Тёмный

Why The Jedi Stopped Wearing Battle Armor 

Star Wars Reading Club
Подписаться 346 тыс.
Просмотров 819 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

1 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1 тыс.   
@CynUnion-ji9uj
@CynUnion-ji9uj 8 лет назад
Chancellor Valorum: The Sith are gone lets demilitarize the Jedi and get rid of our entire army. The Senate: Why? Valorum: Because it will promote peace and prosperity Senate: Shouldn't we have an army in case something happens and we need to go to war. Valorum: War will never ever happen again, trust me. Seriously why of all things would the senate agree to getting rid of the ENTIRE DAMN MILITARY. That is the most ridiculous choice for any government ever.
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
I thought along the same lines as well Union, as it seems that the Jedi thought very similarly. And that ties in very nicely to Sifo-Dyas' concerns that we see from the novel Darth Plagueis, wherein Sifo-Dyas saw dark times ahead but there being no army to defend the Republic, thus making the Clone Army necessary. Great stuff Union and I appreciate you taking the time to watch and comment.
@MWH12085
@MWH12085 8 лет назад
yea, what could possibly go wrong?
@akeiltheseal
@akeiltheseal 8 лет назад
In what book/comic/etc did the chancellor say this?
@CynUnion-ji9uj
@CynUnion-ji9uj 8 лет назад
ConspiracyNova it was a joke about how in Darth Bane Rule of Two, the senate passed the Ruusan reformations which resulted in the republic not having a military.
@SinerAthin
@SinerAthin 8 лет назад
Dude, such a scenario is entirely plausible and realistic :P Just look at optimistic real life politicians.
@BEZERKSTUDIOS718
@BEZERKSTUDIOS718 8 лет назад
...peace has cost you your strength, victory has defeated you...
@Jason-Skywalker
@Jason-Skywalker 8 лет назад
That's deep son.
@fusiontoa18
@fusiontoa18 8 лет назад
bane and darth bane man
@BEZERKSTUDIOS718
@BEZERKSTUDIOS718 8 лет назад
+fusiontoa18 lol, i don't know how i didn't think of that
@nicholsjoshua15
@nicholsjoshua15 8 лет назад
Peace sosa beat them, mesa beat them.Mesa be da greatest Sith Lord ever, Darth Jar Jar Binks.
@b1battledroidslivesmatter701
@b1battledroidslivesmatter701 6 лет назад
Frank Bowman ahh shut up ya dark side junkie.
@SifGreyfang
@SifGreyfang 8 лет назад
shorter version of this video: "because armor in the starwars universe is useless"
@dominiclabriola502
@dominiclabriola502 8 лет назад
If armor is useless than why do pretty much everybody else use armor? Stormtroopers, Clone Troopers, Madalorians.
@jameskalin5685
@jameskalin5685 8 лет назад
+Dominic Labriola because it looks cool and it's good for moral
@mksmike
@mksmike 8 лет назад
Ah, crap xD
@Poldovico
@Poldovico 8 лет назад
They still die in one shot from every weapon, so my guess is fashion. The only armor worth having in Star Wars is plot armor.
@roebuck476
@roebuck476 8 лет назад
+Poldovico cortosis, saber resistant and damn good lookin too.
@ThePalaeontologist
@ThePalaeontologist 8 лет назад
In short; **Jedi Order** : OK MOM I'LL STOP WEARING BATTLE ARMOUR GOSH
@Jaihso
@Jaihso 8 лет назад
Haha nice
@marissaward3003
@marissaward3003 8 лет назад
You fuking Jedi order.stop wearing armour.ideot.😠😡😠😡❎
@slenderman27490
@slenderman27490 8 лет назад
It's not a phase, mom!
@ThePalaeontologist
@ThePalaeontologist 8 лет назад
Marissa Gralton Gosh MOM first you complain about my mind tricks and now my battle armour! GOSH
@nicholsjoshua15
@nicholsjoshua15 8 лет назад
Also, stop using pistols and rifles, they're just too random. I brought a friend over to play with you, he looks like kind of like a fish thing; talks strange, is a little prone to accidents.
@SuperTweedles
@SuperTweedles 8 лет назад
Obi-wan Kenobi wore Full clone armor at the battle of Muunilinst in the orginal 2003 clone wars miniseries, and many jedi wore partial clone armor in the later series of the same name
@garrettdrudik5913
@garrettdrudik5913 8 лет назад
What I can't wrap my mind around is why they wore armor during the 2 miniseries' but back to robes in Revenge of the Sith. I get that the war was pretty much over by then, but it was actually still very much going on. And the old TCW leads right up to ROTS.
@103035icle
@103035icle 8 лет назад
+Garrett Drudik (gmansmith10) episode 3 seemed usualy to be where there not on a battlefield. in the series there on the battlefield for months at a time.
@jamesphillips4009
@jamesphillips4009 8 лет назад
For Obi-Wan and Anakin, not really so much need. But parts like Ki-Adi-Mundi's battle on Mygeeto would only have benefited from the armor, though it was only seconds long.
@103035icle
@103035icle 8 лет назад
James Phillips well it was only shwon. But a lot of thoes jedi had been on the battlefield for a long time.
@bebeaa100
@bebeaa100 8 лет назад
lets take a step back and look at the wrighters. they just goofed
@InweTaralom
@InweTaralom 8 лет назад
Why did the Jedi stop marrying and producing their own children; as well as taking children from their families for training. Why did they start the whole 'no attachment' deal? Why did they discourage their members from marrying, and what if a family doesn't want to give up their child? Would they take the child anyway?
@autotechxbox163
@autotechxbox163 8 лет назад
I am sure that the Jedi would simply use a force mind trick on the family especially if said child is very strong with the force.
@furycarnategaming
@furycarnategaming 8 лет назад
Attachment as Master Yoda said can lead to many darker emotions.. such as jealous, fear, anguish and even hatred. Just being force sensitive is seen abs consent by the being to be trained and just because two force sensitives produce children does not assure the offspring will be. For example two jedi wed and produce three offspring, two force sensitive and one...think of potential hatred that child could grow to harbor for their family.
@thadshaftrammer
@thadshaftrammer 8 лет назад
to make it simple, Imagine say the person you love most in the world and the child you had with him/her were brutally slaughtered. now imagine how a force sensitive person who's power can be affected by Anger, sadness and hatred. a very strong willed jedi could be down the road to the dark side. take Anakin and padme. he would even go to the dark just to keep her alive, and when she died, he went fucking mental
@spritecollcterFTW
@spritecollcterFTW 8 лет назад
By the time of the Clone Wars, Jedi were revered as galactic heroes with great power and morals. It was part of Republic culture to allow Jedi to take children for training as a Jedi, particularly on worlds in which Jedi played a major role, or performed heroic acts. In the Clone Wars tv series, there was a family that was more than happy to give their child to the Order and talked about how they felt this was the best for the child. The child would grow up into a mature, responsible citizen that actively does good. very few people turn a Jedi away, as they believe that not surrendering their child would be considered selfish considering all the good they would do. As or the marriage question, I believe it was a question of loyalty. The Jedi's ultimate loyalty was to the "Greater Good" by being the means of bringing peace and justice to all people. When a Jedi marries, they change their loyalties from the Greater Good to spouse, and offspring. not to mention that sometimes, (though rare) a spouse could lead that Jedi to the Dark Side by having selfish views. Lets say a stalwart Jedi marries a person that believes that Jedi should be a militant force that basically kills people who do not conform to Galactic norms. their perceptions could be changed from outside influence. Its similar to how Catholicism forbids Priests to marry.
@skynetprime82
@skynetprime82 8 лет назад
+[Anonymous] Retro I see your point and in turn understand the concept as well
@edwaiwood2416
@edwaiwood2416 8 лет назад
The simple answer is they spiraled down into a false sense of security, among other things the end.
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
I think you nailed it Ed. Darth Bane definitely played the con about as well as he could have. I hope you enjoyed the video.
@adamdemars3798
@adamdemars3798 8 лет назад
Just think almost 1000 years with out a single sight of a sith lord. I'd think we were safe as well
@coreycollins9620
@coreycollins9620 8 лет назад
emphasis on "sight"
@edwaiwood2416
@edwaiwood2416 8 лет назад
***** (Assuming your american too.) We thought we were safe being neutral in 1941, yet we still should have been ready for pearl harbor. If the Jedi train around the idea of self improvement they still should maintain readiness, and I know I'm not the only one who thinks the Jedi shouldn't have reformed especially not to meet republic political standards. The Jedi are their own state like the Vatican, they aren't or at least shouldn't be a branch of the republic. Maybe I'm not that well read but I don't recall the Jedi carrying ID or being considered republic citizens, maybe its implied but I don't recall any example. Whats the worst that could happen if they remain ever vigilant, they're kicked off Coruscant.
@adamdemars3798
@adamdemars3798 8 лет назад
Ed Waiwood Ya your right in almost every way
@MagpieR6
@MagpieR6 7 лет назад
I loved the old canon
@thomaskhan2933
@thomaskhan2933 6 лет назад
Joshua Collins If only Disney hadn't taken it away
@brieneaton6079
@brieneaton6079 8 лет назад
ill save you all 6 minutes, its because the writers changed lol
@JeanLucPicard85
@JeanLucPicard85 8 лет назад
So what about the Sith, why don't they wear armor? Surely not because of pacifistic ideals.
@Jason-Skywalker
@Jason-Skywalker 8 лет назад
That's what I was thinking. I suppose for some, it was to look more edgy and dark, and not to stick out like a sore thumb.
@Duchess_Van_Hoof
@Duchess_Van_Hoof 8 лет назад
This, it is because the sith became sneaky bastards using conspiracies, corruption and criminals instead of fighting an open war. Thus Palpatine mainly being a politician. But compare with Vader who basically wore armour.
@cyqry
@cyqry 8 лет назад
Except Vader didn't really get much of a choice about wearing his armour.
@JeanLucPicard85
@JeanLucPicard85 8 лет назад
Angryboy Afaik it's not even armor but a life support suit. Vader would die without it.
@cyqry
@cyqry 8 лет назад
Jean~Luc Picard That was kind of the point I was going for in the first place.
@thesnail89110
@thesnail89110 8 лет назад
Jedi didn't know Sith were alive since Bane and his rule of two. That's why Jedi didn't know they were alive. But Yoda knew that they were always two. Problem.. ?
@lordicewolfz
@lordicewolfz 8 лет назад
yes read the book darth pleageus it covers the events befor and during epsode 1 as darth plageus was palpatiens master and it also go into some detail aobut the grand plan of the sith
@garrettdrudik5913
@garrettdrudik5913 8 лет назад
I can save you 6 minutes by saying the Old Republic Jedi thought the Sith were destroyed after the Sith Wars and didn't think they needed to be militarized. Too bad you probably read this after already watching.
@HostileBurger
@HostileBurger 8 лет назад
What about Obiwan in the clone wars cartoon? (i havent finished the video, sorry if that comes up)
@TheDungeonMasterz
@TheDungeonMasterz 8 лет назад
+Matthewgh ikr
@HostileBurger
@HostileBurger 8 лет назад
Matthewgh Short attention span, bad short term memory too. Had to say it before the thought passed
@pvtryan72
@pvtryan72 8 лет назад
You're right he didn't mention that did he? I was thinking about it during the video and maybe it represented the Jedi returning to the militaristic form by becoming generals and commanders which was eventually a downfall of the order. idk thats just my thoughts.
@457falcon
@457falcon 8 лет назад
+ATLIS - Solis Music The downfall of the order was mostly complacency. They believed the sith had been wiped out and forgot the reason of their partial victory in the first place. They only began to re militarize when it was too late. Although they had begun to win in the clone wars sith sympathizers had infiltrated too much of the senate and the order. They were a thousand years too late.
@Kareszkoma
@Kareszkoma 8 лет назад
I don't know for sure, but Obi-Wan was always fore-seeing. He tried to be as resourceful as he could be, minimalize waste and be ready for everything. I think it's because of Darth Maul. Out of all the Jedi Masters, Obi-Wan doesn't seem to hold anyone as highly - not disrespectful - as he did with his master and Yoda. Seeing his master whom was a Grey Jedi and pretty op even in the Council, dead, I think he became a bit paranoic. Maybe he started thinking: If I was a little faster, better. If only we would've been a bit more ready. Out of all the characters in Clone Wars, he seems to be the most serious and thinking of the war. He says things like: The damage done to the farms will soon reach even the wealthiest, The people paid the price for what they didn't want, and etz. Like he is thinking not just what is now, but what will be after the war.
@electricpotroast8402
@electricpotroast8402 8 лет назад
Darth Bane was the biggest bad ass ever.
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
He was without a doubt a head of the game and set up the events post-Seventh Battle of Ruusan pretty flawlessly. Thank you for the support as always EP!
@Fishhunter2014
@Fishhunter2014 8 лет назад
Personally I'm a fan of Darth Nihilus. I mean he was basically a force ghost that ate people.
@nazaereth
@nazaereth 7 лет назад
Electric Potroast I'm willing to bet Revan can kick his butt
@alliemanning1485
@alliemanning1485 7 лет назад
Love how I can nerd binge on these vids, feels so good to have a Star Wars channel to come home when you start missing the franchise.
@electricpotroast8402
@electricpotroast8402 8 лет назад
The death of the bouncer La was Darth Zannah's (then called Rain) first step towards the dark side. She was very angry at the two jedi that killed the bouncer and so she destroyed them with her mind using the force. Which impressed Darth Bane and cause him to take her on as his apprentice.
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
I remember reading that and thinking that it was a pretty cool introduction to Darth Zannah (then Rain). Darth Bane probably made the right choice for his apprentice after that.
@DARTHBLUNT713
@DARTHBLUNT713 5 лет назад
Exactly so true
@ibeurjesuzzzzXD
@ibeurjesuzzzzXD 8 лет назад
KHAAAN!!... Oh wait. Wrong franchise.
@Dynomafia139
@Dynomafia139 8 лет назад
ok
@Dynomafia139
@Dynomafia139 8 лет назад
ok
@a.morphous66
@a.morphous66 6 лет назад
HERETI- wait, wrong franchise again.
@joshbetancourt4070
@joshbetancourt4070 5 лет назад
Lol silly
@oZ_BlaZe
@oZ_BlaZe 8 лет назад
You're so good at explaining stuff. So coherent and clean. Love your videos.
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
I really appreciate that oZ Blaze, it is great to hear that you enjoy them. Thank you very much for the support (it definitely goes a long way!) and I hope you enjoy the upcoming videos as well.
@chase1146
@chase1146 8 лет назад
the way i see it, if you have a weapon like a lightsaber that could cut through almost anything, why waste time on armor that would just slow your down and offer no gain in battle?
@Den-lt2mc
@Den-lt2mc 8 лет назад
to not die from some lucky punk with a blaster?
@chase1146
@chase1146 8 лет назад
denman wolftamer even in rebels they said armor does jack shit, and besides if their jedi they can deflect blaster bolts like they are nothing
@ayleidking5251
@ayleidking5251 8 лет назад
Light Sabers can cut through almost anything but for those rare occasions were there exist more than almost anything such as in the case of those individuals who use Mandalorian Iron, Song Steel, Neuranium, Ultrachrome, Phrik, and the most common of them all Cortosis used by Darth Vader and the Inquisitors. In Star Wars Rebels: The Siege of Lothal Sabine Wren is hit with 4 direct blaster bolts that would have killed a person not wearing Durasteel Mandalorian armor, so armor does do "jack shit". If they are Jedi they can deflect most blaster bolts they see coming, if they did not expect to be shot at, some times Jedi can be caught off guard like what happened to Aayla Secura with her clone troopers. Then there is the situation were the Jedi is completely surrounded and is not fast enough to block every blaster bolt fired at him or her. There has been on some rare occasions in which a blasterfighter is skilled enough to out do or over load a Jedi's enhanced reflexes Cad Bane has managed this more than once.
@Den-lt2mc
@Den-lt2mc 8 лет назад
and don't forgot a wound vs a kill. even basic clone armor could probably turn a death shot into a dangerous one. and a dangerous one less so. it's the same principle we use in the real world with body armor.
@henningratjen4364
@henningratjen4364 8 лет назад
Ist not Durasteel. The typical armor of the mandalorians is made of mandalorian Iron
@suremaine
@suremaine 8 лет назад
I always look forward to the dry humor in every video lol
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
That is so awesome to hear and I appreciate you taking the time to let me know. It is great to hear that you enjoy that part as well. Thank you for the support and I hope you enjoy the upcoming videos.
@ScarletEdge
@ScarletEdge 8 лет назад
I concur.
@darthorder6804
@darthorder6804 8 лет назад
OBI WAN wore a Battle Armor during the Clone Wars
@erikthomsen4768
@erikthomsen4768 8 лет назад
Darth Order, it was still an war.
@michaeldavis4651
@michaeldavis4651 8 лет назад
Am I the only one who thinks it makes very little sense for Clone Wars Jedi not to wear armor on their torsos? I can't remember ever seeing a Jedi with chest armor; yet, most people (especially in a universe with excellent prosthetic limbs) would be more worried about taking shrapnel in the chest rather than in the arms or legs. I like to think that, if I were in that situation, I would wear a full set of armor. It just seems more sensible since your not exactly going to be able to deflect every single blaster bolt or piece of shrapnel that flies your way.
@joshuav8061
@joshuav8061 8 лет назад
I just wantes to let you know that your videos are awesome. The info given is something you could hardly get anywhere else. The points you make are fantastic, and on top of it your dry humor is hilarious. You deserve more subs, and please keep making these awesome videos. Thank you, SWRC!
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
Thank you very much for your very generous comment Joshua! It is great that you are enjoying the informational and the humourous sides of the videos and I greatly appreciate the support. Thank you again.
@Azqalihm
@Azqalihm 8 лет назад
"And so Obi-wan and Yoda went into hiding exile, wearing their galaxy-wide known attire." It's one of the dumbest things that these clothes became canon back in the day.
@ryan7266
@ryan7266 8 лет назад
why didnt the Jedi readopt the battle armor during the clone wars since there were acting generals of a military force?
@intergalactichumanempire9759
@intergalactichumanempire9759 8 лет назад
Ryan G. They did wear armor in 2003, but they were first and foremost peacekeepers
@suremaine
@suremaine 8 лет назад
I know you have tons of videos and ideas lined up but....would you consider making a video about a few non-canon stories that should still be considered canon because they would have virtually no affect on current canon? I mean, I'm sure they're tons of em but I want to hear your favorites.
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
Sure, that sounds like a great idea suremaine as I have a handful that I think could make it into a video such as that. I always appreciate the suggestions, so thanks for that!
@suremaine
@suremaine 8 лет назад
+Star Wars Reading Club Thanks for responding dawg, I appreciate people who do so.
@ethanmerritt1936
@ethanmerritt1936 8 лет назад
the force unleashed 1 and 2 are great examples!
@johnroshak3107
@johnroshak3107 8 лет назад
For some reason I just really like your sense of humor and your voice I might be in a minority here but I personally really like the way you talk.
@joshfactor1
@joshfactor1 8 лет назад
it's probably for the best when you think about it. i mean it would probably be much more expensive to cosplay in battle armor than in jedi robes
@markvicferrer
@markvicferrer 8 лет назад
The relevant info is from 4:26 to 6:20. The rest was just rambling. Some info about the Ruusan reformation is good, but you have to stay topical to the question you're trying to answer.
@intergalactichumanempire9759
@intergalactichumanempire9759 8 лет назад
Mark Ferrer Thanks
@entertainmentcentral7403
@entertainmentcentral7403 7 лет назад
ty
@brotatochimp
@brotatochimp 8 лет назад
but like...armor and castles are cool though.
@arlindonascimento6062
@arlindonascimento6062 7 лет назад
and yet jedi like rahm kota exist
@taejo4975
@taejo4975 6 лет назад
Arlindo Nascimento *A wild Disney appears to destroy Star Wars*
@alwaysfallingshort
@alwaysfallingshort 7 лет назад
This was one of the things I really appreciate in the Red Letter Media review: I never thought Jedi wore the hermit robes Obi Wan was wearing. Making that the official garb of Jedi seemed lazy even to my younger self. My vision of Jedi before the NT was space knights, not orange salesmen.
@katiepersons6575
@katiepersons6575 8 лет назад
Another reason for their discarding of armor may have had to do with the blatant lack of protection afforded against blasters, lightsabers and explosives. Basically everything, really.
@nicktayler2046
@nicktayler2046 8 лет назад
some Jedi had armor that could block blaster bolts and lightsabers
@katiepersons6575
@katiepersons6575 8 лет назад
Cortosis weave. But you were a world class jedi/sith to have that. The rank and file did not.
@nicktayler2046
@nicktayler2046 8 лет назад
Katie Persons no that stuff blocks light sabers the armor that they had could block some blaster bolts not all but some
@donleonsroszavilla5734
@donleonsroszavilla5734 8 лет назад
There are different grades of metal/ ceramic armor that can be used in infrantry personal armor. In the Roll playing Games " R.P.G." it is called Item Hardness and Damage Wound points, = giga jules of impact pressure. Lots of neat picking, debating, and arguements. but hear is the basic of it. Most armor only stops Glacing Hits and not Direct Hits. If the armor could stop a Soild direct hit, there no way it will be able to stop rapid fire in the same 4 square inch location. Your armor may stop a stander 0.5kilogram granade if you have full body protection, but it will not stop a 2kilogram/ 4 lb pine apple.
@nicktayler2046
@nicktayler2046 8 лет назад
DonLeons Roszavilla um wait im confused why did you write this big ol comment for a topic that was already corrected?
@wiibrockster
@wiibrockster 6 лет назад
It wasn't the Jedi's smartest moment when they stopped wearing Battle Armour. I mean The Sith had been defeated before and they had returned before like after The Great Hyperspace War, The Jedi assumed The Sith had been wiped out but thousands of years later they were rediscovered by Revan and Malak and Centuries later The Great Galactic War happened and look what that did to the Republic, It forced them into The Cold War with The Sith Empire. It was a foolish move if you asked me, they pretty much assumed the Sith were extinct and set themselves up for defeat if you ask me.
@genkenobi
@genkenobi 8 лет назад
Luke should bring back battle armor in episode 8
@ancientsithlord3314
@ancientsithlord3314 8 лет назад
Yea battle armor looks way cooler and I like your name
@Rogue.Templar30
@Rogue.Templar30 8 лет назад
Their other big mistake was allowing a political office to have influence over them. Surely someone at the reform would have seen how badly that could go! The Jedi were more powerful, and better off, when they were individual councils which met now and again to discuss bigger issues.
@dyamiroman3494
@dyamiroman3494 8 лет назад
Congratulations on almost 8,000 subs! It's great to see your channel growing so fast and I look forward to more content in the future.
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
I always appreciate your support and encourage Dyami, and I hope you enjoy the videos upcoming in the future.
@juliansmit3770
@juliansmit3770 7 лет назад
He has 63000 now
@mattcarner1762
@mattcarner1762 8 лет назад
Loved the intro to the video. As a mandalorian fan, count me as a proud member of your rebellion's forces, ner vod! also, I've always kinda wondered about this, so thanks.
@lieutenantnomad9198
@lieutenantnomad9198 7 лет назад
Also the armor was heavy and doesn't protect against lightsabers.
@dreamingflurry2729
@dreamingflurry2729 6 лет назад
Well, didn't Obi-Wan wear armor sometimes in the Clone Wars show? Also: Wasn't it up the the individual what they wear? I mean Anakin wore black robes and Ahsoka Tano and Aayla Secura didn't wear robes at all normally! ps: I wouldn't go without armor - not for blaster bolts (that's what you have a lightsaber and force-absord for (what Vader used against Han Solo's blaster shots in "The Empire Strikes Back")), but in order not to be cut to pieces...Cortosis is great against lightsabers after all :)
@elliejohnson2786
@elliejohnson2786 8 лет назад
Then why haven't they STARTED wearing armour again? I mean, it's quite obvious the Sith are back, but i haven't seen any Jedi wear armour...
@Longshanks_
@Longshanks_ 8 лет назад
Obi Wan in the Clone Wars wears bits and pieces of clone armor.
@nickthebrony1298
@nickthebrony1298 8 лет назад
+Axzack probably because he's the only smart one
@KingdomOfDimensions
@KingdomOfDimensions 8 лет назад
Some of the Jedi, including Kenobi and Skywalker, wear armor during The Clone Wars show. It's modified storm-trooper armor IIRC.
@Jason-Skywalker
@Jason-Skywalker 8 лет назад
I think that some of them wear armor because they know they need some, but they don't wear full body armor, because they know that would slow them down and ruin their agility.
@elliejohnson2786
@elliejohnson2786 8 лет назад
Jason Skywalker Jedi armour: +50 Armour -12 Agility
@Dr.Cosmar
@Dr.Cosmar 2 года назад
Because Disney cannon isn't cannon. That's why I watch your stuff. There is a big flaw in this though. Not every Jedi of that age could have been "ok" with giving up their armor, and foregoing any military endeavors. No matter the principle, no matter the creed, no people are that united. Especially since the Jedi expanded considerably on recruitment efforts during the Sith wars. I would find it hard to believe they only chose children and trained them from a young age. That would be impractical if you needed a fighting force soon and ample fresh bodies.
@Ryulin18
@Ryulin18 8 лет назад
Please stop roleplaying your character in your videos.
@happymikasa7226
@happymikasa7226 8 лет назад
If you don't like it, then simply skip that part.
@LordHypnos4
@LordHypnos4 8 лет назад
Its confusing
@xxedgy_outsiderxx9978
@xxedgy_outsiderxx9978 7 лет назад
whiners
@thatlegoclone515
@thatlegoclone515 7 лет назад
what do u even mean?
@ariesstorm9577
@ariesstorm9577 8 лет назад
Even the reformed Sith swapped armour for cloaks (I think Darth Plagueis says something along those lines to Darth Sidious). I would have liked to have seen Anakin wearing armour similar to Darth Vader's suit in revenge of the Sith. Black Jedi tunic similar to Luke's from ROTJ but with the Darth chest piece, black gauntlets and the black cloak (at least that's how I envision him in an alternative Episode III) If it's any consolation my non-canon friend, I too have lost one of my all time favourite characters to this new canon: Darth Krayt. May the Dark Lord rule over the lesser beings in Chaos until the day he defies all canon and resurrects himself once again
@DeepbloodFang
@DeepbloodFang 8 лет назад
This is why I never sided with the Jedi, they are fools.
@mkrump9403
@mkrump9403 8 лет назад
you must be a fool to looking the lights.
@DeepbloodFang
@DeepbloodFang 8 лет назад
***** No, it doesn't, which is why I didn't justify it with a reply.
@mkrump9403
@mkrump9403 8 лет назад
What's opposite of darkness is the light... The force is the light... It might be too nerdy for you.
@DeepbloodFang
@DeepbloodFang 8 лет назад
M krump it's not the concept that confuses me, it's your wording. The force is the force, both Sith and Jedi use the force. So no, the force isn't the "light".
@mkrump9403
@mkrump9403 8 лет назад
DeepbloodFang I understand your confusion. I like your honesty.
@louiscurd
@louiscurd 7 лет назад
What's with Thrawn in loads of your videos? I'm new to your channel so I don't know if you have explained it before, I'm guessing he is your favourite character?! So far, I'm liking the channel, keep it up:)
@drfate7863
@drfate7863 8 лет назад
That was a fatal mistake.
@clintarmstrong2546
@clintarmstrong2546 8 лет назад
One of my favorite youtube channels of all the 9 years I've used this site. Keep it up friend
@MWH12085
@MWH12085 8 лет назад
well, hindsight is 20-20. Probably would've been very helpful during the Clone Wars.
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
Good point MWH. Have to give it to Darth Bane for how well he played this one.
@MWH12085
@MWH12085 8 лет назад
+Star Wars Reading Club should've either kept the militarized Jedi Order or the Republic military. Getting rid of both ended up causing a very turbulent 1000 years.
@JosephDragunov
@JosephDragunov 8 лет назад
Obi-Wan wore armor.
@mastersyfodiaz
@mastersyfodiaz 8 лет назад
His armor was little more than shoulder pads and gauntlets. Edit: My bad, forgot about the Season 5 armor. Disregard.
@GIAP11977
@GIAP11977 8 лет назад
hold on. wouldn't an armor made of mirrors make you practically invulnerable in the star wars universe. well i mean besides vibroblades and trandoshian shotguns
@greatkingdavid9717
@greatkingdavid9717 8 лет назад
Keep them coming guys i love this channel
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
Thank you so much for the kind words of support KDP! It definitely means a lot and it is greatly appreciated. I hope you enjoy the upcoming videos.
@frankg2790
@frankg2790 8 лет назад
I love how this video started with you roleplaying as Admiral Thrawn. He was my favorite Expanded Universe character and it was a shame that they chose him go, but there are rumors that he will reappear in the Star Wars canon, albeit under a different name.
@sekouhicks3974
@sekouhicks3974 8 лет назад
+Frank G he is
@joaquin5541
@joaquin5541 7 лет назад
Frank G well hes back
@LotsOfThoughts
@LotsOfThoughts 4 года назад
How to make the old canon actually canon again: Starve Disney of your money until the property gets sold or something.
@daemonvelaryon5617
@daemonvelaryon5617 7 лет назад
The jedi are too peaceful and constantly leave themselves open.
@LightStreak567
@LightStreak567 6 лет назад
The Exile Luke pointed that out to Rey in Episode 8.
@b1battledroidslivesmatter701
@b1battledroidslivesmatter701 6 лет назад
The Exile and it makes them dark side junkies so damn cocky
@NextGenerationUmmah
@NextGenerationUmmah 6 лет назад
Cause when you have armor KWOTOR restricts a lot of force powers
@DBringmann
@DBringmann 8 лет назад
in all of the star wars movies armor dos not do shit...... battledriods are cut to scraps by lightsabers and stormtroopers go down when hit once despite wearing armor.... to that we can add that jedies can parry shots fired at them with ease with their lightsabers....so why would they wear some armor instead of nice robes??
@happymikasa7226
@happymikasa7226 8 лет назад
Ever heard cortosis? I'm pretty sure the battle armour was made from that.
@DBringmann
@DBringmann 8 лет назад
Kaleb Hernandez no sorry for me it is just about the star wars movies as i said in my post...if you happen to know the stats and armor saves for the storm trooper armor i am happy for you :) everyone that gets hit in the movies goes down, or loses a limb, so the armor is more or less pretty useless :)
@103035icle
@103035icle 8 лет назад
uh. a lightsaber is plasma. do you know how hot plasma is? theres very few material in the world that wouldent instantly melt from contact with it.
@mustekkala
@mustekkala 8 лет назад
It is actually quite puzzling why nothing seems to be made from light saber resistant materials in the movies even though there are many materials like that in the universe, i mean not even villains that expect to fight Jedis never use any.
@Poldovico
@Poldovico 8 лет назад
Because the original trilogy films were made before the then-nonexistent expanded universe ever invented lightsaber resistant materials. The prequels did it because they were crap.
@gabrielthomison1504
@gabrielthomison1504 8 лет назад
The Old Republic Jedi armor is badass. I wish just at least one person in the Clone Wars could wear it.
@daniellewis8813
@daniellewis8813 7 лет назад
Your videos are great but can you please stop showing that blue empire general it's confusing and annoying but other than that your videos are great
@Nitrobolt-ff5zf
@Nitrobolt-ff5zf 6 лет назад
They probably stopped wearing it because robes are lighter than armor, and peace keepers shouldn't look like they are ready to start a battle.
@christopheraaron1255
@christopheraaron1255 8 лет назад
did that really require so long a video? all you did was repeat jedi battle armour, new sith war and militarism over and over.
@maxwoods6547
@maxwoods6547 8 лет назад
Thank you for these awesome videos, it is very fun for me to learn more about Star Wars. :)
@Lawrence_Talbot
@Lawrence_Talbot 4 года назад
Omg I love your intro and your Passion to restore what is no longer canon
@Kal-El_was_taken
@Kal-El_was_taken 8 лет назад
I swear, if I hear "Ruse & Reformation" one more time in the next week it'll be way to sson
@lucifersapprentice
@lucifersapprentice 8 лет назад
I felt the reason they stopped wearing their armor was to appear peaceful and less intimidating. Even if Jedi armour didn't have spikes or jagged points to it, ithe armour may still freighten sum of the people they try to help. Then you may have sum people think of a Jedi wearing battle armour as a contradiction to them being keepers of the peace.
@starwarsreadingclub
@starwarsreadingclub 8 лет назад
I think you make a great point LA. The switch away from battle armor was definitely a representation of their overall shift in philosophy for sure. The fact that they thought the Sith were destroyed really contributed to them making some bad decisions. But like you said, changing to the role of peacekeepers made it very difficult to still wear the battle armor. Thank you for the support LA, I hope you enjoy the future videos as well.
@lucifersapprentice
@lucifersapprentice 8 лет назад
Star Wars Reading Club Dude keep them coming.
@lucifersapprentice
@lucifersapprentice 8 лет назад
***** You would think that. But I believe they didn’t because of the image they wanted to present. While practical it would still conflict with their ideology.
@meurum2561
@meurum2561 7 лет назад
Lucifers Apprentice that's why the Jedi were so weak. They gave up any power they originally had. So many Jedi were killed because all they had was a light saber. They never even considered new sith could rise. Gosh they tried so hard to keep a reputation as peace keepers they were foolishly allowing themselves to be killed or letting evil people live simply because their Jedi beliefs prevented it. In season 4 when the slavers were overturned on Obi wan didn't kill the warden because he was unarmed even though the guy murdered countless innocents(luckily Rex wasn't a Jedi &I killed him). That right there is why the Jedi were so weak and foolish. And their own arrogance is what brought upon their downfall.
@theabominablesnowman1711
@theabominablesnowman1711 8 лет назад
I'm sorry, but I just don't understand why so many people are upset about the de-canonization of the EU..
@craycejedi
@craycejedi 8 лет назад
Because alot of it is pretty well written. There are a few things I didn't like particularly in the New Jedi Order era, but there were alot of cool characters and good storylines. I particularly liked all the Old Republic stuff as I liked seeing the Jedi in their heyday. Not sure if Disney has de-canonized Old Republic stuff but I think I'll decide for myself what's canon and not. I don't need some faceless megacorp telling me what did and didn't happen in one of my favorite fiction universes.
@Fat_Panda_Gamer
@Fat_Panda_Gamer 8 лет назад
Last I heard, The Old Republic was still canon because it takes place 3k years before the movies. I can't recall were I was reading that so don't take much stock in it.
@BFjordsman
@BFjordsman 8 лет назад
because Chewie died saving Anikan Solo fulfilling his life debt. then Han had to live with that loss. (Disney)- emo Kylo kills Han
@naz_deante5795
@naz_deante5795 8 лет назад
+craycejedi exactly
@SwarthyD
@SwarthyD 4 года назад
Anybody else get chills when he says, “expose”?
@DarthDregan
@DarthDregan 8 лет назад
Simple, the Jedi are keepers of the peace. Not soldiers. The Jedi have been the protectors of peace and justice sin the foundation of the republic. During the time of Darth Bane, the Army of Light was created to fight the Brotherhood of Darkness. When the war was over, the Senate made the decision to dissolve the Army so the Jedi became peace keepers again. It was the Clone Wats that gave them the military ranks again. At this point, some of the Jedi took armor again to protect themselves in battle.
@taejo4975
@taejo4975 6 лет назад
DarthDregan but very few Jedi wear it
@Lawdensky
@Lawdensky 8 лет назад
Oooooorr... They realized that lightsabers can penetrate anything and blasters can go through armor. Much in the same way soldiers (1600s+) stopped using heavy metal armors because bullets can easily pierce them. Therefore they went with mobility instead of armoring. Ergo, jedi jump around a lot instead of standing and taking a hit.
@flyingflyer9506
@flyingflyer9506 8 лет назад
Clone armor protects from fire so they can take a couple of shots
@kuriousitykat
@kuriousitykat 8 лет назад
I imagine any armour in age of laser pulsers/blasters would have to be ablative, but ablative armour would only be good for a few direct hits in one spot as it boil away so wearers would have to be very mobile, mobilty requires lighter/thinner armour. More ablation means heavier armour so you would have two classes light & heavy infantry. Jedi favouring mobility would tend to lighter armour to protect from lucky shots or shots from behind when fully engaged to front. Empire relying firstly on expendable clones then later 'peasant' conscripts went for medium armour with clones (although clone commanders seemed to have better/heavy armour), then lighter armour as they expanded their forces to mass conscripts. Also tactics of mass infantry stormtroopers was full frontal bitzkrieg/human wave attack where ST's in front rank would suffer multiple fire into front until they all fell or swarmed their opponents. Armour is not so bad in the duel/slash style of one-on-one combat one Jedi Vs one Sith but in massed mano e mano battle fighting roman style ie stab not slash armour becomes useless.
@madsam9403
@madsam9403 7 лет назад
Anyway armoured Jedi would suck
@innoutfan
@innoutfan 8 лет назад
Christianity and the Jedi had a reformation. But we are still waiting on that Islam reformation
@edsr164
@edsr164 5 лет назад
Michael Martin Don’t, reformations are always followed by a surge in militantism. We need not more fervent militant Muslims
@definitelynotafamousyoutub6131
@definitelynotafamousyoutub6131 4 года назад
Becuse now they have plot armor
@HostileBurger
@HostileBurger 8 лет назад
You've gone up about 3,000 subs in a few months, i think
@CarlosFlores-ng1fi
@CarlosFlores-ng1fi 7 лет назад
Havent watch the video but im sure it cause they have fucking laser swords for weapons and a piece of armor wouldnt do shit but slow them down.
@MyYouTube30335
@MyYouTube30335 7 лет назад
carlos Flores made me laugh, thanks :)
@CommanderLVJ1
@CommanderLVJ1 8 лет назад
That was so wrong in so many ways...;/
@TJDious
@TJDious 2 года назад
Tarsus Valorum was a serious dong.
@AaronDarkus
@AaronDarkus 6 лет назад
How much battle armor limits you in terms of movement?, because according to old games like Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic, battle armor causes that the jedi can´t use (or use properly) force powers or abilities like speed, jump or drain, for mentioning some examples.
@dhamilton707
@dhamilton707 8 лет назад
Hoping to see some awesome jedi armor reemerge in future films. Also they absolutely should make a film if not series of films built around KOTOR. Story, characters, relationships and the planets they can showcase are def worthy of the big screen
@klyanadkmorr
@klyanadkmorr 8 лет назад
But they pulled them out from ,mothballs again during the CLONE WARS. why didn 't you go on to explain that little blip of their return to military action?
@Tyriale
@Tyriale 8 лет назад
Have there ever been Dark Side users that drew not from negative emotions, but positive ones. Jedi are trained early to renounce much just like monks. Like Kyle Katarn, who saw Force abilities as ambiguous, were there others?
@OzzyRampage
@OzzyRampage 8 лет назад
wow, you're totally not bitter about the EU being thrown out for the Disney-JJ-verse. Its ok he did it to Star trek too... Im also not bitter at all also.
@jasonneaves7638
@jasonneaves7638 8 лет назад
You're Canadian aren't you?
@timerdudestephens1
@timerdudestephens1 8 лет назад
You did amazing job make that video I wish my sun crusher two videos be amazing show sun crusher art and inside of Star Wars Jedi academy trilogy novel and top 3 stormtrooper types that never exist show acid trooper,carbonite trooper and cave trooper that never existed can you do history of sith trooper video or why sith trooper not in galactic empire era video !?
@JJoh4040
@JJoh4040 8 лет назад
**"WHY did jedi stop wearing battle armor?"** the jedi became weak pacifists mama milk drinkers who thought it was wrong to fight war then revan shows up and redefines the paradime and then some idiot changed it back to the the way it was before revan thats why EVERY jedi was nerfed and weakened when darth vador shows up and why the jedi were annihilated when the emperor conquered the galaxy when the exile and revan where taken prisoner by the emperor and THAT'S WHY the jedi DO NOT USE the same amount as force powers as they can EASILY command in "legends(EU)" like stasis field, why the jedi stopped using double bladed lightsabors and started that "to become a jedi master you DO NOT need to know how to fight but rather have a VERY good understanding of the jedi way or just be wise or have" nonsense which is why jedi masters are fodderized and can EASILY be killed by 20 storm troopers but gelen marek(the force unleashed) can EASILY one shot entire armies with a force field explosion and force push. ALSO shaak ti was EASILY killed with an anakin skywalker WHILE she mediatated and COULD NOT SENSE ANAKINS EVIL INTENTIONS OF ASSASSINATING HER OR HOW HE JUST BUTCHERED A COMPANY OF KIDS! The jedi when palpatine showed up were WEAK and NERFED, notice NON of the evil sith attacked the jedi when they wore battle armor or were battle trained
@igorthelight
@igorthelight 7 лет назад
4:25 - Explaining itself.
@amaxwell7333
@amaxwell7333 4 года назад
A sith are Democrats and the Jedi are Republican.
@shamrock141
@shamrock141 3 года назад
You'd like to think that wouldn't you
@Efreeti
@Efreeti 8 лет назад
One sentence TL;DR: They thought the Sith were dead so they stopped, but they goofed tho as Darth Bane was still chillin'.
@VladSuperKat
@VladSuperKat 8 лет назад
They stopped using battle armor because armor is expensive to make and it would have broken the budget :))
@sunjetzu
@sunjetzu 8 лет назад
Didn't obi won wear armor during the clone wars. didn't anakin wear it too?
@Turd_Rocket
@Turd_Rocket 7 лет назад
The reason Obi-Wan wore robes was because he lived in a desert. The reason Yoda wore robes was because he made them from hemp-like plants on the shitty planet he was living on. Uncle Owen wore a robe too. Does that make him a Jedi? The prequels were just utter shit written by someone with the mind of a 7 year-old. "Oh, the only Jedi we saw in the original trilogy wore robes. That must be how all Jedi always dressed, all the time. Next plot detail!" (This is also wrong. Luke didn't wear robes after he became a Jedi. He wore a, like, cape thing, once. Surprise! Jedi CAN wear something other than robes.) This pandering to justify idiocy and bad writing is just sad.
@PandemoniumVice
@PandemoniumVice 8 лет назад
Hmm... With Luke going back to the first Jedi temple and exploring their history, I wonder if he'll return them to their more militaristic ways? With the First Order being out there now, and the Sith gone, but replaced by whatever Snoke is doing, it might be a good idea. They aren't going to be dealing with a *ahem* phantom menace, but a large open menace that will probably include an entire division of Dark Side Force users. Obviously none of this is canon anymore currently, but there's no telling what they might bring in from Legends. I, personally, would love to see the return of Jedi Lords and their Commander in Chief. If episode 9 reveals some of these old practices, I might actually... umm.... Yeah, no, I'll not be so crass in this comment section. I'll leave it up to your imagination. I've always loved Star Wars, though I've only started learning about all the expanded universe stuff in the past couple years. The Jedi were actually pretty damn cool at one point. I mean, I've always liked them, but they just seemed like space hippies with swords.
@Petaurista13
@Petaurista13 7 лет назад
They ever did? Kota wears armor same as Obi-Wan and Anakin in Clone Wars. And that was end of Old Jedi Order. Anyway I think reason was simple. Both lightsaber and blaster bolts could pierce armor unless it's lightsaber-proof and those were rare and expensive. So armors were just waste of flexibility. I know most of them were made to give fliexibility, but ANY extra weight and extra, thick layer of clothes makes you less agile and lex flexible.
@Giarcnek
@Giarcnek 8 лет назад
Isn't 'Vanity' one of the Earth religious zealots "Deadly sins?" I think I would have been a 'Dark Jedi'. A. Skywalker was spot on with his view that the 'Jedi Order' were a bunch of hypocrites. The hypocrisy of the Jedi Order knew no bounds. "Cheers!"
@Nsinger998
@Nsinger998 7 лет назад
So basically, The Jedi were once much like European Knightly orders(Teutons, Hospitallers, ect) with significant holdings and temporal power. However, Instead of a powerful Jedi Lord declaring himself king and founding a kingdom as some real life orders did(Livonian order into Livonia) the Jedi instead chose to give all that up and become more like eastern orders of fighting monks.
@wills9108
@wills9108 8 лет назад
Cortosis ore can be used in armour against light sabers, it deflects the energy of the light saber beam back into itself, creating a feedback that overloads the beam, it also can disperse other energy strikes such as blaster bolts, & there is canon of dark side force users using this & similar armour against jedi. (INFO FROM WOOKIEEPEDIA)
@clarity2199
@clarity2199 8 лет назад
Your video's are informative, but the pictures you offer have something to be desired. It really has little to no significance with what you are talking about. Showing random pictures of Jedi and Sith don't offer anything. You should at least put 'some' pictures in that represent the topic of what you're talking about at that time. That would a great deal to hear 'and' visualize it. And yes, I know....you're talking about Jedi and Sith. But showing a gigantic close up of one's face for the first minute just makes me want to turn off the vid. :P
@dazdavis7896
@dazdavis7896 6 лет назад
Bane Is still canon dude, He wasn't "murdered" per se. He was created by Lucas himself when he was doing the backstory and history of the galaxy and event leading up to Ep1. Him destroying the Sith order and building them back up far stronger and implementing the rule of 2 is all completely canon..... Most of the content that took place before that, wasn't really ever canon in the first place. Only the Bane era and event leading up to Ep1, up to ROTJ. The canon expanded content mostly all fell only within that time period. There was some old republic content before the Bane era that was considered canon, but not much. And especially nothing from the post-Ep6 content. Literally NONE of that was ever canon content at any point in time to begin with. Lucas did a segment with AMC to clarify exactly that and confirm that none of the post-ROTJ content was ever canon for ppl that couldn't accept what they were told before...... Like I said, He was mostly referring directly to the stuff after ROTJ, but it includes a lot of the old republic content too. Only some was ever canon in the first place..... Again, that all comes straight from Lucas himself. It does not matter what Leland Chee or anybody else at all said on the matter, if Lucas said otherwise, then it didn't matter what they said at all. www.amc.com/talk/2008/03/george-lucas-th
@domvasta
@domvasta 7 лет назад
So you're the non-canon expert, I assume you know lots about the Proton torpedo launchers on Imperial and Rebel spacecraft, but not much about their turbo lasers turrets... You know? non-"Cannon" expert, haha get it? I'll see myself out.
@whismerhilll
@whismerhilll 8 лет назад
in KotOR, jedi wore armor and/or robes... 4,000 years before the rise of the Galactic Empire. Screw this canon,legend and expanded univers crap. And episodes I,II and III.
@matman000000
@matman000000 6 лет назад
The fan answer: A 10-page analysis of the history of the Jedi Order, drawing from movies, books and speculations. The real answer: Lucas didn't think about it.
@todkarlson1142
@todkarlson1142 8 лет назад
How about the OBVIOUS? If a light saber will cut through the armor with little to no resistance, why wear it? It's the same reason suits of armor ceased to be used on Earth: bullets pass right through, so why spend lots of money on something that's just going to encumber you? The body armor we're now wearing can stop bullets, but when blasters that go right through it are invented, today's body armor will be obsolete as well.
@Nilonimir
@Nilonimir 8 лет назад
Wow. just wow. if I thought the Jedi had problems before, now I know where it started. Though some of it isn't so dumb, but maybe they could have had a loophole for placing themselves under government oversight. Because damn.
@wilhufftarkin8543
@wilhufftarkin8543 8 лет назад
Aaaah, true Star Wars! That feels good! I'm tired of all this DisCanon stuff appearing all over RU-vid. I think I'm going to start reading EU books again...
@enes8k9
@enes8k9 8 лет назад
Listening to this reminded me how Bioware is awesome. By that i mean how they created a universe with KOTOR 1 that is far better than the movies (for me personally)...and then Obsidian with KOTOR 2. Kreia is one of the best written characters in the star wars universe. Don't know how to feel about the TOR mmo, do you play it?
Далее
Why More Jedi Didn't Use Double-Bladed Lightsabers
11:17
How Did the Grand Inquisitor Fall to the Dark Side?
4:59
Grey Jedi Explained
7:32
Просмотров 1,5 млн
What Happened to Jedi Who Failed the Jedi Trials?
6:17
AN ORDER WORSE THAN ORDER 66? - Star wars
4:11
Просмотров 6 млн
The Most Powerful Ancient Sith
6:39
Просмотров 1,5 млн
Why Yoda Chose Dagobah For Exile
8:04
Просмотров 446 тыс.