'With Satan Himself By My Side!' - Jekyll & Hyde Comparison 

I love how Warlow shows the absolute joy Hyde feels about just being alive. Yun Seok-Young looked like he was having fun too.The other versions all feel like they focus too much on showing how evil and mean Hyde can be, and ignore his joy. I love them making crosses with the vial though👌

When I hear that "I feel I'll live on forever" part I don't think Hyde should be attacking anyone. It's too triumphant for that, and that's why Warlow is the winner here.

Anthony Warlow IS A GOD. Geronimo Raunch has a very appealing voice and dramatic sound. And Yum-Seok-young stage preformance was fantastic and emotional with the acts of throwing his cane and hat aside and he looked like he had so much fun toasting the audience with his mischeif as Hyde. Very well done

Definitely Warlow

I love how there's a whole bunch of theatre actors the average person wouldn't have heard of, then David Hasselhoff just there.

3:06 Can we just talk about how actually awesome this performance is? The way the dude writhes on the ground is so perfect, and Hyde is just so down-to-business, yet carefree and fun at the same time? It's awesome! Plus, the way he dumps the alcohol, and then just tosses the bottle behind him? And they used an actual liquid instead of just faking it? I LOVE IT! Plus, the fact that they used real fire (I know some of the others did as well). The contrast between the blue ambiance with the bright orange flame was so contrasting, and breathtaking. An amazing job, truly.

0:35 (Anthony Warlow) 1:25 (Rob Evan) 2:17 (Sebastian Bach) 4:40 (Paul Nicholas) 7:35 (Constantine Maroulis) 8:57 (Aleks Knezyich) They ooze more talent than I ever could have

I love Warlow's rendition, too, but wish some of the purists in the comments would pipe down a bit - he's had the advantage (unlike most of the others here) of recording the segment this in a studio, probably with more than one take and definitely no violent blocking. Pity we never actually got to see him play the role onstage, outside of the occasional concert,,, he definitely made a lovely Phantom. Thank you for making this video!! As someone slowly getting more and more into this musical this is such a helpful and informative watch. So many different voices and takes, on top of the constant directorial changes this show has gone through over the years! A bit sad that Ethan Freeman isn't here, though!! aaa :(

The performance at 7:39 was simply amazing, but ABSOLUTELY NO ONE CAN TOP THE MAN, THE MYTH, THE LEGEND, ANTHONY WARLOW

Haven't seen any, and I seem to keep coming back to this video. So, timestamps: 0:09 - Chuck Wagner 0:33 - Anthony Warlow 1:00 - Robert Cuccioil 1:24 - Rob Evans 1:49 - Guy LeMonnier 2:15 - Sebastian Bach 2:39 - David Hasselhoff 3:04 - Laszlo Molnar 3:30 - Thomas Borchert 3:54 - Drew Sarich 4:18 - Takeshi Kaga 4:39 - Paul Nicholas 5:05 - Jo Seung-Woo 5:29 - Ryu Jung-Han 5:53 - Hong Kwang-Ho 6:17 - Werner Auer 6:41 - Chris Murray 7:08 - Marti Pellow 7:36 - Constantine Maroulis (Personal favourite) 8:02 - Geronimo Rauch 8:28 - Yun Seok-Young 8:54 - Aleks Knezevich

Ramin Karimloo should sings this he’s got the voice to do it

Whoever the cymbal player was during Guy's performance was having the time of their life. 1:49 Edited to add time stamp

For everyone talking about David hasselhoff there’s a different video of him (same part) that I think is better if you want to look for it it’s just the full confrontation song

Incoming longest comment ever! I wanted to give my opinions on these performances and got _way_ too into it! That being said, all of the actors featured here are incredibly talented and have worked super hard to get where they are today. I am by no means an expert, just a geek who's never known life without musical theater but is way too technical about it because I was always too shy to actually perform! Yay! SO HERE WE GO- - Chuck Wagner (0:10) has a great voice, but it's just a little too clean, which makes it feel like he's still in Jekyll mode here. - Anthony Warlow (0:33) is the clearest for obvious reasons, it almost feels like cheating to give a critique. I love him in this role though. Best performance of his in this show is Transformation. - Robert Cuccioli's (1:01) voice is great and he's fun to watch! I love the sexy leg he does in this recording! - Rob Evan (1:25) is my favorite by far! His tone, vibrato, and growl are perfectly balanced, and his Hyde feels truly unhinged! Not shown here is the final high note of this song, which Rob _always_ knocks out of the park! - Why do I feel like Guy LeMonnier (1:48) got mugged by the drummer after this performance? What I could hear of him sounded pretty decent. - Sebastian Bach (2:15) looks like he's having the time of his life! Maybe not my favorite vocal performance, but his Crazy Harry energy makes up for it! - I can't take David Hasselhoff (2:40) seriously. His acting is so ostentatious, and his vibrato is hideously overdone. It sounds less like singing and more like a nervous chihuahua. Maybe the only performance here that I actively dislike. - Laszlo Molnar's (3:02) take is interesting to me. His voice is really nice- you can hear a smile in it, and the casual way he kills the priest, punctuated with that little bit of growl at the end is kind of chilling! - I wish the audio in Thomas Borchert's (3:30) recording was clearer. It's hard to get an idea of his actual vocal performance. However, I love his big dopey grin! Cheerful/playful Hyde is one of my favorite interpretations of the character! - Drew Sarich (3:53) was a little underwhelming, but an interesting casting choice nonetheless. You don't see a lot of Hydes with a lighter tone to their voice. I'd like to see more of his performance, especially since this scene can be physically taxing, before I pass too harsh a judgement on him. - Takeshi Kaga (4:18) has a downright impressive voice. I'd like to see how he'd perform this scene and hear him in a live setting. - Paul Nicholas's (4:39) performance sounded like it hurt. Not that it sounded bad, but it sounded like his voice would be wrecked by the end of the night. The staccato was also an interesting choice. - Jo Seung-Woo's (5:04) voice is good, but there was a distinct dissonance between his theatrical body language and flat facial expression. Threw it off a little for me. - Ryu Jung-Han (5:30) takes the previous performance and sticks the expressions. Also, fantastic vibrato. - On top of a gorgeous voice, I love how menacing Hong Kwang-Ho (5:54) looks. He looks like he'd knock my lights out for breathing too loud. - Confession: I have a soft spot for German musical performances. German is my first second language and musicals are how I learned the majority of my German vocab and pronunciation while I was studying it in high school, which sparked a life-long passion for languages (and a linguistics degree, but I'm not here to talk about stress). That sentimentality smooths out Werner Auer's (6:18) performance a little for me, which is overall pretty great, just not my favorite. - Chris Murray's (6:43) performance is fun. His voice is closer to the top of my list- while it isn't terribly menacing, it's just lovely to listen to. A little lackadaisical on the physical side, but the blocking with Hyde just tossing the priest around is hilarious. - Marti Pellow (7:08) seems like he'd be amazing if the recording didn't sound like it was drowning in jello. - Constantine Maroulis (7:35). . . I'm not going to lie, I hated this arrangement when I first heard it. It's certainly a choice. Little to no actual Hyde in there, but if listened to without the lense of the story, it's a solid performance. - I hate saying negative things about people who are obviously very talented, but I have yet to see a Geronimo Rauch (8:02) performance that really stuck with me. He's obviously an experienced singer, every note is on point, but his cadence feels so flat, in this and Phantom (which was the video I watched right before this one, funny enough). - Yun Seok-Young's (8:29) voice, on the other hand, scares me in the best way. Gorgeous, and that one screamed line near the end is fantastic against the backdrop of his otherwise chipper demeanor. - Then there's Aleks Knezevich (8:55). I think I like his voice best out of the actors I hadn't heard of before this video (which was most of them, but still). He genuinely sounds -and in the photo looks- like a sophisticated gentleman who's flipped his lid and gone on a killing spree. I love his pronunciation and tone, and I'd like to see his live performance and hear more of his work. - Bonus: the other comments got me curious about Joey Richter and CHRIST ON A BIKE I HAVEN'T THOUGHT ABOUT AVPM IN YEARS. Voices I'd like to hear in this role: - Ramin Karimloo. I think he's overrated in Phantom (Crawford fangirl, sorry), but I agree with other commenters that he has enough power in his voice to potentially pull this off. - Terrence Mann. He has a _gorgeous_ voice, and is a versatile actor, having played the Beast/Prince Adam, Rum Tum Tugger, Inspector Javert, and Dr. Frank N Furter, among others. He'd be gold in this role. - Marko Hietala. We've heard Floor Jansen's cover of Dangerous Game, now we need a Nightwish cover of Alive/Reprise. This man has been a staple in the Finnish metal scene for nearly 40 years, underwent a botched polyp removal on his vocal chords in the '90s, and still sounds positively _incredible_- outstanding range, gorgeous vibrato and gentle tone in softer songs, and he can growl and scream like a beast! He would _crush_ this song! - Con O'neill. It sounds ridiculous but I'm only half-joking. He's an accomplished singer and actor, with a very unique voice. He's got a raspy, reedy speaking voice able to pull off an intimidating growl, and a soft, clear tenor when singing. Not to mention, his acting is phenomenal and he is nothing if not dedicated to his craft. The role of Jekyll and Hyde would be right up his alley whether musical or not. If you made it this far, thank you for entertaining the sleep-deprived ramblings of a madwoman, and please feel free to scream at me if you think my opinions are trash or I got something factually wrong! Edited for formatting and timestamps!

Anthony Warlow is just superior, God material but for second place, in my opinion the best performance was Jo Seung-woo. Now I love Korean musicals, evan if I dont speak a word there is something hypnotic about the language, ig that's why k-pops so popular. But not only that he really captured the passion and child-like-joy hyde has, just to be alive and for his actions to have consequence. Alot of these performances were amazing though hyde is such a fun character to play and get to be that perfect theatre level of over the top lol

Wow, some of these arrangements have a bizarre sense of rhythm.

that only dislike is from a Jekyll

They were all amazing, but Robert Cuccioli really looked confident and 100% joyous being Hyde.

Anthony Warlow will always be the best Jekyll and Hyde to me. i wish there were any of his live performances on the internet

Honestly Yun Seok-young went so hard into it and made it SO fucking good

English: Warlow German: Murray

I have never heard “Marti Pellow” sing this but I think is emotion completely matched that of warlow and is one of my new favorites. Too many of these singers completely missed that Hyde isn’t a monster, he’s simply our other half. The one we hide away. Hyde is what we would be if we didn’t have moral instinct. It’s Jekyll freedom. It’s bewilders me how so many people actually playing the part miss that and just start growling instead!

my favorites are Anthony Warlow, Robert Cuccioli, Molnár Laszlo, Hong Kwang Ho and Werner Auer. I feel they exude Hyde's raw passion for life and his craft. and their voices are just so goddamn good

Why did I expect Joey Richter to be here lol

i fell instantly for chuck wagner's portrayal ,,i adore it so much his hyde sounds so joyous and you can hear the smile he has whilst singing and proclaiming how alive he is and you wanna feel what he's feeling alongside him edit: okay but i can also appreciate the relaxed way laszlo molnar performed it, his voice is incredible and his body language made it seem like hyde was just doing something he does every other day which is pretty cool lmao (oh btw thank you so much for this ! if it hadnt been for this video it wouldve taken me ages to seek out the demo and listen to it

Fun fact: The German lyrics in the last verse contain a parallel to the same part in Confrontation that's absent in the English original. Alive goes: "But I'll live on inside you forever, with Satan himself within my body. And I know as a damned one, that everyone will know me, everyone knows Edward Hyde" Whereas Confrontation goes: "But I'll live on inside you forever, with Satan himself within my body. And I know as a damned one, that no one will separate us, no one separates Jekyll from Hyde"

Anthony Warlow, Chuck Wagner and Constantine Maroulis

Chuck Wagner! Pity the recording isnt better for many of the Hydes.

Definitely Warlow and he’s from Australia!

1: Anthony Warlow: No doubt about it. No one is even moderately close to him. Not saying cause it's mainsteam. I genuinly think that. 2: Chuck Wagner. Love the energy in his voice. He does the song really well. The only version that I like almost (but not at all) equally to Anthony Warlow 3: Seung-woo: Legend. Love the acting and singing. He is so fancy and evil at the same time 4: Takeshi Kaga: This version has strangely grown on me. His voice was a bit weird to me the first time I heard it but now I like it. I also like the energy in his voice and generally this japanese version intrigues me. His delivery of this specific part is very good too 5: Chris Murray: He does the confrontation really really well so that's more the reason I mention him here. Also just love how german sounds 6: Yun Seok-young: Also very cool korean performance. Geronimo Rauch/Aleks Knezevich: Decent 7: Rob Evans: Pretty decent. I like his voice and acting choices with it Negative: David Hasselhoff: No offence to him, but I don't think he was good for this role. I guess he did his best but it just did not do it for me at all Negative: Constantine Marouls: No offence to the guy. I think he is talented in what he does (like Hasselhoff) just not for this show. I just don't think metal (or what this is) fits this musical and I don't like the direction this production went in at all The rest are just pretty "meh" to me (for this role, not as actors)

Warlow is definitely better then the other guys

Anthony Warlow by a long shot

Best line of the whole musical. Chuck Wagner , Warlow, and Hong Kwang-ho are the best IMO. Sebastian Bach and Geronimo Rauch also deserve my appreciation.

I feel like we sleeping on the Koreans Hong Kwang ho in my opinion the best

Anthony warlow it's the best

consider, though he isn't in this video, Joey Richter

What an amazing compilation! Ty for putting this together. I have seen five different Hydes

Warlow 100% but I have a soft spot for Hasselhoff

A 16 year old boy played this role in my schools version and my god he was west end standard, nothing less! Not only did he suit the role so well but he was so good at switching between the two and the acting in general. But this song was so good, he sounded so much like Anthony Warlow!

i absolutely love warlow as jekyll/hyde his voice is amazing

My favorite after Warlow is Aleks Knezevich, no contest. Not only does he actually capture the feeling of freedom and ecstasy that Hyde is experiencing, but from the picture of his performance, he looks absolutely terrifying as well. Living for Chris Murray in the German version, too.

Yall Constantine Maroulis killed that

2:41 david hasselhof

Warlow is my favorite for every line

Warlow is my number one, but not sure why you said “flawed little gem” this musical is all but a flaw, even if there are lots of different versions floating around. The core is intact though and it’s priceless

Marti Pellow's version was so different, I actually loved it

anthony warlow is the best one for sure hands down!!! his version is the only one I listen to.

Cool vid may bee some more of Jekyll and Mr Hyde

Ya done good, Hasselhoff, ya done good.

Alecks was an alumni of my high school. He’s super nice and I’m glad he got mentioned! Very talented guy

Every depiction is so well done. Every show was powerful. But of course at first glance and hearing, Anthony Warlow’s talent is flawless and ranks at the top immediately. But no doubt each actor has their own strength.

A lot of people hate david hasselhoff’s performance. I personally think its ok, its not great by any means. Can someone explain me why people hate it so much?

Is no one gonna talk about chuck wagner??? Those vocals are so difficult for a male voice, but he was able to pull it off. It’s insane

I’d like a studio recording of the Sebastian Bach version.

Warlow is the best

I'll be honest, that was a fantastic performance by David Hasselhoff

Warlow is perfect in the role. His Jekyll and Hyde feel like different characters. And his voice is amazing!

Where can you find the full constantine version? It’s amazing and would love to hear it all :)

My favorite is Sebastian Bach. I love how he goes crazy in the role of Hyde. Saying Anthony Warlow is the best is a bit biased since we don’t hear him singing live like all the others are.

Btw Warlow is the best bc he never been in live, it’s more clear the voice

the two last ones and Geronimo Rauch (besides Anthony Warlow and Chuck Wagner ofc) are my favourites!

He isn’t on here, but Chris Murray is an absolute beast in this role.

Wagner on the original recordings vs Chuck Wagner by the 1998 tour is night and day. He plays it much more powerful and menacing by then.

When was the bishop set on fire during Constaine’s run? I thought all he does is stab the bishop in that version

Lowkey love takeshi Kaga’s voice the best.

One thing I noticed is that those who play hyde and jekyll in all their scenes are alot better at the role

I saw Chris Murray live as Jekyll/Hyde. What a Voice. Its amazing who fit he is, i mean he is born 1963. And he Jumps, he is rolling over the stage and climbing on the scaffolding. And i just though WOW.

Warlow for ever 🙏♥️

LOVE Cucciolis take on "himself by my side"

I feel like it would be cool if someone did a confrontation version of this

hey, i know this video is extreeemely old, but where can i find the performance of yun seok-young? it got me absolutely mesmerized, and i just wish i could watch at least this whole song!

Robert Cuccioli will always be my #1 Jekyll. My ranking of these would be: Robert Cuccioli Takeshi Kaga (need to look more into him!) Anthony Warlow Geronimo Rauch Ryu Jung-han Chuck Wagner Jo Seung-woo Hong Kwang-ho Yun Seok-young Aleks Knezevich Chris Murray Lazlo Molnar Marti Pellow Sebastian Bach Werner Auer Constantine Maroulis (but it's not his fault that they bungled the revival so badly) Thomas Borchert Drew Sarich Guy LeMonnier Paul Nicholas And then way at the bottom of hell, David Hasselhoff

As bad as Sebestian Bach is, I did get chuckle over him sardonically pouring holy water(booze?) over his victim XD

i am so upset that joey richter is not a contender.

Robert Cuccioli is my favorite.

I don't think Chuck Wagner gets enough recognition here. Yes, I agree that Anthony Warlow does absolutely amazing, and his voice matches the role greatly along with Robert Cuccioli and Yun Seok-Young. However Chuck's version is almost more desperate and woeful (possibly due to the key change) which I think is a unique interpretation of the song that really shows the pain and battle between Jekyll and Hyde going on at all times, and is just as powerful as the maniacal tone the other singers take to this song.

Some of those (Rob Evan at least) seems to be taken from Alive (reprise), are all of this taken from reprise, or some are from Alive that is not reprise

Its a reasonable idea for a video but because the sound recordings and quality of the examples differ so much its an unfair contest and in my opinion you cant judge the actors performance and voice soley based on a couple of lines or in most of the examples cant even watch.

My favourites 1. anthony 2.geronimo 3.paul, seong, yun 4.robert,Sebastian,aleks 5. Chuck,David,ryujung,Chris 6.rob,laszlo,Henry 7.gus,Thomas 8.drew 9.tako,werner,marti 10.connat

Chuck Wagner sounded and lokked likem will ferrel, and constantine's rock version was pretty cool and different, buck warlow is best.

cool video! i think you missed some russian versions. they are the best in my taste, its kirill gordeev, ivan oshogin, rostislav kolpakov

Esperaba que pusieran las 2 versiones en Español :(

Warlow is my personal favorites hyde

Warlow is my favorite.

Chuck Wagner makes me feel like I’m heaven now, GODDAMN‼️ I’m obsessed with anything that’s J & H so this is ultimately a win win.

7:35 Therapist: Bon Jovi Hyde isn’t real Bon Jovi Hyde can’t hurt you. Bon Jovi Hyde:

Robert slayed (literally)

Which version is the first one? Where can i find it

For the best recording it is Anthony Warlow. But the best on stage performance is Robert Cuccioli. He did this show 6 to 8 times every week and gave it all the emotion and energy every show.

Warlow is the best one

Do own any of these slime tutorials?

Anthony is forever my favorite

Where do you watch the musical with Warlow?!????? I NEED TO KNOW!!!!

I’ve seen so many great singers take the role and crush it as Jekyll, but they get too feral or low for Hyde to do the songs well. I hate it because Warlow has a lot of unfair advantages, but managing to keep the energy in his voice is something he was great about.

Hola. Busco audios y grabaciones de diferentes países y continentes de este musical. Gracias!!!

Robert Cuccioli will always be my favourite but... Ayo...Yun Seok-young went off.

where did. U get the first clip from

**waiting for Joey Richter’s version** ****9:25** mins later** >:(

Talking about costume design here because well I need to talk about David H. pants were so weird I know he’s very tall, 6’ 4, but my god the pants make him seem insanely tall and it doesn’t make sense for Jekyll but when he turns into Hyde, wow it makes sense it makes him seem creepy. Talking about music now because why not it’s a musical, someone pointed out how the first guy (only a couple of names I remember sorry) sounded happy like Hyde was happy to be ALIVE, the others sometimes have that little pop of joy but not many. I love Anthony Harlow’s performance- his voice is deep and I love his confrontation and transformation, he sounds like how I thought Hyde should sound like deep not too deep and for Jekyll not too deep nor to high I don’t know how singing works- I play cello. Now I need to talk about David H. casting I feel like he doesn’t belong as Jekyll, he doesn’t have that right feeling to him, and he also exaggerates his movements in weird ways like one moment Hyde will be walking how most people walk and then he’ll kind of crouch but not fully and then walk, it makes him look insane but not in the good way. I don’t like how his hair is extra long I get it Jekyll should have long enough hair to become Hyde but I feel like his hair was too long- I’m not sure. I think his voice isn’t loud enough either, it’s loud but not loud. I don’t know how to describe it- everyone else seemed to have this wonderful booming voice and then there is him, just there with his mezzo forte voice while everyone else is a forte. It’s very strange. I don’t understand a lick of Korean but the people who did the Korean musical versions of Jekyll and Hyde- did well in my opinion- they were loud and had this air to them that was very good. This is the end of my fairly short rant, I don’t know anything about singing just cello so forgive me.

Anthony warlow is my favorite His performance for Jeckyll have an outstanding clarity and bit tinner voice compared in Hyde which is a little deeper and more powerful