World Recognises Strength, Not Weak Leadership: Piyush Goyal At India Today Conclave 2019 

You did a great job in 2014 keep it up

@Jai Bothra . Ji bilkul. Same goes for me and my friends. 2014 me hum socha kuch aur nikhla kuch aur.

Now u know

Jai Bothra u should be ashamed now my dear for supporting Bharat Jalao party. Where r the 1.5 million to Youth ? Where is the 2 Crore jobs ? Have they stopped cross border infiltration ? What they get from demonetisation? Shame on Bharat Jalao party

@@nonstopfulltimefun6882 ashamed jaise tune Kabhi kuch galat kiya Hi nhi 😁😁😁😁.i regret and will make up for my mistake.

Rahul Kanwal should be Defense Minister

Bhai unka kaam dekho

Jo jhuta insan ek interview nai de sakta, wo opposition ka PM candidate hai :D

@@rutujakatote9390 UTS app dekha mast hai paise kaat ke ticket book nai hota😁

@@rutujakatote9390 kya hai kaam kuch dikh rha hai

rahul is a hypocrite !

The anchor's response "We don't need any lessons, etc.... " is a trite, rude, and egregiously arrogant reply from most of the failed and thuggish leaders of the "Mahajot" and the dung-brain pseudo-intellectuals today, who are actually assailing the fundamental interest of national security and progress of the country, violating the cannons of civility by censoring the valiant military for their defense operation, and defying the provisions of the Constitution in various manners. Those people are pure scoundrels, pukka badmash! If anybody is trying to make a political hay out of the Pulowama incident and the soldiers' lives lost, it is these scoundrels who are sitting on their armchairs and spinning a net to capture the central government and its prime minister position by any means, and then to loot the public resources, demoralize the military by making them their puppets, and gradually destroy all the democratic institutions of the country and darken the international respect that India enjoys today.

We take lessons from congress, you don't need to tell us how to boot lick 😂

@@saktimukherjee451 by using superior words you can't misrepresent what the anchor said. As an ARMY brat who on an everyday basis witness's his father risk his life, I empathize with him. It feels bad that one fine day in a patronizing manner someone questions your patriotism, says you know nothing and humiliates you. After those sleepless nights of worry for his father's life if he happens to ask question that to under journalistic duty, why do you shut him ? Nobody is censuring the Armed forces valour, we are asking them to clear the lies spread by the enemy with indisputable evidence. Only the truth can clear the darkness. Their response is to polarise instead of unite at this time. You are a govt servant, it is your job to be answerable to people however absurd their questions. Yes, the government has 0 corruption but it seems they want 0 accountability too.

No they need a lesson....

srik p.. what is so special about this question ..?

why dont you go to paapistaan to get evidence rice bag??

Abey oye nanga baba follower.. typically andha bhakt I have wht u guys do to kashmiri ppl in up yesterday.. who re u to label us anti national.. Royal secret service Rss help brithishers.. tey first came with 2 nation theory also didn’t participate in quit india movement.. u guys are inferior class bloody mob lyncher, castist, racist.. u just re a big fish in little pound.. world is very big christianity is the biggest religion.. u guys beg in front of us, uk, Australia,cannada embassy to get visa .. tumhari koi aukat nahi.. poverty stuck, kula mai sauch karna wala log.. get lost beggars

@ capricorn sunn.. tak with facts no jumlas.. christian have many sects like anglican, evangelicals, baptist, lutherans and catholic only catholics have head priest in vaticans. Catholic is only 35 % of christian population.. Uk Us , eurpoupens, indian re protestent which re indiginous group of churches ..I hardly hv vatican connection.. even pope has apologized about autocraticies by crusaiders and colonization.. Abortion are gay right re still debatable..even scientists say STD re main disease spread from homosexuality..tey themself re not loyal to each other.. abortion in rare case is allowed ..do u support killing of innocent child before birth..(these re debatable issue which re contradictory with diff church groups) u talk about ngo funding stopped prove it.. or its another jumla like ure anpad rss guys.. do u think money lik 10 lac or 5 lac is paid to convert.. who has tht money u idot bit pastors and priest re beaten and killed bylabelling false allications like graham stains case..India doesnt have any friends in neighboors lik myanmar, bhutan , nepal, srilanka,maldives,pakistan china has taken tem due to weak policies And ure talking about reclaming place in the world idiot😂😂 coz of christian education institute lik st stephans best college in commerce, loyala best is science, xavier inst in mgmt. coz missionary school u got education and learned some english and computer tht why IT sector grew and Our Gdp grew otherwise u aryan and mixed race u will be done mountain climbing and farming through the life.. u talk about swach bharat it’s budget is just 5000 crs less than upa allocation .. with this u can change whole country.. ppl lik u still shit on farms and railway track😂😂😂. Modi spend 5000 cr in ads only wish could spend on shauchalaya more..u re uneducated, immature bunch of fringe elements.. mouthfull of paans and bidis. India in human devolpment index is 134..GDP per capita is very less .. wish govt could have done more in this regard . 20 most polluted cities re in India out of 25 cities arnd the world..still 40 per people live in poverty Govt has to do for this things but govt and guys like u re spreading hate and lies..idiot u re aryans came from iran. We lived in riches never begged u beggars and snake charmers. Go to khajrao temple full of nanga landscape, widow is burned alive, harijan tourched if this is our history sorry to say we shd burry our history..U Labourclass ppl.. coz of ngo lik unesco , world vision donations india survived during 1980 and 1990s..if christian wer not ther u would be stinking labour class gawar and anpads wit rss shakhs.. lik biplab deb, yogi and sakshi mahraj..Thts why I told U re living in little pound.. come out of the closset travel around the world learn about ancient greek culture, egypt history, industrialization in UK, internet revolution in America , manufacturing sector growth in china, Automobile sector in Japan.. And analyse whr we lagged behide..rather them thumping our history.but stop spreading hate.. remove castism and evil frm society lik dowry, domestic violance and fake nationalism..India has long way to go.. but chutiyas lik u wil never learn..gud luck. Tera jaisa bht anpad chutiya ko mai apna naukar rakta hu..u cannot do anything to me..yeh dhamki apna paas rak.. I talked with facts isliya teri gaand jali

christanity ka baare mai bola toh chup ho gya.. Old Testament bible is the oldest starting from Adam..type google ..I dont comment about other religion ..typicall bhakt ...frog in a little pound .. tu kaha rehta hai bol .. desi gawar chaap...if ure not aryan ure adivasis.. some scholers differ tht lik swamy and rajiv malhota not the scientist.. congress and bjp both looted no doubt abt tht but congress didnt spread hate..anyway liv in ure dream land .. u re the no 1 😂😂..

@@jobi705able same to you me bigot. old testament bible is oldest..the crap you believe is truly amazing!!! did adam provide a signed declaration about your document?? come to kolkata i will be waitingfor your lecture. scamress has ALWAYS hated hindus and hinduism, go and read how indira ordered firing on very sanyasis whose support gave her 1970 elections.the atrocities against hindus by muslims, cross huggers and scamress will fill books. better a andh bhakt than a cross hugger supremacist racist. truly the priests must be complemented on their level of brainwashing on the likes of you..better than even ww2 germany!!! anyway good luck with your bigotry and ur dream of lu lu the cross is great land. saala degree aur job ya business hold karke khud to bohut mahan civilised insaan samajta hai. agar kutta sher ka costume pehen leta hai to sher nehi banta . samjha?? WHO HAS MADE JUDICIARY PUSH THE RAM TEMPLE DATE BACK AGAIN AND AGAIN?? the way you defend scamress is enough for anyone to understand your hatred of hinduism. hinduism ya vedas ke baare mein ek bhi line paata hai tujhe?? lecture de raha hai ki we should be grateful as we survived because of the church--height of brainwashing!! .goodbye

you should live in the land of idiotic mamta and ugly face

Exactly i was thinking, while answering he was trying to put the crowd on his side.

Great analysis !!

AGREED, SIMILAR TO KATH PUTALI

@Sher Singh Anand and what has scamress done?? swarg rajya??

@Sher Singh Anand bro but it has not been proved in court also you can see coalgate scam, and those who were highly involved in scam are part of BJP, Does it means they were not involved in scam or should I understand that bjp had fueled as a rumour? In India it is very easy to spread rumours ,but the weight of rumours depends. But u shd hv to accept the criminal activities increased exponentially in this bjp govt.

piyush is more intelligent than your entire clan.

@@AshokKumar-zu8qw a bhakt just got triggered

compare today vs 2014. That will answer your question.

Bhool gai jab bjp power hungry thi ... Bjp se jyada sawal or gande kaam koi party me nahi ki he..

Arti Sharma.....that is probably because no Congress minister tried to insult Rahul in front of so many people . Rahul restrained his voice a lot here, and brought the minister to his senses. The applause was enough for the minister to realise he should stop trying to imitate Modi. The crowd here is not the paid crowd Modi gets in his rallies..

Fact Bhakths will never accept this

@@vishalkundagol3536 and scam bhaktard NOTA VEERS will bever accept that biggest CONGI IT CELL IS INDIAN MEDIA.

So what do you think? BJP giving this 300 numbers to Win 2019 Elections?

Simple , yet strong and conclusive contention ... Well said Akash .super like 😉

After listening to all this thing I will vote to bjp only.Even 300 terrorist died or plants burned because they took the flights in to Pakistan. After Pandit were sent out from Kashmir no action took by govt .after 26/11 what happened nothing. How can this people are sure there are no people. Any way Pakistan will never tell the truth.This people want to believe them.who kill our people from years.This people support Afgzal .Even they think they don't need lessons of nationalism we will teach lesson to them .

Really bro 😂😂😂 what was that 'ek fakiri toh hai aap me'

@@sandeeppatnaik1879 and then planted sikh bhakt doing modi modi. Only Donkey level IQ ppl cannt c dat d interview was scripted. Sadly, d number of dese people r increasing day by dat thanks to our education system.

@@sourabhsiitg HOW MUCH pappu mut was required to write that nonsense??

@a k bhai donkey IQ level, Modi gave interview to only chamcha and paid anchor whih all r scripted. In SIngapore, it was caught red handed when lady translated in english too much that modi didnt even say lolz. Low IQ and brainwashed ppl like u r increasing day by day. Kahan se fakiri aati hain itni bhai

@a k ask modi for an interview with Ravish kumar. Gand phat k hath mai aa jayga.

If the data would have been right i.e. unemployment rates at 4 decade High. then there would have been riots on the street

@a k Its not andh virodh... goyal were just fucking arounf the bush

Rahul Kanwal is obviously less patriotic than PM MODI and Minister .. Rahul Kanwal if he is really patriotic would have joined Army like his father and served nation . Now he chose to come to lime light of TRP Mill called Journalism India needs more Jawans and Army Officers not Journalist. Journalist simply take our valuable time and we feel as if we have become wiser after their talk.. NOTHING Switch off TV - Citizens are better off .. Belive in our POM MODI and Jawans they are great hero not this Suit Boot Journalist who go there for good food

Rahul can speak for himself. not for the 500 odd audiences. He has no right

@@sureshpolali4616 bro you go to army na why are you forcing it down someones throat. Its personal choice. This is what is called andh nationalism. I think you come from some rss shakha or bajrangdal bullshit or something thats why you are also fucking around the bush like goyal and all bjp leaders who when cant give answers just starts saying bharat mata ki jai. Bhai 1 baat yaad rakhna nationalism sae kisi ka paat nahi bharta. Par bjp nationalism kae naam par apni tijori zarur bhar rahi hai.

And no one need certificate of secularism from Congress

How can a BJP as a political party or any one of its member can provide the proof since they were not in the cockpit or the monitoring H.Q? If, I were to ask for an evidence about the Balakote attack , who has the evidence is something you have think about. The proof of destruction would have been captured by the cameras on plane or the SPICE missile which will have to transmit to a satellite if it was programmed. I am quiet sure GOI will release the evidence once it has been examined and studied by the defence forces. So it time to relax and sit back, relax show your support and respect to our armed forces men and women. If you ask for evidence from the Government, in essence you are asking the armed forces to prove it in an indirect way. Your way of looking at the situation is different from mine and I hope you will find time to study the issue to come to fair conclusion. I am son of late AIr Force officer who served the nation from 1944 to 1984 and no one asked for proof from our government of the 1948, 1962, 1965, 1971 and 1999 wars which wee imposed on us.

Rahul, stop your negative narratives-it sucks!

Now, does the Minister need any such narratives from a DUMB journalist like you!

That is a stupid question Rahul !

You and your damn assumptions Rahul

Again, it shows how disgusting you are in your interview techniques - it sucks!

bhia wo commerce ka hai.....

Education qualification Piyush Goyal ka jitna hai tum uske ghutne k barabar bhi nhi ho bhai, kya bol rhe ho..........BJP k cabinet mein ek se ek neta high rank pe highly educated and qualified hai...

@@sohamghosh1303 sabse badiya example to samriti irani ka h😏 Piyush goyal is like shashi Tharoor for BJP

i remember in 2006 thali costed like 150 rupees, by 2013 it started costing 450 , and the taxes were like around 100 rs. you ask the restaurant guy, he says government is putting them. government of UPA introduced so many UNSAID taxes, to put burden on middle class, that everything went to shit. So do not make a fool of yourself here

@@kuldeepadhikari3849 : You seem to be a five star suit-boot ka sahab Sir. Your picture also is suit-boot wala. I don't know which hotels you were going to to pay Rs. 450/- for a thali. I am an ordinary person and am talking about ordinary hotels. It is you who is making a fool of yourself here not me.

Gali koun deta hai comments me bjp it cell wale acche log nahi aa thu

Sir 100 percent true.

Chal jhuthaa!! I am not in any IT cell and the same might be true with other ppl

mulayam family is the biggest crook in whole up. Look at the wealth they have accumulated. Akilesh with mayawati are the most crooked and stupid and idiotic people . You yadav clan will keep them voting. Tell me what they will do solve employment problem.

Pakistani spotted

Stupid bhakt spotted

Amir Yousef you definitely are an anti national

Since you're the "definition" guy, let me take a guess, your definition of Umar Khaled and Kanhaya Kumar would be - freedom fighters and revolutionaries?

@@arindammitra5651 pappu mutra drinker spotted

@Truth Seeker so what about our PM...when all party meeting held after attack to stand shoulder to shoulder with our PM but pm was busy in campaigning for election im Yavatmal, Maharashtra where fadnavis also present... Even if Our beloved pm wouldn't come then also fadnavis would have managed... What is your thought on this??

Did you get your Rs 1/tweet. Well done good job... Keep it up

Achcha tum karo to freedom of expression ham bole to BJP it cell vah 😆🤣🤣

and whatever ministers answer it will always be communal,false data etc?? assholes will be assholes

You dont ask questions like a two year old ..being an adult you should know you wont get answer when its a war situation ..common sense dude. FYI not always you use bullet or bombs to neutralise enemy ...its how smartly you kill ememy's attitude.

As a person who has been serving this country and twice almost lost my life fighting anti national, enemy, intruders and terrorists,and a person who just love this country then any party, after seeing this, I can say that Rahul Kanwal is one of the most stupid journalist, is any Pakistani media questioining failure of pakustani air force defence mechanism, whethetr 300 killed or 3 or none, message has gone across, simple. Israeli bombs used which is one of the most penetrative arsenal and always successful.and armed forces are thankful to present PM for giving free hands, increasing morale and giving respect. Else same IAF and army was there in Congress time and all upa govt Was doing was Kadi Nandi.. Which used to decrease morale of forces.. Lastly if you are asking the no of people killed and not killed and saying that air force has struck only jungles, then you are not asking question to a minister, you are raising the question on the efficiency of iaf.. Bjp will be there or tomorrow may not be m. But how can you talk so stupid as journalist and give Pakistan a chance to question quoting you ....

Real madrid vs Barcelona 😂

you are living in dream. This guy is gold medalist from law school and c.a. exam and successful banker.no coal scam or scam to purchase the led bulbs Improve your skill level if you want jobs not waste time writing here.

@@AshokKumar-zu8qw FYI I am a govt employee and I think I have improved my skills enough to get a job. But this doesn't hide the fact that country is facing these problems. If u live in India, and you haven't seen almost every other train not being on time and the country suffering from highest unemployment in 4 decades, then sorry sir, u seem to live in a different India. And speaking of academic credentials, Raghuram Rajan, Amartya Sen, Dr Manmohan Singh who have time and now challenged this govt's claims of development, have way much higher degrees. So citing anyone's academic credentials isn't even relevant here.

The problem is,his job is to ask questions after he has done research.Journalists task is to do research n find answers n not throw allegations.

@@vrnprm1921 Amit Shah , Sambit said 300 killed. Indian army said they don't know about numbers. International media saying 0 kills. Now simple question to government where did this big 300-400 number come from ? This is not anti national talk. We wanted the revenge for our soliders who martyred in pulwama. We have right to know what damage done to our enemy. We want to know weather media and amit is telling the truth or not.... How can this be anti national ??

Even the proof of surgical strike came after a year. Not just the proof but even a movie was released. And the movie was not even off the screens and 2.0 happened. I am sure they are just waiting for the situation at the border and the public sentiment to cool down a bit. Proof will be released and another movie will be made. May be we will get another war call like How's the Josh??....

@@shyam8730 movie made gud money... n nthn gained to country... feku one more flop strike...to win elections

@@DGoat83 Flop strike!!! Woh. Leave the government don't you believe the IAF when they say that, yes, we have hit our targets based on hard Intel.

Chidambaram is brilliant can't compared with this man.....

Bakwas , British took gandhi lightly . It was azad hind fauz which scared the shit out of british .

Is there a 'Boob' in your name?

Pakistani spotted

@@capricorn4518 as like ur daadi

@@IndianBrains haha

@@VadapavIQ fuck off cross hugger

@@Somnath-Ghosh How do you know he supports Congress? If someone condemns a communal murderer that doesn't automatically imply he supports a corrupt nepotistic manchild. You BJP morons don't know how to argue and just stoop down to using foul language.

Vishal Nair excellent democratic understanding there, boy

How hypocrite the journalist was - Shame on you pseudos

👍

Well said sir 👌👌

@@darshanpatel7012 Thanks A Lot... Jai Hind...

@@rajeshwareedeshpande4961 Thanks A Lot Jai Hind...

*Enemies

Agrima Kumar.. You wrote well.. This can be a 9th standard easy for 7 marks. Tell me who in today's India resposible , cooutable , genuine etc.. If you are hinting at Rahul Kanwal as resposible journalist - you are totally mistaken.. He is most arrogant jurno works for TRP Mill . Questioning the govt is the agenda . WHAT WHEN WHY is not there in this agenda Please do not consider Journalist as responsible citizen of INDIA . They work only and only for TRP there by their pay package .. that is it

Your anti national bro, Actually no. is 500, don't ask me for the proof pls...

He went there with Modi and Imran khan and counted bodies personally 😂😂

Akshay jha. *Patra went there that night and count by himself. But forgot what he had counted. Thats why sometimes he says 300 and sometimes 400.*

@@dishoom2015 mind Ur language you ass hole ... I luv my nation in word and spirit I pay my taxes I observe rules ...

Akshay jha >>I was surcasting in answering you..... This is how the current trend is, if you are asking question against nationalistic party, then one be called anti national which is absolutely rubbish .. I too pay my taxes without defaults, I too love my county... But our countrymens fights against each other on subject nationalism feels very bad and leading party takes advantage...

@@AshokKumar-zu8qw rafale deal started in 2008.congress did nothing for till 6 years and bjp did nothing for 5 years. So what a big deal.i dont mind you call muslim thief because i dont believe in religion.

Your skill level shows very high because you dont believe in humanity.you make me separate from you in name of religion. But still you are species like me.

do not worry about my skill level . I have lived in us for 47 years and still working 50 hours per day at my age. Do you really think rahul gandhi,mulayam or akhilesh,mayawati have a plan to create jobs. Look at the power situation today vs 5 years ago . Is it better or worse. Look at the roads and cleanliness . Is it worse or better. I shall write more later. I do not like modi but what did congress do for 60 years. per capita under nehru dynasty was $300 for 40 years.

@@AshokKumar-zu8qw why you go in the past. We all have to unite and fight for our country people irrespec to caste and creed. Sir i am respect u.. we shld not fight for politicians. We have to be for the people.

@@nosratsayed6785 Nusrat i teach college and you may be surprised how many muslim friends I have . My wife is a sikh and as you know from my name I am not. So I respect all religions and caste. My adopted son comes from Punjabi community but I care for him more than myself. My dad used to walk 16 miles per day in 1936 to go to school . But he always wanted to give his children good education. I have hard coded proof where mayawati accepted 20 crore for a ticket. Do you accept honesty from these people. Modi is not God and he never will be. He lived in us penniless in 2000 when vajpayeji asked him to come back. He does not have much of the financial assets after being in power. He had to do demonetization otherwise all the transaction happening in crores yet govt getting nothing because everything under the table. Rafale deal he had to bring ambani for small part because HAL record for delivery is pathetic. They have become paper tiger and babus collecting salary and doing nothing . Look how long they took to make tejas delivery. Piyush goyal comes with a brilliant academic record yet they are criticizing him . before he took over faruq abdullah was poaer minister. He puchase 15000 crore rupee worth of led without any scam. I shall write more later as someone is asking question on math

and he has the knowledge to answer the question unlike chidamabaran and his son kanti biggest crook in tamilnadu.

@@AshokKumar-zu8qw only gadkari ji is knowledgeable person in bjp and others are duffers.......

@@2011cindrela do you mind sharing your education before calling someone duffer.

@@AshokKumar-zu8qw ha ha.....modi ki qualification se jyada hai...jab wo pm ban sakta hai....to gadkari ji ko usa ka president banna chahiye.....

you muslim should go to pakistan where your menopause problem will be solved. there rupee is trading at 140 to a dollar and imran khan is begging in front of the world. Is power situation better than 5 years ago. In one year they closed all the unmanned railway crossings. Conditions of the road.

Ashok Kumar ... i was critisizing the answer given by rail minister and it had nothing to do with the religion.... well i realize dt u have problems with muslims even if a muslim critisizes a govt...well keep it up ...

aarif since you are at it can you share your education level with all of us. You had to bring the analogy to bring womanhood down, typical mindset.

i have yet to read in the whole conversation any muslim saying anything decent about the govt. I do not know why. They bought 15000 crore of led without any scam. How about the coal auction . Lalu made crores in commission still no criticism. Gowda clan made 1000 crores still they are good. Karunanidhi clan made crores also but no such comment. I can go on for ever.

Ashok Kumar ....u cud b right according to ur perspective but then u have to give room to others abt wat they think of the particular govt and we might differ in our opinions but at the same time shuld respect each others viwes and perception...i criticized a govt as a citizen not as A muslim but only thing u saw is myself being a muslim..... well i apologize if i have offended u in any way....

wow!!! you read body language from videos?? awesome psychic!!! what colour is your shit?? maybe that will tell what tyoe of animal DNA you have

Minister Piyush Goyal is the most confident person - Never ever showed any insecurity or nervousness. He handled big ministries Power, Railways Finance. He is go- to minister in MODI GOvt and MODI likes Piyush Goyal very much 2nd Rank CA student his entire family served this great nation .. B BRAD your reading of Pitush Goyal is grossly wrong . Just for one sentence of Rahul Kanwal if you think Minister will become nervous... come on .. .. He is extremely strong - He did not continue with Rahul's argument as that was inappropriate to crush that small boy called Rahul Kanwal

​@@sureshpolali4616 - If u feel he is good minister good I respect that. But in my humble onion having degrees (though it helps to have a educated minister) or having different posts doesn't make him an efficient performing minster, or that he wont get nervous in situations. I have my reservations. Also if he is Modi's goto minister doesn't qualify him to be the most confident , unless ur privy to some details we aren't. But here its not the topic. By the way he is the one minister I feel in this govt. who will take informed sensible decisions most of the time, but here he was trying to be aggressive & loud to misdirect. Because i believe he didn't want to answer the question, because he knows he cant justify it. So he wanted to drum the narrative that questioning pulwama means you are an anti national & ur against the army. Firstly he or no one questioned the strike, but if a party spokesperson or party president says facts which don't make sense (like 300 people dead) during rallies or tv debates then any sensible journalist will question its their responsibility, their job is to ask tough questions from the govt. Just after Rahul replied to him firmly & the audience clapped its visible on his face he was nervous. I mean if Pappu (RG) said this u will not be replying like this instead u will say it was great question. I remember some silly claims by mamta banerji's govt in west bengal, BJP questioned the facts & news reporters followed up with the Bengal govt. BJP did good there, so then the same yard stick will be applied to BJP too.

@@rahulmallah8306 ok, its fine, u felt that, i didn't. no biases here, i personally dont fan out over these politicians. lets agree to disgree.

He is an andhbhakth

@@vishalkundagol3536 abe scamress IT PIDI baas kar

But under his ministry Railway have achieved what we haven't achieved before 2016, just checkout the work done by him as a Railway minister.