Тёмный

Why these two Steve Jobs biopics are not the same 

Elliot Roberts
Подписаться 117 тыс.
Просмотров 698 тыс.
50% 1

Apple co-founder Steve Jobs has been the subject of two major films:
'Steve Jobs' is by Aaron Sorkin/Danny Boyle and stars Michael Fassbender. Despite few people seeing this film I have long thought that it is a brilliant and underrated take on the biopic genre.
The other movie it 'jOBS,' starring Ashton Kutcher and is representative of everything wrong with modern biopics.
↓↓↓↓ PLEASE CONSIDER SUPPORTING ME ON PATREON ↓↓↓↓
Patreon: / elliotroberts
Instagram: / elliotroberts
Twitter: / elliotroberts5
Letterboxd: letterboxd.com/elliotroberts
Subscribe if you enjoyed this video.
CHAPTERS:
0:00 - Intro
6:20 - Part 1 | Structure
14:43 - Part 2 | Look & Sound
22:00 - Part 3 | Accuracy
27:38 - Part 4 | Performances
39:09 - Part 5 | Story
Music used:
'Analog Memories' - Nick Kelly
'1986' - Angel Salazar
'Morning Sunbeams' - Yehezkel Raz
'Charon' - Yehezkel Raz
'Iramasa' - A.M. Beef
Various clips from the 'Steve Jobs' soundtrack by Daniel Pemberton

Кино

Опубликовано:

 

25 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,6 тыс.   
@shitty_beatles
@shitty_beatles Год назад
Convinced _Jobs_ was made solely because Matt Whiteley saw a photo of young Steve Jobs and thought it was a photo of Ashton Kutcher. I've been there. We've all been there.
@luismarioguerrerosanchez4747
If only Asthon could act.
@MrMightyZ
@MrMightyZ Год назад
@@luismarioguerrerosanchez4747 Dude!
@TheMikeMase
@TheMikeMase Год назад
@@luismarioguerrerosanchez4747 i actually think ashton did a good job, the script was just bad
@pdcdesign9632
@pdcdesign9632 Год назад
@@TheMikeMase Fassbender looks nothing like Jobs. At least they could have dyed his hair dark. I don't care how good the script was, they picked the wrong actor.
@cami5173
@cami5173 Год назад
@@TheMikeMase could you point to something where you like Kutchers acting? I haven’t seen something I like him in yet
@WhaleManMan
@WhaleManMan Год назад
Can't believe you're finally talking about my favorite 60s musician
@enshen2190
@enshen2190 Год назад
I mean he is from the Apple Records label so no wonder!
@someguyorfemaleontheintern5837
My favourite album from him was Black Turtleneck. What a masterpiece.
@thareelhelloagain
@thareelhelloagain Год назад
@@nicolashalbleib6237 My favorite was always "Fruit Only Diet".
@zachariah7114
@zachariah7114 Год назад
@@someguyorfemaleontheintern5837 my favorite was the album cover where Steve, Woz, Mike Markkula, and John Sculley are all walking barefoot across the street. I think it was titled "Infinite Loop" iirc.
@sussvarman
@sussvarman Год назад
@@someguyorfemaleontheintern5837 i love his earlier stuff, especially "I Smell so Bad (Atari Nightshift)"
@BugsyFoga
@BugsyFoga Год назад
As a kid I always thought it was fascinating that we got two Steve Jobs biopics in the span of two years.
@Stranger_In_The_Alps
@Stranger_In_The_Alps Год назад
We only got one. We don’t speak of the other one
@cegalo12
@cegalo12 Год назад
I think it happened because Steve Jobs just died, and many movie studios were like "Stonks!"
@user-ux1vj9vx7s
@user-ux1vj9vx7s Год назад
@@cegalo12 Stonks? What were you trying to say?
@lykukned1
@lykukned1 Год назад
@@user-ux1vj9vx7s stonks is an internet joke for money
@tomsmith6513
@tomsmith6513 Год назад
You were a kid when they were made? Wow. You must be quite young. (Sorry, that wasn't meant as an insult. I'm just in a joking mood.)
@gabrielgodwin7822
@gabrielgodwin7822 Год назад
Seth Rogan as Woz was a genius casting. Adored that film so much, it’s in the top twenty films for me beyond even the biopic genre.
@IvanTheHiro
@IvanTheHiro Год назад
I really hope Steve Jobs (2015) becomes more well-known as a fantastic movie as the years go on. The film and Michael Fassbender as an actor have been so underrated for too long.
@varunemani
@varunemani Год назад
Right so Danny 'Brit boy' Boyles version is just an old English stiff cold needlessly OVER INTELLECTUALISED movie, and over all forgettably unwatchable and boring movie (Except maybe if you are one of those stiff cold boring english crowd of people). For the rest of us 'sane' Canadians and Americans, Kutcher is and will remain the definitive Steve 'American icon' Jobs, something by the way a boring english actor like Fassbender can never achieve the level of mass appeal / likeability to a North American audience! Its like picturing a American born actor playing James Bond.. simply wont work no matter how much Danny Boyle or anybody tries to force it.
@LiamHagan
@LiamHagan Год назад
I think it was already that the day it came out. Definitely a palate cleanser!
@rippspeck
@rippspeck Год назад
@@varunemani Fassbender is German-Irish, you prejudiced smoothbrain.
@paulsynnott2709
@paulsynnott2709 2 месяца назад
@@varunemani "needlessly OVER INTELLECTUALISED" Translation: "It went over my head so it obviously sucked."
@RachelMay1989
@RachelMay1989 Год назад
I don't think it's a coincidence that two biopics you (correctly) point to as the best examples of how good and artistic the genre can be (this and Love and Mercy), approach their stories by looking at a small number of moments in time, as opposed to attempting to sum up the totality of a life. To me it feels like the micro stories tell you more about the person than the macro, however counterintuitive that idea feels. Plus, why would you even bother making a 'traditional' biopic when Walk Hard The Dewey Cox Story exists and is great.
@crieverytim
@crieverytim Год назад
I've never seen a biopic attempt to depict the totality of someone's life. that would be foolish. the very format would have to be more like a series of vignettes unless you are doing a mini series
@HungUpOnADream1122
@HungUpOnADream1122 Год назад
Ugh, Love and Mercy was so fuckin good.
@Woozy.0
@Woozy.0 Год назад
Dewey Cox is basically the perfect biopic, down to the incredible soundtrack
@varunemani
@varunemani Год назад
Right so Danny 'Brit boy' Boyles version is just an old English stiff cold needlessly OVER INTELLECTUALISED movie, and over all forgettably unwatchable and boring movie (Except maybe if you are one of those stiff cold boring english crowd of people). For the rest of us 'sane' Canadians and Americans, Kutcher is and will remain the definitive Steve 'American icon' Jobs, something by the way a boring english actor like Fassbender can never achieve the level of mass appeal / likeability to a North American audience! Its like picturing a American born actor playing James Bond.. simply wont work no matter how much Danny Boyle or anybody tries to force it.
@Oscuros
@Oscuros Год назад
@@varunemani you don't come across as really insecure and easily intimidated at all, you know that. I've never really seen "stiff cold boring" used in grammatically the wrong order like that used as a valid form of criticism of anything and more like some sort of immature emotional reaction to something. Are you sure you wanted to write that out loud to strangers like that? Why can't you think of something about how the Two stories matched up, or what they emphasised as being better for you one way or the other, like everyone else has and instead seem to rely on the fact that you personally don't like Fassbender much? Because he gets a lot more work than Kutcher and has more accolades, like a Screen Actors Guild Award, a Critics' Choice Movie Award, and nominations for two Academy Awards, four British Academy Film Awards and three Golden Globe Awards. Kutcher, who is mostly known for his TV work has mostly Teen Choice awards, speaking of "mass appeal", Fassbender is also Irish, but born in Germany, I know it's all the same to you, but maybe that might help you with that massive English boner you seem to have as a foreigner in English, as it were. You can't project your rather massive insecurities onto actors on a screen doing a job, and if you don't like talking and it hurts your brain, well then, that's why you mop my floors or flip my burgers, or deliver my Amazon, isn't it, and maybe just stick to that instead of with trying to articulate why you don't like competence so badly to strangers and can't think of one rational reason that doesn't instantly show up how clueless you are.
@AarmOZ84
@AarmOZ84 Год назад
I like how Zen the Steve Jobs (2015) movie was. The 3 Acts were obvious, the 5 conflicts were also obvious, and even the theme of seeing what is happening behind the curtain as symbolic metaphor for peering into what made Steve Jobs ticked was beyond obvious. And because of its simplistic, artistic direction.... it felt like a creation of Steve Jobs himself.
@malcorub
@malcorub Год назад
If you don't already know the man's story, Steve Jobs (2015) is hard to follow along. This movie is for folks already familiar with him and the sequence of events.
@varunemani
@varunemani Год назад
Right so Danny 'Brit boy' Boyles version is just an old English stiff cold needlessly OVER INTELLECTUALISED movie, and over all forgettably unwatchable and boring movie (Except maybe if you are one of those stiff cold boring english crowd of people). For the rest of us 'sane' Canadians and Americans, Kutcher is and will remain the definitive Steve 'American icon' Jobs, something by the way a boring english actor like Fassbender can never achieve the level of mass appeal / likeability to a North American audience! Its like picturing a American born actor playing James Bond.. simply wont work no matter how much Danny Boyle or anybody tries to force it.
@yourneighbormordecai
@yourneighbormordecai Год назад
@@varunemani Bro not even American audiences liked the Ashton Kutcher Jobs what the hell are you talking about
@yourneighbormordecai
@yourneighbormordecai Год назад
@@varunemani Also what do you have against Brits lmao. Plenty of Brits have played Americans just fine, like Christian Bale as Bruce Wayne in The Dark Knight Trilogy. The more I read your comment the more I'm convinced you're either the director or writer of Jobs and you're still salty it didn't get an Oscar lol.
@wolfhaley6900
@wolfhaley6900 Год назад
@@yourneighbormordecai CHRISTIAN BALE IS BRITISH?????
@ROBYNMARKOW
@ROBYNMARKOW Год назад
I like to think that Michael Fassbinder's performance was similar to that of Meryl Streep's in "The Devil Wears Prada". In the book,Miranda Priestly was v. shouty & neurotic but in the film version she was quietly menacing & much more nuanced which worked perfectly for that medium 👌
@erikdaniels0n
@erikdaniels0n Год назад
I truly think that the Boyle/Sorkin movie choosing to only focus on a few very key moments in Jobs’ life and career and tell the stories of those moments as thoroughly as possible is a much more engaging formula than a cradle to grave biopic. Honestly, my favorite biopics of the last few years have been ones that have put unique spins on the genre (Jackie being a very internal and introspective character study about Jackie Kennedy’s life directly before and after the JFK assassination, Rocketman turning Elton John’s life into a lavish movie musical)
@seraiharper5553
@seraiharper5553 Год назад
I believe that biopics should always come in the form that the subject worked in. Thus, "De-Lovely" is a Cole Porter musical, "Dragon" is a Bruce Lee kung fu flick, "Man in the Moon" is a mind-bending uncomfortable sorta-comedy, etc. I look forward with great interest to the horror film that will be made about Stephen King.
@BenCol
@BenCol Год назад
@@seraiharper5553 ‘Ed Wood’ is another good example, paying homage to the era and style of the films of Ed Wood.
@seraiharper5553
@seraiharper5553 Год назад
@@BenCol Indeed! Though it was not as low-budget as Wood's actual work, it was a work of fantasy which portrayed him as winning the love and respect he craved. It was the movie about him that HE would have made.
@justagirl36
@justagirl36 Год назад
@kshamwhizzle It was!!! Still upset that Margot Robbie didn't get an oscar for that!! She was robbed imo!!!!!!!!!!
@walrustargaryen7794
@walrustargaryen7794 Год назад
My regret is that the only movie I waited all year was pretty much the Wikipedia versión of Elvis's life. A three simultaneus arcs of Elvis like in the Fassbender Jobs would have worked better, IMO. Not just a greatest hits (even worst, they took the White House visit and the MSG shows away), they treat Elvis as a normal naive person. It wasnt. It was extravagant and out of this World.
@nurturingcompassion
@nurturingcompassion Год назад
Wow, that Danny Boyle interview clip really sold me on the whole movie’s approach. He’s right. Steve Jobs whole mantra was “think different”, and they embodied that beautifully in the film by portraying the themes and key feelings that sum up Job’s life. Rather than checking boxes, it becomes, like you said, an impressionist painting that can deliver more truth than a photograph.
@GaffsNotLaffs
@GaffsNotLaffs 8 месяцев назад
I completely agree that it doesn't really matter how much the actor looks like the person, but I do find it absolutely mind blowing how much Ashton Kutcher looks like young Steve Jobs.
@timber740
@timber740 11 месяцев назад
I watched the Fassbender movie during my elementary years with my father. At the time I couldn't understand anything that was happening during those crucial moments, but the performance and intensity of each scene kept me immensely invested. I felt like I had followed Steve's progression and character development and grew a emotional relationship with the cast, with the film only being two hours long. The character study is phenomenal. Great video analysis.
@murdoph
@murdoph Год назад
I absolutely love your biopic reviews. You've completely changed my mind on how someone's story should be told and I can't thank you enough for your valuable opinions
@Osfacae
@Osfacae Год назад
I always knew I vastly preferred the Boyle film, but never could quite articulate what made it so much more compelling. I think this really nails it flawlessly.
@BenHardyYT
@BenHardyYT Год назад
exactly
@varunemani
@varunemani Год назад
Right so Danny 'Brit boy' Boyles version is just an old English stiff cold needlessly OVER INTELLECTUALISED movie, and over all forgettably unwatchable and boring movie (Except maybe if you are one of those stiff cold boring english crowd of people). For the rest of us 'sane' Canadians and Americans, Kutcher is and will remain the definitive Steve 'American icon' Jobs, something by the way a boring english actor like Fassbender can never achieve the level of mass appeal / likeability to a North American audience! Its like picturing a American born actor playing James Bond.. simply wont work no matter how much Danny Boyle or anybody tries to force it.
@THEODSTKING117
@THEODSTKING117 Год назад
@@varunemani ur such a dork
@amandasunshine2
@amandasunshine2 Год назад
"None of it happened, but it's all true" I feel like that sentence sums up so much
@TheGoldenboyo
@TheGoldenboyo 8 месяцев назад
Although the Kutcher version did not receive as much critical acclaim, I can’t help but think that Ashton was never given the credit he deserved for how accurate his portrayal of Steve was. He absolutely nailed Steve’s voice and mannerisms in a way Michael didn’t. But as you pointed out, Ashton’s movie emphasised the ‘wiki accuracy’ whereas Michael was more captivating as he was clearly leaning into other darker aspects of Steve’s life for his performance. Loved both films.
@sunkintree
@sunkintree 7 месяцев назад
Fassbender's was more about Steve Jobs as a person. Kutcher's was about Steve Jobs as the leader of Apple. Fassbender is good for what it is, but I don't know about you, I just never thought to myself "wow you know what would be great, a whole movie about how Steve Jobs failing at being a father, that's what I'm most interested in" Kutcher's is better.
@user-ft6wo8rs5g
@user-ft6wo8rs5g 6 месяцев назад
Ashton was laughably bad
@TheGoldenboyo
@TheGoldenboyo 6 месяцев назад
@@sunkintree Hmmm. Nice take and yeah completely agree. It still kinda bugs me that majority of people culturally reference Fassbender's version because I enjoyed Kutchers so much more. Fassbender's clearly has wider appeal as it panders to the critics who love a cynical angle. Kutcher is defo more of a purist/origins story which is why I love it so much.
@Donyourmom
@Donyourmom 5 месяцев назад
It’s not his fault, the script was so bad he couldn’t even save it.
@harold3165
@harold3165 3 месяца назад
Nah, Kutcher did a horrible job. It was like an SNL impression.
@SuperMustache555
@SuperMustache555 Год назад
This was really well made! I know you only did it to avoid copyright claims, but I actually love the way you cut between your own monologue and clips from the movie. Well done!
@starry_lis
@starry_lis Год назад
So smooth
@sirfizz6518
@sirfizz6518 Год назад
That had to be a bit tedious, and the result was quite seamless and even poetic
@periwinkleadidas
@periwinkleadidas Год назад
i didnt even realize it was a strategy for that, i fricking loved that
@trevorganoe748
@trevorganoe748 Год назад
I saw “Jobs” around when it came out. My mom ended up having such a negative impression of him that she said she would never buy an Apple product again; then she felt bad when she realized he had just died.
@Stranger_In_The_Alps
@Stranger_In_The_Alps Год назад
Jobs humbled her and he wasn’t even alive. Based ledge
@jothishprabu8
@jothishprabu8 Год назад
You shouldn't buy apple products anyway considering they are a big scam
@tomsmith6513
@tomsmith6513 Год назад
Things often change when people die. When my dad died, my views on the conflicts we had changed. It was frustrating that he often didn't understand my problems and struggles. He often criticised and sometimes even insulted me over what he believed were bad and stupid decisions, but there was something more important than that: he gave me a life and a good financial foundation. He was always there. I came to see that life was a gift. I appreciated what he had given me, what he left behind. It's like what happened when the Queen of Britain died. Whatever people had against her no longer mattered. People saw her death as a loss, that things were better with her around than not.
@cjaquilino
@cjaquilino Год назад
Your mom’s initial reaction was right, regardless of whether he died or not. That was unfortunate but it doesn’t undo the bad things Jobs did either.
@cjaquilino
@cjaquilino Год назад
@@tomsmith6513 As someone with ancestry from a former British colony, a lot of us were glad she died. She presided over quite a lot of our suffering in the world.
@matheus.wagner
@matheus.wagner Год назад
Great screenplay, great filmography, great editing and great storytelling. I'm not talking about the movies though, I'm talking about the video. This is truely beautiful. You just earned yourself a new subscriber! Shout out from Brazil!
@joeyclemenza7339
@joeyclemenza7339 Год назад
While I tend to think Jobs was pretentious and up his own a**, Boyle/Sorkin really created something captivating. I honestly enjoyed it, top to bottom. It cuts the “worship” bullsht of the Kutcher movie, and really delivers on character. If you’re going to make a movie about one man, character is the one thing you really need to nail down.
@beatm6948
@beatm6948 8 месяцев назад
I still think a lot of the ideals of apple are trash (not to say they didn't make any innovations), but it seems like a genuinely good movie, and emotionally, it works very well. Even if I don't particularly like Steve Jobs.
@DangerVille
@DangerVille Год назад
I remember watching Boyle’s Steve Jobs film in cinemas back in 2015 and I fell in love with it. Its such an unconventional way of doing a biopic, yet we learn so much about WHO Jobs actually is. It’s truly a masterpiece. I still enjoyed Kutcher’s Job’s as more of a popcorn flick, its got fun vibes, but its undeniably inferior to the Boyle film. Great video!
@user-bf8fe3kl2c
@user-bf8fe3kl2c Год назад
The “Fasbender” version is a fantastic movie. Years before it came out I heard what they would be doing and wondered how they could make a movie of his life by only covering 3 events. It was amazing what they accomplished. Very emotional and engaging rather than just a series of events of his life. Wonderful film.
@dennislogan6781
@dennislogan6781 Год назад
Pirates of Silicon Valley was an awesome film. I saw it when it first aired. The main song was "Everybody wants to rule the World" and it really fits.
@chimominino5083
@chimominino5083 Год назад
Dude the crescendos you achieved in your video were phenomenal. Script, direction, score… I found your storytelling really emotional actually. Nice video :)
@goblinjones
@goblinjones Год назад
Very quickly you've become my favorite youtuber, please make more video essays like this about film! You put things in very thoughtful but concise way which is really engaging to listen to. Beatles stuff is of course great too but I'm all for you expanding to focusing on similar landmark creatives.
@ElliotRobertsVideos
@ElliotRobertsVideos Год назад
Thanks!
@TheChadTI
@TheChadTI Год назад
Agree, this guy is really good. Charming af.
@estate0007
@estate0007 Год назад
+1 Beatles are great, but there is already so much content about them out there.
@unfotograma
@unfotograma Год назад
FINALLY a content creator I love talks about one of the most underrated movies of the 2010s! Steve Jobs is a work of art and so is this video. Great work as always, Elliot.
@KrishmanyuThakur
@KrishmanyuThakur Год назад
Michael fassbender was nominated for an Oscar....
@harold3165
@harold3165 Год назад
@@KrishmanyuThakur yeh but the movie itself bombed hard at the box office
@VinceVintage
@VinceVintage Год назад
100% agree with everything said about the Aston Kutcher version Loved the breakdown of why the Sorkin version is such a well made film, made me appreciate it so much more
@sergiomartinez5946
@sergiomartinez5946 Год назад
Wassup. Love your videos. You look like Walt Disney, especially when you have a mustache.
@GDub83
@GDub83 Год назад
I have watched all of these movies and I really feel that the Michael Fassbender version is prob the closest version we will get to Steve Jobs on screen. It makes me cry every time.
@seraiharper5553
@seraiharper5553 Год назад
I worked up in Scotts Valley at several software companies in the early 90's (temping), and let me tell you, NOBODY had a good word for Steve Jobs. Everyone hated him. Apparently he was a real monster, and no one wanted to deal with him in any capacity. 'Tis why I never bought the hype about his supposed genius. He had no genius at all for dealing with human beings. On the contrary, he was a miserable SOB to one and all.
@pjetrs
@pjetrs Год назад
as much as I believe you that he was an asshole, which is well known, it doesn't equal him not being genius. He happens to be a genius visionary, not a genius peoples-person. One doesn't exclude the other.
@charlesfarley28
@charlesfarley28 Год назад
Boyle's portrait of Jobs is breathtaking. We see him as both visionary and villain, a man whose ambition flew so near the sun that we all went with him never thinking of the possibility of "too close." It is as compelling a character study as Michael Keaton's Ray Kroc in The Founder. You don't come away with an impression of either man as good or evil, but instead a real human being. Edit: 100 points word usage for accurately declaring the Boyle film a triptych.
@TheSchaef47
@TheSchaef47 Год назад
"The triptychs are twenty feet high!"
@rhabdob3895
@rhabdob3895 Год назад
The only thing “breath taking” about Steve Jobs is his net worth and--ugh I was trying to make some gross rib cage reference. Too much. Even if it’s about this bastard.
@charlesfarley28
@charlesfarley28 Год назад
@@rhabdob3895 won't argue with that. I was referring to the cinematic quality of Boyle's "Steve Jobs" as opposed to the subject himself. He is one of those examples of history likely leaving out the heinous path he trod in order to be that "great man."
@BrawndoQC
@BrawndoQC Год назад
@@rhabdob3895 There much more than just his net worth to it, like the phone you're using even if it's Android is a result of it, but yeah he's not the saint and saviour
@varunemani
@varunemani Год назад
Right so Danny 'Brit boy' Boyles version is just an old English stiff cold needlessly OVER INTELLECTUALISED movie, and over all forgettably unwatchable and boring movie (Except maybe if you are one of those stiff cold boring english crowd of people). For the rest of us 'sane' Canadians and Americans, Kutcher is and will remain the definitive Steve 'American icon' Jobs, something by the way a boring english actor like Fassbender can never achieve the level of mass appeal / likeability to a North American audience! Its like picturing a American born actor playing James Bond.. simply wont work no matter how much Danny Boyle or anybody tries to force it.
@andresplashal8971
@andresplashal8971 9 месяцев назад
Thank yiou for taking the time to do this video essay. Sorkin/Fassbender version is an awesome take on the classic story. The way everyone commands their craft is incredible and really brings the characters/ story to life; It's something special to watch!
@ScouseJazmin
@ScouseJazmin Год назад
Your videos on biopics really helped me understand my own feelings about film. After seeing them, I watched 13 Lives which really ping ponged between a great portrayal of what the story meant to the wider world at that moment in time, and some really affected acting by the leads and jarring the focus when they tried to be "true to life". It's thanks to you that I could find the words to say why I felt so irritated with an overall pretty good film. Thanks for posting and hope you keep going!
@iceteabreak
@iceteabreak Год назад
pirates of the silicon valley is a weirdly amazing movie. that faceoff at the end was amazing
@JoJoJoker
@JoJoJoker Год назад
I *WISH* we could get a John Lennon biopic in the same format at Jobs. 1966 final tour. 1971 post-Beatles. 1975 “Lost Weekend” 1980 final days.
@professionalwidow
@professionalwidow Год назад
i would prefer a lost weekend movie just by itself. especially focusing on his relationship harry nilssen and may pang
@JoJoJoker
@JoJoJoker Год назад
@@professionalwidow yes, including the infamous Tampon incident.
@JoJoJoker
@JoJoJoker Год назад
@Multiversus is the best game ever made I would like to see a limited series about each member of the band. There’s been no good films about any of them, really. Two of Us was the best example I’ve seen…about John & Paul in NYC.
@JoJoJoker
@JoJoJoker Год назад
@Multiversus is the best game ever made it slips my mind for the moment but there is a movie kinda set up like that. Where we see everything through the eyes of one character and then it switches to another where we get their perspective. It’s simply baffling that Brian Epstein has had a proper film made about him. That would probably be the best angle… Also: Johnny Cash deserves a proper film. Walk the Line was a major disappointment for me…his autobiography is filled with stories which would be a joy to see on screen. Like the time he burned down a national forest while he was high.
@JoJoJoker
@JoJoJoker Год назад
@Multiversus is the best game ever made they barely address his addiction…it was made like a TV movie with some mid upper-tier actors. Johnny eats some pills off screen, falls down singing I Got Stripes (it’s a shame we never got a full Phoenix version of that song), June flushes them…generic stuff. Another stores: Cash blew up a Cadillac while driving in Beverly Hills on drugs in the 1960s. The movie tried to paint a rosy version of a man who had a very dark life. That’s due to Johnny Cash’s personal historical revisionism after his evangelical 1970s phase. He had to sign off on the script and wanted it to be a love story. The film doesn’t hold up now, a lot of people got caught up in the musical biopic craze of the early 2000s.
@slob5041
@slob5041 10 месяцев назад
The Walter Isaacson novel turned me back into an Apple fan. Suddenly he became a very tragic mixed figure dealing with dad problems trying to constantly outdo himself until his self imposed death all in the journey of making something beautiful and unique
@iTalkALotDontListen
@iTalkALotDontListen 8 месяцев назад
Almost a year ago, this video brought me to the movie Steve Jobs, and it blew me away. It has remained one of my favorite movies of all time ever since. Thank you.
@thomasobrien1841
@thomasobrien1841 Год назад
Petition to have Elliot review Bohemian Rhapsody
@sallyjay7741
@sallyjay7741 Год назад
Hear hear
@feelflows
@feelflows Год назад
After falling head over heels in love with Love and Mercy purely because of your recommendation, I can’t wait to watch another amazing biopic in Steve Jobs! You explain why it’s great on such a compelling way and you’re quickly becoming one of my favourite RU-vidrs!
@seafoodrichy
@seafoodrichy Год назад
This is beautifully made and I love how in-depth you went into breaking it down. Definitely would love to see more of this type of content.
@zuqini
@zuqini Год назад
Really thankful that you made this video! The Michael Fassbender 'Steve Jobs' is so frustratingly underrated given the unfortunate release date and deserves as much recognition as it can get. I almost missed this masterpiece because I wasn't ready to watch another Jobs movie, but I'm glad I did. I truly hope this film survives the test of time.
@blackjesus6953
@blackjesus6953 Год назад
Normally when I look at other channels, the first few videos look and sound very amateurish but when I see your first videos they look like you have been doing this for a long time! I HEREBY BLESS THIS CHANNEL.
@ElliotRobertsVideos
@ElliotRobertsVideos Год назад
Thanks Black Jesus!
@AllTheArtsy
@AllTheArtsy Год назад
This channel's oldest video is 2 years ago. You can expect the quality to be good from the jump. We're not in 2012 anymore
@Yoshimitsu4prez
@Yoshimitsu4prez Год назад
Sorkin really is the master of “smart people arguing,” the amount of meaning you can pull from his dialogue is crazy. I do think it’s key he works with the right directors though. Fincher on social network, or Boyle on this. They know what to do behind the camera to give the dialogue maximum effect. It’s just excellent filmmaking. Really enjoyed you going over exactly how that filmmaking is excellent. I studied some film in school so it takes a bit of talent to engage me with this kind of analysis 😂. But it’s a good vibe
@KUREHA3D
@KUREHA3D 9 месяцев назад
blown away. your love and attention to detail is astounding. its very clear how much you admire this man. i actually meant to turn this video on as ambience while i worked but i found myself HOOKED, unable to look away from start to finish. thank you for sharing!! very incredibly well done.
@furonet138
@furonet138 Год назад
Your videos are so so good. It’s obvious how carefully crafted each one is. Excellent work
@roseclark5623
@roseclark5623 Год назад
No one talks about Steve Jobs the movie and it always felt like such a shame to me cause I was blown away when I saw it and it completely opened my eyes to what an amazing "biopic" could be. Every friend I show it to always has never heard of it or is uninterested in a Steve jobs movie but then always says the same thing I did after watching it. So glad someone finally made a proper video analyzing both these movies since I always felt the Ashton Kutcher version was so lacking in substance but it was the only Steve jobs movie anyone knew of.
@Crumbs_Crumbs
@Crumbs_Crumbs Год назад
Holy crap I haven't watched this yet but I think that the Danny Boyle Steve Jobs is criminally underrated and I adore it. I'm so happy it gets looked into in this much detail - I don't care about the opinions (of which I dont know yet)! Thank you!
@morgonaut
@morgonaut Год назад
Thank you Elliot a lot! You made me cry. I never saw any of your videos yet, just this one now. Man, thanks again...
@juannakamine1
@juannakamine1 Год назад
Excellent! Well done. Your effort is definitely appreciated. Hope to see more proper video essays from ya!
@dylanpeters9400
@dylanpeters9400 Год назад
Love your biopic breakdowns dude. Always well reasoned and paced, keeps me engaged even if I haven't seen the film.
@DeltaSpartan141
@DeltaSpartan141 Год назад
It sickens me that Steve Jobs isn't being talked about at the same level of The Social Network has.
@gadget00
@gadget00 Год назад
The Social Network is 10 times a better movie imho
@donpeppone4738
@donpeppone4738 Год назад
@@gadget00 And you are right
@noemorales8330
@noemorales8330 Год назад
@@gadget00 ​I would argue Steve Jobs and The Social Network are at a similar level of quality to each other.
@brevin630
@brevin630 Год назад
Congrats, you're one of the few people who convinced me to stop watching a video about a movie and go watch the movie instead, then come back to hear your thoughts
@williamt83
@williamt83 Год назад
Great video - the compare and contrast between the two is really put into such stark relief and talking about the amount of heart that the Fassbender version has is a point that I've never been able to put my finger on until now.
@harrytodhunter5078
@harrytodhunter5078 Год назад
What a fantastic video essay! Definitely expecting another about the Social Network now!
@rosslmccallum
@rosslmccallum Год назад
Huge congrats on going into RU-vid full time mate!!!! Awesome video too 😊
@EggPlanet492
@EggPlanet492 8 месяцев назад
One of the best video essays I’ve seen in a long time. I have to have seen Sorkin’s movie at least 3 times and still learned tons here, alongside all the great bts stuff and context from the biography. Thanks for the great watch!
@johnpenner5182
@johnpenner5182 Год назад
pirates of silicon valley was an excellent film - much better than the later films. he is a man who demanded the best - of himself, and of others. he made a dent in the universe, and the future is better for the poetic sense he brought to everything he did. thxu steve. 🙏
@tyf.5111
@tyf.5111 Год назад
I don't care about Steve Jobs or Apple, nor have I seen either of these films, but you made this video absolutely riveting from beginning to ending. Stellar work. I am stoked the almighty algorithm showed me your channel and I look forward to seeing many more videos from you and witnessing your subscriber count boom. Such great work deserves recognition.
@bnt96
@bnt96 Год назад
i love every video you make and even if you were to branch out into non beatles territory like this one or even the zelda video (which is most excellent) i’m sure everyone would still enjoy it just because of the effort you put into each video and the way you make them so engaging. you could literally make a 20+ min video about anything and i would be interested. the long lengths add an extra layer of epicness along with your style of editing 👌 it makes me actually watch the video while doing other things over just listening
@ElliotRobertsVideos
@ElliotRobertsVideos Год назад
I appreciate that!
@blew1t
@blew1t Год назад
The zelda video is a certified hood classic and we are ascendant intellectuals for liking/knowing about it
@bnt96
@bnt96 Год назад
@@blew1t fr 😎 u can feel the passion
@iwasborninohio1992
@iwasborninohio1992 Год назад
the fassbender version remains one of my favorite movies of all time. Every time I rewatch it I see it from a new angle. It's about technology both alienating and unifying people. It's about art and the artist and the fluid connection between the two "Your products are better than you are brother" "That's the idea brother". It's about change and perspective. It's about the conflict between relationships and ambition. It's about legacy and the power of personality. Also it's one of the best screenplays of the last decade.
@PerfectRodo
@PerfectRodo Год назад
I've never teared up watching a film review before. Thank you, that was so beautiful.
@levothy
@levothy Год назад
What an amazing video as usual Elliot, you've convinced me to watch it!!
@ellieklouda1074
@ellieklouda1074 Год назад
This was so insightful, and your commentary is spot on as always Elliot
@loreta_duran
@loreta_duran Год назад
Can’t believe this essay actually made me cry. Amazing video
@aaronnoraa332
@aaronnoraa332 Год назад
Screenwriting...screenwriting...screenwriting. What an insightful and grounded commentary on such an intensely researched subject. Social Network is incredible too! I'm with you, I'm so glad Danny Boyle got the chance to direct Steve Jobs.
@andyrewco
@andyrewco Год назад
Honestly, this video is a work of art. Incredibly done.
@luciabee
@luciabee Год назад
i loooove your interest in biopics. i never really thought twice about them until i started watching your videos!! now i have huge respect for the art form and the many ways it can be done
@WC-tv7lk
@WC-tv7lk Год назад
Fassbender's work alongside Boyle and Sorkin in the 2015 movie does a great job on answering the why steve jobs thinks the way he does even if you still have to look at it at an artistic representation of reality. They don't glorify him in the movie but showed that he was a very flawed person who actively seeked perfection in innovating apple's products. I love a lot of lines in the movie, but one that strikes right in the feels is when he tells Lisa, his daughter at the end that he's poorly made and finally admitting one of his flaws.
@allanelfe
@allanelfe Год назад
One of the most compelling and interesting video essays I've seen. Super insightful!
@JosephWithaG
@JosephWithaG Год назад
I mean this as a good thing when I say that you're my go-to for biopic recommendations, because I only ever thought of them as unnecessary fictionalised retellings of real events. Your videos about biopics definitely changed my mind about that.
@joeymartinez8529
@joeymartinez8529 Год назад
Well done I’m putting this together. Something I learned from your video towards the end was how Steve finally recognize how important his daughter was to him.
@leomariano2735
@leomariano2735 Год назад
That was beautiful. I got more emotional with your essay than with either of the movies but I most watch the Fassbender version again now
@fairplay3312
@fairplay3312 Год назад
You just can't make a bad video, the work you've put into this channel is truly a thing of beauty, I can only say congratulations and keep them coming, these videos are the best thing youtube has to offer
@eastonwarner5399
@eastonwarner5399 Год назад
If you stop talking about the beatles I'll cry
@RodValentine
@RodValentine Год назад
I'm really glad this got on my recommended, awesome video!
@jermckee
@jermckee Год назад
Great content as always. Please keep it coming
@astarcalledsun7646
@astarcalledsun7646 Год назад
I love your videos dude! Keep it up man! I know when day you're gonna be big
@Josh-os7vn
@Josh-os7vn Год назад
im glad to see you branch out again like you did for the underrated zelda video!! and your biopic reviews are always great
@UnwantedCommentary
@UnwantedCommentary Год назад
This was an awesome video! I am def going to go watch the movie now!
@lukehearnebrown6937
@lukehearnebrown6937 Год назад
loved this really detailed breakdown and comparison keep it up
@pr0xykill978
@pr0xykill978 Год назад
Both biopics failed to depict his childhood friendship with fitness guru Jack Garbarino of THE MOVEMENT.
@emppupalomaki4204
@emppupalomaki4204 Год назад
You've been my favourite youtuber for quite a while already but I've never commented before. Even this 45 minute one, (which is quite long for a RU-vid video, at least for me😅) just easily kept me concentrated all the way to the end and it really tells about the extraordinary quality of your content. Thank you! 😊
@roniemena
@roniemena Год назад
this was amazing. thanks for making it
@ziggybaker3446
@ziggybaker3446 Год назад
The way you analyze films is an artform in and of itself. I love these videos and the way you show the stark differences between two films, taking time to highlight why some work and some don't. As a person who doesn't really watch a lot of films, but does enjoy biopics, the way you think about these types of films always gets me thinking about how the film I'm watching is executing the story. I've never cared about Apple or Steve Jobs's story but you've got me invested in this film now and I might just have to see it!
@kennybeverage
@kennybeverage Год назад
Only saw the Kutcher version, also pirates of Silicon Valley. I really want to see the Danny Boyle one now. Almost got emotional by watching this video about it. Enjoy a lot of your Beatles content. Thank you. Keep up the great work.
@micheledevilliers3474
@micheledevilliers3474 Год назад
I love your videos, Elliot! Thanks!
@cybercab
@cybercab Год назад
Thank you. That was a lot of work and you did an excellent job.
@joshyatnite8686
@joshyatnite8686 Год назад
Sorkin’s Steve Jobs was the first time that i saw a movie and i felt like i was really watching a beautiful crafted stageplay. I’m not really a huge fan of Steve Jobs but that movie showed me that in many ways he had the mind of an artist.
@itishappeningagain3072
@itishappeningagain3072 Год назад
You've officially become The biopic guy
@lugallagher6193
@lugallagher6193 Год назад
loved this vidoe elliot! your insight is so pointed
@west4coast77
@west4coast77 Год назад
Extremely well done! A very cohesive and compelling comparison of the 2 films. A ton of work. Kudos and thanks for posting.
@curtandoscar
@curtandoscar Год назад
Fantastic job, Elliot, as usual. Videos like this are the reason I'm a supporter. This deep dive was a total pleasure from start to finish. So many things the casual movie-film viewer such as myself would not take into account. Like the particulars of the score, the color pallet of scenes, etc. Thank you. (Not a Jobs fan myself given he not only denied paternity even after the positive paternity test, but apparently heavily favored his male child over his daughters. I mean, wow. )
@vesin_9772
@vesin_9772 Год назад
After you mentioned this in the yesterday video, I wondered if you would make a video about this, you should make more film reviews and comparison
@liv_hann
@liv_hann Год назад
i would love to see a video of his on the social network... i genuinely really enjoy seeing elliot talk about the things he likes/admires and i think hearing him talk about how much he loves the social network for 30 minutes would be SO fun. (also there isnt a ton of social network retrospectives/reviews etc out there rn)
@pleaserewind295
@pleaserewind295 Год назад
This is a wonderful video.
@reimusklinsman5876
@reimusklinsman5876 Год назад
The Fastbender movie was great because it did the antihero trope so well. Jobs was such a jerk to everyone but somehow falls into success. His only growth was kind of reconciling with his daughter for being a completely absent father. Wozniak fought tooth an nail to make the best product possible while defending his team, but still gets the shaft because of Jobs. That made me feel so horrible.
@eatatjoes6751
@eatatjoes6751 10 месяцев назад
The one thing I think is really kind of cute about Steve Jobs is that the movie's time cards at the end are colored with blues and pinks and all that quirky stuff Apple had before it switched to all-grey and white. That's so cool and kind of nostalgic.
@hand-jobs
@hand-jobs Год назад
Wow this was a beautiful use of 45 minutes. Thank you!
@kerryallen4665
@kerryallen4665 Год назад
You’re back!!!!
@DodaGarcia
@DodaGarcia 11 месяцев назад
Amazing video! I had never realized how different those movies were and why the Kutcher biopic always felt lacking a bit to me, now I see it's because it's not focused (and I should have noticed it because I had the same issue with other movies like the recent "I Wanna Dance With Somebody"). The analogy of a photograph compared to an impressionistic painting is flawless too - photographs can of course be gorgeous and moving, but when they are it's not due to their photorealistic nature. It's also pretty ironic that probably the main thing the Kutcher film has going for itself is that uncanny resemblance between Ashton Kutcher and a young Steve Jobs, and yet in all the scenes where Jobs is supposed to look older the makeup is incredibly distracting. At least they had the sense to keep those to a minimum, because there's not a second where you believe you're looking at a bald man in his 40s or 50s.
@jits8767
@jits8767 Год назад
man stop making me cry and think about the relationship with my father, i came here for movie bro and computer talk
Далее
The Brand Biopics are taking over!
51:09
Просмотров 171 тыс.
How the Brilliance of Steve Jobs Killed Him
19:39
Просмотров 1,7 млн
Turning trash into triumph, one can at a time!
00:18
Просмотров 2,5 млн
An overly exhaustive review of ‘Yesterday’
28:53
Просмотров 689 тыс.
History Buffs: The Crucible
47:34
Просмотров 702 тыс.
What's Missing From Adam McKay's New Movies?
20:29
Просмотров 4,8 тыс.
The Madness of Steve Jobs Told by Steve Wozniak
1:01:51
There Will Never Be Another Movie Like Borat
17:23
Просмотров 2,7 млн
Elvis (2022) - The Good, the Bad and the Tom Hanks
25:50
Why Love & Mercy is the best music biopic
31:48
Просмотров 542 тыс.