can't be denied.

​@@noelpratikhasda2479 Howarah has the rail traffic in India... No city in India... You take example of air I take example of Railways.... The mode of common people now you can cry more.... Now check facts Akasa Started it operations kolkata and Bagdogra airport

​@@shreyanghosh758 ae bhai bangali emotion diye bero hawrah tor baper na ota geographical conditioner jonne howrah oto boro .shudu station dekhiye compare korchis bhai ek bar to fact ta man je kolkata ar sei purono kolkata nei.

@@noelpratikhasda2479 Akasa has started air services to Kolkata. More and more companies are leasing offices and constructing data centers in Kolkata. Things take time. You really should keep up.

@@shreyanghosh758 No matter how much you justify truth is transparent . Whole India knows the condition of Bengal and CM

I've been to Hyderbad no water logging here. Although rain is severr there too

With a horrible metro connectivity, as compared to cities like Delhi, scarcity of cabs and extremely slow, old tin can buses, I don't think that's what is called good transport...

Bengaluru overtook kolkata in 2023 go bro check it out.

Nicely said bro....

@@BoomBam-fz3zz CRY MORE....

KOLKATA vs DHAKA || Which is The Best City 2023 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_uLQ_5N3K7E.html

​@@shreyanghosh758Bengali work as washer in cities like bangalore mumbai..

Sotti bhi 😂

Tai na?kothay hocche development ta ektu dakhan to.ektu notun it company gulo dakhan to jo gulo kolkata te invest korche.ektu job dakhan to scam diye bhorti west bengal.ektu infra development dakhan to amake oi ekta the 42dekaben otar jonno ek bar Delhi ar Bombay ta visit kore asun .

@@BoomBam-fz3zz ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-iF5oLw46mQQ.html

@@BoomBam-fz3zz ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-qV_RQw0ph2w.html

Kolkata should stay like 'Kolkata '. Kolkata shouldn't be like some other cities of the world. Kolkata and London are the two cities where you can find living soul, this two cities are like living life- not like concrete's jungle. Development is the way to grow but development doesn't mean destroying the city- soul should be intact while developing, it's need planning of how to develop the city like The Kolkata- it's the city of culture _ the city of palace. Even after left government _ the rightist government like TMC didn't do anything to provide benefits for foreign investors which lead to WB's slow development or rather I'd say the reason for undevelopment of WB. The same development strategy can't work for the city of joy, for development of the city of culture_ governments should make plans according to the city and in this case for the city of palace. Government and development plan makers should understand the city first.

Nope it won't

Why any particular reason why it will not

One reason might be work culture , i am kolkatan and worked there for more that 4 years now in bangalore. The old people in there 40s are lazy and shouts . The people needs to change hope once boomers perishes , gen zs will make the city great again.

Kolkata will never raise again in the rule of TMC government

Kolkata should stay like 'Kolkata '. Kolkata shouldn't be like some other cities of the world. Kolkata and London are the two cities where you can find living soul, this two cities are like living life- not like concrete's jungle. Development is the way to grow but development doesn't mean destroying the city- soul should be intact while developing, it's need planning of how to develop the city like The Kolkata- it's the city of culture _ the city of palace. Even after left government _ the rightist government like TMC didn't do anything to provide benefits for foreign investors which lead to WB's slow development or rather I'd say the reason for undevelopment of WB. The same development strategy can't work for the city of joy, for development of the city of culture_ governments should make plans according to the city and in this case for the city of palace. Government and development plan makers should understand the city first.

KOLKATA vs DHAKA || Which is The Best City 2023 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_uLQ_5N3K7E.html

@@pran44442 Showing New Town and tourist spots of Kolkata or comparing Kolkata vs Dhaka does not improve the ground reality that WB is a dangerous place to live and work. Big industrial giants even today avoid WB as a business prospect. Mamata still retains Agnikanya image. Tolabaji has not stopped. Panchayat election saw 47 deaths. Do you think the big industrialists have not noticed this ? 2024 election will drain 68 deaths in WB for sure if you extrapolate the trend. Compare Kolkata of say 1953 vs 2023 and Mumbai, Chennai, Bangalore, Hyderabad, Ahmedabad, Pune, Vizag, Surat, etc. Where is the second new fast developing city in WB with hope, prosperity and growth ?

KOLKATA vs DHAKA || Which is The Best City 2023 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_uLQ_5N3K7E.html

All Bengalis are flocking to Bengaluru for IT and non-it jobs.....still long way to go Kolkata to catch anywhere near Bengaluru....

Its a joke nothing major happening as compared to other cities all political influence flowing all around

@@Prvn708 Going by that logic, a lot of Delhites and Gujaratis are in Bangalore. So Delhi and Gujarat is underdeveloped right?

@@SOUVIK_RAY_ Yes, not as developed as Bengaluru

It has nothing to do with language...

@@thotkata though it has nothing to do with the language but attitude matters . A state can only develop when people start changing their ways of thinking . Northern states like Gujarat Rajasthan etc and South Indian states are developed why simple reason attitude. If a person changes his or her attitude he or she can become successful in life.

Have u ever visited the city.Don't think it has got anything to do with language. Hindi English bollywood is rampant in west bengal. You will never find a person saying speak to me in bengali only. Yes attitude is the reason. Laid-back attitude. Happy being middle class.

@@abhishekbasu8694 read carefully he said exactly the opposite thing..he said Bengalis are arrogant with their language...yes you are corrct Bengalis should be more proud of their language..

@@noelpratikhasda2479 yes..but you mentioned language..so I disagreed...infact bengalis are most multilingual people...regarding attitude your obseravation is correct..

Exactly❤😢

Bhai agar development hi nahi hoga aur earn hi nahi kar paaoge toh property k daam toh kam hi honge na

uske lie earn karna padhega na pahle

@@ayushdxt jyada logo ka savings lifetime ka high property prices me khatm horaha jo justified nhi

WTTFFFF r ya kidding????????? Pagol ki Nothing is organised everything is chaotic n crime rate is also high although lower than Bimaru states

The traffic management and enforcement is way superior to any major city in India. Go out see for yourself

KOLKATA vs DHAKA || Which is The Best City 2023 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_uLQ_5N3K7E.html

@@pran44442 dhaka ❤kolkata Pran kendra of two Bengal

KOLKATA vs DHAKA || Which is The Best City 2023 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_uLQ_5N3K7E.html

New Town is New Town, not Kolkata..

@@saptarshichoudhury513 it is in Kolkata

@@Scythe6140 says who? They both are different cities..

Yes

​@@saptarshichoudhury513 New Town comes under Kolkata Metropolitan Area. When we talk and compare about Kolkata, Mumbai, Chennai we always talk about metropolitan area.

past glory has nothing to do with the present scenario. Kolkata must focus on using its past glory to leverage its position to attract higher investment and invest more on infrastructure.

Ye bolke hilate reh bhikari

"WAS" 😢

Wow - what a deluded, self-hatred filled view. I am ashamed to see that you are a Bhattacharya like myself [although I have brought glory to India worldwide through my own work]. No wonder others laugh at Bengalis for basking in the supposed glory of British colonial subjugation. Subhas Bose would be turning in his grave were he buried. India actually had the world's largest economy (over 25% of global GDP) in the early 18th Century prior to British occupation, deindustrialization and looting of India's resources. Research published by Columbia UP in 2018 showed that the British stole about US45 Trillion from India from 1757-1938 (see Prof. Jason Hickel's article online about how modern Britain was built with loot from India). Britain's Industrial Revolution and much Western development was financed by 'loot' (Hindi for plunder) from India. India's world leading textile industry was systematically eliminated by the Brits so that Britain's new industrial cotton industry [copying Indian techniques and styles - e.g. 'Paisley'] could develop as 19th Century historians H.H. Wilson and Friedrich List both noted. This included tariff barriers, making India a monopolized Captive Market for British goods and breaking weavers fingers and even cutting off thumbs of the famed Dhaka Muslin weavers. Governor General Bentinck wrote that the plains of India are bleached with the bones of her weavers. India had produced the best steel in the world (Wootz) as recognized by English experts in the 1790s - and Sheffield copied its methods. French and British colonial observers noted that 18th Century India made cannon and muskets as good as any in Europe but arms production was eliminated. The oldest seaworthy ship in the Royal Navy HMS Trincomalee was built by an Indian Co. in 1817 but British competitors stopped shipbuilding in India. When 19th Century Indian engineers showed that they could design and build locomotives, this was of course suppressed. It was not until the 1914-18 Great War in Europe that India was allowed to develop some industrial capacity - then only due to Britain's emergency needs. They also killed tens of millions of the poorest in about 3 dozen famines created by Britain stealing India's foodgrains for British profit and Food Security. Robert Clive returned from Bengal with his 'loot' as the richest non-monarch in Europe and his East India Co. mafia became the super-rich new elite known as 'nobs' (from 'nabobs') whilst up to 1/3 of the population of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa (up to 10 million) died in the 1770 Great Bengal Famine created by their rapacity - as predicted by Richard Becher (a relative of novelist William Thackeray). This led to Europe's first Credit Crunch in 1772 when dozens of banks collapsed in days as Indian loot financing Western development dried up for a while. The EIC started peddling Indian opium to China from 1770 (kidnapping children to work on opium plantations etc.) which brought Britain 1/7 of its export revenues for 140 years. In 1877 Cornelius Walford showed that there were 30 famines in British-occupied India in just 120 years compared to 17 famines in all of India in the previous 2,000 years. This was because native Hindu and Indianized Muslim rulers acted to prevent and alleviate famines. The British created them with their profiteering, hoarding and exporting for Britain's profit and Food Security [it was Industrial Britain that did not grow enough food to feed itself - until after 1945 - India as a whole always did]. The Disraeli regime even set up Death Camps for victims of the 1877 manmade famine in Madras Province - giving famine victims less starvation rations for hard labour than given in Buchenwald - killing 94% of inmates. 5-7 million died whilst record amounts of Indian grain exports lowered prices in Britain and the West. Famine survivors were coerced into the new slavery of indentured labour in the Caribbean etc. Disraeli organized the biggest feast in human history, the 1877 Delhi Durbar, to celebrate Vicky being named Empress of India whilst 100,000 a week died in South India. In 1901 The Lancet estimated conservatively from the census that 19 million had died of starvation in Western India during the 1890s due to British policies. In 1936 George Orwell wrote in Road to Wigan Pier that 100 million Indians must be forced to the edge of starvation so that the British can live in comfort. As late as 1942-3, Hindu-hating White Supremacist Winston Churchill was responsible for killing millions in Bengal due to Nazi-like Collective Punishment of Bengal and - after British cover-ups were blown by the press in 1943, preventing Food Aid from other countries reaching Bengal, diverting US, Canadian and Australian grain to the UK. As ever, there were surplus food stocks in India as a whole but the Brits ensured they didn't get to Bengal. Even the Nazis allowed Red Cross Food Aid to Greek Famine victims in 1941. Many Westerners still believe the British propaganda myths, first concocted by James Mill (father of J.S. Mill) who was 2nd in Command of the EIC - that India was a Land of Eternal Poverty and Famine and the cause of this was Hinduism which had supposedly remained unchanged for 3,000 years. In truth, India had been famed for its wealth prior to British looting. The Romans complained of the Silver Drain to India in return for Indian exports. Columbus told his sponsors that he was seeking a new route to the fabled wealth and riches of India. In 1616 English ambassador Thomas Roe wrote that Delhi was the Treasury of the World. In fact it was the economic Silver Drain to India due to India's successful exports that prompted the British Conquest - taking advantage of the power vacuum that arose as the Hindu Marathas had defeated the Mughals in battle - but maintained a figurehead Mughal emperor.

Patna laughing 😂

😂😂😂

@@swarajmukherjee2249 you chor tui Tmc

WB needs a mindset where state government will be changed in every 5 year.

Bol toh aise raha hai Jaise Delhi, Mumbai is New york or Dubai. Gandagi har shahar me hai.

@@SOUVIK_RAY_ whio told u new York is clean ? but out of all Indian cities I have visited I think Kolkata is the dirtiest too much trash

Delhi is literally in the top 5 list of the World's dirtiest cities 🌚

@@SOUVIK_RAY_ Delhi dirty hai par Kolkata bhi hai. Aur leftist govt se development impossible. Vote BJ0

What about Bangladeshi muslim they they are your relatives

@@AjayKumar-tz1fp We are more concerned about Bihari Hindus & Muslims both because both are invasive and terrific. I am not concerned about Bangladeshis because they are limited in number not unlimited like the Biharis.

I made this video after visiting kolkata 2 times

@@InfraTalks211 not talking about you but some people in comments try to create a bad image of Kolkata, Kolkata is not growing fastly like other cities that's true; but it has nothing, no job, no opportunity that's not true, and if the govt focus on beautification in Central and South Kolkata by removing electric wires and shops blocking footpaths, renovating the market places then it will look way better and the image of a dirty city will change. I personally like those old structured buildings they need renovation and proper maintenance.

​@@arghyadipray5278Kolkata is full of slum.congested city.pathetic.

@@InfraTalks211 In your two times visit, you only visited the underdeveloped parts and not the posh or newer parts of the city? Kyon chutiya banata hai public ko?

Kolkata should stay like 'Kolkata '. Kolkata shouldn't be like some other cities of the world. Kolkata and London are the two cities where you can find living soul, this two cities are like living life- not like concrete's jungle. Development is the way to grow but development doesn't mean destroying the city- soul should be intact while developing, it's need planning of how to develop the city like The Kolkata- it's the city of culture _ the city of palace. Even after left government _ the rightist government like TMC didn't do anything to provide benefits for foreign investors which lead to WB's slow development or rather I'd say the reason for undevelopment of WB. The same development strategy can't work for the city of joy, for development of the city of culture_ governments should make plans according to the city and in this case for the city of palace. Government and development plan makers should understand the city first.

Even mamata didi also

​@@GermanReich-Yea

KOLKATA vs DHAKA || Which is The Best City 2023 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_uLQ_5N3K7E.html

He's not kidding come at budge budge fly over at 5 pm and you will see traffic jam

Sir. This video is not hate on Kolkata, we just want to tell through this video that Kolkata did not get the importance it should have got after independence, because Kolkata is a world class city, and Kolkata has immense development potential . Kolkata has seen a lot of development recently, but this video is not on the development of Kolkata, this video is only on what happened to Kolkata after independence, on the development of Kolkata, I will make a separate video

Sir inko rply kyu de rhe ho inhone video ko pura dekha bhi nhi hoga bolne aa gye hai aapne accche se sb explain kiya hai. Kon kon c industry Kolkata me hai wo bhi btaya hai .

Hello bro wake up bro nothing is there in Kolkata. I have been to other states Kolkata is way behind now .

@@InfraTalks211 ok sure thanks 🙏💕

Newtown is not kolkata. In terms of infrastructure there is nothing. All old ones. In terms of silicon valley there is wipro tcs and capegemini. While other IT hubs have Google Microsoft oracle Accenture, etc. Not to mention indian startups like flipkart, snapdeal, mama earth, lenskart, etc were all founded in other cities

🤗🤗🤗

Bihar is way worse though up is way better

Right

What 💀

KOLKATA vs DHAKA || Which is The Best City 2023 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_uLQ_5N3K7E.html

Hmmm ok

This is only in some old part of kolkata. But not new parts

@@Anonymous-sf4hw Okay thanks for the information, I hope the city condition is good now

Yes CPM n now TMC

Vote BJP 2026

Pagal ho kya

Likewise. Where were you visiting from??

✅️ right

U fool don't know after Mumbai Kolkata has the highest skyscrapes in India.. And many more r under hold or already work in progress. Jst go and visit there..

@@shibamdebnath254 I mentioned this in my comment that Kolkata was the 2nd tallest city....for now there is no such commercial or above 150 meter buildings under construction or proposed phase... Guru gram, Noida, Hyderabad all are having huge high rise boom where kolkata lacks.... In Hyderabad there are more than 50 building over 150 meter under construction and approved phase...where kolkata hardly have 5....similer to Noida,Gurugram, Navi Mumbai, Thane...and Gift city also approved so many 200m + buildings... Chennai also have SPR city where 200meter+ building will include... I hope in future kolkata would propose some 200 meter+ buildings in prime locations like em bypass or cbd area.

​@@bidyutmanna3900 mt smjhao bhai inko problem kolkata me nhi in logo ke mindset me hai ye chahte he ni government ko criticize krna government ko pressure bnate to city ka development rukta he nhi

​@@shibamdebnath254ektu bangali emotion diye bariye beriyo duniya ta dakh onek kichu ache vul val bokis na.

Then why thousand and lakhs of Bengali migrate to gujarat for Jobs and bussiness but not any gujarati migrate to west bengal 😂😂🤣 Data and ground reality both are different 😂😂😂

KOLKATA vs DHAKA || Which is The Best City 2023 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_uLQ_5N3K7E.html

Noted

Thank you for your comment! We invite you to watch our 'Future West Bengal' video to gain a deeper insight into our perspective. Our intention was to highlight the positive potential and progress in the state. We appreciate your engagement and are open to constructive discussions about different viewpoints. Feel free to share your thoughts after watching the video. Thank you!

@@InfraTalks211 I appreciate that you took my comment positively instead of showing arrogance. Hope this channel grows!

No brother I love Kolkata

Fr bro😢

They loved Kolkata till 1980s

Tere khalistani state Punjab se toh acchi hai 😂😂😂

Umesh singh to yeh bta ager kolkata khrab city h to isse city of joy kyu bola jata h tum up wale goan ke kya samjhoge

@@jitsaha5600 Bhai kintu City of Joy r roilo na lokeder kaaj r mindset ar crimes er jonno baire thake City of Joy bhitor a onek alada Kolkata r lokera sobsomoy khusi thakte gele mindset change korte hobe jemon Kanpur

Don't spread false misleading information about Kolkata,, Kolkata is much better than your so called hometown

Kolkata should stay like 'Kolkata '. Kolkata shouldn't be like some other cities of the world. Kolkata and London are the two cities where you can find living soul, this two cities are like living life- not like concrete's jungle. Development is the way to grow but development doesn't mean destroying the city- soul should be intact while developing, it's need planning of how to develop the city like The Kolkata- it's the city of culture _ the city of palace. Even after left government _ the rightist government like TMC didn't do anything to provide benefits for foreign investors which lead to WB's slow development or rather I'd say the reason for undevelopment of WB. The same development strategy can't work for the city of joy, for development of the city of culture_ governments should make plans according to the city and in this case for the city of palace. Government and development plan makers should understand the city first.

Water metro and future Megaprojects video's are also on channel go and check

​@@InfraTalks211 to yea vdo keu upload keye ho 🧐🤨

This is also a fact

@BIBIN BABU yeah but central did it first in Kolkata?

@BIBIN BABU then why? 😂😂

I visited last month salt lake kolkata