Well know Scholar Professor Ahmad Rafiq Akhtar explained why he is against Javaid Ahmad Ghamdi and Allama Tahir ul Qadri #ProfAhmadRafiqAkhtar #Ghamdi #TahirulQadri #JavaidAhmadGhamdi #AllamaTahirulQadri
Tu usko toheen reaslaat q mehsus nai hoi. K ktch kehta saadiq ameen k title ko bantny may. Wo lectures dr k isliye thay k ye qom Rasool allah say mohabbat kerti hay. Dr nay rizvi sab nay b qom k love emotions ko use kia.
Shaikh ul islam dr muhammad tahir ul qadri sab written quranic encyclopedia, 100 books on hadith compilation works wich is recognised by arabic scholars in alazhar University work of shaikh ul islam are recognised pls people study work of shaikh ul islam.dr tahir ul qadri sab
Is jahil ko ma'aloom naeen keh Quran Karim ka other naam Furqan hay. His understanding of Quran Karim is that Quran Karim is incomplete in its teachings.
پروفیسر صاحب کو کسی کانام لے کر برا بھلا نہیں کہنا چاھئیے تھا۔ آفرین ھے غامدی صاحب پہ جنہوں نے کبھی بھی کسی کا نام لے کر اس پر تنقید نہیں کی۔ اگر نام لیا تو ھمیشہ تعریف ھی کی۔
Sorry to say professor Sb, with all due respect, Quran is Furqan. You know very well the meaning of furqan. This is the one and only standard we have to judge the authenticity of any saying.
Absolutely Right. Prof sab please keep uploading your stance on latest upcoming fitnas on time, as its social media era and muslims get easily astrayed by today's ghamdis and Eng. Mirza Ghamdias and tahir ul padri are big fitnas todays. Baba g Ameer ul Mujahideen Allama Khadim Hussain Rizvi sahab had exposed them better than anyone very early alhumdulilah. Prof sab you are a gem, Alhumdulilah we have you today
There is no comparison between qadri and ghamdi. Ghamdi is a true scholar who really know how the islamic thoughts in true manner. Even ghamdi and professor sb has no comparison in terms of research and islamic thoughts. Ghamdi sb is unparalleled.
Hassan sab agar aap bura na manayen tu pehlay apney mazhab sa tu agaahi hasil kar lian pir aap ko patha chale ga .keh yeh Gamedi kis qadar Islam ko nuqsan pahuncha Raha ha.aur ye kis ka ajenda par Kam karta ha
dr tahir qadri khud ek video clip me is baat ka khulasa kya hai ke sirf tarjuma quran me un ki mehnat h baaqi saari books anjuman hi tayyari karti sirf main nazre saani krta hun
Aalim apny ilm ko use kaha kerta hay dunia k liye ya allah k liye. Agr allah k liye kery tu agay berhta berhta arif ho jata hay. Agr dunia uski priority ho gea tu wo uss ko dsssss lay ga. Jesy snake dssta hay.
Ye log international level py ummat k problem ko smjty hi nhi hn sirf apna chooran bech ry hn Doctor Tahir qadri ki effort Jo unu NY islam k liye hn professor Rafia 7 dafa b paida ho k ni kr skty
پروفیسر احمد رفیق صاحب ایک نہایت ہی مدبر اور اچھے اور معتدل عالم دین ہے ڈاکٹر طاہرالقادری صاحب کے بارے میں ان کے خیالات ان کا ذاتی نقطہ نظر ہے ڈاکٹر طاہر القادری صاحب پاکستان کے ساتھ ساتھ پوری دنیا میں اسلام کی ترویج اور اشاعت کا کام کر رہے ہیں بہت سے ایسے مسائل ہیں جن کی وجہ سے پاکستان میں رہتے ہوئے ان ممالک تک پہنچنے میں رکاوٹ ہے اپنے کام کو زیادہ بہتر کیسے کرنا ہے یہ ہر عالم دین کا اپنا حق ہے مگر یہ بات طے ہے کہ ڈاکٹر طاہر القادری صاحب بیرون ملک کسی اپنے ذاتی مقاصد کے لیے نہیں گئے
With all respect to professor rafiq sab if dr tahir ul qadri is not alim according to him then I think professor rafiq sab need some special brain assessments by some specialist brain surgeon pls use your brain and study books of dr tahir ul qadri sab then you will know who is alim professor rafiq sab is good speaker bit dr qadri is just so great in every field of islam and if you think iam wrong pls prove me wrong just bring one work of professor rafiq sab on hadith work if he done wich he never or any work on quranic tafseer or any work on asool a hadith or any work on quranic encyclopedia or any work on human writes or any book on scientific research on creation of man and his purpose of life or any latest hadith compilation after the work of mishkat ul musabeeh or any work on fiqh ijtihad issue or any work on shara and tafseer of quran or any work on sura al fathia, dr qadri wrote 4000 page shara of just sura al fathia, also hundreds of Arab scholors take ijaza from dr qadri on hadith, iam realy in shock to hear from professor rafiq sab that dr qadri is not alim he should take his words back iam.sorry to thouse who blind following professor rafiq sab pls I request you to study and see dr qadri sabs work then decide dr qadri is spreading knowledge allover the globe 🌎 his work is based over 90 countries around the globe 🌎 due respect professor rafiq sab is just sitting in Pakistan smoking 🚬 while talking you who follow rafiq sab pls you need to take of your blind fold dr qadri is heavyweight scholor if.you don't believe me prove me.wrong jazakAllah
This scholar has no match of Mr Ghamidi but I agree that there is only one Sadiq and Ameen and that is our beloved Prophet- may the peace and blessings of Allah be upon him! Thanks
Respected Professor Sahib I have great respect for you since you are a very learned personal having immense knowledge but very disappointed to see that you opt to criticise other learned and equally knowledgeable people who might have a different or maybe better understanding about the implications of Hadees. I as a lame person believe in the Quranic saying نشانیاں ہیں عقل والوں کیلئے and most importantly ہم نے اپنی آیات کھول کھول کر بیان کر دی ہیں۔ , Anyways, the reality remains that our Holy Prophet migrated from Mecca to Medina to avoid the threats to his life and it does fall under the category to follow the examples set by him. I fail to understand why would any one talk against certain people who have opted to go abroad and settle down in another country because they might have faced unfavourable living conditions in Pakistan and decided to go away. Its so unfortunate that the scholarly people like you are not setting up any good examples by not respecting individuals right to read, right, express and make decisions based upon their best knowledge and understanding of a particular aspect of life. Its every one's right to be critical under a well defined limits and it is incumbent upon others the so called self proclaimed scholars to become role models by showing personal respect for others who might have a different point of view on any given subject. You do fall under the category of scholars and we expect from you to show better way of expressing your difference in opinion as you do have right to differ and express. My profound apologies in advance in case my comments are considered as offensive. I believe in respect for every one no matter who that person might be
The person who doesn't present the real or true light of Islam but misguide people as scholar of Islam is to be mline and not to be appreciated,,,ghamdi and qadri are such doubtful characters,,listen to professor carefully than you will get his point
We cannot compare migration of Rasool sallahu alihay wasaalam with these so called scholar, migrated to North America. Why not they migrated to any poor country in Aferica? Every one wants north America nationality and die in Madina. Strange...
@@nadeemsharif8954 some of the residents to escape hardship did migrate to Habash. At that time it was a very prosperous country, lot more than Arabia.From your perspective they were also wrong.
You mangled and amalgamated both scholars wrongly, i have some differences with dr tahir ul qadri but he spent his whole life for Allah and ishq for His Rasool s.a.w. He has compiled more than 100 books on hadith.
@@noor-ul-ain386کتابوں کی تعداد جاہلوں کے لیے کوئی معنی نہیں رکھتی ہاں اہل علم حضرات جانتے ہیں کہ چند سطور لکھنے کے لیے کتنی محنت اور مطالعہ درکار ہوتا۔ یہ کام اتنا ہی آسان ہوتا تو ہر ایرا غیرا یہ کام کر لیتا۔
I have watched a couple of videos of Mr Akhtar, but never found them making much sense. May be he was a good professot, while he taught, but his articulation is poor now, neither in Urdu nor when he switches over to English. His intellect or lack of it does not allow him to appreciate the fine point of Mr Ghamdi's deliberations. Mr Qadri, the self-styled Sheikh-ul-Islam is an actor, not worth wasting any words on him. Ghamdi sahab is a true scholar, an aalim-e-din. He seems to understand the progress and limitations of science too. Why he resides where he resides and how he lives his life are not our concern.
@@ishtiaqahmed5213 meray dost unbiased ho kay samjho unko...sab kuch clear ho jaye ga. Main baghair investigation kay zyada baat nahi karta. Aur koi bhi scholar is not hundred percent in everything...because no one is perfect.
i have been listening to ghamdi sahab for 20 years from the time i was a kid, he has very logical point of views. Ghamdi sir left pakistan because his companions were shot and killed. and hadith and quran are obviously different and on hadiths its absolutely correct to question their authenticity. Instead of having discussions, calling them names and saying you are an amazing teacher is kinda stupid
پروفیسر صاحب خود فرماتے ہیں کہ اللہ تعالیٰ کی کاینات میں اپنے آپ کو عقل کل سمجھنا انسان کی سب سے بڑی غلطی اور حماقت ہے پھر بہتر تھا کہ طاہر القادری صاحب کے بارے اثنا ہی کہہ دیتے کہ اللہ تعالیٰ نے جس کو جو ڈیوٹی دی ہے وہ کر رہا ہے
Prof Akhtar sb don’t confuse the people. Dr Qadri sb is serving Islam in all over the world. Is living in abroad against Islam? Dr Qadri gave awareness to the nation about Sadiq and Ameen. Dr Qadri did practical struggle in Pakistan why did you support him? Where were you at that time? Just criticising someone and talking on the stage is easy and playing in the field is difficult. Be honest in your opinion and don’t misguide the people.
Tahirul Qadri sb may have written hundreds of books but What did he do for his poor followers killed mercilessly in Model Town , Lahore. Came couple of times to Pakistan and took part in the drama of "Dharna" in Islamabad , gave all sorts of talks to the audience from safety and comfort of his container and then returned to Canada. Never bothered about all those women , children and men killed in Lahore. There have been speculations about him getting a huge amount of money from the Govt of the time to go back quietly to Canada. End of story.
Tahirul Qadri sb has been coming to Pakistan to do Dharnas in D Chowk in Islamabad. What did he achieve politically , religiously or socially by such Dramas ? What did he do for his poor followers, including women, children, and old people brutally murdered by Police in Model Town ,Lahore. Nothing. Zero. Zilch. Just scooted off to Canada , kept quiet and lived a comfortable life. Is this What all the books written and lectures given by him have taught him ???
آپ کی حثیت ہی کچھ نہیں ہے جتنی کتابوں کے آپ کو نام نہیں آتے ہیں اس سے زیادہ وہ لکھ چکے ہیں آپ کے ماننے نہ ماننے سے کچھ نہیں ہوتا ، آپ ایک عربی عبارت نہیں پڑھ سکتے ڈاکٹر صاحب کے سامنے ، اپنے آپ کو دیکھیں پہلے کیا علمی قد ہے آپکا اور بات جس پہ کر رہے ہیں
Prof Ahmad shb ko chahiye tha k lab kushai sy pyhly thori c tehqeeq kr lyty is mozu py Dr Tahir ul Qadri k drjano ki tadad sy lectures hn. mgr Dr shb ki hazaro achievements or Khidmaat ko nzr andaz kr k sirf bhr rehny ka pallu pakra hva. Rahi baat Allah ki ataa pr to Allah or usk Rasool SAW ka fazal jitna Dr Qadri shb py hy iss century me or kisi py nahi. jo k nzr aa raha hy... Welfare foundation, agosh Orphan care, Thousand of Books, 6 Thousand of lectures, Organization in more than 90 contries, dozens of Islamic Community centers in foriegn contries, Qairo University me unki books slybus ka hissa hn or aysi bht c batyn cmnt long ho jaye ga. پر گھڑے کی مچھلی کو گھڑے سے باہر کیسے دکھائی دیگا، Tehqeeq needed before Bayaan.
From Huzoor Sallallahu Alehi Wasallam to your Companions, Who has migrated in their life, From Imam Bukhari to big muhaddis and alims, Everyone migrated.
Luxury life style aor dunadari ki Shan o shokat wali zindgi guzarne walon ko aalam Deen kehne par Tars aata ha ke woh Kahan tak sunnat ke mutabiq zindgi guzarte Hein????
پروفیسر صاحب ۔ ہر نبی اور رسول صادق اور امین ہے۔ جو رسولوں میں تفریق کرتے ہیں وہ اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کے فیصلے کے مطابق پکے کافر ہوتے ہیں ، لوگوں کو گمراہ کرنا چھوڑ دیں!!!
You are a just story teller but Dr Tahir ul Qadri is a great scholar all-around the world. How you can make remarks without studying Dr Tahir ul Qadri's books and lectures?
Even if professor Sahib has different opinion about other scholars, it doesn't suit him to criticize them ! He should be above this negativity and stop being a judge of others.
Qadri sb enjoying Canadian nationality with his whole family...kaya Quran mai nae likha k inn logo kaya ho gaya hai k chor kyu nae detay Kuffarastan ko kaya Allah ke zameen choti hai?... Yeh kaya jawab de gay Qayamat k din.
Professor sb nay lagta hai Dr tahir ul qadri sb ko suna hi nahi. 1000 Books likh di hai jin ka qayi editions poori dunya main pari ja rahi hain. Professor Rafiq sb ka main b fan hoon lakin bilawaja parnay k baghair ilzam lagana jaiz nahi. Mazret
پروفیسر صاحب کی بہت قدر کرتے ہیں۔۔۔ امید ہے کہ پروفیسر صاحب نے غامدی صاحب کی کوئی کتاب خود سے نہیں پڑھیں ہوگی۔ غامدی صاحب کی پانچ کتب ہیں جن میں سے اگر پروفیسر صاحب 1000 روپے لگا کر کسی پنڈی شہر کے مکتب سے اسلام کے موضوع پر جامع کتاب "میزان" خرید کر پڑھ لیں چاہے پانچ صفحات ہی کیوں نہ ہوں۔۔۔۔۔ پروفیسر صاحب جو غیر ذمہ دارانہ اور بغیر علم کے محض چند کلپ سن کر جو تبصرہ فرما رہے ہیں اس کی نوبت نہ آتی۔۔۔۔۔ یقیناَ غامدی صاحب کی شخصیت کو منفی انداز میں دیکھنے کا یہ زاویہ انہوں نے خود پڑھ کر قائم نہیں کیا ہوگا۔۔۔۔ میزان کتاب کا تعارف یہ ہے کہ یہ کتاب پورے اسلام کو بیان کرتی ہے اس کتاب کے مصنف غامدی صاحب کا دعویٰ ہے بلکہ درست بھی ہے کہ اسلام کو جامع بیان کرنے والی روۓ زمین پر کوئی کتاب ایسی نہیں گزری ہوگی جس میں 1200 کے لگ بھگ احادیث مبارکہ موجود ہوں۔۔۔ جی احادیث مبارکہ کی بات ہورہی ہے میرے کتب خانے میں یہ کتاب پڑی ہے تقریباً ہر صفحہ پر کم از کم اوسطاً دو سے تین احادیث مبارکہ مل جائیں گی۔۔۔۔ کتنی بدنصیبی کہ ایک شخص جو اپنی کتاب کی پہلی سطر ان الفاظ سے کرتا ہے اس پر الزام۔۔۔۔ افسوس ہوتا ہے۔۔۔۔ وہ سطر یہ ہے کہ "دین اسلام کا تنہا ماخذ محمد رسول اللہ کی ذات ہے۔" کیا یہ الفاظ کم ہیں غامدی صاحب کے مخالف اور ناقد یہ سطر ہزار بار پڑھیں اور اپنی عقل کو استعمال کریں کہ اس سطر کا کیا مطلب ہوسکتا ہے اور ہم کیا پروپیگنڈا کررہے ہیں بغیر علم کے۔۔۔۔۔
Prof sb failed to understand the foreign living of Dr Tahir ul Qadri sb. He gave , Irfan ul Quran, Quranc Encyclopedia, 60 volumes of Hadith Encyclopedia and much more which was not possible while living here. He delivered more than 7000 lectures on each & every topic.
Dear, a people who are quite ignorant & illeterat are supposed to follow Ghamedi.He is a wolf for the holy religion islam wearing the dress of Islamic scholar .
Subhan Allah Jazakala khair Thank you very much for your very informative explanation Many times it came to my mind and I have written on Facebook What is the role of Dr Tahir ul Qadri sahib in supporting 126 days dharna Also Dr Farhat Hashmi and Dr Tahir ul Qadri sahib collecting funds from Pakistani people and living in Canada
Rafiq ahmad is wrong. He does not go below the surface even in the academic research. He is prejudice. He does not understand by an iota the point of view ghamdi on hadith, he has never denied hadith.
کینیڈا میں رہ کر تم پاکستانی ملاں اور فلاسفروں سے ذیادہ دین کا کام کر رہے ہیں۔ انکی جماعت بڑی تیزی سے اپنی منزل کی طرف گامزن ہے ۔ پاگل آدمی دنیا کہاں چلی گئی اور تم لوگ بس یہی دیکھتے رہنا کہ کون کہاں رہتا ہے اور کیوں نہیں پاکستان میں۔ ڈاکٹر طاہر القادری صاحب نے 60 سال تمہارے ہی ملک میں گزارے مگر نا اہل لوگ ہو تم پاکستانی۔ قدر ہی نہیں علم کی یہاں
آپ کو چائیے تھا غامدی صاحب کے سامنے بیٹھ کر یہ سوال کرتے تاکہ لوگوں کو کوئی فائدہ ہوتا مگر آپ بھی اسی روش پہ ہیں جس سے بس میں میں اور میں ، آج غامدی صاحب کو دنیا سے گزرنے دیں بھر طوفان برپا ہو گا
اس پروفیسر کو شیخ الاسلام ڈاکٹر محمد طاہر القادری کے بارے میں کوئی معلومات نہیں غلط بیانی کرتے ہوئے انہیں غامدی صاحب سےملا رہا ہے طاہر القادری صاحب کے بین الاقوامی سطح پر خدمت دین کے کام کو دیکھ کر عقل دنگ رہ جاتی ہے ۔
Yes sir our llamas nd peers r most thankfully of west countries they r relux Europe nd adviser of Muslims sorry they have no shame they r same like our political leaders
القرآن۔ ہم نے اس قرآن میں ہر ضروری چیز کا تفصیل سے ذکر دیا ہے۔ (جب قرآن میں ضروی چیزوں کا تفصیل سے ذکر آگیا ہے تو میں پھر غیر ضروری چیزوں کی طرف کیوں جاؤ)
