WHY WEST BENGAL AND IT'S CAPITAL KOLKATA LOSING ATTRACTION AMONG YOUTHS AS A JOB DESCRIPTION 

West Bengal গোল্লায় যাচ্ছে। খুব তাড়াতাড়ি মূখ্যমন্ত্রী বদল করা দরকার।

টাটাকে তাড়িয়ে আমরা নিজেদের ক্ষতি করেছি।আমাদের রাজনৈতিক ভাবনা আমাদের শেষ করেছে।

পিসি ভাইপো কে তাড়ান, কিছু টা হলেও উন্নতি হবে

Tata k tarano was the last pin in the coffin for Bengal N Bengalis... 😢

কলকাতা বর্তমানে একটি চূড়ান্ত অনুন্নত শহর😢

কলকাতা র real estate এর একটা অংশ কেনে west bengal এর বাকি জেলার মানুষ, তারা কলকাতা তে যায় কারণ health আর education এর জন্য, যা তাদের জেলা তে পাওয়া যায় না।

Chennai is famous for health, Pune and Delhi is famous for education, Bengaluru and Hyderabad is famous for IT sector, Mumbai is for finance. Needless to say that so long the corruption, excess politics, agitation and other anti development movement be stopped, a state or a city cannot be developed. Kolkata is now no longer a city of joy. It’s rather a city of shame and sorrow. 😢😢

Kolkata and bengal economy isnt growing as par of other cities, this is not the problem, problem is people there dont want to accept it😅

পিসি ভাইপো না সরলে বাংলায় শুধু নন্দিনীর হোটেল আর কিছু ধাবাই তৈরি হবে। বড় শিল্প হবে না।

এত দিনে মনে হচ্ছে যে এটা goverment এর paid চ্যানেল নয়। বাংলার অনেক সমস্যা , আগে ভুল অর্থনীতির জন্য পুঁজি তাড়ানো, তার পর চুরি cut money ছাড়াও শিল্প বিরোধী attitude ( Tata কে তাড়ানো). বাঙালি ৫০ বছর এই atmosphere এ থেকে,কর্মবিমুখ ,অলস unprofessional হয়ে গেছে। ( বাংলায় তিরিশ বছর ব্যবসা চালিয়ে বলছি )। কর্মচারী ,ব্যাংক কর্মী, পাড়ার ছেলেরা, সরকারি দফতর সব জায়গায় খালি বিরোধিতা আর পয়সা আদায়ের চেষ্টা। তাতে শিল্প উঠে যায় যাবে। কারুর কাছে কোন সহানুভূতি আপনি পাবেন না। ইনভেস্ট করেছেন, চুরির দায়ে ধরা পড়েছেন। এই পরিস্থিতি চলতে থাকলে যা হবার টাই হচ্ছে।

Eto din por ekta sotti vlo presentation hyeche. Government jodi na initiative ney tahole jibone kichu hobe na.

চপ শিল্প বাংলার এক নং শিল্প।

Kolkata is far far behind in comparison with Bengaluru Chennai Hyderabad Mumbai Delhi.

No hope sir. Soon banglore and Hyderabad will overtake Kolkata in terms of GDP . Even last year odisha got more investment than West Bengal. It's a shame. I will leave West Bengal very soon for higher studies. My all classmates will do the same. Most of us will go to Mumbai, Bangalore or Hyderabad. Politics, corruption and strikes destroyed whole West Bengal. Kolkata is the best example in whole world of how politics can ruin one of the best cities.

Bengal needs a visionary leadership who has visited the Business hubs of all the developed states of India

পশ্চিম বঙ্গে বিদেশি বিনিয়োগ বাড়ানোর জন্যে সরকারকে পরিবেশ বান্ধব সুযোগ সুবিধা দিতে হবে , আর 90% স্থানীয় যেন কাজ পায় সেটা দেখতে হবে । রাজ্যে বেশি বেশি করে উদ্যোগী বাড়ানোর জন্যে লোন দিতে হবে সকারকে, আর ফ্রীতে প্রশিক্ষন দিতে হবে ছোটখাটো উদ্যোগ নেওয়ার জন্যে ।

পূজোয় সরকারের ইনকাম হয়েছে 600 কোটি টাকা মদ বিক্রি করে আর বাংলায় Industry তো হচ্ছে চপ শিল্প , কাশফুল শিল্প,মৎসব শিল্প, মদ শিল্প কাটমানি শিল্প এটাই তো উন্নয়নের বাংলা

This type of video is an eye-opener..But nothing is going to change in Bengal..We have to admit Bengalis lag behind communities like Tamil, Telegu, Gujarati, Punjabis etc by atleast 100 years in terms of of attitude & discipline , skillset, intellectual ability , Planning and strategy , physical abilities like field of sports etc...Bengal only did well under British...Bengal has been in a free fall since 1947 when Bengalis took over the management of the state...Just ponder over few points and try to get the answer..1) How many Bengali industrial houses are present in India..Parsi community with a population of only 50k have around 10 industrial groups..Bengal still looks to some tier2 Rajasthani, Sindhi and Punjabi groups for investment. Even South Indians who were earlier known as Service class have created large industrial houses like TVS, MRF, Murugappan group , Sundaram group, Infosys etc..2) How many Bengalis/ East Indian people do we find in top management..Its all dominated by South Indians , Gujaratis and Punjabis. 3) How many good and wide roads do we find in Bengal. All narrow roads- mostly 2 lanes and some 4 lanes. If someone visits states like Tamil nadu , Mah, Haryana etc we see wide roads that are from 6 to 16 lanes..Even the Rajarhat township which is touted as 21st century city has only 6 lanes, out of which 2 lanes are occupied by Buses and parking resulting in choke points and traffic jams at various places in office hours even when the occupancy in New Town is not even 25% of its capacity. I was in Singapore sometime back. The city was built around 1970..Yet the roads are 10 to 12 lanes followed by 2 metre grass lawn and then 2 metre covered footpath. Looks like its ahead of New town by 50 years...Finally, to address these bottlenecks Bengal has to setup various expert committees. Average Bengali has to keep an eye on whats happening around the globe and increase their awareness ,thinking ability and vision. Then only there is hope after 50 years, else this type of videos will keep appearing in next 200 years

কোলকাতা! কোলকাতা! কোলকাতা! এই শহর ছাড়া কি পশ্চিমবঙ্গে আর কোনো শহর নেই যে যা কিছু হবে শুধু সেখানেই হবে বাকি জেলা গুলোও যদি সুযোগ এবং ভালো বিনিয়োগ পাই তবেই তো বাংলার ইকোনমির চালচিত্র পাল্টায় যেমন - গুজরাটে আমেদাবাদ- গান্ধিনগর-সুরাট মহারাষ্ট্রে পুনে -মুম্বই-নাসিক দিল্লি NCR - নয়ডা-গাজিয়াবাদ-গুরগাও কিন্তু কোলকাতা -কোলকাতা এর বাইরে কিছুই নেই 😢 7:29

Bcoz 1. The mindset of Bengalis post communist era really sucks, as Bengalis we see pride in saying that we don't need money and that sucks 2. The party politics and people getting free money have made most of people lazy and that has transformed to the great adda culture and now people want to gain out of people who work by doing nothing which sincerely no hard working people want 3. Post the initial curse of CPM era, tmc with its larger than life corruption has almost acted as nail to the coffin

এখানে শুধু কাটমানি শিল্প আছে

Trust me bhubaneswar will attract more investment than kolkata,

Kolkata jemon ache thak... But wb te another financial center Hoya dorkar... Choto city gulo ke easily transform Kora Jai ... Jemon Durgapur, Siliguri, asansol etc ... Esob jaga ke industry hub e porinoto Kora ta besi dorkar ... kolkata ke niye tanatani na korai vlo..ele it will become second Bangalore

Every Bengali is responsible for presenting Bengal as decaying country. We have proved ourself as spineless nation. Other provinces took away our wealth and industries just by slapping us. And Bengalese as a nation going downhill every time . Should we pray for Bengal and Bengalese!!

Over politicisation of people and society is a big drawback for any person or company to come in

TATA কে তাড়িয়ে বাংলা 20 বছর পিছিয়ে গেছে ।

Main reason akjn e.. Thak nam ta bole case khete chai na😂😂😂

Very Good Video. True. Strong words. We need Hard Business Minded approach to governance. ❤

Shame to Bengal, the worst state.

পশ্চিমবঙ্গে আর একটি বুদ্ধদেব ভট্টাচার্য চাই

Bengaler industries chilo independence r aage. Aar sesh hoeache left fronter aamole. 34 bochorer bam andoloner failure ke dhakte Singurer Tata chole jaoar golpoi besi prochar hoeache. Kono big industries risk nite chaiche na jongi aandoloner bhoye. Union korbo aar 20 Jon neta kono kaaj korbo na. Companyr manager ra netader bhoy pabe aar respect korbe eatai holo Bengaler industries sesh hobar prodhan karon.

Tata কে তারিয়ে যেটা শেষ হয়েছে তার শুরুটা 1977 থেকে তৈরী করেছে, পশ্চিমবঙ্গের এই অবস্থার জন্য বামফ্রন্ট সরকার পূর্ণ দায়ী।

এখানে শিল্প বাণিজ্য গোল্লা শুধুই ভাতা ভিক্ষা এই হোলেই চোলবে

West Bengal is a state which was historically rich in industry and also had a port city like Kolkata but once it started lagging behind other states in the country and now most of the entrepreneurs in the country avoid the state and no one wants to invest here There are not one half but many practical and political reasons behind the present economic malaise of West Bengal which I have tried to highlight in my own way 1. First of all most of the people of the whole country see Bengalis as leftists and it is real West Bengal politics is always left wing dominated and industrialists don't like it because capitalism and socialism can never live together 2. Professionally most Bengalis are government and corporate employees , techer ,doctor, singer, writer, actor, intellectuals and they are proud of it so a large section has always been inexperienced in business 3. West Bengal has always had an anti-central government in power in the state during 34 years of left front Congress, NDA and UPA were in power at the center and then after defeating left front and forming TMC government BJP came to power at the center so as a result of which the political differences and rivalry between the state and the center continued, for which loss Either the state of is gradually lagging behind in industry, business, enterprise and various other sectors 4. West Bengal is currently the most unsafe state for women rape of women, minors and children are reported daily theft, extortion, murders are on the rise police administration is completely broken corruption is rampant because of this a certain section of businessmen do not like West Bengal 5. At present, about 50 percent of the population in the state are migrant workers which further accentuates the state's lack of industry 6. The current new generation of West Bengal is lagging behind the youth of other states in the job market also they are not able to compete with outsiders in various state government exams One of the reasons for this is the politicization of the education sector in the state 7. Finally there is the lack of vision of the state government and it must be remembered that the current government came to power through de-industrialization for which any heavy industry is almost impossible to come up and the government also wants to depend on agriculture and medium industries.

Cm is the reason behind. 😂

Chief minister of bengal is responsible for this. Unless this goverment changed and CM changed no way its possible. Intention needed. The party which comes into power by removing TATA from Sungur.How can you expect this gov will bring industries? See the BJP state and other state.How industries developed there. Even we see in eyes we dont accept.

Wow very nice video bro ❤❤❤❤❤😮🙏❤

অনেক দিন পর একটা খুব সুন্দর ও ভালো ভিডিও দেখলাম

Previously when I lived in Kolkata, I didn't want to leave it. After living in Maharashtra for 6 months I don't want to come back 😅

Until the TMC stays we have no prospect for West Bengal, which non-Bengali says Waste Bengal.

age pisimoni TATA ke taka ferot dik...ar 6 lakh crore loan ta ferot dik😂😂

কলকাতাতে গিয়ে কাজ করলে পশ্চিমবঙ্গের মানুষই এখন ভালো চোখে দেখে না কলকাতায় কাজ করছে খুবই কম মাইনে তার এরকম চোখে । তাছাড়া আরো কিছু চোখে দেখে ১. কলকাতায় গেলে মানিব্যাগ আর মোবাইল সামলে ২. ওখানে তো বিহারিরা ভরে গেছে ৩. কিন্তু সবাই কলকাতার দিকে শিক্ষাপ্রতিষ্ঠানগুলোর কারণে যেতেই হবে । তারপরে অন্য জায়গায় চলে যাওয়া যায় ৪. চিকিৎসা ব্যবস্থা কারণে ৫.

West Bengal এর নাম এখন Waste Bengal. আচ্ছা , পশ্চিম বঙ্গে কি শুধু একটা শহর ? কলকাতা ?

যত দিন tmc থাকবে সপ্নেও ভাববেনা যে পশ্চিমবঙ্গের উন্নতি হবে গ্রেনটি দিলাম

Thanks for your honesty and highlighting key issues... seriously Kolkata jara pore ache... large number of them are staying because of family reasons...

Avoid politics and political people then West Bengal can grow

Kolkatae bahut package kom dae ..r Bangalir sab bisoye political mentality er jonne anek dayi....sab bisoye politics niye ase...sab phaltu projects gulo kolkata theke hoi...IBm er ek somoy development centre chilo...ekhon r nai... Bangalore, Hyderabad e start up companies gulo ato bhalo package dae Kolkata jiboneo bhabte parbe na..ekta 30 age er chele 40 lacs package jekhane same age 8lacs niye kolkatae oi god badha mnc guloe pore ache..just because of home sickness,no alternative options to change r family to achai...Kolkata gan ,bajna,kobita tarpor prosenjit rituparna egulo niye bhalo ache

পশ্চিমবঙ্গে ২০১০ সাল পর্যন্ত ঋণ ছিল ,২ লক্ষ কোটি টাকা।২০১১ থেকে ২০২৩ পর্যন্ত ৪ লক্ষ কোটি টাকা ঋণ। এ পর্যন্ত ৬ লক্ষ কোটি টাকা ঋণ হয়ে গেছে।উন্নতি যা হয়েছে সবাই দেখছেন।এই ঋণ শোধ করতে হবে সুদে আসলে এই বঙ্গের জনগণকে।রাজ্যের রাজনৈতিক পরিবেশ দেখে শিল্প আসতে চাচ্ছে না।এখন আমি অনেক কিছু করে দিয়েছি মনোভাব ছেড়ে সবাইকে নিয়ে শিল্পের জন্য দরবার করতে হবে।আমিত্ব বর্জন না হলে কোন উন্নতি হবে না।মানসিক পরিবর্তনের অত্যন্ত প্রয়োজন।

Very well explained 👍

10 years dhore TMC r ei natok cholche...so etai cholbe..

this govt has fàiled miserably. go and check the transformation done in Odisha.

All the big Electronics MNC already setup Industry in South India, like Apple, Intel,Google, Amazon,Faxocon, TATA, Tesla, Hyundai many more

এপাং ওপাং ঝপাং / সুর ধরেছে পটাঙ ব্যাঙ ডাকে গ্যাঙ গ্যাঙ / হাতির কতো বড় ঠ্যাং l l হরে কর কমবা / গরু ডাকে হাম্বা

কি কমেন্ট করবো। কিচ্ছু বলার নেই। সব কিছু একটা মহিলার জন্য

Not city of joy..It has become City of chor...Supra das bombay

ভুল বলছেন চাকরি বিক্রি ,রেশন scam .chop silpo এগুলো bhulle চলবে?

Kolkata is corrupted city , only bhote bank we are shifted, haidrabad ,

Khoob sundor explanation dilen aapni. Thank you for your valuable opinion. We all love our Bengal. Please guide for the betterment of West Bengal.

Factor Mamata begum

Work and political culture of WB makes industrialists stay away from the state. The state and the people have to be very proactive and practical. An enviourment of sustainable business development is must.

Pc bhaipo sob ses kore dilo

Konta scientific explanation ?? Olpo Olpo kore khawa ?? Wow . Mathai kono sense ache ki bolcho ?

When it is told that 'once Bengal was the zenith of business and economics' - it seldom attributed because of the industrialist gene in the local bengalis, but mostly due to the advent and expansion of the business empire by the East India Company, more predominantly by the Birishers and Westerners. They made Calcutta as the Capital of the colonial British India. This expansion saw more urge for the different communities in the country other than bengalis to come and associate themselves to flourish with the similar business mentality. Bengalis on the other hand, shuned such economic proliferation except for the few sporadic families and groups.... Bengalis on the other hand choose the other side of their skill, that is to oppose and revolt against the oppression of the British colonial regime, and thus created a plethora of politico revolutionary activists whom we fondly remember and revert as freedom fighters ( every family in Bengal would take the pride in naming some of their forefathers as freedom fighters!). It is this mutation of the Bengali gene which attributed to shunning of Capitslist outlook and become the masters of fighting for the oppressed class. Even long after the Colonial British er left India giving Indian the Freedom , the Bengali psyche continued to get going with the anti power/ anti capitalist thought process which manifested in taking a negative and revolutionary way of thinking against the Political power ruling at the Centre Govt. Generations after generations ( more than 50 yrs) continued with such anti Central Govt power system and kept on remaining detached from the benefits of aligning with the Central Govt power politics and confined with petty regional political agendas.... As political power is anonymous with the Industrial and over all economic development of a country/ State, it for the same sole reason the Bengalis are seen to be a negative energy for industrial and economic proliferation and the State of Bengal as a negative destination for Business except for store house of cheap labourers and a bunch self centered parochial political muscleman dictating the future doomsday of this community.

Amazing Episode❤❤

Dada anek din bad apnar video dekhlam ar banglar sotto ghotona dekhalen khub valo laglo Apni sotto ghotona dekhalen bole ami apnar video dekhlam

আমি গর্বিত আমি বাংলাদেশি হিন্দু আকর্ষণ বৃদ্ধি পেয়েছে বাংলাদেশ এবং ঢাকার

Excellent review, thanks

If we saw the tarpaulins covered hawkers occupied footpaths of Kolkata speaks that there is no governance. People take pride in road side vendors shopping but they actually spoil the commerce and business of the established shops.

Very very true words and complete write thoughts 🤔💭

Finally someone is speaking out

Singur er por WB e factory korar sahos ke dekhabe.. Wb er thke Mh, Tn, Ka, gj, hyd ekhn 100 yrs egiye. Ar up and odisha ekhn 30 yrs egiye

Yes Dada, I have seen your earlier video but I don't want to tell anything. But today I am telling you your view point is 100% correct and fully agree with you. Jai Hind

Absolutely well said asha kori west bengal apnar ei report tar upore najor debe nahole aaro besi kore postabhe...!!

Very nice video

Rebel thoughts of Bengalees are the main cause of Bengal Back foot.

I loved this video. This is the truth. Nevertheless many things are happening we are not out of negativity completely as can be seen from some mischievous and uneducated comments, this aura is definitely missing. Many industries are happening, no doubt about it but we are not in the mindshare of people and it's easy to lose but very difficult to gain. Few great things like IB companies like JP and others should have opened some big centers here and building the craze. I feel like even though we are trying to reach the top we are missing somewhere badly on all fronts and successive governments have to responsibility for it.

Chal, Bali, Goru, Koyla, Deadbody theke ektu sore giye Politicians and Govt should now really brainstorm and work hard to make Bengal Industry friendly by improvising policies and reducing corruption.😢😢

বাঙালি দের শক্তি চাই. সেটা হতে পারে. একমাত্র একে অপরের সাথে থেকে

West Bengal developing Politics Industry 😂

Better bring cocktail govt for the development of City of Sorrow.

Lost of Shutdown Industry in WB like Kalyani, Hooghly, Asnasol, Howrah and govt poor land policy,

Poor governance, appeasement politics and institutionalised corruption where ministers , administrators and political mercenaries are looting common people, no sane industrialist will ever think of investing in this state. 2011 was the biggest mistake people of West Bengal made.

Long time opposite parties of central govt who are anti Industry minded also, are ruling bengal.

West Bengal has recommended the inclusion of 87 castes , including 80 from the Muslim Community in the Central List of Other Backward Class (OBCs). This has prompted the National Comission of Backward Classes (NCBC) to seek records dating back to the Imperial Gazetteer to check the status of these caste in British India . The NCBC has expressed concern over the high (Disprortionate) number of Muslim castes being recommended for inclusion in a Hindu-majority state. The Mamta Govt is most probably preparing their fake ppt to ensure reservation to 80 Muslim castes compared to 7 from Hindus . Why the hell Bengal government is getting reduced from meritocratic state to Bihari beggi#g mindset of reservation politics , 500 Rs alms lokhibhandar , club funding politics , syndicates , Institutionalised commission (broker) ecosystem throughout the state . Please save bangla what are you guys doing 😔 You are not Bihar your socio-political landscape is turning into Bihari @b&urdity .

Very well pointed out bro..

kichui hobe na..karon bangali sobjanta gowar type r jaat..khub i gyaan paapi..tai jonyo bangali r bhikka r mentality i cholbe....

Bengal has witnessed FALL since 1911 . Cpim didn't help industries to Grow till 2006 and FALL down 2011 . TMC started its Journey with TATA's expulsion Haven't Heard any Menifesto Form BJP declaring Central project for Bengal !

sotti ekdom straight cut ebong chancha chola description dilen, jeta bolar sahosh keu dekhay na.well done.

With all respect dada tomra je ei sob Investment er video banao ekbar first to till today sob investment gulo sum up koro dekhbe Maharastra, Gujarat, Karnataka combine korleo eto investment hoyni jeta totally on paper ..in practicality and reality total different 10,000 Cr industry bole 100 cr plant hochhe

Very well explained

To develop Bengal drive out TMC first. THat is the first requirement

Good analysis 👍

Well said ❤

Reality ta janun, health and medical treatment er jonyo Kolkatar/WB er lok kyano Vellore etc choley jacche bolun to? Bengal has lost most of their trust and goodwill...

The Hardest Truth is Now Kolkata is a dying city 🥺😢💔

Mamata morlei kolkata egobe

Only Kolkata, is there any other town to be make a city

Sayan da - Utter truth✌️

রাজ্যপালের সঙ্গে ঝগড়া করা আর পলিটিক্যাল নোংরামি প্রধান কারন।

Excellent analysis