Willow & Elvie Pumps currently on sale until 17Jul23! Up to 25% off 🤱🏻Willow Pumps: www.shareasale.com/u.cfm?d=649107&m=89326&u=2114208 🍼Elvie Pump: click.linksynergy.com/fs-bin/click?id=B8Vve8cmYD4&offerid=963262.8&type=3&subid=0
@@laureenkarbarz4434 I’m finally going to order the Willow on 3/18😩 I asked a friend who has twins if she used either n she actually had both. She said she liked the Willow, that it had better suction. I also read where if you use the bags with the Willow you can do more with your baby without worrying of the milk spilling! I’m waiting to order because I have an appointment with the lactation specialist and I’m going to ask her to help me decide on the flange size. The size I measure for, I feel like I get less milk with my current pump then I do with the larger size. I did however order the baby Buddha pump..amazing!! Such a powerful lil pump! But I’m exclusively pumping since returning to work n so I need to be able to do more with my baby instead of having her wait while I finish pumping..sorry for the novel😅 if you want me to let you know what I think of the pump once I receive it I can def do that!
@@melindaandon3249 yess let me know please!!! I’m leaning more towards the ELVIE ! I asked a bunch of women from the bf groups I’m in on fb and pregnancy groups and a lot of them prefer the ELVIE Bc with the willow you need to keep buying bags & spending money vs w/ ELVIE everything comes with it basically
@@laureenkarbarz4434 Really?! I just read more bad reviews on the Willow 😣 I’m already somewhat of an under supplier so I don’t think it’s worth the risk (read a few where people’s supply dropped with the Willow) I think I’ll just stick with the babybuddha. My baby will be 6 months in a few days so I think I can make it work for 6 more
This is such a great video and goes into so much detail! It is hard to get a good idea of the similarities and differences just by looking at them online and even reading about other people's experiences. Since everyone responds differently to different pumps, it is hard to know what to consider as a pro or con with each pump. I think I would go with the Elvie when I eventually decide to purchase one. For the money, I feel like you get way more especially if the bags are not a deal-breaker for you. I also liked that the Elvie had a lower profile making them seem more concealed for wearing in public. @mommysharkuncensored
DO NOT BUY THE WILLOW PUMP UNLESS...you are ok with spending $.50 per bag because the containers absolutely do not work! I bought two sets because the first set went haywire on me, and started saying I was pumping 4 oz in three minutes, which of course I wasn't. Then, the second set started doing the same thing. Now I have a set that don't work at all! I have low milk supply so spending $.50 for one oz of milk is absolutely not worth it. I regret buying this, and I recommend you REALLY consider all this before spending thousands of dollars on this, because you will! You've been warned.
These pumps each have so many benefits! I love that the willow can be pumped in any position but I like that the Elvie comes with all the parts you need
Great video! I have been waiting for a Willow 3.0 vs Elvie comparison and so far you are the only person I know with this video out. Thank you for all the details. Because I got the elvie for a much less expensive price (vs Willow) I will most likely keep it. You are right - unfortunately pumps work differently for everyone. Thank you for all your hard work and research! I plan to EP for my next child as that’s what worked best with my first. 💙 For any other mamas out there - I was able to get the Elvie for $360 at buybuybaby a couple weeks ago - the double pump was on sale for $425 then I had an additional 15% off registry completion coupon.
Haleyy Breezy it is excluded from every coupon EXCEPT the registry completion coupon. I was told that coupon had zero restrictions. I was able to use it for other major brands too like the 4moms mama roo! It worked for their clearance items as well if your local buybuybaby has a clearance/open box section.
I found your videos so detailed and helpful. First I watched when you compared the 3 pumps. Then I narrowed it down to the Willow and Elvie and watched THAT video. I think I’ve made my decision based on the comparisons that you did (pumping parts, suction, battery life, etc.) Thank you for helping this soon to be mama to her first baby girl!! (I already have a 2 year old son).
At first I didn't want to consider willow since the bags and containers are an extra cost and extra waste of plastic. But after watching your video, it occurs to me that I want to use this pump mainly on the go, in flights or outdoor. With the situation these days, contamination became a new concern. I really like the elvie but hope they would have a closed container option available just like willow.
200 hours🤯 wow. I’m there with my spectra pump already and I’m only 5 months pp. I also do not exclusively pump.. usually nurse so to me that’s a short lifespan. The willow looks nicer though
Can you pump only using the Elvie? I’ve seen people say that they use a wall plug in pump at home and the elvie for on the go. If I only use my Elvie will it reduce my supply? I’ve seen people say that also.
Thank you so much for this video! You must get tired of comparing all these pumps! But for moms who are making the decision when it's so expensive it's so helpful!
Do you find these completely drain your breast? I am EP with my 7 week old and I struggle with low-ish supply that I'm building up after mastitis. My main issue is that, using my spectra s2, can sometimes struggle to completely empty without massage, dangle pumping, etc. Looking forward to watching your flange size video to see if that's part of the problem for me!
Ok so before watching this video, i went with the elvie for some reason, i guess bc it seemed to be more popular on youtube amongst vloggers. I did not like it as there were just too many parts and i always had a hard time getting the suction right, so i’d barely get much milk. And yes i did try different flange sizes. So i borrowed my sister’s willow, and I like it much much better. Less annoying parts to clean and assemble, and the suctioning works perfect for me. Both pumps require some effort to put on, but the willow was just much simpler for me. Also, my output was much more with willow. I have also heard the elvie can’t be used as your primary pump as it affected some people’s supply, whereas the willow can be used as a primary pump and is actually targeted for more output. I also know someone who used the willow to exclusively pump, and she said her supply increased. Also, the bags are actually quite convenient as you can just freeze it right away!
I've been looking for a way to compare the Elvie and Willow 3.0 and this video was awesome! Thanks for going into so much detail and knowing most of the questions I would ask before I'd thought of them!
This helped me decide on getting the Elvie! Really hope to win your giveaway! I’m a teacher and soon to be mom of 3 wild little boys! (5, 19m, due in March!)
thank you so much for comparing these two! it’s so easy to find reviews but not a comparison. this video was awesome and had exactly all the information i was looking for. thank you💕
Thanks for the detailed comparison! I’ve been researching and reading reviews and comparisons for weeks and this video really helped me to decide! I was originally wanting the Willow but after tons of researching I’m going to try the Elvie! Only thing I wished to get out of the video that wasn’t said was which you personally prefer. I know it’s different for every body and it’s personal preference but it’s still nice to know which works best for people.
Thank you so much for this video! I am pregnant with my second, and I had a problematic pumping experience the first go round due to being really sick postpartum, and therefore, a severe underproducer. I am a nurse, so you made it a no brainer for me and the willow, but you went in deep while keeping it understandable! I am 99% sold on the Willow after watching your video. Thanks again!
For anyone reading this please be aware that the Willow suction is crazy strong and it hurt me so bad. It can cause nipple damage while some people love it. I really wish I would have gotten the Elvie. Now I have to try to sell it!
I’ve been so torn on which pump to get so I searched RU-vid for a comparison, that’s when I stumbled on this video. The content was exactly what I was looking for! The in-depth review of both pumps made it easy to pick. Yes I’d love to try both but that just isn’t possible for me but after this video I decided to go with willow due to the bag & container option! Thank you so much!
M E I have the Elvie right now. And I'm so disappointed in how easily it spills. It's honestly so frustrating especially since you wear it under your shirt and then you see your milk coming through and you have a giant WET SPOT. You have to be so careful to A- not move to much or to quickly ' and B - to put it together properly. You have to put the bottom piece on FIRST and then the plate that goes against your breast otherwise it will leak like CRAZY. It seems the rubber doesn't connect properly by doing plate first. But either way. You don't have as much movement freedom as you would expect. I had the Ameda Maya already which was amazing because it was wireless. So I could charge it and go. I just have to wear the pump bra and a cover if I'm around people in the house. Yes the tubes suck but the Ameda Maya is cheaper and spills less. AND rechargeable. They now make the Ameda Maya mayo which is a cheaper version because it takes batteries. So if you're going to spend this type of money go for the willow. For sure. And look for reusable bags for sale on Facebook marketplace.
Has Willow seriously not figured out how to charge both simultaneously for a $500 pricepoint?! At least throw in an extra charger until they correct this, Jesus that's so unacceptable.
So I've been trying to figure out which one to get and my biggest concern is which one is going to empty the breast best? My left gets clogged ducts constantly. It's a daily thing. And it takes a high level of suction outside of heat massage and determination to get it to empty. does anyone have any experience when it comes to these with clogged duct issues?
I have a spectra S1 and when I’m I simulation mode I typically do a 4 or 5 level suction. What pump do you think is more comparable to what I’m using currently? I’m EP and just would like freedom to not have to sit down every time I’m pumping which is 6-9x a day.
Elvie seems like the best choice. Willow seems like they’re out to make a buck with how many extras you’re required to purchase if you want to just use it! That’s so frustrating! I’ve been looking into a wireless pump for when baby #2 comes because I’ll have a toddler and pumping last time was so miserable because I couldn’t do anything else while I had these bottles sticking off my body and was attached to the wall. Not to mention how much room all the supplies take up if you want to travel with a regular pump. The willow seems like nothing but a hassle and a pain in my wallet.
Been researching breast pumps for over a year now and really wanted the Elvie. But I had wiped it from my list of options because of all the problems women have been having (auctions and leaks.) But recently started looking at it again and I am so glad I did. That mention at the end about little micro improvements has solidified my decision. Thanks so much.
I just wish it wasn’t so expensive. I’ve been using the Medela freestyle and since I’ll be going back to work the Elvie would be a much better option; I would be able to work and pump at the same time.
Thank You for the comparison because I'm really debating on how I can pump on the go but the best value for my money and have it be useful for when I go back to work soon. My first feeding journey was rough but want to go through longer this time.
This was literally the perfect comparison video. Thank you for the detailed comparison. This is exactly what I needed. I think I’m going to go for the Elvie pump. Too bad I missed your promo code! But I’m also not due until Jan 2021 so I will wait patiently for a potential promo code!
Thank you!! The breakdown of each feature with the charts was so helpful! This review was so thorough, it was like watching all the other reviews combined into one. Leaning towards the Elvie!
Thank you for the help information! I am debating on which one to get since I am going back to work next month and my baby is 1 month and 2 weeks all. I am a hairstylist and one of those will be so helpful ☺
I read that the first willow had a bag issue problem which was if air got into the bag it would read it as milk and you would have to use a whole new bag even though it was not full. Did that make sense 😄? This would be a huge deciding factor, any mama know about this?
I would love your advice on what one you would prefer. My insurance covers both partially and they both would cost $365. What one did you find yourself using more? What app did you like more? Thanks
Thanks for all the great info! Ultimately the Elvie holds 5oz and willow only 4 soooo I feel like I have to go with the Elvie....I’m a major cow when it comes to breast feeding!
Thanks so much for this video! It was definitely helpful! I am leaning towards the Elvie but I would like the option to use it in every position for my night feeding. Please let me know if you found a hack for the Elvie? Bc versatility is my main concern.
Thank you for the information. I like that you exclusively pump. I would rather take advice from someone who uses these products regularly. I would love to try it but I just can't find the $500 for the elvie. Is it even reasonable to just buy one?
This video is insanely helpful! I have been wondering about the true differences between these two pumps and you answered absolutely every question I had...and then some. I feel like I can really make an informed decision about which pump will work better for my needs. THANKFULLY you’re giveaway is for the one I want so I’m totally “pumped” about that 😅 (sorry, couldn’t resist the pun). Thank you so much for your videos!
Man... I would love to win an Elvie! Ive never won anything! We thought we were done having kids 12 years ago and we just welcomed our new surprise baby girl a month ago! Wearable pumps weren't even a thing back then and now im obsessing over them! I only had a hand pump before which i really hated and it gave me problems. This time my insurance sent me a Spectra, which i love! But it would be great to not have to be attached to the wall lol
I am a mother of a 4 year old and a 2 month old. I am a working mom as a radiation oncology veterinary technician for our fur babies. I work for a busy hospital and it is hard to get away to pump. I also am trying to increase my supply for my little one so I believe getting one of these pumps would help me put my mind at ease knowing that I can feed my child while working. I had no idea that there are so many parts to the willow. The extra money for the bags makes me want a Elvie. #suckitcancer
Question for your video on using inserts - if it hasn't already been filmed! - if you are much smaller and purchase the 21mm flanges, will you still be able to fit inserts into them if you need to size down even more? (are there even inserts available that are smaller than 21mm?)
Hi Sara, have you had any issues with it? Is the suction good? I purchased the elvie but one is broken and won't even turn on and so far I'm not too impressed so considering trying the willow?
Kahli Bond I had such a hard time deciding between the 2 pumps, but I am happy I went with the Willow. I am due in July with my 3rd baby, so I haven’t technically used it yet but when I received it, I wanted to know how the suction felt and it is soooo comfortable compared to the other Medela pumps I have used before. The generation 3.0 is suppose to be a lot gentler than the previous 2 models. I also walked on the treadmill and did a little workout and they felt super secure and did not move at all. Let me tell ya though...they make you look like Dolly Parton so if I am wearing them in public, I am definitely going to wear a scarf or nursing cover. Hopefully this helps a little!
@@saracaminiti7095 when you say it's more comfortable, like does it still suck well!? I want good suction. The elvie seemed sooo low suction I got fed up. Thanks for your reply 😊
This video has been really helpful. I have been researching a lot about these two pumps since I am heading back to work and I won't have much time to be tied to the wall, since work at a hospital you never know what will happened during a shift. Thank you so much!!!
For me, everything is pointing towards the Elvie EXCEPT that you can pump while laying down with the Willow 🤔 That'd be so nice to sleep while it's pumping haha
This video is SUPER helpful! I currently have the Elvie, but it’s not working out for me so I’ve been considering the Willow but wasn’t sure how the 3.0 compared to the Elvie. Thanks for the info!
Thank you for your comparison, I think you're still one of the only ones showing Elvie vs. Gen 3.0 on Willow after 6 months of the newest willow on the market. I'd like to see a updated comparison between the two apps user ability and accuracy if that's available.
This is an awesome video! I am pregnant with twins and am really wanting an elvie or a willow. Your video really helped me lean more towards the elvie. It is very informative and gave me all of the info I was looking for. Very much appreciated!
First time posting a comment 🙌 The Willow vs Elvie video is soooo informative and helpful as I want to choose either of these for my new baby due in March 2021 😊 this video goes through everything I had a question about! For my last baby 11/2018 I chose a Freemie Independence for the hands free conceal cups and whisper quiet pump, to pump in my mail truck on my breaks/lunch. Wirefree is going to be so exciting, a new learning curve but I will look forward to pumping again :)
@@MommyShark You are so welcome! I've watched so many videos trying to see if I really wanted one and which one I want. This helped me make my decision
Do you feel like flange sizing for the willow is the same as with traditional sizing/flanges? Like would I be the same size flange in the willow as Medela or spectra flanges? Or do you feel like you have to size down or up?
From what I read on the Willow, it starts off loud while it latches then gets much quieter. Was the noise shown in the video the machine just trying to latch?
Thanks for making all these comparison videos they are so informative. I have decided to go with the Elvie I'm due in August with my second son. I can't wait to try it and I hope I love it. Also you were one of my inspirations on starting my own channel. If you have the time I would if you checked my channel out. Thanks again!
I just checked out one of your videos!! That’s so awesome ! Congrats and I’m so glad I inspire in ways I haven’t even tried to inspire ! Stick around , I’ll be starting an entrepreneurship series on how I grew my channel , hopefully it can help :)
I pump for like 1 and a half years which pump get alot of breast infections if i dont pump the breast that the babe dosnt feed on and i engorge alot so thats my main thing i need for when im out and about in the stores it seems the babe is always hungry when im out and about even though i feed before i go out but i take to long in stores i also need for if im out of town and am only driver i can drive and pump to feed baby . What product do you think is best for me in your experience i also dont like alot of parts. To clean at night lets be honest who wants to deal with that at 12 am 2 am 4 am not worried about the price worried about less parts easier to use in day or night and plus best suchtion since my boobs get enormiouse and i get infections if i dont pump enough milk out plz help since u have experience thanks 🥰🥰🥰
This is a super detailed comparison video of both pumps. One of the best I've come across here on YT. It's helped me get a better idea of which pump might be best for me. I love how detailed you are and love the hacks you share.
-I had the Willow post my 2nd baby in 2020. Im a nurse and busy, so the Willow was very convenient though I looked like Dolly Parton (love you lady but it just wasnt for me), the Willow is heavier as well. It was working fine and I got the hang of fitting it correctly, the app was great, etc. I used it daily as my baby had been a NICU baby and didn't take to breastfeeding. After only 3 months, it would incorrectly error and read air as milk pumped. It was bizarre! I got help from the Willow company, it was issues like soaking the parts in vinegar bath etc, I tried it all but in the end had to buy more containers and flipped between the reusuable containers and bags. I ended up getting frustrated and stopped pumping altogether l, I was so tired. It was so great while it lasted and I did my insurance to cover the entire cost. I think this time, I may get the Elvie to try. Willow had good suction with adjusts for suction but sometimes I felt like it didn't completely empty versus the corded Medela hospital grade pump I used sometimes. I'm hoping that perhaps the Elvie being gentler will be more relaxing for me thereby I may be able to empty better...I think I was stressed and the Willow pump is constantly suction versus the more natural pull motion of the Elvie. Thank you for your reviews, I trust them and watched them extensively before I tried Willow last time. This time I'll try Elvie and see.
This video was extremely helpful!! I took screenshots of the chart to help me make my decision. Thanks for being so thorough and detailed! This was much more helpful than any other review I watched or read due to covering every aspect of each pump.
hello mommy shark! im a fan here..in the future when youre all done pumping and have no use of your pumps anymore..would you mind donating them here in the philippines?im a nurse at a govt hospital.i teach moms the importance of breastfeeding and pumping but our hosp couldnt afford to purchase pumps..so im not sure if im giving them any help at all..sad..just maybe you would want to do that in the future.thank you
Ladies don't forget that you can use insurance to help cover so of the cost of your pumps! The willow is $219 for your cost on some places depending on ur insurance
Does the Elvie container seal when you take it out? Ex: I’m in the car I just pumped and I want to take out the milk collector and put it in the cooler. Meanwhile I have a backup container to pump the other boob.
This video was really helpful thank you so much. I wonder if you know if these two pumps work for inverted or flat nipple? If yes, which one works better? I would really appreciated your or any mama’s response. Thanks :)
I got the ameda Mya and I actually have the spectra as my main pump! Honestly in never use the ameda because it's not more convenient at all. It is just in my pocket while I have a whole mess of tubes etc dangling all over...I also find the suction is just not as good as my spectra so I just don't bother. I got it with insurance so I wasn't that committed to making it work, which is a factor with all pumps!
Are you able to reheat the milk in the bags (like in a bottle warmer?). I'm wondering because I want to use the bags occasionally if I get one of these but I was an undersupplier last time so I would like to do the re-using bags trick until they are full enough. I also have high lipase so read that I can scald my milk using a bottle warmer. It would be convenient if I could do this in the bags...
Willow has fixed the stimulation mode problem with this version. It will go off at the 2 min mark for those that don’t hit the .5. You may consider revising your video to include the correct information.
If you own the willow and your not getting the output you get with the spectra would you buy the elvie i hate being stuck to the wall with a house full of kids
Great video!! This was such a well organized valuable comparison at every level!! Love learning from other youtube mommas :) Thanks for the wonderful content!!
Hi, I'm new here and subscribed your channel and following instagram to learn more. Thank you Mommy Shark 🦈 for helping us and to see the differences of the breast pumps. I'm glad I came here. 😊
Hi lobe the video. I am from UK. Do I still get this discount pls? If so how do I proceed to obtain this I have subscribed to follow you on you tube but I am not really clued in this new following stuff so pls let me know lol 😂 xx
