Тёмный

World's Best Tyrannosaurus Skull shares secrets: No Lips! +7 other facts about Trex you didn't know. 

Fossil Crates
Подписаться 3,2 тыс.
Просмотров 3,4 тыс.
50% 1

(Audio is on the quiet side, apologies!)
Tracy Ford explains why Tyrannosaurus rex and its kin did NOT have lips. He shows the impact of the ectopterygoid, tooth size, aestivation, and foramina on the jaw which all lead him to conclude... NO LIPS.
Heterodonty is briefly discussed and Tracy tells us why he doesn't like calling the teeth "killer bananas." The bite force via musculature is pointed out. And Dr. BC shows his soft side...
The two paleo fans also discuss T. rex arms, binocular vision, antorbital fenestra coverings, narial location, speed, occipital condyle and head angle, and then close with something new for Dr. BC to consider... nasal rugosities. Whew!

Опубликовано:

 

10 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 142   
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
BTW, Fossil Crates sells that very T. rex skull as part of our Total T.rex rex package here www.fossilcrates.com/collections/museum-quality-skull-casts/products/totaltrex
@EbonyPope
@EbonyPope 10 месяцев назад
Prehistoric Planet designed a Rex with lips. With our without I'll always love Rexy. What's most impressive with that design were the neck muscles though. One of the few to get it right. They were huge.
@DrBC
@DrBC 10 месяцев назад
@@EbonyPope Cool!
@The_Cosmic_Yog-Sothoth
@The_Cosmic_Yog-Sothoth 2 года назад
Reptile lips are more likely if the animal uses weaker bite forces when attacking its prey. Komodo dragons have a very weak bite force, using their sharp teeth and venom to subdue their prey, thus those lips are never involved in being hit with a huge opposite force to the direction of the bite, which could cause damage. Reptiles cannot snarl their lips like mammals can, so for reptiles with huge bite force, such as crocodiles and T. rex, lips would be selected against, as they would become dangerously damaged whenever the predator attacked its next meal.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
What a great line of reasoning! I hadn’t considered that.
@nanuqo2006
@nanuqo2006 2 года назад
T. rex wasn't able to close its mouth far enough for the mouth to ever be fully closed without the presence of lips
@The_Cosmic_Yog-Sothoth
@The_Cosmic_Yog-Sothoth 2 года назад
@@nanuqo2006 You make less sense than someone deliberately trying to make no sense.
@nanuqo2006
@nanuqo2006 2 года назад
@@The_Cosmic_Yog-Sothoth The theropod jaw mechanism would not have allowed the skull's jaw to close completely in life. Without the presence of any sort of lip, theropod mouths would be perpetually open a small amount, not fully closed as seen on most lipless dinosaur reconstructions.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
@@nanuqo2006 Can you provide the scientific paper that says that? I have never read thy in the academic literature. I am not saying you are wrong but that is the first I have heard this and would like to read the paper. Thanks!
@claytonnye6841
@claytonnye6841 2 года назад
Great Video Tracy you did a great job describing Tuft’s scull. You covered all the best segments and there primary functions in a comprehensible layperson language. Not a simple thing to do. You are truly gifted in so many areas.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Excellent descriptor!
@EbonyPope
@EbonyPope 10 месяцев назад
Prehistoric Planet designed a Rex with lips. With our without I'll always love Rexy. What's most impressive with that design were the neck muscles though. One of the few to get it right. They were huge.
@DrBC
@DrBC 10 месяцев назад
Cool!!!
@rafaelzabani5488
@rafaelzabani5488 2 года назад
Awesome, great video, this is the best explanation on why theropods didn’t have lips, Tracy always does a good job!!
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Thanks! Tracy is so much fun to hang out with. He brings such a discerning eye and is incredibly well read and fun to talk erudite paleo topics with. I'm so glad we ran into each other in Tucson.
@EbonyPope
@EbonyPope 10 месяцев назад
Prehistoric Planet designed a Rex with lips. With our without I'll always love Rexy. What's most impressive with that design were the neck muscles though. One of the few to get it right. They were huge.
@nate1735
@nate1735 10 месяцев назад
​@@EbonyPope Still a debate Many reptiles have lips like the Komodo dragon, but they don't have a strong bite like the T rex.
@EbonyPope
@EbonyPope 10 месяцев назад
@@nate1735 I know. Searched for does T Rex have lips and found a scientist showing using a fossilized T Rex head that with lips the lower jaw wouldn't fit into the upper. The lips would be perforated by his upper teeth. It was quite convincing.
@antoniorocha3967
@antoniorocha3967 2 года назад
Yeah, never brought that lip thing in teropods, specially those big theeth animals. People often see them as some kind of lizzards or any modern animal, even knowing they're not. Great video, thanks. I'll use it as a referrence.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Glad to know it was useful! Thank you for your comments.
@datto240z
@datto240z 2 года назад
That was awesome. Would love to be there. Good points on the lips!
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
:-)! All Tracy there!
@The_PokeSaurus
@The_PokeSaurus 2 года назад
There is still an argument to be made for lips.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
I think it will end up being a case by case discussion were each taxon must be evaluated individually. I don’t think a person can say all dinosaurs have lips or even all theropods have lips. I do enjoy the scientific method and wish more was in the literature
@The_PokeSaurus
@The_PokeSaurus 2 года назад
@@FossilCrates Can agree with that.
@DocAllo
@DocAllo 2 года назад
Ur content is awsome, i finally found a non biased paleo channel
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Thank you for your kind words!
@AcuarioRex
@AcuarioRex 2 года назад
insteresting , great video
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Thank you!!!
@brawlholic9960
@brawlholic9960 Год назад
The closest relatives of dinosaurs are birds and crocodiles which are all grouped together in the order archosaurs. Birds are of course the closest relatives because they are theropod dinosaurs themselves. Neither birds nor crocodiles have lips, and the only living group of reptiles to have lips is the archosaur's sister group, the lepidosaurs (which includes lizards and snakes). Mammals doesn't count ofcourse because of their distant relation to reptiles in general and due to the fact that they posses muscular lips(the muscles also provide support to their facial skin) which even lepidosaurs do not have either. It would seem that lips are the most logical thing for an animal to have but that's not the case. If we take into account the morphology of the mouth and the structure, lips are not a necessary ''apparatus''. Also, the areas on the maxilla and dentary bone that appear to supply blood to lips could also provide blood supply to nourish large facial scales as well. Also the mandibular teeth (the lower jaw) are protected inside the mouth, a feature unique to theropod dinosaurs. And because the lower jaw fits inside the upper jaw, you can see how far down to the lower jaw the upper teeth reach in this figure. Not the best space for a lower lip to develop and provide cover to the upper teeth especially without the present of facial muscles to support the lower lip. As for the teeth in the upper jaw, firstly we see animals today with exposed teeth and secondly reptiles in general shed their teeth constantly in their lives. So, again, no need for an upper lip to cover and protect them. Large facial scales could also provide some good cover as well and be better suited for intraspecific competition
@DrBC
@DrBC Год назад
Well stated! I have a V2 coming out hopefully later this month, and it addresses a few of your comments, esp. regarding lepidosaur lips. Tracy brings props and more artwork this next time around!
@brawlholic9960
@brawlholic9960 Год назад
@@DrBC Many believe also that Trex had such salivary glands that were able to produce just enough moisture within their jaws to keep the teeth from falling over the threshold(see komodo dragons), or at least maintain them enough until eventually shed them. Maybe the climate played part in this. Climate was more humid back then, but could environmental humidity be so effective to protect dinosaur teeth? I don't know. Along with many unknowns there is the unknown of tongue which could also play vital role in the dinosaur oral physiology.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates Год назад
@@brawlholic9960 Crocodiles today aestivate where their teeth are dry for a month or more.
@tyrannotherium7873
@tyrannotherium7873 2 года назад
Yes thank god I am friends with him on Facebook
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
🙂
@tyrannotherium7873
@tyrannotherium7873 2 года назад
Try to explain that to Ben all those other clowns who think then it had lips after all
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
@@tyrannotherium7873 Ben?
@tyrannotherium7873
@tyrannotherium7873 2 года назад
This guy ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ZyoxPknp670.html
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
@@tyrannotherium7873 I haven't run across him. First I've heard of him.
@tyrannotherium7873
@tyrannotherium7873 Год назад
I don’t think that a tyrannosaurus would not carry its young like a cat would it would probably carry its young like a crocodile
@jislh9453
@jislh9453 Год назад
If T. rex face bite would T. rex use the posterior and anterior side of the teeth ?
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates Год назад
THAT is a great question, one I've never pondered. I suspect it would be the front and front sides but that is my guess, nothing supported in the literature.
@jislh9453
@jislh9453 Год назад
Thanks
@HardcoreHector
@HardcoreHector 2 года назад
Awesome analysis. Do you have any timeline on the horizon to bring the scaled skull back to the shop?
@HardcoreHector
@HardcoreHector 2 года назад
@@DrBC awesome, thank you!
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Thank you for your kind words! We believe we will have more in March. Early or late I can't yet tell but I'm hope-hope-hoping on the early side!
@34r343
@34r343 2 года назад
So his points for a lack of lips is because the teeth sometimes extends pass the lower jaw? That's called tooth slippage buddy and skull distortion. Also theropods wouldn't have closed their jaw that tightly or all the way. Also their are animals with LARGER teeth to face ratio that EASILY fit in to lips. Next is him saying that the foramina is like that of crocodiles or gators. First off the skulls are nothing alike, they have way different textures and sculpting on the them. Also tyrannosaurus and theropods in general don't have that much foramina, and if I'm correct they have it in the 70s or 80s, While crocodiles and gators have a average of 100 foramina in each major bone and averages 1000 foramina. So basically tyrannosaurus doesn't have enough foramina to be lipless. Not to mention the fact that theropods and crocodiles have WAY different lifestyles.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Interesting comments! I wish actual lip experts on either side would publish some peer-reviewed papers. It does suggest that maybe it is more difficult than one would think to come up with a testable, objective approach than I'd assumed. I'm not sure what you mean by skull distortion or tooth slippage, maybe on that specimen but it seems his comments applied to other theropod skulls I've handled. I'm not sure why you say they wouldn't close their jaws that tight or all the way, I'd be curious as to why they wouldn't. How are you defining/measuring "that tightly" and "all the way", maybe that is where I am confused by your comment. What animals are you thinking of with the teeth/face ratio? (I have no dog in this fight, I'm open to hearing both sides!) I spent the weekend looking at some croc, and theropod, skulls and we were actually commenting how some of the textures were very similar. Being as sauropod vert guy personally that may not amount to much though, but visually and tactile-wise they certainly looked similar to me fwiw. I don't believe Tracy's argument applies across all theropods so your "in general" comment doesn't count here imo. Have you checked this blog out, again not peer-reviewed but thought provoking? theropoda-blogspot-com.translate.goog/2021/04/possiamo-predire-matematicamente-la.html?m=1&_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en Thank you for commenting!
@brawlholic9960
@brawlholic9960 Год назад
Reptiles do not have muscular lips. Mammals such as dogs have. The facial muscles can support the facial skin. As the guy in the video said the space between the mandible and the maxilla would be too big for a lip structure without muscle support and if the Trex had lips they would have to be too big to cover the huge teeth which is impractical for a reptile. Theropods overlap their jaws for a reason. No other tetrapod do that including dogs. In that way the lower teeth are protecteed inside the mouth. As for the upper teeth could be partially covered with skin or big armored scales due to intraspecific competition(thus the holes on the jaws provide blood supply to nourish these scales)
@jislh9453
@jislh9453 2 года назад
Wow that was very good and interesting
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Thank you!
@EmpireOfLuciferSatanson666
@EmpireOfLuciferSatanson666 2 года назад
Hoho! Tyrannosaurid teeth in the Morrison Formation? Goodness me!
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
That was new to me as well!!!
@Shehzain
@Shehzain Год назад
I imagine they meant tyrannosauroid teeth. It is nearly impossible for tyrannosaurids proper to have been around at that time.
@ianpanico5501
@ianpanico5501 2 года назад
Never heard of Tracy Ford before, he Is a tyrannosaurus expert ??? Im just a Rookie thanks But i like the no lips theory I cannont convice about lips thing
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Tracy has been around for decades He has an extraordinary keen eye and is as well read a researcher one will find. Check out some of his books and articles. He doesn’t limit himself to tyrannosaurids, he has written on a number of taxa and named 2. He doesn’t seek the limelight, this may have been the first video he did (sheer luck I ran into him that day). Thanks for your comments!
@ianpanico5501
@ianpanico5501 2 года назад
@@FossilCrates ill take a look on internet big thanks. If you can give me a sugestión would be thankfuly to you
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
@@ianpanico5501 He runs dinohunter.com and paleofile.com (a site I use a lot) plus he has a number of books and articles.
@jislh9453
@jislh9453 2 года назад
12:10 so 28 + MPH ?
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Works for me!
@jislh9453
@jislh9453 Год назад
I used a velocity formula for bipedal organisms and it looks like the Scotty would have gone 6 mps and MOR 555 10.413 mps so T. rex was pretty fast depending on the size
@teodormrdenovic1981
@teodormrdenovic1981 2 года назад
It doesn’t make much sense thought. Crocodiles teeth are hydrated because they spend most of their time in water. Having them sticking out would mean they would be dry?
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Tracy's point about aestivation is the croc's teeth are not in water for weeks at a time with no ill effect. With tyrannosaur teeth possibly being replaced every 30 days it would be a moot point in his opinion.
@SharksandDinos
@SharksandDinos 2 года назад
Tracy's first point about the upper tooth being too large to house any lips already leaves me unconvinced. First off, the teeth of theropods going into their lower jaws is not anything unique amongst reptiles because varanid lizards (which them and all other lepidosaurs are on the other side of the saurian phylogeny tree) also have upper teeth that goes into their lower jaws yet they still have lips covering them. Sure their lower jaws do not go into their upper jaws when they do close their mouth, but their upper teeth still goes to their lower jaws regardless. Even when theropod teeth does go past the bottoms of their jaws, it is either an outlier or they just do not go far enough to have lips being a disadvantageous trait like you two are suggesting. The only times I would say an animal's lips would be disadvantageous to the animal are those in bulldogs as you mentioned, they would end up biting the lips. Speaking of which, the bulldog argument is also one I do not find convincing because they have oversized upper lips that are too large to align with their lower lips. If T.rex did have lips, than it would have more facial tissue on its lower jaws to have larger lower lips and the gap between the lips and the jawbone itself (as you would see in Rebor's Kiss Model) would have been bigger too so it can fit them. His second argument also does not hold water because crocodilians have a lot more foramina that they use to detect their prey when entering in the water (not like sharks though which use electroreception). T.rex itself does not have as much foramina since they primarily would have used their great sense of smell along with great eye sight (which Tracy mentioned) to find and detect their prey. Also, varanids (again) also would have used their teeth to tear into prey and they too would have been sensitive due to having foramina, but still have lips covering them due to extra facial tissues. Other than that, it would have been used for various structures to connect or or pass through. I could be wrong of course, but those are my reasons why I am not convinced that theropods (especially T.rex) were lipless as Tracy would suggest. Edit: I don't know why RU-vid is making those huge gaps in my comment, so I literally have no choice but to edit the comment to remove it instead of copying and pasting it then try to remove it.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Thanks for your comments! Let's hope Tracy replies :-). What were your thoughts about this paper? www.researchgate.net/publication/315765917_A_new_tyrannosaur_with_evidence_for_anagenesis_and_crocodile-like_facial_sensory_system
@dinohunter5971
@dinohunter5971 2 года назад
As far as the comparison between varanid lizards and theropods, it is completely different. Yes, the upper teeth do cover the lower teeth, but it is ONLY the teeth. The lower jaw in varanids do NOT fit completely inside the upper jaw. Varanid teeth do not fit over the lower jaw at all. There is a gap between the upper and lower jaw. The way the jaws are in varanids supports lips. I do talk about this in my research paper already mentioned. Even pseudosuchians lower jaw fits inside the upper jaw. The problem is there is no modern analogy we can refer theropods too. The jaw/skull morphology is too different. Using bulldog's doesn't' work either because thier teeth occlude with each other and the lower jaw does not fit inside the lower jaw, which allows for lips. Thank you for your comments and I will add them to my quest for the arguments against lips.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
@@dinohunter5971 Excellent points!
@brawlholic9960
@brawlholic9960 Год назад
Reptiles do not have muscular lips. Mammals such as dogs have. The facial muscles can support the facial skin. As the guy in the video said the space between the mandible and the maxilla would be too big for a lip structure without muscle support and if the Trex had lips they would have to be too big to cover the huge teeth which is impractical for a reptile. Theropods overlap their jaws for a reason. No other tetrapod do that including dogs. In that way the lower teeth are protecteed inside the mouth. As for the upper teeth could be partially covered with skin or big armored scales due to intraspecific competition(thus the holes on the jaws provide blood supply to nourish these scales)
@victorsztorc511
@victorsztorc511 2 года назад
The lip debate is still going
@antoniorocha3967
@antoniorocha3967 2 года назад
Never bought that lip thing. T Rex is no iguana.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Absolutely. But I don’t think they had lips.
@victorsztorc511
@victorsztorc511 2 года назад
@@FossilCrates but a tyrannosaur and theropod expert named ethan storrer who worked on the jurassic world short film battle at big rock argues back saying that the tyrannosaurus rex does have lips
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
@@victorsztorc511 Cool! Can you share me the logic he used? I study sauropods so I don’t worry about it either way but I would like to know. After reading the literature (what little is published) and talking with Tracy I simply don’t see it)
@victorsztorc511
@victorsztorc511 2 года назад
@@FossilCrates he talked about it with his youtube friend klayton fioriti it's on his friends youtube page look up "How Scientifically Accurate Is The Jurassic Park T.rex? "
@jthomas8263
@jthomas8263 2 года назад
🤩🥳 🦖 Brian, Tyrannosaurus Rex is not a Genus after all, Tyrannosaurus had 3 Species. Tyrannosaurus Imperator and Tyrannosaurus Regina.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
Let’s see if those species stand (species aren’t capitalized fyi) though I have for years wondered why T. rex hadn’t been split yet.
@tyrannotherium7873
@tyrannotherium7873 2 года назад
It’s all fake there is only one and that’s Tyrannosaurus rex
@jthomas8263
@jthomas8263 2 года назад
T. Imperator is the Largest.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
It would be T. imperator should it stand. And how does T. lancensis factor in? Glad I study sauropods and have no dog in this fight! But I do have my popcorn ready!!!
@BBAMEG
@BBAMEG 2 года назад
I know everyone laughs at the "bulldog lips", but they are actually flews. They attach pretty high up on the maxilla. If dogs can eat without biting them, why can't a tyrannosaur? They would most likely have wrinkles as well to help the blood wick off them as they ate. I've seen more than one artist representation of a carnotaur with flews, so I mustn't be the only one who thinks that.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
I can't think of any reptiles or birds with flews, nor any evidence on any dinosaur skin thus far discovered. Clearly that doesn't mean it couldn't happen but I don't see loose lips. Granted, I'm a sauropod guy, so take that for what it is worth 🙂
@mikebrown41182
@mikebrown41182 2 года назад
Dog skulls are completely different to anything dinosauria the anatomy in general, several reasons why but it begs for more context. However the well documented osteophagy for Tyrannosaurs - multiply lines of evidence needs to be taken into consideration but the extension of extra oral tissue being proposed for Tyrannosaurs just don’t match the fossils themselves. one aspect wich is being left out is functional morphology and less systematics, alot of second guessing that would operate the same. However through Witmer & Porters work wich highlights highly intervascular pattern, and from their data it shows highly rich in blood supply to support a high rate of tissue repair along the oral margin of the mouth due wear and tear. As for foramina alone" as justification to put extra oral tissue is actually by the evidence at hand a bald claim with little to support such model and certainly not strong enough case - the data we have at hand, it would be premature to say that we know exactly how they would operate - wich one quite recent published paper concluded they confirm the lack of evidence based on neurovascular. i would suggest you read it as they cover important factors to take into consideration. The name of the paper is Bouabdellah et al i can put a link here to the paper. (they touch up on Traceys work aswell) palaeo-electronica.org/content/2022/3518-t-rex-trigeminal-canals
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
@@mikebrown41182 Well-reasoned statements and the link was most excellent! Though a conservative conclusion it is interesting that they point out the presence of lips in lepidosaurs and not the other taxa and invoke phylogenetic bracketing (a concept often invoked for the presence of feathers in many theropods). Thank you for the comments and the link!
@mikebrown41182
@mikebrown41182 2 года назад
@@FossilCrates I think the the most sound way is to aproach this species by species, genera. And what is interesting even the oft-cited across the lip debate - Morhardts master thesis also part of the linked paper (foramina count) find tyrannosaurids exceptional and unique while proposing lips for other theropod taxa. But it is a complex and contentious topic.
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates 2 года назад
@@mikebrown41182 I believe yours is the correct approach, specimen by specimen. I do that with sauropods. Generalities are great for the public but dangerous for the academics. And dangerous when peanut butter smeared even to the public :-). I do wonder why T. rex is considered only one species (more contentiousness 😁).
@antoniocanis6883
@antoniocanis6883 2 месяца назад
No lips make much more sense than lips i hate paleo artist that depict dinosaurs basing themselves too much on small ass relatives of today like little birdies or emmus little lizards you see how agresive a eagle face is and is much smaller than the little birdies they depict them as
@FossilCrates
@FossilCrates Месяц назад
I am eager to watch this field of study evolve!
Далее
The Insane Biology of: The Orca
25:54
Просмотров 7 млн
SUE: The T. Rex Experience Roars Into Denver
4:16
Просмотров 203 тыс.
What's the SMALLEST Tyrannosaurid?
27:38
Просмотров 475 тыс.
5 Ridiculous Archery Tropes (that actually work!)
18:57
T. rex as you've never seen it before
3:45
Просмотров 96 тыс.
VFX Artists React to Bad & Great CGi 148
16:00
Просмотров 623 тыс.
Ever Seen A T.Rex Tooth? #dinosaur
0:16
Просмотров 38 тыс.